CurrentScience 2015 Dhauli Alakh
CurrentScience 2015 Dhauli Alakh
Figure 2. Characters of various kinds of foliations from the HHC. a, Tight fold on psammite/pelite alternations
S0/S1 (lithological banding) and development of intense axial plane foliation S2 near Helang. Loc.
1: 303142 : 793203 (RM 45). Scale: Hammer head. b, S–C and C shear fabrics within schist of the Munsiari
Thrust zone near Helang. Note top-to-SW upwards thrust geometry of planes. Top of photograph points SW. Loc.
2: 303140 : 793008 (RM 36). c, Idealized diagram of S–C and C shear fabric and angle between S and C
planes. d, Measurements of angle (n = 132) within the MCT thrust zone. Distance measured from surface trace
of the Munsiari Thrust.
Shear sense indicators within the HHC on earlier S1–S2 and/or C-foliation, axial plane crenula-
tion foliation (S3) and L3 mineral lineation are developed
The HHC incorporates a very large component of late parallel to the Himalayan orogen; the F3 folds sometimes
Paleoproterozoic metamorphics44 and relict structures produce very large folds in Zanskar and Himachal
such as rare, isolated, tight and ‘flame-type’ F1 folds on Pradesh. Kink bands, tension gashes, slickensides and
lithological banding and/or metamorphic layering (S0), joints are developed on earlier foliations during D4
representing the D1 deformation phase15. However, the deformation. One of the important features of the D4
most prominent, intense and widespread deformation D2 event is the presence of large-scale open and upright
is characterized by penetrative foliation (S2), which cross-folds that produce culminations and depressions,
parallels the axial surfaces of tight to isoclinal reclined to and control outcrop patterns of many tectonic units.
recumbent F2 folds on S0/S1 foliation (Figure 2 a). In the As a consequence of non-coaxial deformation within
absence of fold hinges of these folds, all these foliations the whole HHC belt along the Alaknanda–Dhauli Ganga
become indistinguishable from each other and are valleys from Helong to Malari–Niti, a number of asym-
grouped as the main foliation (Sm; Figure 1 b). Like other metric, small-scale deformational structures provide
parts of the HHC in NW Himalaya, the S2 foliation has extremely useful and invaluable information regarding
undergone extreme flow due to ductile shearing and the direction of tectonic transport and evolution of this
becomes essentially a composite S–C planar shear fabric belt. Most useful shear sense indicators in this belt are the
with regional NW–SE trend and NE dips11,45 (Figure 2 b). S–C and S–C fabrics, asymmetric porphyroclasts and
Measurements of angle between S and C planes indicate porphyroblasts, mineral fishes, asymmetric boudins and
that it decreases from 45 to 15 within the MCT shear duplex-type shear zones. From the asymmetry of the struc-
zone (Figure 2 c and d). This superposed ductile shearing tures shear sense was determined in the field and from ori-
along the S2 foliation has resulted in transposition and ented thin sections in planes perpendicular to the main
obliteration of all the earlier planar structures. Extensive foliation and paralleling the stretching lineation (XZ plane).
flow within the HHC has developed a prominent L2
stretching lineation (Figure 1 c). Such a deformation pat-
tern is not only confined to the HHC, but extends to the S–C and S–C foliation
STDS, the overlying THS cover to the Proterozoic base-
ment, the MT and VT zones, and footwall of the Lesser Shear bands or C-surfaces are shear foliation that tran-
Himalayan Sedimentary Zone11,15,46–48. sects a well-developed simultaneous foliation S at a small
During subsequent superposed D3 deformational phase, angle, and the combined texture is called a shear band
close to isoclinal recumbent to gently inclined F3 folds foliation or S–C foliation/fabric49,50 (Figures 2 and 3).
