Module 912 - Financial Analysis
Module 912 - Financial Analysis
Curriculum Program
Course 912 | Edition 2020
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Module 2: Financial Analysis
i
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
CFP designation holders are highly regarded for their ability to provide
clients with comprehensive financial planning services. They put clients’
interests first and ensure clients’ financial needs and objectives are being
met through the financial planning process.
ii
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
CFP®, Certified Financial Planner® and are trademarks owned by Financial Planning
Standards Board Ltd. (FPSB) and used under license. All other trademarks are those of FP
Canada™.
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada. All rights reserved.
Unauthorized reproduction of any images or content without permission is prohibited.
iii
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Acknowledgements
Written by:
iv
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Module Requirements
v
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Table of Contents
LEARNING OBJECTIVES .................................................................... 1
vi
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Accumulations ...................................................................................................... 84
Target interest rate ............................................................................................... 85
Reasonableness of time horizon .............................................................................. 87
vii
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Bringing it all together: the relationship between net worth and cash flow ....... 133
viii
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
ix
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
x
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
xi
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Learning Objectives
This module explores the fundamentals of the time value of money and
financial statements for individuals and businesses, as required by
candidates in their role as financial planners. It provides candidates with
knowledge they need to clearly document, analyze, project and present
financial information as it relates to individual and business goals, needs
and priorities. The module exposes candidates to key topics such as how to
make financial projections to determine whether goals are achievable and
how to evaluate the impact individuals’ and businesses’ current and
projected cash flow may have on their ability to meet financial goals. After
completing the coursework for this module, the learner will be able to:
1
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Frequency of compounding
Net present value for a cash flow
Purchase of assets
Sale of assets
Change in income
Change in expenses
Debt servicing
Lifestyle expenses
Savings
Asset values
Liability values
Cash flow surpluses/deficits
Growth in asset values
Reduction in asset values
Growth in liability values
Reduction in liability values
2
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The ability to use a financial calculator to factor the time value of money
into various financial planning calculations
The time value of money is a basic but powerful concept. In simple terms,
it is reasonable to say that with money comes opportunity, and with
opportunity comes cost over time. The best way to understand the time
value of money is with an example.
EXAMPLE
Jasmine lends her friend $100 over the weekend, with an agreement that the friend
will pay her back on Monday. Jasmine has given her friend the “opportunity” to use
her money for a day or two. Jasmine, in turn, has foregone the opportunity to use the
money for the same period. Having lent the money to a friend, and because the
period is so short, it is unlikely that Jasmine would expect any payment or return for
the “opportunity” she has temporarily transferred to her friend.
3
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
In the previous example, the small sum and short time period translate into a very
small opportunity cost — one that is most often ignored.
However, imagine if Jasmine’s friend approaches her on Monday about extending the
repayment term. He now offers to pay her back the $100 in exactly one year. Apart
from being slightly annoyed, Jasmine might instantly recognize that her lost
opportunity is now significantly greater. She will lose the ability to use the money to
generate a return for an entire year. Since she realizes that money has value over
time, Jasmine might ask to be compensated for that lost opportunity. She would
probably impress upon her friend that he is no longer simply borrowing money; he is
now, in effect, asking her to give him money outright. Jasmine’s friend resists that
notion and says that he is going to pay her back in full — the whole $100 — and is not
asking her to give him anything.
To explain the time value of money concept as simply as possible, Jasmine reminds
her friend that if he rents a house for a year, he will have to pay rent and return the
house “as found” at the end of the year. She explains that the same principle holds
true for the money he wants to borrow. He must return it in whole and pay for its use.
If he agrees to pay Jasmine for her lost opportunity, she will need to go through an
exercise to determine the value of the lost opportunity, which in effect will determine
the return that she realizes. However, in principle, to ensure she’s compensated for
the lost opportunity, Jasmine should charge her friend interest on the $100 he is
borrowing for a one-year period.
4
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The module begins with simple interest, works through various other
financial functions, and concludes with discounted cash flows, net present
value (NPV) and internal rates of return (IRR).
Financial calculator
This module, along with many others in the Advocis CFP Core Curriculum
Program, requires learners to have access to a financial calculator. We
recommend the Texas Instruments BA II Plus, since helpful hints and
calculator instructions within the course material refer to specific features
of this calculator.
Can you use another financial calculator? Yes, provided that your financial
calculator is capable of calculating internal rates of return, the net present
value of a stream of future cash flows, and time value of money problems.
If you choose to use another financial calculator, make sure you are
familiar with the keystrokes it requires to perform these calculations.
5
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Rates of return
Interest rates
Interest rates apply to loans or debt. An individual who borrows money is
required to pay for the use of that money by paying interest at a specified
rate to the person or institution who lent him or her the money. This
section describes four types of interest rates:
Simple interest
Compound interest
Nominal interest
Effective interest
Simple interest
Simple interest, expressed as a percentage, is the rate of return a lender
earns for lending funds to someone else. If someone deposits money in a
bank account, he or she might expect the bank to provide compensation,
in the form of simple interest, for the use of the funds.
Interest = Amount Invested (Principal) x Interest Rate per Year x Time Period
or
I=PxRxT
6
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
Assume that John deposits $1,000 in an account that pays 6% interest annually. At
the end of the year, John still has his $1,000, plus the bank owes him $60 in simple
interest:
Now assume that after the 12 months, John withdraws the $60 of interest he earned.
He decides to leave the $1,000 — the principal — in the bank account. The $1,000
earns $60 in simple interest in the second year.
What is the total value of John’s investment at the end of two years?
Accumulated Total
Principal Interest
Interest Amount
The simple interest John earns and withdraws is $60 in year one ($1,000 x 6%) and
$60 in year two ($1,000 x 6%). The interest he earns over two years is $120. As a
result, at the end of 24 months, he has a total of $1,000 principal + $120 interest =
$1,120.
In the example above, the bank calculates and pays interest at the end of
the year. However, interest can be calculated and paid over any time
period. For example, many financial institutions offer daily interest bank
accounts, with interest calculated and paid at the end of every day.
7
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Compound interest
Compound interest is an important financial concept. It describes a
situation in which interest earned during a preceding period is added to the
principal amount when calculating interest earned in a subsequent period.
Principal amounts that earn compound interest over a long period can
increase dramatically, especially when interest rates are high.
EXAMPLE
Assume that Samantha makes an initial deposit of $1,000 in a bank that offers a
compound interest account paying 6% interest annually.
At the end of the first year, the bank credits Samantha’s account with $60 ($1,000 x
6%). Compound interest increases the principal amount on which Samantha earns
interest in the second year by the amount of interest she earned in the first year. In
other words, in the second year, she earns 6% interest on the $1,060 compounded
amount ($1,000 of original principal + $60 of interest earned in the first year). With
compound interest, assuming that she withdraws nothing, Samantha has $1,123.60 at
the end of two years, instead of the $1,120 she would have had using a simple
interest calculation.
Accumulated Total
Principal Interest
Interest Amount
Year 1 (6%) $1,000.00 $60.00 $60.00 $1,060.00
Year 2 (6%) $1,060.00 $63.60 $123.60 $1,123.60
Allowing interest to compound (i.e., allowing interest added to the principal to earn
“interest on interest” in subsequent years) gives Samantha an additional $3.60 over
the two-year period.
8
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The additional amount of $3.60 may seem small and insignificant but the
effect of compound interest is much more powerful and dramatic at higher
interest rates over longer periods.
EXAMPLE
Consider two scenarios. In the first, Tom deposits a principal amount of $1,000 in an
investment that pays 10% in simple interest. He invests for 25 years, withdrawing the
interest annually. In the second, Tom deposits the same principal amount of $1,000
for the same period of 25 years, but this time the investment pays 10% in interest that
is compounded annually.
In the first scenario, with simple interest, Tom enjoys $2,500 in total interest payments
(25 years x $100/year = $2,500). In the end, his investment returns $3,500 after 25
years — an amount that includes his original $1,000 plus $2,500 in interest.
In the second scenario, with compound interest, Tom’s investment returns $10,835.70
after 25 years — an amount calculated as $1,000 x (1 + 0.10)25. We will look more
closely at the components of this calculation later in this module. At this point, it is
sufficient to understand the concept of compound interest and how powerful it is as a
wealth-creation vehicle.
With simple interest, the value of Tom’s investment is $3,500; with compound interest,
the value of Tom’s investment is $10,835.
9
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Accumulated
Principal Interest Total Amount
Interest
Year 1 (3%
every six
months
instead of
6% every
year)
First six
$1,000.00 $30.00 $30.00 $1,030.00
months
Second six
$1,030.00 $30.90 $60.90 $1,060.90
months
Year 2 (3%
every six
months
instead of
6% every
year)
First six
$1,060.90 $31.82 $92.72 $1,092.72
months
Second six
$1,092.72 $32.78 $125.50 $1,125.51
months
10
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
How does changing the frequency of compounding affect returns over a longer time
period? Consider $1,000 invested at a 10% interest rate, compounded annually,
quarterly, monthly and daily, over a 10-year period.
It’s clear that, even with identical interest rates, changing the frequency of
compounding has a significant impact on the overall return or future value
of an investment.
11
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
A comparison of nominal interest rates and effective interest rates can help
communicate differences resulting from changing the frequency of
compounding.
The nominal interest rate indicates the basic rate charged or earned for
any compounding period.
EXAMPLE
If Bob has an investment that earns a 10% nominal interest rate compounded
quarterly, that means his investment earns 2.5% for three months (10% ÷ 4). For the
second three-month period, the new principal is the original principal from the first
quarter plus the interest earned during the first quarter. In the second three-month
period, Bob’s investment earns 2.5% on the new principal amount. For the third three-
month period, the new principal is the principal from the second three-month period
plus the interest earned during the second quarter. Finally, the interest rate for the last
three-month period remains 2.5%, but it applies to a new principal amount comprising
the principal from the third three-month period plus the interest earned during the third
quarter.
The table shows Bob’s initial investment of $1,000 with a 10% nominal interest rate,
compounded quarterly.
12
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
compounding frequency increases the total return. Thus, at the end of one
year, Bob earns a rate of return greater than 10%.
The formula for calculating the effective rate of return, or effective yield,
is:
Effective Yield =
13
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Present value
Present value defines the value of a sum of money received in the future in
today’s dollars.
EXAMPLE
Imagine that Nancy comes across ABC Financial Institution, which offers her an
investment that pays $1,000 in three years. The cost today is $900. She isn’t sure if
this is a good investment.
The financial institution is stable and well-recognized. The amount of risk appears to
be no more than what she would incur if she deposited the money with any other
typical Canadian deposit-taking financial institution, such as a bank.
Before looking at mathematical formulas, Nancy tries to reason out the answer. She
recognizes that she could invest her $900 in another financial security paying market
interest rates. If she does, she wants to know if she would have more or less than
$1,000 in three years.
Nancy checks prevailing interest rates and discovers that 5%, compounded annually,
is the market rate for a three-year fixed-term investment. So, she asks, what principal
amount invested today at 5% annually will have a value of $1,000 in three years?
Without using any financial formulas, and with patience to endure a long trial-and-
error guesstimating process, Nancy could eventually discover the precise amount she
would need to invest today at 5% interest with annual compounding to return $1,000
in three years. She could then determine if that amount is more or less than $900.
Fortunately, Nancy can skip the trial-and-error process and use a mathematical
formula or her calculator to get the right answer immediately. The steps to compute
this with a calculator appear later in this module.
14
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Present Value = Future Value ÷ (1 + Nominal Interest Rate)Number of Periods Expressed in Years
or
PV = FV ÷ (1 + i)n
EXAMPLE
In Nancy’s case, the factors can be entered into the formula as:
The present value is $863.84. What does this mean? It means that if Nancy invests
$863.84 for three years at 5% interest, compounded annually, she will have $1,000
after three years ($863.84 x 1.05 x 1.05 x 1.05 = $1,000). Using a 5% interest rate (or
discount rate), $1,000 received in three years has a current or present value of
$863.84.
If Nancy can invest $863.84 in a security that pays $1,000 in three years, why would
she pay ABC Financial Institution $900 for a security that will generate the same
$1,000 after three years?
If Nancy pays the $900 asking price for this investment, she will generate a return
below the market interest rate of 5%. In effect, ABC is asking for $900 in current value
for something that is only worth (i.e., has a present value of) $863.84 in current value.
15
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The same formula works equally well for assessing the present value of a
series of future payments, instead of just one.
EXAMPLE
Assume that Harvey has been promised a payment of $500 at the end of each year,
for the next four years, as part of an investment program he is considering. The cash
flow over the period is $2,000 (4 x $500/year = $2,000). However, the time value of
money concept means the lost opportunity cost associated with waiting to receive
each payment makes each $500 worth less than $500 in current value. Obviously, the
further into the future that Harvey goes, the bigger the lost opportunity cost and the
bigger the drop in present value to compensate for the loss.
Now assume that the market interest rate is 8% for similar investments with similar
risk profiles. With this information, Harvey can calculate the present value of this cash
flow stream.
For Harvey, receiving $1,657 now would have the same economic benefit as
receiving $500 at the end of four consecutive years, based on the assumptions.
16
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Future value
The concept of future value is closely tied to the concept of present value
and uses some of the same elements. This module touched on aspects of
the future value calculation while discussing compound interest. The term
future value refers to the terminal or final value of an investment if the
investment compounds at a given rate of return for a given period. The
future value calculation can determine how much $1,000 invested at 7%,
compounded annually, will be worth at the end of three years.
Future Value = Present Value x (1 + Nominal Interest Rate)Number of Periods Expressed in Years
or
FV = PV x (1 + i)n
EXAMPLE
Ted wants to determine how much $1,000, invested at 7% compounded annually, will
be worth at the end of three years. Using the future value formula, he determines that
the future value is $1,225.04: $1,000 x (1 + 0.07)3.
EXAMPLE
Betty wants to calculate the future value, or terminal value, of investing $500 at the
beginning of each year for four consecutive years, with an annual return of 11%,
compounded annually.
Using the formula, Betty calculates the future value of her investment to be $2,613.91.
18
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The Texas Instruments BA II Plus locates the main function keys used in
TVM calculations in the third row of buttons. Most calculators, including the
Texas Instruments BA II Plus, include a second function for most keys. The
third row of five buttons on the Texas Instruments BA II Plus has five first
functions (white text) devoted to TVM calculations (left to right: N, I/Y,
PV, PMT and FV). These same keys also have second functions (yellow
text) devoted to TVM-related calculations (left to right: xP/Y, P/Y,
AMORT, BGN and CLR TVM).
19
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
PV Present value
FV Future value
CLR Clear the TVM variables (N, I/Y, PV, PMT, FV); does not clear
TVM P/Y and C/Y
It’s also important to understand other relevant keys and functions when
using the Texas Instruments BA II Plus calculator for TVM calculations.
Other calculators have similar functions, although they may operate using
a different series of keystrokes.
20
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
2ND key
The yellow 2ND key is on the far left of the second row from the top. Use
it to access the second function of buttons with second functions in yellow
text. In this module, [2ND] indicates that the 2ND key must be pressed.
To access the second functions in the chart above, press [2ND], followed
by the desired function. For example, to access the xP/Y function, press
[2ND], followed by [N] (which has the second function xP/Y in yellow
text above it).
END mode is the calculator’s default mode. When the calculator is in END
mode, the display does not specifically indicate this. However, when the
calculator is in BEGIN mode, the letters BGN are visible in the top right
hand corner of the display.
21
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
If the first payment occurs at the beginning of the first period, the
calculator must be set to BEGIN mode. This is done by pressing [2ND]
[BGN] to access the second function BGN, and then pressing
[2ND][SET] to SET the calculator to BEGIN mode. The calculator should
now show BGN in the top right-hand corner of the display.
To put the calculator back to END mode, use the same keystrokes: [2ND]
BGN, [2ND] SET.
The BEGIN or END mode only affects the result if there is a series of
periodic payments associated with the TVM calculation. When the
calculator is in BEGIN mode, the letters BGN appear on the display screen.
When the calculator is in END mode, no words appear on the display
screen.
[2ND]
[FORMAT]
9
[ENTER]
22
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
100
[+/-]
Clear TVM
The calculator retains entries in memory so, before beginning any new
TVM calculation, it is important to clear all of the TVM registers. Use the
following keystrokes:
[2ND]
CLR TVM
Helpful hints
Consider these hints as you get started using the calculator:
When you enter an annual interest rate (e.g., 7%), enter it as a whole
number (7), not a percentage (7%) and not as a decimal (0.07).
IMPORTANT! TVM calculations are naturally concerned with the inflow
and outflow of money. The rule of thumb for using the [+/-] button is
to enter amounts paid or invested as a negative number and amounts
accumulated or received as a positive number. Cash inflows are
positive, and cash outflows are negative.
23
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
TVM prerequisites
The Texas Instruments BA II Plus calculates TVM based on several
assumptions or prerequisites:
There must be at least one positive and one negative cash flow in each
calculation (either in the numbers entered or in the resulting outcome)
If there are irregular payments of differing amounts, you must use the
cash flow [CF] function, instead of the basic TVM calculation. We describe
the cash flow calculation later in this module.
24
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
To solve for any of these variables after entering the known information,
press [CPT], followed by the variable you want to compute. For example,
to solve for future value, after entering information for the four other
variables, press [CPT] [FV].
25
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
As part of the negotiations for the sale of a cottage property, a potential buyer offers
Raymond, the vendor of the property, $10,000 payable four years after the deal
closes.
Raymond must calculate the present value of the future payment in order to make an
informed decision. Assume an annual nominal interest rate of 10%, compounded
annually.
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=4
I/Y = 10
PMT = 0
FV = 10,000
Keystrokes:
[CE/C]
4 [N]
10 [I/Y]
0 [PMT]
10,000 [FV]
[CPT] [PV]
26
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
This present value calculation shows that, given a prevailing interest rate of 10%,
$10,000 received at the end of four years is equivalent to $6,830.13 received today.
Stated another way, $6,830.13 invested today at 10% would grow to $10,000 in four
years.
EXAMPLE 2
Harriett has just leased a new car that her brother-in-law has agreed to purchase from
her for $12,000 at the end of the five-year lease period. Using an annual interest
assumption of 7%, compounded annually, calculate the present value of the $12,000
that Harriett will receive in five years.
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=5
I/Y = 7
PMT = 0
FV = 12,000
Harriett explains to her brother-in-law that, using a 7% annual interest rate, she can
consider the $12,000 received after five years to be equivalent to $8,555.83 today.
EXAMPLE 3
As part of the payment for the purchase of her business, Donna is offered a
promissory note for $135,000, which is due at the end of two years. Assuming an
annual return of 6%, compounded annually, what is the present value of this
promissory note? (Disregard taxes.)
27
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=2
I/Y = 6
PMT = 0
FV = 135,000
EXAMPLE 4
Tiffany has received an offer from a corporation that wants to buy her company for
$3,500,000, payable in full after 18 months. Tiffany wonders what the $3,500,000
offer represents in today’s dollars. Assuming an annual return of 9%, compounded
annually, calculate the present value of the offer. (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
I/Y = 9
PMT = 0
FV = 3,500,000
28
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Ashley received a $1,000 investment certificate from her great aunt on her 12th
birthday. The certificate pays a 3% annual interest rate, compounded once each year,
and matures on her 27th birthday. What is the maturity value of Ashley’s investment
certificate? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
I/Y = 3
PMT = 0
PV = -1,000
29
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Keystrokes:
[CE/C]
15 [N]
3 [I/Y]
0 [PMT]
[CPT] [FV]
Ashley’s investment certificate will be worth $1,557.97 at maturity, when she turns 27.
EXAMPLE 2
Sheila’s parents deposited $500,000 into an account on her 22 nd birthday, but she is
unable to access the funds until her 30th birthday. The account in which the money
sits pays an annual interest rate of 8%, compounded once each year. How much will
Sheila’s investment be worth when she reaches her 30th birthday? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 8 (30 – 22 = 8)
I/Y = 8
PMT = 0
PV = -500,000
30
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 3
Liam, age 55, has been offered a retirement package that includes a $50,000
settlement, payable today. If Liam accepts the offer, he would like to invest this lump-
sum amount for the next five years and then use the money towards the purchase of
an annuity. If Liam receives an annual interest rate of 8%, compounded annually, for
each of the next five years, how much will he have accumulated? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=5
I/Y = 8
PMT = 0
PV = -50,000
31
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 4
Anthony has been asked to calculate the future value of three scenarios. Each has
the same present value, but has a different interest rate and investment period. Which
scenario has the greatest future value? (Disregard taxes.)
Option A
$100,000, invested for 3.5 years at an annual interest rate of 23.3%, compounded
quarterly.
P/Y = 4
N = 14 (3.5 x 4)
I/Y = 23.3
PMT = 0
PV = -100,000
Option B
$100,000, invested for seven years at an annual interest rate of 12%, compounded
annually.
P/Y = 1
N=7
I/Y = 12
PMT = 0
PV = -100,000
32
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Option C
P/Y = 12
I/Y = 4.4
PMT = 0
PV = -100,000
The results are $220,920.43 for Option A, $221,068.14 for Option B and $220,461.20
for Option C. While close, Option B results in the highest future value.
EXAMPLE 1
What is the present value of a periodic payment stream that provides Raymond with
$2,500 at the end of each year for the next four years? Assume that the interest rate
is 10%, compounded annually. (Disregard taxes.)
33
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=4
I/Y = 10
PMT = 2,500
FV = 0
Mode = END (the payments are made at the end of each year)
Keystrokes:
First, verify that BGN is not visible on the calculator display; if it is, press [2ND] BGN,
[2ND] SET to switch to END mode. Then press:
[CE/C]
4 [N]
10 [I/Y]
2,500 [PMT]
0 [FV]
[CPT] [PV]
34
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Keystrokes:
Without clearing the calculator, simply change from END to BGN mode. Press [2ND]
BGN, [2ND] SET. BGN should now be visible on the calculator display. Now press:
[CPT] [PV]
To look at how monthly payments change the value, assume a monthly payment of
$208.33 ($2,500 ÷ 12), at the beginning of each month. Remember, the number of
payments per year must be adjusted to reflect a monthly stream. Assume that interest
is compounded monthly to align with the payments.
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 48
I/Y = 10
PMT = 208.33
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
The present value decreases to $8,282.52, compared with the present value of
$8,717.13 when payments are annual. This example provides a good illustration of
the interplay between beginning of period payments and end of period payments, and
yearly versus monthly payments, when it comes to calculating present value.
35
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
Alfred would like to set up an account to pay his grandson $5,000 at the end of each
year for the next 25 years. Using an interest assumption of 5%, compounded
annually, how much should Alfred invest today? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 25
I/Y = 5
PMT = 5,000
FV = 0
Mode = END
EXAMPLE 3
Billy has a $13,000 student loan. He has approached his parents, asking them to pay
off the loan now and offering to pay them back at a rate of $1,200 at the end of each
year for the next 15 years. Billy’s parents feel he must accept some financial
responsibility, so they would like to charge him an annual interest rate of 5%,
compounded once each year. Using these assumptions, determine if the present
value of Billy’s payback proposal results in the full repayment of $13,000 to his
parents. (Disregard taxes.)
36
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 15
I/Y = 5
PMT = -1,200
FV = 0
Mode = END
Accounting for the 5% interest rate charged by Billy’s parents, the stream of payments
that Billy proposed has a present value of $12,455.59, compared with the $13,000
that Billy’s parents must pay now. This means Billy’s proposed payment stream falls
short of providing the return that his parents have requested.
EXAMPLE 4
As part of her retirement package, Nelly expects to receive $6,000 at the beginning of
each quarter, for the next 15 years. Assuming an annual 7% return, compounded
quarterly, what is the present value of this stream of payments? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 4
C/Y = 4
N = 60 (4 x 15)
I/Y = 7
PMT = 6,000
FV = 0
37
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 5
Gail has received an annuity that pays her $10,000 at the beginning of each year for
12 years. Gail would like to sell it now in the open market for its fair market value
(FMV). Assuming an annual interest rate of 6.5%, compounded annually, calculate
the present value to determine what the payment stream represented by the annuity
is worth today. (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 12
I/Y = 6.5
PMT = 10,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
EXAMPLE 6
Robert would like to purchase a 20-year annuity that pays him $4,000 at the
beginning of each year. Payments would begin immediately. Assuming an annual
interest rate of 7.2%, compounded annually, how much would the annuity cost
Robert? (Disregard taxes.)
38
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 20
I/Y = 7.2
PMT = 4,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
EXAMPLE 7
Shiam has an investment that pays her $200 at the beginning of each month. There
are exactly four years of payments remaining, after which there is no value. Assuming
an annual interest rate of 6.6%, compounded monthly, what is the present value of
Shiam’s payment stream? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 48
I/Y = 6.6
PMT = 200
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
39
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Wilson plans to save $6,000 at the end of every year for the nine years remaining
before he retires. He believes he can achieve an annual return of 4.4%, compounded
annually. How much will Wilson have when he reaches retirement? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=9
I/Y = 4.4
PMT = -6,000
PV = 0
Mode = END
40
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Keystrokes:
[CE/C]
9 [N]
4.4 [I/Y]
0 PV]
[CPT] [FV]
Wilson wonders what effect it would have on his total savings if he sold his motorcycle
now for $7,800 and deposited the money in the same account. Assume all other
factors remain unchanged.
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=9
I/Y = 4.4
PMT = -6,000
PV = -7,800
Mode = END
By adding the proceeds from the disposition of his motorcycle to the account at the
beginning, Wilson’s investment accumulates to $76,039.15 at retirement.
41
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
Bob and Carol feel it is important to begin saving now for their children’s university
costs. They estimate they have 11 years to save $50,000. After meeting all of the
expenses of daily living, Bob and Carol believe they can save $196.78 at the end of
each month. They expect to achieve an annual return of 7.1%, compounded monthly.
Will this savings pattern achieve the $50,000 their children need? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 132
I/Y = 7.1
PMT = -196.78
PV = 0
Mode = END
Unfortunately, the savings pattern Bob and Carol have developed will fall well short of
their savings target, achieving only $39,199.75, compared with a need of $50,000.
EXAMPLE 3
Jay wants to raise the money required to make a balloon payment (final payment) of
$63,000 at the end of a 7.5-year period. He currently has $12,300 in an account into
which he is making monthly payments of $342 at the beginning of each month. He
anticipates that he can earn an annual interest rate of 8%, compounding monthly. Jay
wonders if he will have enough money to cover his balloon payment in 7.5 years.
(Disregard taxes.)
42
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 90 (7.5 x 12)
I/Y = 8
PMT = -342
PV = -12,300
Mode = BGN
Jay is happy to discover that, based on the assumptions and if everything goes
according to plan, he will have $64,636.16 in 7.5 years, which is slightly more than the
$63,000 he needs.
EXAMPLE 4
At the beginning of each month, Rachel will receive a licensing fee of $856 from
clients who use software she has just finished developing. Rachel wants to sell the
underlying intellectual property, but only after she has accumulated enough money
from her licensing fee revenue and the interest she earns on that fund. Her target is to
sell the intellectual property in four years. If Rachel can earn an annual investment
return of 3.8%, based on monthly compounding, how much will she have accumulated
at the end of four years? (Disregard taxes.)
43
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 48 (4 x 12)
I/Y = 3.8
PMT = 856
PV = 0
Mode = BGN
Based on the assumptions, Rachel will have accumulated $44,439.82 after four years.
However, Rachel’s goal is to have accumulated $60,000 before she sells the
intellectual property. How much more time will it take her to reach that goal?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 3.8
PMT = 856
PV = 44,439.82
FV = -60,000
Mode = BGN
Rachel will have to wait an additional 15.22 months (1.27 years), or a total of 5.27
years (4 years + 1.27 years), before she accumulates a total of $60,000.
44
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 5
How much will Mahood accumulate if he opens an account with a $16,212 deposit,
adds $112.91 at the beginning of each month for 5.75 years, and earns an annual
return of 9%, compounded monthly? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 69 (5.75 x 12)
I/Y = 9
PMT = -112.91
PV = -16,212
Mode = BGN
EXAMPLE 6
Ian, a high school teacher, wants to demonstrate to his class the power of compound
interest. He explains that an individual who deposits $100 at the beginning of each
month for the next 55 years into an investment paying 7.6% annual interest,
compounded monthly, will accumulate a very large amount. How much exactly will
this investment accumulate? (Disregard taxes.)
45
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 7.6
PMT = -100
PV = 0
Mode = BGN
Based on these assumptions, after 55 years, the individual will have $1,009,139.15.
EXAMPLE 7
If Heba deposits $1,000 at the beginning of every year for seven years into an
account with an initial balance of $1,000, what is the value of her account at the end
of seven years? Assume that she earns a return of 2.5%, compounded annually.
(Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=7
I/Y = 2.5
PMT = -1,000
PV = -1,000
Mode = BGN
At the end of seven years, Heba will have $8,924.80 in the account.
46
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Just as it is important to clear the TVM variables before starting any TVM
calculations, it is important to clear the ICONV function before starting
any interest rate conversion calculations. To do this, press [2ND] [CLR
WORK]. CLR WORK is the second function of the [CE/C] button in the
bottom left corner of the keypad.
47
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
A bank account pays a 3% annual nominal interest rate, compounded monthly. What
is the annual effective interest rate?
Keystrokes:
[CPT]
EXAMPLE 2
An investment certificate pays 6.7% annual nominal interest rate, compounded daily.
What is the annual effective interest rate?
Keystrokes:
[CPT]
48
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 3
Dorothy’s bank manager explains that the annual effective interest rate on her bank
account is 3.9%. If the compounding period is quarterly, what is the annual nominal
interest rate?
Keystrokes:
[CPT]
49
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Mark invests $1,000 in an account and, at the end of six years, he has accumulated a
total of $1,500. Assuming interest is compounded annually, what annual nominal
interest rate did he receive to produce an account balance of $1,500? (Disregard
taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=6
PMT = 0
PV = -1,000
FV = 1,500
Keystrokes:
[CE/C]
6 [N]
0 [PMT]
1500 [FV]
[CPT I/Y
50
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
This simple example looked at lump-sum amounts six years apart. With
TVM calculations, the process can also solve for I/YR when there is a
periodic payment stream.
EXAMPLE 2
Stefanie invests $150 in mutual funds at the end of each month for five years. At the
end of the five years, her investment has accumulated to $12,400. Assuming monthly
compounding, what annual nominal return did the investment earn? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (5 x 12)
PMT = -150
PV = 0
FV = 12,400
Mode = END
Stefanie earned an annual nominal return of 12.45% during the five years.
EXAMPLE 3
Steve started with an initial balance of $12,500 in an investment and added $200 at
the end of each month for 3.5 years. If his balance is $22,875 at the end of the period,
what annual nominal rate of return did Steve earn? Assume monthly compounding.
(Disregard taxes.)
51
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 42 (3.5 x 12)
PMT = -200
PV = -12,500
FV = 22,875
Mode = END
Steve earned an annual nominal rate of return of 3.23% (rounded) on the investment
over 3.5 years. If Steve’s annual nominal rate of return is 3.2307%, what is his annual
effective rate of return?
NOM = 3.2307
C/Y = 12
Compute EFF
EXAMPLE 4
Colleen has saved $2,000 towards the purchase of a car that she would like to buy in
four years. Colleen can save $375 at the end of each month, and she needs $22,800
to pay for the car. What annual nominal rate of return does she need to earn, based
on monthly compounding? (Disregard taxes.)
52
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 48 (4 x 12)
PMT = -375
PV = -2,000
FV = 22,800
Mode = END
Colleen needs to earn an annual nominal return of 5.95% to achieve her goal.
EXAMPLE 5
Ruth has agreed to lend her best friend John $5,000, and he has agreed to repay her
$1,200 at the end of each year for the next five years. Based on this schedule of
payments, what annual nominal interest rate is Ruth charging John on the loan?
(Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=5
PMT = 1,200
PV = -5,000
FV = 0
Mode = END
Ruth is charging her friend an annual nominal interest rate of 6.4%, compounded
annually.
53
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 6
To buy equipment for his shop, Max is borrowing $32,000 right now. He plans to
repay the debt over six years, at which time the equipment will no longer be of value
to him, so he plans to sell it for $8,000. If Max makes monthly payments of $519 at
the end of each month for six years, and gives the $8,000 residual value to the lender
at the end of the six years, what annual nominal interest rate is he paying? (Disregard
taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 72 (6 x 12)
PMT = -519
PV = 32,000
FV = -8,000
Mode = END
That interest rate seemed high to Max, so he asked the lender to sharpen his pencil
and do a little better. The lender offered to lower the monthly payment from $519 to
$489 if that will help close the deal. Before accepting, Max wants to recalculate the
annual nominal interest rate. Without clearing the calculator from the previous
example, it is easy to adjust the calculation to reflect the new information.
PMT = -489
Max learns that payments of $489 per month reflect an annual nominal interest rate of
8.8%, compounded monthly, which is more in line with his expectations.
54
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 7
Barbara is seeking a $15,000 loan on which she plans to make $400 payments at the
end of each month for five years, after which the loan will be fully repaid. What annual
nominal interest rate is she paying?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (5 x 12)
PMT = -400
PV = 15,000
FV = 0
Mode = END
Barbara is paying an annual nominal interest rate of 20.3%. What annual effective
interest rate is she paying?
NOM = 20.31
C/Y = 12
Compute EFF
55
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Monique financed the cost of her education by making a payment at the beginning of
each month for 3.75 years to her uncle, who prepaid her $12,000 tuition fees. Her
uncle wants a 7% annual return, compounded monthly, on the money he paid on her
behalf. Calculate the monthly payments Monique must make to her uncle. (Disregard
taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 45 (3.75 x 12)
I/Y = 7.0
PV = 12,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
56
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Keystrokes:
45 N
7 I/Y
12,000 PV]
0 [FV]
[CPT] [PMT]
EXAMPLE 2
Tompkin Enterprises needs $25,000,000 at the end of 10 years to construct a facility.
If the company can earn an annual return of 5.8%, compounded annually, how much
does it need to save at the end of each year to have $25,000,000 at the end of 10
years? (Disregard taxes.)
57
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 10
I/Y = 5.8
PV = 0
FV = 25,000,000
Mode = END
Tompkin Enterprises must save $1,914,586.79 every year for 10 years to accumulate
the $25,000,000 it needs at the end of 10 years.
EXAMPLE 3
Tony wants to buy a car, but he would like to save up the cash before making the
purchase. He feels he can earn an annual rate of return of 6.9%, compounded
annually, and would like to accumulate sufficient funds over a five-year period. Tony
figures he will need $27,800 at the end of five years to purchase the car and currently
has savings of $10,500. What amount does Tony need to save at the end of each
year if he wants to have sufficient funds to purchase the car? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=5
I/Y = 6.9
PV = -10,500
FV = 27,800
Mode = END
58
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Under this scenario, Tony needs to save $2,289.82 each year to meet his $27,800
target.
EXAMPLE 4
Baha works for a company that allows employees to deduct a portion of their monthly
paycheque to fund a sabbatical year at some time in the future. Baha’s employer pays
3% interest, compounded monthly, on this deducted money. Baha, who currently
earns $84,000 annually, wants to accumulate an amount equal to two-thirds of his
present salary to fund his sabbatical year, which will begin in five years. How much
does Baha need to instruct his employer to deduct from his monthly paycheque during
the next five years, if he is to accumulate the required amount by the beginning of his
sabbatical? Assume that the monthly deduction is made at the end of each month.
(Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (5 x 12)
I/Y = 3
PV = 0
Mode = END
Baha needs to deduct $866.25 from his month-end pay to accumulate $56,000 by the
beginning of his sabbatical year.
59
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 5
Calculate the investment required, at the end of each month, to generate $50,000 by
the end of five years, assuming a 5.5% annual rate of return, compounded monthly.
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (5 x 12)
I/Y = 5.5
PV = 0
FV = 50,000
Mode = END
With these assumptions, monthly investments of $725.89 will generate $50,000 by the
end of five years.
EXAMPLE 6
Karen and Daryl are considering a tropical vacation that will cost $5,500. Although
they do not have the money on hand, they know they can borrow from Karen’s
parents if they agree to pay the loan back within two years. If the couple plans to pay
an annual interest rate of 2.75%, compounded monthly, how much must they repay at
the beginning of each month? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 24 (2 x 12)
I/Y = 2.75
PV = 5,500
60
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
Karen and Daryl must make monthly payments of $235.25, under this scenario.
EXAMPLE 1
Xavier earned $3,500 this summer working as a camp counsellor. He wants to buy a
new road bicycle with this money. He invested the $3,500 in a short-term savings
account that earns 4% compounded annually. The road bicycle Xavier wants costs
$6,000. How long will it take for Xavier’s summer earnings to grow to $6,000?
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
I/Y = 4
PV = -3,500
FV = 6,000
It will take 13.74 years for Xavier’s summer earnings to grow to $6,000.
61
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
Ru wants to buy a car. She expects to be able to buy a good-quality used car for
$25,000. She has not set aside anything yet for the purchase, but is able to save
$600 at the end of each month. How long will it take Ru to save enough to buy a car if
she earns a nominal rate of 6%, compounded monthly?
Mode = END
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 6
PV = 0
PMT = -600
FV = 25,000
Since P/Y and C/Y are set to 12, the problem and solution are denominated in
months. Ru will save enough to buy a car in 37.94 months, which is equivalent to
three years and nearly two months.
EXAMPLE 3
Aesha inherited $32,000 from her grandfather. She would like to buy a Recreational
Vehicle (RV) with the money to travel across Canada. However, $32,000 is not
enough money. She needs $88,000 to purchase the RV of her dreams. If Aesha
invests her inheritance in a savings account that pays an annual nominal rate of 5.5%,
compounded monthly, and she contributes $800 at the end of each month, when will
she have enough money to buy her RV?
62
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Mode = END
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 5.5
PV = -32,000
PMT = -800
FV = 88,000
It will take Aesha 52.46 months, or 4 years and 4.46 months, to save enough to buy
her RV.
EXAMPLE 4
Pierre is 45 years old and has saved only $32,000 for his retirement. He has
determined that he needs $1,000,000 in retirement savings to fund his desired
lifestyle. He can save $1,200 at the beginning of each month towards his retirement
goal. How many years will it be before he can retire if his retirement savings and his
monthly contributions are invested at a rate of 6% per year, compounded monthly?
Mode = BGN
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 6
PV = 32,000
PMT = 1,200
FV = -1,000,000
Pierre can retire in 303.48 months, or 25.29 years (25 years and 3.5 months).
63
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 5
Sangeeta is 65 years old and retires tomorrow. She has $275,000 in retirement
savings and wants to receive payments of $36,000 per year at the beginning of each
year. How many years will it take her to run out of money if she invests her retirement
savings at an annual nominal rate of 8.25%, compounded annually.
Mode = BGN
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
I/Y = 8.25
PV = -275,000
PMT = 36,000
FV = 0
EXAMPLE 6
Maddie just bought a new car and financed it with a $33,500 loan at an annual
interest rate of 7.95%, compounded monthly. She pays $550 at the beginning of each
month towards the loan. How long will it be before Maddie’s car loan is fully repaid?
64
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Mode = BGN
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 7.95
PV = 33,500
PMT = -550
FV = 0
Maddie’s car loan will be fully repaid in 77.6 months, or six years and 5.6 months.
65
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
To see the impact of different compounding periods, Christine calculates the future
value of three options. In each scenario, the total amount invested is $24,000 over a
10-year period, but the compounding and payment frequency differ. (Disregard taxes.)
Option A
Invest $2,400 at the end of each year for 10 years, assuming an annual 4.9% return,
compounded annually.
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 10
I/Y = 4.9
PV = 0
PMT = -2,400
Mode = END
66
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Option B
Invest $600 at the end of each quarter for 10 years, assuming an annual 4.9% return,
compounded quarterly.
P/Y = 4
C/Y = 4
N = 40 (4 x 10)
I/Y = 4.9
PV = 0
PMT = -600
Mode = END
Option C
Invest $200 at the end of each month for 10 years, assuming an annual 4.9% return,
compounded monthly.
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 4.9
PV = 0
PMT = -200
Mode = END
67
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
As expected, Christine’s calculations show that, although the same total amount was
invested at the same nominal interest rate under all three scenarios, the result is
almost $850 more when the investment compounds monthly compared to when it
compounds annually.
EXAMPLE 2
Every month, Rex deposits $169 into a bank account that offers daily compounding.
The annual nominal interest rate is 4%. He wants to know what his bank balance will
be in five years. (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 365
N = 60 (12 x 5)
I/Y = 4
PV = 0
PMT = -169
Mode = END
With daily compounding, the future value of this payment stream is $11,206.36.
To illustrate the effects of daily compounding, you can calculate this same
example using monthly periods and monthly compounding, and yearly
periods and yearly compounding. No adjustment is necessary because, in
68
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
both cases, the payment period and the compounding period match.
Assume payments at the end of the periods. Most of the questions in this
course have matching payment and compounding periods.
EXAMPLE 3
Option 1: Annual
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N=5
I/Y = 4
PV = 0
Mode = END
Option 2: Monthly
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (12 x 5)
I/Y = 4
PV = 0
PMT = -169
Mode = END
Annuities
An annuity is a set of payments made over time. Annuities can be
categorized as ordinary annuities, which make payments at the end of the
period, and annuities due, which make payments at the beginning of the
period. This section reviews how to calculate the present value of a series
of uniform annuity payments made over time and the future value of
annuity payments received over a given period.
The effect of switching to an annuity due is to move all of the cash flows
ahead by one period. Therefore, calculating the present value requires one
less compounding period. To achieve this mathematically, add one term
(l+i) to the formula:
70
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
FV = PMT x (((1+i)n – 1) ÷ i)
EXAMPLE 1
Marie inherited an ordinary annuity that will pay her $300 monthly for another 2.5
years. What is the present value of this ordinary annuity, assuming an annual interest
rate of 4%, compounded monthly? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 30 (2.5 x 12)
I/Y = 4
PMT = 300
FV = 0
Mode = END
71
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
David has purchased an annuity due that pays $970 each year for the next 12 years,
starting today (i.e., at the beginning of the period). What is the present value of this
annuity due, assuming an annual interest rate of 5.3%, compounded annually?
(Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 12
I/Y = 5.3
PMT = 970
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
EXAMPLE 3
Joanne has a court-ordered spousal support agreement to pay her former husband
$400 at the end of each month for 7.25 years. Since the payments are uniform
amounts, this works exactly like an ordinary annuity. Assuming an annual interest rate
of 3.9%, compounded monthly, what is the present value of Joanne’s ordinary
annuity? (Disregard taxes.)
72
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 87 (7.25 x 12)
I/Y = 3.9
PMT = 400
FV = 0
Mode = END
EXAMPLE 4
Dan invests $5,000 at the beginning of each year in an account that pays 6% interest,
compounded annually. What is the value of this account in 3.3 years? (Disregard
taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 3.3
I/Y = 6
PMT = -5,000
PV = 0
Mode = BGN
73
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Deferred Payments
In some calculations — for example, with deferred annuities — we must
account for situations where the payment stream does not begin
immediately, but instead at some point in the future. These calculations
typically involve two stages: the deferral stage before payments begin and
the payment phase. The following example illustrates the present value of
a deferred periodic payment stream.
EXAMPLE 5
Tom just turned 65 years old, and he has a life expectancy of 28.46 years. He is
considering buying a guaranteed life annuity product that will pay him $1,500 at the
beginning of each month starting on his 80th birthday. If the deferred annuity is
calculated based on an annual interest rate of 4.23%, compounded monthly, how
much would it cost for Tom to purchase the annuity today?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
Mode = BGN
I/Y = 4.23
PMT = 1500
FV = 0
Solving for PV calculates the amount Tom requires at age 80 to purchase an annuity
that provides payments beginning at age 80 and continuing for the rest of his life
(13.46 years): $185,137.36. This is the payout period value. However, Tom is only 65
today, and the money isn’t required until age 80. Therefore, we must now calculate
what sum of money today (when Tom is 65) will grow to $185,137.36 in 15 years
74
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
(when Tom is 80). Remember that, during this phase, from age 65 to 80, there are no
payments.
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 4.23
PMT = -0
FV = 185,137.36
It would cost Tom $98,269.50 to purchase the annuity today. This amount is known as
the present value of a deferred periodic payment stream.
EXAMPLE 6
Jane just opened an investment account. She plans to contribute $150 to the account
at the end of each month until her daughter, Beth, turns 15. Beth just turned 6, and
Jane intends to give her the balance in the account on her 18th birthday. If Jane can
achieve a 5.2% return, compounded monthly, on the account over the full period,
what amount can she give Beth on her 18th birthday? (Disregard taxes.)
75
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
Mode = END
I/Y = 5.2
PV = -0
PMT = -150
Solving for FV calculates the amount that will have accumulated when Beth turns 15:
$20,602.51. This is the savings period value. However, although Jane will stop
contributing at this point, the money in the account will continue to grow for another
three years, until Beth reaches 18. Therefore, we must now calculate the amount to
which $20,602.51 will grow during those three years. Remember that, during this
phase, from age 15 to 18, there are no contributions.
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y: 5.2
PMT: -0
PV: -20,602.51
Jane could give Beth $24,072.64 on her 18th birthday. This amount is known as the
future value of a deferred periodic payment stream.
76
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Bonds
Governments, corporations and other institutions issue bonds. A bond is an
interest-bearing debt of the issuer. It represents a loan by the issuer to
the lender with a promise by the issuer to repay the face value (value of
the bond at maturity) of the bond at maturity and to pay the stated
interest periodically. Generally, bonds pay interest semi-annually, which is
reflected in TVM calculations for regular bonds as P/Y = 2.
TVM calculations are relevant to determining the cost of the bond (solve
for present value), the interest or yield (solve for interest), and the value
of the bond (solve for future value).
Pricing bonds
Like most financial assets, bonds are usually negotiable, meaning they can
be sold before maturity. The price at which a bond is traded should reflect
the present value of its future payments. This present value, in turn, will
be a function of the prevailing interest rates when the bond is sold, its
original interest or coupon rate, and the payments associated with the
bond.
77
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Bond prices are quoted similar to an index number, which can be thought
of as a percentage of the bond’s face value. A bond can trade at, above or
below par:
At par: trading at 100; the investor pays exactly the face value
At a discount: trading below 100he investor would pay less than face value.
At a premium: trading above 100. The investor would pay more than face
value.
Remember, the number is not the dollar amount, but rather, a percentage of
the face value. Let’s illustrate with a few examples:
A bond with a face value of $10,000 is trading at 98.50. In this case, the
investor would pay $9,850 for the bond. This bond is trading at a
discount.
A bond with a face value of $250,000 is trading at 99.00. In this case, the
investor would pay $247,500 for the bond. This bond is trading at a
discount.
A $50,000 bond is trading at 92.00. In this case, the investor would pay
$46,000 for the bond. This bond is trading at a discount.
78
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Why do bonds trade above and below their own face values, and why
would an investor pay more than face value for a bond? In general, this is
determined by the bond’s coupon (interest) rate in comparison to
prevailing, current market interest rates. Figure 1 explains the effect
current market interest rates have on bond trading prices.
EXAMPLE 1
Peter owns a 25-year bond with a face value of $10,000, bearing a coupon rate of
6%. The bond matures in 20 years. If the current market rate is 8%, how much would
someone pay today for Peter’s bond? (Disregard taxes.)
79
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
C/Y = 2
N = 40 (2 x 20 years to maturity)
PMT = 300 (($10,000 x 0.06) ÷ 2) (interest payment is received two times each year)
MODE = END
Notice that the coupon rate is not related to I/Y. The coupon rate is what determines
the payment. The PMT is derived by multiplying the face value of $10,000 by the
coupon rate of 6% and dividing the result by two to reflect the semi-annual nature of
bond coupon payments. The I/Y is arrived at by using the market interest rate of 8%,
not the coupon rate of 6%. The bond has 20 years left until maturity, which is
therefore 40 payments as the payment frequency is twice per year (P/Y = 2). If a
buyer pays Peter $8,020.72 for this bond, and the bond pays the buyer $300 twice
each year for 20 years, along with a return of the face amount of $10,000 at the end
of 20 years, the bond will have generated an 8% annual nominal interest rate, which
is the prevailing market rate.
In the previous example, the price of the bond fell below the face value of
$10,000 because interest rates had increased. The market interest rate of
8% was higher than the bond coupon rate of 6%.
80
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
Joan has a 15-year bond issued with a face value of $100,000 and a coupon rate of
5%. A buyer is interested in Joan’s bond at a time when the prevailing interest rate is
3.5%; therefore, Joan expects to realize a premium on the face value of the bond.
