CH 2
CH 2
INTRODUCTION
Many business enterprises have followed various principles in their working over a period of time.
Like APPLE, SAMSUNG, TATA, MAHINDRA, TOYOTA, HONDA
A number of management THINKERS, and WRITERS have also studied principles of management from time-to-
time.
Management principles have evolved and are in the continuous process of evolution.
You can see that the evolution of management thought has been very fascinating.
In this chapter we will study the contributions of
1. Fredrick Winslow Taylor - American mechanical engineer ‘Scientific Management’ and
2. Henri Fayol - French mining engineer ‘Administrative Principles’
Who as you have read are associated with the Classical Management Theory.
- Procedures OR Methods,
Principles are guidelines to take decisions or actions
- Which involve a series of steps to be taken to while practicing techniques.
accomplish desired goals.
Values are something, which are Acceptable OR Principles are basic truths or guidelines for
Desirable. behaviour.
They have moral connotations. Principle of management are formed after research in
work situations,
Values are general rules for behaviour of individuals Which are technical in nature.
in society formed through common practice
Remember
- While practicing principles of management values cannot be neglected,
- Businesses have to fulfil social and ethical responsibilities towards society.
The significance of principles of management can be discussed in terms of the following points:
1. Providing managers with useful insights into reality:
- The principles of management provide the managers the useful insights for understanding of real
world situations.
- Management principles increase
1. Knowledge,
2. Ability and
3. Understanding of Managers
- It will also enable managers to learn from past mistakes and
- Save time by solving recurring problems quickly.
- Management principles increase managerial efficiency.
- For example, a manager can
1. Leave routine decision-making to his subordinates and
2. Deal with exceptional situations which require his expertise by following the principles of
delegation.
2. Optimum utilisation of resources and effective administration:
- Resources both Human and Material available with the company are LIMITED.
- By optimum use we mean take Maximum Benefit With Minimum Cost.
- Principles HELP the managers to Foresee the cause and effect relationships of their decisions and
actions. So the wastages associated with a trial-and-error approach can be overcome.
- Effective administration necessitates impersonalisation of managerial conduct so that managerial
power is used with due discretion.
- Principles of management limit the boundary of managerial discretion so that their decisions may be
free from personal prejudices and biases.
- For example, in deciding the annual budgets for different departments, managerial discretion is
bounded by the principle of contribution to organisational objectives, rather than personal
preferences,
3. Scientific decisions:
- Decisions must be based on
1. Facts,
2. Thoughtful and
3. Justifiable in terms of the intended purposes.
- They must be
1. Timely,
2. Realistic and
3. Subject To measurement and evaluation.
- Management principles help in thoughtful decision-making. Based on LOGIC rather than blind faith.
- Management decisions are free from bias and prejudice here.
- They are based on the objective assessment of the situation.
4. Meeting changing environment requirements:
- Principles of Management are in form of General Guidelines but they are MODIFIED and this help
managers to meet changing requirements of the environment.
- Management principles are FLEXIBLE to adapt to dynamic business environment.
- For example, management principles emphasise Division Of Work and specialisation.
- In modern times this principle has been extended to the entire business whereby companies are
specialising in their core competency and divesting non-core businesses.
- Some companies are outsourcing their non-core activities like
1. Share-transfer management and
2. Advertising to outside agencies.
- Even core processes such as
1. R&D,
2. Manufacturing and
3. Marketing are being outsourced today.
4. ‘Business Process Outsourcing’ (BPO) and
5. ‘Knowledge Process Outsourcing’ (KPO)?
5. Fulfilling social responsibility:
- The increased awareness of the public, forces businesses especially limited companies to fulfill their
social responsibilities.
- Management theory and management principles have also evolved in response to these demands.
Moreover, the interpretation of the principles also assumes newer and contemporary meanings with
the change in time.
- So, if one were to talk of ‘EQUITY’ today,
1. Similar wages
2. Value to the customer,
3. Care for the environment,
4. Dealings with business associates would all come under the purview of this principle.
- Many Public Sector Undertakings have developed entire townships as, for example,
1. BHEL has developed Ranipur in Hardwar (Uttaranchal).
6. Management training, education and research:
- Principles of management are at the core of management theory.
