GAC Referencing Guide
GAC Referencing Guide
© ACT Education Solutions, Limited. All rights reserved. The material printed herein remains
the property of ACT Education Solutions, Limited and cannot be reproduced without prior
permission.
The author and publisher have made every attempt to ensure that the information contained
in this book is complete, accurate and true at the time of printing. You are invited to provide
feedback of any errors, omissions and suggestions for improvement.
Every attempt has been made to acknowledge copyright. However should any infringement
have occurred, the publisher invites copyright owners to contact the address below.
www.acteducationsolutions.com
Table of Contents
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................. I
OVERVIEW .............................................................................................................................................I
LEARNING OUTCOMES ...........................................................................................................................I
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .............................................................................................................................I
ICONS ................................................................................................................................................... II
THE GAC REFERENCING GUIDE ................................................................................................... 1
PART A OVERVIEW ........................................................................................................................ 1
PART B INTRODUCTION TO REFERENCING ..................................................................................... 2
PART C HOW TO USE SOURCES ..................................................................................................... 4
PART D IN-TEXT REFERENCING CONVENTIONS............................................................................ 10
PART E THE REFERENCE LIST...................................................................................................... 15
PART F REFERENCE LIST CONVENTIONS ..................................................................................... 16
PART G SAMPLE REFERENCE LIST ............................................................................................... 22
PART H PRACTISE AVOIDING PLAGIARISM .................................................................................. 23
PART I RECORDING INFORMATION FROM AN ARTICLE ............................................................... 31
WORKSHEET - RECORDING INFORMATION FROM AN ARTICLE ............................................................ 35
PART J ANSWERS AND EXPLANATIONS ...................................................................................... 37
APPENDIX 1 EXAMPLES OF IN-TEXT REFERENCES AND REFERENCE LIST…………………………… 43
THE GAC GUIDELINES FOR DEALING WITH PLAGIARISM FOR STUDENTS ...................... 48
GAC Referencing Guide
Introduction
Overview
Welcome to the GAC Referencing Guide.
The aim of this Referencing Guide is to introduce you to the conventions of an author-date
referencing system, specifically the Harvard style of referencing.
Learning Outcomes
After you have worked through this guide, you should be able to:
Acknowledgments
The Harvard style used in this manual is as advocated by Monash University Library. Details
are available from:
Citing and referencing: How to acknowledge your sources (2006), Library online tutorials,
Monash University Library [online]. Available at:
http://www.lib.monash.edu.au/tutorials/citing/ [Accessed10 March 2011]
The following sources have also been helpful in compiling this guide but note that they each
use a different modified form of the Harvard system:
Quote, Unquote – A Guide to Harvard Referencing (2009), Skills for Learning, Leeds
Metropolitan University [online]. Available at:
http://skillsforlearning.leedsmet.ac.uk [Accessed 10 March 2011
The University of Glamorgan Guide to Harvard Referencing (no date) Learning and
Corporate Services, University of Glamorgan [online]. Available at:
http://lcss.glam.ac.uk/documents/download/721, [Accessed March 10 2011]
The BU Guide to Citation in the Harvard Style (no date), Academic Support-Library and
Learning Support, Bournemouth University [online]. Available at:
http://www.bournemouth.ac.uk/library/citing_references/citing_refs_main.html
[Accessed 10 March 2011]
Icons
The following icons will be used as a visual aid throughout the Referencing Guide:
Icon Meaning
Information
Task
Review
Independent Study
Language focus
Part A Overview
Part B Introduction to Referencing
Part C How to Use Sources
Part D In-text Referencing Conventions
Part E The Reference List
Part F Reference List Conventions
Part G Sample Reference List
Part H Practise Avoiding Plagiarism
Part I Recording Information from an Article
Part J Answers and Explanations
Appendix 1 Examples of In-text Referencing and Reference List
Part A Overview
Overview This Referencing Guide introduces you to the conventions of the Harvard
style of referencing, which is an author-date referencing system.
Parts C and D deal with in-text referencing. Part C shows you how to use
sources for in-text referencing, and Part D lists the standard conventions
for in-text referencing.
Appendix 1 gives you examples of both in-text and reference list formats.
NOTE
Although this guide aims to be comprehensive, the referencing
conventions listed in Parts D and F are not exhaustive. If you need further
guidance on referencing, ask your teacher or visit the following websites:
http://www.lib.monash.edu.au/tutorials/citing/
http://skillsforlearning.leedsmet.ac.uk/
http://www.bournemouth.ac.uk/library/citing_references/citing_refs_main.
html
Caution – No Footnotes
Note that footnotes are NOT used in this referencing system.
LANGUAGE FOCUS
The term ‘a citation’ (verb: to cite) is often used for ‘a reference’ and has the
same meaning.
There are standard conventions for in-text referencing and for the Reference List
that you need to be familiar with and be able to use in your academic writing.
The conventions used in the GAC program are those of the Harvard system of
referencing as used by Monash University (Citing and referencing: How to
acknowledge your sources, 2006) and these are listed in Parts D and F.
Contents
C1 What is in-text referencing?
C2 How to write in-text references
C3 Emphasis on idea or author?
