0% found this document useful (0 votes)
51 views35 pages

Unit 2 Notes

Uploaded by

SATHYA P
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
51 views35 pages

Unit 2 Notes

Uploaded by

SATHYA P
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 35

HUMAN VALUES

AND ETHICS
GE3791
UNIT 2: TOPICS
SECULARISM
Secularism in India refers to the principle of maintaining a separation between religion and
government, ensuring that all religions are treated equally by the state.

1. Equal Treatment of All Religions: The Indian state does not favor or discriminate against any
religion, ensuring that all religions are treated with equal respect and allowed to coexist peacefully.
2. Constitutional Provision: The Indian Constitution explicitly declares India as a secular state in its
Preamble, reinforced by the 42nd Amendment Act of 1976.
3. Freedom of Religion: The Constitution guarantees every citizen the right to freely profess,
practice, and propagate their religion under Article 25, subject to public order, morality, and health.
4. No State Religion: India does not have an official state religion, maintaining a neutral stance
towards all religions.
5. Religious Harmony: Secularism in India promotes religious harmony and tolerance among its
diverse population, encouraging peaceful coexistence of various religious communities.
SECULAR SOCIETY
A secular society is one in which the government operates independently of religious institutions,
and religious beliefs do not influence public policies or laws. This separation ensures that all
citizens, regardless of their religious beliefs, are treated equally under the law.

Separation of Religion and State: In a secular society, religious institutions and government
operations are distinct and operate independently of each other, ensuring that religious beliefs
do not dictate public policies.

Equal Treatment of All Religions: A secular society treats all religions equally without favoring
or discriminating against any particular religion. This ensures that individuals have the freedom
to practice their faith without state interference.

Freedom of Belief and Expression: Individuals in a secular society have the right to believe,
express, and practice their religious or non-religious beliefs freely, as long as they do not
infringe on the rights of others.
Neutral Public Spaces: Public spaces, institutions, and services (such as schools, hospitals,
and government offices) are free from religious endorsements or practices, maintaining a
neutral environment for all citizens.

Legal and Political Equality: Laws and political decisions are made based on reason, evidence,
and common good rather than religious doctrines (set of beliefs, teachings, and principles that
are held and promoted by a particular religion). This ensures that all citizens are treated
equally under the law, regardless of their religious beliefs.
SECULARISM IN INDIA
Secularism in India is a foundational aspect of its constitutional democracy, embodying the
principle of equal treatment of all religions by the state.

Constitutional Provisions:
The Preamble of the Indian Constitution declares India to be a "secular" nation.
Articles 25 to 28 guarantee the freedom of religion, allowing individuals to profess,
practice, and propagate any religion.
Article 15 prohibits discrimination on the grounds of religion.
Article 25: Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice, and propagation of religion.
Article 26: Freedom to manage religious affairs.
Article 27: Freedom from paying taxes for the promotion of any particular religion.
Article 28: Freedom from attending religious instruction or worship in certain educational
institutions.
Equal Respect for All Religions:
Indian secularism is not about the absence of religion but about equal respect for all
religions.
The state maintains a principled distance from religion, intervening when necessary to
ensure equality and social reform.

Separation of Religion and State:


Indian secularism allows for a more interactive relationship where the state can intervene
in religious matters for social reform and to ensure equality.

Legal Framework:
The Indian legal system includes various personal laws based on different religions,
reflecting India's pluralistic society.
The state ensures that these personal laws adhere to constitutional values of equality and
non-discrimination.
Judicial Interpretation:
The Supreme Court of India has played a crucial role in interpreting and upholding the
secular nature of the state.
Landmark judgments have reiterated that secularism is a basic feature of the Constitution
that cannot be altered.

Challenges and Debates:


Despite constitutional provisions, secularism in India faces challenges such as
communalism, religious intolerance, and politicization of religion.
There are ongoing debates about the extent and nature of state intervention in religious
matters, and the balance between religious freedom and social justice.

Cultural Pluralism:
India's secularism is deeply intertwined with its cultural pluralism, recognizing and
celebrating the diverse religious and cultural practices of its people.
Festivals, religious events, and cultural practices from various religions are celebrated and
respected nationwide.
TYPES OF SECULARISM IN INDIA
1. Political secularism: Political secularism emphasizes the separation of religion from the
institutions of government. It advocates that government should remain neutral in matters of
religion, ensuring that no religion has preferential treatment and that all citizens are treated
equally regardless of their religious beliefs.

