Board Exam Intervention-Day 3
Board Exam Intervention-Day 3
GRADE 12
Poets and Pancakes
Q. No. 19) Imagine Asokamitran witnesses a film shooting and visits a film set of
present-day Bollywood. As Asokamitran writes a diary entry penning down the
transformation you notice between the film-making of yesteryears and today.
Ans.
Dear Diary,
In my era, filmmaking was a more intimate affair. The equipment was bulky, and the sets
were often constrained by practical limitations. Actors had to be precise, and retakes
were costly. But today, it's a different world altogether. The sets are grand, almost like a
mini-city, with advanced technology that can create any backdrop imaginable.
Actors seem to have more liberty to experiment, with multiple takes available without
the burden of additional expenses. The precision and detailing in every shot are
remarkable, thanks to digital cinematography. There's also a refreshing diversity in
storytelling and casting, which was limited in my time.
However, I couldn't help but feel a tinge of nostalgia for the simplicity of yesteryears.
The personal touch and the charm of the past seem to have given way to a more
commercialized and fast-paced industry. Nonetheless, the evolution of Bollywood is a
testament to the dynamism of art, and I'm grateful to have witnessed this
transformation.
Yours faithfully,
Asokamitran
Q. No. 20) After reading this story, you are impressed by the author’s use of gentle
humor to point out human foibles. Evaluate whether using such humor contributes
towards bringing about change in people’s attitudes and accepting their foibles.
Ans. The author's use of gentle humor in "Poets and Pancakes" indeed contributes to
highlighting human foibles in a way that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.
Gentle humor, when employed skillfully, can be a powerful tool to make people reflect
on their own flaws and idiosyncrasies without feeling attacked or defensive. It creates a
non-threatening atmosphere, allowing readers to recognize the absurdity in human
behavior.
By showcasing the quirks and shortcomings of the characters in the story, the author
encourages readers to introspect and perhaps even relate to these foibles on a personal
level. This self-awareness can be a catalyst for change in people's attitudes and
behaviors. It fosters a sense of empathy and a willingness to accept one's own
imperfections and those of others.
In essence, gentle humor acts as a mirror that reflects human nature, and when people
see themselves in that reflection, they may be more inclined to embrace their foibles
with a sense of humor and humility. It can promote a healthier, more accepting attitude
towards the quirks and imperfections that make us all uniquely human.
Indigo
Q. No. 1) Read the extract given below and attempt by answering the questions
that follow.
They had merely heard that a Mahatma who wanted to help them was in trouble
with the authorities. Their spontaneous demonstration, in thousands, around the
courthouse was the beginning of their liberation from fear of the British. The
officials felt powerless without Gandhi’s cooperation. He helped them regulate the
crowd. He was polite and friendly. He was giving them concrete proof that their
might, hitherto dreaded and unquestioned, could be challenged by Indians. The
government was baffled. The prosecutor requested the judge to postpone the
trial. Apparently, the authorities wished to consult their superiors.
1. Factual Information:
a) Historical Context: The chapter provides factual information about the
historical backdrop of the Champaran region and the oppressive indigo
cultivation system during the British colonial era.
b) Real-Life Characters: It introduces us to actual historical figures like Mahatma
Gandhi and Rajkumar Shukla, who played essential roles in the Champaran
Movement.
2. Text Structures:
a) Description: The author describes the plight of the peasants in the Champaran
villages, painting a vivid picture of their suffering under the indigo planters.
b) Cause and Effect: The chapter explores the cause-and-effect relationship of
Gandhi's decision to support the peasants, and how it led to the organization of
the Champaran Civil Disobedience Movement.
Conclusion:
"Indigo" incorporates features of a non-fiction text by presenting factual information
and using text structures like description and cause and effect to present a well-rounded
account of historical events and characters. It effectively combines narrative elements
with informational content, making it a compelling excerpt from a biography.
Q. No. 19) Imagine Gandhi was to deliver a speech to students in present-day India
showing them the path to becoming responsible world leaders. Based on your
understanding of Gandhi’s own leadership skills, write a speech, as Gandhi,
addressing the students about the qualities that every leader and politician should
nurture.
Dear students, you are all leaders of social change. I see many bright and
enthusiastic faces that assure me that our future is in good hands. I have learnt
from my own experience……………(continue)………….
Ans. Dear students,
You are all leaders of social change. I see many bright and enthusiastic faces that assure
me that our future is in good hands. I have learned from my own experiences that true
leadership is not about power or authority, but about service and compassion. As you
step into the world as responsible individuals, I urge you to nurture certain qualities that
will make you exemplary leaders and politicians.
