Development Processes and the Development Industry — the Role of NGOs, SHGs, various groups and

associations, donors, charities, institutional and other stakeholders.

Development is often equated with economic growth, but it encompasses much broader dimensions,
including social development, sustainable development, and human development. In simple terms,
development is about bringing social change that enables people to achieve their human potential.

Development as a Process:

 Dynamic Nature: Development is a process involving changes from one state to another, ideally
positive, such as milestones in a child's growth.
 Dimensions of Development:
o Political Process: Development involves actions by certain agencies (state or
development organizations) for others, raising questions about power dynamics.
o Human Development: Advocated by Amartya Sen, it focuses on improving the well-
being of those at the bottom of society rather than the efficiency of those at the top.
o Sustainable Development: Defined by the Brundtland Report as development that meets
present needs without compromising future generations' abilities to meet their own
needs.
o Economic Development: Different from economic growth, it involves both quantitative
and qualitative improvements, transforming low-income economies into modern
industrial economies.
o Social Development: Requires removing barriers so all citizens can journey toward their
dreams with confidence and dignity, especially important in contexts like India where
social barriers like the caste system exist.

Civil Societies

What are Civil Societies?

Civil societies are diverse organizations, including community groups, NGOs, labor unions, indigenous
groups, charitable organizations, faith-based organizations, professional associations, and foundations.
They influence elected policymakers and businesses and include well-known organizations like
Amnesty International, WWF, and Greenpeace.

1 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 1

Civil Society in India:

 Derives strength from Gandhian volunteerism but now expresses itself in various activism
forms.
 Initially filled gaps left by the government in the development process, such as organizing
handloom weavers into cooperatives.
 Acts as an interface between government and governed, promoting good governance by
meeting society's needs efficiently.

Types of Civil Societies in India:

 Registered Societies: Formed for specific purposes.

 Charitable Organizations and Trusts
 Local Stakeholder Groups, Microcredit and Thrift Enterprises, SHGs
 Professional Self-Regulatory Bodies
 Cooperatives
 Informal Bodies and Government-Promoted Third Sector Organizations
 Broader Classification: Civil rights advocacy organizations, community-based organizations,
business and industry chambers, labor unions, international peace and human rights
organizations, media organizations, conservation organizations, private and public foundations.

Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs)

Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) are non-profit groups that operate independently of any
government. They are driven by social principles and engage in activities aimed at promoting
development and addressing various societal issues within the communities they serve.

Types of NGOs

1. Traditional Development NGOs: These NGOs engage directly with the public at the grassroots
level, focusing on areas such as education, health, and rural development.
o Example: NGOs working on literacy programs, healthcare services in rural areas.
2. Activist NGOs: These organizations focus on activism to achieve specific goals. They often
work on social justice, environmental protection, and human rights. Example: Narmada Bachao
Andolan, which fights for the rights of people affected by dam projects.

2 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 2

 3. Research NGOs: These NGOs conduct research, analyze data, and lobby for changes in public
policy. They often work on environmental issues, economic policies, and social research.

Example: Centre for Science and Environment, which conducts environmental research and
advocacy.

Registration of NGOs

1. Societies: Registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. These are formed by a group
of individuals with a common objective.
2. Trusts: Private trusts are registered under the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, while public trusts are
registered under state-specific legislation.
3. Charitable Companies: Set up under Section 8 of the Companies Act, 2013. These companies
are established for promoting commerce, art, science, sports, education, research, social
welfare, religion, charity, and protection of the environment.

Role of NGOs in Development

1. Filling Gaps: NGOs often fill gaps left by the government in development initiatives, especially
in areas where the state is unable or unwilling to intervene, such as addressing caste issues.
2. Complementing State Initiatives: They complement state initiatives in sectors like education
and healthcare by reaching underserved populations.
3. Implementing Welfare Schemes: Due to their proximity to the public, NGOs effectively
implement various welfare schemes and programs.
4. Fighting Social Evils: NGOs actively work to combat social issues such as female foeticide and
other gender-based violence.

