Homework For Chapter 3
Homework For Chapter 3
1. Rewrite the following statement in the form ∀___x, if___ then___ (where each of
the second two blanks are sentences involving the variable x)
Every valid argument with true premises has a true conclusion.
∀x, if x is a valid argument with true premises, then x has a true conclusion.
2. Consider the statement “The square of any odd integer is odd.”
(a) Rewrite the statement in the form ∀___n,___ . (Do not use the words “if” or
(b) Rewrite the statement in the form ∀___n, if___ then___ . (Make sure you use
3. Rewrite the following statement formally. Use variables and include both quantifiers∀and
∃in your answer.
∀r ∃a ∃b (a ∈ ℤ ∧ b ∈ ℤ ∧ b ≠ 0 ∧ r = a/b)
Every rational number can be written as a ratio of some two integers.
4. Rewrite the following statement formally. Use variables and include both quantifiers∀and
∃in your answer.
5. Which of the following is a negation for “Given any real numbers a and b, if a and b are
rational then a/b is rational.”
(a) There exist real numbers a and b such that a and b are not rational and a/b is not
rational.
(b) Given any real numbers a and b, if a and b are not rational then a/b is not rational.
(c) There exist real numbers a and b such that a and b are not rational and a/b is rational.
(d) Given any real numbers a and b, if a and b are rational then a/b is not rational.
(e) There exist real numbers a and b such that a and b are rational and a/b is not
rational.
(f) Given any real numbers a and b, if a and b are not rational then a/b is rational.
∀ real numbers xxx, if x+1>0x + 1 > 0x+1>0, then −1<x≤0-1 < x \leq
(a) Write the converse of T.
0−1<x≤0.
∀ real numbers xxx, if x+1≤0x + 1 \leq 0x+1≤0, then x≤−1x \leq -1x≤−1 or
(b) Write the contrapositive of T.
8. Are the following two statements logically equivalent? Justify your answer.
(a) A real number is less than 1 only if its reciprocal is greater than 1.
Yes because A is the contrapositive of B
(b) Having a reciprocal greater than 1 is a sufficient condition for a real number to be less
than 1.
Yes again because B is also the contrapositive of A
9. For each of the following statements, (1) write the statement informally without using
variables or the symbols ∀or ∃, and (2) indicate whether the statement is true or false and
briefly justify your answer.
(a) ∀integers a, ∃an integer b such that a + b = 0.
1: For every integer a, there is an integer b such that when you add b to a, the
result is 0
2: True. For any integer b = -a satisfies a + (-a) = 0. So, for every integer a, there
1: There exists an integer a such that for every integer b, the sum of a and b is 0.
2: False: There is no single integer a such that for every integer b, the sum a + b
= 0. This would require that a = -b for all integers b, which is impossible because
a would have to be different values for different b’s
10. For each of the following statements, (1) write the statement informally without using
variables or the symbols ∀or ∃, and (2) indicate whether the statement is true or false and
briefly justify your answer.
(a) ∀real numbers x, ∃a real number y such that x < y.
1: For every real number x, there is a real number y that is greater than xxx.
2: True. For any real number x, you can always find a real number y such that
y=x+1 (or any number greater than x). The set of real numbers is unbounded, so
for every x, there is always a larger y.
(b) ∃a real number y such that ∀real numbers x, x < y.
1: There exists a real number y such that every real number x is less than y.
2: False. There is no single real number y that is greater than all other real numbers. The set of real
numbers is unbounded above, meaning for any number y, you can always find a number x that is
greater than y. Therefore, no such y exists.