Module 2 - Environment and Development
Module 2 - Environment and Development
1
• Until two decades ago the world looked at economic status alone as a
measure of human development.
• Thus countries that were economically well developed and where people were
relatively richer were called advanced nations while the rest where poverty
was widespread and were economically backward were called developing
countries.
• They not only exploited their own natural resources rapidly but also used the
natural resources of developing countries to grow even larger economies.
• However, this form of development did not add to the quality of life as the
environmental conditions had begun to deteriorate.
• Development strategies in which only economic considerations were used, had
begun to suffer from serious environmental problems due to air and water
pollution, waste management, deforestation and a variety of other ill effects
that seriously affected peoples’ well being and health.
2
• There were also serious equity issues between the “haves and the have not's”
in society, at the global and national levels. The disparity in the lifestyles
between the rich and the poor was made worse by these unsustainable
development strategies.
• Developing countries were suffering the consequences of a rapidly expanding
human population with all its effects on the over utilization of natural
resources.
• Thus increasingly the world began to see the need for a more equitable use of
earth resources.
• Development must begin to change from aiming at short term economic gains
to a long term sustainable growth that would not only support the well being
and quality of life of all people living in the world today but that of future
generations as well.
3
• Sustainable Development:
• The nations of the world came to clearly understand these issues at the Rio
Conference in 1992.
• Several documents were created for the United Nations Conference on
Environment and Development (UNCED), which brought out the fact that
environment and development were closely connected.
• Sustainable development is defined as development that meets the needs
of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to
meet their own needs. It also looks at the equity between countries and
continents, races and classes, gender and ages.
• To ensure sustainable development, any activity that is expected to bring
about economic growth must also consider its environmental impacts so
that it is more consistent with long term growth and development.
4
• Many ‘development projects’, such as dams, mines, roads, industries and
tourism development, have severe environmental consequences that must be
studied before they are even begun.
• Thus for every project, in a strategy that looks at sustainable development,
there must be a scientifically and honestly done EIA, without which the project
must not be cleared.
• Large dams, major highways, mining, industry, etc. seriously damage
ecosystems that support the ecological health of a region.
5
URBAN PROBLEMS RELATED TO ENERGY
• Urban centres use enormous quantities of energy.
• Traditional housing in India required very little temperature adjustments as the
materials used, such as wood and bricks handled temperature changes better
than the current concrete, glass and steel of ultra modern buildings.
• Materials like iron, glass, aluminium, steel, cement, marble and burnt
bricks, which are used in urban housing, are very energy intensive. The
process of extraction, refinement, fabrication and delivery are all energy
consuming and add to pollution of earth, air and water. This energy
consumed in the process is called embodied energy.
6
URBAN PROBLEMS RELATED TO ENERGY
• Until the 1950s many urban kitchens were based on fuel wood or charcoal.
This was possible and practical when homes had chimneys and kitchens
were isolated from the rest of the house. Smoke became a problem once
this changed to apartment blocks. Kerosene thus became a popular urban
fuel. This changed to electrical energy and increasingly to natural gas by
the 1970s in most parts of urban India.
• Urban centers in hot climates need energy for cooling. The early systems of
fans changed into air-conditioning, which consumes enormous quantities
of energy. New buildings in our country have taken to using large areas
covered by glass. While in cold climates this uses the green house effect to
trap the warmth of the sun inside, in our hot climate this adds several
degrees to the temperature inside.
7
URBAN PROBLEMS RELATED TO ENERGY
• Urban transport depends on energy mainly from fossil fuels. Most urban
people use their own individual transport rather than public transport systems
for a variety of reasons.
• Urban transport in different cities and even different parts of a city are either
inefficient or overcrowded. This means more and more vehicles on the road
which leads to traffic congestion, waste of time for all the commuters, and a
great load of particulate matter and carbon monoxide from the exhaust of
vehicles.
• This causes a rise in the number of people having serious respiratory diseases.
8
WATER CONSERVATION, RAIN WATER HARVESTING, WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
Water conservation:
• Clean water is becoming increasingly scarce globally. With deforestation
surface runoff increases and the sub soil water table drops as water has no
time to seep slowly into the ground once vegetation is cleared.