C4 What is plagiarism?
C5 Using direct quotations
a Short quotation
b Long quotation
c Useful phrases to use in quotations
C6 Grammar in direct quotations
C7 Paraphrasing a quotation
C8 Summarising a quotation
C9 Avoiding plagiarism
a Examples of plagiarism
b Acceptable paraphrase or summary
The purpose of in-text referencing is to direct your reader to the source you have
used, listed in full in your Reference List (see Part E).
Note that there are some exceptions to this. Full details of in-text referencing
conventions are given in Part D.
EITHER
To emphasise the idea, give the referencing details in brackets after the information
you are sourcing.
Example
Recent research indicates that insulin molecules may not be stable under certain
conditions (Smith 2003, p. 312).
OR
To emphasise the author, use the author’s surname in the flow of the text with the year
of publication and page number in brackets after the name.
Example
According to Smith (2003, p. 312), insulin molecules may not be stable under certain
conditions.
PUNCTUATION NOTE
In the examples above, note that
• in the first example, the period (full stop) comes after the brackets
• in both examples, the comma comes after the year of publication.
C4 What is plagiarism?
Plagiarism is:
• presenting other people’s ideas as if they were your own, or
• using someone else’s ideas without referencing them fully.
Every educational establishment has its policy on plagiarism. The GAC plagiarism
policy is attached in the Appendix to this guide.
Strategies for helping you to avoid plagiarism are given in section C9.
Direct quotations are often used to give definitions of terms, as in many of the
examples below.
a Short quotation
If the quotation is less than two lines long, it should be included in the body of
your writing, with the direct quote in double quotation marks. The quotation
should be inserted in the natural flow of the writing and has to fit grammatically
(see section C6 below).
Example
Plagiarism can be defined as “taking, using, and passing off as your own, the
ideas or words of another” (Citing and referencing: How to acknowledge your
sources, 2006).
b Long quotation
If the quotation is longer than two lines, the quotation should be indented, single-
spaced and in a smaller font size if possible. Quotation marks are not required.
Example
A balanced diet is one that is based on
starchy foods such as rice and pasta, with plenty of fruit and vegetables, some
protein-rich foods such as meat, fish and lentils, and some milk and dairy
foods (and not too much fat, salt or sugar).
(NHS Direct 2011)
Note that in the examples above, no page numbers can be given as these are
internet sources – see Part D.
Example
According to Greene (1999, p. 157), “there are many myths about marriage”,
Example
Greene (1999, p. 157) states that “there are many myths about marriage”,
Other phrases:
argues that ...
claims that ...
points out that ...
maintains that ...
emphasizes that ...
stresses that ...
You must NOT change the grammar of a direct quotation to fit your sentence –
on the contrary, you have to change your sentence to fit the grammar of your
quotation. If this proves difficult, it will probably be better to paraphrase the
quotation (see section C7).
C7 Paraphrasing a quotation
When you paraphrase a quotation, you keep the meaning of the original wording
but you say it in your own words. Examples are given below:
Example
Original text about the artist Delaunay:
or
Golding (1968, p. 149) argues that Delaunay was inspired by Picasso and
Braque’s revolutionary use of pictorial space.
It is important when paraphrasing that your version is not too close to the
original wording. If it is too similar to the original, this is a form of plagiarism,
even if you quote the source (see section C9 below).
C8 Summarising a quotation
A summary conveys the main points of the original text but in a shortened form.
As with paraphrasing, it is important that you summarise in your own words. If
your wording is too close to the original, this is a form of plagiarism, even if you
quote the source (see section C9 below).
C9 Avoiding plagiarism
When writing a paraphrase or a summary, it is important that you use your own
words. If your rewritten version is too close to the original wording, you will be
accused of plagiarism. Some examples are given below in section 9b.
Example
Original text about the artist Delaunay:
a Examples of plagiarism
1. Delaunay realized that Picasso and Braque had revolutionized pictorial
space (Golding 1968, p. 149).
This is plagiarism because all the words have been taken from the original (see
below) – this has not been said in the writer’s own words.
Delaunay ... realized ... that ... Picasso and Braque had revolutionized ...
pictorial space.
This is plagiarism because again, all the words have been taken from the original
(see below) even though the word order has been changed.
Delaunay ... realized ... that ...(by dismissing traditional perspective) ...
Picasso and Braque had revolutionized ... ideas of ... pictorial space.
This is still plagiarism because, although some words have been changed
(‘understood’ for ‘realized’, and ‘ignoring’ for ‘dismissing’) this is still too close
to the original (see below for comparison). Much of the wording is the same as
the original, and the word order is identical. This is NOT in the writer’s own
words.
This version has changed the wording and the structure sufficiently to be an
acceptable paraphrase or summary of the original text. It gives the same
information in the author’s own words.
TIPS
When you find quotations or information you want to use in your written work,
it is always a good idea to
- whether your paraphrase or summary has kept the same meaning as the
original (or has unintentionally changed the meaning!), and
• note full details of the source (author, year of publication, title of work,
etc. see Part F) and most importantly page number so that you can find it
again if you need to check any details later. These details are needed for
your reference list (see Parts E and F).
Review
For an in-text reference, you need to state:
• the author’s surname
• the year of publication of the source material
• the page number
There are some exceptions to this depending on your source material and these
differences are detailed in this section.
Tip
Although you need only the above details for in-text referencing, remember that
you will still need to keep a record of full bibliographical details for the
Reference List – see Part F.
D1 AUTHORS
a One author
When there is one author, give the author’s surname and the year of publication.
Example
Recent research indicates that insulin molecules may not be stable under these
conditions (Smith 2003, p. 312).
b Two authors
When there are two authors, give their names in the order given on the title page,
joined by ‘&’.
Example
Smoking was found to be the main cause of the problems experienced (Simpson
& White 2002, p. 145).
However, when the authors’ names are used in the body of the text, use ‘and’ to
join their names.
Example
Simpson and White (2002, p. 145) found that smoking was the main cause of the
problems experienced.
c Three authors
Follow the conventions for two authors, but with a comma between the first two
names.
Example
Recent research indicates that genetically modified crops can be harmful to
wildlife (Lilly, Simpson & White 2003, p. 96).
Example
Lilly, Simpson and White (2003, p. 96) claim that genetically modified crops
can be harmful to wildlife.
Example
If the authors are
Example
Robbins et al. (2004) identified forms of organisational behaviour ...
or
Forms of organisational behaviour have been identified (Robbins et al. 2004)…
Example
Research indicates that depression is brought on by stressful life events which
often involve losses, such as divorce or job loss (Brown & Harris 1978, cited in
Davison & Neale 2001).
The writer’s source in this example is Davison & Neale 2001, which quotes an
earlier source, Brown & Harris 1978, for this information.
When the author is unknown, use the title of the book or article. Note that this is
often the case with electronic sources, and also reference works such as
dictionaries and encyclopaedias.
Write the title in italics, followed by the year of publication and page number
where available.
Example
Vitamin B12 has a biochemical role in the synthesis of fatty acids in the myelin
sheath that surrounds nerve cells (Encyclopaedia Britannica 2002).
If the same author has written more than one work, distinguish between them by
the date of publication.
Example
Moore (1994, p. 134) states that ...........
Moore (1999, p. 56) argues that .............
When an author has published two or more works in the same year, put them in
alphabetical order of title in the Reference List (see Part F) and use ‘a’, ‘b’ and
‘c’ etc. to distinguish between them.
Example
Smith (2003a, p. 98) states that ......
According to Smith (2003b, p. 513) .....
If two authors have the same name and initial, distinguish between them by
giving the first name in full.
Example
George Brown (2001, p. 43) states that ............
Graham Brown (2001, p. 158) discovered that ......
D2 BOOKS
a Referencing a page
When referencing a quotation, or paraphrasing or summarising a quotation, you
must give the page number after the author’s surname and year of publication.
Example
Recent research indicates that insulin molecules may not be stable under these
conditions (Smith 2003, p. 312).
Note that a comma comes after the year of publication, and the period (full stop)
at the end of the sentence comes after the brackets.
If the author’s surname is used in the body of the text, only the year of
publication and the page number need to be in brackets. This must come
immediately after the author’s name, with a comma separating the year and the
page number.
Example
According to Smith (2003, p. 312), insulin molecules may not be stable under
these conditions.
Example
Suffering from feelings of guilt and unresolved grief (Worden 1991), she
subsequently put on a considerable amount of weight ...
In the above example, the theme of Worden’s book is dealing with grief, so the
reference here is to the whole book, rather than to a particular page.
c Edited books
An edited book is usually a collection of articles by different authors. If you are
quoting from an article in an edited book, you must use the name of the author of
the article for your in-text referencing, followed by the year of publication of the
book and the relevant page number, as for a standard in-text reference.
You will however need the editor’s details as well as the author’s for the
reference list (see Part F), so make sure you keep a note of these.
d No date given
If there is no date, write the details as you would for a standard reference but put
‘(no date)’ after the author’s name (or title if no author, as in the example
below).
Example
According to the Citing and Referencing Guide (no date), ...
D3 JOURNAL ARTICLES
References to journal articles in the text of your writing should be treated the
same way as books. Cite the author’s surname, year of publication and relevant
page number.
D4 ELECTRONIC SOURCES
Electronic sources include articles on the internet, articles retrieved from
databases and information obtained from CD-ROMs.
References to electronic sources in the text of your writing should be treated the
same way as books. Cite the author’s surname and year of publication, and the
relevant page number if it is available – often however, electronic sources do
not provide page numbers.
If the author is unknown, follow the conventions for books – use the title in
italics followed by the year, and if available the page number.
Further details
For further details of the Harvard referencing system, see
http://www.lib.monash.edu.au/tutorials/citing/
http://skillsforlearning.leedsmet.ac.uk/
The reason for giving these details is so that your reader has all the relevant
information to locate the source if they want to follow up the reference.
The Reference List comes at the end of your essay or report. If you have an
Appendix, the Reference List comes before the Appendix.
Bibliography
A bibliography is a list of all the books you have consulted for your work
but have not cited in your text. At university, tutors usually want a
Reference List with your assignments (rather than a bibliography) – they are
only interested in the books you have actually cited in your work.
If the author is unknown, the title of the work must be used in place of the
author’s surname and arranged in alphabetical order with the authors.
These details can be found on the title page of the book and the inside front
cover.
a One author
Example
Place of
publication
PUNCTUATION - BOOKS
• Put a comma after the surname, and a period (full stop) after the
initial(s).
• The date is given in brackets followed by a comma.
• The title should be in italics and capitalised, followed by a comma.
(Alternatively, the title can be underlined.)
• If it is an edition (other than the first), use ‘2nd ed.’ or ‘6th ed.’, NOT
in italics, followed by a comma (see example above).
• The publisher’s name comes next, followed by a comma, then the
place of publication.
• If the reference is longer than one line, indent the second and third
lines so that the authors’ names are clear to read, as in the above
example. See also the sample reference list in Part G.
b Two authors
With two authors, use ‘&’ between the two names. Keep the names in the
order they are given on the book title page.
Example
Windschuttle, K. & Elliott, E. (1999), Writing, Researching, Communication
Skills for the Information Age, 3rd ed., McGraw Hill, Sydney
c Three authors
Give all three names, with a comma after the first author’s initials, and ‘&’
between the last two names
Example
Lilly, D., Simpson, G.V. & White, K. (2003), Genetically Modified Crops,
Albion Press, New York
Example
Agnew, M., Barlow, S., Pascal, L. & Skidmore, S. (1995),
Get Better Grades, Piccadilly Press, London
When the author is unknown, use the title of the book or article in italics.
Example
How dangerous is obesity? (1977), British Medical Journal, No. 6069, 28th
April, p. 1115
Example
In-text reference:
Research indicates that depression is brought on by stressful life events which
often involve losses, such as divorce or job loss (Brown & Harris 1978, cited
in Davison & Neale 2001).
In your reference list, you only need to refer to Davison & Neale:
Davidson, G.C. & Neale, J.M. (2001) Abnormal Psychology, 8th ed., John
Wiley & Sons, New York
g Edited books
Use the standard approach for an author, but give the editor’s surname and
initials in place of the author’s. Put (ed.) after the editor’s initials, or (eds) if
there are two or more editors.
Example
Carter, C. & Peel, J. (eds) (1976), Equalities and Inequalities in Health, 2nd
ed., Academic Press, London
If you have quoted from an article in an edited book, put the author’s name
and article title in the Reference List as follows, using ‘in:’ before the editors’
names:
Blaxter, P. (1976), Social Health and class inequalities, in: Carter, C. & Peel,
J. (eds) (1976), Equalities and Inequalities in Health, 2nd ed.,
Academic Press, London
Example
Moore, H. (1996) ..........
Moore, H. (1999) ..........
Moore, H. (2003) ..........
When an author has published two or more works in the same year, put them
in alphabetical order of title and use ‘a’, ‘b’ and ‘c’ etc. to distinguish
between them.
Example
Smith, C. (2003a), Before Time Forgot, Albion Press, New York
Smith, C. (2003b), Kingdoms and Palaces of the Orient, Albion Press, New
York
Smith, C. (2003c), Terrible Tales of an Invertebrate, Albion Press, New
York
If two authors have the same name and initial, distinguish between them by
giving the first name in full
Example
Brown, George (2001) .............
Brown, Graham (2001) ............
F2 JOURNAL ARTICLES
You need:
• Author’s surname and initials
• Year of publication
• Title of the article
• Title of the journal
Example
Furlong, M. & Smith , J. (1994), “The broader system begins with the
workplace”, ANZ Journal of Family Therapy, vol. 15, no. 4, pp. 197-207
PUNCTUATION – JOURNALS
As for book references apart from the following:
• The article title should be in double inverted commas and not
italicised, followed by a comma (after the inverted commas).
• The journal title should be italicised, followed by a comma.
• Write ‘vol’ followed by a period (full stop), the volume number and
then a comma. (Example: vol. 42,)
• Write ‘no’ followed by a period (full stop), the issue number and then
a comma. (Example: no. 3,)
• Write ‘pp’ followed by a period (full stop) and then the page
numbers. (Example: pp. 27-30)
If you are accessing a journal via a database, see the entry under electronic
sources.
F3 ELECTRONIC SOURCES
For electronic sources, you need to provide:
Example
Authors’ Year of Title of article Title of
surnames and publication (in quotation journal (in
initials marks) italics)
Electronic Date of
URL access
medium
Example
3/4/11 – in UK and Australia is 3 April 2011, but in USA is 4 March
2011.
Example
Learning Independently (2006), University of Canberra [online]. Available
from: http://www.canberra.edu.au/studyskills/learning/independent
[Accessed 23 May 2011]
Example
Tanskanen, A., Hibbeln, J.R., Tuomilehto, J., Uutela, A., Haukkala,
A.,Viinamaki, H., Lehtonen, J. & Vartiainen, E. (2001), “Fish
consumption and depressive symptoms in the general population in
Finland”, Psychiatr Serv, vol. 52, no. 4, pp. 529-531, April. Accessed
via PubMed [online]
Carey, M.F. & McCardle, M. (2011) “Can an Observational Field Model Enhance Critical
Thinking and Generalist Practice Skills?”, Journal of Social Work Education, vol. 47,
no. 2, pp. 357-366 [online]. Available from:
http://cswe.metapress.com/content/?k=a+framework [Accessed 27 May 2011]
Cottrell, S. (2008), The Study Skills Handbook, 3rd ed., Macmillan, Basingstoke
Cottrell, S. (2001), Teaching Study Skills and Supporting Learning, Palgrave, Basingstoke
Drew, S. & Bingham, R. (1997), The Student Skills Guide, Gower, Aldershot
Orr, F. (1992), Study Skills for Successful Students, Allen & Unwin, St Leonards
Study Guides and Strategies (2002), University of St Thomas [online]. Available from:
http://www.iss.stthomas.edu/studyguides [Accessed 16 February 2011]
Windschuttle, K. & Elliott, E. (1999), Writing, Researching, Communication Skills for the
Information Age, 3rd ed., McGraw Hill, Sydney
Contents
H1 & H2 Practise paraphrasing
H3 Practise summarising
H4 Practise organising a reference list
H5 Plagiarism quiz
Following are some activities to practise what you have studied in this
manual. Example answers are found in Part J.
H1 Practise Paraphrasing
1 Read the original text below written by William Chubb in 2006 and
found on page 163 of his book entitled “Volcanoes”, and then look
at the imaginary student’s paraphrase below it. Make comments
about it with a partner.
Student’s paraphrase :
Volcanoes are formed because the earth is hot inside, so hot that
it can turn solid rock into liquid rock and this liquid rock is called
magma. The magma is raised toward the surface of the earth
because it is less dense than the surrounding rock. The magma
will be called lava when it reaches the surface and then it
accumulates to make a volcano. (p.163 How volcanoes form by
Rudolf Chubb 2006,)
Your Comments
You can see this student has tried to change the wording but not
sufficiently. There are still some words and phrases that are the same in
both the original and the paraphrase such as ‘is hot inside’. The
structure is virtually the same and too many words and phrases are the
same or too close to the original. Also the source is cited incorrectly.
2 Underline all the words and phrases which are the same in the
original and in the student sample.
H2 Practise paraphrasing
First
o Read the original and make sure you understand the main ideas
o Make notes
o Write down the key words which cannot be changed
o Cover the original and rewrite using your own words
Hint!
In this example, words that are acceptable in a paraphrase are:
magna, volcano, lava, surface, liquid and solid.
1 Read the original and make sure you understand the main ideas
2 Make notes
3 Write down the key words which cannot be changed
4 Choose the section you want to include as a direct quotation. It
should be a section which includes phrases
5 Cover the original and rewrite using your own words
Education in the US is truly in trouble. Many students in elementary school lack basic numeracy
and literacy skills and the standardised test scores of students leaving secondary school have
dropped over the last few years. One main cause of this situation is that children are forced to
attend school even if they do not want to. Government law decrees that it is compulsory for
children between the ages of 5 to 14 to attend school. In my opinion mandatory attendance laws
should be abolished and only those who want to learn should attend school. This will surely
improve the standard of education.
Having students who do not want to learn in a school pollutes the educational atmosphere. These
students are often disruptive and teachers waste many hours disciplining them or providing
unwelcome help rather than providing quality education for the serious ones. Because education
is compulsory, the ultimate consequence of bad behaviour- expulsion - is denied the government
schools. Instead students are passed from grade to grade until they are old enough to leave. Most
likely they are awarded a high school diploma whether they do acceptable work or not.
Private schools do not have this problem as they are at liberty to fail or dismiss students because
they know these same students can attend government schools. Private schools can concentrate
on providing quality education for those whose personal and academic behaviour follow the
educational mission of the school. Compulsory education hampers the ability of government
schools to enforce legitimate educational and disciplinary policies for those students who do not
want to learn.
First the quality of education would improve because teachers could concentrate on providing
quality education. Students would realise that a school is a serious place to which one goes to
learn. To attend classes would be treated as a privilege and all who attended would have the
same goal.
Second public esteem for schools would increase. They would not be treated as child minding
institutions but regarded instead as important places in which future generations are formed.
Third students who have no aptitude for learning would be identified early. These students could
be directed into other areas of vocation and teachers could focus attention on the serious
students. They would not have to award false grades and they would no longer have to pass their
failures on to the next class.
Fourth the cost of enforcing compulsory education would be eliminated. Imagine how costly it is
to track students who play truant. Despite efforts to enforce the law, the number of school age
students who are frequently absent from school is estimated to be almost 15% in the larger cities
(Rubins 2005, p.68). This money could be better spent on providing resources for those who
wish to learn or providing institutions more suited to non-academic students.
Schools should be for educating the next generations and at present they are only pretending to
be. Schools have tried to have an all-encompassing functionality and be all things to all people.
Unfortunately they have failed badly at what they were originally created to do. Abolishing
compulsory education would bring them one step closer to the goal of providing quality
education to functional children.
Written by George Crusove, 27th March 2007. Published in “Letters to the Editor” section of the Daily Standard
newspaper, USA.
1. Is this a good argument? Briefly state why or why not. (You will
come back to this article in Part I)
2. Make your notes here. You may wish to use bullet points.
http://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic/products/socind/inc-
eco.htm for
Indicators on Income and Social; Activity ( 2010 ) from the United
Nations Statistical Division,
and
http://www.managementhelp.org/plan_dec/bus_plan/bus_plan.htm
for
Business Planning ( 2010 )
Free Management Library [online].
H5 Quiz on Plagiarism
1. In your high school English class you wrote an essay about the
advantages of studying abroad. You see there is a similar topic on
the GAC essay assessment and so you hand in the same essay to
your GAC teacher. Is it plagiarism?
YES NO
Reason:
YES NO
Reason:
3. You decide that the best way to illustrate your point about the film
is to include a video clip from the film. Is it plagiarism?
YES NO
Reason:
YES NO
Reason:
You read,
Active volcano
Scientists usually consider a volcano active if it is currently
Dormant volcano
Dormant volcanoes are those that are not currently active (as
defined above), but could become restless or erupt again.
YES NO
Reason:
6. You are writing an essay about pollution and look on the Internet
for information. You find a very good site but it is in your own
language, not English. You translate it into English and include it
as part of your essay. Is it plagiarism?
YES NO
Reason:
Is it plagiarism?
YES NO
Reason:
8. You use some pictures from MS Word “Clip art” to illustrate your
oral presentation. Is it plagiarism?
YES NO
Reason:
Preliminary This is the basic article information. When you have scanned the
Information article and decided that you may use it, complete the following
details. You might not use it in the end but you cannot use any
information unless you have these essential details.
Write the title of the article here. Titles will tell you a lot about the
content of the article: where ,when, what (subject),who, why and
how and, sometimes, something about the author’s approach or
Title:
interpretation
E.g. A Critical Analysis Of The Events Leading Up To The Election Of the
Present Government.
Where and when was this article published? If you have found it in a
data base or on the internet, find the original source of the article if
you can. Where the article is published can give credibility to the
Source:
material. For example an article about Allergies will have more
credibility if it is published in a medical journal and within the last
year.
What does the article seem to be about? Refer to the title and look at
the first couple of paragraphs which should give you a clue. Some
Subject: disciplines include an abstract that precedes the text. This will
summarise the article's subject/content.
Why do you think this article has been written by the author? What
is its method of organisation? Is it offering new information? Is it
arguing for or against something? Is it giving an opinion of some
Purpose:
event or fact or trend? You'll usually find clues to the answer to
these questions in the first paragraph. That is where authors usually
try to show why their article is useful and worth reading.
Primary Start reading. If the article has a labelled introduction, you should
Details find the author's statement of purpose, or thesis statement, before
the end of that section. You should also be able to tell what
evidence the author is going to use to support the position. The
author may also explain the limits on the article, for example, the
time, the location, the extent of the information that's going to be
used, the theories (if any) that are going to be applied. You should
also be able to tell what the author's point of view is in the
introduction and in the first paragraph.
Look at what limits the topic. Is it just about one geographic area or
over a certain time? Is it restricted to a particular group of people
or a particular scientific fact? Here you will also consider what the
Limits:
author doesn’t mention; for example, the article is about Studying
Abroad but it focuses on the costs of studying overseas but not
culture shock.
Make notes of the evidence the author uses to support the argument.
Evidence: This section will form the bulk of your summary and will be in point
form. Consider using a table or bullet points.
Quotations or Use this space to write down sections of the article which you think
Sections for may be useful in your assignment. Make sure you write them down
Paraphrasing: exactly as they are found in the article and note what page they are
on. You will need to document this when you use them in your work.
If the sections are too long, you may wish to just make a note of the
page and paragraph. E.g. “Good point about xxxxxxx, p 41, par. 5,
sentences 2 - 4”.
You may not use them as direct quotations but paraphrase them
instead. Whichever you decide you still need to include these details
in-text in your assignment, as shown previously in Part C of this
guide.
Presentation Keep reading but take note of how the author is presenting his
and information to make it fit into the argument. At this stage of the
Argumentation exercise, you should look up any unfamiliar words, concepts and
jargon. The last few paragraphs of the article should tidy up the
discussion; show how it all fits together, where more research is
needed, and how this article has advanced knowledge; that is, the
implications of the article.
Use this space to note the words, concepts and jargon you had to
Concepts/Words: look up. Did the author use his/her own terms, or use common
terms?
This is where you might note what the argument might mean in a
larger context. Who might find it useful? Would anyone change the
Implications:
way they work, or approach an issue if they read this article? What
difference has it made for you?
Evaluation Now that you've finished reading, consider your personal reaction to
it: not only "Did I like it?", "It was hard to read," or "It was
boring/interesting,". This, along with the work in the other steps, is
the basis for a critical evaluation of the article. Even if you don't
know anything about the topic, you can make some judgements about
the article and how well the author presented the case. Does it have a
high academic standard in terms of writing, presentation,
organization, source citation, etc.?
This is where you note your personal reaction to the article. Your
comments might be one or two words, or might be longer.
Personal Reaction:
Remember, too, that these notes will allow you to quickly review the
article later on.
