Garcia
Garcia
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
http://www.jstor.org
CristinaDelgadoGarcía
Aberystwyth University
[email protected]
The presentarticleanalysesthenarrativedevicesbywhichtheWoolfian,anti-essentialist
notionof subjectivityis producedin MrsDalloway.This analysisthataimsto critically
assessthenovel'sdecentring discourseon selfhoodin a politicallight.Focusingon the
self-definition
of thecharactersat thetimeof thefiction,
thefirstsectionexaminesthe
discursiveproductionof ClarissaDalloway'sdiffusedand connectiveself.The second
sectionofthisarticleconsidersthepoliticsofmemorywithintheproductionof identity
in thenovel,takingtheBergsonian notionsofélanvitaland openmorality as a theoretical
framework. The analysisof theproductionof selfhoodin MrsDallowayat a synchronie
in the diegeticpresenttime) and diachroniclevel (definitionthrough
(self-definition
memory)uncoversstrongphallogocentric and conservativetensionsin the novel,
tensionsthatmayhavebeen overlookedas a resultofVirginiaWoolfs own progressive
politics.
VirginiaWoolf;MrsDalloway;radicalism;
Keywords: selfhood;language;HenriBergson
■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■1
ATfJWttS. oftheSpanishAssociation
Journal Studies.32.1(June2010):15-28
ofAnglo-American
ISSN0210-6124
positionthe use of the termradical.It will be used throughout in its broad sense,
namely"believing or expressing thebelief thatthere should be greator extremesocial
or politicalchange"('Radical',def.la), and not in reference to an alliancewithany
particularpoliticalpartyor organisation. Likewise,conservative referto a tendency
will
"notto likeor trustchange,especiallysuddenchange"('Conservative', def.la). Thus,
thisarticledoes notintendto analysewhether MrsDallowayadvocatesthenecessity of
governmental changein the post-war,conservative- ruledand stillimperialist Great
Britainof 1923. Instead,it will assess the ways in whichWoolfs devicesto create
character eitherallowor disallowa sociallyaware,non-masculinist envisioning of the
selfand ofotherness whichmayepitomisethepossibility ofsocialchallengeand change
in thecharacters'past,in their1923presenttimeofthefiction or in an allegedfuture.
Thisarticlewillanalysethedevicesbywhichtheanti-essentialist selfis producedin
MrsDallowayand theirimplications in termsof radicalism.It willbe arguedthatthe
main characters are createdin relationto two axes - synchronically, by seekingself-
definitionwhile expressinga desire to communicatewith other individuals;
diachronically,by oscillating betweenthe timeof the diegesisand a past recalledby
constantmemories.The discussionon theseaxes on representation willconstitute the
twomainsectionsofthisarticle.The firstpartwillbeginby examining how Clarissa's
diffusedand connectiveself is createdin the novel and what its relationshipto
phallogocentrism and conservatism is. The secondpartwillquestionthe relationship
betweenradicalismand the constantreference to past memories,not onlyfromthe
point of view of the lack of an alternative futurebut also as a mechanismto suffocate
theélanvitaland theopenmorality thatwouldallowprogressive politics.Thiswilllead
to the conclusionthatWoolfs techniquesto constructthe selfpromotesubtlebut
strongconservative tensionsin thenovel.
Thisexamination willallowfortheincorporation of aspectsofthenovelthatwere
overlookedin previouscriticalanalyses,such as the purelynarrative validityof the
connectionsbetweencharacters.It will also preventthe use of Woolfs personal
sympathies as a pre-assumedand biased interpretative basis. Finally,thisdebatewill
prove useful to open alternativereadings ofthe politics theselfin thenovel,suchas
of
thaton theBergsonian élanvitaland the incorporation ofa closemorality.
and
2. Untanglingthe fiction of connectedness:alienation, self-centredness
phallogocentrism
AiïJWlïS. JournaloftheSpanishAssociationofAnglo-American
Studies.32.1 (June2010): 15-28
ISSN 0210-6124
AÏÏJWIÏS. JournaloftheSpanishAssociationofAnglo-American
Studies.32.1 (June2010): 15-28
ISSN 0210-6124
AT£<ANîîS.JournaloftheSpanishAssociationofAnglo-American
Studies.32.1 (June2010): 15-28
ISSN 0210-6124
group of guests,that is, the close circle of her old friendsand her husband's
acquaintances.The narrowingof her moralityis also expressedin her contempt
towardsMiss Kilman'sideologicalinfluenceoverElizabeth:"love and religionwould
destroy... theprivacyof thesoul. The odious Kilmanwoulddestroyit" (2000: 107).
