1

A Case-Based Approach

Student’s Name

Institutional Affiliation

Course Code & Title

Instructor’s Name

Date
 2

Introduction

The case I selected comes from "Complex Cases in Sport Psychology" and features a

professional athlete experiencing symptoms of performance anxiety and emotional burnout as a

result of intense pressure from both external and internal factors. Such an athlete at this elite

competitive level has experienced a dramatic decline in performance as one who can no longer

manage to cope with pre-competition stress or sustain the focus of concentration at times of

choice. The player presents symptoms of anxiety, low self-esteem, and fatigue that have started

to affect both personal life and interaction with teammates. Coaches and management are

concerned about the athlete's mental state because it influences his training and consistency on

game days.

When building rapport, I create an environment that instills confidence in the athlete,

enabling them to speak freely and without inhibition. I do this by first instilling trust through

openness and empathy in communication. I will let them speak with their concern and allow me

to listen as if to understand their feelings, not giving solutions or criticisms right away. It would

entail showing them genuine concern for their well-being outside of performance and helping to

establish a positive therapeutic relationship. The level of confidentiality would be very

important, as top-level athletes may be unwilling to show weaknesses of any kind in such a

demanding environment. Acknowledging their success and respecting the effort they put into it

could help build a better relationship.

Cognitive behavioral therapy, the chosen psychology modality, effectively addresses

performance anxiety by identifying and transforming negative thought patterns that lead to

stress, fear of failure, and low confidence (Nakao et al., 2021). It also provides practical
 3

strategies for managing anxiety in real-time, such as breathing exercises, mental imagery, and

reframing negative self-talk. Second, by working with the athlete to challenge illogical beliefs

("If I don't win, I am a failure") and develop healthier cognitive schema, we can diminish the

psychological impact of external demands. Third, a goal-setting component of CBT has helped

to rebuild the athlete's confidence in focusing on controllable factors, effort, and attitude rather

than results alone (Nakao et al., 2021). We will build the rapport in a non-judgmental and

empathetic manner, utilizing CBT skills to enable the athlete to reclaim control of his mental

state, leading to improved performance and well-being.

Initial Needs Assessment

Rationale for Needs Assessment

A needs assessment will be an important first step in grasping the full scope of the

athlete's psychological and performance challenges. The symptoms that this athlete is presenting

—struggles with performance anxiety and emotional burnout—are merely symptoms of deeper

underlying issues, namely unrealistic expectations, stress, and perhaps identity conflict. The

main goal of the needs assessment is to present a comprehensive review of the athlete's current

psychological status, personal or environmental stressors, and their consequences for

performance and general well-being.

A proper needs assessment will allow me to identify which particular psychological and

emotional barriers are leading to the current deterioration in performance. As a result, the

intervention plan will be based on his or her specific needs rather than a blanket approach for all

athletes suffering from the same problem. This would also help in deciding whether other factors
 4

are contributing to the condition, such as interpersonal conflicts within the team, absence of

coping mechanisms, or overt feelings of burnout due to an overloaded schedule. The process

creates baseline data that allows for the measurement of progress throughout the intervention.

Assessment Tools

In formulating the comprehensive needs assessment, I would employ both qualitative and

quantitative tools to detail the athlete's cognitive, emotional, and behavioral state. Some of the

key tools I could use in this regard are:

Needs Assessment: The needs assessment will be primarily carried out with the use of the

athlete himself by means of a deep, semi-structured interview. This interview shall aim to be

broad in understanding the subjective experience that characterizes anxiety, stress, and burnout

of performance. The areas for discussion shall include self-perception, motivation, past

performances, team dynamics, and external pressures. With this structured yet open-ended

interview format, it is possible to specify major psychological and environmental stressors

associated with the athlete's performance.

Sport Anxiety Scale-2: It is a standardized questionnaire designed to measure sport-specific

anxiety in three domains: somatic anxiety, worry, and concentration disruption. The SAS-2 shall

help in quantifying the levels of anxiety the athlete experiences during competition and training

(Tomczak et al., 2022). This will further provide evidence of whether the athlete's anxiety is

more cognitive (worry, negative thoughts) or more somatic (tension and sweating), which will

guide the choice of interventions.

 5

Burnout Questionnaire: When considering athlete symptoms that indicate burnout, it will be of

great relevance to explore the feelings of emotional and physical exhaustion. An instrument such

as the ABQ could aid in comprehending the impact of burnout on an athlete's motivation, mental

health, and performance. It measures three central dimensions: emotional and physical

exhaustion, reduced accomplishment, and sport devaluation.