First and foremost, always remember the power of truth and nonviolence. Embrace
honesty and integrity in everything you do. Be fearless in standing up for what is right,
even if it means going against the tide. Violence may seem like a quick solution, but it
only breeds more hatred and suffering. Nonviolence requires strength and courage, and
it can transform even the most difficult situations.
Secondly, never lose touch with your humility. As leaders, it is easy to be consumed by
pride and ego. Stay grounded and always remember that you are serving the people.
Listen to their voices and concerns, and be approachable. Understand that true
leadership is about empowering others and lifting them up.
Thirdly, lead by example. Your actions will speak louder than your words. Be the change
you wish to see in the world. Live a life of simplicity and practice what you preach. When
people see your sincerity and dedication, they will be inspired to follow you.
Lastly, be inclusive and embrace diversity. Our country is a tapestry of cultures, religions,
and languages. As leaders, it is your responsibility to ensure that every voice is heard,
and every person is respected. Build bridges of understanding and unity.
My dear students, the path to becoming responsible world leaders may not always be
easy, but with courage, determination, and the right values, you can leave a lasting
impact on society. The world needs leaders who lead with their hearts and strive to
make a positive difference. I have faith in each one of you to carry the torch of truth,
nonviolence, humility, and inclusivity.
Let us work together to create a world that is just, compassionate, and harmonious. The
future is yours to shape. I believe in you.
Thank you.
Yours sincerely,
Mahatma Gandhi
Q. No. 20) Let us assume it was Rajendra Prasad who informed Charles Freer
Andrews of Gandhi’s decision and the reasons for other leaders’ support of him.
Think creatively of how Andrews would have responded and pen down the
discussion you think would have taken place between Rajendra Prasad and
Andrews.
Ans. Rajendra Prasad: Charles, I have something important to share with you. Gandhi
decided to lead the struggle in Champaran, and many other leaders are supporting him.
Charles Freer Andrews: Oh, that's intriguing! I can imagine that Gandhi's decision must
have stirred quite a buzz. But why has he taken up this responsibility?
Rajendra Prasad: Well, Charles, Gandhi believes in the power of truth and nonviolence.
He sees the oppression faced by the peasants in Champaran and feels compelled to
bring about change. His compassion and sense of justice are the driving forces behind
his decision.
Charles Freer Andrews: I see. Gandhi's commitment to truth and nonviolence is truly
remarkable. I believe he can bring about a transformative impact in Champaran. But
what about the other leaders? Why are they supporting him?
Rajendra Prasad: They recognize Gandhi's unique ability to inspire and lead by example.
His humility and dedication resonate with people from all walks of life. Moreover, they
see that his methods of peaceful resistance can mobilize the masses effectively.
Q. No. 21) The prose selections, Deep Water and Indigo, bring out the importance
of overcoming fear, in order to be able to lead our lives successfully.
Imagine yourself to be a motivational speaker who has to address high school
students. Write this address in 120 – 150 words elaborating on occurrences from
the two texts to inspire your audience and convince them about the importance of
overcoming fear.
You may begin like this …
Good morning, students!
We all know what it’s like to be afraid. Fear is our body’s natural response to a
perceived threat or danger. But when …
Ans.
Good morning, students!
We all know what it's like to be afraid. Fear is our body's natural response to a perceived
threat or danger. But when we let fear immobilize us, it prevents us from progressing
and living life to the fullest. Today, I want to share two powerful stories that illustrate the
importance of overcoming fear.
In the story "Deep Water," we meet William Douglas, who had a deep fear of water. This
fear held him back from experiencing simple joys like fishing or canoeing. But instead of
letting fear control him, he made a decision to face it head-on. It took months of
determination and persistence, but he worked through his fear and learned how to
swim. By doing so, he reclaimed his life and freed himself from the shackles of fear.
Similarly, in the text "Indigo," we witness the plight of the peasants in Champaran, who
were living in fear of the British rulers. They were unable to take a stand for their rights
until they found strength in unity. When they gathered around the courthouse in
Motihari, it was a powerful step towards overcoming their fear and fighting for justice.
Their determination and collective efforts eventually led to their triumph.
These stories teach us that overcoming fear requires facing it, devising a plan, and
working through it. It demands persistence and unwavering determination. Just as
William Douglas took small steps each day to conquer his fear, and the peasants of
Champaran fought for their rights despite the risks, we too must find the courage within
ourselves.
