Investigation of Wire-Cut EDM Process Parameters On Nimonic 90 Made by Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Process
Investigation of Wire-Cut EDM Process Parameters On Nimonic 90 Made by Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing Process
https://doi.org/10.1007/s12008-022-01185-5
ORIGINAL PAPER
Received: 28 September 2022 / Accepted: 23 December 2022 / Published online: 3 January 2023
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag France SAS, part of Springer Nature 2023
Abstract
Incurrent times wire arc additive manufacturing is becoming popular and alternate to conventional machining because of its
eco-friendly as wastages. Wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) develops the parts by depositing wire material one layer
above other because it is based on old technology i.e., welding. It even has ability to generate complex parts. As WAAM requires
post processing to obtain the better surface and accuracy of dimensions. To study about the post processing of WAAM specimen,
in this work Wire cut EDM is used, which can machine complicated shapes with high accuracy for any conducting material
without taking into account the hardness of the material. Selection of input parameters is the key for better material removal
and surface finish in Wire EDM.In this study Pulse on time, Wire tension, Servo Voltage withthree levelswereconsidered as
input parameter and Material removal, Surface roughness are considered as output responses. Response surface Methodology
is used for designing the experiment. It is observed that wire tension plays vital role in material removal and surface finish,
pulse on time is important in material removal but not in surface finish. Servo voltage predominant for surface roughness but
less influenced on material removal rate.
Keywords WAAM · Subtractive manufacturing · Wire EDM · Nimonic 90 · RSM · Wire tension · Servo voltage · Pulse on
time · MRR · Surface roughness
123
860 International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867
is 4.9 and includes machining finish, WAAM saves material brittleness. In WEDM energy is discharged as discrete, which
[7]. Wire is used as a filler in the Direct Energy Deposi- occurs at between wire electrode and workpiece through
tion form of additive manufacturingor WAAM, in which dielectric fluid. The energy discharged produces a temper-
an electric arc serves as the heat source to melt the wire. ature of around 20,000 °C between electrodes in very less
One arc process that works best in WAAM is cold metal microseconds [19]. To get a superior surface finish, tool wear
transfer; in this process, consistent, well-controlled current and vibration during machining must be controlled. This is
waves are present, along with filler feed. This results in the because direct contact between the wire electrode and the
weld bead being deposited with fewer protrusion [8]. WAAM workpiece occurs during WEDM, which causes mechanical
has capacity to produce goods with higher quality, robust stress. It is never easy to attain acceptable surface rough-
structures, and favorable mechanical properties has helped it ness and a higher rate of material removal because better
gain appeal [9]. Although WAAM is a new technique within material cutting and better surface finish are always at odds
AM, there are various challenges that must be overcome, with one another [20]. In order to provide insulation and ion-
such as: (i) The major loss in WAAM is tolerance, which isation between the workpiece and the wire electrode, the
is produced by residual stress and input heat distortion. (ii) de-ionized water functions as a dielectric medium. A spark
Accuracy in dimensions and component resolution. (iii) The caused by electricity generates a significant quantity of heat,
surface quality of WAAM component manufacturers is low which is cooled by a dielectric medium, which also removes
[10]. To achieve precise dimensional accuracy, subtractive the eroded material from the surface of the material [21].
manufacturing and WAAM are coupled. In the course of post- For better material removal rate, surface roughness, and kerf
processing, subtractive manufacturing should only be used width, many researchers have tried to optimise the process
after WAAM [11]. Kindermann et al. studied about disso- parameters, such as pulse on time, pulse off time, wire ten-
lution of Nb in eutectic phase around the interlayer regions sion, open servo voltage, and flushing pressure. However,
in CMT WAAM of processing parameters [12]. Effect of experimental evidence from Manna et al. suggests that wire
IN 718 alloy cold rolled with isothermally aging for 8 h at tension and wire feed have good effects on surface rough-
800 °C is investigated by Mei et al. [13]. Jung Hyun park ness while open servo voltage, pulse on time have significant
et al.has investigated the development of 9% nickel steel effects on material removal rate [22].
