"But I Can't Draw!": Iconic' Representation, and Beyond To Reality
"But I Can't Draw!": Iconic' Representation, and Beyond To Reality
VERY YOUNG CHILD draws pictures, and is encouraged to draw and paint at primary school. But few adults have developed this into a mature skill. Our education system is at fault here. It is skewed towards a belief that artistic ability is an inborn talent that cant be taught or learned reinforced by a value system which prizes literacy and numeracy, but not visual thinking. I think this is a shame. Drawing is an excellent discipline for encouraging us to pay attention to the world around us, to see it afresh and to know it in a more direct and intimate way. Drawing also helps us to develop our visual, spatial reasoning skills such a useful mental toolkit to add to the more linear style of thinking which language encourages. And of course, in the practical matter before us in these training sessions, we have a very good reason for wanting to draw better. To devise a more engaging
and memorable educational experience for children, it would be so helpful if we had the confidence to draw (and to help children to draw) tableaux and scenes, wall-friezes, maps, and illustrated booklets and posters.
HEN CHILDREN START TO DRAW, they dont observe the subject they compile the drawing using a kit of iconic components. Consider the child-like drawing here of the teacher. The body is an oval shape with bits stuck on. The arms dont have elbows. The eyes are ovals with circles in the middle, and lines sticking out to represent the eyelashes. The hair is made of squiggles and the mouth is a curved line. The other thing to note is that the body parts are shown sideon, because it is so much easier to draw them that way. So, the feet stick out to either side, at 180 to each other, though we know that nobody can stand like that.
Art educator Betty Edwards in her remarkable book Drawing on The Right Side of the Brain suggests that in this rather primitive iconic method of drawing, the young artist thinks: I need to put an eye there. Ill draw this symbol for an eye. Of course, there is always a greater or lesser degree of observation the careful child makes sure there are five fingers on each hand, not twenty, and maybe the thumb is drawn shorter than the fingers.
1
This almost photo-realistic pencil drawing of a typesetting worker was the result of careful observation, particularly of the way the light illuminates Black skin. But this was not observed from life, but drawn using a photograph as reference. And I modified the original image, because when Id photographed her, Theresa was sitting in front of a very different piece of equipment. So, this example shows how you can cheat by using a photograph as reference, but still create an image that did not exist before.
OU COULD SAY that in the childs style of drawing, it is the linguistic, symbolic aspects of the mind that takes charge of the drawing process. On the basis of experimental work done by her neurophysiology colleages at CalTech where she teaches art, Betty Edwards identifies these mental processes with the left hemisphere of the brain.
Bettys teaching methods are designed to say hands off! to this bit of the brain, so we can learn to look with fresh eyes at the world, and draw what we actually see in front of us.
eyebrow eyeline
nose
You can think of the human face, seen from the front, as a circle (the skull) with an oval (the face) attached. The bottom of the eyes are close to half way from top to bottom. Thirds lines help you to place the eyebrows, nose and ears. 2003 Conrad Taylor: [email protected]
Generic animal (above) shows the skeletal structure of many animals, though actual proportions vary in a horse, for example, the bones which in a human make up the hand and foot are fused and greatly extended. By playing about with this generic structure you can invent some convincing fabulous beasts, such as this Great Northern Spotted Dragon (Draco hyperborealis ).
HE ANCIENT WORLD felt no need to use perspective in art. If you look at Persian or Indian medival paintings, youll see that figures meant to be in the distance are shown further up the page. The size at which people were depicted could indicate their relative importance: the Pharaoh was drawn larger than the servants and soldiers. In Europe, a concern with perspective in drawing was one of the new themes of art in the Renaissance. We see this not only in architectural paintings, but also in how the human form is portrayed. As the clay tablet shown right illustrates,
This artist from Nippur was no fool. He drew the king and officials larger than the working class, and drew everyone side-on to avoid problems of foreshortening.
in much ancient art the forms of people and animals were always drawn from the side, because that way artists could work with the known proportions of limbs. As soon as you try to draw a horse head-on, or show a person with an arm raised towards the viewer, you hit the foreshortening problem, which is the need to modify the proportions of body parts according to laws of perspective. How did artists like Holbein, Vermeer or Michaelangelo solve the problem of foreshortening? Partly by applied geometry, partly through a new interest in painting from life, and partly by cheating with various optical gadgets.
Illustration from Robert Hookes paper delivered to the Royal Society on 19 December 1694, in which he described An instrument of use to take the draught or picture of any thing. It doesnt look particularly comfortable!
to help him to transfer his view of the landscape accurately to a sheet of paper on which he had already drawn a lightly pencilled grid. Some artists also experimented with the use of a lens to project an image perhaps of an artists model onto a sheet of paper mounted on the wall of a small, dark room. The Latin name for a small room is camera and we are still using the word today. It is thought that Vermeer painted his extraordinarily lifelike interior scenes with the aid of just such a camera lucida. The 17th-century English scientist Robert Hooke devised a portable camera (see above right). He thought it could be useful on voyages of exploration, to help explorers draw a pictorial record of the coastal features they were passing.
Typo paper is not as translucent as true tracing paper but has a better surface for taking pencil or ink. To trace, just follow the contours of the original outlines on the upper surface of the tracing sheet. The trouble with tracing is that you end up with a copy on a paper surface thats not good for illustration work, so the next step is to transfer your tracing onto a sheet of suitable material. First turn the trace-sheet over and use a very soft, rather blunt pencil (like a 4B) to rub a dark coating of graphite on the back of all the trace lines. Then turn the trace sheet right way up, place it on your good paper and hold it down with clips or tape so it wont slip. Go over the lines one final time, pushing hard enough to get graphite to come off the lower side and transfer the lines onto the paper. This is a time-consuming process but you can cut out the stage of blacking the back of the sheet if you have a carbon transfer sheet to slide between tracing and good paper before going over the lines to transfer them. I make my own by sprinkling pencil powder from a leadsharpener (I use clutch pencils) onto a sheet of tracing paper, then smear it all
5
A A B C D E F G H I J
The source map has been covered with a grid of regular squares. The surface onto which the map is to be copied & enlarged is also marked out with squares. It is then surprisingly easy to estimate the places where the key outlines cross the gridlines to transfer the design from the original to the copy.
over the tracing paper with a cotton pad dampened with lighter-fuel.
Projection tracing
F YOU HAVE a collection of images on 35mm slides, and access to a slide projector, you can project the image onto a sheet of paper taped to the wall and draw around the outline. Its a method used by some of the Asian artists who produce one-off movie billboards, and when the Scottish academic Malcolm Caldwell was assassinated in Cambodia I used this method to prepare a large airbrush portrait of him for the memorial meeting held by his friends and colleagues back in London. More happily, heres a sketch of an Indonesian friend which I produced this way at about the same time (see right). Similar to the slide projector, but harder to find, is a projector for opaque prints and objects called an epidiascope. Perhaps the hi-tech equivalent of projection tracing would employ a data projector linked to a computer, projecting onto the drawing surface either a scanned image, or one captured with a digital camera!
HE ULTIMATE CHEAT, of course, is to find a picture from a magazine or book and use that. You could photocopy or scan it and use it as it is, or use it as a form of reference for your own drawing, in which case you are not cheating but working in an honourable tradition There is a special category of artwork called clip art or sometimes copyrightfree art. In fact such collections are not free of all copyright protection, but the publisher grants a special waiver to the purchaser of the book, allowing you to use illustrations quite legally (as they are, or modified) in your own projects. Before you get too excited at this prospect of free art, I should warn you that most clip-art collections are aimed at the business communication market. Youll find many images of smart white people in suits at meetings, but not many that represent life in the community. There are some rare exceptions such as the drawings of Petra Rhr-Rouendaal (left).
From Where there is no artist development drawings and how to use them by Petra Rhr-Rouendaal. 2003 Conrad Taylor: [email protected]
Partly informed by watching foxes play in the snow by moonlight, this drawing was also aided by reference to The Illustrated Encyclopdia of Animals. I drew this by hand but added shading using the computer.
Anatomy books I have several of these. My favourites are by medical illustrator Louise Gordon. Animal and bird books because Ive always been interested in nature. The illustrated encyclopdia of animals helped me in several recent projects requiring a lion and a red fox. Atlases because I do a lot of map art, I have many atlases including historical ones, plus one made up of satellite images from space. Objects, buildings and technology I dont have enough of these. While working recently on artwork on the medival Islamic world Ive referred to the Taschen series of architectural guides, and poked around the 2ndhand bookshops in Greenwich to try to find clues to what the ships of the period looked like. The Internet not on my bookshelf of course, but I thought I should add this The Google search engine has helped me to find reconstructions of the Yossi Ada shipwreck, pyramids at Mero and various other subjects.
Figure Reference Manual packed with reference photos of poses both clothed and otherwise. Some of the poses have been shot simultaneously with 24 cameras ranged around the subject: 8 angles 3 heights.
