Lighting Assistant
Lighting Assistant
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
NEW !
The Lighting AssistantTM is a tool offered by G E that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual costs or
savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer (see link above on
left.) Use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2006 General Electric Company All Rights Reserved.
Simple
Energy Estimator
Calculate the energy costs associated with existing and proposed lighting systems.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells. Note graph at bottom of page.
Instructions INPUT
Existing System New System
System DescriptIons (optional)
Hours burned per year 4500 Number of Fixtures 1000 Number of Fixtures 1000
Cost per kWh $ 0.10 Watts per Fixture 100 Watts per Fixture 26
OUTPUT
Fixture Watts can be obtained for many Energy used per yr. Energy used per yr.
(Existing System) $45,000 (New System) $11,700
common systems by going back to the
Home Page and accessing the Fixture
Wattage Tool or the Selected Fixtrue Energy Savings per year
Watages sheet Energy Savings per yr. $33,300 (each new system fixture) $33.30
(entire site)
Instructions INPUT
Quantity Unit Cost Total Cost
Lamps 1400 $1.43 $2,002
Ballasts 700 $18.63 $13,041
Fixtures 700 $0
Other Equipment 2800 $0.20 $560
Disposal 1400 $0.50 $700
Retrofit Labor 700 $18.00 $12,600
Other Labor $0
Total Investment $28,903
Investment per fixture $41.29
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Utility Rebate Programs
Utility Rebate Program List from Edison Electric Institute
A listing of over 330 web sites, arranged by state, from utilites explaining their rebate
programs.
US Dept.of Energy
RealWinWin.com
A privately owned company that maintains a national database and offers to find rebates
(for a fee). Rebate Administration is a success-fee-based service to perform all of the
steps necessary to find and capture dollars for eligible projects.
This is for information only, so you can examine the kinds of services offered by this and similar companies. GE
has no agreements or business contact with this or any other company operating in this field.
Simple Payback
Calculator
Use this tool when the PROPOSED system has the same number of fixtures as the CURRENT System
Current System 400 W HID Proposed 4-lamp T5
Instructions INPUT
Hours burned
Number of Fixtures 170 per year 4680 Cost per kWh $ 0.07
Watts per Fixture Watts per Fixture Cooling Multiplier (load
(Current System) 458 (Proposed System) 231 reduction per W of lighting) 0.17
OUTPUT
Energy used per yr. Energy Savings per yr. Energy Savings per yr.
(Current System) $25,507 (entire site)
$12,642 (incl. Cooling Savings)
$14,791
Energy used per yr. Energy Savings per year
(Proposed System) $12,865 (each fixture) $74.37
$25,000
$20,000
$15,000
$25,507
$10,000
$12,865
$5,000
$0
Current System versus Proposed System
Potential Savings: $12,642 per yr. $14,791 per yr. including Cooling Savings
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Motion Sensors
and Dimming
Energy Estimator
Obtain an overall equivalent wattage and calculate energy reduction obtained when using a dimming system.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells.
Instructions INPUT
Fixture Watts
at Full Power 110 # of Fixtures 220 Burning hrs./yr. 4500
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Life-Cycle Cost
Estimator
Instructions INPUT
Burning hours per year 4500 Cost per kWh $0.10
Lamp A Lamp B
Lamp Name (Optional) Inc 100W CFL 26W
Lamp Watts
(fixture watts / no. of lamps in fixture) 100 26
Lamp Cost
(include disposal cost) $0.50 $10.00
$50
$40 'Lectricity
Labor
$30
Lamp
$20
$10
$0
Inc 100W CFL 26W
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Cost of Waiting
Estimator
Calculate and demonstrate the amount of money being "thrown away" by postponing the lighting upgrade.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells.
Instructions INPUT
Hours burned
Number of Fixtures 1000 per year 4500 Cost per kWh $ 0.10
OUTPUT
Energy used per yr. Cost of Doing Nothing Cost of Doing Nothing
(Current System) $66,600 ( per yr. entire site) $27,450 ( per month. entire site) $2,287.50
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Environmental Impact
Estimator
Calculate the environmental impact associated with upgrading the lighting system.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells. Note graph at bottom of page.
Instructions INPUT
Hours burned
Number of Fixtures 2,000 per year 4500 Cost per kWh $ 0.10
OUTPUT
Energy Savings per yr.
(kWh) 225,000 Energy Savings per yr. $22,500
$$
Assumptions Used
Electricity Carbon Emission 1.43 Annual CO2 sequestration 7,333 Annual CO2 emission per 11,560
Factors per forested acre average Passenger Car
(EPA 2003) lbs.CO2 (EPA 2003) lbs. CO2 (EPA 2003) lbs.CO2
/ kWh
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Inc-Halogen
Life Estimator
Examine the impact of changing the voltage at which the incandescent or halogen lamp is being operated. Click on
the first green cell and tab to the other input cells. Note that predictions of Halogen Lamp life extension greater than
200% may not be realized in practice. Also, this tool is meant to predict
the effect of small voltage changes; predictions for voltage change >10% may be inaccurate.
Color Candle-
Life Watts Lumens LPW
Temp. Power
285% 88% 76% 86% 97% 76%
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Lighting System Lumen
Comparison Tool
# lamps /fixture Lamp Rated Initial Lumens Mean Lumens (%) Life (hr.) Ballast Factor CU
System 1: 1 MVR400/U 36000 65% 20,000 1 1
System 2: 1 CMH250 elec 23000 85% 20,000 1 1
System 3: 4 T5HO 5000 94% 30,000 1 1
System 4: 0 T8HL Hi BF 3100 94% 20,000 1.15 1
Note: Mouseover the cells with red triangle in upper right corner for additional information.
To remove a system, type zero in the number of lamps cell
35000
30000
25000
20000
15000
10000
$3,000
$2,900
$2,800
$2,700
$2,600
55% 60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 85%
Group Relamping Period (as % of Rated life)
COMPARE Average Annual Cost if spot relamping only $3,240
Group Relamping Period (% life) 55% 60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 85%
Group Relamping Period (yr/m) 2yr. 5m 2yr. 8m 2yr. 11m 3yr. 1m 3yr. 4m 3yr. 7m 3yr. 9m
Average Annual Cost (Excluding Energy) $3,152 $2,997 $2,891 $2,833 $2,834 $2,867 $2,931
Savings from Group Relamping $88 $243 $349 $407 $406 $373 $309
Supporting Information
Group Relamping Period (% life) 55% 60% 65% 70% 75% 80% 85%
Fraction replaced (GE model) 0.035 0.055 0.08 0.112 0.156 0.208 0.269
Cost of Spot Labor $378 $594 $864 $1,210 $1,685 $2,246 $2,905
Cost of Spot Lamps $126 $198 $288 $403 $562 $749 $968
Cost of Group Labor $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600
Cost of Group Lamps $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600 $3,600
Total Cost $7,704 $7,992 $8,352 $8,813 $9,446 $10,195 $11,074
Group Relamping at (hrs.) 11,000 12,000 13,000 14,000 15,000 16,000 17,000
Site Lighting Cost per hour $0.70 $0.67 $0.64 $0.63 $0.63 $0.64 $0.65
(excluding energy)
Site Lighting Cost per year $3,152 $2,997 $2,891 $2,833 $2,834 $2,867 $2,931
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or
implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see
and examine the Full Disclaimer; use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or
implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see
and examine the Full Disclaimer; use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
PLANNED MAINTENANCE/ GROUP RELAMPING
In a new site the failure rate is small initially and then gradually
increases with age. At some point the maintenance involved in
replacing burned out lamps becomes a nuisance. Instead of waiting
for lamps to fail and then replacing them individually "GROUP
RELAMPING" can provide economic savings and other benefits.
