Design For All Learning From Each Other
Design For All Learning From Each Other
Acknowledgment
I would like to thank all the contributors for sharing their
ideas end experiences: Peter Vetter, Hansuli Matter, Mi-
chael Krohn, Mark Rölli, Nicole Foelsterl and Vojtech Rada.
And I would like to thank Jalscha Römer and her design
team for their mindful brains, slick eyes and endurance.
Finally I would like to express my sincere gratitude to
Dr. Sunil Bhatia and the editorial team in the Design for All
Institute of India for giving us this great opportunity.
24
Gerhard M.
Buurman
My beginning in Maputo
In 2012 one of our professors, Rudolf Barmettler, an out-
standing typeface design and typography lecturer, passed
his vacations in Africa and particularly in Maputo the cap-
ital of Mozambique. There he met people from the faculty
of the Pedagogic University 1, and when they heard about
his background they asked him about identity, and brand-
ing design. When he came back he told me about his ex-
perience, and asked me to contact his interlocutors in
Mozambique. So I did, and asked the responsible people
of the Pedagogic University to specify their needs and
ideas for a potential exchange and support by our institu-
tion. Based on their answers we decided to establish a
project and because we thought a personal contact could
accelerate the understanding of the necessity and the re- 1
quirements of our African partners I travelled to Maputo Universidade
Pedagógica
to meet the dean and the faculty of the University. Moçambique, Maputo
My first question was, why they asked for identity and brand
design? In my opinion they needed almost everything, as
Mozambique is one of the poorest countries in the world,
but not identity or branding. In long and intensive discus-
sions they explained me their conception of promoting
economic growth. One of the main concepts was the devel-
opment of small and medium businesses, and their need of
design and communication to be able to develop and com-
mercialize their products or services autonomously.
Some of the samples they used to illustrate the present
situation of the economic situation were based on the
fact, that there is not one design studio or communica-
tion agency in Mozambique and they do not have a print-
ing industry able to print their own schoolbooks. Mozam-
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 28
B1 B2
C
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 31
s
tic
s
tic
tic
tic
zo
zo
zo
zo
EN EN
RC TO RC TO
EN EN
RC TO RC TO
100 PO
100 PO
DE O DE O
UITS AD O
100 PO
100 PO
UITS AD
UE
DE O DE O
UE
FR BRIC FR BRIC
TE UT
E FA MAP / 12 UITS AD UITS AD
6 12
E FA TE /
UE
UE
FR BRIC ZIA FR BRIC A
AO / AO / 6
IQ
BE
IQ
AZ
E FA ZAM / 12 E FA G / 12
M 15 M 30 /6 6
AO /
IQ
IQ
AO
B
O ÇAM 15 5
B
O ÇAM M M
B
O ÇAM O ÇAM
s
fr
cs
zoti
D1
zotics
zotics
zotics
D2 D3
F1
maputo – beira
many other daily flights and special tours under www.afritour.com afritour
F2
many other daily flights and special tours under www.afritour.com afritour
The analysis
Every project starts with an analysis phase. In this phase,
all the details of the project are determined. A serious
analysis must question the existing briefing, and if need-
ed specify, change or correct the tasks. Maximum open-
ness is required, and the designers should take nothing
for granted. Michael Bierut, a designer at Pentagram, says
in an interview with the design magazine Design Boom:
“The biggest trap is to believe the brief you’re given is the
whole story. It never is, and I repeat, never the whole story.
Asking
Come up with the ideas
that will challenge the
status quo by asking the
right questions.
Prototyping
Make the ideas more real – at any stage
in the process – so that they can be
experienced, evaluated improved or re-
considered.
Filtering
Challenge assumptions and
conclusions to draw out
the breakthrough from the
banal.
