The Importanceof Goatsinthe World Final Published
The Importanceof Goatsinthe World Final Published
net/publication/371965188
CITATIONS READS
17 200
2 authors, including:
Dilip Bhandari
Heifer International
16 PUBLICATIONS 179 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Dilip Bhandari on 30 June 2023.
4-19-2021
Dilip Bhandari
Heifer International, Little Rock, AR
Part of the Agricultural Economics Commons, and the Animal Studies Commons
Recommended Citation
Lohani, Mahendra and Bhandari, Dilip (2021) "The Importance of Goats in the World," Professional
Agricultural Workers Journal: Vol. 6: No. 2, 4.
Available at: https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Tuskegee Scholarly Publications. It has been accepted
for inclusion in Professional Agricultural Workers Journal by an authorized editor of Tuskegee Scholarly
Publications. For more information, please contact [email protected].
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World
Abstract
It is a challenge to transform the mindset of subsistence farmers to consider goats as a productive
asset. Goat health, breeding, housing and nutrition are the main challenges in a smallholder
production system. The development of the goat market sector is informal and underdeveloped.
As a result, goats have not been identified as a significant contributor to the national gross
domestic product. Many development organizations consider goats a preferred livestock
commodity for poverty alleviation. Therefore, it is desirable to have a systematic approach to
optimize goat production for smallholders. A smallholder goat value chain works well with a
focus on improved goat production, increasing business and entrepreneur skills and organizing
communities for strong social capital. Heifer International has large-scale goat value chain
programs for smallholders in many countries. Partnership and collaborative efforts among
academic/scientific, public/private sectors, producers and civil societies are critical for
sustainable smallholder goat development.
Keywords: Goats, Smallholder Farmers, Value Chain, Poverty Alleviation, Partnership
Introduction
Goats are among the earliest domesticated animals and have been associated to humans for at
least 10,000 years (Monteiro et al., 2018). Due to their adaptability to different environmental
and climatic conditions, they are dispersed all over the world (Mahmoud, 2010). Goats are the
most beneficial animals in the world, providing meat, milk, fiber, fertilizer, and draft power
(Sinn and Rudenberg, 2008). Over 1,153 breeds of goats (FAO, 2007) exist on our planet, living
on every continent except Antarctica and in a quite astonishing range of environments, from
humid tropical rain forests to dry hot desert regions and cold, hypoxic high-altitude regions
(Hirst, 2017). They are different from one another by their size, shape and production types.
Goats survive and reproduce under a variety of extreme conditions, making them an ideal species
for resource-poor farmers, often tagged as “bank on the hoof” and “walking refrigerators.”
Unfortunately, it continues to be a challenge to transform the mindset of subsistence farmers to
consider goats as a “productive asset” rather than “saving asset.”
Traditionally raised for milk and meat, goats are one of the most commonly consumed meats in
the world as they are an excellent source of protein. Goat meat and milk pose very few religious
taboos among the diverse human population. It is low in fat and cholesterol and high in vitamins
and minerals. Similarly, goat milk is widely consumed worldwide and, for many, is easier to
digest. Its rich, complex flavor and nutritional qualities has helped the goat cheese industry
become a major niche market in Europe and the United States. Goat products have become
sought-after commodities in developed countries (Sinn and Rudenberg, 2008).
In rural areas of developing countries, the contribution of goats is highly significant and has an
important role in feeding the resource poor populations. When smallholder farmers cannot raise
cattle and other large animals, goats become the preferred choice. They are ideal for household
milk and meat production and can be easily sold for immediate income. The milk and meat
produced by one goat is the perfect balance: it is often sufficient to meet children’s nutritional
requirements, without the storage problems associated with the larger volume produced by large
animals. Goats are readily adaptable and thrive in all types of climatic conditions (tropical, cold,
dry or humid climates). Due to the size of goats as compared to other species, they can be raised
in very small landholdings of resource poor smallholder farmers.
Figure 2 suggests that goats are mainly concentrated in Asia (57.7%) and Africa (35.7%),
making up 93.4% of the total number in the world (FAOSTAT, 2018). This is due to the
importance of goats to the high number of poor and smallholder farmers in Asia and Africa. The
production of small ruminants, especially sheep and goats, is largely rooted in specific regions,
for both historical and religious reasons. This is the case in Muslim countries where pork is not a
food option, and in India where beef is not eaten, in both cases due to religion.
Figure 1. World Goat Population Growth Trend between 1970 and 2018
https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4 10
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World
Figure 2. Production Share of Goats by Region, Average between 2000 and 2016
Figure 3 shows the leading countries in goat production in five Asian countries (China, India,
Pakistan, Bangladesh and Iran) and five African countries (Nigeria, Sudan-former, Sudan, Kenya
and Ethiopia) (FAOSTAT, 2018). These goats are mainly raised for meat and milk, and to some
extent for fiber.
Figure 3. Top Ten Goat Producing Countries of the World between 2000 and 2016
The goat sector has not followed the same path of development and intensification as other
livestock production sectors such as cattle, poultry, pigs, etc. It continues to be a challenge to
transform the mindset of subsistence farmers to manage goats as “productive asset” rather than
continuing the traditional practice of using it as a “savings asset.” Goat marketing activities have
been largely excluded from organized markets. It is important to recognize the opportunity that
goat farming offers to nutrition and economic development. Goat production systems are multi-
purpose systems oriented towards production of milk, meat, manure, fiber and skin. Goat
development projects generally consider these multifunctional characteristics.
The critical first step for smallholders to earn a living income through goat raising is to build
their capacity in production and marketing. Smallholders engagement is essential for addressing
https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4 12
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World
the goat production and marketing gap and it also ensures that smallholder farmers are motivated
for change.
Heifer International has learned that the most reliable, sustainable way to end hunger and poverty
where it works is to develop and strengthen inclusive local economies. Heifer does this by
helping people start or expand farmer-owned agri-businesses, cooperatives and social enterprises
so they can profitably participate in pro-poor wealth creating value chains.
Smallholder farm entrepreneurs in Nepal, India, Bangladesh, China, Zimbabwe, Senegal and
Haiti (to name a few) are playing a key role in rural economic development via large-scale goat
value chain projects. These smallholders design and commercialize products and services, create
jobs and generate new waves of economic development in their communities. Heifer equips
socially minded entrepreneurs, especially women and youth, with the skills and resources they
need to earn living incomes. Heifer’s large-scale goat value chain program in Nepal includes
more than 200,000 households and more than 70,000 households in India.
https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4 14
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World
Goat Breeding
Technical interventions by most development organizations often lack focus in breed
improvement of goats. Due to a lack of a continuous, structural and established genetic
improvement programs, and the indiscriminate breeding practices by smallholder farmers often
yield negative genetic impact. The result is decreased genetic merit of goats leading to a decline
in productivity. This results into inadequate availability of improved breeds for multiplication.
Therefore, a systematic scientific approach for breed improvement aiming at the production of
seed animals of generic merit is indispensable for increasing the impact.
Selection breeding practices within the breed can be adopted through the participation of
community members to produce seed goats and to improve the genetic performances of the goat
flocks. This is only possible through the introduction of performance recording (Solomon et al.,
2014) and selection as a tool of technical intervention for the improvement of breeds of native
goats so that gradual permanent genetic gain could be achieved over years. Heifer has
successfully carried out a “community initiated genetic improvement in goats (CIGIG)”
program. The analysis of this project clearly indicated that goat breed improvement through
selection could be done with the participation of community smallholder farmers. Breed
improvement analysis in this research was done by comparing the change in the value of the
parameters of the average daily weight gain, average five months’ live weight gain and three
months’ litter weight per doe at one-year intervals (Table 1).
Goat Health
At the smallholder farmer level, management of goat health is a critical aspect for improving
goat production. Periodic vaccination and deworming of goats can reduce disease incidences.
Reducing kid mortalities with better management practices is also very important for
smallholders. Heifer facilitates the improvement of goat health through a community-based
approach utilizing locally trained community members called community Agro-Vet
Entrepreneurs (CAVEs). These CAVEs also support smallholder farmers in improving their
animal management skills (not only limited to goats) and use their own farm as demonstration
Table 1. Analysis of Goat Breed Improvement (Jamnapari X Khari cross) in CIGIG, 2014
site. Through these relationships, CAVEs build steady client bases for their services and
products. This opportunity is attracting youth to agribusiness, reducing their migration to cities in
many Heifer-supported communities around the world. The selected CAVEs go through a series
of trainings including but not limited to animal health and husbandry, agribusiness and enterprise
development, and facilitation and communication skills coupled with Heifer’s social capital
training. Due to enhanced animal health service provided by CAVEs, goat mortality has reduced
significantly. Heifer India reported overall goat mortality below 2% in fiscal year 2016 (Heifer
International India, 2016). CAVEs are instrumental in providing preventive services like periodic
vaccinations and deworming, treatment and first aid services, input supply to smallholder famers.
CAVEs also provide training to farmers on new advances in animal production and health
technology as part of the embedded service of their business. Heifer’s current data shows that
more than 2,400 active CAVEs, community animal health workers (CAHWs) and animal health
promoters are serving smallholder farmers in Heifer communities (Figure 6)
Heifer works with smallholder farmers who possess small plots of land. Heifer promotes zero
grazing practice in its projects. Heifer promotes improved fodder and forage production as a
movement and facilitates cut and carry method for goat feeding. Smallholder farmers are
utilizing unproductive and unused lands, public lands through leases, borders of irrigation canals,
on two sides of roads and trails, terraces and bunds of the farmlands for fodder and forage
production. Community nurseries managed by smallholder farmers are the main source of
seedlings and saplings, in addition to leveraging similar resources from local government
https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4 16
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World
agriculture and forestry departments. Smallholder goat farmers in Nepal have planted more than
8,000 hectares of land (Figure 7) in the last four years (Heifer International Nepal, 2016).
Likewise, Heifer International India has planted more than 500,000 fodder/forage plants in fiscal
year 2016 alone (Heifer International India, 2016). This trend is increasing in all countries where
Heifer has a footprint. Altogether, more than 1.4 million different species of fodder and forage
were planted, and more than 3,400 hectares of land was utilized for forage and pasture
management in fiscal year 2017 (Heifer International, 2018).
Heifer has also introduced the concept of feeding home mixed concentrate feed and mineral
block to improve goat productivity. To minimize feed wastage, improved and sperate feeding
trough and waterer for the goats have been introduced. The concept of community fodder banks
to address the challenge of feed shortage in dry season has also been working effectively (Heifer
International India, 2016).
Heifer has a long history of finding innovative ways to increase goat productivity. Heifer country
programs are innovatively adapting FFS in their goat projects. Using the improved practice, the
average growth rate of goats was almost doubled as compared to traditional practices by
smallholder farmers in Nepal, and the average time from birth to mating was reduced by more
than 100 days. This means more and larger goats in less time, which translates to higher profits
for the farmers. Figure 8 shows how the improved practices through FFS have increased the
body weight of goats in six months (Heifer International, 2012). Improved practices in this case
study include improvements in goat sheds with proper ventilation and manure management;
improvements in feeding with supplemental locally-made concentrate feed, provision of water
and mineral blocks; periodic vaccination against peste des petitis ruminats (PPR) and
deworming. Traditional practices do not include any additional interventions.
https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4 18
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World
Pro-poor wealth creating value chains (Figure 9) integrate poor and vulnerable groups into
market activities in an equitable and fair manner. These value chains create lasting wealth that is
rooted and stays in communities through local ownership, mutually beneficial linkages and
inclusive business relationships. Heifer International works with farmers and communities to:
• Determine the best value chain opportunities
• Identify, support and strengthen agri-enterprises
• Deploy capital and technology
• Mobilize values-based private sector partnerships
Conclusion
Goats are the preferred livestock of smallholder farmers around the world as they are excellent
converters of fodder/forage not preferred by other livestock species into very valuable sources of
human nutrition and income. Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, where the goat population is
concentrated, require more attention to improve goat production and productivity. These regions
also house the highest human population living below the poverty line. There is a strong need for
collaboration between research institutes and universities, and smallholder farmers for increasing
goat production and productivity. Best practices and innovations around improved goat
production are limited to specific geographical locations. Market development in goats is still in
its infancy as compared to other livestock species. All the stakeholders of goat development
(national and international development organizations, research institutes and universities,
private sector players, government agencies and smallholder farmers) should work together in a
public-private-producer-partnership (PPPP) model to enable higher production, for creating
sustainable goat markets and for meeting the nutritional and income needs of resource poor
smallholder farmers.
References
FAO. (2018). “FAOSTAT. Live Animals – Production of Goats by Country. 2018.”
http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/?#compare [Retrieved July 18, 2018].
Heifer International. (2018). “No Title.” The SCAPH Bulletin, Feb 2018 (1): 1 (Internal
Publication of Heifer International).
Heifer International Nepal. (2017). “Annual Report Fiscal year 2017.”
http://www.heifernepal.org/publications [Retrieved June 22, 2018].
https://tuspubs.tuskegee.edu/pawj/vol6/iss2/4 20
Lohani and Bhandari: Goats in the World