Key Features:
State Neutrality: The government does not endorse or promote any particular religion. This
ensures that laws and policies are made based on reason and public interest rather than
religious doctrines.

Religious Freedom: Individuals have the right to practice their religion freely, and the state
protects this freedom while maintaining a distance from religious affairs.

Legal Framework: Secular laws are enacted to govern society, which are applicable to all
citizens regardless of their religious affiliations.
2. Philosophical Secularism: Philosophical secularism is using science and logic to understand the
world around us instead of relying on religious stories. Imagine you want to know why the sky is
blue. A scientific approach would explain it using facts about light and the atmosphere, while a
religious story might give a different kind of explanation. Philosophical secularism prefers the
scientific way of finding answers and believes in making decisions based on what we can see,
test, and understand, rather than just believing in things because they are written in a holy
book.

Key Features
Empiricism and Rationalism: It advocates for understanding the world through observation,
experimentation, and logical reasoning, rather than faith or religious texts.

Humanism: Philosophical secularism often aligns with humanist principles, emphasizing human
dignity, agency, and ethical living without reliance on the supernatural.

Critique of Religion: It may involve a critical examination of religious beliefs and practices,
arguing for secular ethics based on reason and human welfare.
3. Socio-Cultural Secularism: Socio-cultural secularism is about making sure that everyone in
society and culture is treated fairly, no matter what they believe. This means creating a place
where people of all religions, or no religion at all, can feel comfortable and respected without any
favoritism or unfair treatment because of their beliefs. For example, in a school, socio-cultural
secularism would mean celebrating different holidays from various religions or none at all, so
everyone feels included.

Key Features:
Cultural Pluralism: Encourages the coexistence of multiple cultural identities and practices,
recognizing and respecting diverse beliefs and traditions.

Secular Education: Advocates for educational systems that are free from religious influence,
teaching critical thinking and cultural literacy without religious bias.

Public Spaces: Promotes the idea that public life, including ceremonies, rituals, and
celebrations, should be inclusive and secular, welcoming all citizens regardless of their religious
beliefs.
ADVANTAGES OF SECULARISM IN INDIA
Secularism ensures that all religions are treated equally by the state, preventing any one
religion from dominating the political or social landscape.

Citizens have the freedom to practice, propagate, and follow any religion of their choice,
fostering a diverse and pluralistic society.

Secularism strengthens democratic values by ensuring that laws and policies are made based
on reason and public interest rather than religious doctrines.

By promoting religious tolerance and understanding, secularism helps in building social


cohesion and national unity.

Secularism encourages a scientific temper and rational thinking by separating religious dogma
from educational and governmental institutions.
DISADVANTAGES OF SECULARISM IN INDIA
Secularism can sometimes be misinterpreted or misused by political parties for vote-bank
politics, leading to appeasement policies that favor certain religious groups.

Ensuring true secularism in a country with deep religious roots and significant religious
diversity can be challenging.

In a highly religious society, any perceived slight or disregard for religious practices can lead to
social unrest and communal tensions.

If secularism is perceived as being overly critical or dismissive of religious practices, it can


alienate deeply religious individuals and communities.

Secularism might sometimes conflict with cultural traditions that are closely tied to religion,
leading to resistance from those who see such traditions as integral to their identity.
SECULAR VALUES
Secular values refer to principles and ethics that are not based on religious beliefs or doctrines.
These values emphasize the separation of religion from civic affairs and government institutions,
promoting a neutral and inclusive approach to governance and public life.
1. Freedom of Thought and Religion: Ensuring that individuals have the right to hold their own
beliefs and to practice any religion or none at all.
2. Equality and Non-Discrimination: Promoting equal treatment and opportunities for all
individuals, regardless of their religious beliefs.
3. Rationality and Scientific Inquiry: Valuing evidence-based reasoning and scientific methods
as a basis for understanding the world and making decisions.
4. Human Rights and Dignity: Upholding the inherent dignity and rights of all individuals as
fundamental to a just and fair society.
5. Rule of Law: Ensuring that laws are made and enforced without religious influence and apply
equally to all citizens.
6. Tolerance and Pluralism: Encouraging respect and acceptance of diverse beliefs and
lifestyles within society.
THREE SECULAR VALUES
Equality: Ensuring that all citizens are treated equally regardless of their religion. This principle
is enshrined in the Indian Constitution, which guarantees equal rights and protection to all
individuals.

Freedom of Religion: Allowing individuals the right to freely practice, profess, and propagate
their religion. This value upholds the freedom of conscience and the right to religious
expression without fear of discrimination or persecution.

Non-Discrimination: Promoting a society where discrimination on the basis of religion is


prohibited. This includes measures to prevent and address religious intolerance, ensuring that
all communities coexist harmoniously.
HISTORY OF SECULARISM IN THE INDIAN
CONTEXT
Ancient India
1. Vedic Period:
The Vedic period (1500–500 BCE) showed diversity in religious beliefs with the worship of various
deities such as Indra, Agni, and Varuna. The Rigveda, one of the oldest texts, contains hymns that
reflect the polytheistic nature of early Indian society.
2. Buddhism and Jainism:
In the 6th century BCE, Buddhism and Jainism emerged as significant religious movements. Both
religions preached non-violence, tolerance, and coexistence with other religions. The teachings of
Buddha and Mahavira emphasized ethical living and spiritual development, often in contrast to the
Vedic rituals.
3. Mauryan Empire:
Emperor Ashoka (268–232 BCE) promoted Buddhism but respected other religions. His edicts
emphasized moral and ethical conduct, religious tolerance, and the welfare of his subjects.
Ashoka's support for Buddhism did not undermine the practice of other religions.
Medieval India

1. Gupta Empire:
The Gupta Empire (4th to 6th centuries CE) is known for its Hindu cultural revival, yet it was marked
by religious tolerance. Various religious practices, including Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism,
coexisted.

2. Islamic Influence:
The arrival of Islam in the 8th century and the establishment of the Delhi Sultanate (13th century)
introduced new dimensions of religious diversity. Although there were instances of conflict, many
rulers like Akbar (1556–1605) of the Mughal Empire promoted religious tolerance.
Akbar's policy of Sulh-e-Kul (universal peace) and the creation of a syncretic religion, Din-i Ilahi,
were efforts to foster unity among his diverse subjects.
Colonial Period

1. British Rule:
British colonial rule (1858–1947) brought about significant changes. The British adopted a policy
of religious neutrality and non-interference in religious matters to maintain peace among
various religious communities. However, the policy of 'divide and rule' also created divisions
between religious communities, particularly Hindus and Muslims.

2. Freedom Struggle:
Leaders like Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru emphasized secularism and religious
harmony. Gandhi's concept of Sarva Dharma Sambhava (equal respect for all religions) and
Nehru's vision of a secular state influenced India's struggle for independence. The Indian
National Congress promoted a vision of a united, secular India.
Post-Independence

1. Constitution of India:
The Indian Constitution, adopted in 1950, enshrines secularism as a core principle. The
Preamble declares India to be a secular state. Articles 25 to 28 guarantee freedom of religion,
allowing individuals to practice, profess, and propagate their religion. The state does not favor
any religion and treats all religions equally.

2. Key Constitutional Provisions:


Article 25: Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice, and propagation of religion.
Article 26: Freedom to manage religious affairs.
Article 27: Freedom from paying taxes for the promotion of any particular religion.
Article 28: Freedom from attending religious instruction or worship in certain educational
institutions.
Examples:
Uniform Civil Code Debate: The debate over a uniform civil code versus personal laws for
different religions highlights the tension between secularism and religious freedom. While
the state advocates for a uniform set of laws applicable to all citizens, religious
communities often prefer their traditional laws.

Ayodhya Dispute: The dispute over the Babri Masjid-Ram Janmabhoomi site has been a
significant challenge to India's secular fabric. The 1992 demolition of the Babri Masjid led to
widespread communal riots, and the subsequent legal battle tested India's commitment to
secularism. The 2019 Supreme Court verdict aimed to resolve the issue by allocating land
for a temple and providing an alternative site for the mosque.

Minority Rights: India has taken steps to protect the rights of religious minorities.
Institutions like the National Commission for Minorities work to safeguard minority interests.
The government also provides educational and cultural grants to minority communities.
Challenges
1. Religious Polarization:
India faces challenges of religious polarization and communal violence. Political parties
often use religion to garner votes, leading to increased tensions. Incidents of religious
intolerance, hate speech, and mob violence have tested India's secular ethos.
2. Judicial Interventions:
The judiciary plays a crucial role in upholding secularism. Landmark judgments have
addressed issues like the ban on triple talaq (instant divorce) in the Muslim community and
the Sabarimala temple entry for women of menstruating age, reflecting the balance
between religious practices and constitutional principles.
3. Educational and Cultural Initiatives:
Efforts to promote secularism include educational curricula that emphasize India's
pluralistic heritage and cultural programs that celebrate the country's diverse traditions.
Festivals, interfaith dialogues, and community initiatives foster mutual respect and
understanding.
INDIAN VS WESTERN SECULARISM
DISASSOCIATION OF STATE FROM RELIGION
Understanding State and Religion
State: The state is the government or the governing body that makes laws and rules for a
country.
Religion: Religion is a set of beliefs about God or gods, often involving rituals and moral codes.

