P2, Chap 2 - Notes
P2, Chap 2 - Notes
com
➢ Writing: The 4 caliphs also wrote down numerous Ahadiths of Prophet Muhammad.
Hazrat Ali had his own Sahifa in which details about zakat, spirituality etc were present.
Imam Zahabi reported that Hazrat Ayesha once reported that her father asked to bring
+92-321-2744563
➢ This period culminated the oral tradition and commenced the systematic writing of the
prophetic sayings.
+92-321-2744563
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Was Imam Bukhari right in his decision to reject the collection of Ahadiths? [4]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+92-321-2744563
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Why was it important that the Hadith compilations were not made simultaneously with
the Quran compilation? [4]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PRACTICE QUESTION
1. What was the importance of the early Sahifas to the compilers of the Hadith working
after 2 A.H.?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jami
➢ A Hadith collection which contains traditions related to all the eight topics (Belief, Laws
and rulings, Piety, Asceticism, Quranic commentary/interpretation, virtues, defects,
historical matters) is termed as Jami. For example, Jami-e-Tirmidhi or Sahih Bukari.
Sunan
➢ In Arabic, the word Sunan means “word of goodness”
➢ These collections contain Ahadiths about legal matters. Hence, the Ahadiths preserved in
such collections are called “Ahadiths al-Ahkam”
➢ Famous books include: Sunan Abu Dawood, Sunan al-Nasai, Sunan Ibn Majah, Sunan al-
Kubra, Sunan al-Daarmi, Sunan Sa’id ibn Mansur etc
Mustadrak
➢ In Arabic, the word means to write a book that completes another book and covers the
subjects which have been missed in it.
➢ A collection in which the compiler accepts the conditions set by his predecessor collector
and then collects the traditions not included by the predecessors. For example,
Mustadrak of Al-Hakim al-Nisaburi. It is also called Talkhis al-Mustadrak. It contains
about 10,000 Ahadhis.
Arba’niyat
➢ In Arabic, the word Arba’ means 4.
➢ These collections contain 40 Hadiths related to one or more subjects which might be of
special interest to the compiler. For example, al-Nawawi.
PRACTICE QUESTION
1. What is the significance of having different classifications of Hadiths to the Muslims
today?
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AUTHENTICITY OF A HADITH
Introduction:
+92-321-2744563
➢ The text should not be against any verse of the Holy Quran or the basic teachings.
➢ It should not contradict other well-known authentic (Sahih Hadith).
➢ The text should be free of grammatical errors.
➢ It should not be against common sense or normal experience of the people.
➢ It should contain words, phrases, or expressions that Prophet could have not used.
➢ It should not be in praise of any infamous tribe.
➢ It should not be in praise of prophet Muhammad himself.
➢ It should not report any events pertaining to the future.
Classification OF HADITH
Introduction:
+92-321-2744563
➢ There is a lot of redundancy. Without repetition, the total number of Hadith in this book
is about 2600.
➢ Sahih Bukhari is a Musannaf collection
➢ Chapter headings are available in this book which are called “Tarjama tul Baab”.
Imam Muslim
1. Life Details:
➢ Name: Imam Muslim ibn Al-Hajjaj.
➢ Place of birth: Nishapur, Iran
➢ Date of birth: 202 A.H.
➢ Date of death: 261 A.H.
2. Activities:
➢ From an early age, he started attending lectures of his contemporary Muhaddithin like
Ishaq bin Rahwayh and Ahmad bin Hanbal.
➢ He had a small business as a source of income.
3. Books:
➢ Sahih Muslim is the next best collection of Hadith after Bukhari.
➢ Imam Muslim examined about 400,000 Ahadiths but selected only 10,000 to be included
in his book. Without repetition, the number of Hadith equals about 4000 divided over 43
books. It is a Musannaf collection.
➢ He strictly followed the rules of Ilm al Hadiths and Ilm al Rijal which were adequately
used by Imam Bukhari.
➢ He was stricter than Imam Bukhari in highlighting the differences between the narrations
of various narrators.
➢ He took great care while presenting different versions of a single Hadiths.
➢ In the beginning of Sahih Muslim, one finds a prologue written by Imam Muslim which
contains details about Ilm al Hadith (Science of Hadith/Hadith studies). This prologue is
called “Muqaddama” in Arabic.
➢ Different versions of a single Hadith are arranged together at an appropriate place in the
collection. This rigor is not found in the work of Bukhari.
➢ Together with the Sahih of Imam Bukhari, these books are called “Al-Sahihain”
Imam Abu Dawood
1. Life Details:
➢ Name: Imam Suleman Ibn Ashath.
