Electrically Small Resonant Loop For Shortwave
Electrically Small Resonant Loop For Shortwave
Contents
Page
Contents ...........................................................................................................................................2
Figures..............................................................................................................................................2
Introduction ......................................................................................................................................2
Theory ..............................................................................................................................................3
Coil Design .............................................................................................................................3
Capacitor Characteristics ........................................................................................................4
Secondary or Pickup Coil .......................................................................................................5
The Circuit ..............................................................................................................................5
Description and Construction...........................................................................................................6
Frame ......................................................................................................................................7
Tuning Capacitors ...................................................................................................................7
Primary Winding .....................................................................................................................8
Pick-up Coil ............................................................................................................................9
Transmission Line .................................................................................................................10
Options ..................................................................................................................................10
Operation........................................................................................................................................12
Intermodulation .....................................................................................................................13
Stability .................................................................................................................................13
Sources for Air Dielectric Variable Capacitors .............................................................................14
Figures
Page
Figure 1. Basic Loop Antenna Schematic Diagram........................................................................5
Figure 2. Resonant Loop Antennas for Shortwave .........................................................................6
Figure 3. Variable Capacitor Arrangements ...................................................................................8
Figure 4. Detail of Primary Winding ..............................................................................................9
Figure 5. Pick-up Coils ...................................................................................................................9
Figure 6. Twisted Pair and Plug....................................................................................................10
Figure 7. Concept for Vertical Pitch Control ................................................................................11
Figure 8. Static Discharge Protection Circuit ...............................................................................12
Introduction
A good antenna is as useful for what it rejects as for what it detects. A loop antenna is a
delight; it gives you the sensation that you are really tuning your radio and not just pressing
buttons. A well-designed, tunable antenna can be played like a fine musical instrument.
In the early 1980s, I had access to a large engineering library and availed myself of its
wealth of electronic information, particularly regarding loop antennas. Much of the early
research and theory was available. My primary interest at the time was medium wave, although I
designed and constructed resonant loops operating at long waves and short waves.
There are several properties of loop antennas which make them attractive. Amazing things
happen when you take a straight, modest length of hookup wire, wind it into a coil of suitable
2 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
dimensions and resonate it with a capacitor. Properly constructed, the combination will produce
a signal+noise-to-noise ratio comparable or better than random-wire, electric-field antennas.
Initially, you may be discouraged that radio is not as loud. However, carful tuning and some
practice learning how to play the antenna will uncover signals that are not otherwise detectable.
Tuned loops are highly-selective, narrow-band antennas. They must be tuned as you move
up or down the band. Sometimes, retuning the antenna after a change of just 5 or 10 kHz in the
receiver will produce noticeable increase in signal strength. Thus, loops of the type described
here are preselectors. By allowing only a very limited band pass to reach the input of the
receiver, they greatly relieve the receiver’s susceptibility to overloading and intermodulation.
Loop antennas are directional. In many cases it will be possible to produce total nulls of an
interfering signal or locally-produced noise. Since noise and interference are often in opposing
directions to that of the signal, it will be possible to greatly reduce these annoyances. These
features give the loop a distinct advantage over random wire antennas.
This article documents fabrication of resonant loop antennas which cover a large portion of
the shortwave spectrum. It is easily possible to tailor the design described here to optimize
reception of a specific portion of the shortwave spectrum. Four variants, all having the same size
of the outer turn of 17” square (24” diagonal) have been built and tested having the upper
frequency limits as follows.
2 Turn - 22 MHz; 3 Turn - 16 MHz; 4 Turn - 10.5 MHz; 7 Turn - 5.2 MHz
The lower frequency is determined by the maximum amount of capacitance you choose to add.
Thus, each antenna can be made to tune through the lowest shortwave frequencies. For antennas
having fewer turns in the primary coil, however, performance at lower frequencies will be
compromised. The reason for this is described below in the Theory Section.
