DLS212 Workbook Participant WEB 20231012
DLS212 Workbook Participant WEB 20231012
Online Resources
Risk Management Center Training Website
www.rmc.usace.army.mil/Training/Dam-and-Levee
2023
Table of Contents
Course Overview 5
Training Agenda 6
Course Instructors 10
References 70
Glossary 82
2. Click on “Login”
a. Example: DLS212
a. Example: DLS212
Mr. Dillard started with USACE in 2016 as a Geotechnical Engineer performing designs
and risk assessments on Dam Safety Modification projects then moved into the
Geotechnical Branch Chief position. In 2020, he accepted the Deputy Director position
and is also the Lead Engineer for the Lewisville Dam Safety Modification Study. Prior
experiences include design and construction management on the rehabilitation of dams
within the USDA-NRCS Small Watershed Program.
John has been with USACE since 2009, after working for about 10 years in private industry
in Jacksonville. With USACE, John has served as Lead Geotechnical Engineer for the
Herbert Hoover Dike (HHD) rehabilitation project, responsible for completing geotechnical
design and engineering during construction for numerous water control structures and
several miles of cutoff wall at the project. John also served as one of the technical experts
that completed the potential failure mode analysis and risk assessment for HHD and was
one of the primary engineers and authors of the HHD Dam Safety Modification Study
(which provides authority for approximately 30 miles of additional cutoff wall at HHD). Most
recently, John has been serving as the lead engineer for the Jacksonville district National
Risk Cadre which was established in 2016. In this role, Kendall is responsible for a diverse
team of engineers that evaluates risk on USACE dams and levees nationwide. SAJ Cadre
has been responsible for numerous risk assessments and risk informed design support
on dam and levee systems from Seattle to Puerto Rico and have supported risk informed
design support on projects from feasibility through construction.
Ed Friend, P.E.
Mr. Friend is a Professional Engineer, Professional Geologist, and Project Management
Professional with over 25 years of progressive experience related to geotechnical,
geological, and construction engineering for the design of new and rehabilitation of
existing dams and reservoirs. He has been the lead engineer, lead geotechnical engineer,
lead construction engineer, lead design reviewer or project manager on over 40 new
dam or dam rehabilitation projects with construction costs up to $600 million and dam
heights over 200 feet. He has been a key contributor on over 100 dam and reservoir
projects. Mr. Friend has a Bachelor's degree in geological engineering from the South
Dakota School of Mines and Technology.
6. Seepage Berm Case History 16. New Embankment Dam Case History
10. Instrumentation
Module Exercise
Key Points
• Importance of proper drawing layout for embankment dams
• Embankment dams consist of multiple zones with different purposes
• Embankment design needs to consider potential failure modes and to not create new
failure modes
• Numerous factors are used to select an embankment dam cross section
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• The engineering geologist is a vital member of the multidisciplinary team all project
scales, for the full duration of the project.
• Engineering Geology in Embankment Design and Construction is applied at
numerous scales.
• The geologist must take care to representatively sample the site to account for
variability.
• The geology record is important for future investigations and analyses or dam safety
reviews.
• Understanding the dam foundation treatment that was performed during
construction is critical for understanding and characterizing the subsurface conditions,
interpreting instrumentation readings, and identifying seepage issues.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Just because something is plausible, does not mean it is probable. We should
continue to refine our awareness of probability with experience and knowledge of
case histories.
• As new information becomes available, we should remain skeptical and avoid
confirmation bias. Example: continuity.
• While geology is often the key condition with unfavorable conceivable deviations,
we root our uncertainty in the context of what is observed or processes that are
understood. Ex: depositional environment.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• A suite of Index tests (gradation and Atterberg Limits) are used to classify soils using
the USCS.
• Follow ASTM standards for sample size.
• Even if you think dispersive soils are not an issue, run the tests anyway.
• Standard Proctor is the standard used for dam construction.
• Different strength tests are used to estimate the shear strength along the failure path.
• Any strength tests that consolidate or load the samples should be assigned such that
the anticipated stress ranges is covered by the test.
• Peak strength is not always used, in embankment dam design it is not typically ideal
to load soils to their peak strength and critical state is typically used.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Dams are not static, embankment and foundation settlement must be estimated
during design
• Total settlement consists of initial + primary +secondary
• Consolidation tests required for each foundation layer
• Add defensive measures to counteract the affects of settlement
• Use camber for all zones
• Even rock foundations settle and must be estimated as part of design
• Rock foundations are complicated to estimate settlement, advanced modeling and
thorough investigations are required
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Develop a camber design table for a small embankment dam using the information provided in
the sections below.