Challenges Faced by NGOs in India

1. Lack of Funds: Many NGOs struggle with inadequate funding, which limits their capacity to
carry out their activities effectively.
2. Corruption and Misuse of Funds: There have been serious allegations of misappropriation of
funds within some NGOs.
3. Inadequate Trained Personnel: There is a need for dedicated and trained professionals to work
in the NGO sector.

3 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 3

 4. Inequality in Rural Areas: NGOs are often more developed and active in urban areas, leaving
rural areas underserved.
5. Lack of Volunteerism: There has been a decline in volunteer participation, which affects the
operational capacity of NGOs.

State vs. NGOs

1. Accountability Issues: Many NGOs fail to submit required financial details, raising concerns
about their accountability.
2. Regulatory Challenges: The government faces challenges in regulating NGOs effectively. The
Supreme Court has directed that NGOs be audited to ensure transparency and accountability.

Suggestions to Improve the Working of NGOs

1. Relax Regulations and Increase Grants: Simplifying regulations and increasing grants can help
NGOs operate more effectively.
2. Appoint Monitoring Agencies: Establishing agencies to monitor the activities and financial
health of NGOs can improve accountability.
3. Increase Awareness and Collaboration: Enhancing awareness about the work of NGOs and
fostering collaboration with educational institutions can strengthen their impact.
4. Focus on Rural Areas: More emphasis should be placed on developing NGOs in rural areas to
address regional disparities.
5. Encourage Use of Technology: Leveraging technology can improve the efficiency and reach of
NGO activities. Revising pay scales can attract better talent to the sector.

National Policy on Voluntary Sector

The National Policy on Voluntary Sector aims to:

 Create an enabling environment for Voluntary Organizations (VOs).

 Ensure legitimacy in the mobilization of financial resources.
 Promote transparent governance within the voluntary sector.

4 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 4

Self Help Groups (SHGs)

Self Help Groups (SHGs)

Self Help Groups (SHGs) are small, voluntary associations of people with similar socio-economic
backgrounds who come together to solve their common problems through mutual help. They save
money collectively and access loans to start micro-enterprises. SHGs play a significant role in the
economic empowerment of poor and marginalized communities, especially women.

How SHGs Function

 Formation: SHGs typically consist of 5-20 members with similar economic backgrounds and
outlooks. These groups are often facilitated by NGOs, government agencies, or banks.
 Savings and Loans: Members save money collectively and create a common fund. This fund is
then used to provide loans to members for various purposes, such as starting small businesses,
meeting emergency needs, or improving their livelihoods.
 Bank Linkage: After six months of regular savings and internal lending, SHGs can access bank
loans to expand their activities. This linkage is crucial for the sustainability and growth of
SHGs.

Evolution of SHGs in India

 7th Five Year Plan (1985-90): SHGs emerged during this period as a key strategy for poverty
alleviation.
 RBI's 1992 Initiative: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) initiated a significant program to link
SHGs with banks, promoting financial inclusion and credit access for the rural poor.
 National Rural Livelihoods Mission (NRLM): SHGs have become integral to NRLM, which aims
to alleviate rural poverty through sustainable community institutions.

Benefits of SHGs

 Socio-economic Mobilization: SHGs mobilize women and the rural poor, enhancing their socio-
economic status and confidence.
 Health and Education: Improved access to health services and educational opportunities
through collective efforts.

5 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 5

  Financial Independence: Increased financial independence and reduced reliance on informal
moneylenders.
 Participation in Governance: Enhanced participation in village affairs and decision-making
processes.

General Issues Related to SHGs

 Dependence on Agriculture: Many SHGs are heavily reliant on agricultural activities, which are
subject to risks like weather and market fluctuations.
 Lack of Technology: Limited access to technology hampers productivity and growth.
 Market Access: Difficulties in accessing markets for their products due to poor infrastructure
and lack of marketing skills.
 Training: Insufficient training and capacity-building opportunities for members.
 Politicization: Issues of politicization and internal governance problems within SHGs.