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 108, NO. 6, 25 MARCH 2015 1109
RESEARCH ARTICLES
The S-surfaces become sigmoidal in character and gradu- Porphyroclasts
ally deflect near the C-surfaces paralleling the main shear
zone. Sense of shear is determined from acute angle Relict, more rigid porphyroclasts within the HHC of these
between the S- and C-foliations (Figures 2 c and 3 a and valleys consist of a central sigmoidal-shaped single crystal
b). Within the HHC S–C fabrics are developed both in the within highly sheared, fine-grained, foliated matrix
granite mylonite and psammitic gneiss/schist where C- (Figures 3 a and 4 a). They typically develop from more
fabric is superposed upon the S-fabric and both are dis- resistant feldspar in a strongly foliated quartz, feldspar
tinguishable (Figure 3 a). At other places within the MCT and mica matrix in sheared granite mylonite. During the
zone, the C-fabric dominates over the S-fabric or folia- course of deformation, the porphyroclasts develop asym-
tion is mainly marked by C-plane with S-plane denoting metric recrystallized tails showing stair-stepping geome-
the pre-existing foliation (Figure 3 a). try (Figure 3 a). The most common is -type, whose
C-foliation, described originally as C-bands51 or asymmetry and stair-stepping define the shear sense
extensional crenulation cleavage (ecc)52, is observed (Figures 3 a and 4 a). Rarely -type tails are also seen;
within the HHC as oblique discrete bands causing both of them are useful in shear sense determination.
sigmoidal curvature of S-planes. C-planes make angles
of 15–35 with the main C-shears (Figure 2 a and b). Porphyroblasts
These are usually later than the S–C-fabric and more
weakly developed, shorter and wavy than the C-planes. Syntectonically growing, asymmetrical garnet and feld-
One set of C-shears is commonly developed at low angle spar porphyroblasts are recorded from the kyanite-
and exhibits the same sense of movement as the C-shears bearing garnetiferous mica gneiss/schist of the Suraithota
(synthetic) or may also show opposite dip (antithetic) and and Bhapkund Formations within the HHC, while migma-
shear sense as the C-shears. tite from the latter formation contains porphyroblastic
feldspar (Figure 4 b–d). Reaction rims of mafic and feld-
spar–quartz mineral aggregates in the Bhapkund Formation
of the HHC may be classified as mantled porphyroblasts
(Figure 4 d), having sigmoidal inclusion trails of other
minerals, and are themselves bounded by the S–C folia-
tion.
Sigmoidal shapes of numerous quartz and mica inclu-
sion trails, trapped inside the porphyroblasts during their
growth and simultaneous rotation, provide the evidences
of top-to-SW (thrust) shear sense.
Mineral fish
Duplex structure
Figure 3. S–C and C shear fabric/foliation as top-to-SW (thrust)
shear sense indicators from the HHC metamorphic. a, S–C and C
shears within the porphyroclastic granite mylonite of the MCT zone of
Rare duplex structures are observed within the HHC,
the Munsiari Group west of Tapovan along the Dhak Nala. Loc. 7: where low-angle floor and roof thrusts linked by ramps
303128 : 793728 (RM 68). Scale: Width of photograph is 12 cm. bound ‘lozenge’-shaped rock masses due to overlapping
b, Schist of the Munsiari Thrust zone (MCT) near Helang with subpar-
allel S–C fabric. Loc. 3: 303132 : 793030 (RM 35). Scale: Width
characters of thrust surfaces (Figure 5 d). Duplex struc-
of photograph is about 20 cm. tures of both the contractional and extensional regimes
1110 CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 108, NO. 6, 25 MARCH 2015
RESEARCH ARTICLES
Figure 4. Asymmetrical porphyroclast and porphyroblast systems in the HHC showing top-to-SW upward
thrust shear sense. a, Large feldspar porphyroclast within granite mylonite of the Munsiari Group, MCT zone,
west of Tapovan along the Dhak Nala. S–C shear fabric is also seen having same shear sense. Loc. 7:
303128 : 793728 (RM 68). Scale: Photograph width is about 10 cm. b, Winged garnet porphyroblast in silli-
manite–kyanite–garnet gneiss within Bhapkund Formation after crossing the Bhapkund bridge. Loc. 15:
304015 : 795010 (RM 10). Scale: 1 cm. c, Tailed garnet porphyroblast in kyanite–garnet gneiss within the
Suraithota Formation at Vishnuprayag. Loc. 6: 303354 : 793436 (RM 48). Scale: 2 cm. d, Garnet porphyro-
blasts with asymmetrical rim of feldspar-quartz in the Bhapkund Formation of the HHC near Bhapkund. Loc. 11:
303931 : 79500 (RM 95). Scale: Photograph width is about 8 cm.
