Ajol File Journals - 70 - Articles - 198366 - Submission - Proof - 198366 829 499081 1 10 20200806
Ajol File Journals - 70 - Articles - 198366 - Submission - Proof - 198366 829 499081 1 10 20200806
Ese AO CC –BY
Brown VB
Mothers’ knowledge and utilization
Oluwatosin OA of non-routine childhood
immunisation in Ibadan North
Local Government Area, Oyo state,
Nigeria
DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.4314/njp.v47i2.8
Accepted: 8th April 2020 Abstract: Background: Vaccine- were computed and Chi-square test
preventable-diseases are major was used for investigating associa-
Brown VB ( ) contributors to child mortality in tion between categorical variables
School of Nursing, University Africa. In Nigeria, apart from the at 0.05 level of significance.
College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria. routine childhood vaccines that Results: The findings revealed that
Email: [email protected] are provided free by the govern- 62 (56.4%) of the 110 mothers
ment, there are additional lifesav- were aware of non-routine immu-
Ese AO, Oluwatosin OA ing non-routine vaccines like Ro- nisation of which 23 (20.9%) had
Department of Nursing, tavirus, Pneumococcal Conjugate good knowledge about it. Only 23
Faculty of Clinical Sciences, (PCV), Varicella, Cerebrospinal (20.9%) of their children were
College of Medicine, University of meningitis, and Measles, Mumps, immunized with all the non-
Ibadan, Nigeria. Rubella (MMR) vaccines. Until routine vaccines. High income,
2015 when PCV was included in higher level of education and good
. the routine childhood immunisa- knowledge level about non-routine
tion, these five vaccines were immunisation of mothers were
optional and parents paid to im- associated with the utilization of
munize their children with them. all non-routine immunisation
Objective: To assess the level of among their children (p<0.01).
knowledge and utilization of non- Conclusion: Knowledge of moth-
routine immunisations among ers about non-routine immunisa-
mothers. tion was poor and uptake of the
Methodology: A descriptive, cross vaccines among their children low.
-sectional study conducted in Health education to improve moth-
three infant welfare clinics pur- ers’ knowledge and utilization of
posively selected in Ibadan North non-routine immunisation by their
Local Government Area, Oyo children is recommended.
State, Nigeria. Participants were
110 mothers of children aged 6-24 Keywords: Vaccine-preventable-
months. A structured question- diseases, Children, Optional, Im-
naire was used for data collection munisation, Awareness, Uptake,
and analysis done using SPSS Ibadan, Nigeria
version 20.0. Descriptive statistics
This study was a descriptive health facility-based cross- The structured questionnaire utilized for data collection
sectional survey. The study setting was Ibadan North was developed in English after a thorough literature re-
Local Government Area (LGA), which is one of the 33 view. The questionnaire had 48 question items. It was
LGAs in Oyo State, South Western Nigeria. The Local subdivided into three sections. Section A was to collect
Government Area is located approximately on longitude information on demographic data of the respondents,
8°5’ East of the Greenwich meridian and latitude 7°23’ section B considered knowledge of childhood immuni-
North of equators. The Local Government Area also sation including routine and non-routine childhood vac-
houses some tertiary educational institutions such as the cines, and section C considered the utilization of the
University of Ibadan, The Polytechnic Ibadan and sev- routine and non-routine childhood vaccines.
eral private and public secondary and primary schools. Knowledge of respondents in the study were assessed on
The Local Government Area also has one public tertiary five vaccines that were not routinely administered at the
hospital, (University College Hospital), one public sec- time of the study in 2015 namely, Rotavirus vaccine,
ondary hospital (Adeoyo Maternity Hospital) and many Pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV), Cerebrospinal
public Primary Health Centres. The tertiary educational Meningitis (CSM) vaccine, Measles, Mumps, Rubella
institutions also have clinics which provide health care (MMR) vaccine and Varicella vaccine. Knowledge as-
services to the members of their communities. sessment questions included the diseases each vaccine
offers protection against in childhood, the frequency and
A purposive sampling technique was used for selecting timing of administration of each of the vaccines.