➢ Place of birth: Southern Arabia (Azd tribe); Imran was his ancestor who died at Siffin
while fighting for the cause of Ali.
➢ Date of birth: 202 A.H.
➢ Date of death: 275 A.H. (in Basra)
2. Activities:
➢ He spent a great of time with Imam Ahmed bin Hambal in Baghdad and became a master
of Hadith literature.
➢ Because of his extensive knowledge about the Fiqh and Ahadiths related to it, he is
considered by Sunni Muslims as the most expert Faqih amongst the compliers of Kutub
al-Sittah.
3. Books:
➢ His Sunan is one of the most celebrated books when it comes to sacred law and traditions.
➢ He studied 500,000 Ahadiths but selected only 4800 for his book (it took 20 years).
➢ He arranged Hadith thematically, however, an overarching subject is Fiqh.
➢ He has divided the Hadiths contained in his collection into three categories viz., 1)Hadith
mentioned in al-Sahihain; 2) Hadiths that fulfil the criteria of the compilers of al-Sahihain;
3) Hadiths that don’t fulfil the criteria of the compilers of al-Sahihain
➢ He has included mostly Sahih and Hassan Hadiths. However, some weak Hadith are also
incorporated.
Imam al-Tirmidhi
1. Life Details:
➢ Name: Imam Muhammad Ibn Isa Tirmidhi
➢ Place of birth: Termez, Iran
➢ Date of birth: 209 A.H.
➢ Date of death: 279 A.H (Tirmidh)
➢ Title: Ad-Darīr (The Blind one)
2. Activities:
➢ A close student of Imam Bukhari
➢ He was a learnt men in Arabic grammar and preferred Kufa and Basra style of Arabic.
➢ He was also an expert in Fiqh and I’lal-ul-Hadith
3. Books:
➢ Sunan Tirmidhi, which is also called Jami Tirmidhi, is his famous work. It contains about
4000 Hadith covered in 49 chapters.
➢ Authentic and a small of weak Hadiths are incorporated into the collection.
➢ He classifies the Hadiths in a unique way: 1) Hassan Sahih, 2) Hasan Sahih Gareeb, 3)
Sahih Gareeb, 4) Hasan Gareeb.
➢ At the end of almost every Hadith, Tirmidhi makes remarks about the authenticity of the
Hadith.
➢ If a Hadith has numerous Isnad, he presents them as footnotes to the Hadith.
➢ He also wrote Shamāil Muhammadiya (also called Shamāil Tirmidhi) to highlight the
qualities of prophet Muhammad.
Imam Al-Nasai
1. Life Details:
➢ Name: Imam Abu Abdul Rehman Ahmad ibn Shuayb al-Nasai
➢ Place of birth:
➢ Date of birth: 215 A.H.
➢ Date of death: 303 A.H. (Damascus)
2. Activities:
➢ Early education was given to him in his hometown.
➢ At the age of 15, he travelled to Balkh where he studied Hadith literature. Later, he
travelled to Egypt.
➢ In 302 A.H., he travelled to Damascus where he found that people hated Ali due to
Umayyads influence in the past. He compiled a book on the merits of Ali, however, could
not recite it publicly. Once he tried and was harshly treated.
3. Books:
➢ Sunan contains 5662 Ahadiths which are divided into chapters.
➢ He claims that he included only Sahih (authentic) Hadith. This book is similar to the work
of Imam Bukhari and Muslim in terms of determining that only authentic Ahadiths are
incorporated along
➢ His book is given three different names viz. Al-Sunan al-Sughra, Al-Mujtaba, Al-Mujtana
due to different reasons.
Imam Ibn Maja
1. Life Details:
➢ Name: Abu Abdullah Muhammad ibn Yazid
➢ Place of birth: Qazwin
➢ Date of birth: 215 A.H.
➢ Date of death: 303 A.H. (Damascus)
2. Activities:
➢ Early education was given to him in his hometown.
➢ At the age of 15, he travelled to Balkh where he studied Hadith literature. Later, he
travelled to Egypt.
➢ In 302 A.H., he travelled to Damascus where he found that people hated Ali due to
Umayyads influence in the past. He compiled a book on the merits of Ali, however, could
not recite it publicly. Once he tried and was harshly treated.
3. Books:
➢ Sunan contains 4341 Ahadiths spread over 32 books and 1500 chapters.
➢ Repetition is less and is considered one of the best Sunan.
➢ 20 fabricated Hadith were later discovered.
➢ About 1300 + Ahadiths are without repetition which is a huge number.