- As such these are used as a basis for management Training, Education and Research.
- Many management institutes are conducting management Aptitude Tests for admission.
- These principles provide basic groundwork for the development of management as a discipline.
- Professional courses such as MBA (Master of Business Administration), BBA (Bachelor of Business
Administration) also teach these principles as part of their curriculum at the beginner’s level.
- These principles enable refinement of management practices as well by facilitating the development of
new management techniques.
1. Operations Research (OR) – Analytical method of problem solving
2. Cost accounting – assigning cost to cost objects
3. ‘Just in Time’ – Goods are received when they required
4. ‘Kanban’ – Inventory control system
5. ‘Kaizen’ – Approach to creating continuous improvement.
6. Have developed due to further research on these principles.
1893 Consulting
Principles of Scientific Management In the earlier days of the Industrial Revolution, in the absence of an
established theory of factory organisation, factory owners or managers relied on Personal Judgment in
attending to the problems they confronted in the course of managing their work. This is what is referred to
as ‘rule of thumb’.
There was a need to follow an approach that was based on the method of science
- Defining A Problem,
- Developing Alternative Solutions,
- Anticipating Consequences,
- Measuring Progress And
- Drawing Conclusions.
He proposed scientific management as opposed to rule of thumb.
He broke up human activity into small parts and found out how it could be done effectively, in less time
and with increased productivity.
It implies conducting Business Activities According
- To Standardised Tools, Methods and Trained Personnel in order
- To increase the OUTPUT, improve its QUALITY and reduce COSTS and WASTES.
In the words of Taylor, “Scientific management means knowing exactly what you want men to do and
seeing that they do it in the best and cheapest way.”
These are based on the various experiments he conducted during his career.
1. Functional Foremanship
- In the factory system, the foreman represents the managerial figure with whom the workers are in
face-to-face contact on a daily basis.
- The foreman is the lowest ranking manager and the highest ranking worker. He is the pivot around
whom revolves the entire production planning, implementation and control.
- Taylor concentrated on improving the performance of this (foreman) role in the factory set-up.
- In fact, he identified a list of qualities of a good foreman/supervisor and found that no single person
could fit them all. Foremen should have
1. Intelligence, 5. Judgment,
2. Education, 6. Special Knowledge,
3. Tact, 7. Manual Dexterity (Skill) and Energy,
4. Grit - Calmness 8. Honesty and Good Health.
- This prompted him to suggest functional foremanship through 8 persons.
- Taylor advocated separation of planning and execution functions.
- This concept was extended to the lowest level of the shop floor. It was known as functional
foremanship.
- Under the factory manager there was a planning incharge and a production incharge.
1. Under PLANNING incharge four personnel namely
1. Instruction Card clerk - Draft instructions for the workers
2. Route clerk - Specify the route of production
3. Time and cost clerk - Prepare time and cost sheet
4. Disciplinarian - Ensure discipline respectively.
2. Under PRODUCTION incharge, personnel who would work were
1. Speed boss - Timely and accurate completion of job
2. Gang boss - Keeping machines and tools ready for operation by workers
3. Repair boss - Ensure proper working condition of machines and tools
4. Inspector - Check the quality of work
- Functional foremanship is an extension of the principle of division of work and specialisation to the
shop floor.
- Each worker will have to take orders from these 8 foremen in the related process or function of
production.
- Each specialist is to be assigned work according to her/his qualities.
- For example, those with Technical Mastery, Intelligence and Grit may be given Planning Work.
- Those with Energy and Good Health may be assigned Execution Work.
2. Standardisation and Simplification of Work
- Standardisation refers to the process of setting standards for every business activity; it can be
1. Process, 5. Machinery,
2. Raw Material, 6. Methods Or
3. Time, 7. Working Conditions.
4. Product,
- These standards are the BENCHMARKS, which must be followed to during production.
- The objectives of standardisation are:
1. To reduce a given line or product to fixed types, sizes and characteristics.
2. To establish interchange ability of manufactured parts and products.
3. To establish standards of excellence and quality in materials.
4. To establish standards of performance of men and machines.
- Taylor was a great supporter of standardisation.