Behavioral observations: Observing an athlete's behavior during training sessions and

competitive events can yield valuable data (Park et al., 2023). For example, identifying

patterns in excessive pre-game rituals and physical signs of anxiety such as fidgeting, shallow

breathing, or withdrawal from teammates might be indicative of how performance stress

manifests. Self-report measures may not capture objective insights provided by behavioral

observations.

Individuals and Groups to Engage

The athlete: This will be the main client for the purpose of our needs assessment. Repeated

interviews, lasting one to two weeks, will allow for the development of rapport and further

exploration of the athlete's thoughts and feelings. The athlete will also complete the

questionnaires, SAS-2, ABQ, and performance profiling (Tomczak et al., 2022).

Coaches: Coaches are very instrumental in the athlete's development and can sometimes

provide very useful insight into the athlete's mind and emotional state. An informal

interview with the coach will help contextualize the athlete's performance history, work ethic,

and any changes in attitude or behavior over time. The coach's perspective will be important in

noting team dynamics that may lead to the athlete's stress or burnout.
 6

Sports Psychologist: If applicable, engaging a team sports psychologist or another mental health

professional the athlete has worked with could give further context on past interventions or

psychological patterns. They may also be able to provide insights into the athlete's broader

mental health and previous coping strategies.

Medical Team: The degree of reported fatigue and burnout of the athlete may involve the need

for the medical team to rule out overtraining syndrome or any other physiological condition that

could be contributing to their mental health concerns.

Timeline

The first step, the needs assessment, would take place over a period of two to three

weeks. Week one includes the athlete and coach's initial interviews, questionnaires (SAS-2,

ABQ), and performance profiling. The second week is further data collection, including

behavioral observations during training sessions and games. By the end of the third week, we

shall have established findings from the collected data and go on to analyze the same data to

come up with an intervention plan with the athlete. During the course of the intervention,

ongoing observation and feedback ensure accurate monitoring of progress and any necessary

adjustments.

Interventions and monitoring

When an athlete experiences these problems or demands resulting from performance

anxiety and burnout, both psychological and environmental variables must be considered. The

central issue is pre-competition performance anxiety, which results in worry, disruption of

thought, and muscular tension. Anxiety in this context probably arises from high internal
 7

expectations, a sense of failure, and pressures imposed by coaches or even family members and

teammates. Simultaneously, burnout also emerges, characterized by emotional exhaustion, low

achievements, and even a diminished value for the sport. These complex issues impact athletes'

performance, potentially jeopardizing their mental well-being.

Different psychological interventions, tailored to the specific sport the athlete participates

in, can address each of these issues. One of the most applied methods so far has been cognitive

behavioral therapy, widely accepted as a modality for the treatment of disorders such as anxiety.

CBT will help the athlete to become aware of and change unconstructive thought patterns that

feed anxiety and burnout (Karyotaki et al., 2021). For example, if this performer tends to

catastrophize or is preoccupied with the worst possible outcome for every performance, CBT

will focus on identifying such thoughts and replacing them with more balanced and realistic

thinking. We will utilize techniques such as cognitive restructuring, thought diaries, and Socratic

questioning to confront negative thinking patterns and foster more adaptive thinking. CBT works

particularly well in sports settings because it is structured, time-limited, and goal-oriented,

matching the athlete's focus on performance outcomes.

Another intervention that would be useful is mindfulness-based stress reduction, which

builds an athlete's ability to become present and composed during high-pressure moments of a

competition. The process of being mindful involves paying attention to thoughts, emotions, and

feelings without judgment (Schuman-Olivier et al., 2020). An athlete can control their anxiety

without succumbing to it. Mindfulness integrated into the athletes' daily routines will help them

build resilience from stress and emotional regulation during competition. The athlete can achieve

this by practicing guided meditation sessions, body scans, and mindfulness exercises during
 8

training and in pre-competitive settings. MBSR, in particular, has the potential to avert cognitive

incapacitations such as loss of focus or worry that come with performance anxiety by keeping

the athlete in the present moment.

An SFBT approach may reduce the feeling of burnout. SFBT is based on "building on

strengths rather than focusing on deficits, problem dwelling, or failings." SFBT encourages the

athlete to reflect on moments of success or motivation, fostering a belief in self-efficacy and

optimism in their ability to overcome burnout (Sucipto et al., 2020). Regular feedback sessions

can incorporate this, encouraging the athlete to set small, manageable goals that will help them

regain some mastery in their sport.