Site Description
Exercise
Use the following equations to finish filling out Tables 2 and 3:
-1-
Draw the camber profile for the dam crest and core:
Camber Profile
21
20.5
20
19.5
Elevation (ft)
19
Dam Crest
18.5 Core
18
17.5
17
0+00 1+00 2+00 3+00
Dam Station
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Seepage through and under embankment dams is governed by the constitutive
equations of fluid flow through porous media.
• Two-dimensional seepage analysis is governed by LaPlace’s equation.
• An estimate of hydraulic conductivity is needed to evaluate seepage.
• Hydraulic conductivity can be measured through laboratory or field tests, but it can
also be estimated empirically through published tables of values or equations that
relate soil data such as the grain size to hydraulic conductivity.
• Void ratio and the porosity of the soil heavily influences the hydraulic conductivity of
the soil.
• The relationship between degree of saturation and hydraulic conductivity is important
in transient loading modeling and in partially saturated soils in seepage models.
• Flow nets or other numerical solutions can be used to evaluate the seepage concerns
for the embankment.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Introduction
Design a filter to protect a base soil that is representative of a silty sand (SM) embankment zone.
Step 1: Gather all base soil gradations. To simplify this exercise the base soil has been selected
and is shown in the figure below. The base soil is not dispersive.
Engineering judgment should be used in the selection of a representative base soil gradation. In
the majority of cases, the selected gradation will be taken from the fine side of the sample
gradation range. Prior to selecting the representative base soil gradation, the gradations should
be regraded, if necessary. For this exercise this step has already been completed.
Because gradation for the base soil contains gravel (materials larger than the #4 sieve (4.75 mm))
an evaluation needs to be made to determine if the material should be regraded. Use flow chart in
Figure 2 and fill out Table 1 to determine if the base soil needs regrading.
1
DLS-212 – Exercise 2
30 DLS-212 | Modules & Workshops | 2023
Exercise
Filter Compatibility
where:
𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝑢𝑢𝑢𝑢 = 𝐷𝐷𝐷𝐷60 ⁄𝐷𝐷𝐷𝐷10 (Base Soil Cu = ~22)
𝐶𝐶𝐶𝐶𝑧𝑧𝑧𝑧 = 𝐷𝐷𝐷𝐷30 2 ⁄(𝐷𝐷𝐷𝐷10 𝐷𝐷𝐷𝐷60 ) (Base Soil Cz = ~1.4)
Figure 2. Logic Diagram Showing When Regrading of the Base Soil is Required.
Gradation Base soil Base soil is not Base soil is not Should soil be
Number contains <15% gap graded? broadly regraded?
fines? graded?
Base Soil
3
Exercise
Filter Compatibility
• D85B = ___ mm
• D15B (prior to regrading) = ___ mm
• Fines content (percent passing the #200 sieve) after regrading = ___ percent
Based on the fines content of ___ percent, the base soil is categorized as a soil category ___
according to Table 3.
Fine the equation for the maximum D15F for category ___ soils, according to Table 4 and
calculate the maximum D15F in the space below:
Base Soil
Filtering – Maximum D15F
Category
The maximum D15F should be ≤ 9 x D85B, but not less than 0.2
mm, unless the soils are dispersive. Dispersive soils require a
1
maximum D15F that is ≤ 6.5 x D85B size, but not less than 0.2
mm.
The maximum D15F should be ≤ 0.7 mm unless soil is
2 dispersive, in which case the maximum D15F should be < 0.5
mm.
For nondispersive soils, the maximum D15F should be:
40 − 𝐴𝐴𝐴𝐴
≤� � [(4 × 𝐷𝐷𝐷𝐷85 𝐵𝐵𝐵𝐵) − 0.7𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚∗ ] + 0.7𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚𝑚∗
40 − 15
Where:
3
A = Percent passing No. 200 sieve after any regrading.
34
5
DLS-212 | Modules & Workshops | 2023
DLS-212 – Exercise 2
Exercise
Filter Compatibility
5 × ____ mm = ____ mm
D15 F ≥ ____ mm
Note that D15B is selected before regrading for Step 6. This is plotted as “Point B” on Figure 4.
To prevent the use of gap-graded filters, the width of the filter band should be adjusted such that
the ratio of the maximum diameter to the minimum at any percent passing less than 60 percent is
5 or less. This adjustment is done initially with the maximum and minimum D15F sizes
calculated in Steps 5 and 6. The width of other portions of the filter band are checked with a
“sliding bar” as discussed below. In addition, check the D10F and D60F limits for both the
maximum and minimum sides of the filter band to ensure the coefficient of uniformity (Cu) is
between 2 and 6.
“Max D15F/ Min D15F” = ____ mm / ____ mm = ___. If the result is greater than 5 change the
calculated D15F points to Max D15F / 5 = ____ mm.
Min D10F = Point D = Min D15F / 1.2 (but not less than 0.075 mm) = ____ / 1.2 = ___ mm
A “sliding bar” is used to prevent the specified maximum gradation being more than 5 times the
minimum gradation at any percent passing below 60 percent. The “sliding bar” defined by
“Points G and H” where
6
DLS-212 | Modules & Workshops | 2023 35
DLS-212 Exercise 2
Exercise
Filter Compatibility
F<G<E
H=Gx5
To limit segregation potential using Table 6, when minimum D10F = ____ mm, the maximum
D90F = ___ mm (“Point K” on Figure 4)
If
Then, maximum D90F
minimum
Base soil category is:
D10F is:
(mm)
(mm)
< 0.5 20
0.5–1.0 25
1.0–2.0 30
ALL categories
2.0–5.0 40
5.0–10 50
> 10 60
Commercially available material will be used for construction of this filter because the small
quantity of filter material required for construction will not make producing a different material
financially feasible. A C33 fine aggregate (C33 concrete sand) is filter compatible with many
base soils and the specifications for C33 concrete sand were plotted on Figure 4. Does a C33
meet the filter requirements based on the design filter band? YES or NO (Circle One)
7
Exercise
Filter Compatibility
Figure 4. Filter Compatibility Results for Base Soil to C33 Concrete Sand
Key Points
• There are numerous factors that need • Numerous cross-sections have been
to be considered when evaluating the used, and the cross-section for a new
location of a new embankment dam, and dam must be selected based the local
the type conditions
of embankment to use • Filters and drains are essential design
• Embankment dams must be designed components for both embankments
for all anticipated loading conditions as well as for outlet works conduits and
• The design of the foundation is critical to spillways
ensure the performance of the structure • Stream diversions and cofferdams are
• Several key features (water barrier, shells, typically required to construct a new
seepage control, slope erosion) need to embankment dam.
be considered
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Four slope stability loading conditions are generally considered in embankment
design.
• Soil strengths are always governed by effective stresses.
• Limit equilibriums methods are the most used methods to evaluate slope stability.
• If artesian pressures or a different pore pressure regime is expected in different layers
of the embankment model, this can have a large effect on the analysis results.
• Unit weight, analysis method and computer program are far less critical.
• Pore pressure conditions in the foundation of the embankment are generally not
assumed to not change from the pre-construction evaluation
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Elements of an effective dam safety monitoring program.
• Deformation monitoring can monitor for stability, settlement, and differential
settlement and is accomplished by many methods, such as surface monuments,
embedded settlement points, and inclinometers.
• Seepage monitoring can monitor for internal erosion and scour related concerns,
and is accomplished by many methods, such as piezometers, observation wells, and
seepage weirs and flumes.
• Collection of instrumentation data may be automated, which allows for frequent data
collection, collection and evaluation of data at remote locations, and “real time” data
evaluation at any time, though it also presents challenges that must be considered.
• Instrumentation data does not replace visual observations; it supplements those
observations.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Foundation shaping and cleaning are crucial for rock foundations and abutments
to prevent low stress zones and CLE at various locations in the foundation and
embankment.
• Dewatering of foundation excavations for embankment dam construction and
rehabilitation is typically required
• Numerous methods for strengthening and cutting off soft and permeable foundations
– confirm Do No Harm.
• Foundation design and construction are critical for dam safety and long-term
performance.
• Evaluations and design updates occur through construction.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Two behaviors of concern are liquefaction or large strength loss leading to instability
and no large strength loss, but accumulated deformations
• Methods to perform seismic evaluations include post-earthquake limit equilibrium
slope stability, Newmark style simplified deformation analyses, and Numerical
analyses using FLAC or similar.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Note impervious fill material consists of CL material, however SM and SP materials are readily
available in the foundation and reservoir area. The sandstone is pervious and horizontally
bedded.
Key Points
• Just like a new dam design, there is no “one size fits all” for remediation
• Whenever you work in an existing dam and its foundation, expect the Unexpected
• Do No Harm
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• It is critical to protect the foundation from internal erosion.
• Extensive dewatering system (well points) was required to excavate to the planned
depths.
• Foundation mapping of the soil foundation was performed prior to placing any fill at
specific areas.
• The trenching method was used to construct the chimney filter.
• Since this was the first filling, identification of potential issues through observations
(seepage, movement/cracks) and instrumentation (abnormal instrument readings)
were critical to ensure it was safe to progress with reservoir filling.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Risk informs the decision to act, but design is still standards based.
• Risk informs what potential failure modes warrant action.
• Risk informs how safe is safe enough (ALARP).
• In some cases, designs may be based on risk that may ignore minimum design
standards (may be more or less than typical design standard depending on risk
characterization)
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
1. Draw a typical raised dam cross section showing internal zonation, slope protection,
excavations, and dimensions/elevations of critical features.
2. List all materials that are required to raise the dam, and their potential sources.
3. List proposed instruments and locations.
4. List at least two embankment analyses or evaluations that will be needed to complete
the final design of the embankment raise.
Given Information:
Geology:
• Sedimentary rock with low permeabilities on the left abutment, and granite with
moderate to high permeabilities on the right abutment. The contact of the two
formations is about in the middle of the dam.
• Surficial deposits of alluvium and colluvium over bedrock.
• A 40-foot-thick deposit of very soft to medium stiff clay foundation material exists
starting at the ground surface and extends upstream and downstream of the existing
dam (except at the cutoff trench).
Borrow Material:
• Clay deposits are located along the bottom of the valley in the existing reservoir area.
• Silty sand and sandy silt colluvial deposits are located on the valley side slopes along the
existing reservoir rim.
TH-10
B TH-2 TH-9
TH-5 B
TH-3
TH-1
TH-8
TH-4
TH-7
TH-6
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Key Points
• Material balance should be evaluated to ensure optimum use of on-site materials.
• Filters and drains must be protected from contamination.
• QA/QC are critical to ensure project is constructed as designed, and that no additional
failure modes are created.
• Test fills can be useful in determining equipment that is required and placement
methods.
• Moisture condition filters immediately prior to compaction.
• Do not over compact filters and drains.
• Clay core should be compacted at or slightly above optimum; scarify between lifts to
ensure a good bond and no preferential seepage path is created.
REFLECTION
In the space below, answer the two questions related to this module.
Photo References
1 NGI Research and Development Solutions, https://www.ngi.no
2 The Constructor, Laboratory Tests for Determining Strength of Rocks, https://theconstructor.
org/building/laboratory-tests-determine-strength-rocks/11665/
3 Dr. J.N. Jha, Professor and Head (Civil Engineering), Guru Nanak Dev Engineering College,
Ludhiana, Punjab-141006, https://slideplayer.com/slide/4713675/
4 Geoengineer, Prefabricated Vertical Drains, March 2014. https://www.geoengineer.org/
education/web-class-projects/cee-542-soil-site-improve-winter-2014/assignments/
prefabricated-vertical-drains
5 Dynamic Compaction, Deep Densification, Pete G. Nicholson, 2015, Soil Investigation and
Pile Design, El-Reedy, M., 2017. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/engineering/dynamic-
compaction
6 Interactive geotechnical design of bridge foundations, Kovacevic M., https://www.
researchgate.net/figure/Jet-Grouting-procedure_fig2_237749672
7 Hoover Dam, Information and Background
https://web.mst.edu/~rogersda/hoover_dam/index.htm
8 DGSI Durham Geo Slope Indicator, Inclinometers, Inclinometer Applications, https://
durhamgeo.com/inclinometers/
9 United States Geological Survey, usgs.com
10 Kansas Geological Survey, Kansas Earthquakes, http://www.kgs.ku.edu/Geophysics/
Earthquakes/network.html
Information about this training and other dam or levee safety trainings
can be found on the RMC training website at www.rmc.usace.army.
mil/Training. If you have questions about dam or levee safety trainings
please email [email protected].