Evaluationofthesubsurfacestructuralfeaturesofthe Farafra Oasis
Evaluationofthesubsurfacestructuralfeaturesofthe Farafra Oasis
net/publication/371448040
CITATIONS READS
2 329
6 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Mohamed Mostafa Khalifa on 15 June 2023.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Abstract
The Egyptian government has launched enormous national initiatives to reclaim and sustainably developing of 1.5 million
acres. Among the promising areas, the Farafra Oasis which has a ground water usage for drinking and irrigation has chosen
as the focal point of the project initial phase. Qualitatively and quantitively assessment of the subsurface structures that
have an impact on the ground water circulation were taken place using the airborne magnetic data. The airborne magnetic
data was subjected to numerous magnetic processing techniques including the reduction to the northern magnetic pole
(RTP), power spectrum analysis, 3D Euler deconvolution and 3D modelling technique. Also, Tilt derivative techniques
were applied to define the main contact zones, depths and the structural indices of the causal subsurface structural features.
The deduced subsurface shallow structures were found at 2 km, whereas the deep structures were extended to 5 km depth.
Analysis of the 3D magnetic modelling emphasized the outputs of the applied power spectrum technique that the depths
of the basement rocks were ranging from 2 km to more than 4.7 km. Quantitively interpretation of the RTP map revealed
the presence of numerous NE-SW, NNE-SSW, ENE-WSW, and NW-SE faults that dissected the area.
Keywords Aeromagnetic data · Subsurface faults · 3D modeling · Euler deconvolution · Farafra Oasis
Farafra Oasis is one of the biggest tectonic depressions The Oasis marked by prominent karst features with four
located in the Egyptian Western Desert that formed in the basic geomorphologic units; northern plateau, eastern pla-
limestone plateau of uneven triangle and apexes pointing teau (sand dunes, playas, and sand sheets), western plateau
toward the Dakhla Oasis (Fig. 1). The area has a dry climate, and the bottom of the depression with their associated land-
with an average annual precipitation of 3 mm and tempera- forms (Fig. 2). These features were created by wind activity
tures ranging from 20 °C in the winter to 38 °C in the sum- in a tectonically active environment that alternated between
mer, and daily evaporation rates of 5.6 mm in December and arid and humid climates during the Miocene epoch. Several
19.8 mm in June. However, playa deposits and a hyper arid minor depressions were also created on the main depres-
environment point to a wet paleoclimate in this region (El sion’s floor by chemical weathering and wind deflation pro-
sheikh 2015). cess (Aref et al. 1987). The exposed sedimentary strata of
the Oasis are stratigraphically dated from the Late Creta-
ceous to the Recent age. Numerous authors have been stud-
ied the Oasis’s surface and subsurface geology (Said 1962;
Ahmed Awad El Ramly 1964; Hermina 1967; Barakat and Abdel Hamid
[email protected] 1974; El-Kiki 1972; Zaghloul 1983; and Salem 2002). The
surface sedimentary succession comprises of (Fig. 3): Qua-
1
National Research Institute of Astronomy and Geophysics, ternary aeolian sand and playa deposits that make up the
Helwan, Egypt
surface and the floor of the sedimentary succession. The
2
Geology Department, Faculty of Science, Al-Azhar aeolian sand creates scattered sand dunes along the plateau
University, Cairo, Egypt
surface and the floor of the depression. The playa deposits
3
Geology Department, Desert Research Center, Cairo, Egypt
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 3 Geological map of the study area, Modified after Conoco 1987
The aeromagnetic dataset used in this study are extracted Reduction to the north magnetic pole
from Getech’s compilation study ‘African Magnetic Map-
ping Project’ (AMMP) in the form of unified 1 km grid of A ccording to the earth’s coordinates, there is a changing in
total magnetic intensity (TMI) (Getech 1992; Green et al. the values of the declination and inclination angles of the
1992; Zaher et al. 2018). The airborne magnetic data was geomagnetic field that causes a shifting in the positions of
subjected to numerous magnetic processing techniques the magnetic field data.
including the reduction to the northern magnetic pole Therefore, the reduction to the north magnetic pole
(RTP), power spectrum analysis, 3D Euler deconvolution approach (RTP) helped to identify the precise location of
and 3D modelling technique. Also, Tilt derivative tech- the magnetic anomalies that reflect the subsurface structures
niques were applied to define the main contact zones, depths in the studied area. The total intensity aeromap was reduced
and the structural indices of the causal subsurface structural to the pole using the inclination angle (39°) and declination
features. angle (4°). These variables are used to create the reduced
The primary magnetic anomaly directions in the study north magnetic pole and the RTP magnetic map (Fig. 6).