Figure 5. a, b, Photomicrographs of the feldspar, quartz and muscovite fishes from the mylonitized gneiss of
the HHC along the STDS at Timarsain. Loc. 21: 304547 : 795100 (RM 20). c, Foliation fish formed by iso-
lated lens-shaped polycrystalline mica aggregates preserving an earlier shear fabric from the MCT zone near
Helang. Loc. 1: 303137 : 793000 (RM 34). Scale: 4 cm. d, Duplex structure having top-to-SW shear sense in
mica schist of the MCT zone near Helang. Loc. 4: 303152 : 793147 (RM 39). Scale: Width of photograph:
1 m.
Figure 7. Ductile to brittle–ductile shear zones within the HHC. a, Top-to-SW thrust-type shear zones within
the STDS zone, transposing the older folded fabric along the shear zones before village Kosa. Loc. 14:
304021 : 795019 (RM 9). b, Sheared quartz vein train transposed along NE-dipping top-to-SW thrust-type
shear zones branching up from the main foliation S m. Loc. 8: 302945 : 794300 (RM 58) near Suraithota.
c, Top-to-NE downward shear bands within migmatite, having leucogranite melt near Bhapkund. Loc. 12:
303955 : 795029 (RM 21). Scale: 3 cm. d, Steep NE-dipping brittle–ductile shear zones paralleling the
STDS. Note the sigmoidal bending of the earlier main foliation. Sense of movement is shown by arrows. North of
Malari near Timarsain. Loc. 22: 304600 : 794955 (RM 20A). Scale: Photograph about 10 m.
Figure 8. Asymmetrical shear boudins from the HHC. a, Series of top-to-SW shear boudins in vein quartz embedded in
psammitic schist south of Suraithota. Loc. 8: 302945 : 794300 (RM 58). b, Series of fish-mouth shear boudins in vein
quartz showing top-to-NE (normal) shear sense near Bhapkund Loc. 9: 303614 : 794811 (RM 26).
throughout the HHC up to the STDS. However, peak From the Malari village, a picturesque view of the
metamorphic pressures increase from 12 to 14 kbar 3 km STDS contact between the steeply-dipping HHC and the
above the VT and then decrease to 9 kbar at the STDS40. gentle THS is available and depicts the overall tectonics
Thus, the HHC belt is typically characterized by inverted of this fault (Figure 11 a, b). As one crosses the Malari
metamorphism with development of sillimanite–K- village going further northwestward, one can observe
feldspar gneiss and migmatite in the uppermost parts of normal faults (Figure 11 b, c) and their fault gouge zones
the Bhapkund Formation. and intense pulverization (Figure 11 c) due to brittle
Brittle structures like normal faults and conjugate frac- deformation by the STDS. Extensional shear bands also
tures increase in frequency up section toward the STDS. affect the Martoli Formation and have top-to-NE down-
Most orogen-parallel normal faults strike subparallel to ward normal shear sense (Figure 11 d).
the STDS and have minor displacements (<10 m) with At the Malari village, rocks on the hanging wall of the
mostly top-to-NE downward motion40. extensional STDS acquire listric geometry, especially
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 108, NO. 6, 25 MARCH 2015 1113
RESEARCH ARTICLES
granite, which exhibits gentle-dipping ‘apparent’ thrust- structures showing the top-to-SW structures remain the
type duplexes, possibly due to rollover antiform as a con- dominant shear fabric and are continuously observed to
sequence of the extensional movements along the STDS be dominant up to Tamak village. Between Tamak (Loca-
to accommodate the space (Figure 11 e (i) and (ii)). Both tion II – 303549N : 794731E) and the next village
types of shear sense indicators were observed within the Juma, the zone contains several folds and flow structures
Malari granite. Close-up observations of the Malari gran- along with the first appearance of leucogranite material.