Why Should Religion and State Be Separate?


When the state (government) and religion are closely linked, it can create problems. For example,
people of different religions might feel unfairly treated if the government favors one religion over
others. Keeping them separate helps ensure that everyone is treated equally, regardless of their
religious beliefs.
The Relationship Between Religion and State
1. State Religion System: Some countries have an official state religion. This means the
government supports and promotes a specific religion, which can lead to unequal
treatment of people who follow other religions.
2. Separation of Religion and State: This idea means that the government doesn't favor
any religion. It treats all religious beliefs equally and ensures that laws are made based
on fairness and equality for everyone.

Importance of Separating Religion from State


1. Fairness: Everyone is treated equally, no matter what they believe.
2. Freedom: People are free to follow any religion or no religion at all.
3. Peace: It helps prevent conflicts between different religious groups.
4. Focus on Common Good: Laws and decisions are made for the benefit of all people,
not just those of a specific religion.
Five Models of State and Religion

1. Atheism: In this model, the state promotes the idea that there is no God. Religion is not supported by the
government. Example: In North Korea, Religious activities are tightly controlled, and open worship is rare.
2. Theocracy: The government is run by religious leaders and follows religious laws. Example: In Iran, country's
laws are heavily based on Islamic principles.
3. State Church: The government supports a specific religion, but people are free to follow other religions.
Example: England, The Church of England is the official state church, with the monarch serving as its
Supreme Governor. While the Church of England has special status, people in the UK are free to follow any
religion or none at all.
4. Multiculturalism: The state supports multiple religions equally and promotes diversity. Example: Canada
promotes multiculturalism and provides support for various religious communities. The government
ensures that people of different faiths can practice their religion freely and equally, celebrating the
country's diverse cultural and religious landscape.
5. Secularism: The government does not support or promote any religion. It treats all religions equally and
keeps religion separate from government affairs. Example: France follows a principle called "laïcité," which
ensures the separation of religion from state affairs. This means that religious symbols and practices are
not allowed in public institutions like schools and government buildings, and the government does not fund
or promote any religion.
Problems with a State Religion

1. Unfair Treatment: People who follow other religions might feel left out or discriminated
against.
2. Conflict: Favoring one religion can lead to tension and conflict between different
religious groups.
3. Limited Freedom: People may feel pressured to follow the state religion even if they
don’t believe in it.
4. Biased Laws: Laws might be made to favor the state religion, which can be unfair to
people of other faiths.
ACCEPTANCE OF ALL FAITHS

Historical Context

India has a rich history of religious diversity and acceptance of various faiths. The Indian
subcontinent is the birthplace of major world religions such as Hinduism, Buddhism,
Jainism, and Sikhism. Additionally, it has welcomed and integrated a myriad of other
religions including Islam, Christianity, Zoroastrianism, and Judaism. The historical
acceptance of all faiths in India can be traced back to ancient texts and the philosophies
of Indian rulers and sages who promoted the idea of religious harmony and coexistence.
Concept of Acceptance of Faiths

The concept of acceptance of faiths in India is deeply rooted in the idea of "Sarva Dharma Sambhava"
which translates to "equal respect for all religion". This principle advocates that all religions lead to the
same truth and deserve equal respect and recognition. This ethos is reflected in various aspects of
Indian culture and society:
1. Philosophical Foundations: Indian philosophy, particularly Vedanta, promotes the idea of unity in
diversity. The Upanishads, which form the core of Vedantic thought, emphasize the oneness of the
divine and the plurality of paths to reach it.
2. Historical Figures: Leaders like Mahatma Gandhi and Swami Vivekananda championed religious
tolerance and acceptance. Gandhi’s principle of Ahimsa (non-violence) was grounded in respect
for all faiths, and Vivekananda's speech at the Parliament of the World's Religions in Chicago
emphasized the unity of all religions.
3. Legal Framework: The Indian Constitution guarantees freedom of religion under Article 25, which
allows individuals to practice, profess, and propagate any religion of their choice. The state
maintains a stance of secularism, which means it does not favor any religion and treats all religions
equally.
Contemporary Usage (How the acceptance of all faiths is practiced and manifested in
present day India)