three infant welfare clinics in the LGA. The clinics se-
lected for the study consisted of the Institute of Child The respondents were requested to circle the correct
Health, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Kola answer for each item. Correct response to each knowl-
Daisi Foundation Primary Health Centre and Adeoyo edge question on non-routine vaccine was scored 1,
Maternity Hospital. The three infant welfare clinics were while the wrong response was scored 0. The total
selected for the study due to the availability of the non- knowledge score a mother obtained was computed,
routine childhood vaccines at these clinics. minimum score obtainable was 0 and the maximum ob-
The target population for this study was mothers having tainable score was 14. Based on the total knowledge
at least one child 6-24 months attending infant welfare score, the levels of mothers’ knowledge for each non-
clinic. Inclusion criteria were being mothers of children routine vaccine were classified into 3 categories good,
between six months and 24 months, currently attending fair and poor. Any mother with a score of 10 (75% cut-
the selected infant welfare clinics and being present at off point) or higher was regarded as having a good
98
knowledge, mother’s score between 7 and 9 (50-65%) Ethical Review Committee. Written informed consent
was regarded as fair knowledge while any mother who was obtained from all the respondents who voluntarily
scored below 7 (˂50%) was regarded as having poor participated in the study.
knowledge about non-routine immunisation.
Information regarding the children’s non-routine immu-
nisation status was obtained through mothers’ recall and
verified from the immunisation cards. Results
To ensure content and face validity, the questionnaire
was developed after thorough literature review and was One hundred and ten (110) out of the 122 questionnaires
then reviewed by experts for completeness and appropri- administered were retrieved, giving the response rate of
ateness to ensure validity. The reliability of the instru- 90.2%.
ment was assessed using test retest method carried out The mothers’ ages ranged from 18-40 years with a mean
with mothers from the University Health Centre, (SD) of 27.7 ±5.4 years. Only six (5.5%) of the mothers
University of Ibadan. had no formal education, 11 (10%) of them had primary
After obtaining informed written consent from eligible education, 26 (23.6%) had secondary education, while
mothers, data were collected during the clinic hours in 67 (60.9%) had tertiary education. The ages of the chil-
the selected infant welfare clinics. dren in the study ranged from 6-20 months, mean age
+SD was 9.7 months +2.5. Eighty-nine (80.9%) of them
Data Analysis were ≤9 months old, only eight (7.2%) were above 12
months. Seventy-two (65.5%) were male and 38
Data entry was carried out using the IBM SPSS Statis- (34.5%) were females.
tics version 20 software (IBM Corporation, Armonk, Sixty-two mothers (56.4%) were aware of non- routine
NY). Descriptive statistics were computed to describe immunisation, their sources of information about non-
participants' socio-demographic characteristics. Continu- routine immunisation is presented in figure 1. Most
ous variables were summarized using means and stan- (96.8%) of the mothers got the information from post-
dard deviations (SD). Chi-square test was used for in- natal clinic while educational institution was the least
vestigating association between categorical variables of (6.5%) source of information.
interest at 0.05 level of significance. The total knowledge score a mother obtained was com-
puted, minimum score obtainable was 0 and the maxi-
Ethical consideration mum obtainable score was 14. As shown in figure 2,
only 23 (20.9%) mothers in the study had good knowl-
Ethical approval for the study was obtained from the edge about non-routine immunisation.
University of Ibadan/University College Hospital Ibadan
Table 1: Factors Associated with Respondents’ Knowledge of Non- routine Childhood Immunisation
Variable Knowledge Score χ2 p-value
Good Knowledge Fair Knowledge Poor Knowledge Total
Age in years 23.17 .003
≤ 25 1 (3.4%) 2 (6.9%) 37 (92.5%) 40
26-30 9 (23.7) 4 (10.5%) 25 (65.8%9 38
31-35 10 (47.3%) 3 (14.3%) 8 (38.1%) 21
36-40 3 (27.3) 2 (18.2%) 6 (54.5%) 11
Religion 8.49 .092
Christianity 17 (28.8%) 8 (13.6%) 34 (57.6%) 59
Islam 6 (12%) 3 (6%) 42(84.0%) 51
Marital status 8.96 .176
Single 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 4 (100%) 4
Married 21 (20.6%) 10 (9.8%) 71 (69.6%) 102
Separated/Divorced 2 (66.7%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 3
Widow 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1(100%) 1
Occupation 62.38 .000
Civil servant 11 (22.4%) 8 (16.3%) 30 (61.2%) 49
Trading/Artisan 10 (24.4%) 2 (4.9%) 29 (70.7%) 41
Housewife 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 7 (100.0%) 7
Student 0 (0%) 1 (50%) 1 (50%) 2
Health care workers 11 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 11
99
Fig 1: Respondents’ Sources of Information about Non- rou- (12.1%) vaccinated their babies based on doctor’s rec-
tine Immunisation ommendation while 25 (75.8%) claimed they acted
Doctor 5 based on the information they received about the vac-
Source of Information cines from the clinic.
n Nurse/Midwife 29
io
ta
Antenatal Clinic 20
m
r
o
f Postnatal clinic 60
The major barriers perceived by 49 (44.5%) mothers to
In
f their children’s uptake of non- routine immunisations
o Electronic media 42
se were lack of information about the vaccines, 40 (36.4%)
cr Friends/Neighbours 6
u of them perceived inability to afford the vaccine while
o
S Relations 3
21 (19.1%) mothers perceived the vaccines were not
Educational Institution 4
important since their children were healthy.