It is true--and this is a frequent and obvious objection-- that you are throwing away lamps which still
have some life left. But users will relate to the notion of getting rid of an automobile which is still
running. Even though it is working today, the cost of maintaining it tomorrow--and the day after and
the next month--is likely to be so high that you are better off investing in a new car and being
guaranteed worry-free operation at least for the first few years. Similarly at some point most of the
lamps are so old that you are better off just getting them out of the ceiling and replacing them with
brand new lamps.
There are other reasons for doing group relamping relating to performance (and aesthetics):
lumen depreciation and color shift. Replacing aging lamps with brand new lamps gives the entire
site a face-lift: the space is brighter and the lamps have greater uniformity. Group relamping also
provides an opportunity to clean the fixtures and recover from Luminaire Dirt Depreciation (LDD) on
a regular, planned basis. Further, a site designed with group relamping in mind will use fewer
fixtures or have higher average light levels, consume less energy and provide economies far beyond
the simple economies of labor savings.
When is the correct time to group relamp based on economics? This depends on many factors like
lamp price, burning hours and the difference in relamping costs when you replace lamps as a group
or when you replace them individually. GE's Group Relamping Economizer Tool calculates the
optimum ECONOMIC time for group relamping based on GE's lamp mortality model. The tool takes
user input regarding number of lamps at the site, life of the lamp, labor for relamping etc.. and shows
the optimum point for group relamping.
Note that this tool provides purely an economic analysis, it does not include the aesthetic and
performance benefits of group relamping. If the lamps are expensive or if the labor differential
between spot and group relamping is not large, the tool will not show a cost benefit for group
relamping even though it is justified from a lamp performance point. Note that rated life is
merely a statistical point when 50% of lamps will have failed; there is no justification in operating
lamps to rated life. Indeed, it is more practical to define a "useful life" of the lamp based on various
factors like mortality curves, lumen depreciation and color shift. "Useful life" of many lamps falls in
the region defined earlier--between 65% and 75% of rated life, and this is typically the region
suggested as the optimum group relamping point by the tool.
Lighting Institute, GE
Upgrade Options by Fixture
Select the type of fixture
T12 U6 T12 U3
(Mod-U-Line)
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
T12's normally operate on magnetic ballasts.
T12 U6 T12 U3
Energy Savings are possible by upgrading to
T8U on electronic instant-start ballast
(UltraMAX). T8U's also have longer life (20,000
hours)
6 inch spacing 3 5/8 inch spacing
Life 14,000 hr. If currently using T12U6, then T8U6 will go into
Lumens about 3000 same socket (ballast change required)
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Possibilities include
upgrading to UltraMAX ballast,
Linear 2-ft F17T8 putting SPX lamps for higher CRI or
XL lamps for longer life.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
8 foot T8
"Standard"
High Output (HO)
Single pin
Recessed Double Contact R17d
T8 Instant Start
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Strip
2 x 4 troffer Industrial
T12 T8
1 1/2 inch diameter 1 inch diameter
Previous Back to Top
T12
4-foot T12 lamps were the most common fluorescent lamps even a few years ago. Most of
them are operated on magnetic ballasts which are inefficient. Significant energy savings can
be realized by switching over to T8 lamps on electronic ballasts
The same fixture and socket can be used for the retrofit: only a ballast change is needed.
Two 2-lamp magnetic ballasts can be replaced by one 4-lamp electronic ballast.
The most common T12 lamp is the F34T12CW/WM (Cool-White Wattmiser) which can be
replaced by GE's F28T8/SP41/UMX on a 0.77 ballast factor UltraMax ballast to provide up to
44% energy reduction with about the same light level with improved color rendering. Many
other T8 options are also possible (click "Previous" and go to T8).
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
T8 lamps are available in a wide variety of color temperatures: warm (3000K) to cool (4100K)
to very cool (5000K and 6500K). Listed below or some useful upgrade options.
Also consider GE's UltraMax ballast for maximum energy savings or GE's UltraStart ballasts
for extended life even with motion sensors and frequent switching
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
F96PG17
(Power Groove)
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Strip Industrial
T12 std. (Single Pin, IS ballast) upgrade to XL, SP, SPX, C50 or Wattmiser and WM/XL also
WM/ECO; T12 std not available in CW but WM is; also WMPlus ECO (SP35 only)
T12 VHO (Very High Output) only available in halophosphors (liteWhite, CoolWhite,
WarmWhite and DayLight)
Previous 8-foot T12 Single-pin lamps Back to Top
You can ask them, you can climb up and peek in the fixture or you can go to the stock room
and see what type of replacement ballasts are being stocked.
Note that some customer may have started out with magnetic ballasts and then started
replacing failures with electronic ballasts. In such an installation you will have a mixture of
magnetic and electronic ballasts in the ceiling.
Click here if they are using Click here if they are using
MAGNETIC BALLASTS ELECTRONIC BALLASTS
Previous Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
F96T12 on Electronic Ballasts
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
VHO lamps: No easy upgrade options… unless they are willing to do a major lighting
redesign using (for example) T5HO fixtures. Significant energy savings may be
possible because of the increased energy efficiency of newer technologies
HO lamps: Again, a key question is: are they using Magnetic or Electronic ballasts?
Remember to check if they are using HO lamps or HO/WM lamps
Click here if they are using Click here if they are using
F96T12HO or HO/WM lamps on F96T12HO or HO/WM lamps on
MAGNETIC BALLASTS ELECTRONIC BALLASTS
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
F96T12/HO lamps on Magnetic Ballasts
Convert 8-ft T12/HO lamps to 4-ft. (1) chances are they are using 4-ft. lamps in
T8/HL lamps on high BF UltraMax the building anyway, so you can standardize,
ballasts (2) most technoical innovations and advances
are occurring with 4-foot technology.
You can replace each 8-ft lamp with
two 4-ft. lamps (end to end) with Remember, HO lamps must be replaced with
fixture retrofit kits or you can put in lamps that provide similar high lumen output,
new 4-ft fixtures not standard lamps.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Convert 8-ft T12/HO lamps to 4-ft. Remember, HO lamps must be replaced with
T8/HL lamps on high BF UltraMax lamps that provide similar high lumen output,
ballasts not standard lamps.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Previous Back to Top
Horizontal Lamps
Vertical Lamps
Sports and
area lighting
or building lighting
Previous Back to Top
Most Industrial Hi-bay and Low-bay fixtures use HID lamps in the Base-up (BU) position.
Click on the lamp wattage below
175-250 W
400 W
1000 W
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Energy-saving upgrades Back to Top
400W MVR/U lamp in BU position is the most common metal halide lamp.
Many attractive energy-saving upgrade options are available.
Click on any option below to see more details:
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
GE's electronic HID ballast represents a quantum leap in HID system performance.
Benefits include increased efficiency, significantly improved mean lumens, flexibility
(change from 250-300-320-350-499W with a set-screw) etc..
Many fixtures can be retrofitted with this ballast and use the same
Electronic reflector and optics. However, it is often convenient to buy a new
HID ballast fixture and replace the existing fixture.
400/U can be replaced with CMH 250 or with 320PA lamp. CMH
250 saves 41% in energy and actully provides higher lumens late
in life; 320 PA saves 25% in energy costs and provides 15%
higher mean lumens.
This ballast will also operate lamps from 250W to 400W--a great
feature to accommodate future new products and upgrades!
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Replacing 400/U fixtures with a 4-lamp or 6-lamp Hi-bay
linear fluorescent fixture is a significant trend. Options
included (typical wattages noted below):
Depending on the light level and light distribution needed, significant energy savings can
be realized, along with improved CRI, instant on-off, etc.. Note that many other factors
need to be considered including lamp replacement policy, temperature effects, dirt
degradation of luminaires, etc..
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Upgrade options fall into three major categories
Safety-related or
Code-required upgrades
Energy-saving upgrades
Performance-improved upgrades:
(1) Better Color, or
(2) Higher Light levels
Previous Safety-related or Back to Top
Code-required upgrades
Before 2005, 400 W and 1000 W metal halide lamps were permitted to operate in OPEN
fixtures as long as they were burned Base-up.
While existing systems are exempt, it is clear that all new installations and major renovations
have to satisfy this code. Replace MV400/U in open fixtures with the
MP400 "O" rated lamps to satisfy the code. Alternately, replace open fixtures with enclosed
fixtures. Some manufacturers are offering retrofit kits to convert open fixtures into enclosed
fixtures.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Performance-improved upgrades:
Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
One possibility would be to redo the lighting layout using linear fluorescent
fixtures--either T5 or T8--for great energy savings, improved CRI, instant on/off
etc… However, the number of fixtures would almost double.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
If MVR/Universal lamps are being used in a Horizontal position, their life and lumens are
significantly reduced. Using the appropriate GE lamp designed for HOR operation brings the
following benefits.
POMB - Position Oriented Mogul Socket has a slot and lamp base has a pin
so the lamp screws to a stop in a specified orientation
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Sports and
area lighting
or building lighting
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
HPS lamps are very efficient, have long life and good lumen maintenance.
Their main drawback is poor color.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Improved Back to Top
Color
Ballast change (to metal halide): Other wattages can be switched to metal
halide but will require a ballast change.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Longer
Life
Standby Longlife Lucalox Lamps
Standby Longlife
Dual Arc Tube
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Non-cycling Back to Top
Low mercury
30,000 hour life! Lamp turns bluish white at end of life instead of cycling.
Becomes easy to spot lamps needing to be replaced.
Lamp uses low mercury dose and lead-free solder. Passes US Govt. TCLP test.
Available in 70-100-150-200-250-400
Also Available! Ecolux TCLP HPS lamps without the non-cycling feature.
Example: LU400/ECO
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Mercury lamps are significantly less efficient than HPS or Metal Halide
and should probably be ugraded.
However, there are a few possibilites for retrofitting with HPS or Metal Halide lamps with
no ballast change.
Examples:
E-Z Lux HPS lamps will operate on 175-250-400 W mercury ballasts.
I-line Metal Halide lamps will operate on 400-1000 W mercury ballasts.
In these cases the wattage saving is small and the light output is significantly higher.
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Replacing Standard Halogen or Halogen Plus Lamps with upgrades can provide
significant benefits including energy savings, more light and longer life.
However, there are many options to choose from (Click Below for Details)
Silver-IR HIR-XL
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
90 W
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous
Retail HIR
45W
5W HIR/XL
45W
HIR Silv-IR
50W 50W
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous
15 W Retail-IR
45W
10 W HIR Silv-IR
50W 50W
Retail-IR HIR/XL
5W 55W
55W
Silv-IR
60W
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous
20 W
10 W
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous
Retail-HIR
30 W 90 W
HIR
20 W 100 W
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Wide floods ---> CFL reflector lamps Click here for More Details
Spots and narrow beams ---> HIR (Halogen Infrared Reflecting) and silverized
reflectors
Click here for More Details
CMH lamps provide approximately 3 to 4 times the light for the same energy
consumption. They also last mcuh longer. However, they need ballasts to
operate them.
Replacing PAR Halogen lamps with CMH lamps can provide significant
energy savings and reduced maintenance.
CMH PAR lamps are available in 20W, 39W, 70W and 100W.
Typical life ratings are 10,000 hours
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
Previous Back to Top
Diamond Precise
Provides MR16 optical control in a 120
volt socket.
Replace 50W PAR or R incandescent
with 21 watt electronic MR16
ConstantColor™
MR16
Reflector
Medium
Screw
Base Electronic 12-volt
Ballast Filament
These are some ideas. Please make independent check for suitability of suggested upgrades. See Disclaimer.
21
rendering)
allasts)
position.
antColor™
tor
GE Value Added Upgrades
Existing Lamp Desired Features Upgrade Option Notes ( pg. refers to GE Lamp Products Catalog 2004)
Fluorescent Systems Upgrades
Energy Savings with F28T8/UMX lamp on Maximum savings: the most efficient retrofit system available today for replacing T12
T12 CW on
about the same mean .77 BF UltraMAXä systems without significant loss in light levels; GE's UltraMAXä ballast is a feature-laden
Electromagnetic Ballast
lumen levels ~ 42% energy savings! electronic ballast, the best value for its price! pg. 4-9
F28T8 UMX F32/WM/XL gives you BOTH energy savings and longer life! You can get more savings
Energy Savings,
F32T8/WM or with F28 but may run into striations in lamp, expecially if temperatures fall to 60F or
same ballast
F32T8/WM/XL below. pg. 4-9
Longer Life, XL have 25% longer life, SXL has 50% longer life; also consider F32T8//WM/XL. pg. 4-
XL and SXL lamps
T8 System on Electronic same ballast 8 - 4-9.
Ballast
More Light, HL (High Lumen) lamps HL lamps give 11% more light than SP
same ballast SPX lamps` SPX lamps give 5% more light than SP. pg. 4-9
Better color,
SPX lamps CRI improves from 78 to 86, also get 5% more light. pg. 4-9.
same ballast
Excellent shatter protection, unique product, superior to competing schemes (tubes, etc.)
T5, T8 and T12 Shatter protection CovRguardÒ
pg. 4-19 - 4-22
HL (High Lumen Lamps)
Reduced Reduce fixture count with fewer lamps to maintain; this is the highest efficacy Fluorescent
New Installations on high BF UltraMAXä
fixture count System available today (including F28) pg. 4-9.
ballasts
Elegant fixtures, indirect lighting, motion sensors, etc.. (T5 is a programmed start ballast)
Old or New Installations Design Improvement T5
pg. 4-7.
Frequent Switching Prolong Lamp Life UltraStartä ballasts These programmed start ballasts prevent short life due to frequent starts.
HID Systems Upgrades
All Metal Halide Energy Savings, Retrofit exisitng fixtures using the same optical assembly: replace MVR400/U with
GE elctronic HID ballast
250-400W Higher Avg. Lumens CMH250 on the elecronic ballast, reduce energy 41% with higher lumens at end of life
Energy Savings
MVR360/StaybrightÒ
(without ballast 10% energy savings AND 15% higher mean lumens! GE # 47685 pg. 3-13
/Watt-MiserÒ
change)
10% to 20% energy savings.
MVR 400 Energy Savings (with 350 PulseArcÒ, 320
320PA-- GE # 45666; 350PA-- GE # 10202; 320CMH-- GE # 17264;
Vertical Burn ballast change) PulseArcÒ, 320 CMHÒ
pg. 3-10-3-11
More Light
MVR400/StaybrightÒ/ 32% higher mean lumens, same energy consumption, same life.
(without ballast
VBU GE # 26865 pg. 3-14
change)
MVR 400 More Light, 15% higher initial lumens, 33% longer life. Does not require socket change like many
MVR400/HOR/MOG
Horizontal burn longer life HOR high output products. GE # 26218, pg. 3-13
Silv-IR
HIR-XLÒ delivers a stunning 6000 hour life in addition to energy savings over std.
Longer Life Retail HIRä
halogen. (pg. 2-5)
HIR-XLÒ
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of
lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer; use of this tool
constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Version 3.0
Sales Opportunity
Estimator
Estimate the lighting sales opportunity involving a certain building or area.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells.
Instructions INPUT
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Lighting and Productivity
Summary Worksheet
Instructions Business Details
Net Sales or Production (annual) $40,000,000
Profit Margin (on incremental sales) 30%
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Equivalent Sales Increase
Calculator
If you did not do the lighting upgrade, how much woiuld you need to grow sales instead
to create the same change in net profit before taxes?
to create the same impact on the bottom line as the lighting upgrade.
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
ysis
al
er;
ved.
Lighting Cost
per Employee
Estimate the amount being spent on Electricity and on Lamps per employee annually.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells.
Instructions INPUT
Burning hours per week 60 Energy rate ($ per kWh) $0.10 No. of Employees 36
Approximate Lamp Life
(hr.) 20,000 Approximate Lamp Cost $1.50 Approximate Sq. feet 6,600
OUTPUT
Annual Energy Cost Annual Lamp Cost Annual Energy Cost per
per Employee $55.22 per Employee $1.53 Square foot (Lighting) $0.30
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Energy Policy Act 2005 © 2006 General
Electric Company
Tax Deduction Incentive Estimator All Rights Reserved
Version 1.8
4 ASHRAE/ IESNA 90.1 (2001) building limit for category 1.3 watts/ sq. ft.
(see Fixture
8 Fixture wattage of proposed system
Watts tab)
45 watts
9 Watts per sq. ft. with proposed system 0.50 watts/ sq. ft.
Tax deduction of $0.30 per sq. ft begins at power density 25% below ASHRAE/ IESNA 90.1 (2001) limit, and goes to $0.60 per sq.
ft. at 40% below ASHRAE/ IESNA limit. (Exception: Warehouses must get to 50% below limit and qualify for $0.60 per sq. ft.)
Other conditions include bi-level switching, automatic turn-off of lights for new buildings over 5000 sq. ft. and illumination levels
satisfying minimum requirements for that space as spelled out in the IES Handbook, 9th edition (2000).
This estimator is for illustrative purposes only. CONTACT A QUALIFIED TAX PROFESSIONAL FOR FULL DETAILS OF
ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS AND FOR INDEPENDENT PROFESSIONAL VERIFICATION OF THE RESULTS AND
CALCULATIONS. GE does not, in any way, imply a warranty of performance or savings predicted by this tool.
Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer which can be accessed from the Home Page. Use of this tool constitutes your
acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2006 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Energy Policy Act 2005 © 2006 General
Electric Company
Multiple Lighting Systems in Facility All Rights Reserved
Version 1.8
4 ASHRAE/ IESNA 90.1 (2001) building limit for category 1.2 watts/ sq. ft.
Enter details of the lighting systems below No. of Fixtures Fixture Watts
7A System 1 Hallways 4-lamp T8 5,000 250
7B System 2 Atrium MVR400 86 460
7C System 3 Patient Rooms 468 68
7D System 4 Office Area T8 4 lamp 660 98
7E System 5
7F System 6
8 Watts per sq. ft. with proposed systems 1.39 watts/ sq. ft.
10 Percent below ASHRAE/ IESNA 90.1 (2001) limit Higher than ASHRAE/ IESNA Limit
11 Qualify for Tax Deduction? NO
12 Tax Deduction per sq. ft. expected NONE per sq. ft
Tax deduction of $0.30 per sq. ft begins when power density is 25% below ASHRAE/ IESNA 90.1 (2001) limit,
and goes linearly to a maximum of $0.60 per sq. ft. when density is 40% below the ASHRAE/ IESNA limit.
(Exception: Warehouses must get to 50% belo
w/sq.ft
NONE NONE 2001
Convention Center 1.4
Dining-Leisure 1.5
Dining-Family 1.9
Gymnasium 1.7
Healthcare 1.6
Library 1.5
Manufacturing 2.2
Motel 2
Movie Theatre 1.6
Museum 1.6
Office 1.3
Parking Garage 0.3
Penitentiary 1.2
Post Office 1.6
Religious 2.2
Retail 1.9
School/University 1.5
Sports Arena 1.5
Town Hall 1.4
Transportation 1.2
Warehouse 1.2
Workshop 1.7
Fixture Count
Estimator
Estimate number of fixtures needed to light an indoor area to a specified light level (foot-candle level).
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells. Note: Do not use this tool for a final layout, it is simply an estimator.
Contact a lighting professional or design firm for proper design.
Instructions INPUT
OUTPUT
Estimated Estimated Estimated Fixture Spacing
no. of Fixtures 118 no. of lamps 236 (feet) 7.5
Total kW load 6.4 Energy cost per year $2,039 Watts per sq. ft. 0.97
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Footcandle
Estimator
Estimate the footcandles achieved in an indoor area when lit with a specified number of fixtures.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells. Note: Do not use this tool for a final layout, it is simply an estimator.
Contact a lighting professional or design firm for proper design.
Instructions INPUT
OUTPUT
Estimated Estimated Estimated Fixture Spacing
Average Footcandles 47 no. of lamps 120 (feet) 7.7
Total kW load 3.2 Energy cost per year $1,458 Watts per sq. ft. 0.90
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Watts/sq. foot
Estimator
Estimate the watts per square foot contribution from two different lighting schemes.
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells.
Instructions INPUT
Area to be lit
(sq. feet) 40,000
System 1 System 2
System Name
(Optional) T12 T8
OUTPUT
System 1 System 2 Reduction
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Understanding Lighting Layouts
= average foot-candles
Work Plane
IMPORTANT NOTE: Lighting Design cannot be based
merely on footcandles These numbers are taken from IESNA
IESNA Recommended Footcandles publications that provide substantial additional information and
must be consulted.
V-2S40-TP
V-2E75-S-TP
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49771 GE-132-MAX-N/Ultra
49766 GE-159-MAX-N/Ultra
49766 GE-159-MAX-N/Ultra
49707 GE-232-MAX-L/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49775 GE-232-MAX-H/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49707 GE-232-MAX-L/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49775 GE-232-MAX-H/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49708 GE-332-MAX-L/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49776 GE-332-MAX-H/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49708 GE-332-MAX-L/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49776 GE-332-MAX-H/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49709 GE-432-MAX-L/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49709 GE-432-MAX-L/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49707 GE-232-MAX-L/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49707 GE-232-MAX-L/Ultra
49772 GE-232-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49767 GE-259-MAX-N/Ultra
49708 GE-332-MAX-L/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49708 GE-332-MAX-L/Ultra
49773 GE-332-MAX-N/Ultra
49709 GE-432-MAX-L/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
49709 GE-432-MAX-L/Ultra
49774 GE-432-MAX-N/Ultra
GEL
GEL Catalog GEL Prod GEL Catalog Prod GEL Catalog GEL Prod GEL Catalog GEL Prod GEL Catalog GEL Prod
Description Code Description Code Description Code Description Code Description Code
B332I277HE/Ultra
B432I277HE/Ultra
Instructions INPUT
Lamp A Lamp B
System or Lamp Name
(Optional) MVR400 T5
OUTPUT
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Retrofit
Options Analyzer
Compare different lighting schemes to retrofit an indoor area -- # fixtures is input, fc is output
Click on the first green cell and tab to the other input cells. Note: Do not use this tool for a final layout, it is simply an estimator. Contact
a lighting professional or design firm for proper design.
Instructions INPUT
Area to be lit Burning hours Energy Rate
(sq. ft.) 10,000 per year 4500 ($ per kWh)
No. of Fixtures 50 50 50
No. of lamps
per fixture 1 6 4
Rated mean lumens
per lamp 23500 2950 4700
OUTPUT
Estimated Mean Footcandles
(over life) 71 61 61
Estimated
Fixture Spacing (feet) 14.1 14.1 14.1
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
put, fc is output
out, it is simply an estimator. Contact
$0.10
Alternate 3
CMH250SPXX-
eHID
50
19500
0.6
269
59
14.1
13.5
$6,053
$4,253
1.3
rcompany.com
Instructions INPUT
Area to be lit Burning hours Energy Rate
(sq. ft.) 18432 per year 4500 ($ per kWh) $0.10
OUTPUT
Estimated
no. of Fixtures 84 76 43 38
Estimated
no. of lamps 504 304 43 38
Estimated
Fixture Spacing (feet) 14.8 15.6 20.7 22.0
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
The Lighting Assistant is a tool offered by GE that examines the projected impact of lighting decisions. Neither this tool nor the analysis
generated by this tool, in any way constitutes or implies either a warranty of lamp or ballast performance or a guarantee of the actual
costs or savings that will be realized or the appropriateness of the solutions suggested. Kindly see and examine the Full Disclaimer;
use of this tool constitutes your acceptance of the Full Disclaimer. Copyright Ó 2005 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved.
Hi-Bay Performance Comparison Tool
45000
Representative fixture
watts shown including
ballast
40000
35000
Average Lumens of Lamps at site
30000
25000
20000
15000
10000
NOTE: Curves shown are approximations based on data determined under ANSI specified test conditions. Performance of individual lamps or groups of lamps
depends on operating conditions and may vary from what is represented here.
5000 © 2006 General Electric Company. All Rights Reserved. Prepared by The Lighting Institute, Nela Park, Cleveland, OH.
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000Burning Hours25000
(S/P)n Tables and
Adjustment Calculator
This tool calculates the (S/P)n adjustment to lumens and footcandles based on the ratio of Scotopic to Photopic Lumens (S/P)
for any light source, for any n specified in the box below. This method has been endorsed by some lighting designers. Note
that there is some controversy about the appropriateness of this method and that the IESNA (Illuminating Engineering Society
of North America) has not (until now, April 2006), accepted this method. GE provides this tool merely as a calculational aid for
customers interested in this method. GE has no opinion about the validity of this adjustment. GREEN cells are user defined,
BLUE cells are calculated
S/P ratio 2.00 S/P index (n) 0.78 "Adjustment" (S/P)n 1.72
Other Lamps
Initial Lamp Lumens Adjustment
(S/P) Ratio Adjusted
Lamp Type (Example shown, but
(typical)
varies with wattage) (S/P)n "CAL-Lumens"
LFL F28SP41
HL/XL/SPX41
1.8
1.8
2750
3100
1.58
1.58
4350
4903
SP50 1.9 2750 1.65 4537
SPX50 2.0 2800 1.72 4808
50
This tool allows you to do simple lighting layouts that include the (S/P) n adjustment to lumens and footcandles based on the ratio of
Scotopic to Photopic Lumens (S/P) for any light source, for any n specified in the box below. This method has been endorsed by
some lighting designers. Note that there is some controversy about the appropriateness of this method and that the IESNA
(Illuminating Engineering Society of North America) has not (until now, April 2006), accepted this method. GE provides this tool merely
as a calculational aid for customers interested in this method and to ilustrate how this calculation is carried out. GE has no opinion
about the validity of this adjustment. GREEN cells are user defined, BLUE cells are calculated
This human eye sensitivity curve called V(l) or the Photopic curve was adopted by CIE, the International Commission on
Color in the 1930’s. The perceived brightness of illumination depends on color: it takes more energy in the blue or red
portion of the spectrum to create the same sensation of brightness as in the yellow-green region. Light meters measuring
lumens and footcandles are designed to mimic the eye sensitivity curve of humans and give more weight to the yellow-
green light. This is an attempt to mimic the perceived brightness of light to the human eye.
The subjects in these original experiments were looking straight ahead in a 2 degree field of view (foveal vision). If the
same brightness matching experiment is carried out with peripheral vision the curve is significantly different. Foveal
vision has a peak response in the yellow-green region (at 555 nm) while peripheral vision peaks in the bluish-green region
(505 nm). Peripheral vision is significantly more sensitive to blue light; therefore, a lamp emitting more blue light will
appear brighter as far as peripheral vision is concerned.
The eye contains two light-sensing cells: rods and cones. Peripheral vision is mediated almost entirely by rods while
foveal vision is mediated by cones. The Photopic V(l) curve represents the sensitivity of the cones while another curve,
the Scotopic V¢(l) curve represents the sensitivity of the rods. Generally accepted measurements like lumens and
footcandles take only cone sensitivity into account and ignore rod sensitivity. At very low light levels vision is entirely
governed by rods and the Scotopic curve is appropriate to use. At intermediate light levels lies the Mesopic region which is
in between the Scotopic and Photopic regions. While it is agreed that rod sensitivity must be taken into account at low light
levels and that rods are more sensitive to light than cones, there is controversy whether rods are also important at normal
indoor light levels.
There is a movement among certain lighting professionals led by Dr. Sam Berman to modify our criteria and to include rod
sensitivity. If we use only cone sensitivity we would use the Photopic curve exclusively. If we use only rod sensitivity we
would use the Scotopic curve exclusively. If we want to be somewhere in-between we could use a mixture of the two.
Berman’s proposal is to multiply the Photopic lumen rating P by (S/P)n where P is Photopic lumens and S is Scotopic
Lumens. If n = 1 we get pure Scotopic lumens and if n = 0 we get pure Photopic lumens. If n is in-between 0 and 1 we get
a weighted average of the two. The question now becomes: what n to use?
Berman proposes that for reading tasks we should use n = 0.78 and for computer tasks n = 1.0. If we are merely
interested in "perceived brightness" of a space, Berman finds n = 0.58 to most correctly predict human response. Berman
also showed that the pupil size depends on Scotopic lumens. Blue-rich light will result in smaller pupils and therefore
provide a sharper image on the retina, along with more depth of focus. It is also true that smaller pupils result in less light
falling on the retina, but Berman’s view is that this is not as important as the improvement in visual acuity resulting from a
sharper image.
When we walk into a space we are taking light in both foveally and peripherally. So our perception of brightness of a
space is likely to be influenced by our Scotopic vision. Whether this brightness perception also impacts task performance
is questionable. Most tasks are carried out with foveal vision. If our eyes are not properly corrected or if the task is close
to visual threshold, the reduced pupil size will improve visual acuity. However, if the task is not near visual threshold,
Boyce and Akashi argue that there is no measurable benefit arising from smaller pupil size.
So, clearly, there is controversy about what measure to use. Some designers have been justifying reduction of footcandle
levels (with accompanying energy savings) when going to higher Color Temperature sources by arguing that the
“corrected” footcandle should be used, e.g. regular IES footcandles multiplied by (S/P) n. This, in essence, amounts to a
redefinition of the lumen and the footcandle. This redefined lumen can be called a "Calibrated" Lumens or humorously
referred to as a “California” lumen since the West Coast is where this approach originated and is being most actively
pursued. The tool provided here allows you to do lighting designs based on regular IES lumens or based on the redefined
CAL-lumen. Note that the IESNA (Illuminating Enginering Society of North America) has not (April 2006) accepted or
endorsed this new method, nor is it likely to do so in the near future. End-users following this path are well advised to
examine an area actually lit with the proposed scheme and to satisfy themselves about light levels as well as appearance
before agreeing to go through with the lighting upgrade.
Web Resources (Internet) Go to EliteNet Login (for GE Distributors)
GElighting.com Organizations/Resources
GE's Lighting Business Page Institute Conferences Illum. Eng. Soc. of N. America (IESNA)
Catalogs (pdf files) Lighting Institute Tour IESNA Publications
Product Brochures Nela Park History Lighting Research Center (LRC)
Sell Sheets GE Edison Awards Program Right Light Consortium
Application Brochures e-training on Lamps and Lighting NCQLP (Lighting Certification)
Testimonials E-catalog National Lighting Bureau (NLB)
Lighting Specifier Newsletters Main Page e-catalog Search National Lighting Product Info Program (NLPIP)
Ballast Retail HIR HIR-XL Silver Saver Diamond Pr National Electrical Mfr. Assoc. (NEMA)
Ballast Product Specs F28T8 T8WM T8/HL/XL UltraMax Energy Star (EPA)
Color Booth T5 HE T5 HO CovRGuard Cold Temp Green buildings Council (LEED)
General Lighting Information CMH Hi-Watt CMHPAR e-HID Ballast Non-cycl HPS International Dark Sky Assoc. (IDA)
Specifying Lamp Color Segment Selling Information Lighting Information Office (Div. of EPRI)
Lamp Spectral Curves Hospitality Consortium for Energy Efficiency (CEE)
IES Files for Reflector Lamps Restaurant Lighting Education Resources (Compiled by IDA)
"Specifying Light and Color" brochure Healthcare www.lighting.com (Online Resource)
GE Lighting Toolkit Property Management Environmental Resources
Glossary of Lighting Terms Retail Lighting Environmental Information (GE page)
GE FAQ's about LIGHTING (Useful!) Residential Builders LampRecycle.org
Energy Eficient Lighting for Home (pdf) Benefits of working with GE Disposal Laws by State
CFL's for home US/Canada Sales Offices (GE) Recycling Companies
GE's Home Lighting Products International Sales Offices (GE) Handling broken Fluorescent Lamps (NEMA)
Web Cross Reference Tool OSHA Web Site
GE is not responsible for the content of external web sites, these are provided merely for convenience Resources for Identifying Rebate Programs New!
Energy Policy Act, 2005 New! Utility Rebate Program List from Edison Electric Institute
FAQ's from EfficientBuildings.org ASHRAE/ IESNA Standard 90.1 - 2001 US Dept.of Energy
NEMA 2-page Overview of the Act Complete (official) text of the Energy Policy Act CEE Consortium for Energy Efficiency
NEMA Assessment of the Act NEMA Complete Description of the Act RealWinWin.com
Miscellaneous Lighting Publications and Articles on the Web
California Title 24 (2005) PDF CEE list of High Performing LFL lamps/ballast Cutting Edge Retrofits
Ashrae 90.1 (2004) ONLINE Lighting and Productivity I HiBays
Advanced Lighting Guidelines (Download) Lighting and Productivity II Search for a Lighting Manufacturer
Lighting Terminology (LRC) Lighting and Productivity III Lighting Answers (NLPIP)
Lighting Answers (NLPIP) Lighting for Older Adults (LRC) Lighting Links (NALMCO)
NLB articles Outdoor Lighting Regulations Luminaire Dirt Depreciation
New!
User Notes
Version 3.0
This is an alphabetical listing of the Excel Worksheet tools available on the Home page of the
GE Lighting Assistant Version 3.0 March 2006) The number (##) refers to the worksheet page
where you will find this tool.
Make sure you print out this page and examine all the tools first.
(34) COL Pie Chart (Cost of Light Pie Chart) INFO: The 4-8-88 rule explained in a graphic.
(7) Cost of Waiting: When the end user becomes aware of energy savings being available with
an upgrade, they may say something like: “ Oh, that sounds great, we’ll put a proposal in and
budget this for next year.” What they may not be aware is that there is a cost to continuing to
operate inefficient lighting systems. Every month they postpone the upgrade results (effectively)
in throwing a certain amount of money away on excess energy costs. This tool brings the point
home. It is essentially the same as the Simple Energy Estimator except, instead of showing the
energy savings possible it displays the energy money being “thrown away” each month and each
year by postponing the upgrade.
(12) Cross Reference Tool: This is a set of sheets that makes it easy for you to identify the
ordering code for a particular lamp, starting out with an ordering code for any major manufacturer.
For example, if someone brings in a competitive lamp you can quickly identify the GE product
that is its equivalent.
(8) Environmental Impact: You can plug in information on the new and old system and the tool
calculates not only the energy saved in kWh, but also the reduction in greenhouse gases (carbon
dioxide emissions), the equivalent area of new forest that would have the same beneficial impact,
and the equivalent number of cars being taken off the road that would create the same reduction
in greenhouse emissions.
(15) Equivalent Sales Increase: This is a simple way of showing the customer the impact on the
bottom line: how much they would need to increase sales by just to have the same impact on the
bottom line as the energy-saving upgrade you are proposing.
(19) Fixture Count Estimator: This tool allows you to estimate the number of fixtures it would
take to light up an area to a desired Footcandle level. It is a useful estimator, but, of course, the
final layout should be done with professional software. A key number for this calculation is the
Coefficient of Utilization (CU) which stand for the percentage of lumens emitted by the lamp which
finally find their way to the work plane (e.g. table surface). Typically, CU ranges from 50% to 75%
depending on the efficiency of the fixture, the reflectance of the walls, floor and ceiling, etc.. For a
first pass a value of 0.60 (60%) should be used.
Note that this tool asks for the mean rated lumen of the lamp, not the initial lumens. Some
professional software use the initial lumens and the use a “Light Loss Factor” which includes
lumen depreciation and other factors like dirt depreciation, light reduction from voltage fluctuation
and temperature effects, etc.. In this tool the CU number is meant to include both CU and light
loss factor, and so an appropriate adjustment can be made if these light loss factors are
(19) Fixture Count Estimator: This tool allows you to estimate the number of fixtures it would
take to light up an area to a desired Footcandle level. It is a useful estimator, but, of course, the
final layout should be done with professional software. A key number for this calculation is the
Coefficient of Utilization (CU) which stand for the percentage of lumens emitted by the lamp which
finally find their way to the work plane (e.g. table surface). Typically, CU ranges from 50% to 75%
depending on the efficiency of the fixture, the reflectance of the walls, floor and ceiling, etc.. For a
first pass a value of 0.60 (60%) should be used.
Note that this tool asks for the mean rated lumen of the lamp, not the initial lumens. Some
professional software use the initial lumens and the use a “Light Loss Factor” which includes
lumen depreciation and other factors like dirt depreciation, light reduction from voltage fluctuation
and temperature effects, etc.. In this tool the CU number is meant to include both CU and light
loss factor, and so an appropriate adjustment can be made if these light loss factors are
considered to be significant.
(23) Fixture Replacement: This tool allows comparison of two different lighting schemes. For
example, if one has a space lit with MVR400/U fixtures and is considering replacing them with
(say) 6-lamp T8 fixtures. This tool provides two numbers: (1) if you do a one-for-one fixture
replacement (i.e. have the same number of fixtures) how much will the average light level
change? (100% means the light level is unchanged.) and (2) to achieve the same average light
level, how many T8 fixtures would you need. Note that the tool is doing a simple calculation
involving CU’s and mean rated lamp lumens etc. It does not take into account changes in light
distribution patterns that might justify going to lower average light levels.
(2) Fixture Wattage Tool: Users complained that there was no easy way to find out fixture watts
to put in the various calculators--for example, what is the wattage of a 2-lamp F32WM fixture on a
high ballast factor UltraMax ballast?. This tool was designed to arrive at approximate wattage
numbers with a few clicks. See also, Selected Fixture Wattages.
(20) Footcandle Estimator: This tool is similar to (and the complement of) the Fixture Count
Estimator. Please read that description also. He difference is: this tool estimates the light level
given a certain number of fixtures, while that tool estimates the number of fixtures required to
achieve a given light level in a space.
(11) Group Relamping Economizer: Group relamping can save money on maintenance costs.
The per-lamp cost of replacing a lamp will be less if you change out all the lamps at one time,
rather than replacing them one at a time as they fail. True, the users are buying more lamps but
they spend less on labor. Particularly with fluorescent lamps (for which this tool is designed)
lamps are relatively inexpensive compared to the labor of replacing a lamp. This tool takes the
relevant cost numbers for an installation and plots the average maintenance costs based on when
they choose to group relamp. If the curve shows a minimum, then that is the point where costs
are minimum. A second sheet (#11A) provides a write-up explaining the logic of group relamping.
(9) Hi Calc (Inc-Halogen lamp life) This tool tells you how the life, lumens etc. of a lamp varies
as you change the voltage coming in to the socket, e.g. what happens if you operate a 120 volt
lamp at 125 volts, a 130 volt lamp at 120 volts, and so on.
(26) High-Bay Comparison: Allows you to see average light level comparisons for different
systems. The selector allows you to toggle individual systems on and of, so you can pick the
specific systems you wish to compare. Most of these plots assume that you will be group
relamping at 70% of life.
(3) Investment Calculator: A convenient way of calculating the total investment required to
upgrade the site. If more than one system is involved, you need to add the individual investment
on each system.
(6) Life-Cycle Cost: This tool calculates the average cost of owning and operating a lamp over
its life. It is useful for comparing effective costs when the existing and proposed lamps have very
different life ratings. For each lamp, the tool adds up one lamp cost, one labor cost and energy
used over life, and amortizes it over the life of the lamp. It finally converts this number to an
average cost of owning and operating the lamp for a year.
(14) Lighting and Productivity: It seems plausible that an improvement in Lighting can lead to
increased productivity. However, it is impossible to come up with a specific number in a
statement such as: “if you increase footcandles from 30 to 40, you will get a 3% improvement in
productivity!”
So we choose an alternate approach. We appeal to the sensibilities of the end-user and say: “do
you think an improvement in lighting could lead to a half percent improvement in productivity… , a
one percent improvement… ?” Then we say: “let me show you what a half percent improvement
means!” This tool examines a half percent (or one percent or whatever you put in) improvement
in productivity and shows what impact it has on the bottom line (profit). Then it calculates how
used over life, and amortizes it over the life of the lamp. It finally converts this number to an
average cost of owning and operating the lamp for a year.
(14) Lighting and Productivity: It seems plausible that an improvement in Lighting can lead to
increased productivity. However, it is impossible to come up with a specific number in a
statement such as: “if you increase footcandles from 30 to 40, you will get a 3% improvement in
productivity!”
So we choose an alternate approach. We appeal to the sensibilities of the end-user and say: “do
you think an improvement in lighting could lead to a half percent improvement in productivity… , a
one percent improvement… ?” Then we say: “let me show you what a half percent improvement
means!” This tool examines a half percent (or one percent or whatever you put in) improvement
in productivity and shows what impact it has on the bottom line (profit). Then it calculates how
much you could justify spending on lighting and still get a one-year payback based on the profit
that resulted from the lighting enhancement.
The purpose of this tool is to show the prospect that even a small productivity improvement could
cost-justify almost any lighting upgrade.
LightPRO Training: (external link) This package contains lamp and product information as well
as basic lighting knowledge. People new to lighting can use this as a short e-training course,
while experienced Lighting Salespersons can use this as an easy reference (e.g. "I forgot... what
exactly is THD... Total Harmonic Distortion...???)
(16) Lighting Cost per Employee: Many businesses are unaware of how little they are
spending on lamps. This tool calculates the amortized cost per year of lamps being used at the
site as well as energy and lighting maintenance cost per employee. It helps to highlight that the
amount spent per employee on lighting is very small, and that investing in better lamps can
provide better working conditions for a very small expense.
(35) Lighting Layouts (Overview) : A sheet explaining the basic principles behind lighting layout
calculations and providing recommended footcandle levels for typical applications. This sheet
allows you to understand many of the other tools in the package.
(5) Motion Sensors and Dimming: When a dimming system is used with a predictable and
repeated schedule it is possible to calculate the effective wattage of the new system. For
example, if a 100 watt lamp is burned at full wattage for 50% of the time and half wattage for 50%
the time, the “effective” watts will be 75 watts. This is simple and intuitive, but for more
complicated schedules this tool will be useful. In calculating total kWh, then, the user must
understand that all the time (including the hours burned at zero watts) must be included in the
formula: energy used in watt-hours = effective watts (from this estimator) x (burning hours).
(18) Tax Incentive Estimator (Energy Policy Act of 2005): If a space has several lighting
systems, this tool calculates the total watts per sq. ft. for the space and compares it to the
requirment for a tax incentive.
(25) New Installation Analyzer: This is a variation of the Retrofit Options Analyzer. There you
specified the number of fixtures, here you specify the footcandles desired and the program
estimates the number of fixtures needed to achieve that level of illumination. This is, therefore
useful in comparing different schemes which would call for different numbers of fixtures used in
lighting the same space.
(31) Representative CU's (INFO): Shows the Coefficients of Utilization for different fixture types,
a key number for estimating lighting layouts. CU's can vary widely between fixtures and also
depend on room geometry, wall and ceiling reflectances etc.. Therefore, it is necessary to contact
fixture manufacturers for specific CU's. However, this tool provides a useful table of CU's for a
first pass comparison.
(24) Retrofit Options Analyzer: This tool allows you to analyze up to four different lighting
schemes for the same space. For each scheme you specify the number of fixtures, the wattage
per fixture, the lamp lumens, etc.. and the tool estimates footcandle levels and energy costs.