Mrs Dalloway's identification of love and Christianity witha threatto theselfreveals
the shrivellingof hermorals,whichonce werepreoccupiedwithsocial issues.In her
matureyears,theneed forpreserving one's personalspace is feltstronger thanthatof
creating bonds of love with humanity, something posed by religion and its correlative
openmorality.
Mr Dalloway'spositionas a Conservative MemberofParliament couldpromotehis
engagement with social a
politics; politics not easily labelled as progressive but
nevertheless compelled to enhance the condition of England. Even Lady Bruton thinks
that"Richard'sfirst dutywas to hiscountry"(2000: 94). Thisstatement wouldseemto
point to Mr Dallowaybeing the bearer ofan open morality, it is
although important to
notethatthenotionofcountry refers bothto thestateand to itspeople,and heremay
referto eitherof thetwo.In anycase,thehumancirclethatconcernsRichardis even
narrower thanthat.He "didn'tcare a strawwhatbecameof Emigration" (2000: 96),
"he had no illusionsabout the London police" and thoughtthatthe faultof all this
malfunctioning was "in [England's]detestable socialsystem"(2000: 98). Comingfrom
a politician,thiscontempttowardstheentiresocialbodyand itsinstitutions seemsto
express the loss ofa political idealism and a willto affect the whole of society. Like Mrs
Dalloway, Richard seems to have shifted towards the search for an inward,personal
fulfilment thatis moreattachedto closedmoralities.
Conversely, Clarissa'sdaughter, Elizabeth,is portrayed as stillmaintaining theélan
vitaland the radicalspiritthatthe older generationhas abandoned.Like Sally in
Bourton,Elizabethis consciously unobservant of therulesofbehaviourand etiquette:
Clarissanoteshow "[Elizabeth]did not care a bit" about "how she dressed,how she
treatedpeoplewhocameto lunch"(2000: 10),whichis a reflection on herfeeling duty-
less towardsthe maintenanceof her parents'social status.The homoeroticdesire
betweenyoungClarissaand Sallyis replicated in therelationship betweenElizabethand
MissKilman.The bondbetweenthelatterpairis describedas a "falling in love" (2000:
10) byClarissa,who also acknowledges herfeelings towardsSallyas havingbeen,"after
all,love" (2000: 28). Likewise, Miss Kilmanand Elizabethre-enacttherolesof radical
mentorand learning protégée thatSallyand Clarissaplayedin Bourton.It is becauseof
Miss KilmanthatElizabethis awarethat"law,medicine,politics,all professions are
opento womenof [her]generation" (2000: 111),and thatallowsfordaydreamofbeing
a "doctor,a farmer, [or] possiblygo intoParliament ifshe foundit necessary" (2000:
116).Elizabethis portrayed as beingin a stageofherlifewhenherélanvitaland an open
morality arestillalive.Peterforesees a futurelevellingofElizabeth'sfeelings withthose
oftheolderguestsin thepartywhenhe says:"She feelsnothalfwhatwe feel,notyet"
(2000: 164). UnlikeTo The Lighthouse, thisnoveldoes not providea futuretimein
whichElizabethmaybe revisited so as forthe readerto witnessthe evolutionof her
radicalimpulses.
A1ZJWIÎS. Journal
oftheSpanishAssociationofAnglo-American
Studies.32.1 (June2010): 15-28
ISSN 0210-6124
4. Conclusion:decentreddiscourse,self-centred
politics.
WorksCited
Woolf:TheCommonGround.Edinburgh:
Beer,Gillian1996: Virginia Edinburgh UP.
Bergson,Henri1984 (1907): CreativeEvolution.
Trans.ArthurMitchell.Lanhan:UP ofAmerica.
Trans,ofV'Evolution Créatrice.
1935 (1932): The Two Sourcesof Moralityand Religion.Trans. R. AshleyAudra and
CloudesleyBrereton.London:Macmillan.Trans,of Les Deux Sourcesde la Moraleet de la
Religion.
Blanchard, Margaret 1972:'SocializationinMrsDalloway. CollegeEnglish34.2:287-305.
Bradshaw, David2000: 'The Socio-Political VisionoftheNovels'.Sue Roe and SusanSellers,eds.
TheCambridge CompaniontoVirginiaWoolfCambridge: CambridgeUP. 191-208.
Burwick, Frederick and Paul Douglass1992:Introduction. TheCrisisin Modernism:Bergson and
theVitalistControversy. Cambridge: CambridgeUP. 1-11.
'Conservative'.CambridgeDictionariesOnline. 2007. Cambridge UP. <http://dictionary.
cambridge.org> (Accessed28 Nov,2009)
Dick,Susan2000: 'Literary RealisminMrsDalloway,To theLighthouse, Orlandoand TheWaves'
Sue Roe and Susan Sellers,eds. The Cambridge Companionto VirginiaWoolfCambridge:
Cambridge UP. 50-71.
Forbes,Shannon2005: 'EquatingPerformance withIdentity:
theFailureof ClarissaDalloway's
Victorian"Self in VirginiaWoolfs MrsDalloway' Journal oftheMidwestModernLanguage
Association38.1:38-50.
Gillies,MaryAnn1996:HenryBergson andBritishModernism. Montreal:McGill-Queen'sUP.
Goudge,ThomasA 1999:Introduction. An IntroductiontoMetaphysics.ByHenriBergson.Trans.
T. E. Hulme.Indianapolis:Hackett.9-20.
Helal, KathleenM. 2005: 'Anger,Anxiety, Abstraction:
VirginiaWoolfs "SubmergedTruth'".
SouthCentralReview22.2:78-94.
Kumar,Shiv1979:Bergson and theStreamofConsciousness Novel.Westport:GreenwoodP.
Marcus,Laura2000: 'Woolfs Feminismand Feminism's Woolf. Sue Roe and SusanSellers,eds.
TheCambridge Companion toVirginiaWoolfCambridge: CambridgeUP. 209-44.
2004: 'Writingthe City:"StreetHaunting"and Mrs Dalloway. VirginiaWoolf2nd ed.
Plymouth: Northcote House.61-83.
Moi,Toril2002: Sexual/Textual Politics:
FeministLiteraryTheory.London:Taylor& Francis.
Mullin, Katherine2006: 'Modernismsand Feminisms'.Ellen Rooney,ed. The Cambridge
CompaniontoFeminist LiteraryTheory. Cambridge:CambridgeUP. 136-15.
'Radical'. Cambridge Dictionaries Online. 2007. Cambridge UP. <http://dictionary.
Cambridge. org> (Accessed28 Nov,2009)
Rooney,Ellen2006: 'The Literary PoliticsofFeministTheory'.EllenRooney,ed. TheCambridge
CompaniontoFeminist LiteraryTheory. Cambridge:CambridgeUP. 73-96.
JtfLjwns. Journal
oftheSpanishAssociationofAnglo-American
Studies.32.1 (June2010): 15-28
ISSN 0210-6124
Received13 January
2010 Revisedversion
accepted19 February
2010
DelgadoGarcíaholdsa BAinJournalism
Cristina anda BAinEnglish
andLinguisticsfromtheUniversität
Autònoma (Spain),as wellas an MAdegreeinPost-1
de Barcelona 900sLiteratures,
Theories
andCultures
fromtheUniversity
ofManchester (UK).She is a PhDcandidate
atAberystwyth (UK),whereshe
University
has beenawarded a TFTSDoctoral Studentship toconduct
research
on radicalepistemologies
oftheself
inBritish
theatreofthe1990sand2000s.Herinterests include
modernist
andpostmodernist and
narratives
theatres,
contemporary
European drama, and
gender sexuality,performance and
politics critical
theory.
of Theatre,Filmand Television
Address:Department Studies.AberystwythUniversity.
Parry-Williams
UK.SY233AJ.Tel.:44 (0)1970622828.
Aberystwyth,
Building. Fax:44 (0)1970622831.
Journal
AÏJCJWIÏS. oftheSpanishAssociation Studies.32.1(June2010):15-28
ofAnglo-American
ISSN 0210-6124