Epidemic Ix & MGT
Epidemic Ix & MGT
Learning objectives
At the end of this module, participants will be able to:
1
11/26/2014
Contents
1. Introduction
2. Investigation of an outbreak/epidemic
1. Introduction
• Disease occur in a community at different level at
particular point in time
– Predictable level called expected level
• Endemic
• Holo/hyper/meso/hypoendemic
– Excess of what is expected
• Epidemic, Outbreak, Pandemic, Cluster
– Irregular and occasional occurrence
• Sporadic
2
11/26/2014
Introduction…
• Epidemic:- occurrence of disease or health related
condition in excess of the usual frequency in a given
area or among a specified group of people over a
particular period of time.
Introduction…
Note
1. A disease may be endemic in a population at any
frequency level, provided that it occurs with
predictable regularity.
3
11/26/2014
Introduction…
4. Knowledge of expected number is crucial to
label occurrence of a particular event as
epidemic
Introduction…
• Outbreak:- epidemic of shorter duration covering a
limited area.
E.g. Outbreak of gastroenteritis after sharing a common meal
at an event
- HIV pandemic
8
4
11/26/2014
Introduction…
• Cluster:- unusual aggregation of health events in a
given area over a particular period.
⇒emphasis is on aggregation of cases in a certain locality
than the actual number of cases.
Introduction…
• Sporadic:- a disease that is normally absent from a
population but which can occur in that population,
although rarely and without predictable regularity.
10
5
11/26/2014
Introduction…
Examples of disease occurrence in Ethiopia:
1. Endemic: malaria, schistosomiasis, chronic hepatitis,
trachoma, scabies, malnutrition, amoebiasis,
tuberculosis and typhus.
11
Introduction…
• Types of Epidemics
– Common source
• Point source:- e.g. food borne outbreak of acute Gastro
enteritis in attendants of a wedding feast
6
11/26/2014
2. Outbreak investigation
• Outbreak investigation is a method for identifying
and evaluating people who have been exposed to an
unusual occurrence of disease/other health problems.
13
Outbreak investigation…
– Challenges in outbreak investigation
1. Urgency to find out the source and prevent additional
cases and substantial pressure to conclude rapidly
particularly when outbreak is ongoing;
– may lead to hasty decisions regarding source and
negative consequence on control measures
7
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
• How are outbreaks recognized?
– Possible outbreaks of Ds come to the attention of public
health officials in various ways:
Outbreak investigation…
• Why are outbreaks investigated?
– The most compelling reason is that exposure to the
source(s) of infection may be continuing
⇒Investigation provides helpful information:
To take immediate action (i.e. by identifying and
eliminating the source of infection we can prevent
additional cases)
8
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
– Other reasons include:
• To describe new diseases and learn more about
known diseases
17
Outbreak investigation…
• When should outbreaks be investigated?
– For some communicable Ds, a single suspected case
might suffice the start of the process of investigation
⇒Need immediate investigation and immediate response
– For some other Ds,
when a certain threshold is passed or
when un usual increase in the number of deaths due
to certain cause is noticed during analysis of
surveillance data or
when cluster of deaths due to unknown cause is seen
18
9
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
• Activities in Outbreak investigation
19
Outbreak investigation…
– The activities include:
20
10
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
– Activities…
21
Outbreak investigation…
1. Verify that there is epidemic/ outbreak
– Reports about presence of epidemic are not always
correct
⇒ Important for considering resource that would be
expended for artifuactual rise in number of cases/
deaths
a) Verifying the diagnosis in the index case/s
b) Compare current occurrence with the expected
occurrence considering seasonal variations
c) Rule out artifuactual changes in the occurrence of
diseases
22
11
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
– The following three things should be considered to
declare epidemic in case of incomplete data:
Outbreak investigation…
2. Prepare to conduct an investigation
a) Search and gather scientific information necessary for
the outbreak investigation
– No single investigator is fully knowledgeable about all
diseases and health problems which need Investn and
appropriate management of their outbreaks.
12
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
b) Make important communications
25
Outbreak investigation…
c) Establish an outbreak investigation and management
team
– For smooth execution of outbreak investigation and
management establish team with clearly defined roles.
13
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
d) Develop data collection tool for the outbreak investign
– The investigation team should develop collection tool
with the following variables regardless of disease
under investigation
• Identifying information: Name, address, etc
• Socio-demographic variables: age, sex, occupation, etc
• Clinical and lab infon: Sx, signs, date of onset, lab test
result
• Risk factor infon: exposure to suspected causes, e.g.
contact with people with similar illness, travel history,
immunization status…
27
Outbreak investigation…
e) Make administrative arrangements
14
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
3. Construct a suspected case definition
– Suspected case definition is definition of a Ds used at
initial stage of outbreak investigation
29
Outbreak investigation…
4. Collect laboratory specimens and obtain laboratory
results
– Laboratory results are mandatory for most epidemics of
infectious diseases for:
Confirming diagnosis in the individual patient
understanding the cause of the epidemic
15
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
– Based on additional lab results, the cases who fit
suspected case definition can be classified as:
• Confirmed/definite: A cases with lab confirmation
• Probable: A cases with typical clinical features of the
disease without lab confirmation
• Possible: A cases presented with fewer of the typical
clinical features
– laboratory tests may include environmental investigations:
• food sanitation
• suspected breeding sites
• animal reservoirs
31
Outbreak investigation…
5. Search and record additional cases while managing
the already identified cases
– This is done by:
a) Passive surveillance (stimulated)
– Searching similar cases in the registers of health facilities
where cases have been reported
b) Active surveillance
– Sending out letter describing situation & asking for reports
– Alerting public directly to see physician if they have Sx
compatible with diseases in question
– Asking case-patients if they know any one else with same
condition
– Conducting active case finding mission 32
16
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
– Meanwhile:
Cases of the disease that are already identified
should get the appropriate treatment.