region are E-W, NW-SE, and NE-SW with overall magnetic Qualitatively, the resulted magnetic sources are showing
strength ranges from − 97.41 to 125 nT. The presence of a non-homogeneous texture with three distinct anomaly
shallower subsurface magnetic sources may be responsible zones: high intensity anomaly zones (> 40 nT), anomalies
for the eastern region’s greatest values, whereas the western zones ranged from more than − 55 and less than 40 nT and
region’s lowest values were caused by a deep, poorly mag- low intensity anomaly zones (<-55 nT).
netized sedimentary layer (Fig. 5).
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 4 (A) Structural lineaments map (After Conoco 1987) and (B) Azimuth frequency diagram (Rose diagram) generated from the lineaments of
the study area
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 7 (A) low-pass filtered (regional RTP map) and (B) High-pass filtered (residual RTP map)
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
anomalies that could be shallow local structures or geologic of the edges of anomalous sources when using a vertical
features. These local anomalies are primarily found in the contact model. Specifically, at the high gradient, zero con-
E-W, NE-SW, and NW-SE directions. tours (the black line) approximate the horizontal locations
of rapid lateral shifts in magnetic susceptibilities (MS)
Tilt derivative (TDR) filter between positive and negative anomalies.
The tilt derivative filter was proposed by Miller and Singh Depth estimation techniques
(1994) and Verduzco et al. (2004) and later developed by
Salem et al. (2007a, b), Salem et al. (2008) and Fairhead The depth estimation techniques are one of the most signifi-
et al. (2010). According to its fundamental and functional cant steps in the quantitative interpretation of magnetic data
nature, it showed considerable interest (Hinze et al. 2013). that provides useful information about the source body. The
It defined as: Euler deconvolution technique and the 3D magnetic mod-
elling methodology were both utilized to assess the depth
T A = tan−1 ∂BT
/ ∂B T
, of the subsurface anomalies. They depends primarily on a
∂h
∂Z
2 (1) particular algorithm which derived based on distinct con-
2
where ∂B
∂h
T
= ∂BT
∂x
+ ∂BT
∂y straint factors and mostly controls the predicted results. For
instance, the structural index of the source body serves as
the main constraint for the Euler Deconvolution method, the
Where (∂BT/∂h), (∂BT/∂x), (∂BT/∂y), and (∂BT/∂z) are the spectral window of the FFT and the fitting method serve as
derivatives of the total magnetic field BT in the (h, x, y, z) constraints for the power spectrum, and the magnetic sus-
directions with h being any horizontal direction in the (x, ceptibility of the subsurface layers serve as constraints for
y) plane. three-dimensional modelling.
Regardless of the amplitude of the vertical derivative or
the overall horizontal gradient’s absolute value, the TDR 3D Euler deconvolution, power spectrum techniques and
ranges are from − 2/2 to + 2/2, or -90o to 90o (Salem et al., magnetic source identification
2008). The TDR yields a zero value over the source edges,
allowing one to trace the contour of the edges (Miller and The Euler deconvolution technique developed by Thomp-
Singh 1994). Hinze et al. (2013) discovered that the half son (1982) was primary used for profile data analysis and
lengths between − 45o (-0.78 rad) and + 45o (0.78 rad), or later expanded to comprises the analysis of the grid data
the horizontal distance from − 45 to the 0 point of the tilt (Reid et al. 1990). Numerous authors have also studied the
angle, are identical to the depth to the top of the contact technique (Stravrev and Reid 1997; Gerovska and Araúzo-
(Salem et al., 2007). Figure 8 shows how the TDR map Bravo (2003; Gobashy and Al-Garni (2008; Abdelazeem
makes it easier to pinpoint the horizontal location and size and Gobashy (2016; Abdelazeem et al. (2019).
