Grade 10 Task 1 Tourism Skills Assessment Task: Scenario: Western Cape - Attraction Sector and Problem Solving
Grade 10 Task 1 Tourism Skills Assessment Task: Scenario: Western Cape - Attraction Sector and Problem Solving
Grade 10 Task 1
Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Scenario: Western Cape – Attraction Sector and Problem Solving
TEACHER INSTRUCTIONS
Page 1 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Study the information in ANNEXURE A and answer the questions that follow
about the attraction subsectors of the Tourism industry.
1.2 Select one attraction subsector and discuss two benefits of this
subsector for the tourism industry (It does not have to be from
Question 1.1). (5)
1.3 Predict THREE negative impacts of too many visitors to attractions that
belong to the conservation sector. (3)
1.4 Tabulate (write in a table with columns) the attractions you identified in
Question 1.1 into the following categories: man-made or natural. (4)
1.5 Name the site where the activity can be seen as an extraordinary ‘mode
of transport’. (2)
1.6 The site that you named in Question 1.5 can be classified as a primary
attraction. By referring to the distance table in ANNEXURE B, describe
TWO other activities that are also available for tourists as secondary
attractions. (4)
[30]
Page 2 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Overview
A problem the attractions in the Western Cape and elsewhere are facing, is that isolated
hiking trails for locals and tourists are targeted by criminals. These areas are supposed to
be a getaway to enjoy the beauty of nature and experience National Parks and World
Heritage Sites as true authenticity of South Africa. It is unfortunate that the beauty of these
attractions is overshadowed by crime and violence.
Refer to ANNEXURE C
Scenario
You are chosen by UNESCO to investigate one of the challenges that occurred in the
past at the Table Mountain National Park. Carefully read ANNEXURE C and see which
article interests you the most. You will then answer the questions below on the challenges
faced.
There are various techniques that one can use to solve a problem. The Fish
Technique is used widely to solve complex problems.
Study the information about this technique before applying it to an issue facing the
tourism industry in the Western Cape.
Read the information in your resource pack about the Fish Technique.
Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTzDL_RjQ9U
A transcript (what is said is typed out in words) can be read in Annexure D of the
resource pack if you do not have access to the video.
Another possibility is to read the transcript (text) and then watch the video, and thereafter
simultaneously follow on the transcript (text) what is said on the video.
2.1 Read the information about the Fish Technique and watch the relevant
video clip.
Choose ONE of the challenges from ANNEXURE C and use the Fish
Technique (ANNEXURE D) to identify the causes and effects of this
problem.
Use ANNEXURE E and complete the Fish Technique diagram on
your answer sheet as indicated on the next page.
Page 3 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
3.1 Which of Section 1 or Section 2 did you like completing the most?
Give the reasons for your preference.
3.2 Which part of completing the Tourism Skills Assessment task did
you struggle with the most and why?
3.4 List the insights that completing this Tourism Skills Assessment
task brought to you.
[5]
[20]
GRAND TOTAL: 50
Page 4 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
ASSESSMENT INSTRUMENT
Page 5 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
The main issue is not Only ONE cause or NO Only ONE solution or NO
indicated. causes have been indicated solutions have been
on the diagram using the indicated. Information from
information Annexures the Annexures provided has
provided. ✓ not been used. ✓
The main issue is incorrectly TWO causes indicated but Through critical thinking
described.✓ information provided in the TWO possible solutions
Annexures has not been were identified. The
used. ✓✓ information provided in the
Annexures has not been
used. ✓✓
The main issue has been THREE correct causes have Through critical thinking
identified correctly.✓✓ been indicated using the THREE possible solutions
information provided in the have been identified.
Annexures.✓✓ ✓ Information from the
Annexures provided have
been used.✓✓✓
FOUR correct causes have Through critical thinking
been indicated using the FOUR possible solutions
information provided in the have been identified.
Annexures.✓✓✓✓ Information from the
Annexures provided have
been used.✓✓✓✓
Page 6 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
QUESTION 3 (5 marks)
Criteria 0 1 2-3 4-5 T M
Complete Unable to give Able to give Able to give a Well-written
the self- a preference some clear preference preference with
reflection and reasons preference with some reasons, and
questions for the but no reason reason and able able to give
preference. and able to to indicate a fair clear
Unable to indicate some number of parts indications of all
indicate which parts they they struggled the parts they
part they struggled with. struggled with.
struggled with. with. Able to Able to
Unable to Able to recommend recommend
recommend recommend a some good
improvement. bit of improvement or improvements
Unable to list improvement list more than a or list many
insights. or list a few few insights. good insights.
insights.
GRAND TOTAL: 50
Page 7 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
RESOURCE PACK
ANNEXURE A – Western Cape Tourist Attractions
3. GARDEN ROUTE
Page 8 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
4. KKNK
5. STRUISBAAI HARBOUR
6. CAPE AGULHAS
The V&A Waterfront in Cape Town is one of the most popular tourist destinations in South
Africa. Located on the edge of the city’s busy harbour, the V&A Waterfront offers a wide
range of shopping, dining and entertainment options. The area is home to a number of
markets, restaurants, pubs and clubs, as well as the popular Two Oceans Aquarium.
