Proposal Penelitian
Proposal Penelitian
ROFI’AH
NIM 1842300026
1
Lilik Tahmidaten & Wawan Krismanto. (2020). Permasalahan budaya membaca di Indonesia (Studi pustaka
tentang problematika & solusinya). Scholaria: Jurnal Pendidikan dan Kebudayaan, 10(1), 22-33.
2
Andalusia N Permatasari, D. N. (2017). Literasi Dini dengan Teknik Bercerita. Jurnal FamilyEdu, 20-21
3
Ibrahim, G. A. (2017, April 30). PISA dan Daya Baca Bangsa—Kompas.com [Newspaper]. Retrieved March 9,
2019, from Kompas.com website:
https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2017/04/30/11135891/pisa.dan.daya.baca.bangsa
detrimental to effective school learning. Through reading, students will know about
the text, understand the main idea of the text or get the gist of the reading. In addition,
reading also helps them learn many aspects even in other language skills such as
writing, speaking, and listening skills.
To improve students' reading skills is not an easy thing. There are many
processes that students have to go through starting from reading the beginning to
reading to understand the contents of the reading. In carrying out the process to
achieve a predetermined goal sometimes there are problems that can hinder the
achievement of a goal. Likewise with reading, the level of ability of each student is
different, starting from his family background, the role of parents, and the
surrounding environment.
The main problem in this case is that students may be less than necessary
reading strategies to overcome these challenges. This case will be frustrating and
demotivating, such an attitude is often the result of an unsuccessful reading
experience. this is motivated by the author when the author took teaching practice in
X Science 2 of Islamic Senior High School in Paiton Probolinggo, where most of the
students cannot read and understand the text, although some students can read or
pronounce words well but they can't understand to understand the text well because
they cannot identify the meaning difficult words in the text.
To overcome this problem, many strategies are needed so that reading
comprehension can occur. Strategies can assist teachers in creating the classroom
environment into an effective condition for teaching and learning. In the process of
reading activities, the teacher must consider students' problems, so that the use of
reading strategies can help students to understand the text. And one technique that can
be applied to increase students' insight and understanding in reading is the storytelling
technique. This technique if implemented properly, it can help students in
understanding the reading. Several teachers expressed their opinion that in applying
the storytelling technique, students would gain reading comprehension by asking
questions. Storytelling techniques can improve student learning outcomes, besides the
application of storytelling techniques that emphasize the sequence of events can make
it easier for teachers to deliver material so that learning objectives can be achieved
effectively.
Peck (1989) said that telling stories in the classroom furthers oral and written
language development, as well as furthering comprehension for reading and listening.
Malo and Bullard (2000) said that storytelling might be more powerful than other
mediums at developing skills that prepare children for reading. In an observational
study conducted by Palmer, Harshbarger, and Koch (2001), young children made
gains in story concept, comprehension, vocabulary, and many other areas, after
participating in a story time program using storytelling.
In the literature, it is highlighted that stories are an effective means of
acquiring critical reading skills (Gaber-Katz, 1999). Stories that are produced and
shared in a social context reflect social relationships. In fact, stories are a bridge
between individual experiences and social patterns. In this context, story analysis can
be a potential tool to raise a more critical awareness of social relations in society
(Faircloth, 2009). In this sense, it is considered that analyzing the story will enable
students to express their own opinions and have a critical view of the text.
Based on the description described above, the authors are interested in
conducting classroom action research entitled "Improving the Student's Reading
Comprehension Achievement Through Storytelling Techniques"
4
Anne P. Sweet. (2005). Assessment of Reading Comprehension: The RAND Reading Study Group
Vision. Department of Education.
5
Janette K. Klingner, S. V. (2007). Teaching Reading Comprehension to Students with Learning
Difficulties. New York: The Guildford Press.
Maynard in (Inayah, 2015) defined stories as the way people communicate
their experience, the way they understand the experience of others, the way
they liberate their imaginations, the way they make sense of the world and
their own position within it. Maynard stated that stories are important to
people, politics, and education. Stories are how people make sense of
themselves and their worlds.
H. Previous Research
Some writers have conducted the research about improving student’s reading
comprehension through storytelling technique. They are:
The first research was conducted by Jumairi Binti Kassim (2018). The method used
by the researcher is a qualitative research method, while the formula for calculating
the respondent's questionnaire is quantitative. Researchers used 2 classes as research,
namely class A and class B which consisted of 56 students for class A and 70 students
for class B. The number of questionnaires distributed was 44 with 10 questions. The
results of the questionnaire explained that as many as 70.46% of children liked
storytelling activities and as many as 29.54% of children did not like storytelling
activities. And as many as 100% of children admit that storytelling activities are very
important to help increase their child's reading request. From the results of the data
analysis above, it shows that the use of storytelling techniques can increase students'
reading interest in AN Nur's Kindergarten.
The second research was conducted by Sri Astuti, Sri Lestari, and Desni Yuniarni
(2019). The method used by the researcher is Classroom Action Research. This
research was conducted with a qualitative research approach because this research is
descriptive and naturalistic. This research was conducted in Islamic Kindergarten
Bina Pontianak. The subjects in this study consisted of 21 children and 2 teachers.
Data collection techniques used in this study using observation techniques. The
research implementation is planned in 3 research cycles. Based on the results of
observations on the results of teacher teaching activities in the implementation of the
storytelling method in the first cycle of 3 meetings, it shows that the teacher's teaching
ability in each indicator is in the very good category. Children's learning outcomes at
meeting 1, the category of ability to connect simple writing with symbols that
symbolize it 57.14% of children are in the category of developing according to
expectations, in the category of mentioning simple writing and symbols that
symbolize it 47.62% of children are in the category of developing according to
expectations and at the category of recognizing various kinds of vowel and consonant
symbols 52.38% of children are in the category of developing as expected. From the
results of the data analysis above, it is shown that the use of storytelling techniques
can improve students' reading skills in Islamic Kindergarten Bina Empat Lima.
The third research has been conducted by Arda Arasmita (Arasmita, 2019). The
method which is used by the writer is pre-experimental research design specifically
one-group pre-test post-test design. This research design has one class which are not
randomly selected. The researcher conducted the pretest of Grade XI IPA 1 which is
consisting of 22 students. The pretest contains of 40 questions of multiple choice
about narrative text. First, the result of mean score of posttest (76.82) was higher than
the mean score of pretest (65.11). Furthermore, the statistical analysis shows that the
value of t-counted (9.51) was higher than the value of t-table (1.721) with 0.05 level
of significance of 21 (22-1) degree of freedom (df). From result data analysis shows
that the use of Story Mapping Strategy can improve students' reading comprehension
at SMA Negeri 9 Palu.
6
Wikipedia contributors. (2021, September 24). Second-language acquisition. In Wikipedia, The Free
Encyclopedia. Retrieved 07:57, December 15, 2021, from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?
title=Second-language_acquisition&oldid=1046187090
According to Michael H. Long (Long, 2017) Second language acquisition (SLA),
like applied linguistics, is an interdisciplinary field with widely varying
interpretations placed on it, and varying demands made of it. SLA theory and
research findings are utilized in many fields, including first language acquisition,
theoretical linguistics, neurolinguistics, language learning in abnormal
populations, language teaching, education, and psychology (Long, 2017).
In Saville-Troike and Barto (Muriel Saville-Troike, 2017) Second Language
Acquisition (SLA) refers both to the study of individuals and groups who are
learning a language subsequent to learning their first one as young children, and
to the process of learning that language. The additional language is called a
second language (L2), even though it may actually be the third, fourth, or tenth to
be acquired. It is also commonly called a target language (TL), which refers to
any language that is the aim or goal of learning.
In learning a second language, it is stated that people who within themselves have
a desire, impulse, or goal to be achieved in learning a second language tend to be
more successful than people who learn without being based on an impulse, goal
and motivation.
b. Reading Comprehension
Because the purpose of reading is to understand the content of the reading, then
reading comprehension is reading cognitively (reading to understand the content
of the reading). Reading without understanding is not reading at all.
Comprehension and reading go hand in hand. Reading with comprehension is the
connection between the conscious and the subconscious. Even Edmund Burke
said 'Reading without reflection is like eating without digesting'.
Burns (Somadayo, 2011) argues that students understand a reading if they can
make conclusions, for example the main idea of the reading, the topic
sentence/main sentence in a paragraph, casual relationships, and reading analysis.