In contemporary India, the acceptance of all faiths manifests in various ways:

1. Religious Festivals: India celebrates a multitude of religious festivals from different faiths.
National holidays include Diwali (Hindu), Eid (Islamic), Christmas (Christian), and Gurpurab
(Sikh), showcasing the acceptance and celebration of diverse religious traditions.
2. Interfaith Marriages: Although challenging, interfaith marriages are becoming more common,
reflecting an increasing acceptance of different religious backgrounds.
3. Educational Institutions: Schools and universities often include teachings about various
religions to promote understanding and tolerance among students of different faiths.
4. Legal Protections: The judiciary often steps in to protect the rights of religious minorities and
uphold the secular nature of the state. For instance, the Supreme Court has ruled against laws
and actions that infringe upon religious freedom.
5. Media and Literature: Contemporary Indian media and literature often explore themes of
religious harmony and acceptance, reflecting society’s ongoing dialogue about the importance
of religious tolerance.
Challenges and Future Prospects

While India has a strong tradition of religious acceptance, it also faces challenges:

1. Communal Tensions: Periodic outbreaks of communal violence remind us of the underlying


tensions between different religious communities.
2. Political Exploitation: Sometimes, political entities exploit religious sentiments for electoral
gains, leading to polarization and conflict.
3. Social Discrimination: Certain religious minorities still face social discrimination and
marginalization.
ENCOURAGING NON-DISCRIMINATORY
PRACTICES
Non-discriminatory practices refer to actions and policies that ensure fair and equal
treatment of individuals, irrespective of their inherent or chosen characteristics. These
practices are essential in creating an inclusive society where every individual has the
opportunity to thrive without facing bias or prejudice.

Meaning of Non-Discrimination
Non-discrimination means treating individuals equally and fairly without prejudiced
distinction based on characteristics such as race, caste, religion, gender, sexual orientation,
disability, or age. It involves providing equal opportunities and ensuring that no one is
excluded or disadvantaged because of their identity or beliefs.
Need for Considering Non-Discrimination
1. Equality and Justice: Ensures that every individual is treated equally and fairly.
2. Social Harmony: Promotes a cohesive society by reducing tensions and conflicts
arising from discrimination.
3. Economic Growth: By providing equal opportunities, it harnesses the full potential of
the workforce, leading to overall economic development.
4. Human Rights: Upholds the fundamental human rights as enshrined in various
international conventions and national constitutions.
5. Moral and Ethical Responsibility: Aligns with the moral duty to respect and value all
individuals.
Principles of Non-Discrimination
1. Equality: Equal treatment and opportunities for all.
2. Respect for Diversity: Valuing and respecting differences.
3. Fairness: Just and impartial treatment.
4. Inclusion: Ensuring all individuals can participate fully in societal activities.
5. Protection: Safeguarding individuals from any form of discriminatory practices.
Scope of Non-Discrimination
1. Indirect Discrimination: Practices or policies that appear neutral but
disproportionately affect certain groups.
2. Prohibited Grounds for Discrimination: Includes race, caste, religion, gender, sexual
orientation, disability, age, and others as recognized by law.
3. Legal Recognition: National laws and international conventions that prohibit
discrimination and promote equality.
4. Complaints and Redress: Mechanisms for individuals to report and seek redress for
discriminatory practices.
5. Other Conduct: Ensuring non-discrimination in areas like employment, education,
healthcare, and public services.
6. Exemptions: Specific circumstances where differential treatment is permissible, such
as affirmative action.
7. Special Measures: Positive actions to correct historical disadvantages faced by
marginalized groups.
Limitations of Non-Discrimination

1. Socio-Cultural Barriers: Deep-rooted societal norms and prejudices that persist


despite legal prohibitions.
2. Implementation Gaps: Challenges in effectively enforcing anti-discrimination laws
due to lack of awareness, resources, and institutional support.
3. Economic Disparities: Economic inequalities can exacerbate discriminatory
practices and limit the effectiveness of non-discrimination policies.
4. Intersectionality: Overlapping and intersecting forms of discrimination, such as
caste and gender, which complicate redress mechanisms.
5. Regional Variations: Differences in the implementation and enforcement of non-
discrimination laws across various states and regions in India.
6. Political Will: Varying levels of commitment from political leadership to prioritize
and address discrimination issues.

You might also like