Remember, there is strength in unity when facing a common fear. Together, we can
overcome any obstacle that stands in our way. Once we conquer our fears, we are free
to live our lives to the fullest and pursue our dreams.
So, my dear students, I urge you to embrace your fears and turn them into stepping
stones for growth. Don't let fear hold you back from reaching your full potential. Take
inspiration from the stories of William Douglas and the peasants of Champaran, and let
their courage fuel your own.
Believe in yourselves, work through your fears, and never stop pushing forward. Success
and fulfillment await those who dare to overcome their fears and embrace the
possibilities that lie beyond.
Thank you, and may you find the strength to conquer your fears and live a life of
purpose and achievement.
The Interview
Q. No. 1) Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
i. According to Christopher Silvester, the interview can be “in its highest form, a
source of truth”. Choose the option that does NOT enable this.
a. An interview allows for the discovery of new knowledge about the interviewee
and/ or the subject being discussed.
b. An interview enables the interviewer to probe deeply, seek clarifications, and
confirm understanding.
c. An interview represents an opportunity to open doors to experiences that may
not otherwise find a voice.
d. An interview requires the interviewer to have in-depth prior knowledge of the
interviewee and the subject.
Ans. Option (d)
ii. Column A below describes Rudyard Kipling’s views on interviews. Column B
provides fictional descriptions of some of Kipling’s works if they were about
interviews and interviewers. Choose the option that correctly matches interview
attributes given in Column A to the works in Column B:
Column A Column B
1. immoral (i) ‘The Mark of the Beast’ – An illicit tale of unforgivable offenses against man and society.
2. (ii) ‘The Jungle Book’ – A journey into the corrupt jungle of information where conscience and principles do
cowardly not exist.
(iii) ‘The Light that Failed’ – A story of audacious truth being left in the dark alleys of craven scandal and
3. vile
misrepresentation.
(iv) ‘The Man Who Would Be King’ – A saga of evil depravity of a man who ruled over heroes and became a
4. criminal
villain.
v. What makes an interview 'a source of truth'? State any one feature.
Ans.
A feature of an interview is that we get information about the person from the
person themself.
An interview is usually done on the spot, which does not give us practiced
responses.
The interviewer asks the interviewee specific questions which the interviewee may
not have disclosed otherwise.
vi. Complete the given sentence appropriately.
The author of the extract has a/an __________ tone while describing the interview.
Ans.
neutral/balanced
factual/objective
matter-of-fact/unemotional.
Q. No. 6) Why do you think Christopher Silvester describes the viewpoints of other
writers and authors when discussing the concept of an interview? Support your
opinion with reference to any one writer cited.
Ans. Christopher Silvester describes the viewpoints of other writers and authors to
illustrate the diverse and sometimes conflicting perspectives on interviews. For instance,
by referencing writers like V. S. Naipaul, Lewis Carroll, Rudyard Kipling, H. G. Wells, and
Saul Bellow, he highlights the range of opinions on interviews, from being seen as a
source of truth and art to being condemned as intrusive and damaging. This adds depth
and context to the discussion of interviews in his prose.
Q. No. 7) How would you evaluate Mukund Padmanabhan as an interviewer?
Mention at least two qualities he displays in his interview, supported by textual
evidence.
Ans. Mukund Padmanabhan exhibits two notable qualities as an interviewer in his
conversation with Umberto Eco.
Firstly, he demonstrates a strong capacity for asking thoughtful and probing
questions, as seen when he inquires about Eco's transition from academia to
fiction.
Secondly, Padmanabhan's active listening and ability to engage in a meaningful
dialogue with Eco, allowing the author to share personal stories and insights,
reflect his effectiveness as an interviewer.
Q. No. 8) Christopher Silvester shares the authors’ reservations about interviewing.
Bearing that in mind, would you interview a writer of your choice? If so, what
would you pay particular attention to in interviewing the said writer?
Ans. Yes, I would interview a writer of my choice. In doing so, I would pay particular
attention to their creative process, sources of inspiration, and the themes and messages
they aim to convey through their work, aiming to understand the deeper aspects of their
writing beyond the surface narrative.
Q. No. 9) Umberto Eco, with reference to "The Name of the Rose" says, “I think if I
had written The Name of the Rose ten years earlier or ten years later, it wouldn’t
have been the same.” What could he have meant?
Ans. Umberto Eco suggests that the success of his book, "The Name of the Rose," was
largely due to timing. He believes that if he had written the book ten years earlier or ten
years later, it wouldn't have had the same impact.
This could be interpreted as Eco recognizing the importance of cultural context
and how the reception of a work of art is influenced by the historical, social, and
political climate of its time.
Eco might be suggesting that the themes and ideas he explored in his novel
resonated particularly strongly with readers in the cultural moment in which it
was published and that this moment was fleeting.
Therefore, if he had written the book earlier or later, it might not have been as relevant
or timely, and might not have captured the same level of attention and interest.
Q. No. 10) Imagine that you are Christopher Silvester. You have been invited to a
seminar series titled – ‘Ethics and Techniques of Interviewing’.
The organizers would like you to speak about the challenges of conducting
interviews, and skills interviewers must have in order to conduct good and ethical
interviews.
Based on your reading of The Interview, Part I and II, draft your speech. Include
relevant details from the text in support of your answer.
Ans. Ladies and gentlemen, esteemed organizers, and fellow participants,
Today, I stand before you to discuss the captivating world of interviews, drawing
inspiration from my reading of "The Interview." Interviews, as we've seen, have evolved
into a commonplace in journalism and communication. They serve as a powerful
medium for extracting information, and they often offer us unique insights into the
minds and lives of individuals.
However, as "The Interview" has highlighted, interviews come with their own set of
challenges. Interviewers must navigate the fine line between probing for information
and respecting an individual's privacy. Our discussion of various authors' reservations
regarding interviews, including Lewis Carroll's "just horror" or Rudyard Kipling's belief
that interviews are "immoral," underscores the ethical dilemmas interviewers can face.
To conduct good and ethical interviews, we need to hone our skills in crafting questions
that are insightful yet respectful, listening actively to our subjects, and maintaining a
genuine curiosity about their experiences. We must strike a balance between seeking
information and respecting boundaries, understanding that interviews are a delicate art
where ethics and techniques must coexist harmoniously.
Thank you.
Q. No. 11) Mukund Padmanabhan was gifted the ‘Penguin Book of Interviews - An
Anthology from 1859 to the Present Day’ edited by Christopher Silvester, after
interviewing Eco.
He shared his thoughts on his personal blog exploring his own concerns about
interviewing a distinguished writer like Eco, followed by an evaluation of the
interview in light of his reading.
As Mukund Padmanabhan, write the blog post.
Ans.
An Encounter with Eco: Navigating the Art of Interviewing
In the world of interviews, opportunities like the one I had with Umberto Eco are truly
exceptional. A writer of his caliber, renowned for his scholarly work and acclaimed
novels, presents a unique set of challenges and opportunities.
Before the interview, I couldn't help but share my concerns on my personal blog.
Interviewing a distinguished writer like Eco was a thrilling yet daunting prospect. Would
I be able to do justice to his intellect and creativity? Could I craft questions that would
delve into his philosophical interests and his journey from academia to fiction?
Now, looking back, I evaluate our conversation in light of my reading. I'm proud that I
managed to create a space where Eco could share his stories, his interests, and his
thoughts. It was a momentous experience, and I hope that my interview added a new
dimension to the rich anthology of interviews that Silvester presented in "The Penguin
Book of Interviews."
The journey of an interviewer is filled with uncertainties, but it is the quest for
knowledge and understanding that drives us forward. And in interviewing Eco, I
discovered the power of dialogue and the magic of storytelling.
Q. No. 12) Part I of ‘The Interview’ is an excerpt from the Penguin Book of
Interviews. Do you think that the extract fails to present a balanced perspective
about interviews?
Substantiate your answer with relevant textual details.
If this were the entire introduction, what would your expectation from the book
be?
Ans. Part I of 'The Interview' from the Penguin Book of Interviews does seem to present
a somewhat unbalanced perspective about interviews. While it discusses various
authors' reservations and concerns about interviews, it doesn't provide an equal amount
of space to voices that may highlight the positive aspects and merits of this journalistic
form.
For instance, it cites V.S. Naipaul's feelings of being wounded by interviews, Rudyard
Kipling's strong condemnation, and Saul Bellow's comparison of interviews to
thumbprints on his windpipe. The focus is primarily on the negative or skeptical views.
If this were the entire introduction to the book, my expectation would be that it is more
likely to delve into the challenges and controversies surrounding interviews, rather than
celebrating their value and significance. I might anticipate a critical exploration of
interviews, which could be valuable for understanding the complexities and ethical
considerations but might not provide a comprehensive overview of the broader world of
interviews, which includes their role in storytelling, journalism, and communication.
******************************