HRNM WHII SOL 10b Lesson 1of2
HRNM WHII SOL 10b Lesson 1of2
Context: This is the first of two lessons designed to completely cover SOL WHII.10b, on the major battles and
technological advances of WWI. This includes propaganda as a technological advance, though that is covered in lesson 2
of this mini-unit. Lesson 1 has students using a variety of photos from WWI to match primary and secondary source
accounts of events/ technologies in the war, and to create a photo exhibit/ collage describing the effects of new
technology on the soldiers fighting the war.
SOLs Objectives
WHII.10b Describing the location of major Given primary and secondary source documents,
battles and the role of new technologies students will create a collage that synthesizes a
WHII.1a Synthesizing evidence from artifacts selection of documents to describe the role of
and primary and secondary source documents new technologies in WWI soldiers’ experiences,
to obtain information about events and life in in order to score “green/satisfactory” on the skill-
world history content rubric.
WHII.1d Evaluating sources for accuracy,
credibility, bias, and propaganda
Materials and Resources Essential Question(s)/ Understandings
Warm-up (cartoon) Battles of World War I extended across the
YouTube video (link provided) Eastern and Western fronts
Notes sheet & map These battles employed many deadly
Event maps & descriptions technological advancements
Photo Analysis Worksheet How did new technologies affect soldiers’
Eyewitness accounts experiences in WWI?
Photo sets
Collage/ Photo Exhibit Rubric
Time Breakdown:
Warm-up: 5-7 min
A-set/ hook: 5-7 min
Guided notes: 25-30 min
Photo Analysis/ Eyewitness Accounts: 15-20 min
Photo Exhibit/ Collage: 20-25 min
Exit Ticket: 5-7 min
Instructional Procedures:
A-set: Students will watch short video showing elements of life in the trenches during WWI and discuss the weapons and
other images as well as the attitudes of the soldiers.
Guided Notes: Students will examine maps and short secondary-source descriptions of key battles/ events of WWI to
complete a guided notes chart and locations map. Alternatively, teacher may present information to class, if desired or if
additional time is needed elsewhere in the lesson, more scaffolding is needed with maps, etc.
Photo Analysis: Teacher will present and model photo analysis tool (National Archives’ is provided, but not required).
Students will analyze approximately 5 photos showing various new technologies of WWI (tanks, trench warfare, gas,
machine guns, submarines) using the analysis tool. Additionally, students will be provided with brief eyewitness
accounts related to each of the technologies, and determine which image(s) best fit with each description. Teacher will
debrief findings with students and discuss effects of those technologies during the war. Suggested photo-account
matches are:
Account #1- Photo #1
Account #2- Photo #17
Account #3- Photo #28
Account #4- Photo #29
Account #5- Photo #9
Account #6- Photo #7
However, these may be adjusted as desired to scaffold the activity.
Historical “Photo Exhibit”/ Collage: Students will develop a collage or exhibit, either on poster paper or online (ex,
Glogster.com) that combines WWI-era photos, primary and secondary source excerpts, and their own analysis/
interpretation thereof, to answer the question, “How did new technology influence soldiers’ experiences in WWI?”
Students will choose additional photos from a predetermined set to analyze and include in their project. If time and
resources permit, students may do additional research and/or create their collages online, but outside resources are not
necessary. Sample rubric for evaluation is attached.
Exit Ticket: Questions for students—Which image did you find the most interesting/ compelling/ etc.? Why do you think
you had that response to that picture? What did it tell you about WWI?
Which technology do you believe was the most important in WWI? Why?
Assessment
Formative Summative
Warm-up (previous learning) SOL section quiz is included in Lesson 2 of this set
Student participation in group discussion
Photo/ Eyewitness account match & explain
Photo Exhibit/ Collage- daily objective
Exit Ticket
Attachments:
-Warm up cartoon
-YouTube link (a-set/ hook video suggestion)
-Guided notes sheet/ guided notes map
-WWI Event Secondary source sets- map & description (6 sets)
-Photo Analysis Tool
-Eyewitness Accounts set (6)
-WWI Primary source photos (40)
Warm-up:
3. Why did this event cause the US to enter WWI? 4. Does this cartoon best show “nationalistic feelings,”
“imperialism,” or “diplomatic failures” as a cause of
World War I? Explain your answer.