So, to reveal the reading comprehension data in this study, the researcher will
measure it through several indicators, namely:
The second research has been conducted by Indriyani (Indriyani, 2019). The
method which is used by the writer is quasi-experimental research design. In
presenting the data, the researcher analyzed the data taken from pre-test and
posttest. The researcher had given pre-test and post-test to both experimental
group and control groups. Pre-test was conducted in order to know the student’s
prior reading comprehension skill before they got the treatment. After the pre-
test, the researcher conducted the treatment by using Story Face Strategy for six
meetings to the experimental group, while the control group was not. The average
value of students in the experimental group pretest was 53.78 while the control
group was 56.47. Then the average value of the posttest the experimental group
was 78 while the control group was 66.27. In analyzing the data, the researcher
used 0.05 as the significance level and 62 (30+34-2) degrees of freedom (df). The
calculated t value in this study is 7.64 and the t table value is 1.67. The calculated
value of t is greater than the value of the t table, which means that the hypothesis
is accepted. In other words, the use of Story Face Strategy can improve reading
comprehension tenth grade students at SMA Negeri 1 Parigi.
The third research has been conducted by Greselia Kaganang (Kaganang, 2019).
The method which is used by the researcher is Classroom Action Research. This
researcher took 21 students from a class (class B) in Senior High School 1 of
Middle Halmahera. The result can be seen by using frequency (f) which is
significantly different from 1st to 2nd cycle. In the 1st cycle, the f of result No is
11 which means that 11 students or 52 % of the students do not pass the passing
grade. In the 2nd cycle, the f of result No decreased significantly from 11 to 1
which means that the percentage of the students who do not pass the passing
grade decreased from 52% to 5%. To make it clearer, we can see the difference of
the MIN, MAX, and MEDIAN of each cycle. It can be seen that the lowest score
in the 2nd cycle is higher than the score in 1st cycle. It also can be seen that the
median and the highest score in the 2nd cycle are higher than in the score in the
1st cycle. Based on the data showed above, it can be concluded that Problem-
Based Learning has increased the students’ reading comprehension.
e. Story Telling
Success in learning to read comprehension, it is necessary to pay attention to
some basic principles of designing reading learning as stated by Brown (Abidin,
2012), one of which is the need for reading learning techniques/strategies to build
students' intrinsic motivation. One of the techniques that can be used to improve
students' reading comprehension is the storytelling technique. Storytelling is one
of the learning strategies that can provide a learning experience for students.
Through stories, many things can be conveyed and understood by listeners,
because of the interesting way of delivery, the language used is also simpler. In
her article, Maxine (Alterio, 2002) reveals that storytelling is a powerful and
enduring means of communication that has widespread appeal. Storytelling is an
ideal teaching and learning tool, because it urgently requires students to make
sense of the experience, using the meaning-making process generated by their
own culture as cited in (Alterio, 2002). Storytelling can also support and enhance
relationships between students who create new knowledge and learn from others.
This is supported by Mauro (Dujmovic, 2006) Storytelling is also a living art.
In story telling activities, the storytelling process becomes very important because
from this process the value or message of the story can reach students. When the
story telling process takes place, there is an absorption of knowledge that is
conveyed by the storyteller to the listener. Many do not realize that how to teach
students can create an unpleasant impression during reading comprehension
activities. Reading comprehension activities that only rely on books will seem
boring. And therefore, reading comprehension activities will not be effective.
Most students feel forced when they learn to read and understand the text.
However, with storytelling, students will have a different experience. Through
storytelling, students will learn to read and understand the text without feeling
forced to do so.
Through storytelling technique, it is expected that students' reading
comprehension achievement will be further increased.
J. Research Method
1. Approaches and Type of Research
The research approach used in this research is Classroom Action Research. This is
because classroom action research is able to offer approaches and procedures that
have a direct impact on improving and increasing teacher professionalism in
managing the learning process in the classroom.
From some of the definitions above, it can be concluded that classroom action
research (CAR) is a research method whose implementation is carried out to find
out problems in the learning process and the steps that teachers can use in
improving the quality of learning. Classroom action research is also research
conducted to improve the learning process in the classroom, so that there is an
improvement in teacher performance in the teaching and learning process which
ultimately affects student learning outcomes.
2. Research Subject
The subject of this research was class X Science 2 that consisted of 36 students. This
research was conducted at MA Nurul Jadid Paiton Probolinggo in the academic year
2021/2022.
3. Collecting Data
In this study, the researchers used qualitative and quantitative for collecting data.
