VectorNetworkAnalysis
VectorNetworkAnalysis
Basics
Network Analysis is NOT.…
Router
Bridge
Repeater
Hub
Page 2
Objectives Page 3
– Review RF basics
Converters
Circulators
Attenuators Antennas
VCAs
Adapters
Switches Amplifiers
Opens, shorts, loads
Delay lines Multiplexers
Cables Mixers
Samplers VTFs
Transmission lines
Multipliers Modulators
Resonators
VCAtten’s
Dielectrics Diodes
Low
R, L, C's
Transistors
Page 4
Lightwave Analogy to RF Energy
Incident
Transmitted
Reflected
Lightwave
DUT
RF
Page 5
The Need for Both Magnitude and Phase
S21
1. Complete characterization
S11 S22
of linear networks
S12 4. Time-domain characterization
2. Complex impedance
needed to design Mag
matching circuits
Time
3. Complex values
5. Vector-error correction
needed for device
Error
modeling
Measured
Actual
Page 6
Agenda Page 7
– High frequencies
• Wavelength » or << length of transmission medium
• Need transmission lines for efficient power transmission
• Matching to characteristic impedance (Zo) is very important for
low reflection and maximum power transfer
• Measured envelope voltage dependent on position along line
Page 8
Transmission line Zo
– Zo determines relationship between voltage and current waves
1.5
1.4 attenuation is
normalized values
lowest at 77
1.3 ohms
1.2
1.1
50 ohm standard
1.0
0.9
0.8
Page 9
Power Transfer Efficiency
RS
For complex impedances, maximum
power transfer occurs when ZL = ZS*
RL
(conjugate match)
Rs +jX
1.2 -jX
1
(normalized)
Load Power
0.8 RL
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
RL / RS
Page 10
Transmission Line Terminated with Zo
Zo = characteristic impedance
Zs = Zo of transmission line
Zo
Vinc
Page 11
Transmission Line Terminated with Short, Open
Zs = Zo
V inc
o
Vreflect In-phase (0 ) for open,
o
out-of-phase (180 ) for short
Page 12
Transmission Line Terminated with 25 Ohms
Zs = Zo
ZL = 25 W
Vinc
Vreflect
Page 13
High-Frequency Device Characterization
Incident Transmitted
R B
Reflected
A
REFLECTION TRANSMISSION
Reflected A Transmitted B
= =
Incident R Incident R
VSW Group
Return
R Gain / Loss Delay
Loss
S-Parameters Impedance, Insertion
S11, S22 Reflection Admittance S-Parameters Phase
Coefficient S21, S12 Transmission
R+jX,
G, r G+jB Coefficient
T,t
Page 14
Reflection Parameters
Vreflected ZL - Zo
G r
Reflection
Coefficient
=
Vincident
= F =
ZL + Zo
Return loss = -20 log(r ), r = G
Voltage Standing Wave
Vmax
Vmin
Ratio
Vmax 1+r
VSWR = =
Vmin 1-r
No reflection Full reflection
(ZL = Zo) (ZL = open, short)
0 r 1
dB RL 0 dB
1 VSWR
Page 15
Smith Chart Review Polar plane o
90
+jX
1.0
.8
.6
.4
0 +R + 180 o .2 o
0
-
0
-jX
-90 o
Rectilinear impedance plane
Constant X
Z L = Zo Constant R
G= 0
Smith Chart maps
Z L = 0 (short) ZL = (open)
rectilinear impedance G =1
G= 1
O
±180
O
0
plane onto polar plane
Smith chart
Page 16
Transmission Parameters
V Incident V Transmitted
DUT
V Transmitted
Transmission Coefficient = T = = t
V Incident
VTrans
Insertion Loss (dB) = -20 Log = -20 Log(t)
V Inc
V Trans
Gain (dB) = 20 Log = 20 Log(t)
V Inc
Page 17
Linear Versus Nonlinear Behavior
A * Sin 360o * f (t - to)
A
— Linear behavior:
to
Time Input and output frequencies are the
same (no additional frequencies
Sin 360o * f * t
A
phase shift =
created)
to * 360o * f Output frequency only undergoes
Time
f
1
Frequency magnitude and phase change
Input DUT Output
— Nonlinear behavior:
f
1
Frequency Output frequency may
Time
undergo frequency shift (e.g.