with 625 alloy of super TIG welding, it has been observed Although WAAM has gained industrial acceptance by pro-
that compared to conventional fluxed cored arc welding, ducing final parts in accordance with the specified designs,
Super TIG welding exhibited high tensile strength, Impact a secondary subtractive operation is still required. In order
toughness, hot cracking resistance which are due to low non- to produce the specimen’s surface polish and to first detach
metal inclusion in metal [14]. Nickel-based super alloys are the WAAM specimen from the substrate, subtractive man-
used in additive manufacturing which are second to titanium ufacturing is required. It has been noted that while many
alloy in popularity. Due to its favourable mechanical qualities academics have produced extensive research on the WAAM
and corrosion resistance, particularly at high temperatures, method utilising a variety of materials, very few papers have
nickel super alloys are used in the aerospace, energy, and focused on Nimonic 90 which is one of the nickel-based super
petrochemical industries [15]. One of the nickel-based super alloys that is widely utilised in various applications due to
alloys, Nimonic 80, is resistant to heat, oxidation, and cor- its resistance to oxidation at high temperatures as well as its
rosion, especially at high temperatures, making it valuable resistance to corrosion. Few researchers have integrated a few
for gas turbine engine parts, the space industry, and nuclear additive and subtractive manufacturing processes, however
reactors [16, 17]. Nimonic 90 is a nickel-based super alloy. It WAAM and WEDM have not yet been integrated. There-
has excellent corrosion resistance, high thermal stability, and fore, a part is created in this article using Nimonic 90 wire in
unique properties like strong affinity to heat, low thermal con- WAAM, and then WEDM is utilised to analyse how param-
ductivity, and low diffusivity, which makes it challenging to eters affect the part’s machining. Servo voltage, pulse on
build via subtractive manufacturing [17]. When nickel alloys time, and wire tension were selected as the input parame-
are machined using conventional techniques, a built-up layer ters in accordance with previous studies and the objective of
forms on the cutting tool face, the surface integrity is sub- this investigation, which is to obtain a high material removal
par, and there are numerous microcracks, including surface rate and minimal surface finish. By using Design of Experi-
ripping, material pull-out/cracking, and drag [18]. This type mentsthree levels of WEDM input parametersservo voltage,
of hard materials can be machined by using chemical reac- wire tension, and pulse on time are designed using the RSM
tions, melting and evaporation with electrical energy known technique.
as non- traditional machining, WEDM is one among non-
traditional machining which can machine any material that
is conductive in nature without considering its hardness and
123
International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867 861
123
862 International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867
Table 3 Maxi-cut eWire EDM process parameters & its range 3 Results and discussion
S. No Process parameter Range
3.1 Variation of responses with input parameters
1 Pulse on time 0–131 (μs)
2 Pulse off time 0–63 (μs)
The variations in responses with input parameters are stud-
ied using main plots. Main plots are drawn using Minitab
3 Wire tension 0–15 (N)
2021software.
4 Servo voltage 0–99 (V)
5 Water pressure 0–15 (kg/sq cm)
3.2 Effects of Input parameters on MRR
6 Wire feed rate 0–15 (m/min)
7 Peak current Upto 230 (A)
Main effect Plot of MRR with Pulse on time, Servo volt-
age and Wire tension are shown in Fig. 3. With increase
in wire tension, Pulse on time there is increase in material
2.2 Calculation of MRR removal rate and with increase in servo voltage MRR increase
initially then material cutting rate decreases. During initial
increase of servo voltage MRR increases, as there is increase
in sparks between the electrodes which heats and evapo-
4 × 5 × 0.25 × 5 rates the material. Whereas when voltage increases there
MRR 6.25(mm3 /min).
7 is increase in current but less amount of heat gets transmit
to workpiece since gap increases between electrode, which
By using above formula, we can able to calculate the MRR leads to decrease in MRR [26]. As Wire tension increases
of all the specimens and surface roughness are calculated by there is decrease in vibrations and makes wire electrode
using Taylor surf device. The responses are tabulated for all straight which leads to increase in cutting of material from
the 20 experiments in Table 5. work piece[27]. It is observed that with increase in pulse-on
– 1 0 1
Pulse-on time μs 7 8 9
Servo voltage Volts 2 3 4
Wire tension N 1000 1150 1300
123
International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867 863
Table 5 Experimentation
responses S. No Ton (μs) SV (V) WT (N) MRR (mm3 /min) SR (μm)
1 80 50 10 3.570 3.257
2 110 50 12 6.950 3.658
3 80 80 12 3.650 3.106
4 95 65 11 5.950 3.298
5 95 65 11 6.100 3.997
6 110 80 10 6.512 3.842
7 110 80 12 7.210 3.675
8 95 65 11 6.085 3.705
9 80 50 12 5.850 2.890
10 80 80 10 3.256 3.756
11 95 65 11 6.085 3.551
12 110 50 10 6.521 4.499
13 95 80 11 5.750 2.988
14 110 65 11 6.480 3.992
15 95 65 11 6.224 3.530
16 80 65 11 4.125 3.306
17 95 65 10 5.325 3.885
18 95 50 11 5.810 3.499
19 95 65 11 5.980 3.516
20 95 65 12 6.350 3.257
there is increase in cutting of material i.e., material removal. 3.4 Contribution of process parameters
This is due to increase in length of pulse will increase in
energy discharged, melting of material and flushing of mate- Contribution of process parameter for output responses with
rial [28]. respect to input parameters are shown by Figs. 5 and 6.
3.3 Effect of input parameters on Ra 3.5 Analysis of surface topology of WEDM process
Main effect Plot of Surface roughness with Pulse on time, After WEDM operations, the scanned electron micro-
Servo voltage and Wire tension are depict in Fig. 4. From scope(SEM) made by Joel 6067 been used to investigate the
figure it is observed that with increase in Pulse on time change insurface properties of work material after WEDM
there is increase in Surface roughness whereas with increase process. It has been examined that large number of micro
in wire tension, Servo voltage surface roughness decreases. cracks, crater formation,white layer formation and recast
With increase in servo voltage stability in spark and uni- layer formation takes placeon the surface of the work mate-
formity in dispersion occurs which leads to improvement rial after WEDM which were confirmedby SEM image. This
in surface finish [29]. When wire tension is low surface can be observed that higher Ton results in generation of
roughness is more and less for high values of wire tension, higher thermal energy, when the temperature reaches above
this due to fact thatas wire tension increases there is reduc- 10,000 °C, which is high enough to melt and evaporate the
tion in deflection of wire which is due to reactional force metal and pressure is being buildup inside the melt,when
to the sparks developed and water pressure. This reduction it reaches its limit, it explode, which can splatter melted
in deflection of wire from path, leads to proper machining material on the surface, produce pockmarks, micro holes
and produces better surface finish [30]. During pulse time, and globules, resulting in an irregular surface as can be seen
bridge of spark is developed between the electrodes, which in Fig. 7 [32]. It can also be observed that with the rise in
generate current. As pulse time increases sparks becomes SV, the roughness of the surfacealso increases as it generate
longer which leads to formation to formation of deeper, more thermal energy in the gap, causing stern cracking of the
boarded cuts on surface, thus surface roughness increases dielectric to happen more frequently, leading to the formation
[31]. of a molten pool that is becoming overheated. This molten
metal condenses onto gas bubbles since it evaporates [33].
123
864 International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867
123
International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867 865
Fig. 5 % Contributionof
Responses on MRR
Fig. 6 % Contribution of
Responses on Ra
When the charge stops, the gas bubbles shatter, expelling • It has been found that servo voltage has less of an impact
the molten metal from the surface of the Nimonic alloy. on MRR than do pulse-on time and wire tension. The
Consequently, a big lump of re-solidifiedmass has appeared plot demonstrates that as pulse on time and wire tension
on the machined surface with big and wide crack. Further increase, MRR also does. This is because an increase in
size and population of craters were increased extremely and discrete energy with increasing pulse on time melts and
overlapped craters were extended to the complete surfaceas evaporates more material, whereas an increase in wire ten-
illustrated in SEM micrograph Fig. 8 [34]. sion results in a stiffer wire and more evenly distributed
energy, leading to an increase in MRR.
• MRR first rises as servo voltage rises, but falls as voltage
rises more. There is a tiny space between the electrodes
4 Conclusion when the servo voltage rises, and this heat-generating gap
causes additional material to melt and evaporate. MRR,
Nimonic 90 was made in WAAM for experimental purposes, however, diminishes when servo voltage increases the
and it was machined using WEDM. For 20 experiments that space between the wire electrode and workpiece, which
were designed using RSM, the outcomes are as follows. With in turn reduces the heat generated between them.
varying input parameters, main graphs were created for the • Surface roughness is seen on plots to grow with pulse on
output responses. time but decrease with servo voltage and wire tension.
123
866 International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867
References
1. Newman, S.T., Zhu, Z., Dhokia, V., Shokrani, A.: Process plan-
ning for additive and subtractive manufacturing technologies. CIRP
Manuf. Technol. 64, 467–470 (2015)
2. Ngo, T.D., Nguyen, I., Kate, T.Q., David, H.: Additive manufac-
turing (3D printing): a review of materials, methods, applications
and challenges. Comp. Eng. 143, 172–196 (2018)
3. Leach, R.K., Bourell, D., Carmignato, S., Donmez, A., Senin, N.,
Dewulf, W.: Geometrical metrology for metal additive manufac-
turing. CIRP Ann.-Manuf. Technol 68, 677–700 (2019)
Fig. 7 Sem analysis of Experiment 12 (Ton= 110, SV 50 V, WT 4. Zidong, L., Kaijie, S., Xinghua, Y.: A review on wire and arc addi-
10 N) tive manufacturing of titanium alloy. J. Manuf. Process. 70, 24–45
(2021)
5. Anton, A.K., Maria, V.G., Andrei, E.: Effect of wire addi-
tive manufacturing process Parameter on the quality of
steel components. Glo. J. Res. Eng. J. Gen. Eng. 21:316-
332 (2021). https://globaljournals.org/GJRE_Volume21/4-Effect-
of-the-Wire-Arc-Additive.pdf
6. Eschelbacher, S., Mohring, H.C.: Hardness and orthogonal cutting
analyses of wire and arc additive manufacturing. Pro. CIRP 101,
26–29 (2021)
7. Wani, Z.K.: Abdullah, A. B.: A review on Metal 3D printing; 3D
welding. Mat. Sci. Eng. 920 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1088/1757-
899X/920/1/012015ƒ
8. Ayed, A., Valencia, A., Bras, G., Bernard, H., Michaud, P., Balcaen,
Y., Alexis, J.: Effects of WAAM process parameters on metallur-
gical and mechanical properties of Ti-6Al-4V deposits. Adv. Mat.
Mech. Manuf. 26–35 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-
24247-3_4
9. Sagar, S., Satish, K., Sharma, S., Dinesh, W.R.: A review on process
planning strategies and challenges of WAAM. Mater. Today Proc.
47(19), 6564–6575 (2021)
10. Jafari, D., Vaneker, T.H., Ian, G.: Wire and arc additive manu-
facturing: opportunities and challenges to control the quality and
Fig. 8 Sem analysis of Experiment 13 (Ton= 95, SV 80 V, WT 11 N)
accuracy of manufactured parts. Mat. Des. 202, 109471 (2021)
11. Maider, R.D.A., Pedro, A.: Influence of deposition strategy and
heat treatment on mechanical properties and microstructure of 2319
aluminium WAAM components. Mat. Des. 221, 110974 (2022)
The depth and size of the craters that are produced on the 12. Kindermann, R., Roy, M., Morana, R., Prangnell, P.: Process
workpiece’s surface grow when the pulse on is increased. response of Inconel 718 to wire + arc additive manufacturingwith
• As wire tension increases, the deflections of the wire cold metal transfer. Mat. & Des. 195, 109031 (2020)
13. Yunpeng, M., Yongchang, L., Chenxi, L., Ching, L., Liming, Y.,
diminish, which reduces uneven material removal. Sur- Guo, Q., Li, H.: Effects of cold rolling on the precipitation kinetics
face roughness will be reduced as servo voltage increases and the morphology evolution of intermediate phases in Inconel
because heat is reduced and less material is removed as a 718 alloy. J. Alloys Comp. 649, 949–960 (2015)
result. 14. Jung, H.P., Young, H.K., Baek, H.-J., Sang-Myung: Cho.: study
on process development of super-TIG welding for 9% nickel steel
• Microcracks, globules, and craters generated on the spec- with Alloy 625. J. Manuf. Process. 40, 140–148 (2019)
imen’s surface are visible in the SEM scans. Microcracks 15. Chamanfar, A., Jahazi., J.G.M., Wanjara, P., Yue, S.: Mechanical
emerge as a result of residual strains on the specimen property and microstructure of Linear Friction Welded WAS-
brought on by thermal stresses during energy discharge PALOY. Met. Mater. Trans. A42, 729–744 (2011)
16. Gunen, A., Dolekar, K.M., Korkmaz, M.E., Gok, M.S., Erdogan,
and dielectric media cleansing pressure. A.: Characteristics, high temperature wear and oxidation behaviour
• The surface tension of the degraded particles causes glob- of boride layer grown on Nimonic 80A Ni-based superalloy. Surf.
ules to develop. Because of the abrupt cooling caused by Coat. Technol. 409, 126906 (2021)
123
International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing (IJIDeM) (2023) 17:859–867 867
17. Dhananchezian, M., Rajkumar, K.: Comparative study of cutting 28. Perumal, A., Kailasanathan, C., Stalin, B., Kumar, S., Rajku-
insert wear and roughness parameter (Ra) while turning Nimonic mar, S., Gangadharan, P.R., Venkatesan, T., Nagaprasad, G.,
90 and hastelloy C-276 by coated carbide inserts. Mater. Today Dhinakaran, N.: Multiresponse optimization of Wire Electrical
Proc. 22, 1406–1416 (2019) Discharge Machining Parameters for Ti-6Al-2Sn-4Zr-2Mo (α-β)
18. Kumar, V., Jangra, K.K., Vikas, K., Neeraj, S.: WEDM of nickel- Alloy using Taguchi-Grey Relational Approah. Adv. Mater. Sci.
based aerospace alloy: optimization of process parameters and Eng. 95, 285–289 (2022)
modelling. Int. J. Interact. Des. Manuf. 11, 917–929 (2017) 29. Prasad, A.R., Ramji, K., Kolli, M.: Machinability studies of lead
19. Priyadarshini, M., Vishwanatha, H.M., Biswas, C.K., Singhal, P., induced Ti-6Al-4V alloy using Taguchi technique on WEDM pro-
Buddhi, D., Behera, A.: Effect of grey relational optimization of cess. Mater. Today Proc. 44, 2593–2599 (2021)
process parameters on surface and tribological characteristics of 30. Kumar, H., Manna, A., Kumar, R.: Modeling of process param-
annealed AISI P20 tool steel machined using wire EDM. Int. J. eters for Surface Roughness and Analysis of Machined Surface
Interact. Des. Manuf. 11, 917–929 (2022) in WEDM of Al/SiC-MMC. Trans. Indian Inst. Met. 71, 231–244
20. AnoopJohny, T.C.: Investigation of surface integrity and it’s (2018)
optimization on pure titanium using molybdenum wire by recip- 31. Kumar, A., Kumar, V., Kumar, J.: Multi-response optimization of
rocated travelling WEDM—a review. Mater. Today Proc. 33(7), process parameters based on response surface methodology for
2581–2584 (2019) pure titanium using WEDM process. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol.
21. Sonawane, S.A., Kulkarni, M.L.: Multi-quality response optimiza- 68, 2645–2668 (2013)
tion of wire EDM for Ni-75 using PCA based utility theory. Mater. 32. Singh, H., Kumar, V., Kapoor, J.: Modeling of WEDM parameters
Today, Proc. 5, 4584–4591 (2018) and surface integrity characteristics in the machining of Nimonic75
22. Manna, A., Bhattacharyya, B.: Taguchi and Gauss elimination alloy. Mater. Today Proc. 28(3), 363–1371 (2020)
method: a dual response approach for parametric optimization of 33. Kumar, A., Abhishek, K., Vivekananda, K., Maity, K.P.: Effect of
CNC wire cut EDM of PR AlSiC MMC. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Tech- wire electrode materials on die-corner accuracy for wire electrical
nol. 28, 67–75 (2006) discharge machining (WEDM) of Inconel 718. Mater. Today Proc.
23. Khan, M.A.S., Nandakumar, C., Kumar, C.S.: Machinability study 5, 12641–12648 (2018)
of Incoloy using different wire electrode in wire-cut EDM. Mater. 34. Manjaiah, M., Narendranath, S., Basavarajappa, S., Gaitonde, V.N.:
Today Proc. 58(1), 33–38 (2022) Investigation on material removal rate, surface and subsurface char-
24. Kumar, U.A., Saidulu, G., Laxminaryana, P.: Experimental inves- acteristics in wire electro discharge machining of Ti50Ni50-xCux
tigation of process parameters for machining of Nimonic alloy 75 shape memory alloy. J. Mat. Des. Appl. 232(2), 164–177 (2018)
using wire-cut EDM. Mater. Today Proc. 27(2), 1362–1368 (2020)
25. Nandakumar, C., Mohan, B., Salman Khan, M.A.: Experimental
investigation on machinability of Inconel 800 using CNC WEDM
Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to juris-
and modeling of process parameters. J. Adv. Micros Res. 13(2),
dictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
160–165 (2018)
26. Nadupuru, R., Suman, K.N.S.: Experimental investigation and
Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds
evaluation of EDM characteristics of inconel 718 material with
exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the
and without assistance of magnet. Int. J. Interact. Des. Manuf. 15,
author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted
225–238 (2021)
manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such
27. Tina Chaudhary, A.N., Siddiquee, A.K., Chanda: Effect of wire
publishing agreement and applicable law.
tension on different output responses during wire electric dis-
charge machining on AISI 304 stainless steel. Def. Technol. 15(4),
541–544 (2019)
123