Do The Churches in India Still Depend Upon Help From Foreign
Do The Churches in India Still Depend Upon Help From Foreign
Yes, many churches in India still depend on help from foreign sources, although the degree of
dependence varies across denominations and regions. This assistance can come in the form of
financial aid, training, resources for ministry, and sometimes partnership for specific missions
or social work.
Here are some reasons why Indian churches may continue to rely on foreign help:
1. Financial Support
3. Partnership in Mission
Evangelism and Church Planting: Foreign missions often partner with local
churches in India to support evangelistic efforts and church planting, especially in
areas where Christianity is less established or in restricted regions.
Support for Missionaries: Some Indian churches and missionary organizations
receive financial support from foreign churches to sustain local missionaries,
particularly in remote or hostile environments.
4. Historical Ties
However, there is also a growing movement towards self-reliance among Indian churches.
Many denominations are working to strengthen local giving, develop local leadership, and
reduce dependency on foreign aid, aiming for sustainability within the Indian context.
Foreign help for Christian missionary work can be both good and bad, depending on how it is
applied and managed. Here’s an exploration of both the positives and negatives:
If Good, Why?
If Bad, Why?
Conclusion
Foreign help in Christian missionary work can be good when it is used wisely to strengthen
and empower local churches, promote self-reliance, and foster global Christian unity.
However, it can become bad if it leads to long-term dependency, cultural insensitivity, or
negative perceptions that harm the local church's mission. The key is balance—foreign help
should support and not control, empower and not dominate, always respecting the local
context and fostering local leadership.
The modern Ecumenical Movement began in the early 20th century, though its roots can be
traced back to earlier efforts at Christian unity.
1. Historical Background
o Early Christian Unity: In the early centuries of Christianity, the Church was
largely united, though regional differences existed. However, various
theological disputes and political tensions led to major divisions, most
notably:
The Great Schism (1054) between the Eastern Orthodox Church and
the Roman Catholic Church.
The Protestant Reformation (16th century), which led to the creation
of Protestant churches and further divisions within Christianity.
Despite these divisions, there were occasional efforts to reunify the church, but most
were unsuccessful until the 20th century.
Conclusion
The Ecumenical Movement has made significant strides in promoting dialogue, cooperation,
and unity among Christian denominations. While complete unity has not yet been achieved,
the movement has fostered mutual respect and collaboration, especially in addressing social
and humanitarian issues. Its growth continues as churches around the world engage in
dialogue to overcome historical divisions and present a unified Christian witness to a world in
need of hope and peace.
The Edinburgh Conference brought together more than 1,200 delegates from
various Protestant denominations and missionary societies from across the world. It
was the first time such a broad representation of different Christian groups gathered
with the express purpose of discussing missions and cooperation in spreading the
Gospel.
Although it primarily focused on Protestant churches, it established the idea that
Christians from different backgrounds and traditions could work together for a
common cause, especially in mission fields.
A key theme of the conference was the recognition that Christian divisions hindered
the effectiveness of missionary work. Delegates realized that competing
denominational efforts in non-Christian regions often led to confusion and
inefficiency, which weakened the overall mission of the Church.
This practical concern for unity in missionary work spurred the desire for closer
cooperation between denominations, which eventually evolved into broader
ecumenical concerns for Christian unity beyond just missions.
The Edinburgh Conference didn’t just conclude with discussions; it led to the
creation of structures that would foster continued cooperation among churches. For
example, the International Missionary Council (IMC) was formed as a direct result
of the conference. The IMC later merged with the World Council of Churches
(WCC), a leading ecumenical body today.
The Faith and Order Movement and the Life and Work Movement, two early
ecumenical efforts that sought to address doctrinal issues and social concerns, can
trace their origins to the cooperative spirit of the Edinburgh Conference.
The missionary context of the conference helped shift the focus from internal church
conflicts to the broader goal of spreading the Gospel. This provided a common ground
for different denominations to unite, even if they disagreed on doctrinal matters.
The realization that Christians could collaborate in mission despite their differences
was a major step toward the broader goals of the Ecumenical Movement, which
would later include issues of faith, order, and social justice.