• As many areas depend on wells, it has become necessary to go on making
deeper and deeper wells. This adds to the cost and further depletes
underground stores of water.
• As deforestation and desertification spreads due to extensive changes in land
use the once perennial rivers are becoming increasingly seasonal.
• Over use and misuse due to various activities that waste water or cause
pollution has led to a serious shortage of potable drinking water.
• Newer forms of irrigated agriculture such as sugarcane and other water hungry
cash crops required enormous quantities of water. However, such irrigated
areas become waterlogged, saline and unproductive. 9
WATER CONSERVATION, RAIN WATER HARVESTING, WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
• Saving water in agriculture:
• Drip irrigation supplies water to plants near its roots through a system of
tubes, thus saving water.
• Small percolation tanks and rainwater harvesting can provide water for
agriculture and domestic use.
• Rainwater collected from rooftops can be stored or used to effectively
recharge subsoil aquifers.
• Saving water in urban settings:
• Leaking taps and pipes are a major source of loss of water.
• Canals and pipes carrying water from dams to the consumer lead to nearly
50% loss during transfer.
• Reducing the demand for water by saving it is more appropriate than trying
to meet growing demands.
10
WATER CONSERVATION, RAIN WATER HARVESTING, WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
Rain water harvesting:
• It is a technique of increasing the groundwater by capturing and storing rainwater
through special water harvesting structures like dug-wells, percolation pits, lagoons
and check dams.
• Proves useful not only for poor and scanty rainfall regions but also rich ones.
Objectives:
• Reduce run-off
• Avoid flooding
• Meet increasing demands of water
• Raise water table by recharging ground water
• Reduce groundwater contamination
• Supplement groundwater supplies during lean season.
11
WATER CONSERVATION, RAIN WATER HARVESTING, WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
Traditional RWH:
• Check dams
• Rooftop RWH 12
WATER CONSERVATION, RAIN WATER HARVESTING, WATERSHED MANAGEMENT
Watershed Management:
• Rivers originate in streams that flow down mountains and hill slopes.
• A group of small streams flow down hillsides to meet larger streams in the
valley which forms the tributaries of major rivers.
• The management of a single unit of land with its water drainage system is
called watershed management.
18
WASTELAND RECLAMATION PRACTICES:
• In India, the wasteland reclamation and development falls under the purview
of the Wasteland Development Board, which works to fulfil the following
objectives:
• Improve the physical structure and quality of marginal soils.
• Improve the availability of good quality water for irrigating these lands.
• Prevent soil erosion, flooding, and landslides.
• Conserve the biological resources of land for sustainable use.
19
There are however situations where communi- to the urban sector. Wealth also shifts in the
ties request for shifting to a new site. This is same direction. This unequal distribution of
often observed where people live inside or on wealth and access to land and its resources is a
the periphery of a National Park or Wildlife Sanc- serious environmental concern. An equitable
tuary. In these situations, such as the Gir in sharing of resources forms the basis of sustain-
Gujarat, the local people have asked to be given able development for urban, rural and wilder-
alternate land where they could live peacefully ness dwelling communities. As the political
away from lions that kill their cattle, but the Gov- power base is in the urban centers, this itself
ernment has been unable to find suitable areas leads to inequalities and a subsequent loss of
where they can be shifted for decades. sustainability in resource management in the
rural and even more so for forest dwelling
people.
6.5 ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS: ISSUES AND
POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS In 1985, Anil Agarwal published the first report
on the Status of India’s Environment. It empha-
Environmental ethics deals with issues related sized that India’s environmental problems were
to the rights of individuals that are fundamen- caused by the excessive consumption patterns
tal to life and well being. This concerns not only of the rich that left the poor poorer. It was ap-
the needs of each person today, but also those preciated for the first time that tribals, especially
who will come after us. It also deals with the women and other marginalized sectors of our
rights of other living creatures that inhabit our society, were being left out of economic devel-
earth. opment. There are multiple stakeholders in In-
dian society who are dependent on different
natural resources which cater directly or indi-
6.5.1 Resource consumption patterns and rectly to their survival needs. Anil Agarwal
the need for their equitable utilisation: brought forth a set of 8 propositions which are
of great relevance to the ethical issues that are
Environmental ethics deals with issues that are related to environmental concerns. These in-
related to how we utilise and distribute re- clude:
sources. Can individuals justifiably use resources
so differently that one individual uses resources 1. Environmental destruction is largely caused
many times more lavishly than other individuals by the consumption of the rich.