ite exhibit both older top-to-SW upwards structures over However, shear sense indicators are absent throughout
which the younger top-to-NE downward structures are this narrow zone. After crossing Juma (Location III –
superimposed (Figure 11 e (iii) and inset in (ii)). 30367N : 794818E), kinematic indicators with top-
to-NE shear sense become dominant with the appearance
Observations and discussion of migmatite for the first time. A large migmatite zone is
observed after crossing the next village Jelam; the mig-
The top-to-SW shear sense indicators are ubiquitously matites are ubiquitously distributed up to Malari, but they
present throughout the HHC. However, kinematic indica- are observed to be dominant only in the upper parts of the
tors having exclusively top-to-SW shear sense are Bhapkund Formation. A few relict structures of top-to-
observed within the Munsiari and Joshimath Formations SW shear sense are also observed along with the domi-
and continue till the upper parts of the Suraithota Forma- nant top-to-NE shear fabric between Bhapkund and
tion. Structures showing top-to-NE shear sense first start Malari. Beyond Malari (Location IV – 3040 52N :
appearing in the middle parts of the Suraithota Formation 795320E), i.e. in the Martoli Formation, we observed
somewhere between Suraithota and Tamak at Location I exclusively top-to-NE downward shear sense indicators.
(303412N : 794456E; Figure 12). However, shear On the basis of our field observations and analysis of
the shear sense indicators, the whole HHC has been sub-
divided into the following five zones between Helang and
Ghamsali–Niti, including parts of the LHS and the THS
(Figure 12). The above classification is based on our
shear sense analysis and the simple fact that older phase
ductile shear fabric (DS1) or the top-to-SW shear sense
indicators represent a compressional/contractional envi-
ronment, while the younger ductile shear phase fabric
(DS2) or the top-to-NE shear sense indicators represent
(i)
(iii)
(ii)
Figure 11. STDS near Malari. a, Geological map of the STDS showing various structures in its vicinity of Malari.
b, The STDS above Kailashpur, observed rom Malari. Steeply-dipping HHC gneiss (left) is tectonically overlain by gen-
tly-dipping Martoli Formation. Unfilled rectangles indicate small-scale faults. Lines with rectangles are traces of joints.
Loc. 20: 304500 : 795313. c, Normal fault and its fault gouge and breccia within leucogranite due to isolated splay
extensional fault of the STDS. About 4 km from Malari on the Malari–Niti road. Loc. 19: 304232 : 795252 (RM 14).
d, Martoli quartzite deformed by brittle–ductile extensional fault zone near Malari. Loc. 18: 304137 : 795300 (RM
2). Scale: Pen. e (i), Overall fracture pattern in deformed granite with thrusts, normal faults and joints at Malari village.
Loc. 17: 304100 : 795300 (RM A). e (ii), (Inset) Details of subhorizontal thrust. e (iii) Porphyroclastic Malari granite
having asymmetrical megacrysts having top-to-SW (arrow) overthrust sense, and shear bands with top-to-NE downward
shear sense on the road near village Malari Loc. 16: 304057 : 795345 (RM 80). Scale: 5 cm.
an extensional environment. These zones have been tion up to the village Tamak. This zone extends up to
mapped as A to E in Figure 12, while observational approximately 18 km (map distance) from the (VT); TZ
points of their changes in the field are indicated as I to is the zone between the villages Tamak and Juma. It
IV. starts at a distance of 18 km approximately from the VT
(A) Pure contractional zone (PCZ), exhibiting only the and is around 2 km wide; it is the zone starting after the
DS1 top-to-SW shear phase fabric. village Juma up to Malari. This zone accommodates up-
(B) Dominant contractional zone (DCZ), DS2 move- per parts of the Suraithota Formation and the entire
ment planes with top-to-NE shear sense make their first Bhapkund Formation. It starts at a distance of 20 km
appearance, but the DS1 fabric remains dominant. from the VT; PEZ is the zone which accommodates the
(C) Transition zone (TZ) having no DS1 and DS2 shear entire Martoli Formation and starts at a distance of about
sense indicators, but is marked by considerable rock 30 km from the VT (Figure 12).