There are eight years left until the bond reaches maturity. What is the present value,
or market price, of the bond? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 2
C/Y = 2
N = 16 (8 x 2)
FV = 100,000
MODE = END
Joan will realize $110,387.87 on the sale of this bond. The buyer can afford to pay a
premium over face value because the additional above-market interest he can earn
will give him a nominal annual interest rate of 3.5%, which is the market rate, during
the remaining years until maturity.
81
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 3
Chris is considering the purchase of a bond with a $1,000,000 face value that pays a
coupon rate of 6.2% and has exactly six years remaining until maturity. If Chris pays
$925,000 for the bond, what is his annual nominal rate of return? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 2
C/Y =2
N = 12 (6 x 2)
PV = -925,000
FV = 1,000,000
Mode = END
Since this bond is selling at a discount to its face value, it is reasonable to expect that
the annual nominal interest rate will be higher than the bond’s coupon rate. This holds
true, as the annual nominal interest rate is 7.79%, whereas the coupon rate is 6.2%.
So, if Chris purchases this bond for $925,000, receives semi-annual payments of
$31,000, and receives $1,000,000 at the end of six years, he will earn an annual
nominal interest rate of 7.79% on his investment.
EXAMPLE 4
For $642,000, Brittany purchased a bond with eight years to maturity that has a
coupon rate of 4% and a face value of $600,000. What is Brittany’s annual nominal
rate of interest? (Disregard taxes.)
82
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 2
C/Y = 2
N = 16 (8 x 2)
PV = -642,000
FV = 600,000
Mode = END
As expected, when the bond sells for a premium over face value, the annual nominal
rate of interest is less than the coupon rate. In this case, the annual nominal rate of
interest is 3.01%.
NOM = 3.0089
C/Y = 2
[CPT] [EFF]
Retirement calculations
TVM calculations are very relevant in retirement planning. They can help
track capital accumulation and determine how much capital is required to
fund a future income stream, determine the appropriateness of the time
horizon over which the funds will be spent, and to support a variety of
other calculations important to retirement decisions. Retirement
calculations will be reviewed here for general understanding.
83
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Accumulations
Any retirement planning projection comprises two main phases: the saving
or accumulation phase and the dissaving or distribution phase. The
accumulation phase refers to the period during which an individual is
working and striving to build the value of his or her investments. The
distribution phase describes the period after the accumulation phase in
which retirees begin accessing and using their funds. TVM calculations play
a key role in both phases.
EXAMPLE 1
Mato, who has accumulated retirement savings of $41,000, would like to retire in 13
years. By that time, he hopes to have accumulated $100,000 in total retirement
savings. He estimates that he can earn an annual return of 2.8%, compounded
monthly. How much will Mato have to invest at the end of each month for the next 13
years to meet his $100,000 objective? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 2.8
PV = -41,000
FV = 100,000
Mode = END
If Mato invests $218.31 at the end of each month for 13 years, he will have the
$100,000 he hopes to accumulate for his retirement.
84
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
Erica would like to retire with sufficient capital to provide a monthly retirement income
of $1,500 at the end of each month. She anticipates that she will need the income for
25 years during retirement and can earn an annual rate of return of 5%, compounded
monthly. How much will Erica need to fund her retirement plan? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 5
PMT = 1,500
FV = 0
Mode = END
EXAMPLE 1
Jamie is about to retire and has accumulated $429,000 in an RRSP. She would like to
draw a retirement income of $3,000 at the beginning of each month for 16 years.
Jamie wants to know what annual nominal interest rate she needs to earn during
retirement to support her plan, assuming monthly compounding. (Disregard taxes.)
85
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
PV = -429,000
PMT = 3,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
If her retirement fund earns an annual nominal interest rate of 3.91%, compounded
monthly, Jamie will have sufficient capital to achieve her retirement goals.
EXAMPLE 2
Jack wants to have a $500,000 retirement fund when he retires in 8.5 years. At the
moment, he has $289,000 in his retirement account. He plans to contribute $750 at
the end of each month for the remaining 8.5 years that he is at work. Assuming that
Jack’s retirement account earns interest that compounds monthly, what annual
nominal rate of interest does he need to achieve to enable him to fund his retirement
goal? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
PV = -289,000
PMT = -750
FV = 500,000
MODE = END
86
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
If Jack’s retirement account earns a nominal annual return of 4.08% (or more),
compounded monthly, he will achieve his goal of accumulating $500,000.
EXAMPLE
Louise is approaching retirement age but is unsure whether she wants to retire. She
has a retirement account balance of $377,000, and she would like to create an
income stream of $2,500 at the end of each month. She anticipates an annual return
of 4.8%, compounded monthly. Based on these assumptions, how long will Louise’s
money last? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 4.8
PV = -377,000
PMT = 2,500
FV = 0
Mode = END
87
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Loan payments/repayments
TVM calculations are used frequently in loan calculations from a number of
different perspectives, including solving for the loan interest rate, loan
amount, loan payment and loan period.
In addition to the interest rate, other factors impact the size of required
payments, including the length of the repayment period (because larger
payments are necessary to pay back a loan over a shorter period) and the
size of the loan (because a larger loan over a similar repayment period
requires larger payments).
The following examples illustrate how TVM calculations play a key role in
loan calculations.
88
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
Harvey approaches a credit union for a $25,000 loan to finance his new car purchase.
The manager tells him that he will have to pay the debt off over five years and that his
payments will be $525, at the beginning of each month. What annual nominal interest
rate will Harvey pay, assuming monthly compounding?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (12 x 5)
PV = 25,000
PMT = -525
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
Harvey will pay an annual nominal interest rate of 9.85% for his car loan. Note that in
this example, the loan payment was due at the beginning of the month. However, in
real life, loans are most commonly calculated on a deferred payment schedule, which
means payments are due at the end of the month (mode = END).
89
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
Martin has $60,000 saved for a down payment towards a new boat. He needs to
borrow funds for the balance and anticipates an annual interest rate of 6%,
compounded monthly. Martin would like to pay off the debt over a five-year period and
feels he can afford payments of $2,000 at the end of each month. What is the
maximum loan amount Martin can afford to borrow, and what is the maximum amount
Martin can pay for the boat?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (5 x 12)
I/Y = 6
PMT = -2,000
FV = 0
Mode = END
90
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
Susan borrowed $19,100 from her sister for a period of 10.5 years. She promised to
pay annual interest of 7.7%, compounded monthly, and to make payments at the end
of each month. What is Susan’s monthly payment amount?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 7.7
PV = 19,100
FV = 0
Mode = END
91
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE
Tim has a car loan with $10,400 still outstanding, and he is paying 8% interest,
compounded monthly. He would like to double his monthly payments to $500. How
many months will it take for Tim to pay off the remaining balance of the loan? Assume
that Tim makes payments at the end of each month.
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
I/Y = 8
PV = 10,400
PMT = -500
FV = 0
Mode = END
If he doubles his monthly payments to $500, Tim has 22.47 monthly payments left.
92
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Leasing calculations
It is possible to perform TVM calculations from the perspective of the
lessee (the person who makes lease payments) or the lessor (the person
who receives lease payment). A lease is a loan for something of value
(land, a vehicle, equipment, etc.) for a period of time, with specific pre-
arranged periodic payments. Unless otherwise stated, lease payments are
generally due at the beginning of each payment period.
EXAMPLE
Laura leases dental equipment worth $50,000 from a finance company. The lease
runs for five years. She makes monthly payments of $930 at the beginning of each
month. In addition, she must make a $10,000 balloon payment at the end of the
lease. What annual nominal rate of interest is Laura paying on the lease?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 60 (12 x 5)
PV = 50,000
PMT = -930
FV = -10,000
Mode = BGN
93
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
If the nominal interest rate an investment earns does not exceed the
expected inflation rate, there is no real interest rate return. The following
formula expresses the real rate of return:
Real Rate of Return = (annual nominal rate of return – annual rate of inflation) ÷
or
94
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Thomas has an investment with a nominal interest rate of 4%, while the expected rate
of inflation is 2%. If inflation runs at 2%, what is Thomas’s real rate of return?
EXAMPLE 2
Casey was quite excited to see that she could obtain a 4.75% nominal interest rate on
the renewal of her investment. However, inflation was projected at 1.5% for the
upcoming period. If inflation remains as expected, what real rate of return will Casey
experience on her investment?
With an inflation rate of 1.5%, Casey’s real rate of return will be 3.2%.
To use the real rate of return in a TVM calculation, enter it as the interest
variable. Using the real rate of return effectively removes inflation from the
investment return.
95
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 3
Cheryl is quite wealthy, and she would like to set aside sufficient funds to help her
mother with long-term expenses. Cheryl would like to provide her mother with $20,000
in annual income for the next 25 years, payable at the beginning of each year, and
indexed for annual inflation of 1.5%. Assuming Cheryl can earn a return of 6% on her
investment, compounded annually, how much money does she need today to fund
the annual income, payable at the beginning of each year? (Disregard taxes.)
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 25
PMT = 20,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
Cheryl needs $311,843.39 to fund the desired annual income for her mother.
Note that the calculation of the real rate of return for the I/Y value was entered directly
into the TVM register. This allows the TVM function to use the maximum number of
floating decimal places, resulting in greater accuracy.
96
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The calculations use the marginal tax rate (MTR), which is the rate of tax
paid on the next dollar of income. This is not the same as an individual’s
actual tax rate or average tax rate. The formula to calculate the after-tax
rate of return is:
EXAMPLE
Blair has invested $100,000 in a non-registered interest-bearing investment that pays
an annual nominal interest rate of 5.5%, compounded annually. Blair’s marginal tax
rate is 42%. What is Blair’s after-tax rate of return?
97
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
What amount of after-tax income will Blair derive from this investment after one year?
After-tax income
Blair’s after-tax income from this investment will be $3,190 at the end of the first year.
or
In this formula, the annual nominal rate of return, annual rate of inflation
and MTR are expressed as decimals.
EXAMPLE 1
Herbert and Myra are working with their financial planner to develop a savings
program aligned with their personal retirement objectives. At retirement, they hope to
have sufficient non-registered savings to provide an annual after-tax income of
$60,000 for 25 years, indexed for annual inflation of 2%. If, during retirement, Herbert
and Myra can earn a before-tax annual return of 7%, compounded annually, and they
anticipate a 35% marginal tax rate, what savings amount do they need at the
98
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 25
PMT = 60,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
Herbert and Myra need savings of $1,133,099.15 to fund their current retirement plans.
EXAMPLE 2
Now assume all factors in the example above remain the same except the rate of
return assumption. If Herbert and Myra could earn 10% before tax, how would this
affect the required savings?
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
N = 25
PMT = 60,000
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
Increasing the rate of return to 10% decreases the required savings to $937,438.75,
which is $195,660.40, or 17%, less than $1,133,099.15.
99
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Lawrence is considering buying an investment that never matures but pays $1,000 at
the end of each month in perpetuity. The prevailing market nominal interest rate is
8%, compounded monthly. What should the market price of the security be?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 999,999,999
I/Y = 8
PMT = 1,000
FV = 0
Mode = END
The market price of the security should be $150,000. Note that using the formula
above produces the same result:
= 150,000
100
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
Harold’s brother owes him $1,000. However, instead of repaying the entire $1,000,
Harold’s brother promises to repay him $5 at the beginning of each month for the rest
of his life. The prevailing market nominal interest rate is 5.5%, compounded monthly.
What is the present value of this perpetual?
P/Y = 12
C/Y = 12
N = 999,999,999
I/Y = 5.5
PMT = 5
FV = 0
Mode = BGN
The value of this perpetual is $1,095.91, which is more than the $1,000 Harold’s
brother currently owes him. Again, using the formula above produces the same result:
= 1,095.91
101
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
the Cash Flow application using the CF key — the second key in the
second row from the top.
The guideline is that investments make financial sense only if they have a
positive NPV; that is, only if the net present value of the future revenue
streams exceeds the original investment. In essence, a positive NPV is an
indication that a project has strong enough cash flow to pay the expected
return to the investors who have put up the capital, and also have some
left over that represents an increase in wealth for those investors.
102
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
NPV calculations, the “i” factor represents not merely interest (returns on
debt), but also economic returns (returns on debt and equity). For this
reason, NPV calculations and internal rate of return (IRR) calculations
(discussed later in this module) use the words “discount factor,” instead of
“interest.”
The NPV calculation uses the NPV key — the middle key in the second
row from the top. It is important to remember to input cash outflows as
negative amounts and cash inflows as positive amounts when calculating
NPV.