Many of the leaders who attended the Edinburgh Conference went on to play
prominent roles in the development of the modern Ecumenical Movement. The
conference’s success in fostering cooperation inspired future gatherings and initiatives
that promoted Christian unity on a larger scale.
Conclusion
The World Missionary Conference of 1910 is considered the beginning of the modern
Ecumenical Movement because it demonstrated the possibility and necessity of Christian
unity, especially in the context of missionary work. Its emphasis on cooperation, dialogue,
and mission laid the foundation for future ecumenical efforts, ultimately leading to the
formation of the World Council of Churches and other ecumenical bodies. This conference
marked the first significant step toward overcoming denominational divisions and working
together as one body of Christ, which became the core vision of the Ecumenical Movement.
EXPLAIN THE FAITH ORDER MOVEMENT AND LIFE AND WORK JOINED
INTO THE WCC ALSO HOW IT MERGING AND GROWTH THE MISSIONS
WORK
The Faith and Order Movement and the Life and Work Movement played key roles in the
development of the World Council of Churches (WCC) and the growth of the modern
Ecumenical Movement. These two streams focused on different aspects of Christian unity
but eventually merged within the WCC, enhancing its ability to foster global Christian
cooperation and advancing the mission of the Church. Here’s an explanation of both
movements, their merger into the WCC, and how this contributed to the growth of missionary
work:
Purpose: The Faith and Order Movement was established to address the theological
differences among Christian denominations and to promote doctrinal unity. It
sought to find common ground on issues such as the sacraments, ministry, and the
nature of the Church.
Historical Background: It began in 1927 with the first Faith and Order Conference
in Lausanne, Switzerland. This movement gathered representatives from various
Christian traditions, including Eastern Orthodox, Protestant, and Anglican churches,
to discuss ways to reconcile doctrinal divisions that had persisted for centuries.
Focus: The focus was on theological dialogue and understanding the differences and
commonalities among various Christian traditions. Faith and Order tackled important
questions about church governance, the interpretation of scripture, and the role of
sacraments in worship.
Purpose: In contrast, the Life and Work Movement focused on the practical and
social aspects of Christian unity, emphasizing collaboration in addressing social
justice issues, such as poverty, peace, and the economic well-being of communities.
It was more action-oriented and aimed at encouraging churches to work together to
improve society and address global challenges.
Historical Background: This movement officially began with the Life and Work
Conference in Stockholm in 1925, under the leadership of Nathan Söderblom, the
Archbishop of Uppsala. It sought to demonstrate that, despite doctrinal differences,
Christians could unite in efforts to bring about social change and promote peace in the
world.
Focus: Life and Work emphasized the practical application of Christian values in
society, including efforts toward peacebuilding, social justice, humanitarian aid,
and global missions. It promoted the idea that churches should be at the forefront of
addressing moral and ethical challenges in the world.
3. Merging of Faith and Order and Life and Work into the World Council of Churches
(WCC)
The Formation of the WCC: The World Council of Churches (WCC) was
officially formed in 1948, largely through the efforts of the Faith and Order and Life
and Work movements. These two movements realized that their goals were
complementary: while Faith and Order focused on doctrinal unity, Life and Work
emphasized practical cooperation in social issues. By coming together, they could
present a more united Christian front.
o The merger was a response to the need for a comprehensive approach to
Christian unity that addressed both theological and practical dimensions of
faith.
o This convergence marked the birth of the WCC as a global ecumenical body.
It brought together Protestant, Orthodox, Anglican, and later Catholic
representatives to work on issues of doctrine, social justice, and global
missions.
WCC’s Structure: The WCC was structured to have both theological dialogue
(through the continuation of the Faith and Order work) and social action (through
Life and Work projects). The merging of the two movements enabled the WCC to
pursue a broader agenda, combining deep doctrinal reflection with active engagement
in addressing the world's pressing issues.