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Table 2 Average depths (Zavr) in meters and structural indices (SIavr) the explained depths, structure indices and the predicted
for different groups
structure types for the five solution clusters. The G3 cluster
Cluster Zavg SIavg Predicted
causative index represents the most prevalent structural component
structure (107 solution points). It has an average depth of 3,500 m
1 2590 0.576 Contact and an average structural index of 0.7 that attributed to fault
2 1710 0.094 Contact or contact structure. The main deduced structural patterns
3 3500 0.76 Contact/ for this method was NW-SE and E-W tendencies.
thin sheet
The application of the power spectrum technique to the
4 3720 1.03 Sill/dike
potential field data was first introduced by Bhattacharyya
5 2060 0.131 Contact
(1966) that followed by Spector and Grant (1970) whose
developed the method to permit the determination the depths
The Euler homogeneity equation, when accounting for a of the anomalous bodies. The method was extensively uti-
base level for the background field, can be written as: lized by numerous authors Mishra and Naidu (1974) and
Ofoegbu and Onuoha (1991). Following the concept that
df df df the magnetic field measured at the surface is the summa-
(x − x0 ) + (y − y0) + (z − z0) = NF (2)
dx dy dz tion of the magnetic signatures from all depths. The average
depths of these source ensembles can be ascertained using
Where the homogeneous function (f) is the observed field the Fourier transform-obtained power spectrum of the mea-
at location (x, y, z) that caused by a source at location (x0, sured surface magnetic field. Using the radially averaged
y0, z0). N physically, is a measure of the rate of decay of the 2D power spectrum the depth of shallow and deep-seated
field with the distance and geophysically, is the structural magnetic components for the study area was calculated. The
index (SI) that is related directly to the shape of the caus- obtained shallow sources have a depth of up to 2 km, while
ative source. the deep sources has a depths up to 5 km (Fig. 10).
The Euler technique was applied to the RTP map to esti-
mate the depths and structural indices associated with the 3D magnetic modeling
distinct clusters arising from the various stages, in order to
evaluate the relationship between the resultant lineation and Construction of the magnetic modeling of the magnetic
the geological units in the research area. Table 1 presents the data was done using the GMSYS-3D of the Geosoft Oasis
3D-Euler deconvolution results for the study area with the Montaj (2007) software. The model was designed by a col-
approved five solution clusters and their confident, average lection of stacked grid surfaces with density, susceptibility
locations and the structure indices. Table 2 and Fig. 9 shows and magnetization distributions described for the layers
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Structural features
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 12 (A) Basement relief map and (B) 3-D view map
the deep-seated as troughs, and as synclines in the shallow- mineralization zones that can be located at the study area.
seated portion. In addition, the intense magnetic gradients According to Afflek (1963), there is a coreelation between
was portrayed as faults and lineation. The lengthy zones of the magnetic anomaly trends and the forces and intensities
high slopes without well-defined closures may have been of the Earths crust. He also claimed that the tectonic history
caused by subsurface faulting that shifted the magnetic rocks of the rocks is documented partially by the amount and pat-
(Dobrin 1990). In the present study, the structural interpre- tern of magnetic anomalies. The investigation of the Rose
tation of the aeromagnetic survey data was performed by diagram revealed that the area is influenced by numerous
constructing a basement tectonic map (Fig. 13A). This map faults taking the following tendencies NE–SW, NNE–SSW,
was primarily based on RTP magnetic anomaly and depicts ENE–WSW, and NW–SE. Some important subsurface fault
the region’s overall structural framework and major tectonic trends such as NE-SW (Aualitic) and NW-SE (Gulf of Suez-
features. The primary tectonic deformations of the studied Red Sea, Clysmic) are also extended upward in the sedi-
region was directed NE–SW, NNE–SSW, NNW–SSE, and mentary layers.
NW–SE.
The Trend analysis technique is used here to identify
the structural trends and intensity of forces as well as the
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Fig. 13 (A) Structural Features of the Study Area as deduced from RTP magnetic map and (B) Rose Diagrams Showing rose diagram of the Main
Structural Lineaments
13
Modeling Earth Systems and Environment
Barakat MG, Abdel Hamid ML (1974) Subsurface geology of Farafra Mishra DC, Naidu PS (1974) Two-dimensional power spectral analy-
Oasis, Western Desert Egypt. J Geol 17(2):97–110 sis of aeromagnetic fields. Geophys Prop 22:345–534
Bhattacharyya BK (1966) Continuous spectrum of the total magnetic Ofoegbu CO, Onuoha KM (1991) Analysis of magnetic data over the
field anomaly due to rectangular prismatic body. Geophysics Abakaliki Anticlinorium of the Lower Benue Trough, Nigeria.
31:97–121 Marine and Petr. Geolo, 8, 174–183, 1991
Conoco C (1987) Geological map of Egypt 1:500,000. The Egyptian Reid A, Allsop JM, Granser H, Miliett AJ, Somerton WI (1990) Mag-
General Petroleum Corporation, Cairo netic interpretations in three dimensions using Euler deconvolu-
Dobrin MB, Savit Ch (1990) Introduction to geophysical prospecting. tion. Geophys 55:80–91
McGraw-Hill Book Co., New Yourk, p 749 Said R (1962) The geology of Egypt; Amesterdam-New York. Else-
El Aref MM, Abou Khadrah AM, Lotfy ZH (1987) Karst topography vier, Pub. Co., Amesterdam, New York, p 377
and karstification processes in the Eocene limestone plateau of El Salem A (2002) Hydrogeological studies on the Nubian sandstone
Bahariya Oasis, Western Desert, Egypt. Z für Geomorphologie, aquifer in Bahariya and Farafra depressions, Western Desert
45–64 Egypt, Ph.D. Thesis, Geol. Dep. Fac. of Sci. Ain Shams Univ.,
El Ramly IM (1964) The use of the fissured limestone in locating Egypt, p 157
groundwater resources and its application to Farafra Oasis, West- Salem A, Williams S, Fairhead D, Smith R, Ravat D (2007a) Interpre-
ern Desert, U. A. R. Arab Soc Min Petrol Assoc Bull V XIX:15 tation of magnetic data using tilt-angle derivatives. Geophysics
El-Kiki FE, Badawi (1972) Contribution to the hydrochemical charac- 73(1):L1–L10
teristics of water bearing horizons in Kharga Oasis. Read before Salem A, Williams S, Fairhead JD, Ravat D, Smith R (2007b) Tilt-
Geol. Soc., Egypt depth method: a simple depth estimation method using first-order
El sheikh AE (2015) Mitigation of groundwater level deterioration of magnetic derivatives. Lead Edge 26(12):1502–1505
the Nubian Sandstone aquifer in Farafra Oasis, Western Desert. Spector A, Grant FS (1970) Statistical models for interpreting aero-
Egypt Environ earth Sci 74(3):2351–2367 magnetic Data, Geophysics, vol.25; 293–302, 1970
Fairhead JD, Salem A, Blakely RJ (2010) Continental to basin scale Stravrev P, Reid A (1997) Euler deconvolution of gravity anomalies
mapping of basement depth and structure using the tilt-depth from thick contact/fault structures with extended negative struc-
method, in EGM 2010 International Workshop tural index. Geophysics 75:151–158
Geosoft Oasis Montaj (2007) Aero Service Company, Mineral Petro- Thompson DT (1982) EULDPH—a technique for making com-
leum Ground-Water Assessment Program (MAGMAP), 2-D fre- puter assisted depth estimates from magnetic data. Geophysics
quency-domain processing. Geosoft Inc., Toronto, Canada 47:31–37
Gerovska D, Araúzo-Bravo MJ (2003) Automatic interpretation of Verduzco B, Fairhead JD, Green CM, Mackenzie C (2004) New
magnetic data based on Euler deconvolution with unprescribed insights into magnetic derivatives for structural mapping. Lead
structural index. Comput Geosci 29(8):949–960 Edge 23:116–119
Getech (1992) The African Magnetic Mapping Project–commercial Zaghloul EA Geology of Abu Minqar-Farafra-Ain Dalla stretch, West-
report (unpublished) ern Desert, Egypt PhD, Thesis (1983) Geology Dep., Fac.of Sci.,
Gobashy MM, Al-Garni MA (2008) High resolution ground magnetic Cairo Univ., Egypt. p 127
survey (HRGM) for determining the optimum location of sub- Zaher MA, Elbarbary S, Sultan SA, El-Qady G, Ismail A, Takla EM
surface dam in Wadi Nu’man, Makkah Al Mukarammah, KSA. J (2018) Crustal thermal structure of the Farafra Oasis, Egypt,
King Abdulaziz Univ Earth Sci 19:57–83 based on airborne potential field data. Geothermics 75:220–234
Green CM, Barritt SD, Fairhead JD, Misener DJ (1992) The African
magnetic mapping project, extended abstract, EAEG 54th meet- Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to juris-
ing and technical exhibition, Paris dictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Hermina MH (1967) Geology of the North-Western approach of
Kharga. Egypt Geol Surv, Cairo, pp 44–88 Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds
Hinze WJ, Von Frese RR, Saad AH (2013) Gravity and magnetic exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the
exploration: principles, practices, and applications. Cambridge author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted
University Press, p 385 manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of
Miller HG, Singh V (1994) Potential field tilt -a new concept for loca- such publishing agreement and applicable law.
tion of potential field sources. J Appl Geophys 32:213–217
13