Data collection techniques are activities to find data in the field that will be used
to answer research problems. This matter because the right technique will produce
accurate data. Judging from the data collection theory according to Arikunto
(Arikunto, 2010) which states that the process carried out by researchers to
uncover or capture phenomena, locations or conditions of researchers is in
accordance with the scope of research.
Data collection techniques used in this study are as follows:
a) Observation
Observation technique is a data collection technique by observing the
research object. Observations were made during the implementation of
learning; this observation was to determine the activities of students and
educators as well as the implementation of lesson plans and the
implementation of learning during the teaching and learning process.
b) Test
A test is a tool or procedure used to find out or measure something in an
atmosphere, in a way and with predetermined rules. The test is used by
researchers to get the learning outcomes of students who have studied
reading comprehension through storytelling techniques as an evaluation
after the learning process takes place.
4. Analysis Data
Qualitative data analysis is conducted if the empirical data obtained is qualitative
data in the form of a collection of tangible words and not a series of numbers and
cannot be arranged in categories/classification structures. Data can be collected in
various ways and are usually processed before they are ready for use, but
qualitative analysis still uses words that are usually arranged into expanded text,
and does not use mathematical calculations or statistics as analytical tools.
According to Miles and Huberman, analytical activities consist of three streams of
activities that occur simultaneously, namely data reduction, data presentation, and
conclusion drawing/verification.
K. Systematic Research
This research was conducted in cycles (cycle 1 and cycle 2). Each cycle consists of
four steps, namely: planning, action, observation, and reflection. Each step consists of
several items that must be done as follows:
Planning: A plan developed for carrying out an action and/or used to collect
information and data in order to observe or capture the experience or monitor
the practice. In this stage the research questions and methods are made
explicit.
Action: Researchers implement plans or change practices and collect data.
Data can be collected from various sources.
Observation: at this stage the researcher observes class activities during the
teaching and learning process and analyzes the data. The main issues related to
the problem are identified.
Reflection: The researcher reflects and interprets the information and
communicates and discusses it with the class to determine whether further
cycles are needed or not.
Bibliography
Abidin, Y. (2012). Pembelajaran membaca berbasis pendidikan karakter. Bandung: Refika Aditama.
Alterio, M. (2002). Using storytelling to enhance student learning . Higher Education Academy.
Andalusia N Permatasari, D. N. (2017). Literasi Dini dengan Teknik Bercerita. Jurnal FamilyEdu, 20-21.
Arikunto, P. D. (2010). Prosedur Penelitian: Suatu Pendekatan Praktik. Jakarta: Rineka Cipta.
caroline T Linse, D. N. (2005). Practical English language teaching : young learners. New York:
McGraw Hill.
Catherine Snow, C. (2002). Reading for Undestanding: Toward an R&D Program in Reading
Comprehenison. Arlington: RAND.
Creswell, J. (2012). Educational Research: planning, conducting, and evaluating quantitative and
qualitative research 4th. Boston: Pearson Education.
Creswell, J. W. (2008). Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative and
Qualitative Research. New Jersey: Pearson.
Duffy, G. G. (2009). Explaining Reading, Second Edition: A Resource for Teaching Concepts, Skills, and
Strategies. New York: The Guilford Press.
Dujmovic, M. (2006). Sory Telling as a method of EFL Teaching. Methodical Horizons, 77.
Harun, L. (2018). The Implementation of Learning Model in Talking Stick by Using Short Story Text to
Improve Students’ Reading Comprehension At SMP Negeri 15 TIKEP. Langua: Journal of
Linguistics Literature, and Language Education.
Inayah, R. (2015). IMPROVING STUDENTS’ SPEAKING SKILL THROUGH. Eltin Journal: Journal of
English Language Teaching in Indonesia, 30.
Indriyani. (2019). USING STORY FACE STRATEGY TO IMPROVE STUDENTS. e-journal of ELTS (English
Language Teaching Society).
Mills, G. E. (2011). Action Research: A Guide for the Teacher Researcher, 4th Edition. Boston:
Pearson.
Nell K. Duke, P. D. (2009). Effective Practices for Developing Reading Comprehension. Journal of
Education, 216.
Somadayo, S. (2011). Strategi dan teknik pembelajaran membaca. Yogyakarta: Graha Ilmu.
Sweet, A. P. (2005). Assessment of Reading Comprehension: The RAND Reading Study Group Vision.
Department of Education.