- According to him scientific method should be used to analyse methods of production prevalent under
the rule of thumb.
- The best practices can be kept and further refined to develop a standard which should be followed
throughout the organisation.
- This can be done through
- Work-Study Techniques = Time Study + Motion Study + Fatigue Study + Method Study
Simplification:
1 Hour 3 Boxes
- According to Taylor, the difference of Rs. 190 should be enough for the inefficient worker to be
motivated to perform better.
- From his own experience, Taylor gives the example of a worker named Schmidt who was able to earn
60% more wages by using this technique.
- This differential system must be based on the premise that efficiency is the result of the joint efforts of
the managers and the workers.
- The workers and managers should work in harmony for maximising the output rather than restricting
it.
- Clearly the sum and substance of Taylor’s ideas lies not in the disjointed description of principles and
techniques of scientific management, but in the change of the mindset, which he referred to as mental
revolution.
8. Mental revolution
- It involves a change in the attitude of workers and management towards one another from
competition to cooperation. Both should realise that they require one another. Both should aim to
increase the size of surplus.
- Management should share a part of surplus with workers.
- Workers should also contribute their might so that the company makes profits.
- This attitude will be good for both of them and also for the company. In the long run only worker’s
well-being will ensure prosperity of the business.
We can also examine the present status of scientific management.
- Today, many New Techniques have been developed as a sequel to scientific management.
1. Operations research was developed in the Second World War to optimise the deployment of
war material.
2. Assembly line was also discovered by F.W. Taylor, which was used very successfully by Ford
motor company for manufacturing ‘Model T’ car for the masses. This concept is much used
now.
3. The latest development in scientific management is ‘LEAN MANUFACTURING’.
4. Robotics and Computers are being used in production and other business activities.
- 1841 to 1925
- Explained
How to manage work?
Focusing on Manager’s Efficiency
- For his contribution he is also known as the ‘Father of General
Management’
- French Mining Engineering at age of 19 yrs
- 1888 -1918 Become Managing Director then Diretor till Death.
- First who identify the functions of Management
Planning Directing
Organising Controlling
- Industry could divided
Technical Security
Commercial Accounting
Financial Managerial
- Manager’s Qualities
Physical Moral
Education Experience
Knowledge
- He believed that the number of management principles that might help to improve an organisation’s
operation is potentially limitless.
- Based largely on his own experience, he developed his concept of administration.
- The 14 Principles Of Management propounded by him were discussed in detail in his book published in
1917, ‘Administration Industrielle Et Generale’.
- It was published in English as ‘General and Industrial Management’ in 1949 and is widely considered a
foundational work in classical management theory.
1. Division of Work:
- Work is divided into Small Tasks/ jobs.
- A Trained Specialist is required to perform each job.
- Division of work leads to specialisation.
- According to Fayol, “The intent of division of work is to produce more and better work for the same
effort. Specialisation is the most efficient way to use human effort.”
- In business work can be performed more efficiently if it is divided into specialised tasks; each
performed by a specialist or trained employee. This results in Efficient and Effective Output.
- For example companies have separate departments for
1. Finance,
2. Marketing,
3. Production
4. Human Resource Development etc.
- All of them have specialised persons. Collectively they achieve production and sales targets of the
company.
- Fayol applies this principle of division of work to all kinds of work – TECHNICAL as well as
MANAGERIAL.
1. Hospital or even
2. Government office
3. School
4. Temple
2. Authority and Responsibility:
- According to Fayol, “Authority is the right to give orders and obtain obedience, and responsibility is
the result of authority.
- The two types of authority are
1. Official Authority - The authority to command, and
2. Personal Authority - The authority of the individual manager.”
- Authority is both Formal and Informal.
- Managers require authority as well as responsibility.
- There should be a BALANCE between authority and responsibility.
- An organisation should build safeguards against abuse of managerial power.
- At the same time a manager should have necessary authority to carry out his responsibility.