A-set/ Hook: Short video clip of WWI battles/ trenches. Suggested video: “Life in a Trench” by the History Channel
(3:14), from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_G4ZY66BG38
Students should note specific examples of weapons, conditions, and attitudes of the soldiers that they see or are
discussed in the video.
First Battle of
the Marne
Gallipoli
Verdun
Somme
Battle of Tannenberg
“The German war plan committed the bulk of the Empire's forces to the Western Front, leaving just one
German army in the East to face Russia's First and Second Armies. Combined with the defeat at the battle of
the Marne, a victory by the numerically superior Russian forces could have crushed the German war effort in
its crib. Instead, the Germans were victorious. The Russians scored a tactical victory at Gumbinnen, but
instead of pressing the advantage, they waited for the Second Army to arrive. The Germans audaciously
moved south to face the Second Army before it could combine its strength with the First. German forces were
aided by exceedingly poor Russian communication security — Russian troops hadn't mastered even basic
cryptography, so German intelligence was aware of how poorly coordinated the two Russian armies were.
Victory at Tannenberg set the stage for a subsequent German victory over the First Army at the Battle of
Mausurian Lakes. Those two wins prevented the Russians from taking strategic initiative against Germany in
the East.”
Source: http://www.vox.com/a/world-war-i-maps
Battle of the Marne:
“In a sense, this September 1914 conflict was the decisive battle of the war. Germany's advance into France
was halted by a combined Franco-British army on the outskirts of Paris near the Marne River and the German
army was forced to fall back. In these early phases, the war was moving too quickly for the opposing armies to
have much in the way of fixed positions, and the hasty defense of the Paris suburbs included reinforcements
being sent to the front from the city via a rapidly assembled fleet of urban taxis. The battle was followed by
the so-called "race to the sea" in which German and Allied forces tried and failed to outflank each other until
the lines reached all the way to the North Sea and no more battles of maneuver were possible. The
stalemated Western Front with its trench warfare came next. Germany's strategic war plan — knock France
out quickly so troops could be sent back east to fight Russia — had essentially failed.”
Source: http://www.vox.com/a/world-war-i-maps
Gallipoli Campaign:
“British forces, with assistance from the French navy, hatched a daring plan for an amphibious assault on the
Gallipoli Peninsula in Turkey in the winter of 1915. Had they succeeded in capturing the peninsula, Allied naval
forces could have sailed through the Dardanelles Strait up into the Sea of Marmara and supported an attack
on the Ottoman Empire's capital of Istanbul. That would have opened the door to direct Allied communication
between the Western and Eastern Fronts. Instead, Turkey kept the Allied troops bottled up and after months
of fighting, they retreated in early 1916. Heavy participation of volunteers from Australia and New Zealand in
the campaign makes it an iconic moment in those nations' military histories even as the Turkish victory is
celebrated in that country.”
Source: http://www.vox.com/a/world-war-i-maps
Battle of Verdun:
Verdun was one of the longest and costliest battles of the Western Front, raging from February to December
of 1916. About 300,000 people were killed for the sake of moving the front line about 5 miles. At the outset of
the battle, German military officials had concluded that they had no way of puncturing Franco-British defenses
and winning the war. Their plan, instead, was to take advantage of the fact that the battle lines were on
French soil to trick the Allies into defeating themselves. As Western fighting degenerated into a stalemate, the
French front lines in the vicinity of Verdun poked awkwardly into German-held territory. The plan was to seize
some high ground on the Eastern bank of the Meuse from which Verdun could be shelled. German
commanders hoped that rather than retreat from the town, the French would counterattack furiously in a way
that allowed German defenses to inflict massive casualties. And, indeed, about 156,000 French soldiers were
killed during the fighting. But so were 143,000 German soldiers.
Source: http://www.vox.com/a/world-war-i-maps
The Battle of the Somme:
The Battle of the Somme, fought in northern France, was one of the bloodiest of World War One. For five
months the British and French armies fought the Germans in a brutal battle of attrition on a 15-mile front.
The aims of the battle were to relieve the French Army fighting at Verdun and to weaken the German Army.
However, the Allies were unable to break through German lines. In total, there were over one million dead
and wounded on all sides.
In 141 days, from July to November 1916 the British had advanced just seven miles and failed to break the
German defense. Some historians believe that with a few more weeks of favorable weather the Allies could
have broken through German lines. Others argue the Allies never stood a chance. In any case, the British army
inflicted heavy losses on the German Army. In March 1917, the Germans made a strategic retreat to the
Hindenburg line rather than face the resumption of the Battle of the Somme.
Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/timelines/ztngxsg
North Sea Mine Barrage:
“At the outbreak of the war the United States proposed to the Allies the construction of a Mine Barrage
completely across the North Sea to limit the activities of the U-Boats [submarines], which were devastating
the shipping of the world…
Operations were begun in June [1918]… and continued until the last of October and, before the Armistice was
signed, a complete barrage of these powerful mines, two hundred miles long and thirty miles wide, laid at
varying depths, had been stretched across the North Sea from Norway to the Orkney Islands.”
Source: The Nothern Barrage: Mine Force United States Atlantic Fleet, pub. By the US Naval Institute, 1919
Photo Analysis Tool, from National Archives education programs. Electronic copy can be completed at
https://www.archives.gov/education/lessons/worksheets/photo_analysis_worksheet.pdf
Alternatively, students can analyze photos with the following three questions:
1. What do you see?
2. What does it mean?
3. Why is it important?
Eyewitness Account #1:
“The Russian soldier was a very good soldier, provided he was properly led. But without officers - the officers were
wounded or killed - the simple Russian muzhik had not much initiative, after all they were mostly peasants, very simple
good-natured men, very big and tough but without guidance they were lost. And very often... to our great surprise they
surrendered in droves, and it was almost an embarrassment sometimes to handle these large numbers of prisoners.”
Source: nationalarchives.gov.uk
Photo 13: British officer leads the way “over the top”
Photo 15: Aerial view of the Hill of Combres, St. Mihiel Sector of the Western Front
Image source: San Diego Air and Space Museum Archive, via
http://www.theatlantic.com/static/infocus/wwi/introduction/
Photo 16: German soldier and horses with gas masks
Image source: San Diego Air and Space Museum, via http://www.theatlantic.com/static/infocus/wwi/westernfront1/
Photo 23: French soldiers make a gas and flame attack on German trenches
Photo 33: British soldiers play football (soccer) while wearing gas masks
Content Knowledge At least 85% of technology At least 70% of technology Fewer than 70% of
roles/ impacts are correctly roles/ impacts are correctly technology roles/ impacts
and thoroughly explained. and thoroughly explained. are correctly and/or
thoroughly explained.
Skill Application Information from sources is Information from sources is Information from sources is
synthesized clearly and synthesized appropriately. not synthesized
skillfully. Student weaves Student may exhibit some ‘list- appropriately. Student relies
details from multiple making’ of details to support entirely on ‘list-making’ of
sources together to their conclusions, but most details from sources to
support and/or explain all arguments are directly related support their conclusion/
of their conclusions. No to or supported by the argument or creates their
evidence of ‘list-making’ is combination of details from arguments from only one
present. sources. piece of evidence.
Skill Application At least 85% of At least 70% of explanations/ Fewer than 70% of
explanations/ impacts on impacts on soldiers for each explanations/ impacts on
soldiers for each piece of piece of technology are based soldiers for each piece of
technology are based on on information from multiple technology are based on
information from multiple sources (combination of more information from multiple
sources (combination of than one: photo, eyewitness sources (combination of
more than one: photo, account, secondary source, more than one: photo,
eyewitness account, etc.) eyewitness account,
secondary source, etc.) secondary source, etc.)
Work Habits Exhibit/ Collage is totally Student has achieved 3 of the Student has achieved fewer
completed and submitted following: than 3 of the following:
on time with clear evidence 1. Exhibit/ Collage is totally 1. Exhibit/ collage is totally
of thorough, thoughtful completed completed
effort. There is evidence of 2. Submitted on time 2. Submitted on time
creative and/or higher 3. Clear evidence of 3. Clear evidence of
levels of thinking present. thorough, thoughtful thorough, thoughtful
completion completion
4. Evidence of creative/ 4. Evidence of creative/
complex thinking complex thinking
Totals for each category:
Overall rating: