A High-Speed Fully Differential Telescopic Op-Amp For Active Filter Designs in V2X Applications
A High-Speed Fully Differential Telescopic Op-Amp For Active Filter Designs in V2X Applications
net/publication/356534235
CITATION READS
1 93
2 authors, including:
Ertan Zencir
University of Turkish Aeronautical Association
38 PUBLICATIONS 124 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Ertan Zencir on 09 December 2022.
Furkan Barin†
€ ITAK-Informatics
T UB _ and
Information Security Research Center,
41470, Gebze, Kocaeli, Turkey
[email protected]
Ertan Zencir
Department of Electrical & Electronics Engineering,
University of Turkish Aeronautical Association,
06790, Etimesgut, Ankara, Turkey
[email protected]
In this paper, an ultra-wideband fully di®erential two-stage telescopic 65-nm CMOS op-amp is
presented, which uses low-voltage design techniques such as level shifter circuits and low-
voltage cascode current mirrors. The designed op-amp consists of two stages. While the tele-
scopic ¯rst stage provides high speed and low swing, the second stage provides high gain and
large swing. Common-mode feedback circuits (CMFB), which contain ¯ve transistors OTA and
sensing resistors, are used to set the ¯rst-stage output to a known value. The designed two-stage
telescopic operational ampli¯er has 41.04 dB lower frequency gain, 1.81 GHz gain-bandwidth
product (GBW) and 51.9 phase margin under 5 pF load capacitance. The design consumes a
total current of 11.9 mA from a 1.2-V supply voltage. Presented fully di®erential two-stage
telescopic op-amp by using low-voltage design techniques is suitable for active ¯lter in vehicle-
to-everything (V2X) applications with 120 m55 m layout area.
Keywords: Common-mode feedback; fully di®erential op-amp; telescopic ¯rst stage; ultra-
wideband; V2X.
1. Introduction
WITH the advancements in the CMOS deep sub-m technology, transistor sizes
continuously scaled down, which led designers to construct faster analog–digital
mixed circuits. This rapid development opened a new era that devices communicate
*This paper was recommended by Regional Editor Piero Malcovati.
† Corresponding author.
2250095-1
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
with each other and share information. Vehicle-to-everything (V2X) systems aim to
achieve an intelligent transportation system by using this excessive information
transmit rate in the near future.
V2X applications use a 5.9 GHz frequency band to communicate. This standard
contains 10 and 20 MHz channel sizes with several wideband options such as 60, 80
and 100 MHz.1 In the active ¯lter designing, fully di®erential op-amps are usually
used in negative feedback, so high speed and high gain become essential parameters
in these circuits to satisfy the V2X applications' requirements. There are several
active ¯lter topologies such as Rauch ¯lter (Multiple-Feedback Filter), Tow–Thomas
¯lter, Akerbeng–Mossberg ¯lter and Sallen–Key ¯lter. The Sallen–Key topology
requires a Di®erential Di®erence Ampli¯er (DFF) for implementation in fully dif-
ferential form, so this topology cannot be used for this paper. So, we implemented a
bandwidth programmable fourth-order Multiple-Feedback ¯lter, as can be seen in
Fig. 1. Equal-R method is used to create the ¯lter transfer functions. Also, band-
width programmability is achieved by using programmable capacitor arrays, as can
be seen in Fig. 1.
Nowadays, CMOS devices work with very low supply voltages. However, unlike
digital circuits, analog circuits cannot take advantage of it because transistors'
threshold values inevitably become high in short channel designs. This poses a sig-
ni¯cant challenge to design cascode devices to work correctly. In this paper, to reduce
this e®ect in the input stage, low threshold PMOS transistors are used.
CMFB circuits are the most critical parts of the fully di®erential op-amp de-
signing. If CMFB circuits are not properly designed, the circuit can oscillate or
shutdown itself because of the insu±cient common-mode voltage at output nodes.
Furthermore, common-mode sensing is done with complex circuits such as source
follower stages or MOSFETs working in the triode region in the long channel process.
2250095-2
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
However, in the short channel process, resistive structures can be used due to small
rO values. In this work, a resistive feedback method and ¯ve-transistor OTA-based
CMFB circuit adjust the output nodes to a known common-mode value.
Unlike the other works that have been done over the years, in this work, PMOS
transistors are used as the input stage, and a higher transition frequency value is
achieved.2,3 PMOS transistors are used in the input stage because the noise immu-
nity of the PMOS transistor is better than the NMOS transistor.4
This paper is organized as follows. Section 2 presents the fully di®erential tele-
scopic two-stage op-amp design. The simulation results of the op-amp are given in
Sec. 3. Finally, the paper is ¯nished with a conclusion in Sec. 4.
2250095-3
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
op-amp structures is that it has the highest speed performance. Also, the telescopic
op-amp structure has low power dissipation and low noise.3 Low-voltage design
causes headroom limitations and makes the op-amp designs challenging. In order to
overcome these limitations, low threshold M1 , M2 PMOS transistors are used in the
input stage.
Furthermore, the fully di®erential op-amp cut-o® frequency strongly depends on
the circuit's dominant pole due to the miller e®ect. In this work, an 850 fF capacitor
is used as a pole-splitting capacitor. The dominant pole's approximate location can
be shown as the function of the ¯rst-stage output resistance, compensation capaci-
tance, and the second-stage gain, as depicted in (1)
1
P1 ¼ ; ð1Þ
ð1 þ gm2 R2 Þ Cc R1
2250095-4
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
mirror with minimum length values. In this work, the op-amp's cut-o® frequency is
calculated as 14.39 MHz under 5 pF load.
The bias circuit of the system is shown in Fig. 4. As we can see, M22 and M27
transistors are used to generate drain voltages of M23 , M25 , M28 and M31 transistors
by using M24 , M26 , M29 , M30 transistors. IREF refers to the current that is generated
from the bandgap circuitry.
The change in common-mode input level a®ects the M1 , M2 transistor's VDS, and
M3 , M4 transistor's VGS values. Hence, gain also drops with the common-mode
input voltage. To have the gain constant, M11 and M12 transistors are used as a level
shifter circuit.4 For minimal power dissipation, the level shifter circuit is designed to
draw minimum current from the bias circuit.
2250095-5
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
current. OTA's output controls 30% of the main tail current through the M9 tran-
sistor to avoid stability issues in the common-mode feedback loop. Figure 5 depicts
the designed ¯ve transistor OTA and common-mode sensing resistors.
2250095-6
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
Right half-plane zero appears on the circuits because the pole-splitting capacitor
shorts the ¯rst- and second-stage outputs at high frequencies. The right half-plane
zero has the same magnitude response as the left half-plane zero. However, the phase
response of the right half-plane zero behaves the same as the left half-plane pole.
Thus, the stability of the system is decreased.7
The simplest method to reduce the right half-plane zero e®ect is connecting a
zero-nulling resistor series with the compensation capacitor.6 With this approach,
the zero location of the system becomes as
1
Z¼ : ð5Þ
Cc 1
gm2 Rz
If the zero-nulling resistor is made equal to 1/gm2 , the right half-plane zero dis-
appears from the system. However, the zero-nulling resistor can be used to cancel the
e®ect of the nondominant pole.6 As shown in Fig. 7, increasing the RZ value carries
the zero from the right half-plane to the left half-plane. A 180 zero nulling resistor
is used to reduce the nondominant pole's e®ect in this work.
2250095-7
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
2250095-8
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
ground. Ideally, a fully di®erential ampli¯er has in¯nite CMRR and PSRR, but due
to mismatches that is caused by parasitic extraction, the designed op-amp exhibits
72.26 dB CMRR, 87.91 dB PSRR+ and 60.41 dB PSRR. PSRR+ and PSRR
denote the noises that are originated from power supply and ground, respectively.
2250095-9
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
Fig. 9. Magnitude responses of the operational ampli¯er for TT, FF, and SS corners.
Fig. 10. Phase responses of the operational ampli¯er for TT, FF and SS corners.
2250095-10
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
Fig. 11. E®ect of temperature and supply voltage variations on the operational ampli¯er's gain.
Fig. 12. E®ect of temperature and supply voltage variations on the operational ampli¯er's phase.
Table 2. The op-amp's speci¯cations for various supply voltage and temperature variations.
2250095-11
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
Figure 16 depicts the THD of the designed operational ampli¯er from 100 kHz to the
500 MHz frequency. To achieve a trustworthy result, the ¯rst ¯ve harmonics are included
in the THD calculation. 2 k feedback resistors and 5 pF and 10 k loads are used in
post-layout THD simulation. 55 dB THD value is achieved at 100 MHz frequency.
2250095-12
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
The post-layout transient simulation of the op-amp is shown in Fig. 17. 100 mV
peak-to-peak (Vpp ) sinusoidal signal with 100 MHz frequency is applied to the op-amp
di®erential inputs for 10 periods. 2 k feedback resistor is used as a unity gain
feedback network. THD value is calculated as 55 dB for 10 periods as previously
simulated in the THD simulation.
2250095-13
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
In Table 3, recent works and their performance characteristics can be seen. The
Figure of Merit (FoM) method is used to compare the designed op-amps with their
certain characteristics. There are several ways to calculate the FoM, but in this work,
it is calculated as presented in Ref. 8.
GBW½MHz CL ½pF
FoM ¼ : ð6Þ
W ½mW
In Eq. (6), the power consumption can be changed as total current consumption.
This FoM calculation method is usable for the compared op-amp designs apart from
the process.
In this work, the FoM value is calculated as 632.86 MHzpF/mW, and the best
FoM value is achieved among the other papers that have been published.
In layout design, it is observed that big IR drops from the power supply disturb
the circuit working. To reduce the resistance values from power supply and ground
through to the op-amp circuit, metal lines with a width of 5 m from metal1 to
metal6 have been used.
Figures 18 and 19 show the post-layout Monte Carlo simulations of the gain and
phase margin of the op-amp. Totally, we ran 200 Monte Carlo simulations. We
achieved 40.49 dB mean and 1.67 dB standard deviation in gain and 50.31 mean and
2.54 standard deviation in phase margin.
2250095-14
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
Table 3. Comparison to op-amps in the literature.
2250095-15
and 1 k)
12 0.18 m 80 dB 660 MHz 73 3.8 mW 1.8 V 1 pF 173.68 2006
13 90 nm 72.1 dB 202 MHz 63 5.2 mW 1.2 V 2 pF 77.6 2015
14 90 nm 72.8 dB 221 MHz 61 2.9 mW 1.2 V 2 pF 152.8 2014
15 65 nm 60 dB 45 MHz 45 158.4 W 1.2 V 1 pF 284.1 2019
This work 65 nm 41.04 dB 1.81 GHz 51.9 14.3 mW 1.2 V 2 (5 pF and 10 k) 632.86
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
F. Barin & E. Zencir
4. Conclusion
In this paper, a fully di®erential telescopic operational ampli¯er is presented in 65 nm
technology with core and low threshold voltage devices. Despite the low-voltage
headroom caused by 1.2-V supply voltage, the telescopic cascode structure is prop-
erly designed with level shifter and low-voltage cascode current mirror circuits.
Magnitude and phase simulations are done under TT, FF and SS corners. The
2250095-16
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
A High-Speed Fully Di®erential Telescopic Op-Amp
designed op-amp has a GBW of 1.81 GHz, a low-frequency gain of 41.04 dB and a
phase margin of about 51.9 with 1.2-V supply voltage. Very high GBW value and
comparable power dissipation of the designed op-amp to other works make this
design a suitable choice for active ¯lter designs in V2X applications. The designed
op-amp can be used, where high-speed operations are the main design speci¯cations
besides the ¯lter applications.
Acknowledgments
This paper is a result of the BEYOND5 (www.beyond5.eu) project which has re-
ceived funding from the ECSEL Joint Undertaking (JU) under grant agreement No
876124. The JU receives support from the European Union's Horizon 2020 research
and innovation programme and France, Germany, Turkey, Sweden, Belgium,
Poland, Netherland, Israel, Switzerland, Romania. The document re°ects only the
authors’; view and the Commission is not responsible for any use that may be made
of the information it contains.
References
1. GSA, Automotive - Cellular-V2X Ecosystem (GSA, 2020), pp. 1–5.
2. F. Schl€ogl and H. Zimmermann, 1.5 GHz OPAMP in 120 nm digital CMOS, Proc. 30th
European Solid-State Circuits Conf. (Leuven, 2004), pp. 239–242.
3. F. Schl€ogl, K. Schweiger, H. Zimmermann and H. Uhrmann, A 1 GHz-GBW operational
ampli¯er for DVB-H receivers in 65 nm CMOS, 12th Int.l Symp. Design and Diagnostics
of Electronic Circuits & Systems (Liberec, 2009), 182–185.
4. B. Razavi, Design of Analog CMOS Integrated Circuits (McGraw Hill, New York, 2001).
5. P. J. Hurst, S. H. Lewis, R. G. Meyer and P. R. Gray, Analysis and Design of Analog
Integrated Circuits (Wiley, New York, 2001).
6. R. G. Meyer and Paul R. Gray, MOS operational ampli¯er design — A tutorial overview,
IEEE J. Solid-State Circuits 39 (1982) 969–982.
7. R. J. Baker, CMOS Circuit Design, Layout and Simulation (Wiley, New Jersey, 2010).
8. W. M. Sansen, Analog Design Essentials (Springer, US, Leuven, 2006).
9. M. Kozak, E. G. Friedman and B. Shem-Tov, A high-speed CMOS op-amp design
technique using negative Miller capacitance, Proc. 2004 11th IEEE Int. Conf. Electron-
ics, Circuits and Systems (Tel Aviv, 2004), pp. 623–626.
10. M. Taherzadeh-Sani and A. A. Hamoui, A 1-V process-nsensitive current-scalable two-
stage opamp with enhanced DC gain and settling behavior in 65-nm digital CMOS, IEEE
J. Solid-State Circuits 46 (2011) 660–668.
11. J. Harrison and N. Weste, 350 MHz Opamp-RC ¯lter in 0.18 m, Electron. Lett. 38
(2002) 259–260.
12. M. M. Ahmadi, A new modeling and optimization of gain-boosted cascode ampli¯er for
high-speed and low-voltage applications, IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. II Express Briefs 53
(2006) 169–173.
13. S. Golabi and M. Yavari, A three-stage class AB operational ampli¯er with enhanced slew
rate for switched-capacitor circuits, Analog Integr. Circuits Signal Process. 83 (2015)
111–118.
2250095-17
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
F. Barin & E. Zencir
2250095-18
Copyright of the works in this Journal is vested with World Scientific Publishing.
The article is allowed for author’s personal use only. No further distribution is allowed.
View publication stats