There is something for everyone making it the perfect place to spend a day or two
exploring. Take a harbour tour and enjoy the views from the waters, or aim a little higher
on the Ferris wheel (observation wheel) known as the ‘The Cape Wheel’. There are also
plenty of shops and restaurants that cater to young and old. Whether looking for a taste of
local culture or just wanting to relax by the water, the V&A Waterfront has something for
everyone.
Page 9 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Located in the V&A Waterfront, the Two Oceans Aquarium showcases the different
oceans’ wildlife through interactive displays and more than 8 000 marine (sea) animals
from 200-plus marine species.
- Family fun at Cape Town’s aquarium in the V&A Waterfront.
- Over 3 000 marine animals from the Atlantic and Indian Oceans alone.
- See sharks, penguins, seahorses, jellyfish, turtles and thousands of fish.
- Jelly Hall - a breath-taking display of jellyfish
TABLE MOUNTAIN
AERIAL CABLEWAY
V&A WATERFRONT
(starting from Mossel
KKNK (Oudtshoorn)
TABLE MOUNTAIN
NATIONAL PARK
GARDEN ROUTE
CAPE AGULHAS
AQUARIUM
HARBOUR
Bay)
DISTANCE IN KM
STRUISBAAI HARBOUR
223 222 273 323 6.8 219
Page 10 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
ANNEXURE C – Articles
06 Dec 2023
The latest attacks within the Table Mountain National Park involved a mountain
guide and her American friend, as well as a group of mountain bikers. Both groups
were held up at knifepoint. Two suspects were arrested in connection with the
mountain bike incident.
In the first incident, which happened between 8:15 and 9:00 on Monday morning,
mountain guide Brinny Ridgway and a tourist friend from North Carolina in the USA were
robbed by a man holding a knife on the Kasteelspoort hiking trail on Table Mountain.
The Kasteelspoort trail takes hikers to a lesser-visited part of Table Mountain, with views
of Camps Bay, Lion’s Head, Clifton beaches and the mountain range.
Ridgway, who has 15 years’ experience as a mountain guide, said the robber was hiding
behind a bush at the top of the trail, dressed in khaki pants. He suddenly jumped in front
of them with a “big knife”, ordering them not to move.
“He ordered us to sit down. And then he took my wedding ring, and said he would chop
my finger off as I was having difficulty taking it off. He took my friend’s phone and asked
me if I had any cash. I gave him all my cash, including my cell phone,” she said.
“He then wanted me to log into my bank account and transfer some money to him, but
there’s no reception there. I explained to him, and showed him, I was trying to log in. I
said to my friend just sit down and don’t look at him. After we gave him the cash he
actually calmed down.”
“He gave me my purse and driver’s licence back, and all my cards. He went a little way
down to get reception, and said we shouldn’t move. As he went down the path, we quickly
gathered our bags and went up the mountain as quickly as we could.”
They bumped into two women from the mountain club and told them what had happened,
and then reported the incident at Camps Bay police station.
Page 11 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
A group of mountain bikers had been held up at knifepoint and mugged of their valuables.
A description of the attackers was quickly circulated among various role players within the
Table Mountain National Park Safety Forum. “A short while later, SAPS arrested suspects
matching the description.”
“We now need to ensure that these criminals are brought to justice.”
Andy Davies from Friends of Table Mountain (FOTM) said the Kasteelspoort incident is
unheard of.
“It is the first time an attack has been reported that high up on the side of the mountain.”
The latest attacks are among more than 80 muggings that have been reported on Table
Mountain, Signal Hill and Lion’s Head in 2023, according to the FOTM.
“The trees, the peace and quiet and the fresh air helped me to clear my mind and process
thoughts after a busy day.”
“I begged them not to hurt me and I handed over my phone, even volunteered the
necklace I was wearing. Immediately after that the two men robbed another person close
by and disappeared. “Even though I got away unharmed, the trauma and feelings of
violation still affect me. I haven’t had the courage to go back to the mountain,” she admits.
A lot has been taken, comfort, the feeling of freedom, and the feeling of safety.”
The criminals are well aware that once they try anything in town they will get caught, so
they go to Table Mountain because there is no beefed-up security.
Page 12 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Crime has no boundary, said Taahir Osman, the founder of Take Back Our Mountains
(TBOM), an organisation that arranges secure hikes and runs in all high-risk areas in the
Table Mountain National Park.
“The criminals are taking advantage because there is no beefed-up security on the
ground. It’s all about talk-show hype whenever there is a crime in the media, but being on
the group doing regular patrols is a different story.”
“Crime is something that has been inherited from social and economic challenges years
ago, that is why we are severely struggling nowadays. The Cape Town city managers
have improved cameras within the CBD with a lot of small security units to boost safety in
the inner city, only forgetting all these other areas like Table Mountain National Park.
