Week 2 CRYSTALLOGRAPHY AND RIETVELD REFINEMENT
Week 2 CRYSTALLOGRAPHY AND RIETVELD REFINEMENT
Symmetry Operations
Both have 3!
So notation is 3m
• Rotation (A)- rotational symmetry involves repeating
a motif by a set of uniform rotations around an axis.
(symmetry about an axis)
– Repeating the pattern every 120° of rotation means 3-fold
symmetry.
– Every 60° = 6-fold symmetry
– Denoted as #Ax where x=x fold rotational symmetry
m 3Ā3
• The 32 crystal classes represent the 32
possible combinations of symmetry
operations.
• Each crystal class will have crystal faces that
uniquely define the symmetry of the class.
• These faces, or groups of faces are called
crystal forms.
• Note that the 32 crystal classes are divided
into 6 crystal systems.
• The Triclinic System has only 1-fold or 1-fold
rotoinversion axes.
• The Monoclinic System has only mirror
plane(s) or a single 2-fold axis.
• The Orthorhombic System has only two fold
axes or a 2-fold axis and 2 mirror planes.
• The Tetragonal System has either a single 4-
fold or 4-fold rotoinversion axis.
• The Hexagonal System has no 4-fold axes, but
has at least 1 6-fold or 3-fold axis.
• The Isometric System has either 4 3-fold axes
or 4 3-fold rotoinversion axes.
Symmetry Operation Symmetry Symbol Hermann-Mauguin Symbol
Mirror m m
- - - - -
Rotoinversion Ā1=i, Ā2,Ā3,Ā4,Ā6 1,2,3,4,6
Axis
Lattice Notation
• Origin chosen as 000
• Axis directions a, b, c
and unit measurements
defined by particular
crystal system
• Axes are shown with
brackets, i.e., [001]
• Lattice points are
defined in 3-dimesions
as units along the axes,
without brackets (i.e.,
111, 101, 021, etc.)
Complexity of
calculations is
dependent on
the symmetry
of the crystal
system.
Lattices and Crystal Systems
There are 5 possible planar (2-d) lattices in the different
coordinate systems:
Orthorhombic P
C (or A, B) abc mmm
I = = = 90
F
Tetragonal P a1 = a2 c 4/mmm
I = = = 90
Hexagonal R a1 = a2 c m
P = = 90, = 120 6/mmm
Cubic P a1 = a2 = a3
I = = = 90 m3m
F
25
Fraction
26
27
Detector
X-ray
tube
w q 2q
2q 2q 2q
n = 2d sinq
XRD Pattern for NaCl
33
Learning outcomes
• Students shall be able to model and quantify
phases in the XRD pattern using the Rietveld
method - lab
• Students shall able determine and understand
each of the refinement parameters.
• Students shall be able to recognize factors that
effect the intensity and positions of peaks.
• Students shall be able to calculate the crystallite
size and measure the amorphous content.
• Student shall understand and able to interpret
the XRD pattern.
34
Overview on the Diffraction Pattern
• Diffraction pattern
– Peak position
– Intensity
– Background
– Peak profile
35
36
37
Single Peak
Summary
A peak may be described by the following peak
parameters:
• background (if yid(2q) instead of ybragg(2q) is
used),
• position,
• intensity,
• line width,
• shape factor and,
• asymmetry.
38
Background
• Why we have background?
– Due to
• scattering by air,
• detector noise
• fluorescence radiation,
• diffuse scattering (TDS) or
• long tails of neighbouring peaks the measured
intensity will show not only coherently scattered
intensity (the Bragg peak itself) ybragg(2q) (light
green),
• background radiation yb(2q) (green).
• Unknown radiation
– Background radiation is often estimated to be linear
within the actual region of interest.
39
Principles
Crystal and Unit Cell
• An ideal crystal is formed by unit cells
of the same size consisting of atoms
arranged in an identical manner.
40
Principles
Another view on the Bragg´s law
n = 2d sinq
41
Principles
Reflection planes in a cubic lattice
42
Direction in a crystal
43
Direction in a crystal
44
Fraction
45
Principles
Miller’s indices and Pattern
46
TiN and NaCl
47
a=b=c=5.62A
atom x y z
Na/K 0 0 0
Cl 0.5 0.5 0.5
a=b=c=6.309A
48
KCl
a=b=c=6.309A
In the NaCl trace, the (111) peak is clearly
visible. In the KCl trace, the same reflection is
effectively absent.
NaCl
a=b=c=5.62A
49
NaCl a=b=c=5.62A
No of electrons determines the intensity
Heavier atoms scatter more effectively
NaBr
a=b=c=6.0A
50
51
Principles
Relationship between d-value and the lattice constants
52
Overview
• Space group (symmetry group of a conf in space)
and lattice parameter determine the position
peak in 2 theta region.
• Position of atom, type of atom, its occupancy
determine its intensity ratio.