103
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Carmen is considering investing $12,000 in Project ABC, which will generate cash
flows as follows:
Year 1 -$20,000
Year 2 -$1,000
Year 3 $15,000
Year 4 $27,000
Year 5 $32,000
Using a discount factor of 13%, what is the net present value of this investment?
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
CF0 = -12,000
CF1 = -20,000
CF2 = -1,000
CF3 = 15,000
CF4 = 27,000
CF5 = 32,000
I = 13
104
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Keystrokes:
[CE/C]
[CF]
12,000 [+/-] [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for the initial investment, CF0)
[down arrow]
20,000 [+/-] [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 1, C01)
1,000 [+/-] [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 2, C02)
15,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 3, C03)
27,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 4, C04)
32,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 5, C05)
[NPV]
[down arrow]
[CPT]
The net present value of this project is a positive $13,841.41, which means Carmen
should invest in the project.
EXAMPLE 2
Sandra is considering investing in two different projects. Project Fireside requires an
initial investment of $50,000, while Project Logic requires an initial investment of
$125,000. The table outlines the cash flows for the two projects.
Fireside Logic
Using a discount rate of 10%, which of the two projects offers a stronger financial
case for investment?
106
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Fireside
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
CF0 = -50,000
CF1 = 5,000
CF2 = 15,000
CF3 = 25,000
CF4 = 30,000
I = 10
Logic
P/Y = 1
C/Y = 1
CF0 = -125,000
CF1 = -5,000
CF2 = 50,000
CF3 = 60,000
CF4 = 65,000
I = 10
Fireside has a net present value of $6,215.42 and Logic has a net present value of
$1,251.26. Based on the NPV of each project, Fireside is the better investment.
107
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The IRR calculation takes a future cash flow stream and determines what
specific discount factor applied to it would make the present value (PV)
amount exactly equal to the original investment — which would mean the
NPV equals zero. So, instead of using a target cost of capital as the
discount rate, as in NPV calculations, IRR calculations solve for the
discount rate that makes NPV equal zero. In fact, the IRR is the discount
rate that makes NPV equal zero. The calculation burden when solving for
the discount factor in this situation is non-trivial. For this reason,
calculators or spreadsheets are essential to calculate the IRR.
When calculating an IRR, input cash flow numbers in exactly the same
way as you did for the NPV calculation. Then, instead of pressing [NPV]
as the last key, press [IRR].
108
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
An earlier example calculated the net present value of two different projects: Fireside
and Logic. Using the same cash flow information, calculate the internal rate of return
for each of these projects.
Fireside
P/Y = 1
CF0 = -50,000
CF1 = 5,000
CF2 = 15,000
CF3 = 25,000
CF4 = 30,000
Keystrokes:
CE/C
CF
50,000 [+/-] [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for the initial investment, CF0)
[down arrow]
5,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 1, C01)
15,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 2, C02)
109
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
25,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 3, C03)
30,000 [ENTER] (enters the cash flow amount for year 4, C04)
[IRR]
[CPT]
Logic
P/Y = 1
CF0 = -125,000
CF1 = -5,000
CF2 = 50,000
CF3 = 60,000
CF4 = 65,000
In the earlier NPV calculation, the cost of capital was assumed to be 10%. In this
example, the IRR for the Fireside project is 14.44%, and the IRR for the Logic project
is 10.35%. In both cases, the IRR is greater than the cost of capital (10%), which
indicates that both projects are economically viable.
110
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Summary of formulas
Simple Interest = (Amount Invested) x (Interest Charged per Year) = Total Interest
or
PV = Amt ÷ (1 + i)n
or
FV = Amt x (1 + i)n
or
PV = A x ((1 – (1 + i)-n) ÷ i)
111
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
or
FV = A x ((1 + i)n – 1) ÷ i
Real Rate of Return = (Annual Nominal Rate of Return – Annual Rate of Inflation) ÷
or
or
112
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
client, combined with materials requested from the client, can be effective
ways to collect the data needed to create financial statements.
Money management
The concept of money management is an integral part of financial
planning, because financial goals can only be established on solid ground if
there are sufficient resources to support the planned outcome. Financial
goals can be optimized by using money management strategies, and the
concept of money management ties closely to that of debt management.
Budgeting process
Personal money management involves prioritizing the cash flows in and
out of a family unit in an effort to achieve desired financial goals. This can
be accomplished through budgeting, which involves advanced planning for
a systematic allocation of net income across various expenditures.
114
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Income
A summary of income from all sources helps to derive the total amount of
money available to support expenditures. An examination of the timing of
cash inflows is an important part of this analysis. Make a distinction
between regular inflows of cash (e.g., monthly salary) and lump-sum
amounts received on an infrequent basis (e.g., dividend income). The
allocation of income across the monthly cash flow statement should reflect
variance in the timing of cash inflows.
Expenses
Similar to income, monthly projections should incorporate the timing of
expenses and recognize regular and lump-sum amounts. The types of
expenses will differ by family, but what’s important is to ensure that the
monthly cash flow statement captures and accounts for all expenses as
completely as possible. The budgeting exercise requires estimates, as
information is not always known in advance. However, planners should
base estimates on all realistic information available when they create a
projection. As new information arrives, planners can integrate it through a
revision process.
115
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Emergency fund
Everyone experiences an unexpected need for cash at some point;
however, some experience this more often than others. An emergency
fund aims to provide sufficient, readily accessible, liquid funds. In the past,
a standard rule of thumb was that a family should have an amount equal
to three to six months of living expenses set aside in a liquid asset —
money available to finance emergency needs. Expenses that should be
included in the calculation are non-discretionary expenses, including both
fixed (rent or mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance premiums,
etc.) and variable (groceries, transportation, clothing, etc.) expenses.
Discretionary expenses such as vacations, entertainment, and dining out
should not be included when calculating emergency fund requirements.
Every family should still have some available funds they can access easily
(e.g., a savings account, Canada Savings Bond or modest-sized cashable
Guaranteed Investment Certificate) in a financial emergency. However, the
amount will vary depending on the family’s other easily accessible
resources.
116
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Assets
Assets are items of monetary value purchased based on the financial
decisions of a person over time. Assets appear in the top portion of a
personal net worth statement, and may include:
Car
Home
Cottage
Marketable securities
Cash
Insurance policies
117
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Mutual funds
RRSP balances
Stock portfolio
The bottom half of the personal net worth statement has two major
sections that are similar to those on a company’s balance sheet statement:
liabilities and equity.
118
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Liabilities
Liabilities represent financial obligations: amounts of money that must be
paid or repaid. In other words, liabilities are amounts a person owes, and
may include:
Mortgage
Car loan
Equity
The equity section on a personal net worth statement is often referred to
simply as “net worth.” It looks different than that of a company because
there is no share capital. In the case of either a company or an individual,
the difference between the market value of assets and the amount of
financing in place equals the owner’s equity, or net worth.
periodic net worth calculation can also highlight areas for improvement.
Let’s look at an example of how an individual’s net worth can change from
one year to the next.
EXAMPLE 1
In Year 1, Tony owns a house worth $380,000, with a $220,000 mortgage. He has a
car worth $19,000 that he owns outright. Tony has a balance of $2,300 in his savings
account, and $950 in his chequing account. His line of credit has a limit of $30,000
and a balance of $8,500. Tony has a MasterCard with a $5,000 limit and a balance of
$0, and a Visa with a limit of $7,500 and a balance of $1,300. The book value of
Tony’s RRSP is $23,500, and its current market value is $27,000. He also has $5,000
in a non-registered GIC. Calculate Tony’s net worth.
120
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Tony Smith
($)
Assets
Liquid Assets
GICs 5,000
Property Assets
Vehicle 19,000
Long-term Assets
RRSPs/RRIFs 27,000
Liabilities
Mortgage 220,000
Now let’s assume that one year has passed and Tony recalculates his net worth.
Some liabilities have increased and some assets have decreased, and yet Tony’s net
worth still shows an overall increase.
121
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Tony Smith
($)
Assets
Liquid Assets
GICs 5,200
Property Assets
Vehicle 17,000
Long-term Assets
RRSPs/RRIFs 28,500
Liabilities
Mortgage 210,000
Tony’s net worth increased from $204,450 in Year 1 to $230,600 in Year 2. In order
words, Tony’s net worth increased by $26,150.
122
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
A personal net worth statement prepared for Sharon and Max West shows that,
together, the Wests have accumulated assets of $566,600, with $244,400 in liabilities.
Since net worth equals assets ($566,600) minus liabilities ($244,400), the Wests have
a net worth of $322,200 — the number that appears at the bottom of the net worth
statement.
On the Wests’ personal net worth statement, the assets are divided into categories:
non-registered, registered, other and personal. While this categorization is not
essential, it makes the net worth statement easier to read and update as
circumstances change.
123
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Assets
Non-registered Assets
Bonds
Real Estate
Registered Assets
Other Assets
Business Equity
124
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Personal Assets
Liabilities
Business Loan
Note: Assets at market value could be subject to income tax consequences not
accounted for in this net worth statement.
125
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Cash flow
Unlike a net worth statement, which is an overview of financial health
calculated at a single point in time, a cash flow statement is a detailed
description of cash inflows and outflows over a stated period.
Bank and credit card statements sometimes surprise us when we see the
amount of money we’ve spent. That’s because, without proper accounting
or recordkeeping, it’s easy to lose track of expenses. The most effective
way to address this problem is to construct a personal cash flow
statement.
Salary
Rental income
Royalties
Groceries
Mortgage or rent
Clothing
Vacations
A positive net cash flow results from having more cash inflows than
outflows — that is, making more than you spend. If cash outflows exceed
inflows, net cash flow is negative.
As with net worth statements, the true value in preparing a cash flow
statement emerges when you perform the calculation at regular intervals
over time. This can highlight areas of excess spending and areas for
improvement, as well as identifying times when there are cash surpluses,
which can be used for investing or other purposes.
127
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 1
Jenna works as an associate advisor at an investment management firm, where she
has an after-tax annual income of $48,000. Jenna recently purchased a condo, and
her mortgage is $230,000. Her monthly mortgage payment is $1,100, and the monthly
condo fee is $230. Every month, she spends about $120 for her cable and internet
package, $90 for electricity and $85 for her cell phone. Jenna spends roughly $100
per week on groceries, and another $100 per week at restaurants. Her gym
membership costs $55 per month, and her yoga classes cost $75 per month. Jenna
also recently purchased a new car, and she has a car loan. Her car payment is $290
per month, and she spends an additional $150 per month on gas and $85 per month
for auto insurance. Construct a cash flow statement for Jenna.
128
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Amount
($)
Cash Inflows
Income 4,000
Cash Outflows
Mortgage 1,100
Cable/Internet 120
Electricity 90
Phone 85
Groceries 433.33
Car Insurance 85
Gym Membership 55
Yoga Classes 75
129
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
EXAMPLE 2
A sample cash flow statement for Sharon and Max West demonstrates that this type
of statement normally begins with all income items grouped together, followed by all
expenses. In this case, money allocated to registered savings is in a separate
category. The difference between inflows (income items) and outflows (expenses and
savings) is labelled unallocated cash flow. Similar to net worth statements, cash flow
statements normally show information at a family unit level, as well as individually. In
contrast to businesses, individuals are less concerned with formal accrual accounting
and depreciation treatment.
The Wests had income of $107,200 during 2019, from a variety of sources that
included salary for both Max and Sharon, self-employment earnings for Sharon, and
dividend and interest income for Max.
Expenses for the West family totalled $76,800, including outflows for mortgage
payments, property taxes, expenses associated with the family automobiles, and a
range of other expenses.
130
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Max Total
Sharon ($)
($) ($)
Income
Expenses
131
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
132
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Note that the calculation for the PSR uses net income, not gross income.
That is, it uses the amount of income actually received, after income tax
deductions, Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Employment Insurance (EI)
deductions, Registered Pension Plan (RPP) contributions, union dues and
any other deductions from gross pay.
EXAMPLE
Corinne has a gross income of $60,000 per year, or $5,000 per month. After taxes
and deductions, her net monthly pay is $3,450. Corinne saves $100 per month to her
Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA). Calculate Corinne’s personal savings rate.
133
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
134
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Importance of standardization
For financial statements to be useful, they have to be meaningful.
Safeguarding the meaningfulness of financial reports is more complicated
than one might expect. The desired goal is that readers should be able to
determine the financial position of two companies merely by comparing
their financial statements. However, comparisons are meaningless if
Company A believes certain financial metrics are important and has strong
feelings about the way those metrics are calculated, while Company B uses
different metrics or calculates the same metrics differently. For this
reason, standardization is a very important principle in financial accounting
and reporting.