(27) (S/P) Tables for Light Sources: Lists S/P ratios for various light sources and also calculates
(S/P)n for various user-specified n. See (28) Area Layout using S/P ratios and (28A) (S/P) Ratio
Debate(Overview)
(28A) (S/P) Ratio Debate (Overview): A summary of the various facts and opinions behind
todays S/P Ratio controversy.
(13) Sales Opportunity Estimator: If you are driving by a building and estimate the square
footage of space, this tool will give you a sense of how many lamps and ballasts are involved.
per fixture, the lamp lumens, etc.. and the tool estimates footcandle levels and energy costs.
(27) (S/P) Tables for Light Sources: Lists S/P ratios for various light sources and also calculates
(S/P)n for various user-specified n. See (28) Area Layout using S/P ratios and (28A) (S/P) Ratio
Debate(Overview)
(28A) (S/P) Ratio Debate (Overview): A summary of the various facts and opinions behind
todays S/P Ratio controversy.
(13) Sales Opportunity Estimator: If you are driving by a building and estimate the square
footage of space, this tool will give you a sense of how many lamps and ballasts are involved.
(32) Selected Fixture Wattages: Shows wattage of common systems, LFL (4 foot) and HID in a
conveninet one-page reference.
(1) Simple Energy Estimator: This tool calculates the energy used and the energy saved with a
potential upgrade. If a cost per fixture (to upgrade) is put in, the tool calculates the time it would
take to recover the investment from energy savings alone. Note that the tool does not consider
the life of the lamps or the additional A/C savings. It is a simple and direct calculation of energy
savings and is often adequate to get to the heart of the matter. The savings shown by this simple
calculation is often sufficient to justify the upgrade.
If the existing and proposed lamps have very different life ratings, use the Life Cycle Cost
Estimator. If you want to take into account labor savings in the first few years—which could be
substantial—use Value*Light. Value*Light keeps track of lamp and ballast replacement costs on a
month by month basis. Since the new system (typically new lamps and new ballasts) will have
few failures in the early years, this saving—compared to what they would be spending on
maintenance if they continued with the old system—can be a significant contributor to payback.
(4) Simple Payback Calculator: This is a more sophisticated version of the Simple Energy
Estimator. The tool allows you to include labor savings and A/C savings in addition to energy
savings in calculating the payback. The “Cooling Multiplier” must be input manually (see notes on
the tool). As with all the tools the light green cells are the input cells.
(30) Suggested Light Levels (Info): Although lighting design is about much more than light
levels, it is useful to have a page that lists IES recommended light levels for various types of
spaces
(10) System Lumen Comparison: This is a very useful tool that displays the lumens versus time
coming from a fixture. Two copies are provided here and in each, three different lighting schemes
can be shown on the graph at the same time. The drop down lists accessed by hovering the
mouse over the column heading displays the life. Lumens etc.. of different lamps as a quick
reference.
(17) Tax Incentive Estimator (Energy Policy Act of 2005): This tool allows you to provide your
customers with a simple review of the potential tax incentive as it relate to their installation. Drop
down tools activated by buttons that toggle on and off allow calculation of light levels and of
energy svings while satisfying power density limits.
(22) Upgrade Options by Fixture: Probably the most useful and important tool in this package.
Starting with the fixture you see overhead and with just a few clicks you will learn what beneficial
upgrades are available to your end-user. This tool is a starting point for the Lighting Assistant!
Once you have identified the options, then you can use the other tools to perform calculations on
energy savings, light levels, and so on.
(33) Utility Rebates (INFO): Many electric utilities offer rebates for energy efficient upgrades
which can be substantial and which make a significant difference in the economic justification of
the retrofit. Here are a few web sites that provide links to various utility web sites organized by
state. A little research can unearth attractive incentives!
(12A) Value-added Listing: This one sheet contains most of the significant value added
opportunities and is a convenient reference sheet.
Value*Light(TM) Value Light is GE’s top-of-the-line lighting audit tool for energy saving
upgrades. This link will run Value Light if you have it already loaded on your computer. If you
don’t have Value Light, contact your GE Sales Rep for access.
(21) Watts per Square Foot: Many codes and regulations attempting to limit energy consumption
specify upper limits on watts of electricity used per square foot of area space to illuminate the
space (e.g. 1.6 watts per sq. foot). Often there will be several lighting systems operating in the
same space: general lighting, track lighting, task lighting, etc., and the net load must be
calculated. This tool allows a simple comparison of two different lighting schemes. If several
(12A) Value-added Listing: This one sheet contains most of the significant value added
opportunities and is a convenient reference sheet.
Value*Light(TM) Value Light is GE’s top-of-the-line lighting audit tool for energy saving
upgrades. This link will run Value Light if you have it already loaded on your computer. If you
don’t have Value Light, contact your GE Sales Rep for access.
(21) Watts per Square Foot: Many codes and regulations attempting to limit energy consumption
specify upper limits on watts of electricity used per square foot of area space to illuminate the
space (e.g. 1.6 watts per sq. foot). Often there will be several lighting systems operating in the
same space: general lighting, track lighting, task lighting, etc., and the net load must be
calculated. This tool allows a simple comparison of two different lighting schemes. If several
overlapping systems are present, their individual watts per square foot must be added. Note that
there are complex specifications when it comes to track lighting, dimming systems and motion
sensors and a thorough understanding of the code is necessary for a professional evaluation.
(11A) Why Group Relamping? (INFO): A short write up explaining the beneffits of group
relamping both for Linear Fluorescent Systems and for Metal Halide Systems.
FULL DISCLAIMER.
(It is important to include this disclaimer when providing analysis to a customer or end-
user so they understand fully that the assumptions and scenarios covered by this tool do
not, in any way, imply a warranty of performance or savings predicted by this tool.)
This tool is aimed at assisting users in decision-making by providing analysis based on various
assumptions and a variety of factors. While an effort has been made to use accurate assumptions
and factors in developing this tool, GE MAKES NO WARRANTY OR GUARANTEE, EXPRESS
OR IMPLIED, (i) THAT THE RESULTS DESCRIBED HEREIN WILL BE OBTAINED UNDER END-
USE CONDITIONS, OR (ii) AS TO THE EFFECTIVENESS, SAFETY OT APPROPRIATENESS
OF ANY DESIGN INCORPORATING GE MATERIALS, PRODUCTS, USES,
RECOMMENDATIONS OR ADVICE. IN NO EVENT SHALL GE BE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY
LOSS RESULTING FROM ANY USE OF THIS TOOL.
Each user bears full responsibility for making its own determination as to the suitability of GE's
materials, products, recommendations, analyses, or advice for its own particular use. Each user
must identify and perform all tests and analyses necessary to assure that its products and designs
incorporating GE material or products will be safe and suitable for use under end-use conditions.
Nothing in this or any other document, nor any oral recommendation or advice, shall be deemed to
alter, vary, supersede, or waive any provision of this Disclaimer, unless any such modification is
specifically agreed to in writing signed by GE. No statement contained herein concerning a
possible or suggested use of any material, product or design is intended, or should be construed,
to grant any license under any patent or other intellectual property right of General Electric
Company or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates covering such use or design, or as a
recommendation for the use of such material, product or design in the infringement of any patent
or other intellectual property right. Questions about models and assumptions used in these
calculations may be addressed to the Lighting Institute, GE Consumer and Industrial, Nela Park,
Cleveland OH 44112. Tel: (216) 266 9000. e-mail: [email protected].