To monitor the effectiveness of these interventions, the athlete will be regularly checked

in with regarding his progress, and strategies will be revised as necessary. The athlete's self-

reported scores on the Sport Anxiety Scale-2 serve as one measure to concurrently track a

decrease in anxiety. You can administer this at regular intervals, such as once every two weeks,

to monitor changes in anxiety levels over time. Also, I can assist the athlete in reflecting on his

perceived improvement in key mental and physical skills through performance profiling. This

tool visualizes progress and may be a beneficial motivational factor in demonstrating tangible

improvements.

Another form of monitoring will be behavioral observation during training and

competition. Being able to observe decreases in anxiety-related behaviors, such as muscle

tension or avoidance of specific drills, provides an indication that the athlete is adhering well to

the practice of relaxation techniques and CBT interventions (Sucipto et al., 2020). In this regard,
 9

if necessary, I will also consult with the coach about the athlete's attitude and performance in

practice, further ensuring that psychological gains are translated into improved performances.

The engagement in mindfulness practices will be monitored through self-report logs

where the athlete documents the frequency of the mindfulness exercises and perceived

effectiveness. During feedback sessions, we should review the logs to track patterns in adherence

to the practice and identify any perceived barriers. If there is any difficulty in setting aside time

for the mindfulness techniques, we will be able to discuss options on ways in which to modify

their current routine with shorter, more manageable exercises or incorporate mindfulness into

their current exercise warm-ups. The monitoring of burnout reduction will be based on the

athlete's self-described sense of accomplishment and emotional exhaustion, which can be

measured using ABQ. This can be read ministered every few weeks to measure progress.

Furthermore, regular sessions with SFBT will also provide qualitative data about an athlete's

motivation and emotional investment in his or her sport, letting us know whether the intervention

strategies have the desired effect (Sucipto et al., 2020).

Evaluation of Intervention

Evaluation is integral to any kind of psychological intervention. In sport psychology,

interventions' outcomes may have direct implications for an athlete's future performance and

overall well-being. Such an assessment aims to evaluate the effectiveness of the intervention

approaches, meet the athletes' needs, and make necessary adjustments to the strategy. Evaluation

has several uses: it provides evidence of the intervention's effectiveness, allows for

accountability, informs decisions, and aids the practitioner in refining future interventions.

Determining which parts of the intervention led to improvement, which parts require revision, or
 10

whether new problems need attention would be challenging without a structured evaluation

approach.

In this case, the athlete is experiencing performance issues such as anxiety and burnout;

therefore, evaluation plays a crucial role in ensuring the achievement of mental health and

performance goals. Anxiety and burnout are subjective experiences that differ among

individuals; therefore, the incorporation of both subjective and objective feedback is important in

capturing a holistic picture of the intervention's success. Therefore, the estimation of both the

external changes (cognitive, emotional) and internal modifications (behavioral, performance-

relevant) stands to provide a fuller understanding of the athlete's progress (Turner et al., 2023).

Decisions about the evaluation tools are critical. In the case of subjective feedback, self-

report questionnaires such as the SAS-2 and ABQ provide efficient information about the

athlete's internal state. SAS-2, which is specifically designed to assess the intensity of sport-

related anxiety, provides detailed insights into the cognitive, somatic, and worry dimensions of

anxiety. Over the course of an intervention, the practitioner can quantify changes in the

components of anxiety, such as precompetition worry and physical tension. The ABQ is a valid

construct for emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and reduced personal accomplishment

that constitutes burnout. These questionnaires, when administered over regular periods, provide a

view of the athlete's psychological state along a longitudinal axis, allowing for the establishment

of trends over time and responses to fluctuations.

In regard to objective feedback, there are some behavioral observations in training and

competition that are extremely important: the physical signs of an athlete's anxiety, such as

muscle tension or nervous habits; engagement in training, such as a desire to attempt challenging
 11

drills or concentrate on tasks. Another important tool that is useful in performance profiling

allows both the practitioner and the athlete to make judgments about the improvements that

occur in the performance-related areas. Therefore, performance profiling provides a clear and

traceable metric of improvement by visualizing skills such as concentration, confidence, and

relaxation. Secondly, the athlete's coach can also present the external views concerning observed

changes in performance, motivation, and attitude.

However, there are various key considerations that must be taken into account from the

perspective of any intervention. The athlete's mood on any given day, external pressures, or even

their understanding of the intervention itself can influence the subjective nature of psychological

change, potentially altering internal experiences like anxiety and burnout (Sucipto et al., 2020).

