Acoustic Emission Wave Propagation in A Viscoelastic Plate
Acoustic Emission Wave Propagation in A Viscoelastic Plate
Received 13 October 1998; received in revised form 20 January 1999; accepted 5 February 1999
Abstract
In loaded materials the strain-energy release due to microstructural changes results in stress-wave propagation. Acoustic emission
deals with the recognition of such waves over the material surfaces and for this reason the application of acoustic emission techni-
ques to the monitoring of the mechanical integrity of materials and structures is appropriate. Nevertheless, the use of such tech-
niques in the case of polymer-based composite materials needs a clearer understanding of the relationships between the recorded
signal, the damage process and the structure geometry. In this work a model is proposed of the propagation in a viscoelastic plate of
waves due to a damage event. The microfailure event has been represented as a point source and ray theory has been applied to
develop the physical model of wave propagation. The spectral analysis technique has been applied to the solution of the wave
equations. Model calculations in the frequency domain have been compared with experimental spectra resulting from ®ber break-
age in dierent ®ber/matrix systems from single-®ber fragmentation tests. # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: A. Polymer-matrix composites; C. Damage mechanics; D. Acoustic emission; Wave propagation
0266-3538/99/$ - see front matter # 1999 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S0266 -3 538(99)00035 -4
1736 M. Giordano et al. / Composites Science and Technology 59 (1999) 1735±1743
A1 ÿikA2 ÿik2 A3 0 4
ultrasonic waves in a viscoelastic plate have been stu-
died by Weaver et al. [8,9]. Double transform technique Eq. (4) de®nes the wavenumber k and its relationship
has been used to solve wave equation. A closed form in with frequency ! is known as the spectrum relation.
the frequency domain for the high-frequency response Each value of k that satis®es Eq. (4) represents a mode
to a step load has been obtained. of propagation of the wave and the general solution, in
In this work a model of the AE process in a ®nite the frequency domain, is given by the superposition of
viscoelastic medium has been developed. The strain- the dierent modes.
energy release at the failure event has been analyzed to X
recover the source model. The ray theory has been s^ x; ! Cm !eÿikm !x 5
applied to model the propagation problem in a linearly m
viscoelastic plate with reference to a Maxwellian med-
ium. As spectral analysis technique has been used in The time, space solution s x; t can be obtained by tak-
solving the wave equation. Model results have been ing the inverse transform Eq. (5)
compared with experimental data from single-®ber frag-
mentation tests, taking into account the transducer trans- s x; t s^ x; !ei!t d! 6
fer function. The paper has been organized as follows: a
M. Giordano et al. / Composites Science and Technology 59 (1999) 1735±1743 1737
The same result is achieved by using the Fourier series ! !0 , and by `low frequency' ! !00 , with a wide
representation of s x; t range of frequencies which are comparable with some of
X the characteristic ones.
s x; t s^ x; !n ei!n t 7 We assume that the viscoelastic behavior of the med-
ium is represented by the Maxwell model accordingly
where s^ x; !n are the Fourier coecients, that can be with experimental evidence of an elastic behavior at
evaluated from Eq. (5) at ! !n . high frequencies:
Finally
XX d d"
E ÿ 13
s x; t Cm !n ei!n t eÿikm !n x 8 dt dt
@s
The coecients Cm !n must be evaluated by imposing where " @x .
the appropriate boundary conditions. The wave equation [Eq. (1)] becomes the well known
telegraph equation:
2.2. Linear viscoelastic media
@2 s 1 @s E @2 s
ÿ 0 14
Analysis of the wave propagation has been restricted @t2 @t @x2
to linear viscoelastic media: in this case the spectrum
relationship k k ! is derived from Eq. (4) once the and the wave number k results in
constitutive equation has been assigned. s
The wave number, k, de®nes the phase velocity, c, i 1 p
and the attenuation, a, of a propagating wave. k ! ! !ÿ ! ! ÿ i 15
E ce
!
k ! kR ! ikI ! ia ! 9 The phase speed depends on the frequency leading to a
c ! dispersive medium. In fact dierent frequency compo-
In the case of an elastic solid theqwave number is real nents of the wave travel at dierent speeds changing
wave shape as it propagates. The Maxwell constitutive
and the wave phase velocity c E is independent on
equation shows two limiting behaviors:
the frequency. No dissipation occurs in an elastic solid;
as a consequence the wave frequency content and . ! ! 0 viscous behavior
amplitude do not change during propagation. Both phase velocity c and attenuation a increase with
In the case of a Newtonian ¯uid both attenuation and the square root of frequency.
wave speed change with frequency [11];
s . ! ! 1 elastic behavior
r
! 2! Phase velocity c is not dependent on frequency while
jaj c 10
2 attenuation attains a constant value becoming negligible
as relaxation time increases. Fig. 1 shows the depen-
Energy is dissipated and the wave is smoothed out dence of the wave number on frequency.
changing its frequency content during propagation.
As we move to viscoelastic materials, for which there 2.3. Source model
are at least three parameters, E; and , one can de®ne
an elastic velocity ce and an intrinsic frequency ! (or The boundary conditions must be speci®ed at the
relaxation time ): damage localization within the material. During failure,
p the strain energy stored in the material is dissipated in
ce E= 11
the creation of new surfaces, in heat generation and in
the generation of stress waves propagating through the
! E= 1= 12
medium. However, we assumed a point defect, neglecting
The existence of an intrinsic frequency characterizes also the heat generation.
viscoelastic materials; for such materials (but not for Let us consider the strain-energy release caused by the
elastic solids or Newtonian ¯uids) there is an objective failure, that is:
criterion for distinguishing between high frequencies,
! ! , and low frequencies, ! ! . Of course, a real 1
U ÿ E"2o 16
material is endowed with a spectrum of relaxation 2
times, spanning characteristic frequencies from some
minimum frequency !0 to some maximum one !00 ; hence where "0 is the strain before cracking that is fully
perhaps by `high frequency' one should understand released at the end of failure process.
1738 M. Giordano et al. / Composites Science and Technology 59 (1999) 1735±1743
We assume that the failure process is characterized by of longitudinal waves on the boundary surfaces has
an emission time Te and all the stored strain energy been assumed. Fig. 3 shows the plate geometry
1 2
2 E"o is released during the failure. The model aims to evaluate the control point P L; h
The accurate dynamics of damage process is descri- displacement in response of a strain longitudinal wave
bed by the power P as a function of time. In fact, the generated in the source point P(0,0). It is based on the
failure process brings the material from an equilibrium consideration that the signal detected at the control
state (before the damage) to a new equilibrium state point P L; h is the superposition of the dierent rays
(damaged), when the released power is exactly zero. All reaching this position after their re¯ection at the
the information regarding the source mechanism are boundary surfaces.
collected in the expression of the power P during the The free surface boundary condition
emission time Te (Fig. 2). Considering no dissipative
mechanism acting during failure: yy 0 wy 0 19
"
1 ÿ t
leads to the generation of two re¯ected waves at each
E "d" E "2 ÿ "20 P tdt 17
"o 2 0 ray impact point. A wave is re¯ected in a wave of the
same type and with the same angle plus a wave of dif-
The strain history at failure location can be evaluated ferent type with an angle given by the Snell law [12]. For
from the released power. Eq. (17) results: our analysis the secondary waves have been neglected
s considering their slowness. Fig. 4 shows the picture of
t this mechanism for the primary waves.
" t P t
1 1 2 dt 18 It can be easily shown that the total distance covered
"0 0 2 E"0
by the nth ray is:
q
2.4. Wave propagation in a plate Rn h2 2n ÿ 12 L2 20
In this section a model of the wave propagation based In addition it must be considered that the nth ray
on the ray theory has been developed. Acoustical rays impacts the control point with an angle n
have been described as plane waves and total re¯ection
L
n arctan 21
2n ÿ 1h
where n is the angle between the nth ray and the y axis.
Total re¯ection hypothesis allows to evaluate the con-
trol point response as the superposition of rays travelling
distances Rn in a pseudo-in®nite medium. The y compo-
nent of the displacement in the frequency domain is:
X
s^y RL;h ; ! s^n Rn ; ! cos n 22
n
Fig. 1. Dimensionless phase speed co c=ce (solid line) and attenua- 3. Model calculations
tion koI kI ce (dotted line) as functions of frequency.
In general terms, the relation between the frequency
spectrum of the signal detected by the transducer and
the source spectrum can be expressed [13] as:
Fig. 2. Strain energy release rate due to a failure event. Fig. 3. Plate geometry.
M. Giordano et al. / Composites Science and Technology 59 (1999) 1735±1743 1739
k~ !~
"^~ !; ~ C~ e !
~
~ x; ~ ÿi
e
~ x~
C~ e !H ~ x
~ m !~ ; ~ 29
"^~ !;
~ L; ~
~ h; ~ C~ " !H ~ L;
~ mg !~ ; ~
~ h 31 Deborah numbers , ^ as a function of dimensionless fre-
quency !~ for dierent plate sizes L. ~
where L~ Ll . In the viscous case, ^ 1, (Fig. 8a) the dimensionless
A ®rst consideration is that it is not possible to sepa- strain amplitude spectrum is smooth at low frequency.
rate the eect of geometry from the eect of the mate- It fragments for frequencies !Te 51 showing sudden
rial on the wave propagation. The transfer functions changes of the amplitude values versus frequency. The
Hm ! and Hg ! from Eq. (23) are grouped into the fragmentation of the amplitude spectrum spreads
transfer function Hmg !. toward lower frequencies as the plate size increases.