Theory
Much can be said about how I arrived at the concept. Suffice it to say, there is nothing new
here. It is, I feel sound application of the basic theory laid out almost 100 years ago. This is an
electrically small loop, meaning the overall dimension of the primary coil is much smaller than
the wavelength of the received signal. This is a tuned loop, meaning the primary coil is made to
resonate at a specified frequency. This is accomplished by placing a capacitor in series with a
coil of wire (inductor). The coil is the antenna proper and the capacitor is used to tune or
resonate the circuit. At resonance, the current flowing through the circuit is greatly increased
and other frequencies are attenuated. Thus, the antenna is also a preselector. The circuit can be
made to resonate through an entire band of frequencies by changing the value of the capacitor or
inductor. It is normally more practical to change the value of the capacitor.
Coil Design
The capacitor’s only function is to provide resonance. The values of capacitance and
inductance can be varied inversely to resonate at the same frequency. The coil is responsible for
capturing the field of the incoming signal; and it makes sense for the inductance to be large and
the capacitance small. Inductance and, consequently, the antenna’s effective height, increases by
making the cross-sectional area of the coil larger or increasing its number of turns. Effective
height for a non-resonant loop is calculated by the formula he = 2 NA/, where N is the number
3 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
of turns, A the area of the turns (or average area for a flat coil having different areas for each
turn), and the wavelength. For resonant loops, he is multiplied by Q, the figure of merit.
I have chosen to impose a limit on the size of the loop. Two 24” lengths of strip wood
joined at a 90-degree angle at their centers produce a suitably strong framework, which can be
mounted on a simple base and located on a desktop in close proximity to the radio.
If we keep capacitance of the circuit constant, lower frequencies will require larger
inductances than higher frequencies. But, there is a limit to the size of the inductor.
Unfortunately, there is no such thing as a perfect coil. The amount of useful inductance
produced by the coil in a resonant circuit is in part limited by its distributed or self-capacitance.
For example, two turns of a coil in close proximity have a slightly different potential, and
therefore act as a capacitor. This capacitance is cumulative and distributed along the coil
windings. It acts with the value of inductance of the coil and will form a circuit resonant at some
frequency, beyond which the coil is useless as a tuned circuit. This physical barrier quickly
comes into play at shortwave frequencies and limits the size of the loop to just a few turns of
wire.
The question is then, how do you minimize distributed capacitance? It is reduced by
increasing the distance between each turn in the coil. In addition, distributed capacitance is
minimized by winding the coil in a single plane rather than in a solenoid shape. Each turn of the
coil is separated a suitable distance from adjacent turns. The separation distance is limited by the
coil’s geometry. If the dimensions of the coil are kept small, the number of turns must be
increased to achieve the same value of inductance, and these turns must necessarily be wound
more closely.
There is one more characteristic, at least in theory, which has some impact on the antenna
we are building, namely wire gauge. At resonance, two of three impediments to current flow in
the circuit are cancelled, the inductive and capacitive reactances. That mainly leaves the
resistance of the wire itself to limit current flow. Low resistance will increase the figure of merit
or “Q” of the circuit. Heavier wire or stranded wire has less resistance and will make a better
conductor, particularly at radio frequencies.
Many air- and ferrite-core loop antenna coils are formed from Litz wire. This is based on
the theory that, as frequency increases, most of the current flow gravitates to the outer surface of
the wire. By using multiple strands of insulated wire, this outer surface is increased and the
resistance to current flow is lowered. Litz wire may be fabricated from several strands of wire
insulated by enamel or fabric.
In practice, AWG 22 stranded wire is a convenient point of diminishing returns. Even at
longwave frequencies requiring very large coils, this wire is large enough to produce extremely
high Qs in very large coils. The benefit of heavier wire will be lost with the added distributed
capacitance and mechanical drawbacks it produces.