Independent Use the template on the following page to make your own analysis
Study of an article. You might like to practise first with a partner using the
article about compulsory education on page 24 of this guide.
If you would make changes to the template, what would you do?
Preliminary information
Title:
Author(s):
Source:
Analysis of Information
Subject:
Purpose:
Audience:
Sources:
Primary Details
Thesis:
Limits:
Evidence:
Concepts/Words:
Conclusion:
Implications:
Evaluation
Personal Reaction:
Strength of Case:
Adapted from:
Graham, A. (1998) The Annotated Sheet: A Guide to Filling Out the Record Sheet [Online]. Available from:
http://www.yukoncollege.yk.ca/~agraham/guides/aguide.htm [Accessed 14 June 2011]
H1 The words and phrases in the paraphrase are too close to the original.
The source has been acknowledged but does not have the correct format
for an in text reference. In the student’s text there should only be the
author’s surname and the year of publication (refer to Part C).The full
name of the book, author and other details should be included in the
reference list.
The similarities are shown underlined in the original and in italics in the
student paraphrase.
Original
Student paraphrase:
Volcano is formed because the earth is hot inside, so hot that it can
turn solid rock into liquid rock and this liquid rock is called magma.
The magma is raised toward the surface of the earth because it is
less dense than the surrounding rock. The magma will be called
lava when it reaches the surface and then it accumulates to make a
volcano.
H2 Example Paraphrase
A volcano is formed when the extreme heat in the core of the earth melts
rock and turns it into “magna” which is the rock in a liquid form.
Because this liquid form is not as thick or heavy as the neighbouring
rocks, it ascends to the surface and an eruption occurs. The liquid rock
which comes out is now known as lava and as this solidifies, it builds up
the volcano. (Chubb, 2006, p. #)
H3 Example Summary
schools. Private schools can expel or get rid of problem students who
take up teachers’ time depriving dedicated students of focussed
education. With compulsory education laws in place, government schools
are obliged to include all children regardless of their behaviour or
academic ability. He claims that students are passed from one year level
to the next whether or not they have passed.
Answer
References
H5 Plagiarism Quiz
Answers
In most cases, you are expected to produce new work for every module
or subject that you take. However, you may ask your professors/teachers
about their individual policies regarding multiple submissions. You
would also want to be sure that your high school essay addressed all
parts of the GAC assignment!
3. No, unless you try to pass off the film as your own work.
The important point is to let your audience know the source of the video
you’re showing. You can do this by telling the audience what film it is.
Don’t show too much of it otherwise the bulk of your presentation will
be someone else’s work.
4. Yes. You must always acknowledge the use of any ideas that are not
your own.
Take good notes, record the date, and cite the lecturer in your
assignment. Talk with your teacher or tutor to find some sources that you
can read and cite.
You could either use direct quotations, that is put the definitions in
quotation marks to indicate they are the exact words from the original
text, or else you could paraphrase the definitions. Either way you would
still need to acknowledge your source both as an in-text reference and in
your Reference List.
You would include details of your source in the Reference list and say
that you have translated it.
Note Be wary of using online translation services which translate word for
word and do not allow for grammar or syntax.
7. Yes
You could then write the paragraph as a direct quotation (in quotation
marks) or paraphrase it. The bibliographic details of the article would go
into your reference list.
Preliminary information
An Argument Against Compulsory Education
Title:
George Crusove
Author(s):
Published in the “Letters to the Editor” section of the Daily Standard Newspaper,
USA. 27th March 2007.
The credibility of this article is low. The author does not tell us his qualification to
Source:
speak on the topic. The article is not published in an academic education journal – it
is published in an opinion section of a daily newspaper (a tabloid) to which any
person can send in articles for publication,
Analysis of Information
The author argues that mandatory education should be abolished and that only those
who want to learn should attend school. He claims this will increase the quality of
Subject:
education for determined and purposeful children.
General public, readers of the newspaper. The author does not make any claims as to
Audience: why his article is useful.
The author uses only one source, Rubins 2005 p. 68, and because there is no
reference list we cannot see all the details. But given that the article is written to a
newspaper we would not really expect to see more. In the first paragraph where the
Sources: author states that “is compulsory for children between the ages of 5 to 14 to attend
school”, he does not need to put a source because this is “common knowledge” in
the USA.
Primary Details
“In my opinion mandatory attendance laws should be abolished and only those who
want to learn should attend school. This will surely improve the standard of
Thesis: education.”
(End of paragraph 1)
Authors arguments:
1. Lazy students pollute the educational atmosphere
• disruptive
• can’t be expelled
• get diplomas anyway
2. Private schools can expel because students can attend government ones
→ better quality of education at these schools
For example:
Quotations or sections for Good phrase “pollutes the educational atmosphere” par 2, line 1.
paraphrasing: Students may choose others.
Evaluation
It is a simple argument. His arguments would have been more convincing if the author
had drawn on data, facts and examples for support. Also, the lack of a counter argument
Strength of Case: weakened the case. As a writer you need to acknowledge that you have carefully
considered the other side of the argument but rejected it as being unsound.