Fig. 8 shows the dimensionless strain amplitude spec- In the elastic case, ^ 1, (Fig. 8b) the main eect of
tra for a ®xed value of the shape factor h, ~ for dierent the boundary re¯ection is the fragmentation of
the dimensionless strain amplitude spectrum, both in
low and high frequency zone. The viscoelastic case,
^ 1; (Fig. 8c) shows characteristics of both the limit-
ing cases.
A clear explanation of the sudden changes of the
amplitude values can be provided. The dierent arrival
times of each ray induces phase modi®cation in fre-
~ ~ R~ n L; ~
~ h
quency domain according with the term eÿik !~ of
the transfer function. So the summation over rays cor-
responds to adding components with dierent phase.
This interference phenomenon produces the fragmenta-
tion of the amplitude spectra. The more severe frag-
mentation of the high frequency components can be
explained with reference to the phase spectrum of the
source. In this region the phase spectrum is very irre-
gular, as a consequence a time shift produces larger
eect on the amplitude evaluation. On the other hand in
the viscous region of the spectrum (!~ 1) the inter-
ference is reduced due to the slowness of the waves.
Table 1
Experimental data from Single Fiber Fragmentation Tests for dierent
matrix/®ber systemsa
References
the same propagation medium, while the emission time
[1] Ohtsu M, Onu K. A generalized theory of acoustic emission and
Te is the ®tting parameter. Table 2 summarizes the
Green's functions in a half space. J Acoustic Emission 1984;3:27±40.
estimated parameters together with the values of the [2] Ohtsu M, Onu K. A generalized theory and source representa-
~ L;
dimensionless variables ; ~
~ h. tions of acoustic emission. J Acoustic Emission 1986;5:124±33.
[3] Suzuki H, Takemoto M, Onu K. The fracture dynamics in a dis-
4.2. Conclusions sipative glass-®ber/epoxy model composite with AE source simu-
lation analysis. J Acoustic Emission 1996;14:35±50.
[4] Cagniard L. Re¯ection and refraction of progressive seismic
The proposed model is able to reproduce the main waves. New York: McGraw±Hill, 1962.
features of the acoustic emission signals from single ®ber [5] Ceranoglu AN, Pao YH. Propagation of elastic pulses and
fragmentation tests varying the ®ber size and the propa- acoustic emission in a plate Part 1: theory. J Appl Mech
gation medium. In the following the main assumptions 1981;48:125±32.
[6] Ceranoglu AN, Pao YH. Propagation of elastic pulses and
of the model have been recalled and criticized. acoustic emission in a plate Part 2: epicentral responses. J Appl
. The acoustic emission point source has been mod- Mech 1981;48:133±8.
[7] Ceranoglu AN, Pao YH. Propagation of elastic pulses and
eled by means of simple considerations on the
acoustic emission in a plate. Part 3: general responses. J Appl
strain energy release due to the failure event. At Mech 1981;48:139±47.
this elementary stage, the source is characterized [8] Weaver RL, Sachse W, Niu L. Transient ultrasonic waves in a
by a single parameter, the source emission time Te . viscoelastic plate: theory. J Acoust Soc Am 1989;85:2255±61.
In the real cases failure involves an extended [9] Weaver RL, Sachse W, Niu L. Transient ultrasonic waves in a
viscoelastic plate: applications to materials characterization. J
damaged area. So, a more precise source model
Acoust Soc Am 1989;85:2262±7.
should consider a deeper analysis of the failure [10] Doyle JF. Wave propagation in structures. New York: Springer,
micromechanics. 1997.
. Wave propagation in a plate has been analyzed [11] Landau LD, Lifshitz EM. Fluid mechanics. Oxford: Pergamon
with reference to the ray theory. Response at the Press, 1987.
[12] Kolsky H. Stress waves in solids. New York: Dover, 1963.
transducer position is due to the superposition of [13] Berthelot JM, Souda MB, Robert JL. Frequency analysis of
rays re¯ected on the plate surfaces. Rays have acoustic emission signals in concrete. J Acoustic Emission
been described as plane waves but, in principle, the 1993;11:11±18.
same formulation can be extended to spherical [14] Giordano M, Calabro A, Esposito C, D'Amore A, Nicolais L.
waves. In addition the secondary waves has been An acoustic emission characterization of the failure modes in
polymer-composite materials. Comp Sci Tech 1999;58:1923±8.
neglected according to their slowness: the last [15] Felix MP. Attenuation and dispersion characteristics of various
hypothesis released leads only to a cumbersome plastics in the frequency range 1±10 MHz. J Comp Mater
problem. 1974;8:273±87.