Capacitor Characteristics
From the explanation above, it also makes sense to consider the characteristics of the
capacitor you use to resonate the coil. In order to maximize the amount of inductance you can
use, you want to minimize the amount of capacitance you add to tune the highest resonant
frequency. A tuning capacitor set at minimum capacitance (rotor and stator plates open) does not
4 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
have zero capacitance; rather it is typically on the order of 10 to 20 picofarads. This value, plus
the value of the distributed capacitance of the coil acting in parallel, will determine the highest
resonant frequency for the circuit. Unlike distributive capacitance, we have some control over
the minimum added capacitance, and can reduce it by methods that are described below.
The Circuit
Figure 1 shows the basic diagrams for the antenna. Figure 1a shows the circuit with a
single gang tuning capacitor and trimmer. The component values shown are typical for a 4-turn
primary coil. The effect of distributed capacitance is represented in red.
High band ‐ 6.9 to 10.5 MHz – S1 open;
Low band ‐ 9.0 to 2.1 MHz – S1 closed.
C2 Capacitor
C1A Frame
~33 pf
Cd
L1 L2
C1 S1 L1 L2
15 to
~5 pf 15.5 h C1B S1
365 pf
5 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
tuning range by limiting the lower range of C1. Adjusting C2 will have much greater effect at
the low end of the tuning range. S1 is added to remove C2 from the circuit, thereby restoring the
full range of C1. When open, it is in the ‘high band’ position; closed, the ‘low band.’
Figure 1b shows the circuit using a 2-gang tuning capacitor. The dotted line indicates the
sections are tuned simultaneously. Assuming each gang to be 15 to 365 pf, with the gangs open
minimum capacitance would be ~15/2 = 7 pf. With the gangs closed, the maximum capacitance
is ~365/2 = 183 pf. S1 provides a shunt across one section of the capacitor. This effectively
increases the total capacitance. The range would then be 15 to 365 pf, and the circuit would tune
to much lower frequencies, with some overlap between the two bands. Distributed capacitance
still exists in the coil, but is not shown in the diagram.
6 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
lower range of any antenna is limited only by the amount of capacitance you add. 365 pf will
tune any of these antennas down to 2 or 3 MHz or lower.
Frame
The primary coil consists of 2, 3, 4 or 7 turns of AWG 22 wire, depending on the highest
frequency you intend to tune (see Page 2), and is wound on a cross frame of wood, tennis racket
style. The two cross members are 24 inches long. The frame cross members can be made from
either ½” 5/8” or 3/8” square strip wood. 3/32” holes are drilled at 1” intervals for the 2-, 3-, and
4-turn loops and ½” intervals for the 7-turn loop. Extra holes, providing a future capability for
modification, may be drilled from the ends of the cross members inward to approximately 2
inches from the center.
The center of each member is notched to mate with the opposite member. ¼” plywood
pads, 2” or 3” square are used, one at the center to reinforce the joint between the two cross
members and one at the end of one of the cross members to mount the variable capacitor and
base. The strip wood joint and pads are bonded with wood glue.
The tuning capacitor is mounted to the plywood pad at the end of the frame member. Be
careful when mounting the capacitor. The frame is probably threaded, usually for 6-32 machine
screws. The screws must not penetrate much beyond the inner surface of the frame; otherwise
they could contact the stator or rotor plates. A solder lug can be used under the head of one of
the screws to serve as a terminal point for the coil.
The base can be made out of any non-conductive material such as wood or plastic. I have
used large plastic jar lids. With the capacitor mounted at the bottom of the primary coil, the
center of gravity is quite low and the base doesn’t have to be very large. This makes it
convenient to rotate. The frame is mounted to the base with wood screws through the bottom of
the base into the pad at the end of the frame member.
Tuning Capacitors
Unfortunately, air-dielectric, variable capacitors have pretty much gone the way of slide
rules and buggy whips. A good source is an old radio. These tuning capacitors customarily had
two or three sections or ‘gangs,’ as they variously tuned oscillators, mixers and possibly RF
stages within the radio. Although a single gang capacitor is perfectly acceptable, a 2-gang
capacitor does have the advantage that you can connect the gangs in series to reduce the normal
minimum capacity (two capacitors in series) and thus extend the range to cover higher
frequencies. Some sources for air-dielectric, variable capacitors are listed in the Sources for Air
Dielectric Variable Capacitors Section.
Figure 3a shows an example of a 2-section, ganged capacitor; the schematic diagram is
shown in Figure 1b. In the high-band range, each stator gang is connected to an end of the
primary coil, and the metal frame ‘floats’ in the center. Connecting the frame to the stator plates
of either gang, shorts out that gang and leaves only one gang in the circuit. As shown in the
figure, this can be done with a short wire and alligator clip, or, you can get elegant and use a
switch.
7 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
Primary Winding
Run the AWG hookup wire loosely through the holes around the frame. When the desired
number of turns has been wound, check their spacing through the correct holes, and then solder
the outer end at the bottom of the lower frame member to the variable capacitor. For a single-
gang capacitor, this will likely be the frame. For a 2-gang capacitor, this will be one of the stator
gangs.
Pull the wire snugly around the loop working your way from the outer turn to the inner
turn. Lace the end of the last turn back through the next inner hole in the frame. This will
provide some tension to hold the last turn in place. You may go back a second or third time to
8 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
pull out some slack. The turns should be tight, but not have excessive tension. In addition,
ensure the frame members retain their position normal to one another.
Figure 4 shows a detail of the primary windings passing through a
frame member. When using holes spaced 1” apart, this results in an actual
separation of approximately 5/8” between turns. Now solder the remaining
(inner) lead of the primary coil to one terminal on the trimmer capacitor or
the remaining stator terminal on a 2-gang capacitor. If a 2-gang capacitor
is used, you can solder the ‘band switch’ across the frame and one gang of
stators. If a trimmer capacitor is used, don’t forget to connect it’s
remaining terminal to the stator terminal of the single-gang capacitor.
9 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
Transmission Line
It is not necessary to use coaxial cable as a
transmission line. A twisted pair of wires will achieve the
same result and be more flexible, see Figure 6. Take two
pieces of AWG 22 stranded wire, clamp an end of each wire
in a vise, connect the remaining two ends to the chuck of a
hand drill, and twist the pair until you have 8 to 10 turns per
inch. The polarity of the secondary coil does not matter;
either end can serve as the ground side, relative to the radio.
I have used transmission lines in excess of 6’ in length with
negligible loss. Since this antenna is intended to operate on
a desktop next to the radio, there is no reason why the Figure 6. Twisted Pair and Plug
transmission line can’t be kept under 2’ in length for mere
convenience.
Options
Lowering the Frequency
The best way to lower the tuning range of this antenna is to add more turns to the primary
coil. Using the same maximum diameter of the outer turn, 7 turns at ½ the turn spacing will
produce a range between approximately 160 meters and 60 meters. You can add more
capacitance to a coil with fewer turns to produce the same result, but, as explained above, the
effective height of the antenna will be greater if you increase the size of the coil.
Raising the Frequency
Removing one turn from the loop described above will raise the maximum tuned
frequency, but it will also raise the minimum tuned frequency. Again this can be compensated
with more capacitance, but at a price of a lower effective height.
10 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
Swivel
Point
(Vertical)
Pitch
Pivot Finishing
Handle
Point Nail
Swivel
Universal Point (1 of 2)
Washer (Lateral) Universal
Fork
Lateral (1/4” ID) Fork
Pivot
Point Tripod
Center Post Handle
11 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
The danger of electrostatic discharge using the loop antenna described here is minimal,
certainly not the concern it should be if end-fed antennas, particularly outdoor antennas are
plugged into the receiver’s external jack. The pick-up coil of the loop antenna has very low
inductance and represents a dc short across the external antenna jack. However, the possibility
of bodily static discharge still exists when connecting or disconnecting anything from the
external jack, particularly during winter months when the air is dry.