Unified Missionary Efforts: The WCC’s formation helped unify Christian efforts in
missionary work, especially in regions where denominational divisions had
previously weakened the Church’s witness. Missionaries from different Christian
traditions could now cooperate more effectively in spreading the Gospel and
addressing social needs.
o In mission fields, the emphasis shifted from denominational competition to
collaboration, which improved the church’s credibility and effectiveness.
o The WCC created a platform for joint mission projects, where churches could
pool resources and personnel to reach unreached people groups and engage in
holistic mission efforts (evangelism combined with humanitarian aid).
Social Justice as Mission: The merging of the Life and Work movement into the
WCC expanded the traditional concept of mission. Mission was no longer seen as
purely evangelistic but also included social justice, peacebuilding, and economic
development. This broadened the scope of missionary work to include efforts such
as:
o Combating poverty and hunger.
o Promoting human rights and equality.
o Addressing environmental concerns.
Missionary efforts were increasingly seen as part of the church’s responsibility to
transform society, bringing Christian values into public life. The Life and Work
tradition infused the missionary movement with a stronger commitment to social
change, grounded in the Gospel.
Theological Unity Strengthened Mission: The work of Faith and Order helped
create a sense of theological solidarity among different Christian traditions, which
allowed for more cooperative mission endeavors. Although complete doctrinal
agreement was not always possible, Faith and Order’s focus on understanding
differences helped missionaries from various backgrounds feel more united in
purpose.
o This unity encouraged churches to send joint mission teams and participate in
cross-denominational mission organizations, maximizing the church’s impact
on a global scale.
Global Influence: The WCC, with its roots in both Faith and Order and Life and
Work, became an influential body in shaping the direction of global missionary
efforts. It provided a forum for churches from all over the world to coordinate their
missionary strategies and address common concerns such as religious persecution,
global conflict, and poverty.
Increased Collaboration: The merging of Faith and Order and Life and Work within
the WCC fostered a spirit of cooperation in the global mission field. Churches worked
together to establish hospitals, schools, and relief programs in developing countries.
This partnership approach strengthened the global Christian witness and made
missionary work more sustainable.
Focus on Local Leadership: As the ecumenical spirit grew, there was a push for
local leadership in mission fields. The WCC emphasized the importance of training
and empowering local pastors and church leaders rather than relying solely on foreign
missionaries. This helped indigenize the mission and made the Christian faith more
relevant to different cultural contexts.
Holistic Mission Approach: The WCC promoted a holistic mission approach,
combining evangelism with social and humanitarian work. This broadened the
church’s mission from a narrow focus on conversion to a wider concern for human
dignity and community well-being, especially in regions affected by war, poverty, or
disease.
Conclusion
The merging of the Faith and Order Movement and the Life and Work Movement into
the World Council of Churches represented a significant step in the history of the
Ecumenical Movement and the global mission of the church. By combining efforts to address
both theological unity and practical social concerns, the WCC became a powerful force for
Christian cooperation in mission work. This merger allowed for greater unity in the global
mission field, making Christian efforts more effective, sustainable, and relevant to the needs
of the world.
The World Council of Churches (WCC) holds assemblies roughly every eight years,
bringing together member churches from around the world to discuss ecumenical issues,
foster unity, and address global concerns. Each assembly is a significant event in the life of
the WCC, marking key moments in its development. Here is an overview of the first seven
assemblies of the WCC, highlighting their themes, locations, and contributions to the
ecumenical movement:
Conclusion
Each of the first seven WCC assemblies addressed the specific challenges of their time while
staying focused on the broader goals of Christian unity and mission. The assemblies
emphasized themes such as Christ’s hope, light, life, and renewal, and they increasingly
addressed social justice, peace, and the environment. The decisions made at these
assemblies helped shape the direction of the global ecumenical movement and contributed to
the growth and impact of missionary work by fostering cooperation among different Christian
traditions and focusing on both spiritual and social aspects of the Church’s mission.
The attitudes of missionaries in the 19th and 20th centuries toward the non-Christian world
varied, reflecting both the context of their time and the evolving understanding of mission
work. Here are some key attitudes and their impact on the success of these missions in
winning people to Christ:
Attitude: Missionaries of the 19th century often felt a strong sense of divine
mandate to evangelize non-Christian peoples, driven by the belief in the exclusivity
of Christ for salvation. They saw it as their duty to "save souls" from eternal
damnation, as many adhered to the belief that those outside of Christianity were lost.
Success: This deep conviction led to widespread missionary movements, particularly
during the Great Century of Missions, where figures like William Carey (India),
David Livingstone (Africa), and Hudson Taylor (China) spearheaded efforts to reach
unreached populations. Their success was measured by the establishment of churches
and Christian communities in previously non-Christian lands.
Attitude: Some missionaries, like Hudson Taylor of the China Inland Mission,
began adopting an attitude of inculturation—embracing local languages and customs
rather than imposing Western ways. Taylor famously adopted Chinese dress and
sought to live among the people as one of them.
Success: This approach showed respect for the local culture, and Taylor’s work in
China became one of the most successful in terms of establishing lasting Christian
communities. By blending into local life, missionaries gained greater access to the
people and their trust.
Attitude: The 20th century also saw a growing emphasis on interfaith dialogue
rather than outright confrontation with other religions. The idea was to engage with
non-Christian faiths respectfully while still holding firm to the uniqueness of Christ.
Missionaries like Lesslie Newbigin emphasized the need for Christians to listen to
people of other faiths while presenting the Gospel.
Success: This approach helped to break down barriers that previously alienated
people of other faiths. It led to more effective witness in pluralistic societies,
especially in places like India, where Hinduism and Islam were deeply entrenched.
While conversions happened more gradually, the approach fostered better long-term
relationships and understanding.
c. Holistic Mission and Social Justice
d. Indigenization of Leadership
Attitude: One of the major shifts in the 20th century was the growing recognition that
local leaders needed to be in charge of the Church in non-Christian regions. Instead
of being dominated by foreign missionaries, churches began to raise up their own
pastors, teachers, and evangelists.
Success: This empowered local communities and helped Christianity to become a
more authentic expression of faith in various cultural contexts. The rapid growth of
the Church in regions like Africa and Asia during the 20th century is largely attributed
to the indigenization of leadership, where local believers took ownership of the
mission and carried it forward in ways that resonated with their own people.
Conclusion
The success of 19th- and 20th-century missionaries in winning people to Christ was shaped
by evolving attitudes. While the 19th century was marked by a combination of evangelistic
zeal and sometimes cultural superiority, the 20th century brought a growing emphasis on
contextualization, indigenous leadership, dialogue, and holistic mission. These shifts
allowed Christianity to spread across the globe, particularly in Africa and Asia, where it
continues to grow today. However, in many contexts, success also depended on how well
missionaries adapted to and respected the cultures they were engaging, rather than imposing
foreign ideas and practices.
2. The Evangelical Revivals / The Great Awakenings (18th and 19th Centuries)
Overview: These were periods of religious revival that swept through Europe and
North America in the 18th and 19th centuries, leading to widespread church renewal
and evangelistic fervor.
First Great Awakening (1730s-1740s): Led by figures like Jonathan Edwards and
George Whitefield, this movement in the American colonies emphasized a personal,
emotional experience of conversion and a renewed focus on evangelism.
Second Great Awakening (1790s-1840s): A broader revival that took place across
the United States, spearheaded by leaders like Charles Finney. This revival
emphasized personal salvation, social reform (such as the abolition of slavery), and
missionary activity.
Awakening Effects:
o Evangelism: The revivals brought a renewed emphasis on evangelism,
converting large numbers of people and inspiring global missionary
movements.
o Spiritual Renewal: They rekindled a sense of spiritual urgency and
personal piety in believers, encouraging them to live out their faith actively
and personally.
o Social Reforms: The Second Great Awakening, in particular, spurred
significant social movements, such as the temperance movement, abolition of
slavery, and advocacy for women’s rights, as Christians sought to apply their
faith to all areas of life.
o Expansion of Denominations: These revivals led to the growth of
denominations like Methodism and the Baptist churches, which emphasized
personal conversion and a direct relationship with God.
Both of these movements deeply impacted the Christian Church, leading to spiritual
awakenings, reforms, and the spread of Christianity across new regions and cultural contexts.