Popov 2006
Popov 2006
Original Russian Text © D.V. Popov, D.V. Swirkun, A.I. Netreba, O.S. Tarasova, A.B. Prostova, I.M. Larina, A.S. Borovik, O.L. Vinogradova, 2006, published in Fiziologiya Che-
loveka, 2006, Vol. 32, No. 5, pp. 121–127.
Abstract—The study was designed to test the hypothesis that, during strength training, a restricted blood sup-
ply to the working muscles stimulates the secretion of anabolic hormones and an increase in the muscle mass
and strength can be achieved with significantly lower training loads. During eight weeks, three times a week,
18 young, physically active males trained their leg extensor muscles. Nine subjects (group I) worked at 80% of
the maximal voluntary contraction (MVC), whereas the rest (group II) performed their exercise without relax-
ation and at a lower load (50% MVC). The total training load in group II was significantly lower than in group
I (77 ± 5 vs. 157 ± 7 kJ, respectively). The eight-week training of both groups significantly increased the mean
maximum strength (by 35 and 21% in groups I and II, respectively) and volume (by 17 and 9%, respectively)
of the muscles trained (however, the differences between the groups with respect to these changes were nonsig-
nificant). Group I displayed a higher increase in the blood level of creatine phosphokinase than group II, while
group II showed a greater increase in the blood concentration of lactate. In contrast to group I, group II dis-
played a significant increase in the blood concentrations of growth hormone, insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1),
and cortisol. Hence, the suggestion that the secretion of metabolic hormones is triggered by a metabolic, rather
than mechanical, stimulus from working muscles seems plausible.
DOI: 10.1134/S0362119706050161
609
610 POPOV et al.
Table 1. Volumes of muscles and maximal voluntary contraction before and after eight weeks of strength training
Group I Group II
Parameter (classic strength training) (strength training without relaxation)
before after before after
Volume of the m. quadriceps femoris, cm3 2155 ± 1175 2467 ± 147* 2209 ± 113 2320 ± 75*
Volume of the m. gluteus maximus, cm3 907 ± 57 1064 ± 64* 859 ± 48 979 ± 51*
MVC displayed in exercise, N 410 ± 18 553 ± 29* 397 ± 29* 481 ± 28*
* Significantly different from the pretraining value, p < 0.05.
Work, kJ mmol/l
30 15
(a)
25
‡ *
20 *
* 10
15 * * * *
*
10
b
5 5
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Training time, weeks
0
‡ b ‡ b
Fig. 1. Time course of the work performed in (a) group I IU/l
(trained according to the classic scheme at a load of 80% (b)
MVC) and (b) group II (trained without relaxation at a load
of 50% MVC). Asterisks indicate significant between- 300
group differences (p < 0.05).
Table 2. Biochemical parameters of the blood at the beginning (week 2) and the end (week 7) of the training course before
and after training sessions in groups I and II
Group I (classic strength training)
Parameter 2 week 7 week
before after before after
Growth hormone, ng/ml 0.22 ± 0.02 3.47 ± 0.76* 0.20 ± 0.05 6.30 ± 2.82*
Insulin-like growth factor 1, ng/ml 277 ± 39 259 ± 29 276 ± 27 266 ± 30
Testosterone, ng/ml 4.0 ± 0.7 4.1 ± 0.8 3.5 ± 0.5 4.0 ± 0.6*
Cortisol, ng/ml 195 ± 19 259 ± 37 253 ± 22 341 ± 53
Testosterone/cortisol 0.021 ± 0.006 0.014 ± 0.002
Group II (strength training without relaxation)
