CBR Writting
CBR Writting
Lecturer:
Authors
Table of Contents
PREFACE 1
TABLE OF CONTENTS…………………………………………………………………………………2
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 3
I.I. BACKGROUND OF CRITICAL BOOK REVIEW 3
CHAPTER II SUMMARY…………………………………………………..…………………………..5
CHAPTER 1: THE BRIEF REVIEW OF CULTURE……………………………………………………..5
CHAPTER 2: THE INTERCULTURAL COMMUNICATION……………...……………………………7
CHAPTER 3: THE ADDRESSING, GREETING PEOPLE, and MAKING
INTRODUCTION………………………………………………………………………………………...10
CHAPTER 4: THE POWER OF SMALL TALK…………………………………………………..…….12
CHAPTER 5: THE COMPLIMENT and ALLOCATION………………………….…………………….15
CHAPTER 6: BUILDING COMMUNICATION and INTERACTION…………………………………17
CHAPTER 7: CONTACTING PEOPLE ACROSS CULTURE………………………………………….20
CHAPTER 8: THE TELEPHONE ETIQUETTES AND LANGUAGE…………….……………………21
CHAPTER 9: THE NON-VERBAL COMMUNICATION………………………………………………25
CHAPTER 10: THE EXPRESSIONS OF EMOTIONS………………………………………………….28
CHAPTER 11: The Exchanges of Cultural Viewpoints…………………………………………………..30
CHAPTER 11: The Exchanges of Cultural Viewpoints…………………………………………………..32
CHAPTER III
DISCUSSION…………………………………………………………………………….33 III.I
STRENGHTS…………………………………………………………………………………………..34
III.II
WEAKNESSES…………………………………………………………………………………………34
CHAPTER IV CLOSING……………………………………………………………………………….35
IV. I CONCLUSION……...………………………………………………………35
IV.II SUGGESTION……………………………………………………………...35
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
In this Critical Book Review we learn that cross-cultural understanding refers to the ability to
appreciate, respect, and communicate and interact effectively with people from different cultural
backgrounds. This involves recognizing and valuing the diversity of beliefs, values, customs and
traditions that exist in various societies throughout the world. Developing cross-cultural
understanding is essential in today's globalized world to foster empathy, reduce
misunderstandings, and increase cooperation between individuals and communities with diverse
cultural backgrounds.
1. To fulfill the CBR assignment for the leadership course given by Mam Elisa Betty Manullang
S.S, M.Hum.
2. Train students to think critically in finding information and analyzing the differences that exist
in the book Cross Cultural Communication.
3. Strengthen and improve understanding of Language and Culture, especially in the evaluation
section in the field of literature. Increase critical power and strengthen English Literature
material.
2. Obtaining information from books that can be used as implications and solutions when
implementing teaching materials.
3. Obtaining critical thoughts in reporting the discussion of the contents of the book Cross
Cultural Communication.
Title: Understanding Language and Culture For Global Communication And Interaction
Published: 2022
Pages: 186
CHAPTER II
SUMMARY
CHAPTER 1: THE BRIEF REVIEW OF CULTURE
A.Culture is learned
Human does not inherit culture hat's why, culture is learned. So to learn culture is important
because by learning one can acquire, understand, adopt the culture systematically and
strongly.They need to be learned to pre serve and to develop as well.
B.Culture is abstract.
Culture is called abstract because the very basic term of culture is way of thought or way
of thinking or way of reference. When wea talk about culture as a way of thought, it exists in
minds.
C.Culture is shared.
The culture domain either material or immaterial,A pattern of behaviors, languages. dances,
and many other forms of culture are shared from time to time.
D.Culture is pervasive.
Culture as a total system in the life of the society is pervasive It is called pervasive because
culture touches every aspect of life.
E.Culture is transmitted.
The culture ways are learned by persons from persons. Many of them are handed down' by
one' elders, parents or even teachers It is a fact that one does not acquire the behavior patterns
spon- tenaciously. He learns it. This means that culture is transmitted by learning.
F.Culture is changing.
The changing of culture is unavoidable
The change of culture may be in terms of developing to be better,minimizing, or even fading of
certain cultural systems.
5. Intercultural Miscommunication.
It is a fact that there are often more problems in cross-cultural or intercultural
communication between and among people of differ ent cultural backgrounds. This happens
because each participant may interpret the other speech or language expressed according to his
cultural conventions and expectation.
Regarding intercultural miscommunication, Barna proposes some factors leading to
miscommunication in the intercultural communication process. The following factor is as
follows:
1.Assumption of similarities:This refers to our tendency to think about how we behave and act is
the universally accepted rule of behavior. When someone differs, we have a negative view of
them.
2. Language differences:Talking the same language itself can sometimes lead to discrepancies as
some words have different meanings in various contexts, countries, or cultures.
3. Nonverbal misinterpretation:The way we dress, the way we express ourselves through our
body language, eye contact and gestures also communicates something. A simple gesture like
nodding the head is considered to be YES in certain cultures and NO in others.
4. Preconceptions and stereotypes:Stereotypes involves putting people into pre-defined slots
based on our image of how we think they are or should be.
But stereotypes may lead to wrongful expectations and notions. A preconceived opinion of
another can lead to bias and discrimination.
5. A tendency to evaluate: Humans tend to make sense of the behavior and communication of
others by analyzing them from one's cultural point of view without taking into consideration why
the other person is behaving or communicating a certain way.
6.High anxiety: Sometimes being confronted with a different cultural perspective will create an
anxious state in an individual who does not know how to act or behave and what is considered to
be appropriate.
1. Addressing Form.
In terms of addressing. (Wardhaugh, 1992) states that address terms are the terms in the forms of
words, phrases, names, titles or the combination of them which are used to address the interlocutors or
other persons. The address terms are used by the speaker to, among others, to respect other people,
show familiarity or unfamiliarity, show intimacy, and show social status.
The individual forms of address terms can indicate the social back ground of the speakers.
Contrastively, the social relationship between the speakers leads to the use of different address terms. A
choice of address terms signals have the relationship between language and the society and how a
person imagines his or her relationship with the ad dresses within this society. Here are some common
address express sions of different society and culture.
2. Greetings.
The word 'greeting' means is an act of communication in which hu man beings intentionally make
their presence known to each other, to show attention to, and to suggest a type of relationship (usually
cordial) or social status (formal or informal) between individuals or groups of people coming in contact
with each other. Greetings sometimes are used before a conversation or to greet in passing, such as on a
sidewall or trail, or other public places. While greeting customs are highly culture and situation-specific
and may change within a culture depending on social status and relationship, they exist in all known
human cultures.
In a real sense, greetings can be expressed both audibly and physically, and often involve a
combination of the two. This topic exclude military and ceremonial salutes but includes rituals other
than gestures A greeting, or salutation, can also be expressed in written communications, such as letters
and emails. A greeting can consist of an exchange of formal expression, kisses, handshakes, hugs, and
various gestures. The form of greeting is determined by social etiquette, as well as by the relationship of
the people.
Beyond the formal greeting, which may involve a verbal A knowledgment and sometimes a
handshake, facial expression, gestures, body language and eye contact can all signal what type of
greeting is expect ed. Gestures are the most obvious signal, for instance greeting some one with open
arms is generally a sign that a hug is expected. However, crossing arms can be interpreted as a sign of
hostility. The facial ex pression, body language, and eye contact reflect emotions and interest levels. A
frown, slouching and lowered eye contact suggests disinterest. while smiling and and exuberant attitude
is a sign of welcome.
3. Making Introduction.
The language usages to introduce oneself in English can be classified by the formality of the
situation. Generally, the phrases and or ex pressions are likely different from formal and informal
situation. Here are the common phrases or expressions used by the English people to introduce
himself or herself.
A. Informal:"Hi, I am Mike."
"Nice to meet you.
(After someone has told you his name.)
"I am Veron."
B. .Informal or formal:
"Hello. My name is Evita. "
"It is nice to meet you. My name is Vannesa."
C. Formal
"Let me introduce myself. My name is George."
"I don't believe we've met. I am Mark."
Actually, the silence (time when there's no sound) you get when two people don't have anything to say
is called an awkward silence. Awkward means uncomfortable and embarrassing,
To avoid these awkward silences, you need to know how to make small talk in English. For Americans,
for instance, silence is often-awkward. But it may be not so in many other cultures. Take a look the
following testimony of an immigrant in US.
This chapter mainly discusses about small talks as an initial express sion to start a conversation with
other people you already know or you don't know yet.
In fact, on the other hand, learning to make small talk can help to build your confidence so that
you can start conversations, make connec-tions, and develop your social skills.
In addition, some other linguists propose that small talks also able to:
a. Help people decide if they want to get to know each other better b. Think that if a person
doesn't make small talk, then he or she not friendly (Friendliness is something that is important
for Amer cans.)
e. Help people feel comfortable with each other, especially at the be ginning of a conversation
(for example, in a phone conversation).
d. Be able to lead to conversations about more interesting, more serious , and more important
topics
B. CULTURAL NOTES
In every culture, there are certain topics that people commonly talk about. When people make
small talk, they talk about things like the weather, sports, their weekend, and so on. The topic
may be unimportant, but small talk itself is important. But if doing business or pleasure takes you
to Scandinavia coun- tries such Sweden, Finland, or Norway, you are to be shocked.
A small talk is actually meaningful expression in our communication, For examples, in
Argentina, Chili and Venezuela, politics is regarded to be taboo and asking marital status, for
African people is regarded rude and taboo.
B. CULTURAL NOTES
It is a fact that western people, especially Americans, give compliments when interacting and
communicating
Mostly they tend to deny it by saying 'No, it is not true, 'or 'I don't think so' or 'you are kidding'
etc. It seems that people are happy when someone compliments them but many people don't feel
modest or humble if they accept the compliment with a 'Thank you' or 'Thank
To build effective communication and interaction, the communi- cation experts propose five
ways to be an active and effective listener
a. Face the speaker. Show your attentiveness through body language
b. Maintain eye contact. To a degree, you both feel comfortable.
c. Keep an open mind. Wait until the other person finishes a thought before deciding you agree
or disagree.
d. Minimize external distractions, for example, drop your phone, push your computer aside, and
focus on the conversation.
e. Engage. Ask a question, paraphrase points the other person ha made, and only offer your
advice if the other person asks for it.
2. Interrupting in English
Excuse me, but I don't quite understand.
I am sorry, but I have a question.
Could I ask a question?
Sorry to interrupt, but I don't Understand.
Could I interrupt for a quick second?
Just a quick interruption, if that's okay.
Those sentences are usually used when you interrupt someone when he or she is speaking
Actually here are only some sentences of many ways how to interrupt people when speaking.
In general, interruption during the communication process is regarded and stereotyped as a
negative act or bad. And too many interruptions during conversation and or communication are
also regarded as rude. Also, it is kind of wasting time during the communication process.
In a positive perspective, interruption is important to do because it is also one of the ways to
build interaction and to sustain the flow of conversation when communicating. So that why, it is
sometimes necessary to interrupt politely to ask a question.
Again, the interruption is not something bad in communication if it is done in a proper
moment and proper language usages.
3. Guiding the Conversation When you involving in conversation, actually it is easy sometimes
to lose control of conversation especially for the non-native speaker of English due to lack of
English mastery or cultural differences.
To communicate in a multicultural event with different people across the globe, you need to
know how to guide the conversation to make the conversation flow well and a misunderstanding
can be avoided
4. Interacting in Group
Interacting in a group or 'group interaction' or 'small g group inter- action' is similarly by term.
The real sense, the group interaction or interacting in a group are probably in the forms of
discussion, focus group discussion, small meeting, class discussion, or meeting at work, etc. As
students, academicians, company workers, or even state figures, the interaction in a group can be
avoided in your daily life because it is a part of your own business. As a matter of fact, in many
cases, involvement in group interaction is not easy to do.
B. CULTURAL NOTES
In some cultures, including American culture, people usually say something to the speaker to
show they are listening and that they understanding. In the communication process, it is a kind of
feedback. In any social interaction and communication, people sometimes interrupt the speaker
to ask questions so that they understand. However, having interruption during the
communication process is sometimes influenced by cultural habits and individual matters.
In some cultures, it is very rude to tell someone that they are wrong or that they have made
mistake especially in front of the people. The person may become embarrassed, and can 'lose
face.
In American culture American usually to correct someone, they usually often begins with a
'softening' sounds such as 'uh' or 'uhm' or a word or phrases such as 'well.' Or 'I think,' or
'Actually' before disagreeing with someone. For example, 'I think, you may be wrong,' with an
emphasis on 'may and nat 'you.
The problem is to get to know and build a conversation with the people from a different culture
is not always as easy as getting to know the people from one's own culture. So, having good
conversation skills is a really good asset for everyone he communicating today, especially with
someone new and or with someone from different cultural backgrounds. This chapter mainly
discusses about making the conversation mov ing, making the first move, and asking without
judging.
B. CULTURAL NOTES
Greetings and openings in most languages mean almost the same, but sometimes their word-
for-word translations are very different. Here are the examples 'How are you' stated or expressed
differently among cultures.The common expression 'See you later' is a common way of say- ing
'Goodbye' in American English. However, it doesn't mean that 'I'll see you later. Empirically, one
day, an American woman said 'See you later' to a non-native English speaker who does not
understand well the expression. She thinks that the American woman will come on the day after
so she waits but the American woman doesn't show up. A non native speaker of English feels
disappointed. This happens because a non- native speaker woman translates the expression 'See
you later' literally. This of course can lead to embarrassment due to misunderstanding.
Not all conversations in every language and culture are like ping- pong. In some languages and
cultures, one person may speak longer than the other person. However, a good conversation in
English is like a ping-pong game with the speakers going back and forth and talking in turns to
speak.
Because of the many differences, everyone should apply good methods and ethics to avoid
misunderstandings and social awkwardness between people of different cultures, especially in
public spaces. By etiquette, a person knows how to act in any circumstances, he will feel
comfortable in an unfamiliar environment. Telephone etiquette refers to the way a person speaks
on the telephone.
2. Telephone Etiquette
In online communication, one still has the time to devise a great answer and think about
what you are going to speak about before you press «enter» When you are talking to someone in
the flesh, you can use facial expressions and body language to convey your message. CHAPTER
8 your So it is clear that telephone etiquette is essential to learn how one should interact with the
other person over the phone because we communicate by telephone and are unable to see the
facial expression and the body language of the other person and vice versa.
A universal telephone ring
Do not say, «Hello, it's Syndi, call me back.» At least state the subject about which you want the
person to call you back about. The person on the telephone takes precedence over someone who
happens to walk in your office or passes by while you are on the phone. Always, leave your re-
turn telephone number as part of your message, including the area code and S-L-O-W-L-Y,
including REPEATING your telephone number at the end of your message. If you are in a
meeting during certain times and state you will monitor your expecting an important call, inform
the caller you will be message indicator for when it illuminates you will excuse yourself to leave
the meeting and return the call.
3. Telephone Languages
Telephone etiquette does not only refer to the acts of telephoning but also the language use
over the phone. Many argue that telephoning is one of the most difficult things to do especially
in another language. English, for example.
As it is generally known that good phone etiquette is important be cause we cannot see the facial
expressions and body language of the other person and they cannot see us. We must compensate
by choosing our words carefully and using much more tone inflection to convey our message
than if we were face to face.
B. CULTURAL NOTES
«Phubbing» simply means snubbing someone you're talking to look at a cell phone. That
may be particularly harmful because phubbing happens all the time. Phubbing may also hurt
your reputation. This happens because they don't know the rules, etiquettes, and the language use
of the telephoning
To be able to communicate via telephone across culture, in terms of language use, one should
speak slowly and clearly and use simple language. Even though the etiquette and language use of
telephoning to some extent vary from culture to culture, or from society to society, but to be a
good listener on the phone is universal. By having good listening skills, you will be able to
communicate by phone effectively and properly. To be able to do so, you should have good
listening skills.
In general, many researches show that 60% of all human communication is non-verbally
language, 30% is your tone, so it means that 90% of what your saying is not coming from of
your mouth. Another research also shows similar data in which 86% of human communication is
through non- verbal language and the rest is about 14% by words.
Those statements mean that developing an awareness of why hear- ing words is not sufficient to
discern meaning because in many cases, silence communicates is more than speech. In short it
can be concluded that non-verbal communication is very important in human communication.
Non-verbal language is truly powerful one to convey the meaning of the communication.
B. CULTURAL NOTES
Americans typically look directly into each other's eyes when talk- ing, conveying
informality, spontaneity, and equality in their exchange of glances. When eyes shift and avoid
meeting those of the other per- son, Americans may sense disinterest or perhaps even deception.
How- ever, a lack of consistent and strong eye contact may be a sign of res pect or humility in
other cultures. In some Asian cultures, eyes may be downcast or sweeping, and this often
disturbs Americans.
Deep below the "water line" is a culture's core values. These are primarily learned ideas of what
is good, right, desirable, and acceptable is, as well as what is bad, wrong, undesirable, and
unacceptable.In many cases,different cultural groups share the similar core-values (such as
'honesty', or 'respect', or 'family'), but these are often interpreted differently in different situations
and incorporated in unique ways into specific attitudes we apply in daily situations.
In addition, it is also important to note that the core values of a culture do not change quickly or
easily. They are passed on from generation to generation by numerous institutions which
surround us. These institutions of influence are powerful forces which guide us and teach us.
Although an economic system may change, or a new methodology in school may be adopted, or
new definitions of "common and normal" may be perceived on the television, there are
innumerable forces that continue to mold a culture as they have in the past.
So, like an iceberg, there are things that we can see and describe easily but there are also many
deeply rooted ideas that we can only understand by analyzing values, studying institutions, and
in many cases, reflecting on our own core values www.languageandculture.com/ cultural-
iceberg/2/12/2020.
Culture has been aptly compared and associated to an iceberg. Just as an iceberg has a visible
section above the waterline and a larger, invisible section below the water line, so culture has
some aspects that are observable and others that can only be suspected, imagined, or intuited as
illustrated in the following Figure 1 below.
Statistically, only about 10-15% of the total culture dimensions such as food, language, art,
dance, holiday etc. regarded as the deep surface culture while the rest is in deep culture. In short,
there are so many deep culture dimensions need to be explored deeply and comprehensively.
These dimensions include such as concept of communication system, concept of time, attitudes,
etc. To have more comprehensive understanding of surface culture and deep culture see Figure 2
below.
2. Real-life Experiences
In this section, you learn about real-life experiences among people from different culture when
they behave, interact, and communicate. The focus of this section is on asking questions,
answering, the questions and or discussing about on learning from miscommunication or
misunderstandings. You will study and discuss the following situations or case to widen your
horizon about the issues.
III.II Weakness
Some things explained in the book are difficult to understand, especially in the Examples section
In conclusion, Cross Cultural Understanding is crucial for building harmonious relationships and
thriving in our interconnected
IV.II Suggestion