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 34
The hypothesis
In the second phase, a number of different hypotheses
will be developed with the aim of exploring different cre-
ative alternative solutions or scenarios. Basically, it is prov-
en that developing various scenarios at this stage of the
project as well as a critical comparison lead to innovative
solutions. The creative presentation of different variations
The synthesis
The third phase focuses on detail design. The basic ele-
ments are clearly defined by the decision taken at the
end of the second phase. What is now important is the
further development and design of all relevant media ex-
4 pressions. Where phase two focused on the breadth of
The description of the
design process is a
exploration, this phase requires depth. Technical and fi-
modified extract from the nancial factors are also taken into account. Similarly, the
authors book: Design
as Investment – Design feasibility of specific solutions must be verified by means
and Communication
as a Management tool; of additional investigations or tests. At the end of this
Peter Vetter and
Katharina Leuenberger;
phase, a presentation will be the output, which covers all
edited by Spielbein aspects of the recommended solution including a com-
Publishers, Wiesbaden
(Germany); 2016 prehensive argumentation. 4
The developments
The relevance and the characteristics of the projects (e.g.
exotic countries, uncommon situations and questions, in-
novation etc.) generated by the students a great motiva-
tion and engagement. The specific requirements of the
situation of the various business cases generated unusu-
al approaches and also different conceptual as well as es-
thetic propositions. To summarize the experience: It was
one of the most successful projects we have undertaken.
This outcome ensured me to organize other projects in this
direction. In 2013 we organized the Indian project together
with the Abhati Foundation (a Swiss-Indian Foundation in-
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 36
H I
J
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 37
K
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 38
N1
N2
N4
N5 O
P
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 40
product with potential for export. The product line for teas
is a prototypical sample for natural cultivation, fair-trade,
Macedonian natural resources and of economic rele-
vance. The new brand and its educational promotion of
the tea products will, in the future, lead to the develop-
ment of other similar product offers.
An outlook
The experience, especially the two projects in Morocco
and Macedonia proved the importance, not only for design
and economy, but of young people from different countries
with different cultures and languages, to work together and
to learn from each other. Another outcome, supported by
the results from all five projects is the energy and the cre-
ative force such projects generate thanks to the relevance
of the problems and the willingness of young people to
contribute with their ideas to the solution of the many
pending problems in the world. In one of the discussions in
Macedonia we where asking ourselves if our contribution
as small it might be constitutes a constructive approach,
and all participants agreed that many little propositions
6
Michel Bierut: How
will during time generate something bigger and we where
to use graphic design…; part of this process. Or, to say it with Michael Bierut’s words,
Thames & Hudson,
London (UK ); 2015 “... and once in a while change the world!” 6
As a summary, out of the experience from the five projects,
I think we could develop a broader project aimed to the de-
velopment of creative Industries 7 in developing countries.
Such a program should foresee a collaboration with local
Universities and involve students, assistants, and junior
lecturers from Europe together with local faculty and stu-
dents with the goal i) to develop real projects as described
and ii) offer train the trainer programs, and iii) prepare a
new generation of lecturers conscious of the didactic and