Parameter 2 week 7 week
before after before after
Growth hormone, ng/ml 0.27 ± 0.03 9.09 ± 1.37* 0.20 ± 0.03 8.29 ± 1.41*
Insulin-like growth factor 1, ng/ml 320 ± 50 350 ± 47* 304 ± 17 372 ± 30*
Testosterone, ng/ml 2.8 ± 0.3 3.4 ± 0.6 2.3 ± 0.5 2.5 ± 0.6
Cortisol, ng/ml 154 ± 18 264 ± 29* 187 ± 14 358 ± 30*
Testosterone/cortisol 0.024 ± 0.006 0.013 ± 0.003**
*Significantly different from the preexercise value, p < 0.05
**Significantly different from the preexercise value recorded at week 2, p < 0.05.
ume of work performed in the training with incomplete Hence, the changes in the blood levels of lactate and
relaxation, the corresponding postexercise blood con- CPK MM observed for the two training schemes indi-
centrations of lactate were higher than its concentra- cate that the classic scheme is associated with greater
tions after the classic training. damage to muscle fibers, manifested through a higher
blood level of this CPK isozyme. On the other hand, the
The presence of muscle CPK in the blood indirectly exercise performed with incomplete relaxation is asso-
reflects the load-dependent damage to cell membranes ciated with a higher rate of glycolysis, which leads to
in the working muscles. For example, any eccentric higher blood concentrations of lactate. This means that
exercise produces higher blood levels of CPK than any the classic training scheme predominantly produces a
concentric exercise [18–20]. At week 2 of our study, its mechanically dependent stimulus that can trigger ana-
increase was higher in group I (Fig. 2), which, most bolic processes in muscle fibers, whereas the training
probably, is related to the higher training load than in scheme with incomplete relaxation is associated with
group II, training at a low intensity without relaxation larger metabolic changes. Any explanation of the
(80 vs. 50% MVC, respectively). Occlusion of the hypertrophic response observed in the latter case (if the
working extremity during low-intensity training does restriction of the blood supply to the working muscles
not increase the postexercise blood level of CPK MM can be regarded as the main feature of this scheme)
[8]. By the end of the training course (week 7), the dif- should necessarily involve the results of occlusion tests.
ference between the groups in the postexercise concen- For example, MR images showed that four weeks of
trations of CPK MM became even greater because of its aerobic bicycle ergometer training (45-min sessions at
significant decrease in group II, which was not accom- a load of approximately 20% MVC performed four
panied by any significant changes in group I (Fig. 2). times a week at an additional pressure of 50 mm Hg
The lower postexercise increase observed at week 7 applied to the lower half of the body) increased the
agrees very well with the fact that, in response to a stan- cross-sectional area (CSA) of a working muscle (pre-
dard load, trained subjects displayed a much lower dominantly, type I and IIB fibers) [9, 14]. The authors
increase in the concentrations of CPK MM than their explain this hypertrophy by higher levels of contractile
untrained counterparts did [21]. A remarkable reduc- proteins and glycogen accompanied by hyperhydration.
tion in its increase after exercise was observed in the Similar results were obtained during eight-week
course of eccentric training, which can be explained by ischemic (with a cuff pressure of 200 mm Hg) low-
weaker damage to membranes (a consequence of adap- intensity strength training (twice a week, four sets of
tation of muscles to high loads) [22]. exercise at 50% MVC) of elite rugby players [11]. In
this case, the dynamic strength of the knee extensor muscle ischemia, is caused by stronger effects of meta-
muscles and their CSAs increased by 14 and 15%, bolic stimuli in the muscle during its training with
respectively. Like the accompanying changes in the incomplete relaxation necessarily associated with a
electromyographic activity, these phenomena are restricted blood flow. The eight-week strength training
explained by a corresponding increase in the contractile performed according to the classic scheme or to the
protein content. scheme with incomplete relaxation resulted in rather
An increased secretion of GH and IGF-1 may be similar gains in muscle strength and volume. Our data
responsible for these effects. We found that the postex- allow us to attribute the positive effect of the low-inten-
ercise blood concentration of GH was higher in group sity training performed without relaxation to metaboli-
II, although the mechanical effects exerted on the mus- cally stimulated secretion of anabolic hormones; the
cle fibers were significantly lower than in the classic mechanism of this phenomenon requires further, more
scheme (Table 2). A similar increase in the concentra- detailed analysis.
tion of GH was observed earlier during aerobic and
strength exercises performed with controlled occlusion ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
of veins [8, 10]. The authors of these papers attributed
this effect to the activation of group III and IV afferents We are grateful to O.I. Belichenko, B.E. Sinitsyn,
caused by the local intramuscular accumulation of and D.V. Ustyuzhanin (Myasnikov Institute of Clinical
some physiologically active metabolites that took place Cardiology).
under the restricted blood supply (a phenomenon This work was supported by the Ministry of Science
known as a metabolic reflex). and Education of the Russian Federation (contract no.
IGF-1 is the main mediator of the anabolic effects of 02.467.11.3001 of March 30, 2005) and the Russian
GH. It is secreted both systemically (by GH-stimulated Foundation for Basic Research (project no. 06-04-
liver cells) and in the autocrine way (by skeletal muscle 49699-a).
fibers during their high contractile activity) [5]. For
example, intense synthesis of IGF-1 takes place in mus- REFERENCES
cles after heavy strength training with a rather high
mechanical tension [5]. Similarly, we detected 1. Kraemer, W.J., Patton, J.F., Gordon, S.E., et al., Compat-
increased blood concentrations of IGF-1 only after the ibility of High-Intensity Strength and Endurance Train-
ing on Hormonal and Skeletal Muscle Adaptations,
exercise performed with incomplete relaxation. In con- J. Appl. Physiol., 1995, vol. 78, no. 3, p. 976.
trast, the classic strength training performed with much
higher mechanical loads caused no significant changes 2. Ahtiainen, J.P., Pakarinen, A., Alen, M., et al., Muscle
Hypertrophy, Hormonal Adaptations and Strength
in its concentration. It should be noted that the postex- Development during Strength Training in Strength-
ercise increase in the IGF-1 concentration observed in Trained and Untrained Men, Eur. J. Appl. Physiol., 2003,
the subjects trained with incomplete relaxation coin- vol. 89, no. 6, p. 555.
cided with a higher secretion of GH (Table 2). The sig- 3. Hakkinen, K., Alen, M., Kraemer, W.J., et al., Neuro-
nificant correlation (r = 0.88) between the postexercise muscular Adaptations during Concurrent Strength and
increases in the concentrations of GH and IGF-1 Endurance Training versus Strength Training, Eur. J.
observed during week 2 of the training course allows Appl. Physiol., 2003, vol. 89, no. 1, p. 42.
us to conclude that the increased concentration of 4. McCall, G., Grindeland, R., Roy, R., and Edgerton, V.
IGF-1 resulted from the metabolic increase in the Muscle Afferent Activity Modulates Bioassayable
secretion of GH. Growth Hormone in Human Plasma, J. Appl. Physiol.,
Remarkably, the low-intensity strength training 2000, vol. 89, p. 1137.
stimulated not only the secretion of anabolic hormones 5. Goldspink, G., Mechanical Signals, IGF-1 Gene Splic-
but also the secretion of cortisol. Table 2 shows that, by ing, and Muscle Adaptation, Physiology, (Bethesda)
the end of the training course, group II displayed a sig- 2005, vol. 20, p. 232.
nificant decrease in the testosterone/cortisol ratio com- 6. Gordon, S.E. Kraemer, W.J., Vos. N.H., et al., Effect of
pared to its level during week 2; a similar (although Acid–Base Balance on the Growth Hormone Response
nonsignificant) trend toward a decrease was observed to Acute High-Intensity Cycle Exercise, J. Appl. Phys-
iol., 1994, vol. 76, no. 2, p. 821.
in group I. This indicates that the physiological cost of
this training load is rather high [23]. 7. Lu, S.S., Lau, C.P., Tung, Y.F., et al., Lactate and the
Effects of Exercise on Testosterone Secretion: Evidence
for the Involvement of a cAMP-Mediated Mechanism,
CONCLUSIONS Med. Sci. Sports Exerc., 1997, vol. 29, no. 8, p. 1048.