flowage. Observation of numerous shear sense indicators along
(D) Dominant extensional zone (DEZ), in which the these valleys revealed two phases of ductile shear defor-
DS2 phase shear fabric is dominant over the DS1 phase mation, DS1 and DS2. The later phase DS2 showing top-
shear fabric. to-NE downward shear sense was superposed over the
(E) Pure extensional zone (PEZ) with only the DS2 older phase DS1 showing top-to-SW upward shear sense.
phase shear fabric within the THS. The DS1 indicates that the HHC has been deformed
According to the above classification, the PCZ is the within a broad non-coaxial ductile shear zone of the over-
zone from the upper parts of the LHS up to the middle thrust type with a consistent top-to-SW sense of move-
parts of the Suraithota Formation; DCZ is the zone ment. It also suggests an early deformation history of the
accommodating the upper parts of the Suraithota Forma- HHC involving large-scale SW-verging ductile shearing
CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 108, NO. 6, 25 MARCH 2015 1115
RESEARCH ARTICLES
within the Higher Himalayan Shear Zone (HHSZ), asso- pure Poiseuille (or parabolic) flow between stationary
ciated with the India – Asia continental convergence and rigid plates where horizontal gradients in lithostatic pres-
compressional tectonics11,45. Though it is difficult to sure and frictional resistance along channel boundaries
envisage precise relationship between the ductile shearing produce greatest velocities in its centre with decreasing
within the HHSZ and its movement along the MCT, it is velocities toward the margins, leading to development of
likely that the latter represents a zone of high ductile opposing shear senses, or (iii) a combination of the
strain. The STDS, on the contrary, is associated with two57,58 (see also Godin et al.17; references therein). The
extensional deformation. critical wedge/extrusion models postulate southward
The present work highlights the distribution pattern of extruding metamorphic belt, bounded by the MCT and
various kinematic indicators along the Alaknanda–Dhauli the STDS at the base and the top respectively10,57.
Ganga section and is useful in understanding the evolu- Shear sense indicators from the HHC belt of
tion of the Himalayan metamorphics within a framework the Alaknanda and Dhauli Ganga valleys can only be
of various recent tectonic models like (i) ductile shear- explained by a combination of the pure Couette (or linear)
ing45, (ii) channel flow30,31 and (iii) critical wedge/ flow and pure Poiseuille (or parabolic) flow within either
extrusion10,29,34. The ductile shear model postulates con- a ductile shear zone or a channel, bounded by the MCT
sistent top-to-SW thrust shear sense from various kine- and the STDS, where top-to-SW shear indicators are
matic indicators within a broad, ductile HHSZ, where superposed by the top-to-NE verging structures over a wide
millimetre-scale ductile shearing along S–C shear fabric zone near the STDS. The Couette (or linear) flow possi-
caused the inverted metamorphism and decompression bly provided top-to-SW shearing throughout the shear
melting in the upper parts; top-to-NE shear sense near its zone/channel to start with, and was subsequently super-
upper margin remained not so well explained45. The posed by the Poiseuille (or parabolic) flow at a later stage;
channel flow model and its different variants visualize ei- both the flows would remain indistinguishable from each
ther (i) a pure Couette (or linear) flow between rigid other in the lower parts of the shear zone/channel. It is
plates where these move relative to one another and pro- only after crossing the Transition Zone that the structures
duce uniform simple shear across the channel or (ii) a of the Poiseuille flow will start showing up in the shear
zone/channel due to their opposite vergence.
Conclusions