Accounting concepts
Readers of corporate financial statements expect them to be prepared
according to well-established accounting principles. Without going into
great detail, an example of these principles is the use of accrual accounting
instead of simple cash accounting. Another example is customarily
reporting assets at historical costs rather than at fair market value, and
135
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
closely matching expenses with revenue. Although many take these and
other similar principles for granted, they form the cornerstone of
standardized reporting. These principles are important to recognize
because, in spite of their contribution to standardization, they also
contribute to the very real limitations of financial analysis — a topic we will
explore in the discussion of financial ratios.
Statement selection
Typically, all the financial information of a company is compiled into three
financial statements that reflect the company’s financial position:
Balance sheet
Income statement
The nature of these statements stays the same for individuals, but in
practice personal financial statements are usually called:
Statement form
Careful observation of multiple financial statements reveals another
important element of standardization: the balance sheets and income
statements of different companies, even in different industries, have many
136
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
of the same categories. On the balance sheet, for example, every company
has categories for cash, marketable securities, accounts receivable, capital
or fixed assets, and more. Furthermore, not only will each company have
an accounts receivable amount, but readers can have confidence it was
calculated according to similar accounting principles.
Accounting principles
Over the years, accountants have developed hundreds of accounting rules
to create meaningful and standardized corporate financial statements. The
two methods of accounting used in Canada are Generally Accepted
Accounting Principles (GAAP) and International Financial Reporting
Standards (IFRS). These provisions, in combination with the broader
accounting principles described above, contain the guidelines accountants
use to measure, process and communicate financial information. They help
accountants prepare financial statements that are understandable,
comparable, relevant and consistent.
137
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
acceptable set of accounting standards for PAEs. While the CRA does not
specify that financial statements must be prepared following any particular
type of accounting principles or standards, the AcSB requires PAEs to use
IFRS in the preparation of all interim and annual financial statements.
While some private companies still use GAAP, most also have the option to
adopt IFRS for financial statement preparation.
Note that neither IFRS nor GAAP apply to personal financial statements.
138
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
From a financial analysis perspective, the balance sheet reflects the status
of a company in terms of three major activities: investing, financing and
operating.
If assets reflect “what” the organization spent its money on, then liabilities
and owner’s equity reflect “where” the organization got the money to
acquire the assets. This reflects the fact that the investment made in
assets must be financed either by borrowing the money (liability section)
or using the owner’s own money (owner’s equity section). Linking
investments with financing decisions makes it evident why assets must
equal liabilities and owner’s equity, or why a balance sheet must balance:
the investments are exactly offset by the financing used to acquire them.
The owner’s equity section of a balance sheet includes share capital (the
money invested by owners in the business) and retained earnings (the
cumulative money earned by the company over the years that has not yet
been distributed to shareholders).
1
Hughes, John, and Fisher, Alex. “Reading Financial Statements: What Do I Need to
Know?” Chartered Professional Accountants Canada, www.cpacanada.ca/en/business-and-
accounting-resources/financial-and-non-financial-reporting/international-financial-
reporting-standards-ifrs/publications/reading-financial-statements-what-do-i-need-to-
know-faq (accessed May 2, 2019)
139
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The difference in the RE account from one year to the next year is the net
income of the firm minus any dividends paid. The RE account, especially in
firms that pay no dividends, is a running total of the cumulative total
profitability of the firm.
Intuitively, it’s clear that one must calculate a balance sheet as of one
specific calendar date. While it will balance on any day it is calculated, the
specific accounts may vary considerably from one day to the next. It is,
therefore, appropriate to talk about balance sheet items and the financial
ratios derived from them as of the one specific calendar date for which
they were prepared — usually, the end of an accounting period.
The balance sheet, in this case, captures information at two points in time: December
31, 2018, and December 31, 2019. This is helpful for comparison purposes. Apex’s
total assets increased by $296,880 ($1,345,080 – $1,048,200) between December
31, 2018, and December 31, 2019.
The retained earnings at December 31, 2018, equaled $319,800, a number that
represents the cumulative amount Apex earned over the years that it had not yet
distributed to shareholders. Shareholders had invested a total of $132,000 in Apex
($12,000 in common shares + $120,000 in preferred shares).
The retained earnings of $596,160 at December 31, 2019, were $276,360 higher than
at December 31, 2018 ($596,160 – $319,800 = $276,360).
140
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Notice that the ending retained earnings balance of $596,160 comprises 2018’s end-
of-year retained earnings of $319,800 plus 2019’s net income of $288,360 minus the
$12,000 of dividends paid.
Income statement
The income statement summarizes revenue and expenses and calculates
the net income or net loss of a company or individual for a period of time,
such as a year or a month. The income statement may also be called a
statement of earnings or profit and loss statement.
A company’s net income or net loss is its sales revenue minus its
expenses. Sales revenue represents the value of the goods or services the
company has sold to its customers. Expenses represent the costs the
company incurred to generate the sales revenue. Appendix 2 shows Apex
Manufacturing’s income statement for the year ended December 31, 2019.
141
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
The cost of goods sold was $567,240. Subtracted from sales of $1,705,680, that left
Apex with a gross profit of $1,138,440.
While sales increased 13.3% from one year to the next, net income increased by only
1.6% ((288,360 – 283,800) ÷ 283,800 = 1.6%).
2 Ibid.
142
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Each account on the income statement has its own set of issues to resolve
using carefully thought-out accounting policies.
The goal of the cash flow statement is to track and analyze the changes
that occur in a single balance sheet account — the cash account — from
one period to the next. Appendix 3 shows Apex’s cash flow statement for
the year ending December 31, 2019, with a comparison for the year
ending December 31, 2018.
The cash flow statement reviews the cash impact of the three major
activities of the firm: investing, financing and operating. Conceptually,
think about the statement as changes in cash caused by:
143
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Note that the cash at the end of the year should be equal to the cash on
the balance sheet.
Notes:
1
From cash account on 2018 balance sheet.
2
Balances with cash account on 2019 balance sheet.
144
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
One last detail: the cash flow statement looks at a company’s cash
changes during the period on a comprehensive basis, factoring in the
impact of operations, investments and financing on the ending cash
position. However, readers of financial statements are often interested in
understanding how much cash the company generates purely from
operations, or the “cash earnings” of a business. They want to know how
much cash a business generates from operations before including interest,
taxes and non-cash charges. This calculation is referred to as EBITDA
(earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization), and it is
becoming increasingly popular among financial analysts and the financial
press as a metric for comparing different companies on a cash flow basis.
145
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Additional considerations
So that a company’s financial statements are reliable and meaningful, they
are compiled, reviewed and audited according to specific standards.
Compiled
Compiling does not provide any assurance with respect to the financial
statements. When engaged to compile financial statements, the
practitioner receives information from the client and compiles it in the form
of financial statements. The practitioner does not perform any other
procedures on the financial statements. Furthermore, the form of the
financial statements does not necessarily have to comply with a financial
reporting framework.
146
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Reviewed
Reviewing provides some assurance, but less than auditing. When engaged
to review financial statements, the practitioner provides limited assurance
primarily by performing inquiry and analytical procedures, unless he or she
becomes aware of a matter that may indicate the financial statements
have material misstatements. When this happens, the practitioner designs
and performs additional procedures based on the situation. Reviewed
financial statements are prepared in accordance with a financial reporting
framework (e.g., IFRS or Canadian Accounting Standards for Private
Enterprises (ASPE)), and the practitioner applies the concept of materiality
when evaluating misstatements and forming a conclusion.
Audited
Audited financial statements provide readers with the highest level of
assurance. However, this assurance is not absolute. The auditor’s
conclusion indicates whether the financial statements are prepared
materially in accordance with the respective financial reporting framework
(e.g., IFRS or ASPE). When performing their work, auditors obtain
reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. As in a review, auditors
apply the concept of materiality when planning and executing their audit to
ensure that any misstatements identified, individually or in aggregate, are
not material. The materiality the auditor applies depends on the needs of
those who will use the financial statements and is subject to the auditor’s
judgement.
147
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Accompanying reports
One of the following three reports may accompany an organization’s
financial statements.
148
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Auditor’s report
An auditor’s report accompanies audited financial statements. It
communicates the auditor’s conclusion, providing the auditor’s opinion as
to whether the financial statements are presented in all material respects
in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework (e.g., IFRS
or ASPE). If the auditor is unable to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence
to form an opinion, he or she will provide a modified opinion rather than an
unmodified opinion.
The auditor’s report includes both the auditor’s opinion and the basis for
that opinion. Additionally, it includes information on the entity’s going
concern (see next section), management’s and the auditor’s
responsibilities with respect to the financial statements, and any other key
audit matters or other information the auditor determines must be
communicated.
Business valuation
Many different methods and techniques help to determine how much a
company is worth. Here are some of the most common.
Going concern
The going concern method determines the value of a business based on
the stream of cash flow it is capable of producing in the future. A business
that can generate higher cash flows in the future is worth more today. A
key characteristic of this approach is that it uses past revenues to
extrapolate and predict future revenues.
149
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Liquidation
Analysts often use the liquidation approach for businesses facing solvency
issues and being sold to cover outstanding debts to creditors. This method
assigns values to all assets, such as land, facilities, inventory and accounts
receivable. Note that in times of duress and hardship, assets often sell for
less than their fair market value. In addition, the liquidation value does not
include intangible assets, such as goodwill.
Market value
For publicly traded companies, the market generally refers to market value
— also known as market capitalization — calculated by multiplying the
current share price by the number of shares outstanding. For example, if a
firm has a share price of $5.25 and two million shares outstanding, the
market value of the firm is $5.25 x 2,000,000 = $10,500,000. This means
the company has a market value of $10.5 million.
150
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Financial ratios
Financial statements capture a wide range of financial information about a
company. However, it is difficult for analysts to draw conclusions about a
company’s performance based on a specific line on a statement, unless
they can relate that number to other reported numbers in a meaningful
way. This is why analysts use financial ratios when examining a company’s
financial statements.
For example, assume that a company reports a net income of $100,000 for
its fiscal year. Is that a good or bad result? Has management used its
assets effectively? How well has the company managed pricing and
merchandising? By itself, the $100,000 reported net income does not tell
an outside observer very much about the performance of the company.
151
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Liquidity
Leverage/debt
Profitability
Throughout this section, the financial ratio examples use information from
the financial statements for two companies: Apex Manufacturing and
Compass Retail. We will point out distinctions that affect the ratios for
manufacturing firms and retail firms. To highlight differences in the ratios,
the financial statements assume that both companies have exactly the
same revenue in each of the two years. Find complete sets of financial
statements for Apex Manufacturing and Compass Retail in the Appendices:
152
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Liquidity ratios
Liquidity ratios measure a company’s ability to pay its current debts or
obligations. Companies are considered to have good liquidity, or to be
strong in terms of solvency, when they have sufficient cash or near-cash
assets on hand to meet their short-term financial liabilities. Creditors have
a special interest in liquidity ratios, but they are useful to anyone with an
interest in determining the overall liquidity of a firm.
Current ratio
The most widely used liquidity ratio is the current ratio, calculated as:
The major asset categories in the asset portion of the current ratio are:
Cash
Accounts receivable
Inventory
The current ratio’s rationale is that all of these assets will be converted
into cash (or already are cash) during the normal business cycle.
Therefore, they give an indication of how much cash a company could
generate, if necessary, in the short term.
153
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
industry. With a current ratio of two, a company could liquidate 50% of its
current assets and still meet its short-term financial obligations.
The current ratio improved from 2018 to 2019, but is still below an “ideal” of two. By
themselves, these ratios would not be cause for concern.
In both years, Compass has a stronger current ratio than Apex. It’s tempting to
conclude that Compass is more solvent and has stronger liquidity than Apex.
However, as a retailer, most of Compass’s current assets are tied up in inventory.
This underscores why it is important to avoid jumping to conclusions about liquidity
without first looking at supporting ratios, such as the quick ratio.
154
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Quick ratio
Analysts calculate the quick ratio, often called the acid test, to determine a
company’s ability to meet its current financial liabilities using current
assets other than inventory. It is a more conservative current ratio in that
it recognizes an outsider may find it difficult to gauge the liquidity of
inventory on hand. Instead of making assumptions about the saleability of
inventory that may or may not reflect reality, the quick ratio simply
ignores the inventory number.