8. Takarada, Y., Nakamura, Y, Aruga, S., et al., Rapid
This work provides the first evidence that low-inten- Increase in Plasma Growth Hormone after Low-Inten-
sity exercise (at 50% MVC) without relaxation leads to sity Resistance Exercise with Vascular Occlusion,
greater secretion of anabolic hormones than the more J. Appl. Physiol., 2000, vol. 88, no. 1, p. 61.
intensive classic strength exercise (80% MVC). Pre- 9. Sundberg, C.J., Exercise and Training during Graded
sumably, this phenomenon, like the effect produced by Leg Ischemia in Healthy Men with Special Reference to
Effects on Skeletal Muscle, Acta Physiol. Scand. Suppl., 17. Dons, B., Bollerup, K., Bonde-Petersen, F., and Hancke,
1994, vol. 615, p. 1. S., The Effect of Weight-Lifting Exercise Related to
10. Viru, M., Jansson, E., Viru, A., and Sundberg, C.J., Muscle Fiber Composition and Muscle Cross-Sectional
Effect of Restricted Blood Flow on Exercise-Induced Area in Humans, Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. Occup. Physiol.,
Hormone Changes in Healthy Men, Eur. J. Appl. Phys- 1979, vol. 40, no. 2, p. 95.
iol. Occup. Physiol., 1998, vol. 77, no. 6, p. 517. 18. Cerney, F.G. and Haralambie, G., Exercise-Induced Loss
11. Takarada, Y., Sato, Y., and Ishii, N., Effects of Resistance of Muscles Enzymes, in Knuttgen, H.G., Vogel, J.A., and
Exercise Combined with Vascular Occlusion on Muscle Poortmans, J., Eds., Biochemistry of Exercise, Cham-
Function in Athletes, Eur. J. Appl. Physiol., 2002, paign (IL): Human Kinetics, 1983, vol. 13, p. 441.
vol. 86, no. 4, p. 308. 19. Newham, D.J., McPhail, G., Mills, K.R., and Edwards,
12. Burgomaster, K.A., Moore, D.R., Schofield, L.M., et al., R.H., Ultrastructural Changes after Concentric and
Resistance Training with Vascular Occlusion: Metabolic Eccentric Contractions of Human Muscle, J. Neurol.
Adaptations in Human Muscle, Med. Sci. Sports Exerc., Sci., 1983, vol. 61, no. 1, p. 109.
2003, vol. 35, no. 7, p. 1203.
20. Newham, D.J., Jones, D.A., and Edwards, R.H., Plasma
13. Moore, D.R., Burgomaster, K.A., Schofield, L.M., et al., Creatine Kinase Changes after Eccentric and Concentric
Neuromuscular Adaptations in Human Muscle Follow- Contractions, Muscle Nerve, 1986, vol. 9, no. 1, p. 59.
ing Low Intensity Resistance Training with Vascular
Occlusion, Eur. J. Appl. Physiol., 2004, vol. 92, nos. 4– 21. Evans, W.J., Meredith, C.N., Cannon, J.G., et al., Meta-
5, p. 399. bolic Changes Following Eccentric Exercise in Trained
14. Nygren, A.T., Sundberg, C.J., Goransson, H., et al., and Untrained Men, J. Appl. Physiol., 1986, vol. 61,
Effects of Dynamic Ischaemic Training on Human Skel- no. 5, p. 1864.
etal Muscle Dimensions, Eur. J. Appl. Physiol., 2000, 22. Newham, D.J., Jones, D.A., and Clarkson, P.M.,
vol. 82, nos. 1–2, p. 137. Repeated High-Force Eccentric Exercise: Effects on
15. Seluyanov, V.N., Podgotovka beguna na srednie distan- Muscle Pain and Damage, J. Appl. Physiol., 1987,
tsii (Training of a Middle-Distance Runner), Moscow: vol. 63, no. 4, p. 1381.
SportAkademPress, 2001. 23. Hakkinen, K., Pakarinen, A., Alen, M., et al., Relation-
16. Netreba, A., Popov, D., Vdovina, A., et al. Physiological ships between Training Volume, Physical Performance
Effects of Low-Intensity Strength Training without Capacity, and Serum Hormone Concentrations during
Relaxation, in 10th Annual Congress of the ECSS. Book Prolonged Training in Elite Weight Lifters, Int. J. Sports
of Abstracts, Belgrade, Serbia, 2005, p. 397. Med., 1987, vol. 8, suppl. 1, p. 61.