Socio-Cultural Hurdles in Penetration of SHGs in Rural Areas

 Entrenched Patriarchy: Patriarchal norms and gender biases limit the participation and
effectiveness of women in SHGs.
 Lack of Entrepreneurial Spirit: Limited entrepreneurial skills and motivation among members.
 Family Responsibilities: Women's heavy family responsibilities often hinder their active
participation.
 Regional Disparities: Uneven distribution and regional disparities in the presence and
performance of SHGs.

Measures Taken by the Government to Promote SHGs

 SHG-Bank Linkage Programme: This program links SHGs with formal banking institutions to
enhance their financial capabilities.
 Priority Sector Lending: Inclusion of SHGs under priority sector lending to increase focus and
support from banks.
 Deendayal Antyodaya Yojana: Aims to alleviate rural poverty through sustainable community
institutions and SHGs.

6 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 6

Suggestions to Improve the Working of SHGs

 Integrated Approach: Adopt an integrated approach to meet the diverse credit needs of SHGs.
 Proactive Delivery Systems: Develop proactive delivery systems and simplify loan processes for
SHGs.
 Training and Capacity Building: Regular training and capacity-building initiatives to enhance
members' skills and knowledge.
 Gender Sensitization: Promote gender sensitization to overcome socio-cultural barriers.
 Technology Use: Encourage the use of technology to improve productivity and market access.
 Incentivize Personnel: Offer incentives to attract and retain dedicated personnel for SHG
activities.

Conclusion

SHGs have proven to be an effective model for empowering marginalized communities and fostering
sustainable development. By addressing the challenges and enhancing support mechanisms, SHGs can
further contribute to the socio-economic transformation of rural areas in India.

7 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 7

Development Aid in India

Development aid is a critical tool for fostering economic, social, and political development in
developing countries. It aims to address issues like poverty, inequality, and lack of infrastructure by
providing financial assistance and resources to support sustainable development initiatives.

Foreign Aid to India

1. Historical Recipient of Aid:

o India has historically been one of the largest recipients of foreign aid, which has
significantly contributed to its development in various sectors, including health,
education, and infrastructure.
2. Shift in Dynamics:
o Over the years, India's economic progress and geopolitical changes have led to a decline
in foreign aid. India's growing economy and improved self-reliance have reduced its
dependence on external assistance.

Foreign Funding and NGOs

1. Regulation through FCRA: The Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA) regulates the
acceptance and utilization of foreign contributions and hospitality by individuals, associations,
and companies. The aim is to ensure that foreign funds do not compromise national security
and interests.
2. Recent Amendments: Recent amendments to the FCRA have been made to enhance
transparency and accountability in the way NGOs receive and utilize foreign funds. These
changes include stricter compliance requirements and more rigorous scrutiny of fund usage.

Foreign Aid from India

1. Provider of Aid: As India's economic situation has improved, it has transitioned from being a
major recipient to a significant provider of foreign aid. India now offers substantial aid to
other developing countries, focusing on various strategic, economic, and humanitarian
objectives.
2. Objectives of Indian Aid:

8 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 8

  Strategic Objectives: Strengthening political alliances and enhancing regional
stability.
 Economic Objectives: Promoting economic cooperation and development, often tied
to trade and investment agreements.
 Soft Power: Enhancing India's influence and image on the global stage through
humanitarian aid, cultural exchanges, and educational scholarships.

Key Aspects of India's Development Aid

1. Areas of Focus: India's development aid covers a wide range of areas including infrastructure
development, healthcare, education, capacity building, and disaster relief.
2. Geopolitical Strategy: India's aid programs are strategically directed towards neighboring
countries in South Asia, Africa, and other developing regions to foster good relations and
regional stability.
3. Economic Cooperation: India provides aid that encourages economic cooperation and
development, often in the form of technical assistance, concessional loans, and grants.