economic value of such initiatives. The main idea of “learn-
ing from each other” should lead to better understanding
of different point of views, cultures, and problems and ulti-
mately create an exchange platform and finally effective
partnerships and collaborative networks. Projects like 6
these should represent an innovative initiative for progres- See also: UNESCO:
Creative Industr y;
sive design schools, and universities. w w w.unesco.org
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 44
Q1
Q2 Q3
R1
R2 R3
12
0 2 4 8 KM
LOCAL ROAD
HIKING TRAIL
STREAMS
BEAR TRAIL
SHEEPHERD TRAIL
PLANT TRAIL
WATER SPORT
HOME STAY
RESTAURANT
CHURCH
GAS STATION
HOSPITAL
GRILL AREA
WORKSHOP
POST
SKI CENTRE
CAMPING
INFO POINT
2233
2754
KORAB
2391
SHARA MOUNTAIN
Projects for Macedonia, 2016
Zurich University of the Ar ts and
Ss. Cyril and Methodius University, Skopje
PUBLIC TRANSPORT
MARKET
HIGHLIGHTS
1980
2373
BISTRA
2343
DESHAT
2078
2107
S1 S2
71
S3
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 47
T1 T2
T3
T4
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 48
2012
Laboratorium Mozambique: 26 Projects for Mozambique
Lecturer: Peter Vetter
Assistant: Martin Waldner
Students:
Zurich University of the Arts; Visual Communication (BA):
Selina Theiler, Daniel Jerosch, Anina Amacker,
Lea Fischlin, Jamie Edward, Nico Bucci, Sabrina Kugler,
Lukas Ackermann, Tingshan Cavelti, Andreas Spörri,
Tanja Schaub, Sibylle Frutiger, Julia Schäfer, Ursina Meyer,
Jalscha Römer, Dario Mutter, Laia Ortiz Sansano,
Boris Stoll, Romy Strasser, Ronja Scheidel, Ramon Aemmer,
Christa Akert, Monika Nef, Anita Kolar, Mia Braunwalder,
Aurelia Zihlmann
2013
Projects for India
Lecturer: Peter Vetter
Assistant: Denise Bertschi
Students:
Zurich University of the Arts; Visual Communication (BA):
Sara Hardegger, Alessio Aliprandi, Jil Bargues,
Kerstin Barth, Laura Bonsignore-Slodownik, Ruben Brändli,
Philip Bührer, Sofia Ciriello, Jeanne Decasper,
Julia Felber, Christoph Friedli, Malin Gewinner, Maria del
Mar Ginot Blanco, Dennis-Kyōsuke Ginsing, Salome
Grand, Janina Hess, Johannes Inauen, Niklaus Knecht,
Rahel Preisig, Lorena Stohner, Allaina Venema
2015
Projects for Madagascar
Lecturer: Peter Vetter
Assistant: Henriette-Friederike Herm
Students:
Zurich University of the Arts; Style and Design (BA):
Mirjam Maag, Céline Géraldine Lütolf, Paula Rigendinger,
Alexander de Macedo, Anna Z’Brun, Maurice Müller,
Anna Elena Marchini Camia, Sarah Schott, Antje Kropf,
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 49
2015
Projects for Marrakech – learning from each other
Lecturers: Peter Vetter, Vincent Melilli, Florence Robert
Assistants: Bernd Grether, Jimmy Elias,
Katharina Leuenberger
Students:
Ecole Supérieure des Arts Visuels de Marrakech; Film
and Graphic Design (BA/MA): Ghita Ait Bensaleh,
Issam Battoum, Joussef Bonzidi, Fatine Ariba, Ilias El
Mezouari, Youssef Ait Ayad, Nathalie Eock, Omar
Janati Idrissi, Abderahman Benhatoum, Hamza Essalouh,
Maha Mouidine, Ahmed Messoudi, Abderahman
Benhatoum, Hamza Essalouh, Maha Mouidine, Ahmed
Messoudi, Ali Benhayoune, Hasna Bella, Salima
El Assaly, Qualid Ayoub, Aymen El Hankouri, Chayma
Ghenam, Ikbal Barez, Souad Mahmoudi, Hiba Chaari
2016
Projects for Macedonia – learning from each other
Lecturer: Peter Vetter, Sofija Siderenko, Tatjana Kandikjan
Assistants: Christian Imhof, Katharina Leuenberger,
Slave Ristomanov
Peter Vetter: Learning from each other 50
Students:
Ss. Cyril and Methodius University, Skopje; Industrial
Design and Economy (BA and MA):
Petar Avramoski, Milosh Sokolikj, Marija Mitrovska, Martin
Jankoski, Simona Mihajloska, Filip Avramov, Natalija
Cebova, Martina Miladinoska, Simona Anchevska, Ognen
Manevski, Elena Radeska, Davor Velinov, Ana
Zdravkova, Andrej Gjorgjievski, Petar Popovski, Boris
Djartov, Bojan Boshevski, Jovan Molkoski, Roberta
Kamchevska, Slavco Nikolovski, Simona Tasevska, Andrej
Pavlov, Christijan Vasilev, Ivona Negreva, Asja Mucha,
Angela Loboska, Anastasija Cikarska, Simona Peovska,
Nenad Simonovski, Aleksandra Aleksovska, Ema
Velkovska, Trajanka Mickovska
www.coande.com
145