- For example,
Sales Manager Allowed credit period 40 days
Customer demanding 60 days
Deal amount 50 Crore
In this case the manager should be granted authority of
offering credit period of 60 days in the interest of the
company.
Similarly, in this example this manager should not be given a power to offer a credit period of say 100
days because it is not required.
- A manager should have the Right To Punish a subordinate for wilfully not obeying a legitimate order
but only after sufficient opportunity has been given to a subordinate for presenting her/his case.
3. Discipline:
- Discipline is the Obedience to Organisational Rules and Employment Agreement which are necessary
for the working of the organisation.
- According to Fayol, discipline requires
1. Good Superiors At All Levels,
2. Clear and Fair Agreements and
3. Judicious Application Of Penalties.
- For Example Management and Labour Union have entered into an agreement whereby
Workers have agreed to put in EXTRA HOURS without any additional payment to revive the
company out of loss.
In return the Management has PROMISED TO INCREASE WAGES of the workers when this
mission is accomplished.
- Here discipline when applied would mean that the workers and management both HONOUR THEIR
COMMITMENTS without any prejudice towards one another.
4. Unity of Command:
- According to Fayol there should be ONE AND ONLY ONE BOSS for every individual employee.
- If an employee gets orders from two superiors at the same time the principle of unity of command is
violated.
- Dual subordination should be avoided. This is to PREVENT CONFUSION regarding tasks to be done.
- The principle of unity of command states that each participant in a formal organisation should Receive
Orders From and Be Responsible To Only ONE SUPERIOR.
- Fayol gave a Lot Of Importance to this principle.
- He felt that if this principle is violated
1. Authority Is Undermined,
2. Discipline Is In Jeopardy,
3. Order Disturbed And
4. Stability Threatened
- The principle resembles MILITARY organisation.
- Suppose a Salesman get Instructions from two Persons
Marketing Manager – 10% Discount
Finance Manager – 5% Discount
- Now there is no unity of command.
- This can be avoided if there is coordination between various departments.
5. Unity of Direction:
- All the units of an organisation should be moving towards the same objectives through coordinated
and focussed efforts.
- Each group of activities having the same objective must have ONE HEAD and ONE PLAN. This ensures
unity of action and coordination.
- For example, if a company is manufacturing motorcycles as well as cars then it should have two
separate divisions for both of them.
- Each division should have its Own Incharge, Plans and Execution Resources. So, NO OVERLAPPING
between two divisions.
- The company would want to get MAXIMUM - An employee may want to get MAXIMUM SALARY
OUTPUT from its employees at a competitive cost while working the least.
(salary).
- Every employee is equal - An individual employee may demand some
concession like working for less time.
In all the situations the interests of the GROUP/COMPANY will SUPERSEDE the interest of any one individual.
- This is so because larger interests of the workers and stakeholders are more important than the
interest of any one person.
- For example, interests of various stakeholders, i.e., OWNERS, SHAREHOLDERS, CREDITORS, DEBTORS,
FINANCERS, TAX AUTHORITIES, CUSTOMERS and the SOCIETY at LARGE cannot be sacrificed for one
individual or a small group of individuals who want to exert pressure on the company.
- A manager can ensure this by her/his exemplary behaviour.
- For example, she/he should not fall into temptation of misusing her/his powers for individual/ family
benefit.
- This will create good impression in the eyes of the workers and at the same time ensure same
behaviour by them.
7. Remuneration of Employees:
- The overall pay and compensation should be FAIR to BOTH employees and the organisation.
- The employees should be Paid Fair Wages, which should give them at least a reasonable standard of
living. At the same time it should be within the Paying Capacity of the company.
- In other words, remuneration should be Just and Equitable.
- This will ensure Positive Atmosphere and Good Relations between Workers and Management.
Consequently, the working of the company would be SMOOTH.
8. Centralisation and Decentralisation:
- The CONCENTRATION of decision-making authority is called centralisation whereas its DISPERSAL
among more than one person is known as decentralisation.
- According to Fayol, “There is a need to BALANCE subordinate involvement through Decentralisation
with managers’ retention of final authority through Centralisation.”
- The degree of centralisation will depend upon the circumstances in which the company is working.