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Analysis of association between the two most utilized
Frequency non- routine vaccines and some variables about the
mothers /children socio-demographic status revealed a
Figure t 2. Lev els of
* Multiple Responses
100
number of significant findings as shown in table 3. Re-
n garding the factors associated with utilization of all non-
Respondents' e
cr K nowledge routine vaccines, mothers’ level of education was found
e to have significant association as all the 23 mothers who
about NPon-ro 0 utine… vaccinated their children with all the non-routine vac-
Percent
Just over half of the mothers were aware of non-routine Regarding the uptake of all the non- routine immunisa-
immunisation, this showed that a large proportion of the tion, only about a third of the children whose mothers
mothers were not aware of the non-routine immunisa- participated in the study received all the vaccines. The
tion. Majority of those mothers who were aware got the findings of the study showed that high income, higher
information from post-natal clinic. This indicates the level of education and good knowledge level about non-
need for health care providers to provide adequate infor- routine vaccines were associated with the utilization of
mation for mothers about non-routine immunisation all the vaccines among their children. Previous studies
early especially during ante-natal clinics considering the corroborated that higher education and high income of
deadly childhood diseases the vaccines can prevent. mothers are significantly associated with childhood non-
Providing information about non-routine immunisation routine immunisation uptake22,23. This is another indica-
six weeks after the delivery of a baby may be quite late tion for the implementation of strategy and actions for
in guiding parental decisions about the vaccines. women economic empowerment and access to quality
education in Nigeria.
The findings of the study showed that less than a quarter
of mothers in the study had good knowledge about non- This study had its strength and limitations. In the study
routine immunisation, this finding corroborates the find- setting, studies on non-routine immunisation are scarce,
ings in India where majority of mothers in the studies so this study is one of the few studies on the subject
had poor knowledge regarding optional vaccines13,14. matter. One of the limitations of the study is the fact that
Mothers’ educational level was found to have an asso- the study was conducted in three clinics which limit the
ciation with their knowledge of non-routine immunisa- generalizability of the findings. Also non-routine vac-
tion, as a higher proportion of mothers’ with tertiary cines were not being administered in many health facili-
education had “good knowledge” compared with moth- ties especially at Primary Health Care (PHC) level, so
ers with secondary education or less. This suggests the this study did not involve PHC centers.
need to intensify the advocacy for mothers’ education as
maternal education has been found to be significant in
reducing child mortality and morbidity 15,16,17,18.
Conclusion
Regarding the association between mothers’ occupation
and their knowledge, it is not surprising that the highest In conclusion, this study showed that knowledge of
proportion of mothers who had good knowledge were mothers studied about non-routine immunisation was
health workers. This is an evidence that health workers poor and the uptake of the vaccines among their children
have access to information relevant to their jobs, and was low. Considering the life threatening effects of in-
ultimately may enhance a culture of knowledge sharing fectious diseases in Sub-Saharan Africa and Nigeria and
with health care consumers. Overall the uptake of non- the life-saving benefits of routine and non-routine im-
101
munisations against the infectious diseases, there is need Africa.
for health care professionals’ especially nurses and mid- Authors contribution
wives to empower mothers with information to improve EAO, BVB and OOA contributed to the concept, design,
their knowledge and utilization of non-routine vaccines. intellectual content, literature search/review, data analy-
It is also important for health care professionals and sis and manuscript preparation.
other stakeholders in child health to advocate for the Conflict of interest: None
reduction in the costs of non-routine vaccines to make Funding: None
them affordable for parents. All these strategies may in
turn reduce the mortality and morbidity associated with
infectious diseases among children in Sub-Saharan
References
1. Liu L, Oza S, Hogan D. et al. 6. World Health Organization, 13. Vanaja Kumari B, Indira S,
Global, regional, and national United Nations Children's Kavitha B. Knowledge on
causes of child mortality in Fund: Global Immunisation optional vaccines for children
2000-13, with projections to Vision and Strategy: 2006- among mothers of under five
inform post-2015 priorities: an 2015. 2005, Geneva, Switzer- children at pediatric ward in
updated systematic analysis. land: World Health Organiza- Narayana medical college
Lancet. 2015;385(9966):430- tion hospital, Nellore, A.P. Int J
40. 7. Amdekar Y K. Optional vac- acad Res Dev 2017;2(4):350-
2. Bona G, Guidi C. Meningococ- cines: a critical appraisal. In- 51.
cal vaccine evolution. J Prev dian J Med Ethics. 2000. 8:1. 14. Padda P, Kaur H, Kaur A. et
Med Hyg. 2012;53(3):131–5. 8. PAN Advisory Committee on al. Immunisation coverage of
3. Macias-Parra M, Rodriguez- Immunisation. Paediatric Asso- optional vaccines. Online J
Weber MA, Moreno-Espinosa ciation of Nigeria (PAN) rec- Health Allied Scs. 2012;11
S, Ceron-Trujillo B, Ojeda- ommended routine immunisa- (2):8.