with mixers)
Additional frequencies created
(harmonics, intermodulation)
f Frequency
1
Page 18
Criteria for Distortionless Transmission
Linear Networks
Frequency
Phase
Frequency
Page 19
Magnitude Variation with Frequency
Time
Time
Linear Network
Magnitude
Page 20
Phase Variation with Frequency
F(t) = sin wt + 1 /3 sin 3wt + 1 /5 sin 5wt
Linear Network
Time Time
Magnitude
Frequency
0°
Frequency Frequency
-180°
-360 °
Page 21
Deviation from Linear Phase
Phase 1 /Div
o
o
+ =
Page 22
Why Use S-Parameters?
‒ Relatively easy to obtain at high frequencies
‒ Measure voltage traveling waves with a vector network analyzer
‒ Don't need shorts/opens (can cause active devices to oscillate or self-destruct)
‒ Relate to familiar measurements (gain, loss, reflection coefficient ...)
‒ Can cascade S-parameters of multiple devices to predict system performance
‒ Can compute H-, Y-, or Z-parameters from S-parameters if desired
‒ Can easily import and use S-parameter files in electronic-simulation tools
Incident S 21 Transmitted
a1
S11 b2
Reflected DUT
S22
Port 1 Port 2 Reflected
b1
a2
Transmitted S12 Incident
b1 = S11 a1 + S12 a 2
b 2 = S21 a1 + S22 a 2
Page 23
Measuring S-Parameters
S b2
Incident 21 Transmitted
a1
Z0
S 11
Forward Reflected DUT Load
b1 a2 = 0
Reflected b1 Reflected b2
S 11 = = a S 22 = = a
Incident 1 a2 = 0 Incident 2 a1 = 0
Transmitted b Transmitted b
2 S 12 = 1
S 21 = = a = a
Incident 1 a2 = 0 Incident 2 a1 = 0
a1 = 0 b2
Z0 S 22
DUT
Load Reflected Reverse
a2
b1 Transmitted S 12 Incident
Page 24
Equating S-Parameters With Common
Measurement Terms
S11 = forward reflection coefficient (input match)
S22 = reverse reflection coefficient (output match)
S21 = forward transmission coefficient (gain or loss)
S12 = reverse transmission coefficient (isolation)
Page 25
Agenda Page 26
DUT
Reflected
SOURCE
SIGNAL
SEPARATION
RECEIVER / DETECTOR
PROCESSOR / DISPLAY
Page 27
Source Incident
DUT
Transmitted
Reflected
SOURCE
SIGNAL
SEPARATION
REFLECTED TRANSMITTED
INCIDENT (R) (A) (B)
RECEIVER / DETECTOR
Page 28
Signal Separation
Incident Transmitted
DUT
Reflected
SOURCE
REFLECTED TRANSMITTED
RECEIVER / DETECTOR
PROCESSOR / DISPLAY
splitter
bridge
Detector
directional
coupler Test Port
Page 29
Directivity
Directivity is a measure of how well a directional coupler or
bridge can separate signals moving in opposite directions
Page 30
Directional Bridge
— 50-ohm load at test port balances
the bridge -- detector reads zero
— Non-50-ohm load imbalances
bridge
50 W 50 W — Measuring magnitude and phase of
imbalance gives complex
impedance
Detector — "Directivity" is difference between
maximum and minimum balance
— Advantage: less loss at low
50 W frequencies
Test Port
— Disadvantages: more loss in main
arm at high frequencies and less
power-handling capability
Page 31
Interaction of Directivity with the DUT
(Without Error Correction)
0
Data max
DUT RL = 40 dB
30 Device
60
Frequency
Directivity
Data min
Device
Device
Add out-of-phase
(cancellation)
Page 32
Detector Types:
Narrowband Detection - Tuned Receiver
RF
ADC / DSP
IF Filter
— Best sensitivity / dynamic range
LO — Provides harmonic / spurious signal rejection
— Improve dynamic range by increasing power,
decreasing IF bandwidth, or averaging
— Trade off noise floor and measurement speed
Page 35
Incident Transmitted
Reflected
SIGNAL
SEPARATION
REFLECTED TRANSMITTED
INCIDENT (R) (A) (B)
RECEIVER / DETECTOR
PROCESSOR / DISPLAY
Harmonic f
It is cheaper and easier to make frequency "comb"
broadband front ends using generator
samplers instead of mixers, but
dynamic range is considerably less
Page 37
Dynamic Range and Accuracy
Error Due to Interfering Signal
100
10 -
+
phase error
Error (dB, deg)
1 Dynamic range is
very important for
magn error
0.1 measurement
accuracy!