More subjective measures, such as self-report questionnaires, may thus be useful but afford

neither a consistent nor an accurate picture of the athlete's true state. The athletes may

underreport their anxiety due to a social desirability bias or fear of disappointing the practitioner.

Alternatively, the athletes can exaggerate progress as a means of trying to meet and satisfy

expectations.

Another challenge lies in the degree of complexity regarding the measurement of efficacy

for psychological interventions within a constantly changing environment that is usually under

tremendous pressure, such as competitive sport. Numerous factors other than the intervention

itself, such as coaching styles, team dynamics, injuries, and life stressors beyond sport, can

influence each athlete's performance. This makes the evaluation of the independent impact of the

psychological interventions very difficult. For instance, one could associate performance gains

with enhanced technical training instead of anxiety reduction. On the other hand, performance
 12

decrements may not signal the failure of the intervention; instead, externally imposed stressors

may temporarily eclipse its effects.

Another concern is intervention engagement monitoring. Utilizing mindfulness diaries

and session feedback forms may account for the athlete's practice in relation to mindfulness and

relaxation, but this is based on honesty and dedication. If the athlete does not practice outside of

direct sessions, the treatments will not be as effective (Sucipto et al., 2020). This may not

become apparent to the practitioner until the athlete or coach makes this assertion; therefore, any

judgment about the intervention's effectiveness may not be fully possible.

A constant, flexible review process is required to realize this. Continuous monitoring

during the intervention will allow for real-time adjustments that post-event reviews cannot

provide. Frequent feedback meetings with the athlete, grounded on subjective and objective data,

will help facilitate quick changes if certain strategies are not working. Qualitative feedback,

which may include open-ended observations on how treatments are working from the athlete, can

complement quantitative data and provide a wider context to the individual's experience.

Evaluation of Consultant Effectiveness/Reflective

Sport psychology consultants have much to learn from case studies, since every case can

present an individual combination of challenges and experiences. Case studies allow consultants

to put theoretical knowledge to practical use, after which they are able to view their results and

practice building their expertise. These practical experiences are useful, in fact, to the extent that

they serve as a link between theory and practice and create further levels of understanding for the

consultant in the way psychological interventions actually work in different environments

 13

(Rooney et al., 2021). Through close collaboration with athletes, teams, or organizations,

consultants become aware of complexities in human behavior and performance in sport that

often do not emerge in controlled research settings. Such exposure in the real world shapes

problem-solving skills, adaptability, and how to navigate the multilevel dynamics of sport

psychology.

One of the key benefits of case studies is that they provide an opportunity to test the

efficacy of interventions. Consultants may reflect on how well their chosen methods have

addressed the athlete's needs, identify what works and what has been a barrier to progress, and

then formulate ideas on what factors lead to and limit success. This reflection is valuable during

professional development, enabling consultants to consider what they would do differently if a

similar situation presented itself in the future. Also, revisiting case study outcomes provides an

opportunity for consultants to pay back into the greater realm of sport psychology by

disseminating findings and recommendations among colleagues in written form or in discussion.

On the whole, this is a very valuable learning vehicle that will allow consultants to refine their

approach, be more effective, and further develop their expertise.

In this regard, reflective practice remains at the core of such learning, where performance

anxiety and burnout take a front toll on an athlete's psychological well-being. In light of the

previous statement, reflective practice would involve critical examination by the consultant of

acts, decisions, and the intervention process as a whole for deeper self-awareness and

understanding. This is important because it maximizes continuous learning and improvement by

allowing the consultant to see strengths and areas for growth. For example, in the case of

burnout, reflective practice might help the consultant better understand the impacts of his
 14

strategies, the quality of his rapport-building, and the appropriateness of the chosen

psychological approach, such as CBT. That way, through reflection, the consultant will learn

whether the measures were effective or if they need to change something for further

interventions.

Reflective practice is particularly important in sport psychology, given the fluid, dynamic

nature of the sporting environment. Competition pressures, training demands, and personal

expectations are constantly changing, putting additional strain on athletes' psychological state.

Each session's reflection and the athlete's responses allow for flexibility and responsiveness to

the athlete's growing needs. Reflection, for example, may allow the consultant to consider why

this particular athlete resisted certain techniques and whether this approach might have been

counter-indicated in this case. This is also where reflective practice aids in examining one's own

biases and assumptions as a consultant, ensuring objectivity and maintaining an open mind while

working with the athletes. Thus, reflective practice forms a privileged part of the delivery of

support.

A reflective journal with supervision or peer consultation is advised for reflective

practice.During intervention, the consultant may record his thoughts, emotions, and observations

in a reflective diary. Writing regularly helps the consultant to track their grasp of the athlete's

demands, emotional reactions, and behavior or developmental trends (Nakao et al., 2021). This

documentation allows the consultant to critically analyze his conclusions. The reflective diary

will evaluate the suitability of the initial treatments and identify any need for revisions based on

athlete input and reaction.

 15

Further reflection comes via supervision or peer consultation. The supervisor or colleague

consultant discusses the case in order to provide feedback on the intervention method, challenge

assumptions, and gain new perspectives. Supervision also allows the consultant to discuss any

ambiguities or concerns in the case, with the supervisor's amicable environment helping them

better their professional growth. This approach, which integrates both solo and collaborative

reflection, ensures a comprehensive learning experience by fostering both intrapersonal and

interpersonal growth.

Gibbs' Reflective Cycle and Schön's Reflective Practice Model have the potential to

assist consultants in their reflection process. Gibbs' Reflective Cycle supports consultants

analyzing their experience through description, emotions, appraisal, analysis, conclusion, and

action plan. This methodology helps ensure comprehensive systematic reflection rather than

reactive reflection (Sow et al., 2024). Identification in Schön's paradigm of reflection-in-action—

thinking on one's feet during intervention—and reflection-on-action—reflecting afterward—

would support consultants to improve their profession in real time and retrospectively. These

frameworks permit the consultants to reflect and come up with important realizations and

behavioral changes.
 16

References

Karyotaki, E., Efthimiou, O., Miguel, C., genannt Bermpohl, F. M., Furukawa, T. A., Cuijpers,

P.,... & Forsell, Y. (2021). Internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy for

depression: a systematic review and individual patient data network meta-

analysis. JAMA psychiatry, 78(4), 361-371.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/article-abstract/2774861

Nakao, M., Shirotsuki, K., & Sugaya, N. (2021). Cognitive-behavioral therapy for management

of mental health and stress-related disorders: Recent advances in techniques and

technologies. BioPsychoSocial medicine, 15(1), 16.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13030-021-00219-w

Park, J. S., O'Brien, J., Cai, C. J., Morris, M. R., Liang, P., & Bernstein, M. S. (2023, October).

Generative agents: Interactive simulacra of human behavior. In Proceedings of

the 36th annual acm symposium on user interface software and technology (pp. 1-

22). https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3586183.3606763

Rooney, D., Jackson, R. C., & Heron, N. (2021). Differences in the attitudes to sport psychology

consulting between individual and team sport athletes. BMC Sports Science,

Medicine and Rehabilitation, 13(1), 46.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13102-021-00271-7

Schuman-Olivier, Z., Trombka, M., Lovas, D. A., Brewer, J. A., Vago, D. R., Gawande, R., ... &

Fulwiler, C. (2020). Mindfulness and behavior change. Harvard review of

psychiatry, 28(6), 371-394.

 17

https://journals.lww.com/hrpjournal/fulltext/2020/11000/Mindfulness_and_Behav

ior_Change.3.aspx?context=LatestArticles

Sow, C. F., Rasiah, S., & Er, H. M. (2024). A critical Exploration of Theoretical Frameworks for

Reflective Learning: Reflections from a Faculty Development

Workshop. Medical Science Educator, 1-5.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40670-024-02173-y

Sucipto, A., Purwanto, E., Japar, M., & Iłendo-Milewska, A. (2020). Improving the

psychological well-being of prisoners through group counseling with solution-

focused brief therapy (SFBT) approach. Psikohumaniora: Jurnal Penelitian

Psikologi, 5(2), 155-168.

https://journal.walisongo.ac.id/index.php/Psikohumaniora/article/view/6036

Tomczak, M., Kleka, P., Walczak, A., Bojkowski, Ł., Gracz, J., & Walczak, M. (2022).

Validation of Sport Anxiety Scale-2 (SAS-2) among Polish athletes and the

relationship between anxiety and goal orientation in sport. Scientific

Reports, 12(1), 12281. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-16418-6

Turner, M., Jones, M., & Wood, A. (Eds.). (2023). Applying cognitive behavioural therapeutic

approaches in sport. Taylor & Francis. https://books.google.com/books?

hl=en&lr=&id=8r2uEAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PT8&dq=the+estimation+of+both

+the+external+changes+(cognitive,+emotional)+and+internal+modifications+

(behavioural,+performance-relevant)
 18

+stands+to+provide+a+fuller+understanding+of+the+athlete

%27s+progress.&ots=Eyh5hZZEb9&sig=bJzZux2a5KcVb2Oh1rETVMJWvHU