Diezbarroso K, DeAntonio tion schedule for Nigerian chil- 15. Adewusi OA, Nwokocha EE.
R, et al. Economic burden of dren. Niger J Paediatr. 2012 Maternal education and child
varicella complications in two Apr; 39(4): 152-8, Available mortality in Nigeria. Niger J
referral centers in Mexico. Hum from: http:// Soc Anthro 2018; 16(1): 111-
Vaccin Immunother. 2018;14 dx.doi.org/10.4314/njp.v39i4.1 30.
(12):2950-2954. 9. World Health Organization. 16. Andriano L, Monden CWS.
4. United State Agency for Inter- Pneumococcal disease. 2014). The causal effect of maternal
national Development (USAID) Available from: http:// education on child mortality:
for Africa. Immunisation Ba- www.who.int/immunisation/ evidence from a quasi-
sics. Strengthening Routine diseases/pneumococcal/en/pdf. experiment in Malawi and
Immunisation Services and Accessed on 2017 Dec 29. Uganda. Demography.
Sustainable Financing for Im- 10. World Health Organization. 2019;56(5):1765-90. doi:
munisation 2009. Available Rotavirus. 2016. Available 10.1007/s13524-019-00812-3.
from: http:// from: http://www.who.int/ 17. Kiross GT, Chojenta C,
www.immunisationbasics.jsi.co immunisation/diseases/ Barker D, Tiruye TY, Loxton
m/CountryActivities.htm. Ac- rotavirus/en/pdf. Accessed on D. The effect of maternal edu-
cessed on 2020 March 18. 2017 Dec 29. cation on infant mortality in
5. Chizoba W, Stokes-Prindle C, 11. Luman ET, McCauley MM, Ethiopia: A systematic review
Aina M. et al. Land Scape Shefer A. et al. Maternal char- and meta-analysis. PLoS One.
Analysis of Routine Immunisa- acteristics associated with vac- 2019; 29:14(7):e0220076.
tion in Nigeria International cination of young children. doi: 10.1371.
Vaccine Access Centre Pediatrics. 2003;111(5 Pt 18. Mandal S, Paul P, Chouhan P.
(IVAC); 2012. Available from: 2):1215-8. Impact of maternal education
http://www.jhsph.edu/research/ 12. Araoye MO. Sample size deter- on under-five mortality of
centers-and-institutes/ivac/ mination. Research methodol- children in India: Insights
projects/nigeria/IVAC- ogy with statistics for health from the National Family
Landscape-Analysis-Routine- and social sciences. 1st Ed. Health Survey, 2005-2006 and
Immunisation-Nigeria- Ilorin: Nathadex Publishers 2015-2016. Death Stud. 2019;
Brief.pdf. Accessed on 2017 2004;115-120. 20:1-7. doi:
Nov 17. 10.1080/07481187.2019.1692
970.
19. Biya O, Alabi O, Tolough G.
Cerebrospinal meningitis out-
break in Kano state, Nigeria.
Int J Infect Dis. 2010; 14,
(11):e56.
102
20. Omoleke SA, Alabi O, Usman 22. Manthiram K, Blood EA, Kup- 23. Mvula H, Heinsbroek E, Chi-
YB. et.al. Lessons learnt from puswamy V. et al. Predictors of hana M. et al. Predictors of
cerebrospinal meningitis out- optional immunisation uptake uptake and timeliness of
break surveillance data-a case in an urban south Indian popu- newly introduced pneumococ-
for public health action. Glob J lation. Vaccine. 2014 5;32 cal and rotavirus vaccines, and
Health Sci. 2016;9(2):76. (27):3417-23. of measles vaccine in rural
21. Nnadi C, Oladejo J, Yennan S. Malawi: A population cohort
et al. Large Outbreak of Neisse- study. PLoS One. 2016 5;11
ria meningitidis Serogroup C - (5):e0154997.
Nigeria, December 2016-June
2017. MMWR Morb Mortal
Wkly Rep. 2017 Dec 15;66
(49):1352-1356.