0.01
0.001
0 -5 -10 -15 -20 -25 -30 -35 -40 -45 -50 -55 -60 -65 -70
Page 38
T/R Versus S-Parameter Test Sets
Transmission/Reflection Test Set S-Parameter Test Set
Source Source
Transfer switch
R1
R
A B A B
R2
Page 39
Modern VNA Block Diagram (2-Port PNA-X)
+28V J11 J10 J9 J8 J7 rear panel J2 J1
+ LO
-
Source 2
OUT OUT Noise receivers
1 2 To receivers
Source 1 Pulse
OUT OUT modulator 10 MHz - 3–
1 2 3 GHz 13.5/
R1 Pulse
26.5
GHz
modulator
Pulse generators R2
A 1
2
B
3
4
Source 2 Source 2
Test port 1 Output 1 Output 2 Test port 2
Page 41
Processor / Display
Incident Transmitted
DUT
Reflected
SOURCE
SIGNAL
SEPARATION
REFLECTED TRANSMITTED
INCIDENT (R) (A) (B)
RECEIVER / DETECTOR
PROCESSOR / DISPLAY
‒ Markers
‒ Limit lines
‒ Pass/fail indicators
‒ Linear/log formats
‒ Grid/polar/Smith charts
‒ Time-domain transform
‒ Trace math
Page 42
Agenda Page 43
Page 44
Measurement Error Modeling
– Systematic errors
• Due to imperfections in the analyzer and test setup
• Assumed to be time invariant (predictable)
• Generally, are largest sources or error
– Random errors
• Vary with time in random fashion (unpredictable)
• Main contributors: instrument noise, switch and
connector repeatability Errors:
SYSTEMATIC
– Drift errors Measured Unknown
Data
RANDOM Device
• Due to system performance changing
DRIFT
• after a calibration has been done
• Primarily caused by temperature variation
Page 45
Systematic Measurement Errors
R A B
Directivity Crosstalk
DUT
Frequency response
Reflection tracking (A/R) Source Load
Transmission tracking (B/R) Mismatch Mismatch
Page 46
What is Vector-Error Correction?
Errors
Measured
Actual
– Vector-error correction
• Is a process for characterizing systematic error
• Measures known electrical standards
• Removes effects of error terms from subsequent measurements
– Electrical Standards
• Can be mechanical or electronic
• Are often an open, short, load, and thru,
but can be arbitrary impedances as well
Page 48
Using Known Standards to Correct
for Systematic Errors
– 1-port calibration (reflection measurements)
• Only three systematic error terms measured
• Directivity, source match, and reflection tracking
Page 49
Reflection: One-Port Model
Error Adapter
RF in Ideal
RF in 1
ED = Directivity
– If using port two of NA and DUT reverse isolation is low (e.g., filter passband):
• Assumption of good termination is not valid
• Two-port error correction yields better results
Page 50
Before and After A One-Port Calibration
Page 51
Reverse model
Two-Port Error Correction Port 1 Port 2
E RT'
Forward model a1
S21
A b2
E L' S11 S22 ED'
A A E S' a2
Port 1 EX Port 2 b1
E TT' S12 A
S21A ETT b2
a1 ES EX'
ED S11A S22 a2
A
b1 EL
S EX ' S ED
- Each actual S-parameter is a function of ( 12m )(1 11m ( E S E L ' ))
E TT ' E RT
S12a
all four measured S-parameters S
(1 11m
ED S
E S )(1 22m
ED' S
E S ' ) E L ' E L ( 21m
E X S12m E X '
)( )
E RT E RT ' E TT E TT '
- Analyzer must make forward and
reverse sweep to update any one S- S 22m E D '
( )( 1
S11m E D
ES ) E L ' (
S 21m E X S12m E X '
)( )
E RT ' E RT E TT E TT '
parameter S22a
S ED S ED' S E X S12m E X '
(1 11m E S )(1 22m E S ' ) E L ' E L ( 21m )( )
- Luckily, you don't need to know these E RT E RT ' E TT ETT '
Page 52
Crosstalk: Signal Leakage Between Test Ports
During Transmission
– Can be a problem with: DUT
– Isolation calibration
• Adds noise to error model (measuring near noise floor of system)
