1

Modernization of the California DMV

Jacob A. Dunckel

Trine University

BAN 5003: Operations Analytics

Dr. Jeffery Edwards

January 14, 2024

Modernization of the California DMV

There has been a growing demand on all levels of government in recent years to better

serve communities. Expectations from consumers and industry standards are changing as more

services become accessible online and on mobile devices. The California Department of Motor

Vehicles (DMV) is an excellent example of a government body that has altered its interactions

with the general population. The DMV has developed a number of online services, such as online

appointment scheduling and driver's license renewal, making it easier and more convenient for

citizens to obtain the services they require.

The DMV's recent modernization efforts have been motivated by a variety of causes,

including the growing popularity of online services, a desire to improve customer service, and

the need to cut expenses. The DMV has come a long way in recent years, but there is still space

for improvement. For example, the DMV's mobile app does not support license renewals or

requests for driver records. The DMV should fill this gap in order to better serve its clients.

Overall, the DMV serves as an example for other government organizations seeking to enhance

customer service. The DMV's online services are convenient and simple to use, and the agency

has committed to providing better customer service. The DMV is not without flaws, but it is on

the right route.

The Most Important Facts Surrounding the Case

The DMV has gone through various changes over the past decade, adapting to

technological changes, and meeting new customer expectations. For reference, the DMV is the

largest customer service agency in California, which serves 33 million registered vehicles along

with 25 million licensed drivers (Hertzberg, 2015). Serving such a large customer base, it is not

an easy task to adapt to changes. Despite this, the DMV has implemented new online measures
3

that allow for appointment scheduling, vehicle registration, and address changes. Some of these

online features have not yet translated to the mobile app, as license renewals and driver records

requests cannot be completed through the app. This may prove to be an issue, as an increasing

number of Americans expect all services to be available through a mobile app. A recent survey

by Business Insider, “showed nearly 40% of Americans, and 51% of 18- 44 year olds, want to

use their mobile phone to access government services” (Hertzberg, 2015). In order to keep up

with changing trends, the DMV needs to adapt their services to meet consumer needs.

In 2015, the California governor implemented a traffic ticket and infraction amnesty

program with the goal of collecting outstanding court-ordered debt from traffic violations, which

at the time exceeded $10 million (Hertzberg, 2015). This was the second amnesty program

attempt in five years, which aimed to improve upon a less successful program in 2012. The 2015

program offered more incentives to repay debts, including running for a longer duration (18

months), assurance that driver’s licenses would be reinstated for participants, and a way to test

for availability to pay a greatly reduced amount on outstand debt (Hertzberg, 2015). This version

of the program focused on participants who were unable to pay because of costs rather than those

who intentionally avoided payments. Early results from the Los Angeles County showed a high

participation and collection rates, outperforming the 2012 program in just one month (Hertzberg,

2015).

While the program showed early signs of success, there are some challenges and

concerns that arose. First, some unethical debt collectors mislead consumers about their

eligibility for the program, which is fueled by earning a commission based on the amount

collected from consumers (Hertzberg, 2015). Another issue involved consumers that had tickets

across multiple counties, which proved to be difficult to resolve all tickets at a single location.
4

Lastly, improvements were needed for low-income consumers that had difficulties applying for

potential relief (Hertzberg, 2015). Despite these concerns, the program still was on a successful

track.

Key Issues

The issues faced by the DMV and the traffic amnesty program can be separated into two

categories: accessibility and program implementation. The accessibility aspect refers to the

DMV’s inability to collect court-ordered debt and has incurred more than $10 billion in 2015

(Hertzberg, 2015). Program implementation relates to the traffic amnesty program and the

challenges that arose from it.

While the California DMV offers simple online services such as appointment scheduling

and vehicle registration, its mobile app falls short, missing important features such as license

renewals and record requests. This digital divide fails to meet the expectations of today's mobile-

first consumers. Furthermore, low-income consumers may experience difficulties as a result of

lengthy court procedures including payments and applications (Hertzberg, 2015). To make

matters worse, resolving fines in numerous counties becomes an administrative nightmare, which

could limit program participation. These challenges of accessibility and convenience highlight

areas where the DMV needs to close the divide and improve its services for all individuals,

regardless of their technical skills or financial level.

Despite the purpose of assisting those who are in debt with the Traffic Ticket and

Infraction Amnesty Program, ethical considerations complicate its implementation. Accusations

that debt collectors misled consumers about their eligibility raise concerns about the transparency

and the possible exploitation of vulnerable people. While the initiative attempts to assist people

who were unable to pay, it could inadvertently benefit those who purposely avoided payment.
5

Finally, the lack of real-time statewide data makes it difficult to conduct a thorough evaluation of

the program's efficacy, making it harder to identify areas for improvement and assure fair access

for all.

Alternate Courses of Action

Based on the some of the key issues identified, the DMV could take different courses of

action that specifically improve the areas of access, convenience, and future program

implementation. The first approach is to improve mobile app functionality, as majority of

consumers prefer to complete DMV actions through a mobile device. Secondly, a focus to

improve accessibility and convenience for low-income individuals through simplified court

payment and application process, along with additional multilingual communication. Lastly,

strengthening future repayment program oversight and transparency will allow for more trust

between consumers and the DMV.

Implementation of alternate courses of action and using data to track the status of them

will allow the DMV to collect more debts and build trust with the consumers. While these

alternative courses of action may be dependent on multiple factors, such as budget requirements,

support from the government and consumers, resources, and the priorities of the DMV, focusing

on improvements will only benefit the DMV and consumers alike. The employment of multiple

business analysts may further improve operations for the DMV. In the article Why Business

Analysts Are Essential to Your Operations Team, Paul Crosby states that, “While some

companies still believe that BAs are an added cost, they actually do the opposite and help reduce

company costs through increasing its ROI and lowering project costs” (Crosby, 2019). Leaning

into business analysts may help the DMV to implement these alternate courses of action.
6

Evaluation of Alternate Courses of Action

While the DMV's mobile app is a step forward, it lacks critical functions such as license

renewals and record requests. To close the gap, the DMV could focus on development based on

user research, focusing first on these fundamental functions that users want in the app. Working

with professional mobile app developers allows them to benefit from their expertise in user-

friendly design and effective implementation. However, prior to a complete launch, a pilot

testing program with specific user groups and repeated feedback loops are critical. This

guarantees that the app genuinely matches the needs and expectations of the users, moving it

from just a convenience to a meaningful resource for consumers.

Another course of action the DMV can implement in order to reach all Californians is to

focus on those that may have hard time accessing technology. Simplifying court procedures and

providing other payment choices such as cash or installments will help low-income consumers

who are suffering with fines and applications. Working with community organizations and legal

aid services help to overcome the knowledge gap while also offering focused assistance and

raising awareness about the amnesty program. Finally, providing bilingual communication and

instructional materials guarantees that all residents have equal access to information and

resources, regardless of their native language. By removing barriers, the DMV can better serve

all Californians of all social classes.

To make sure that everyone has a fair chance and trusts the ticket amnesty program, the

DMV must strengthen its control over debt collectors by enforcing stronger laws and establishing

clear eligibility requirements. Transparency takes more than just words. Real-time data analytics

are essential for tracking participation across income levels and ethnicities. The DMV can use

this data-driven approach to detect any unintended effects of the "unable vs. unwilling" problem
7

and change program criteria to make sure equal opportunity and benefit distribution. Investing in

an in-depth real-time data system is about making educated decisions that improve outcomes for

all Californians, guaranteeing the program meets its objective without generating new problems.

The DMV may address the primary challenges outlined in the paper and strive for a more

effective, efficient, and equal system for all Californians by implementing an alternate course of

action now or in the future.

Best Course of Action

Choosing the most significant course of action for the DMV is a difficult decision

because each option considers major issues with strong reasons. However, given the broader

context and potential impact, the DMV should focus their efforts to emphasize accessibility and

convenience for low-income individuals as an immediate priority.

Addressing this issue has the ability to reach a large portion of the consumer base that

faces cost hurdles to getting important services. Their lives can be directly and positively

impacted by streamlining court processes, providing alternate payment options, and collaborating

with community organizations. These actions can enhance their access to equity, financial

stability, and even the reinstatement of their driver's license, which can be necessary for

employment and basic necessities. Since the low-income demographic in California is

significant, this course of action will result in the most efficient way to collect unpaid traffic

debts.

While improvements to mobile app functionality and program implementation are

critical, they may need a lengthier development timeframe and resource allocation. Streamlining

court procedures and collaborating with existing community organizations, on the other hand,

can be adopted quicker and create faster results. Prioritizing low-income consumer's needs
8

corresponds with the key ideas of equity and social justice. A fair and just society requires equal

access to government services and the removal of financial barriers. Addressing accessibility can

open the path for other measures to be implemented more effectively. For example, by

streamlining court procedures and raising awareness among low-income citizens, the DMV can

increase Amnesty Program participation, resulting in better outcomes for both the program and

individuals with debt.

Despite focusing on one specific course of action, the DMV shouldn't disregard other

initiatives. Improvements to program implementation and mobile app functioning should be

addressed simultaneously, utilizing data analytics to track progress and guarantee fair results for

all residents. However, the DMV can significantly improve the lives of a vulnerable population

and set the stage for a more inclusive and effective system for everybody by concentrating first

on accessibility and convenience for low-income individuals.

Conclusion

Although the California DMV's modernization efforts are a step in the right

direction, there are still major obstacles in the way. User expectations are hampered by the

mobile app's lack of essential features, low-income citizens are especially impacted by

accessibility issues, and the Amnesty Program's execution is had some ethical issue. While every

issue is important, the most effective and practical place to start is by giving low-income people's

accessibility and convenience top priority. In addition to directly improving lives and promoting

equity, streamlining court processes, providing alternate payment alternatives, and collaborating

with community organizations can open the door to resolving additional issues. The DMV can

transform its modernization efforts by understanding the struggles of low-income communities

and utilizing data-driven insights. This will ensure that all Californians can access all

necessary services regardless of their means of access.

References

Crosby, P. (2019, September 3). Why Business Analysts Are Essential to Your Operations Team.

Business Analyst Training and Product Management Courses.

https://theuncommonleague.com/articles/202362/lazex8ersti0ry1we2jroywdzmuk5v

Hertzberg, R. (2015, December 15). The DMV: A Case Study in Modernization. California State

Senate.

https://sgf.senate.ca.gov/sites/sgf.senate.ca.gov/files/background_informational_hearing_

the_dmv-_a_case_study_in_modernization.pdf