who have barely enough to survive? In a just
world, there has to be a more equitable sharing 2. The worst sufferers of environmental de-
of resources than we encounter at present. The struction are the poor.
just distribution of resources has global, national
and local concerns that we need to address. 3. Even where nature is being ‘recreated’, as
There are rich and poor nations. There are rich in afforestation, it is being transformed
and poor communities in every country. And away from the needs of the poor and to-
there are rich and poor families. In this era of wards those of the rich.
modern economic development, the disparity
between the haves and have-nots is widening. 4. Even among the poor, the worst sufferers
Our human environments in the urban, rural and are the marginalised cultures and occupa-
wilderness sectors, use natural resources that tions, and most of all, women.
shift from the wilderness (forests, grasslands,
wetlands, etc.) to the rural sector, and from there
8. It is totally inadequate to talk only of sus- “I am often amazed and extremely angry,
tainable rural development, as the World when people talk about Environment Edu-
Conservation Strategy does. We cannot cation for the villages. It is the so-called, edu-
save the rural environment or rural people cated people who need Environment
dependent on it, unless we can bring about Education more than anyone else”.
sustainable urban development. – Anil Agarwal, ‘Human-Nature Interac-
tions in a Third World Country’.
Common property resources in India once in- The economically advanced West has exploited
cluded vast stretches of forests, grazing lands their own natural resources to such an extent
and aquatic ecosystems. When the British found that they have exhausted them nearly every-
that they were unable to get enough wood for where. They now buy their resources from re-
ship building and other uses they converted for- source rich but economically deprived nations
est areas into Government ‘Reserved Forests’ for at a low cost. This depletes the developing na-
their own use to grow timber trees. This alien- tions of natural resources on which their poor
ated local people from having a stake in pre- depend for their livelihood.
serving these resources. This in turn led to
large-scale losses in forest cover and the cre- Changing this unfair economic practice to a
ation of wasteland. In the past, in traditional more just and fair way in managing trade would
villages that were managed by local panchayats, require a new thinking on the part of people
there were well defined rules about managing who live in the super rich countries.
grazing lands, collecting forest resources, pro-
tecting sacred groves, etc. that supported con-
servation. There was a more or less equitable 6.5.3 Urban – rural equity issues
distribution that was controled by traditional
mechanisms to prevent misuse of common prop- The common property of rural communities has
erty resources. Any infringement was quickly increasingly been used to supply the needs of
dealt with by the panchayat and the offender the urban sector. Land itself that was once held
was punished. Common property resources as a common property resource of villages is
were thus locally protected by communities. As being taken over by the urban and industrial
landuse patterns changed, these mechanisms sectors as it expands. The rural sector not only
were lost and unsustainable practices evolved, supplies food, but also a part of the energy needs
frequently as a result of an inadequately planned (mainly fuelwood) to most towns and cities in
development strategy. India, at a pittance. As a result, the commons of
the rural sector are being depleted of their re-
sources. Thus while the cities get richer, the ru-
6.5.2 Equity – Disparity in the Northern and ral sector, especially the landless, get poorer.
Southern countries The urban rich must appreciate where their re-
sources are derived from and be willing to pay a
Environmental ethics are concerned with, who fair price for using them.
owns resources and how they are distributed.
