G10 SLM3.a Q3 Final 4 - Removed
G10 SLM3.a Q3 Final 4 - Removed
English
Quarter 3 – Module 3.a:
CRITIQUING A LITERARY SELECTION BASED ON
STRUCTURALIST/FORMALIST AND MORALIST
APPROACHES
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_v2
English – Grade 10
Alternative Delivery Mode
Quarter 3 – Module 3a: CRITIQUING A LITERARY SELECTION BASED ON
STRUCTURALIST/FORMALIST AND MORALIST APPROACHES
Second Edition, 2021
Republic Act 8293, section 176 states that: No copyright shall subsist in any
work of the Government of the Philippines. However, prior approval of the
government agency or office wherein the work is created shall be necessary for
exploitation of such work for profit. Such agency or office may, among other things,
impose as a condition the payment of royalties.
WHAT I KNOW 2
WHAT’S IN 2
Task 1 2
WHAT’S NEW 3
Task 2 3
Task 3 4
WHAT IS IT 5
WHAT’S MORE 10
Task 4 10
ASSESSMENT 20
GLOSSARY 23
ANSWER KEY 24
REFERENCE LIST 26
4ii
Hi again dear learner! Welcome to this Module 3a in G10 English for
Quarter 3. In the previous module, you were taught how to compose an
independent critique of a chosen selection. I’d like to believe that you already
have in mind the basic steps or ways in writing a critique for they are
important processes in literary criticism.
You will be provided with activities that will assist you as you learn
about the meaning of literary criticism, about what is critiquing a literary
selection, what does it mean to critique literature, how to critique a literary
selection, what are the ways or approaches to be employed in critiquing a
literary selection, why do we need to write critiques and how to write a
critique or close analysis and/or critical interpretation of a literary text.
Critique examples are also provided which will serve as your guide in making
your own literary reviews later.
I hope that through this module you will learn to appreciate literary
criticism and its approaches. Thus, it is of high importance that you
complete all the tasks carefully and productively. Work with your heart and
perform well. Have a good time learning this module.
Learning Competency
1
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
Please take note that all answers shall be written in your activity
notebooks, and that there should never be any markings placed in this
module.
Pre-assessment:
critique
interpret
2
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
. To give the reader a sense of the writer's overall purpose and
intent.
2. To examine how the structure and language of the text convey
its meaning.
3. To state the significance or importance of each part of the text.
4. To make a judgment of the work's worth or value.
5. To evaluate (a theory or practice) in a detailed and analytical
way.
This time, I want you to look at the illustration below. Observe closely.
D
source:
https://www.shutterstock.com/image-
illustration/cute-black-roof-3d-residential-house-
207612982
NOTE: No matter from what angle we are seeing the object, it’s still the
same. It doesn’t change. You still see a house.
3
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
This task is related to literary criticism. When it comes to literary
criticism, you are looking at a text or selection in different angles or in
different perspectives. So no matter what perspective or what angle you look
at a certain text, the text remains the same. It’s just that you are looking at
it in different ways. The next task shows an example of a poem that you may
have encountered in your Grade 9 English. Let us find out what are your
views on this literary text.
Instructions: Read and understand the poem below by Robert Frost and
answer the questions that follow. Write down your answers in your
notebook.
4
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
QUESTIONS:
1. How many stanzas does the poem have? How many verses or lines
does each stanza have?
2. What words rhyme with another in the first stanza?
3. Does the poem use figure of speech?
4. What are the metaphors found in the poem? (Give at least 2)
(Metaphor refers to an implied comparison or the use of a word or
phrase to refer to something that is not, invoking a direct similarity
between the word or phrase used and the thing described without the
words like or as)
5. Pick out the simile in the 2nd stanza.
(Simile is a figure of speech in which one thing is compared to
another, in the case of English generally using like or as)
6. Identify the assonance in the last stanza.
(Assonance is the repetition of similar or identical vowel sounds,
though with different consonants)
7. What figure of speech is the third line of the second stanza?
8. What is the tone or feeling of the author of this poem?
When you look at the object in Task 2 and read the poem in Task 3,
did you ask yourself some questions? It is natural for us to ask questions
when we read. Part of the reading process is to make connections to the
writing, which means you spend time interpreting it.
What does it mean to interpret literature? When you interpret
literature, you are trying to find the meaning and significance of a literary
work, like a story for example. You criticize it. You are asking yourself both
what the text means and why it is important. And there are many ways on
how to properly interpret or evaluate literature.
In Task 2, you were asked to describe, examine or evaluate the given
object. In Task 3 you were also asked to analyze, evaluate, or interpret the
given poem. You were actually criticizing an object or a piece of literary
work. It is when you look at the thing and text in different perspectives or
in different angles that you can actually understand it. You did literary
criticism in Task 3 so you can fully understand the context of the text.
5
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
What Is a Critique and Literary Criticism?
One reader writes down his or her views on what a particular work of
literature means so that others can respond to that interpretation. The
ccritics typically engage in dialogue or debate with other critics, using the
views of other critics to develop their own points.
6
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
between the individual and society, and so on--so that when we approach
these problems we do so with greater self-awareness and greater tolerance
for the views of others. When we interpret literature, we are taking what we
already know about human nature and adding in the experience and
wisdom of the author (even if we don't share all of the author's convictions).
Interpretation then is a social act--we bring to it all of our past experiences
with people, and we come away with an even richer, more complex
understanding.
As a reader of literature, you may find the views of others very helpful
in developing your own interpretations. When you write an essay about
literature, you will also find criticism helpful for supporting your points. But
criticism should never be a substitute for your own original views--only in
very rare cases would an assignment require you to summarize a critical
work without including your interpretation of the literature. Besides being
useful, good literary criticism can be fun in itself, like listening to and
participating in a lively discussion among friends. By reading the critic, you
add yet another point of view to yours and the author's.
(https://www.uv.es/~fores/programa/hale_literarycritic.html)
Writing a critique helps us to develop knowledge of the work’s subject
area or related works, gain understanding of the work’s purpose, intended
audience, development of argument, structure of evidence or creative style,
and it provides recognition of the strength and weaknesses of the literary
work.
7
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
COMMON CRITICAL APPROACHES TO LITERATURE
8
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
view, diction, symbolisms, and other elements of the text (including the
elements of plot). In formalism we have to identify how these elements
contribute in the progress and message of the whole story itself.
So, don’t ever forget that formalism seeks out meaning from a work by
giving attention to the form or structure of a work and literary devices
operating it. Meaning, in examining a text through formalism, the social,
historical, cultural, and political realities inside the text are neglected. Bear
in mind that Formalist Criticism uses the following in order to interpret the
text:
a. Literary elements – how each element of the work relates to the
work as a whole
b. Literary devices – how the literary devices function to create
meaning
c. Structure – how the work is structured or organized (formed)
d. Language – language of literary work; style of writing
9
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
• What are the behavior/s that the characters display which the author
wants us to think are “right”?
• What behavior is “wrong”? What religious or ethical beliefs does the
text deal with directly? Are there any religions or philosophies
mentioned specifically in the text?
• What religious or ethical beliefs or philosophies does the author seem
to favor?
Look for:
• Moral (good)
• Immoral (bad)
• Amoral (neutral)
More Issues:
• What moral issues are raised in the story?
• How do they relate to / reflect on moral issues facing our society?
• What standards of morality are presented in the story?
Instructions: Read and analyze the poem below entitled “Richard Cory” by
Edwin Arlington Robinson. Identify what approach to literature is used in
each of the given criticisms. Choose between structuralist or formalist
approach and moralist approach.
Richard Cory
by EDWIN ARLINGTON ROBINSON
STANZAS ILLUSTRATIONS
1
Whenever Richard Cory went downtown,
We people on the pavement looked at him:
He was a gentleman from soul to crown,
Clean favored, and imperially slim.
10
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
“Good morning” and he glittered when he walked.
CRITICISMS APPROACH
1. (For stanza 1)
-There is Alliteration= the words “people” and
“pavement” (P sound is repeated)
-Rhyme scheme= the words “town”, “crown” and “him”,
“slim” rhymes
-The pattern is ABAB
2. (For stanza 2)
-There is Repetition=Two lines at the top begin in the
same way “And he was always”
-Rhyme= “arrayed”, “said” and “talked”, “walked”
3. (For stanza 3)
-Rhyme= the words “king”, “everything” rhymes and
“grace”, “place” rhymes
4. (For stanza 4)
-Irony= This situation is irony because Richard Cory, a
man who seemed to have everything, is the one who
takes his own life in such a violent way.
-Rhyme = “light”, “night” and “bread”, “head” rhymes
5. The poem is about Richard Cory, a rich man who
seems to have everything in life but still kills himself in
the end. The poem is set in a place where people can
see the huge gap between the rich and the poor.
The poem has 4 stanzas and each stanza has four
lines. It uses an ABAB rhyming pattern throughout the
poem, which means that the first- and third-line
11
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
rhyme, as well as the second and fourth line (town and
crown, and him and slim).
6. We tend to judge people based on how they look on
the outside. Richard Cory looks as if he has everything
in life, but he is still unsatisfied, hence, he kills
himself. Although it is not exactly clear why he decides
to do that, one thing’s for sure, he is not happy. The
lesson here is that happiness is not tied to
achievements, fortune, or material things.
7. The poem is written in iambic pentameter, which
means that there are five sets of unstressed and
stressed syllables. The poem uses words such as
gentleman, clean favored, imperially slim, glittered, and
schooled to make a clear picture of the appearance of
Richard Cory.
8. Richard Cory committed suicide because of his
“spiritual vacancy” and his lack of purpose and that
the “people on the pavement” are surprised by the self-
violence of so imperial a man and are somewhat awed
by the mystery of life.
Now that you have knowledge on two approaches, also bear in mind
that when you use these approaches in understanding a certain literary text
it doesn’t mean that your criticism or interpretation of that particular text is
already correct. Always remember that it’s only the author who knows the
real meaning of his literary piece. These approaches function as, for
instance, your eyeglasses or pair of lenses through which you view the text
you are reading. (See the illustration below)
Congratulations! You’ve made it this far! It’s time for you to share your
learning insights, reflect on them and assess your skills, knowledge, and
12
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
comprehension. Think of why you need to learn the concepts on approaches
to literature and their importance especially in critiquing a literary selection.
Ponder on what you have learned, what you have realized, and what you
intend to apply in the future. Use the sentence starters on the next page and
write your reflections in your journal notebook.
Example:
I have learned that
Topic Fully introduces the Introduces the topic Does not introduce
topic they are writing they are writing the topic they are
about about writing about
Details Supplies more than Supplies one fact Supplies no facts
one fact about the about the topic about the topic
topic
Closure Provides a sense of Provides a sense of Does not provide a
closure related to the closure that is sense of closure
topic unrelated
Comments: TOTAL
Student Name:
Adapted from:
https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/Product/Common-Core-Explanatory-Writing-Rubric-282873
13
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
ASSESSMENT
Finally, you were able to deal with the different related activities to sharpen
your skills on critiquing a literary selection based on structuralist or formalist
approach and moralist approach. Now, it’s time to evaluate your learning. Ready?
Here we go!
Directions: Read and understand the following statements. Draw a in
your notebook if the given statement is true and if the statement is false.
Great! You have done a very good job. You can make use of what youhave
learned about critiquing or writing critical interpretations of a literary text based
on Structuralist/Formalist and Moralist Approaches in your daily life.
Now, relax for a while, spend time at ease and stretch your muscles.
Decompress and cope with whatever you are struggling with. Be relieved
from the efforts and stress of everyday life. Take your snacks, drink a refreshing
juice or a glass of water and attend to your personal necessities. When you are
already feeling relaxed, return to your study area and do this related activity.
14
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
Bressler, C. (n.d). Literary criticism. An introduction to theory and practice.
https://www.pearson.com/us/higher-education/product/Bressler-Literary-
Criticism-An-Introduction-to-Theory-and-Practice-4th-
Edition/978013153443 html
Nance, Tim. “What is Literary Criticism?” Last modified Feb 25, 2015. Accessed
February 10, 2021. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f31V4XiPBdI.
17
NegOr_Q3_English10_Module3a_V2
For inquiries or feedback, please write or call: