Duke Neurogensis From 2013 Jahg Autumn v11n2
Duke Neurogensis From 2013 Jahg Autumn v11n2
Reductionist’s Rant
Neurogenesis:
Nerve Growth or Regeneration
with Herbs and Food Plants
James Duke, PhD
Thanks to Kevin Spelman, PhD, and Alan Tillotson, PhD, for constructive criticisms and suggestions.
M
y reliable Dorland’s Illustrated base it on some challenging assumptions: In his distinguished career,
James Duke served the US
Medical Dictionary (25th edition,
Department of Agriculture
1974) defines “neurogenic” 1. A
ll food plants contain thousands of different
for over 30 years. Before
first as “forming nervous biologically active phytochemicals familiar retiring, he developed
tissue, or stimulating nervous to our genes from when our ancestors his ethnobotanical and
energy”; but I define it as first ingested plants containing such phytochemical database
“stimulating nerve growth or regeneration.” phytochemicals possibly millions of years ago. online at www.ars-grin.gov/
duke. It is one of the most
Dorland’s didn’t define the word “neuritogenic”
frequently consulted areas
back in 1974, but I define it as “stimulating 2. W
hen chemically out of balance (diseased),
of the USDA website. Duke
growth or regeneration of small nerves called our bodies try to achieve health by getting grows hundreds of plants on
axons or neurites.” Doctors have prescribed or in balance homeostatically, mostly his six-acre Green Farmacy
suggested many medicines and modalities for sequestering needed (phyto)chemicals Garden with his wife, Peggy.
Since retiring from the USDA,
progressive neuropathy (in Dorland’s defined as and voiding unneeded or contraindicated
Dr. Duke has served for
a “disturbance of the nerves”). In the 83 year-old (phyto)chemicals. It is my questionable
five years as Senior Science
me, it’s catastrophic, causing tingling feet and assumption, after compiling data for 30 Advisor to Nature’s Herbs and
creaking knees. In other words, I have arthritic years, that probably all edible plants contain with allherb.com. Since 2001,
and wobbly knees that creak as I climb the stairs. both some neurogenic and antineurogenic he has been a distinguished
Below the knee, my legs are numb and tingly. phytochemicals. Ingesting plants that contain herbal lecturer at Tai Sophia
Healing Institute (now
Your reductionistic ranter, senile senior greater quantities of needed chemicals
Maryland University of
Jim Duke, suffers serious neuropathy, possibly can help bring the body back to health.
Integrative Health). He has
caused by one or more of the following: most written over 30 books on
likely spinal stenosis and spondylosis; cryptic 3. M
y public domain USDA database already has medicinal plants.
Lyme disease for nearly a decade; possibly identified many of the chemicals in many food
pesticides (many of my USDA colleagues seem plants that might help preserve, protect, or
to have suffered pesticide poisonings, but not even generate new nerves or neurites. Queried
many of them worked with Agent Orange as did intelligently, the database can identify the
I); alcohol (my liver tests have never fingered my most promising food “farmaceuticals” to help
generous consumption of alcohol); or diabetes the body heal itself. And that is why, in this
(my tests have never indicated diabetes). rant, I list some of the phytochemicals and
I seek a “food farmacy” approach that herbs that offer hope for neuropaths who are
might reduce neuropathic suffering, but it too old to go the surgical route (like me). If I do
may be more expansive than reductive. I an equally intense review of antineuritogenic
72
Reductionist’s Rant J A H G Volume 11 | Number 2 Journal of the American Herbalists Guild
Reductionist’s Rant
Neurogenic:
helpful with spasticity and tremor. Phase III Onjisaponins A, B, E, F and G, major
stimulating
clinical trials may rationalize cannabinoids
for MS (Croxton & Miller 2004).
saponins in Polygala, strongly
increased NGF level, much more
nerve growth or
Cannabidiol (CBD) is currently used for
MS spasticity and pain. (Karmaus, Wagner et al
than the ginsenosides Rb1 and Rg1
(Yabe et al 2003). Another study
regeneration
2012). A 1:1 mix of delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol found that Asian goldthread (Coptis)
plus cannabidiol, oromucosally introduced, extracts neuritogenically enhanced
has been approved in some countries, reducing the activities of NGF in tissue culture. Neuritogenic:
traditional psychotropic Cannabis actions. No Weaker activity was demonstrated by
tolerance, abuse or addictive issues were found berberine and even less by coptisine stimulating
(Oreja-Guevara 2012). Germany approved a
Cannabis extract in 2011 to treat refractory
and palmatine, alkaloids present in
goldthread, but also in American growth or
spasticity in MS, but it is often used off-label
for anorexia, nausea, and neuropathic pain
barberries, goldenseal, goldthread
and yellowroots (Shigeta et al 2002).
regeneration
(Grotenhermen & Müller-Vahl 2012).
The endogenous cannabinoids, anandamide
Syracuse scientists studying the
important hepatoprotective Silybum
of small nerves
and 2-arachidonoyl glycerol, interact with the marianum (milk thistle) extract called axons or
G-protein coupled cannabinoid (CB) receptors found it also to be neuritogenic
CB(1) and CB(2). The CB system is emerging as and NGF-genic (Kittur 2002). neurites
a key regulator of neuronal cell fate, conferring
neuroprotection. Many poor neurological Legumes
conditions are associated with excitotoxicity, Wake Forest scientists found that estradiol was
oxidative stress, and neuroinflammation. Some nearly twice as active as soy phytoestrogens
CB molecules inhibit these events and slow or at stimulating NGF (Pan, Anthony et al
stop the neurodegeneration. Such may offer 1999). Notice that the authors specify soy
hope in Alzheimer’s disease, MS, and cerebral phytoestrogens, most of whose phytoestrogens
ischemia (Gowren, Noonan et al 2011). are shared by many other edible legumes
much more pleasing to my occidental palate. (I
Various Familiar and Obscure Herbs suspect that most soy-sponsored phytoestrogen
A Finnish study showed that two of 10 policemen studies will have “soy” specified in their title,
who volunteered to be sprayed with crowd- even though genistein is genistein is genistein.)
control pepper spray (Capsicum or its capsaicins) A Japanese study concluded that “genistein
had increased levels of NGF in their tears enhanced the NGF-induced neurite outgrowth”
(Vesaluoma et al 2000). In 1999 the Japanese in PC12 tissue culture cells (Nakajima, Niisato
added several neuritogenic species: the well et al 2011). A 2011 Italian study found that
known Equisetum giganteum (horsetail), Panax soy genistein injected in the paws of diabetic
ginseng (ginseng), and Ruta gravolens (rue), rats relieved painful peripheral neuropathy,
and the obscure Gymmopteris rufa, Picrorhiza and restored NGF in diabetic sciatic nerves
scrophulariiflora, Imperata cylindrica, and (Valsecchi et al 2011). Another study showed
Gochnatia polymorpha. Picrorhiza induced that daidzein and genistein found in most edible
the longest neurites, but horsetail was best at legumes (but in this case Pueraria thomsonii,
neurogenesis though the neurites were short kudzu) exhibited cytoprotective activity that
(Li, Matsunaga et al 1999). In 2003, Japanese might even help in Parkinson’s disease (Lin et
scientists studying the kampo medicine al 2010). As early as 1993, University of North
Ninjin-yoei-to found that it increased NGF Carolina researchers suggested that not only
secretion in cultured astrocytes. The compound genistein but other inhibitors of protein tyrosine
contained several species including roots of kinases increased the length of neurites in the
Polygala tenuifolia and Panax ginseng extracts. presence of NGF (Miller, Lee et al 1993).
74
Reductionist’s Rant J A H G Volume 11 | Number 2 Journal of the American Herbalists Guild
Reviews
Phytochemical Plant Source PubMed ID
ASIATIC-ACID: Neurogenic 16105244 gotu kola
ASTRAGALOSIDE-IV: Neurogenic 19409437 astragalus
ASTRAGALOSIDES: NGF-Activator 19409437 astragalus
BAICALEIN: Neuritogenic 19327378 Baikal skullcap
BAICALEIN: Neuroprotective 19327378 Baikal skullcap
BERBERINE: Neuritogenic, NGF-Genic 12506995 goldthread, goldenseal, barberry, amur cork tree, prickly poppy
BISDEMETHOXYCURCUMIN: Neuritogenic 22145830 turmeric
BETA-BOSWELLIC-ACID: Neuritogenic 20217445 Boswellia serrata
CARNOSOL: NGF-Genic 14600414 rosemary, sage
COPTISINE: Neuritogenic, NGF-Genic 12506995 bloodroot, California poppy, celandine, fumitory, goldthread,
great scarlet poppy, opium poppy, plume poppy, prickly poppy
CURCUMIN: Neurogenic 16646663; 17617388; 18299980;
18362141; 19882093; 22145830 turmeric
DOPAMINE: Neurogenic 15128392; 16246330 banana peel, avocado, cacao
ELEUTHEROSIDE-B: Neuritogenic 18612196 eleuthero
ELEUTHEROSIDE-E: Neuritogenic 18612196 eleuthero
ESTRADIOL: NGF-Genic 10352122 pomegranate
(+)-EUDESMIN: Neuritigenic, NGF-Genic 17225460 magnolia
beta-EUDESMOL: Neurogenic 12023507 ginger, celery seed, hops, walnut, angelica, watermint
FALCARINONE: Neuritogenic 16219303 celery, caraway, dang gui, ivy, notoginseng, parsley
FERULIC-ACID: Neuritogenic 21809545 asafetida, chia, pineapple, apple, peanut, lemon, tarragon,
grapefruit, wheat, potato, garlic, corn, cabbage etc.
GARCINIA-XANTHONE-E: NGF-genic 14600386 garcinia
GARCINOL: `Neurogenic 21214247 garcinia
GENTISIDE-A: Neuritogeni 20189814 some gentian
GENTISIDE-B: Neuritogeni 20189814 some gentian
GENTISIDES C-K, esp.
GENTISIDE C: Neuritogenic 20813533 some gentian
GINKGOLIDE: possibly NGF-Genic 16716609 ginkgo
5-HYDROXY-3,6,7,8,3’,4’-
HEXAMETHOXYFLAVONE: Neuritogenic 22140566 citrus, esp. orange peel
ISORHAMNETIN: Neurogenic 22761636 tarragon, dill, ginkgo, grapefruit, yarrow
NEOVIBSANIN-A: Neuritogenic 20233658 Viburnum
NEOVIBSANIN-B: Neuritogenic 20233658 Viburnum
NEOVIBSANIN-L: Neuritogenic 20233658 Viburnum
(8Z)-NEOVIBSANIN-M (4) Neuritogenic 20233658 Viburnum
OLEANOLIC-ACID: Neuritogenic 12762811, 15235225 clove, thyme, sage, lavender, marjoram, basil, summer savory
PARTHENOLIDE: Neurogenic 19900365 feverfew, tansy
PEONY-GLYCOSIDES: NGF-Genic 20176057 peony
PROTOCATECHUIC-ACID: `Neurogenic 21946114 onion, coriander, oregano, wheat
QUERCETIN: NGF-Genic 19370542 ubiquitous
ROSMARINIC-ACID: Neurotrophic 20633629 heal-all, oregano, marjoram, spearmint, rosemary, bugle, clary
sage, applemint, european pennyroyal
SCHISANDRIN: Neurogenic 21302324; 18547723 schisandra
SCOPARONE: Neuritogenic 218547723 tarragon
SOMINONE: Neurogenic 16553605; 19594760 ashwagandha
WITHANOLIDE-A: Neurogenic 15711595; 18670181 ashwagandha
WITHANOSIDE-IV: Neurogenic 16553605; 19594760 ashwagandha
WITHANOSIDE-VI: Neurogenic 18670181 ashwagandha
WOGONIN: Neuritogenic 20888794 Baical skullcap
76
Reductionist’s Rant J A H G Volume 11 | Number 2 Journal of the American Herbalists Guild
Modern
The Certified Herbal Consultant program con-
sists of eight courses that build an understanding
of how to effectively use herbs and natural healing
methods from the basics on up, including assess-
Herbal
ment, natural therapies, herbal preparations and
applications, and more.
The Advanced Herbal Training Program, taught
by Steven Horne and Thomas Easley, professional
Medicine
members of AHG, provides you in-depth training
on 300 medicinal herbs, plus basic botany and
plant identification.
Starting this fall we’ll be offering a new series of classes,
http://modernherbalmedicine.com taught via webinar, on Health Sciences for Herbalists. Call
800-416-2887 or visit http://modernherbalmedicine.com
Excellence in Herbal Education for more information.
J A H G Volume 11 | Number 2 Journal of the American Herbalists Guild 77
Reductionist’s Rant
Lang UE, Mahlberg R, Hellweg R 2003, Chronic for Experimental Biology and Medicine. 221(2):118-25
cannabis abuse raises nerve growth factor serum Phan CW, Wong WL, David P, Naidu M, Sabaratnam V
concentrations in drug-naive schizophrenic patients 2012, Pleurotus giganteus (Berk.) Karunarathna &
Journal of Psychopharmacology. 17(4):439-445 K.D. Hyde: Nutritional value and in vitro neurite
Karmaus PW, Wagner JG, Harkema JR, Kaminski NE, Kaplan outgrowth activity in rat pheochromocytoma cells BMC
BL 2013, Cannabidiol (CBD) enhances lipopolysaccharide Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 12:102
(LPS)-induced pulmonary inflammation in C57BL/6 Pongsa-Asawapaiboon A, Asavaritikrai P, Withyachumnarnkul
mice Journal of Immunotoxicology. 10(3):321-8 B, Sumridthong A 1998, Melatonin increases nerve
Kittur S, Wilasrusmee S, Pedersen WA, Mattson MP, growth factor in mouse submandibular gland
Straube-West K, Wilasrusmee C, Lubelt B, Kittur DS Journal of Pineal Research. 24(2):73-77
2002, Neurotrophic and neuroprotective effects of Rudakewich M, Ba F, Benishin CG 2001, Neurotrophic
milk thistle (Silybum marianum) on neurons in culture and neuroprotective actions of ginsenosides Rb(1)
Journal of Molecular Neuroscience.18(3):265-269 and Rg(1) Planta Medica. 67(6):533-537
Kivatinitz SC, Grabois VR, Quiroga S 1995, High-density Shindel AW, Xin ZC, Lin G, Fandel TM, Huang YC, Banie L,
lipoprotein inhibits UDP-N-acetylgalactosamine:GM3, Breyer BN, Garcia MM, Lin CS, Lue TF 2010, Erectogenic
N-acetylgalactosaminyltransferase and differentiation and neurotrophic effects of icariin, a purified extract of
of cultured cerebral cells: comparison with a horny goat weed (Epimedium spp.) in vitro and in vivo
formerly described inhibitor of this enzyme Journal of Sexual Medicine. 7(4 Pt 1):1518-1528
Journal of Neurochemistry. 65(2):775-781 Spelman K, Aldag R, Hamman A, Kwasnik EM, Mahendra
Kwon HC, Jung IY, Cho SY, Cho OR, Yang MC, Lee SO, Hur MA, Obasi TM, Morse J, Williams EJ 2011, Traditional
JY, Kim SY, Yang JB, Lee KR 2003, Phospholipids herbal remedies that influence cell adhesion molecule
from Bombycis corpus and their neurotrophic effects activity Phytotherapy Research. 25(4):473-83
Archives of Pharmacal Research. 26(6):471-7. Takano N, Inokuchi Y, Kurachi M 2011, [Effects of ethanol extracts of
Li Y, Ishibashi M, Satake M, Oshima Y, Ohizumi Y 2003, A new herbal medicines on dermatitis in an atopic dermatitis mouse
iridoid glycoside with nerve growth factor-potentiating activity, model] [Article in Japanese] Yakugaku Zasshi. 131(4):581-586
gelsemiol 6’-trans-caffeoyl-1-glucoside, from Verbena littoralis Tang W, Kubo M, Harada K, Hioki H, Fukuyama Y 2009,
Chemical & Pharmaceutical Bulletin. 51(9):1103-1105 Novel NGF-potentiating diterpenoids from a Brazilian
Li P, Matsunaga K, Ohizumi Y 1999, Enhancement of the medicinal plant, Ptychopetalum olacoides Bioorganic
nerve growth factor-mediated neurite outgrowth from & Medical Chemistry Letters. 19(3):882-886
PC12D cells by Chinese and Paraguayan medicinal plants Tosini G, Ye K, Iuvone PM 2012, N-acetylserotonin:
Biological & Pharmaceutical Bulletin. 22(7):752-755 neuroprotection, neurogenesis, and the sleepy
Lin CM, Lin RD, Chen ST, Lin YP, Chiu WT, Lin JW, Hsu FL, Lee brain Neuroscientist. 18(6):645-653
MH 2010, Neurocytoprotective effects of the bioactive Valsecchi AE, Franchi S, Panerai AE, Rossi A, Sacerdote P,
constituents of Pueraria thomsonii in 6-hydroxydopamine Colleoni M 2011, The soy isoflavone genistein reverses
(6-OHDA)-treated nerve growth factor (NGF)-differentiated oxidative and inflammatory state, neuropathic pain,
PC12 cells Phytochemistry. 71(17-18):2147-2156 neurotrophic and vasculature deficits in diabetes mouse
Lin H, Wang H, Chen D, Li J, Gu Y 2008, [Effect of extract model European Journal of Pharmacology. 650(2-3):694-702
of ginkgo biloba leaves on proliferation of SCs Vesaluoma M, Müller L, Gallar J, Lambiase A, Moilanen J, Hack
cultured in vitro] [Article in Chinese] Zhongguo Xiu T, Belmonte C, Tervo T 2000, Effects of oleoresin capsicum
Fu Chong Jian Wai Ke Za Zhi. 22(9):1047-1050 pepper spray on human corneal morphology and sensitivity
Ma J, Li W, Tian R, Lei W 2010, Ginsenoside Rg1 promotes Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science. 41(8):2138-2147
peripheral nerve regeneration in rat model of nerve Wei S, Yin X, Kou Y, Jiang B 2009, Lumbricus extract
crush injury. Neuroscience Letters. 478(2):66-71 promotes the regeneration of injured peripheral nerve
Miller DR, Lee GM, Maness PF 1993, Increased neurite in rats Journal of Ethnopharmacology. 123(1):51-54
outgrowth induced by inhibition of protein tyrosine Yabe T, Tuchida H, Kiyohara H, Takeda T, Yamada H 2003,
kinase activity in PC12 pheochromocytoma cells Induction of NGF synthesis in astrocytes by onjisaponins of
Journal of Neurochemistry. 60(6):2134-2144 Polygala tenuifolia, constituents of kampo (Japanese herbal)
Nakajima K, Niisato N, Marunaka Y 2011, Genistein medicine, Ninjin-yoei-to Phytomedicine. 10(2-3):106-114
enhances the NGF-induced neurite outgrowth
Biomedical Research. 32(5):351-356
Oreja-Guevara C 2012, [Treatment of spasticity in multiple sclerosis:
new perspectives regarding the use of cannabinoids]
[Article in Spanish] Revista de Neurologia. 55(7):421-430
Pan Y, Anthony M, Clarkson TB 1999, Effect of estradiol and
soy phytoestrogens on choline acetyltransferase and
nerve growth factor mRNAs in the frontal cortex and
hippocampus of female rats Proceedings of the Society