Importance of Aid and Private Funding in Development

1. Addressing Development Gaps: Development aid and private funding are essential in addressing
gaps in public funding, especially in developing countries where resources are limited.
2. Catalyst for Change: These funds act as a catalyst for social and economic change, supporting
projects that might otherwise be underfunded or overlooked.
3. Enhancing Capacities: Aid and private funding help build local capacities, promote sustainable
practices, and empower communities to achieve long-term development goals.

By strategically leveraging both foreign aid and private funding, India not only advances its own
development goals but also contributes to the broader global effort to achieve sustainable
development and reduce poverty and inequality worldwide.

9 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 9

Microfinance Institutions (MFIs)

What are Microfinance Institutions?

Microfinance Institutions (MFIs) are financial entities that provide a variety of financial services,
including loans, savings accounts, insurance, and fund transfers, to individuals or groups who are
typically underserved by traditional banking systems. These services are particularly aimed at
unemployed or low-income individuals, enabling them to start or expand small-scale businesses and
improve their economic conditions.

Role of Microfinance Institutions in Development

1. Empowering Women: MFIs play a crucial role in empowering women by providing them with
financial resources and opportunities to engage in entrepreneurial activities, thereby increasing
their financial independence and social status.
2. Promoting Rural Development: By offering financial services in rural areas, MFIs contribute to
the overall development of these regions, facilitating economic growth and improving living
standards.
3. Enhancing Financial Inclusion: MFIs bridge the gap between the formal banking sector and
the financially excluded segments of society, providing access to credit and other financial
services to those who lack traditional banking facilities.
4. Reducing Dependency on Informal Moneylenders: By offering affordable credit options, MFIs
help reduce the dependency of low-income individuals on informal moneylenders, who often
charge exorbitant interest rates.

Issues Related to Microfinance Institutions

1. High Interest Rates: Despite their mission to serve the poor, some MFIs charge high interest
rates on loans, which can burden borrowers and lead to debt traps.
2. Over-Dependence on Banking Sector: Many MFIs rely heavily on the banking sector for
funding, which can limit their operational flexibility and sustainability.
3. Financial Literacy: A lack of financial literacy among borrowers can lead to poor financial
decisions, misuse of loans, and difficulties in loan repayment.

10 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 10

 4. Regulatory Challenges: MFIs often face regulatory hurdles that can impede their operations
and growth. Navigating the complex regulatory landscape can be challenging, especially for
smaller institutions.

Suggestions to Improve the Working of Microfinance Institutions

1. Field Supervision: Implementing robust field supervision mechanisms can help ensure that MFIs
operate effectively and ethically, protecting the interests of both the institutions and their
clients.
2. Rural Penetration Incentives: Providing incentives for MFIs to expand their services in rural
areas can enhance financial inclusion and support rural development.
3. Improved Services: MFIs should focus on improving their service offerings, including customer
support, financial education, and tailored financial products to meet the diverse needs of their
clients.
4. Alternative Funding Sources: Diversifying funding sources, such as tapping into social impact
investors or crowdfunding, can reduce the dependency of MFIs on traditional banks and
enhance their financial stability.
5. Use of Technology: Leveraging technology, such as mobile banking and digital payment
systems, can improve the efficiency, reach, and cost-effectiveness of MFI operations.
6. Separate Regulatory Authority: Establishing a dedicated regulatory authority for MFIs can
provide more focused oversight and support, ensuring that these institutions can operate
effectively while adhering to regulatory standards.

Societies, Trusts, Donors, Charities, and Other Stakeholders

Societies

Societies are associations formed by individuals with common objectives, registered under the
Societies Registration Act, 1860.

Trusts, Religious Endowments, and Waqfs:

 Created for charitable and religious purposes, registered under various laws.
 Trusts: Private and public trusts governed by specific laws.
 Religious Endowments: Property dedicated for religious purposes.
 Waqfs: Endowments under the Waqf Act, 1995.

11 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 11

Trade Unions:

 Formed to regulate relations between workers and employers, enhancing worker rights and
collective bargaining.

12 Governance and Social Justiceby Mukund Madhav Sharma 12