Because it removes inventory from the calculation, the quick ratio will be
smaller than the current ratio. For a company that holds inventory, a quick
ratio is considered strong if it is greater than one.
Looking at the current ratio or quick ratio in isolation may indicate that a
company has serious problems. However, analysts generally also take into
consideration these ratios for the same company over multiple periods, or
these ratios for competitors in the same industry during the same period,
to assess the financial health of a company.
Apex’s quick ratio is quite strong in both years. For example, in 2019 the value and
saleability of Apex’s inventory would not be a serious factor in determining liquidity
because of the size of the safety margin (quick ratio > 1).
155
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Compass’s quick ratio is much lower than Apex’s. This is typical in the financial
reports of retailers that sell their products primarily for cash; however, a quick ratio of
less than 0.5 suggests it would be useful to examine an activity ratio to help determine
the quality and saleability of the inventory. Compass clearly has significant resources
tied up in inventory. Whether the investment is too much, or whether it acquired
products that will not sell, can become clearer by calculating additional ratios.
Working capital
Working capital is necessary for all companies that must either extend
credit to their customers or finance the direct inputs required to build or
buy the products they sell. In contrast, a company that bills out service
personnel on an hourly basis, and gets paid in cash immediately, would
have very low working capital requirements.
The amount of working capital required for a given business can vary
greatly depending on seasonal factors, industry specifics and the stage of
the business cycle. One thing that companies sometimes overlook is the
need to increase working capital as the company grows.
156
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
157
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Debt-to-equity ratio
The debt-to-equity ratio is one of the most commonly used metrics for
assessing financial leverage, calculated as:
Investors are also interested in the debt-to-equity ratio. They use it to help
assess the risk of investing in the common shares of the company. All
158
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
other things being equal, the more financial leverage a company uses, the
riskier the common shares are and the higher the financial return common
shareholders expect.
The numbers used for both the numerator and denominator of the debt-to-
equity ratio change depending on the interested party’s perspective. For
example, do preferred shares belong in either the numerator or
denominator of the ratio? It depends on your perspective. Senior secured
lenders might view preferred shares as equity since they rank below senior
debt and, therefore, form part of the “cushion” available to lenders to
satisfy or settle their debt. For this reason, a senior lender may include
preferred shares in the denominator. On the other hand, common
shareholders, who rank below preferred shareholders, may view preferred
shares as “debt” since they have to be satisfied in whole before any money
accrues to common shareholders following a company’s dissolution.
Therefore, common shareholders may include preferred shares in the
numerator. In financial analysis, perspective is everything.
159
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
There is a fairly significant change in this ratio from 2018 to 2019, with 2019 having
the more favourable number. The calculation shows that the proportion of total debt to
shareholder equity decreased, which creditors view positively.
Compass’s debt-to-equity ratio is much lower than Apex’s because Compass has no
long-term debt.
Debt-to-asset ratio
The debt-to-asset ratio derives from the debt-to-equity ratio and has some
of the same uses, but it expresses the leverage of the company differently.
The debt-to-asset ratio calculation is:
160
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
These are fairly conservative debt-to-asset ratios, for both years. It is an open
question whether Apex could apply more financial leverage to increase shareholder
returns. Part of the answer depends on the degree of operating leverage currently in
place. Risks increase when companies achieve operating leverage through
aggressive debt financing. One positive sign is that the ratio decreased year over
year, which means creditors now have more of a cushion of equity support to protect
their debt investment in Apex.
161
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Interest coverage
Interest coverage, also called the times-interest-earned ratio, measures
the extent to which earnings can decline without impacting the company’s
ability to meet its debt service obligations. In other words, it measures the
extent to which the company’s operating income covers its interest
expense. The times-interest-earned ratio calculation is:
Times-Interest-Earned Ratio =
* Note that this specific item may not appear on an income statement; to calculate it,
find net income and add back interest and taxes.
Creditors use the times-interest-earned ratio to assess risk. The closer the
ratio is to one, the higher the risk of default. This ratio, or one very similar
to it, is often incorporated into the debt covenants a lender negotiates with
a borrower when negotiating a debt facility. If the borrower reports a
times-interest-earned ratio that does not meet the terms of the pre-
negotiated covenant, this triggers remedies that may include the borrower
requiring additional security, charging a higher interest rate or declaring an
outright deemed default of the loan.
While different creditors may set different appropriate thresholds for the
times-interest-earned ratio, almost all are interested in how this ratio
changes over time. A steadily decreasing times-interest-earned ratio can
be an early warning sign of substantial problems. This ratio often serves as
a barometer of excessive financial leverage for outside observers. As long
as it falls within a pre-arranged “safety range,” creditors tend to remain
confident of a company’s ability to service its debt.
162
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
This is one area where there would be no concern for Apex’s lenders. The amount of
net income available to service the debt obligations of the organization is very strong
in both years. The more volatile Apex’s income becomes, the smaller the margin of
safety for lenders, and the larger this ratio needs to be for lenders to feel comfortable.
163
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Profitability ratios
Profit margins measure how much a company earns in relation to its
overall sales. Generally, a company with a higher profit margin than its
competitors is more efficient. The three profit margin ratios are gross profit
margin, operating profit margin and net profit margin. All three compare a
profit figure to the overall revenue or sales number.
The gross profit margin measures how much of each sales dollar the
company uses to finance the direct inputs required to manufacture or
merchandise the product it sells. If the company provides services instead
of products, substitute the “cost of revenue or direct expenses” for the
“cost of goods sold” and calculate the ratio in the same way.
164
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
On the other hand, commodity producers tend to have the lowest gross
profit margins. A large proportion of the selling price of a barrel of refined
oil is required to cover the direct input costs, and this translates into a
lower gross profit margin for the oil refinery industry as a whole. For this
reason, it is not useful to compare the gross profit margin of an oil refinery
firm with that of a pharmaceutical firm. Gross profit margins are most
useful when comparing companies within the same industry and when
analyzing the trend of a specific company over time.
Apex’s gross profit margin is fairly stable year over year, in the two-thirds range.
Extending this thought, many competitors may have similar direct material
input costs and be subject to similar direct labour costs. Where companies
can differ substantially is in the third component used to calculate the cost
of goods sold: production overhead. In this area, different production
volumes and different operating leverages can produce significantly
different gross profit margins. For this reason, it is always necessary to use
care when analyzing the gross profit margin of a company.
That said, financial analysts generally expect that a retailer will have lower
gross profit margins than a manufacturer.
* If operating profit is not listed, look for the term earnings before interest and taxes
(EBIT).
166
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Interest
Taxes
While the gross profit margin looks at the efficiency associated with direct
production costs — direct materials, direct labour and production overhead
— the operating profit margin broadens the metric to include all operating
costs. The operating profit margin looks at the business results
independent of the non-operating decisions the company makes.
167
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
As might be expected, Compass has lower operating profit margins than Apex. The
operating profit margin of a retailer depends on what part of the market it serves.
Retailers in the premium end of the market tend to have higher operating profit
margins, while discount retailers tend to have lower operating profit margins.
However, lower volume often accompanies higher operating profit margins in the
premium end of the market.
* If net profit is not listed, look for the term net income.
Net profit margin considers the firm’s results as a whole for the given
accounting period, whereas the operating profit margin separates out the
non-operating factors, such as interest, taxes and foreign currency
accounting gains/losses, to focus exclusively on operating results. The net
profit margin of a company indicates how much of each sales dollar falls to
the bottom line in after-tax profit. This ratio is important to shareholders
and investors because it combines both operating and non-operating
factors to determine the final profit number of the company. Keep in mind
168
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
that this ratio is not useful for companies losing money, since they have no
profit.
Companies that have lots of transactions and strong sales volume often
operate with small net profit margins. It is not uncommon, for example, to
see net profit margins in the retail grocery industry averaging between 1%
and 5%. Companies with the highest net profit margins have usually been
successful in erecting substantial barriers to competition. Sometimes the
barriers are based on intellectual property ownership through copyright or
patents (as may be the case for a drug company), successfully
standardizing a market with proprietary corporate technology (as may be
the case for a major software provider) or exploiting low extraction costs
of natural resources (as may be the case for companies that source oil
from abroad).
Some industries have inherently lower net profit margin potential than
other industries. For example, it has been more than 100 years since air
travel began. In the intervening century, the collective net profit margin of
the entire airline industry has been very close to zero, even though
individual companies have managed at times to sustain positive net profit
margins. The airline industry has a very high ratio of fixed costs to total
costs, which makes net profit margins highly volatile as air travel demand
changes throughout a business cycle.
Apex’s net profit margins are in the high teens, respectable numbers for many
manufacturing companies. The net profit margin is of interest to shareholders
because it is the after-tax amount that accrues to them as common shareholders.
Several factors directly affect the return on common equity. The most
important is the amount of leverage a company employs. If the company’s
capital structure comprises primarily debt, the equity base is small so that
even modest profit generates a substantial return on common equity.
However, large amounts of debt also increase the debt service
requirements, making profit more difficult to achieve.
Apex’s return on common equity drops sharply from one year to the next. This ratio
parallels the drop in the debt-to-equity ratio. The net worth of the company is the sum
of the common share capital and the retained earnings. In the case of Apex, retained
earnings dominate the denominator of this ratio because the share capital amount is
small. Therefore, as the retained earnings of the company grow from year to year,
similar income creates only half the return on common equity, due to the steadily
increasing denominator. Sometimes, this ratio is calculated with only share capital in
the denominator, but that tends to distort the picture because investors are interested
not only in the return on share capital, but also in the return on the retained earnings
left in the business. The cautionary note in this analysis is that it is important to
171
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
examine all ratios carefully in conjunction with other ratios to draw appropriate and
valid conclusions. On its own, Apex’s drop in return on common equity could easily be
misinterpreted.
Compass shows a stable return on common equity from year to year. Compass had a
much larger cash infusion than Apex in terms of the original share capital of the
company ($120,000 versus $12,000). In addition, Compass showed stronger year-
over-year earnings growth. Supported by those two factors, the return on common
equity is identical from one year to the next.
The return on total assets for both years is in the low to mid twenties, within the
expected range for a manufacturer. This is one of the most important financial ratios
when it comes to evaluating management performance, especially in a divisional or
subsidiary business structure. By compensating divisional managers based on return
on total assets, it focuses management’s attention on maximizing income and
minimizing the investment needed to generate the income. The ratio decreases from
year to year for Apex, primarily because management has invested close to $200,000
in marketable securities. If that investment generates no income, then return on total
assets will decrease. For that reason, subsidiary managers in a real situation would
likely either invest that $200,000 in an income-producing asset or dividend that
amount back to the parent company to decrease the asset base.
173
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
A significant issue with this ratio is that it uses accounting numbers (book
value of total assets) to assess management performance, rather than
economic numbers (fair market value of assets) that may more closely
correspond to shareholder wealth creation.
Typically, retailers do not have the same investment in plant and equipment that
manufacturers such as Apex have, so their return on total assets is generally higher.
However, retailers often have a substantial investment in inventory on hand, which
also affects this ratio. Generally, a return on total assets of less than 20% is
considered low for a retailer and could suggest a build-up of inventory. That said,
accepted norms vary significantly from one industry to the next.
174
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
ASSETS
Current Assets
Capital Assets
LIABILITIES
Current Liabilities
175
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Long-Term
SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
176
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Operating Expenses
177
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Apex Manufacturing
Statement of Retained Earnings
for the years ended December 31, 2019 and 2018
178
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Operating Activities
Investing Activities
(162,960) (133,560)
Financing Activities
(6,120) (39,840)
179
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
180
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
ASSETS
Current Assets
Fixed Assets
LIABILITIES
Current Liabilities
181
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
SHAREHOLDERS’ EQUITY
182
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Operating Expenses
Compass Retail
Statement of Retained Earnings
for the years ended December 31, 2019 and 2018
183
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
Module 2: Financial Analysis
Operating Activities
Investing Activities
Financing Activities
184
Copyright © 2020 The Financial Advisors Association of Canada
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Financial Services professionals are expected to possess the knowledge that will allow them
to clearly document, analyze, project and present financial information related to an
individual’s goals, needs and priorities. Such knowledge will aid professionals to:
Financial Analysis is one of twelve modules in the Advocis Core Curriculum Program for CFP®
and QAFP™ Certification.