The circuit is shown in Figure 8a. Voltage is limited by the two diodes. Depending on the
polarity of the discharge, one diode will be reverse biased and not limit voltage. Meanwhile, the
remaining diode is forward biased and will conduct current sufficient to limit voltage to about 1
Volt. The light bulb is optional. It presents low resistance to the incoming signal and acts as a
fuse which will blow if the voltage across its filament exceeds its rating.
Any low-voltage,
incandescent lamp
.01 mfd
1/8" Twisted
1N4148 pair to 1/8"
phono
jack (×2) phono plug
b) Discharge Protection Circuit c) Assembled Discharge
a) Circuit Diagram
Installed in Plastic Can Protection Circuit
Operation
The antenna has a very high Q, meaning, at resonance, it has very low resistance in the
resonant circuit, resulting in a very narrow bandpass. There may be a complete absence of
signals with the antenna tuned slightly off resonance.
1. Tune the receiver to the desired frequency. Bandwidth and use of a synchronous
detector may be applied as desired after the antenna is tuned.
12 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
2. Tune the antenna capacitor to peak the tuned frequency of the radio. Tuning will be
very sharp. Sometimes it will be easier to tune the antenna with the receiver first tuned
to background noise 5 or 10 kHz off frequency, particularly if the signal is fading
rapidly.
3. Rotate the antenna to a point where the overall signal+noise-to-noise ratio is the best.
This should be somewhere within a 180-degree arc.
4. Adjust the bandwidth and synchronous detector of the receiver for best response.
Intermodulation
Some receivers are capable of occasional intermodulation, that is, reception of strong
signals at frequencies where the station is not transmitting. It is possible that intermodulation
will still be present when operating with this antenna. Intermodulation may peak by tuning the
antenna to a point removed from the receiver’s tuned frequency. However, it can be totally
eliminated or significantly reduced when the antenna is tuned to resonate at the receiver’s tuned
frequency.
Stability
Stability refers to the variation of the tuned frequency over time. With some radios,
particularly old vacuum tube radios, this was a problem where the resonant frequency of tuned
circuits would drift, particularly as the radio warmed up and thermal change caused component
values to change. The result was that the station would slowly detune over several minutes.
The resonant loop described here may demonstrate a stability problem, though this has a
different cause. This antenna is a victim of its own success. First, it operates at a very high Q. It
has a very narrow bandpass at resonance. In order to maximize its effective height, the size of
the coil has been made a large as possible. Together with the capacitance required to bring it
into resonance, it has a very high inductance-to-capacitance (L/C) ratio. At the top end of its
frequency coverage, it operates very close to its resonant or natural frequency. The addition or
subtraction of 1 or 2 picofarads (pf) will detune it and the resulting signal strength to the receiver
will decrease noticeably.
There are two likely causes for this. It may be a loosely wound primary coil, where the
turns tend to wobble, their separation distances changing if the antenna is repositioned or jarred.
The remedy for this is simply to tighten the turns in the primary coil as described in the
Description and Construction Section. The more likely cause is body capacitance introduced
when you operate the main tuning capacitor. This adds to the total capacitance of the tuned
circuit and tends to lower the resonant frequency.
Even with reasonable care taken in the design and fabrication of your antenna, you may
still notice that body capacitance causes the antenna to detune when you pull your hand away
from the tuning knob. The final remedy is to detune the capacitor very slightly toward in the
lower frequency direction (more capacitance). Then when you remove your hand, the correct
amount of capacitance will be applied and you should detect an increase in signal strength near
peak.
13 Revised 7/12/2013
Electrically Small Resonant Loop Antenna for Shortwave
14 Revised 7/12/2013