- In general Large Organisations have More Decentralisation than small organisations.
- For example, PANCHAYATS in our country have been given more powers to decide and spend funds
granted to them by the government for the welfare of villages. This is decentralisation at the national
level.
9. Scalar Chain:
- An organisation consists of superiors and subordinates. The formal lines of authority from highest to
lowest ranks are known as scalar chain.
- According to Fayol, “Organisations should have a Chain Of Authority and Communication that runs
from top to bottom and should be followed by managers and the subordinates.”
- For example a situation where there is one head ‘A’ who has two lines of authority under her/ him.
1. One line consists of B-CD-E-F.
2. Another line of authority under ‘A’ is L-M-N-O-P.
- If ‘E’ has to communicate with ‘O’ who is at the same level of authority then she/he has to traverse the
route E-D-C-B-A-L-M-N-O. This is due to the principle of Scalar Chain being followed in this situation.
- According to Fayol, this Chain Should Not Be Violated in the normal course of formal communication.
However, if there is an emergency then ‘E’ can directly contact ‘O’ through ‘GANG PLANK’ as shown in
the diagram.
- This is a Shorter Route and has been provided so that communication is Not Delayed.
- In practice you find that a worker cannot directly contact the CEO of the company.
- However, in an EMERGENCY it can be possible that A WORKER CAN CONTACT CEO DIRECTLY.
10. Order:
- According to Fayol, “People and materials must be in suitable PLACES at appropriate TIME for
maximum efficiency.”
- The principle of order states that ‘A place for everything (everyone) and everything (everyone) in its
(her/his) place’. it means ORDERLINESS.
- If there is a fixed place for everything and it is present there, then there will be No Hindrance in the
activities of business/ factory.
- This will lead to increased productivity and efficiency.
11. Equity:
- Good sense and experience are needed to ensure fairness to all employees, who should be treated as
fairly as possible,” according to Fayol.
- This principle emphasises KINDLINESS and JUSTICE in the behaviour of managers towards workers.
This will ensure Loyalty and Devotion.
- Fayol does not rule out use of force sometimes. Rather he says that lazy personnel should be dealt with
sternly to send the message that everyone is equal in the eyes of the management.
- There should be NO DISCRIMINATION against anyone on account of sex, religion, language, caste,
belief or nationality etc.
- Now a days in multinational corporations people of various nationalities work together in a
Discrimination Free Environment.
- Equal opportunities are available for everyone in such companies to rise.
12. Stability of Personnel (Employees):
- According to Fayol. “Employee turnover should be minimised to maintain organisational efficiency”,
- Personnel should be selected and appointed after due and tough procedure.
- But once selected they should be kept at their post/ position for a minimum fixed tenure. They should
have stability of tenure.
- They should be given Reasonable Time to show results.
- Any adhocism in this regard will create instability/insecurity among employees. So people will leave
the organisation.
- Stability in tenure of personnel is good for the business because Recruitment, selection and training
cost will be high.
13. Initative:
- Initiative means taking the first step with self-motivation.
- It is thinking out and executing the plan. It is one of the traits of an intelligent person.
- According to Fayol Workers should be encouraged to develop and carry out their plans for
improvements.
- Initiative should be encouraged.
- But it does not mean going against the established practices of the company for the sake of being
different.
- A good company should have an Employee Suggestion System whereby initiative/suggestions which
result in substantial cost/time reduction should Be Rewarded.
14. Esprit De Corps:
- According to Fayol Management should promote a TEAM SPIRIT of Unity and Harmony among
Employees,
- Management should Promote Teamwork especially in large organisations because otherwise
objectives would be difficult to realise. It will also result in a loss of coordination.
- A manager should Replace ‘I’ with ‘WE’ in all his conversations with workers to foster team spirit.
- This will give rise to a SPIRIT of mutual trust and belongingness among team members.
- It will also minimise the need for using penalties.
Comparison Henri Fayol Vs. F.W. Taylor
- Both of them have Contributed Immensely to the knowledge of management, which has formed a
basis for further practice by managers.
- It must be pointed out that their contributions are COMPLEMENTARY to each other.
-