This can be looked upon at different levels. At
the global level it deals with the great North – 6.5.4 The need for Gender Equity
South divide between the rich industrialized
nations of North America and Europe, as against All over India, especially in the rural sector,
the needs of developing countries of the South women work on the whole longer hours than
6.5.7 The ethical basis of environment edu- lege level be exposed to a course on environ-
cation and awareness: ment. It is not to create only an awareness of
environmental issues, but also to bring about
Perhaps the most important concern is related pro environmental action. Among the variety
to creating an ethos that will support a sustain- of tools that can bring home the ethical issues
able lifestyle in society. This brings us to the need of the environment, no solution is as powerful
for environmental education. The Honorary Su- as real life experiences in nature. Creating a love
preme Court of our country has thus ordered for nature brings about strong pro environmen-
that every young individual at school and col- tal action. Our current educational processes at
There are two aspects that are closely connected Many species were not only valued, but also ven-
with ethical issues that are related to our envi- erated.
ronment. These are based on valuing nature and
appreciating the beauty of nature and treasur- In today’s world where many of us are far re-
ing the magnificence of the wilderness. moved from nature, we need to remind our-
selves that everything we use, if tracked back
Valuing nature as a resource: It is essential that to its source, has come from nature. We de-
a value system that is based on environmental pend on an intact unpolluted world which is
concern becomes a part of the thinking that we based on nature’s goods and services. No life is
as responsible citizens of our country and our possible without this. If we as citizens begin to
earth need to bring into our own daily lives. again respect Nature and all its varied species
For our ancestors, Nature was considered to be forming a complex web of life, and appreciate
like a mother. This has been essentially forgot- Nature’s functions and services, it will continue
ten. In ancient India, forests were considered to support our lives. If we disrespect nature one
sacred. We now know that forests clean up our cannot expect her to continue to support our
air, and act like a sponge that can hold water well being. Nature’s resources that we all use
for the dry season. In the Hindu scriptures, Bud- and depend on can only be optimized if they
dhist philosophy and especially in the Jain reli- are equitably shared by all of us. If the disparity
gion, each and every species on earth is is too great it can only result in anarchy. The
supposed to have a place in the scheme of life. ‘have not’s’ cannot be expected to remain in
With the signing of the Montreal Protocol in In 1986 the Nuclear Power Station at
1987, a treaty for the protection of the ozone Chernobyl in USSR developed a problem that
layer, the use of CFCs was to be banned by the led to a fire and a number of explosions in
year 2000. After 2000, the ozone layer is ex- its Nuclear Reactor. The radioactive dust
pected to recover slowly over a period of about spread over many kilometers and covered
50 years. not only Europe but North America as well.
Three people died in the explosion and 28
shortly after due to radiation exposure. Some
6.6.5 Nuclear Accidents and Nuclear Holo- 259 sick were hospitalized. As the area had
caust: to be evacuated 1,35,000 people had to be
moved immediately and another 1.5 lac by
Nuclear energy was researched and discovered 1991. As radioactive fall out continued even
by man as a source of alternate energy which more people had to be moved. An estimated
would be clean and cheap compared to fossil 6.5 lakh people may have been seriously af-
fuels. And although this did happen, along with fected. They may get cancer, thyroid
the benefits of nuclear energy came its down- tumours, and cataracts, and suffer from a
falls. In the short history of nuclear energy there lowered immune mechanism.
have been accidents that have surpassed any
natural calamity or other energy source extrac- As radioactivity passes from grass to herbi-
tion in their impacts. A single nuclear accident vores, sheep in Scotland and Reindeer in
can cause loss of life, long-term illness and de- Lapland were affected and were unfit for
struction of property on a large scale for a long human consumption. Vegetable, fruit and
period of time. Radioactivity and radioactive fall- milk were contaminated in Europe.
out leads to cancer, genetic disorders and death
in the affected area for decades after, thus af- A French Nuclear Waste Processing Center
fecting all forms of life for generations to come. in Normandy may have affected the lives of
children playing nearby. They may develop
leukemia (blood cancer) in later life.
Nuclear holocaust:
The use of nuclear energy in war has had dev-
astating effects on man and earth. The
Hiroshima and Nagasaki incident during World
War II, the only use of nuclear power in war in
history, is one of the worst disasters in history.
In 1945, the United States dropped atomic
bombs in Japan over the towns of Hiroshima
and Nagasaki. These two atomic bombs killed
thousands of people, left many thousands in-
jured and devastated everything for miles