Its extraordinarily difficult to get evidence of what the medival Arab trading ship in the Eastern Mediterranean would have looked like, but what evidence I could find went into this drawing. 2003 Conrad Taylor: [email protected]
STARTED DRAWING in black and white media as a child with plain pencils and pens mostly because they were cheaper. Later I learned that highcontrast black and white artwork done with pen and ink made better originals for posters, leaflets & magazines printed on a litho press or a stencil duplicator, or copied on a photocopier. So now, when I draw for reproduction, I generally create an image that relies heavily on expressive outlines. These can be shaded or coloured as a later stage if the method of reproduction allows.
This springy brush in the right hands can make a transition from a stroke 23 millimetres wide to a line as fine as an individual hair (quite literally), giving a lively and expressive quality to lines. But it is a skill acquired only after much practice, and takes time and care to do. These days I am more than happy to experiment with fibre-tipped and rollerball pens, pigment pens and other newfangled devices. Fibre and nylon points give a slightly more expressive line than metal or ceramic roller-balls can. Youll also want to evaluate the various inks used in disposable pens some can take several minutes to dry properly, which increases the risk of smudging. My usual practice is to ink lightly over the pencilled lines, let the ink dry and the use a plastic eraser to clear all of the pencilling out of the way before going on. The outermost lines are often built up by going over them several times, as I like to use strong outlines of varying width to give a sense of volume to the major masses of the figure.
9
The finished archer project, inked in with Kolinsky sable brush and ink, plus various fineliner pens
shading or colouring work, if required, will be done in the computer. The computer also helps in other ways when I work with drawings. For example I dont worry as much about stray lines and mistakes any more: they are easy to edit out. By the way, I should have said that its a good idea to draw larger than the final reproduction size of your image if you can, because as it is reduced for printing your mistakes will get smaller too! (Cartoonists often work at twice the final size they images will be printed.) As for the actual magic tricks that I use to edit, shade and colourise my drawings in the computer, space doesnt permit me go into them in detail here. Ill just tell you that Adobe Photoshop is the software I use, and I usually apply the shading or colouring on a second layer, almost like an acetate overlay, with the blending options of the colourisation layer set to multiply so it behaves as if transparent. Finally, I flatten the image to a single layer, and save a copy in an appropriate file format such as TIFF ready to put into my publishing project. (Again, I have to spare you the technical details of this.)
OR THE MOST PART this paper has been about images drawn with handheld media such as pens and pencils, though they may be produced or finished in a computer-assisted fashion. But I should mention that software also exists for creating drawings made up not of pixels sampled from a scanned original, but as lines and curves and geometric shapes what is known as vector art. Early drawing software was somewhat clunky, but modern versions of Adobe Illustrator or Corel Draw are excellent tools in skilled hands. A great advantage of vector art is that it has no particular resolution, so can be printed very large indeed without becoming all pixellated. Another advantage is that these pictures are made up of objects which can have their colour attributes edited at any time. I have exploited both of these features of vector art in various mapping projects.
Vector drawing software is excellent for producing flowcharts, diagrams, and various kinds of icon, logo or symbol. If an organisation asks a designer to make a logo for them, it will usually be done in this sort of software. Another intriguing possibility is to make simple outline symbols available as characters in a font for the computer. They can be drawn in vector illustration software to start with, then copied into a font-editing program to make PostScript or TrueType fonts for installation in the computer. Then you can use them in any program in the computer, such as Word or PowerPoint. Here are some examples of symbols from the fonts Webdings and Carta:
During 2002, I undertook a project to create a series of country maps for the PTEP project of the Institute of Ismaili Studies, for use in a PowerPoint presentation. To make the project future-proof and re-usable, I started by creating a resolutionindependent vector art map of the world, using Adobe Illustrator (see above). Youll note that various layers of the map can be switched on or off, and that each country is an object (note how selecting Denmark also picks up the Faroe Islands). Right, a small regional map generated in less than 25 minutes from the data in the main source map. 2003 Conrad Taylor: [email protected]
11
Why do you think Conrad has drawn us with these silly round eyes and stylised mouths, Sharon?
some suggested reading because the pictures are more important than the text right?
Dunno either his observational skills are poor or he thinks hes a cartoonist!
This paper is illustrated with Conrads pictures except Petras drawing on page 7 and the Mesopotamian image from 1500 BCE on page 3. The drawings were scanned and processed in Adobe Photoshop, and the paper was pulled together in Adobe PageMaker, on an Apple Macintosh PowerPC G4 computer. Print-outs were made on a Tektronix 740P PostScript laser printer. PDFs of this document can be found here: http://www.ideography.co.uk/drawing/download.html
12