No publication “…” (Brown, no date) Brown (no date) admits that… Brown, S. ( no date) B. B. Bernard, Sunshine Press,
date London
Author “…” (Brown & Harris, 1978, cited in Research indicates that …(Brown & Davison, G.C. & Neale J.M. (2001), Abnormal
quoted in Davison & Neale 2001, p. 26). Harris, 1978, cited in Davison & Neale Psychology, 8th ed., John Wiley, New York
another book 2001, p. 26).
eBook (Electronic Book)
One author Flick (2009, p. 127) notes “…” Flick (2009, p. 127) mentions the idea Flick, U., (2009) An Introduction to qualitative
that… research, 4th ed., Sage, [online]. Available from:
http://books.google.com.au/books?id=sFv1oWX2D
oEC [Accessed 11 May 2011]
Corporate or “…” (UNESCO 2011, p. 27) UNESCO (2011, p. 27) reports UNESCO, (2011) The Hidden Crisis: armed conflict and
institutional Education; EFA global monitoring report, 2011,
author UNESCO, Paris [online]. Available from:
http://unesdoc.unesco.org/ulis/cgi-
bin/ulis.pl?catno=190743&gp=1&mode=e&lin=1
[Accessed 11 May 2011]
Journal Articles
Article from Tanskanen et al (2001, p. 530) report Tanskanen et al (2001, p. 530) discuss Tanskanen, A., Hibbeln, J.R., Tuomilehto, J., Uutela, A.,
an electronic the”…” the notion that … Haukkala, A.,Viinamaki, H., Lehtonen, J. &
database Vartiainen, E. (2001), “Fish consumption and
depressive symptoms in the general population in
Finland”, Psychiatr Serv, vol. 52, no. 4, pp. 529-531,
April. Accessed via PubMed [online]
Article from a Gulliver (2010, p. 726) defines According to Gulliver (2010, p. 726)… Gulliver, T. (2010)” Immigrant Success Stories in ESL
printed success as “…” Textbooks”, TESOL Quarterly, vol. 44 no. 4,
journal – one December 2010, pp. 725-745
author
Article from a Furlong and Smith (1994, p. 198) Furlong and Smith (1994, p. 198) claim Furlong, M. & Smith , J. (1994), “The broader system
printed make the claim that “…” that … begins with the workplace”, ANZ Journal of
Wiki “…” (Infoteach 2007) Infoteach (2007) compares … Infoteach, (2007), Learning_outcomes [Online].
Available from:
http://infoteach.org/wiki/doku.php/learning_outc
omes. [Accessed 10 May 2011]
Dictionaries Shorter Oxford English Dictionary … (Shorter Oxford English Dictionary Shorter Oxford English Dictionary (2007) 6th ed.,
(2007, p. 69) defines “…” 2007, p. 69) Oxford; Oxford University Press
Online Is defined as “…” (Oxford Advanced … (Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary Online (2011)
Dictionary Learners Dictionary Online 2011) Online 2011) Oxford University Press [online]. Available from:
http://www.oxfordadvancedlearnersdictionary.co
m/ [Accessed 11 May 2011]
GAC course ACT Education Solutions, (2011 p. … (ACT Education Solutions 2011, p. 20), ACT Education Solutions, (2011), The GAC Referencing
materials 20) states “…” Guide, Sydney, ACT Education Solutions
Podcasts “…” (Geach 2011) Geach (2011) discusses … Geach, J.E., (2011) The Lost Galaxies [Podcast].
Scientific American, 11th April [Online]. Available
from:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id
=the-lost-galaxies [Accessed 11 May 2011]
Online image “…” (Scienceblogs 2006) The image on Scienceblogs (2006) Scienceblogs (2006) Polar Bear [Online image] [online].
conveys the idea that … Available from:
http://scienceblogs.com/strangerfruit/polar-
bear.jpg [Accessed 11 May 2011]
An article or “…” (Richard 2004) Richard (2004) discusses the notion Richard, A.C., (2004) The Money Trail: Europe Can Do
paper taken that… More to Shut Down Terrorist Funds, International
from an Herald Tribune, March 19, 2004 [online]. Available
electronic from: ABI/Inform Global database [Accessed 28
database April, 2006]
Document or “…” (Citing and referencing: How to Citing and referencing: How to Citing and referencing: How to acknowledge your
article from a acknowledge your sources 2006) acknowledge your sources (2006), sources (2006), Library online tutorials, Monash
website outlines … University Library [online]. Available at:
http://www.lib.monash.edu.au/tutorials/citing/
[Accessed 10 March 2011]
Website “…” (Study Abroad 2011) Study Abroad (2011) illustrates … Study Abroad (2011) Education Dynamics [online].
Available at: http://www.studyabroad.com/
[Accessed 11 May 2011]
Plagiarism:
If plagiarism is detected in an assignment or assessment event, you will be asked to resubmit.
The maximum mark possible for resubmission is 55%. If you resubmit work that contains
plagiarism, you will receive a fail.
It is most important that if you include quotations, you must comment on and make their
relevance to the essay explicit.
Any assignment containing more than 10% quotation will be returned to you. You may or
may not be able to resubmit, depending on the circumstances.
There are exceptions where it is necessary to include more than 10%. Your teacher will make
that determination.