33
Outbreak investigation…
6. Describe the epidemic with respect to time, person
and place
– Purpose:
• To get a clue about the general features of the
epidemic:
– where are most cases of the epidemic seen
– where is epidemic spreading to
– what the source of the epidemic is
– who the high risk groups are, etc
so that early and timely measures can be started.
34
17
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
a) Characterize epidemic by time: epidemic curve
Outbreak investigation…
• Type of epidemics
– Point source
• Rapid rise and fall (log-normal distribution) except for
diseases with long IP (e.g. Hepatitis A)
• The curve starts and ends within a single incubation
period
36
18
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
c a = minimum IP
b = duration of outbreak
Number of
c = mode of IP
a + b = maximum IP
cases
a b
Date of
Exposure onset
Outbreak investigation…
38
19
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
39
Outbreak investigation…
– Progressive/propagated epidemic:
40
20
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
41
Outbreak investigation…
• Probable date of exposure (from point source curve)
– The time till date of mode of epidemic curve is taken
as average IP of etiologic agent
– Date of exposure = date of the mode – average IP
42
21
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
Estimating date of exposure Peak
10
One incubation period
9 Rubella = 18 days
8
7
Probable time of
6
Cases
5
4
exposure
3
2
1
0
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
Days
43
Outbreak investigation…
Estimating date of exposure
10 Maximum incubation
9 21 days
8
7
Probable time of
6
Cases
5
exposure
4
3
2 Minimum incubation
1 14 days
0
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29
Days 44
22
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
• Timelines of case detection, investigation and
response
45
Outbreak investigation…
23
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
b) Characterize the outbreak by place: Spot map
47
Outbreak investigation…
• Application of Spot map
– Shows cluster of cases
– Shows relation of clusters with presumed sources of
infection
– Helps to distinguish between common source and
propagated epidemic when difficult to identify them
by the epidemic curve
Propagated epidemic: geographic spread with
successive generation of cases
Common source epidemic: cases tend to aggregate
in certain place
48
24
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
Spot map showing distribution of cases by place
49
Outbreak investigation…
Spot map showing distribution of cases by place
50
25
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
c) Characterize the outbreak by person: person specific
attack rates
– Identifying personal variables that could be related with
the cause of epidemics gives valuable clues about:
the epidemic
the high risk groups
– Identifying high risk groups makes issuing interventions
feasible in addition to unraveling helpful clues as to the
cause of the epidemic.
E.g. some of the interventions are not plenty enough to give
to every affected population (e.g. vaccination)
51
Outbreak investigation…
– Some of personal characteristics include (depending
on type of disease):
52
26
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
7. Formulate and test hypothesis about cause of the
epidemic
53
Outbreak investigation…
– Attack rate method: two groups (exposed and
unexposed) are compared.
54
27
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
Attack rate method
Number of people Number of people who
who ate specified item did not eat specified item
Attack Attack Relative
Food Ill Well Total Ill Well Total
Rate % Rate % Risk
Baked Ham 29 17 46 63 17 12 29 59 1.07
Mashed potatoes 23 14 37 62 23 14 37 62 1.00
Spinach 26 17 43 60 20 12 32 62 0.97
Cabbage Salad 18 10 28 64 28 19 47 60 1.07
Milk 2 2 4 50 44 27 71 62 0.81
Ice Cream (Van) 43 11 54 80 3 18 21 14 5.71
Fruit salad 4 2 6 67 42 27 69 61 1.10
Ice Cream (Choc) 25 22 47 53 20 7 27 74 0.72
55
Outbreak investigation…
56
28
11/26/2014
Outbreak investigation…
Food consumption by cases and controls, outbreak of salmonellosis,
Jura, spring 1997
Foods nr (%) of cases nr (%) of controls OR
have eaten have eaten matched CI 95%
(n=42) (n=42)
Outbreak investigation…
8. Reach at a final decision based on all the available
evidences
• This step of investigation should come up with:
– Etiologic agents
– Mode of transmission
– Exposure that cause the disease
58
29
11/26/2014
59
30
11/26/2014
61
62
31
11/26/2014
63
64
32
11/26/2014
b) Setting priority
• Before setting priority, answer the following based on
literature review, reports, health institution records,…
– Major epidemic prone diseases?
– Risk of epidemics?
• Time since last outbreak: example one may
suspect meningitis outbreak every 2 years
• Frequency of previous outbreaks and recent Ds
trends
65
66
33
11/26/2014
d) Implement/strengthen surveillance
• Successful epidemic response depends on effective
surveillance system
⇒It is necessary to keep population at special risk
under surveillance during acute phase and then
community after epidemics is controlled.
• Surveillance should keep all links of disease chain
under close scrutiny
68
34
11/26/2014
69
35
11/26/2014
72
36
11/26/2014
73
74
37
11/26/2014
75
38
11/26/2014
78
39
11/26/2014
Summary
• In general, epidemiologic outbreak investigation and
management involves the under listed activities:
1. Verifying that there is an epidemic/outbreak
80
40
11/26/2014
Summary…
81
Reading assignment
1. Monitoring and evaluation of Epidemic
Investigation and management
41
11/26/2014
83
42