• Only perform if really needed (use averaging if necessary)
Page 53
Errors and Calibration Standards
UNCORRECTED RESPONSE 1-PORT FULL 2-PORT
SHORT
SHORT SHORT
DUT OPEN
OPEN OPEN
thru
Convenient LOAD
LOAD LOAD
Generally not accurate
DUT
No errors removed
DUT
Easy to perform thru
Use when highest
accuracy is not For reflection measurements
DUT
required Need good termination for
Removes frequency high accuracy with two-port
devices Highest accuracy
response error
Removes these errors: Removes these
Directivity errors:
Source match Directivity
ENHANCED-RESPONSE Source, load match
Reflection tracking
Combines response and 1-port Reflection tracking
Corrects source match for transmission Transmission
measurements tracking
Crosstalk
Page 54
Calibration Summary SHORT
Test Set (cal type)
Reflection T/R S-parameter OPEN
(one-port) (two-port)
Reflection tracking
LOAD
Directivity
Source match
Load match
Test Set (cal type)
Page 55
Response versus Two-Port Calibration
Measuring filter insertion loss
Uncorrected
Page 56
ECal: Electronic Calibration
– Variety of two- and four-port modules cover 300 kHz to 67 GHz
– Single-connection calibration
• dramatically reduces calibration time
• makes calibrations easy to perform
• minimizes wear on cables and standards
• eliminates operator errors
Page 57
Thru-Reflect-Line (TRL) Calibration
We know about Short-Open-Load-Thru (SOLT) calibration... What is TRL?
A two-port calibration technique
Good for non-coaxial environments (waveguide, fixtures, wafer probing)
Characterizes same 12 systematic errors as the more common SOLT cal
Uses practical calibration standards that
are easily fabricated and characterized
TRL was developed for
Other variations: Line-Reflect-Match (LRM),
non-coaxial microwave
Thru-Reflect-Match (TRM), plus many others
measurements
Page 58
Agenda Page 59
– Gain Compression
4-port VNA Block Diagram
(E5071C)
R1 R1 R1 R1
A A A A
Bias-tee
(optional)
Page 61
Full 3 and 4-Port Error Correction
1
Ex21
Ex21
S21M
Et21 Port 4
a11 b21
S11M Ed1
S21A Et41
El21
Es1 Ex41 El41
Er1 S11A S22A
S23A
S31A a21
b11
1 Et21
S13A S12A
S32A
Port 1
Ed1 Es1 El21 Port 2
S33A
a31 b31
Er1
Page 62
Agenda Page 63
– Gain Compression
Mixed-mode S-parameter Measurement
Example
Differential amplifier
Output Impedance
Input
Impedance
Common
Differential
to Differential
Gain
Conversion
Differential to
Common Mode
Conversion
Page 64
Agenda Page 65
– Gain Compression
Example of VNA-based time domain analysis
(E5071C)
Freq domain
Sdd21
Time domain
Sdd21
Page 66
Agenda Page 67
– Gain Compression
What is gain compression? DUT
Parameter to define the transition between the linear and nonlinear region of an
active device.
The compression point is observed as x dB drop in the gain with VNA’s power sweep.
Sufficient power
level to drive DUT
Linear region Power is not high enough
Compression to compress DUT.
(nonlinear) region
Page 68
Gain compression over frequency
Frequency Frequency
Page 69
Gain compression measurement example
Ch 2 (vs. Frequency):
Tr 1: Pin @ P1dB vs. Freq
Tr 2: Pout @ P1dB vs. Freq
Page 70
RF amplifier test
The modern VNA is a more suited solution for many parametric tests of RF amplifiers.
f1 f1 f2 f3
PNA
High performance microwave
PNA-L
Economy microwave
Reach for unrivaled excellence
E5071C / E5072A
High performance RF NA
E5061B
• Low-cost simple RF NA
• LF-RF NA
Drive down the cost of test
FieldFox
Portable RF/MW Analyzer