“SANParks is not putting much effort in intensifying its efforts to deal with these ongoing
attacks on mountain users. The national park is currently a weak point.”
FOTM have started a campaign to stop crime. There is a link to its petition.
If you feel threatened or uncomfortable on the mountain you can call the city’s emergency
line on 021-4807700.
Hiking up Table Mountain is a very rewarding experience. The majestic mountain offers a
variety of routes to the top, but the mountain is as beautiful as it is dangerous.
Page 13 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
While you might have heard about ‘easy’ routes to the top, the effort it takes – and the
dangers involved – should not be underestimated.
Business Day reported that callouts for rescuers on Table Mountain increased from 169 in
2015 to 175 in 2016.
Spokesman Johan Marais told the paper that rescuers were most commonly called out to
people getting lost, injured or dehydrated. The majority of these are tourists.
“The majority of people who report incidents are people from overseas; about 70% of our
calls is to rescue a tourist. People underestimate Table Mountain,” he said. “They
misjudge the size of the mountain and they go unprepared. They don’t take water with
and they wear flip flops.”
If you plan on hiking up Table Mountain, here are some safety tips. These tips are not
meant to discourage you from hiking to the top. The climb to the top is one of the most
fulfilling ways to get up there, but you must be safe.
BE PREPARED
This might sound like an obvious one, but far too many people do not understand what
being prepared for a hike up the mountain means. Plenty of water, correct footwear, a
charged phone (and a power bank for good measure), a map, sunscreen and warm
clothing are some of the essentials you need to hike up. Even when opting for a so-called
‘easy’ route like Platteklip Gorge, the weather can change in an instant and dehydration is
a risk.
Seriously. Do not think you are safe just because the clouds are covering the sun. Make
sure you are covered in sunscreen – or better yet – wear a thin jacket to keep the most
harmful rays away. A couple of packets of Rehidrat are also a must.
Take note of landmarks so that you know where you are at all times and know how to
return should you get lost. If you are lost or hurt and need assistance, take clear images
of where you are and some landmarks that can help the rescue team find you. Also keep
in mind to not risk going onto ledges to get the ‘perfect’ selfie. And watch out for snakes.
DON’T GO ALONE
Do not attempt hiking up the mountain on your own, especially if you are not familiar with
the routes. Make sure you go with somebody who knows what they are doing. And never
attempt routes you’re not familiar with on your own or even in a group.
Page 14 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
CARRY A MAP
Slingsby maps are recommended by the professionals. It’s important that you familiarise
yourself with your route up and down. If you plan on taking the cable car down, be sure
to check on the official website whether the cable car is running.
There are several different routes. While some – like Platteklip – are popular and busy
and more difficult to get lost on, many of the other routes can be dangerous and very easy
to get lost on. Do not underestimate just how big the mountain is – and how easy it is to
get lost – when you use these routes. If you are unsure, book your hike with a qualified
guide.
Always make sure somebody knows where you are and how long you expect your hike to
take. Let them know when you get to the top.
Leave behind all valuable belongings like your passport, expensive jewellery or cash
General Emergency Number: 0214807700 from a Cell Phone, or 107 from any Telkom
Line
Page 15 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Video – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QTzDL_RjQ9U
A transcript (what is said is typed out in words) can be read here in Annexure D of the
resource pack if you do not have access to the video.
Another possibility is to read the transcript (text) and watch the video, and then
simultaneously follow what is said on the video on the transcript (text).
For the learner with a visual impairment: Audio on the video as well as the possibility
that the transcript can be read at a slower pace or recorded in a familiar accent.
Write the problem on the right-hand side of a white sheet of paper. This represents the
head of the fish.
Page 16 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Step Two
Draw a straight line from the problem all the way across to the left side of the paper. This
line represents the backbone of the fish.
Step Three
Write down the causes of the problem, connecting each cause with a line to the spine of
the fish. This represents the first bones of the fish diagram.
Page 17 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Step Four
Gather more information and find possible causes for the causes in point 3. Connect
these with smaller lines to the main causes in point 3. These will represent the smaller
finer bones of the fish. In this way you will break down the problem into the main root
causes, making it clearer what the actual problem is.
Step Five
Brainstorm many possible solutions. Solutions are ones that eliminate the root cause
preventing the problem from reoccurring.
Page 18 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
Step Six
Decide on the most appropriate solution to implement and take action. The best solution
may be the one that meets the business’ interests. Factors such as cost, duration and
complexity must be taken into consideration while finding the appropriate solution.
Step Seven
Feedback is very essential in making sure of the impact of the solution. In other words,
making sure your solutions have not created extra problems and has removed what was
an obstacle in your business’ path to success.
As explained, the fish technique is one of the most used techniques in organisations
today.
We suggest you use it in finding excellent solutions to your problems making it a unique
and challenging experience.
Page 19 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
ANNEXURE E
Page 20 of 21
Grade 10: 2024 Task 1: Tourism Skills Assessment Task
ANNEXURE F
Page 21 of 21