• Concentration of unit cell in the sample
determine its scale factor.
• Peak shape – instrumental broadening, particle
size
• Background – air scattering, amorphos /
disordered structure/ temperature factor
53
Methods
What information contains a Powder Diagram?
54
Methods
Powder Diagram and Structure
• The d-spacings of lattice planes depend on the size of the elementary cell which determine
the position of the peaks.
• The intensity of each peak is caused by the crystallographic structure, the position of the
atoms within the elementary cell and their thermal vibration.
• The line width and shape of the peaks may be derived from conditions of measuring and
properties - like particle size - of the sample material.
55
Basic principles of Rietveld
method
56
Rietveld method-Introduction
• The Rietveld method was developed by Hugo
M. Rietveld 1967/1969.
57
Rietveld Method-Purpose
• Structure refinement
– (lattice change/distortion, position of atoms ,
occupancy, thermal parameter, crystal density,
volume)
• Quantitative phase analysis
– (Amount of phase, crystallite size, lattice strain,
amorphous content)
58
Rietveld method-Basic principle
• Modeled the profile pattern (calculated
pattern) Using crystal structure of all phase
present -– obtained quantitative result
(phase wt%, crystallite size, lattice strain)
59
Basic principle
• Fitting the whole profile pattern
– Fitting the background
– Scale factor
– Peak shape
• Correction
– Shift or displacement of peak
– Intensity
– Preferred orientation
60
Rietveld method-The model
The starting model consists of:
– structure parameters: (describe the
crystallographic parameters)
– global parameters: (affect the entire pattern,
regardless of phase(s))
– profile parameters: (describe the width and shape
of diffracted peaks)
– miscellaneous parameters: (affect the intensity of
a phase)
61
General requirement
• Sample preparation
• Data collection (high quality)
• Phase identification (Qualitative analysis)
• Crystal structure data
• Model the diffraction pattern (instrument,
sample, peak profile, background, preferred
orientation, correction)
62
Preparing a powder specimen
• An ideal powder sample should have many crystallites in random
orientations
– the distribution of orientations should be smooth and equally distributed
amongst all orientations
• If the crystallites in a sample are very large, there will not be a smooth
distribution of crystal orientations. You will not get a powder average
diffraction pattern.
– Particle size should be < 10mm in size to get good powder statistics
• Large crystallite sizes and non-random crystallite orientations both lead to
peak intensity variation
– the measured diffraction pattern will not agree with that expected from an
ideal powder
– the measured diffraction pattern will not agree with reference patterns in the
Powder Diffraction File (PDF) database
63
Preferred orientation
• If the crystallites in a powder sample have plate
or needle like shapes it can be very difficult to get
them to adopt random orientations
– top-loading, where you press the powder into a
holder, can cause problems with preferred orientation
• In samples such as metal sheets or wires there is
almost always preferred orientation due to the
manufacturing process
• For samples with systematic orientation, XRD can
be used to quantify the texture in the specimen
64
Data collection strategy
65
Rietveld method-Data collection
• Scan time – (minimum intensity > 10,000 counts on the highest
peak
• Counting errors are related to the square root of the intensity. If u
have 10,000 counts, then the error is 100 (1% as percentage error)
• ∆2θ < + 0.02o (for indexing)
• ICDD PDF: a pattern is considered to be a high quality pattern if
differences between measured and theoretical peak positions: Δ2θ
≤ ±0.04o
• Fixed Divergence slit
• Infinitively thick sample for reflection geometry
• To compare- measure all scans with the same optics, instrument
condition and treats all scans in the same way. E.g the step time,
step size, divergence slit, sample length,
66
Accuracy and precision of the
measurement
67
Phase identification
• All phase although minor phase should be accurately
identified.
68
Rietveld method requires –Correction
on shifted of diffraction pattern
• Zero shift (possible error that come from
instrument allignment)
69
Rietveld method requires - crystal
structure data
• Lattice parameter
• Space group
• Position of atoms in (x, y, z direction)
• Occupancy
• Temperature factor
70
Lattice parameter
• It is important not to let the cell dimensions
change too much from their original starting
value. This may happen in cases when the phase
is quite low in abundance or when there is
particularly high peak overlap.
• The shape and the size of the electron cloud has an effect on
our diffraction pattern.
77
Temperature factor/displacement factor
78
Background determination
• To distinguished between peak intensity and
background intensity
• Background intensity – air scattering,
flourescense, amorphous etc
79
80
Fluoresced X-rays
• The increased background noise from fluoresced X-rays can
be removed by using:
– a diffracted-beam monochromator
– an energy sensitive detector
81
Refine the background
• Polynomial
• Chebychev
• Shifted Chebyshev
• Amorphous sinc funtion
• Damped amorphous sinc fuction
• Available background
82
Rietveld method- Model the peak
Profile
• Peak profile parameter
– Peak shape
– Peak width
– Peak asymmetry
83
Refinement parameter-Peak shape
function
• Pseodo voight
• Pearson
• Voight and Pseodo voight 3
• Gaussion and Lorentzian
84
Peak shape function-Gaussion
• Broad tip and short tail
85
Peak shape function-Lorentzian
• Narrow peak tip and has quite long tales
86
Refinement parameter - Peak width
• Must also be accurately match.
• Peak width parameter: u, V, W
• Full Width at Half Maximum
• It depends on θ
• Cagliotti function
– H2=U tan 2θ + V tanθ + W
• Often sufficient just to refine W
87
Peak width resolution
88
Refinement parameter-peak width
• FWHM are not consistent across the measurement range.
90
Miscellaneous parameters
• Scale factor
• Preferred orientation
91
Scale factor
•The scale factor is a number that adjusts the overall
intensity of all peaks of a phase.
92
Preferred Orientation
• General assumption in powder diffraction that the particles are randomly
orientated.
• If the particles are not randomly orientated, we will measure more crystal
than average for certain crystal planes. Consequently, we will see some peaks
that are more intense than expected.
93
Preferred Orientation
• Results from crystallites lining up.
94
Preferred Orientation
• Can be refined when necessary.
• Corrected using March Dollas function.
• Each reflection is corrected for intensity
according to the angle α between the plane of
the reflection and the main direction of the
preferred orientation.
• The preferred orientation direction should be
selected by the user.
95
Microabsorption
• Arise when a sample contain phases that have
differences in linear absorption coefficients, μ
96
Microabsorption
• If we have 2 phases, “a” and “b” and μa >> μb or
particles of “a” much larger than particles b, the
diffracted intensity of “a” crystal will be much less than
the calculated intensity.
97
Absorption due to surface roughness
• When the surface is rough, some particles are exposed
directly to full X-ray beam, while other are exposed to
the X-ray beam after some absorption has taken place.
101
The classical Rietveld Method
102
Structure Factor
• The structure factor is a means of grouping the atoms in the unit cell
into planar elements, developing the diffraction intensities from each
of those elements and integrating the results into the total diffraction
intensity from each dhkl plane in the structure.
F (hkl ) ( f N , N )
N
Where F(hkl) is the structure factor for the hkl reflection of the unit cell,
f is the atomic scattering factor for each of N atomic planes and
is the repeat distance between atomic planes measured from a common
origin (called the phase factor)
103
Multiplicity of Bragg Planes
• The number of identically spaced plane cutting a unit cell in a
particular hkl family is call the multiplicity factor.
104
ATOMIC SCATTERING FACTOR AND
DEBYE-WALLER
105
THE CLASSICAL RIETVELD METHOD
106
THE CLASSICAL RIETVELD METHOD
107
THE CLASSICAL RIETVELD METHOD
108
THE CLASSICAL RIETVELD METHOD
109
QUALITY OF THE REFINEMENT
110
The R indices
111
WSS AND GOFF (OR SIGMA)
112
RIETVELD PROCEDURE
113
STARTING POINT: DEFINING THE
PHASES
114
ADJUSTING MANUALLY: CELL
PARAMETERS, INTENSITIES
115
STEP 1: REFINING SCALE FACTORS AND
BACKGROUND
116
STEP 2: PEAKS POSITIONS
117
STEP 3: PEAKS SHAPES
118
STEP 4: CRYSTAL STRUCTURE
REFINEMENT
119
Instrument
120
HIGH RESOLUTION INSTRUMENTS
121
LOW RESOLUTION INSTRUMENTS
122
Instrument assessment
123
The step size
124
Sample characteristics (1)
125
Atomic scattering factor
• Scattering of X-rays mainly caused by the electrons.
• Ions, which have more or less electrons in the valence orbitals, have
different atomic scattering factors compared with neutral atoms,
which is significant especially at small scattering angles.
• The X-ray scattering power of an atom decreases with increasing
scattering angle and is higher for heavier atoms.
• The atomic scattering factor for the jth atom is the atomic
scattering factor for the jth point atom multiplied by an exponential
function of the atomic temperature factor:
where:
– fj is the atomic scattering factor for the jth atom
– f0j is the atomic scattering factor for the jth atom at rest
– B is the atomic temperature factor
126
Temperature factor
sin 2 q k
B j
Fk N j f j e 2
e i k
j
B 8 u
2 2
Anisotropic parametrisations also exist.
127
A good fit refinement
A correct (quantitative result)
128
Refinement parameter
• The number of refinables nmax depends on the
model used.
129
Peak Profile
• The width of the divergence slit (primary beam)
and detector slit (secondary beam) also cause
broadening.
130
Rietveld method- General Procedure
• Phase identification
• Obtain crystal structure data
– Directly insert if available
– Find from free online structure data base and fed into TOPAS and
develop the ‘str. file’
• Define Global Parameter
– Emission profile
– Background
– Insert instrument set up during XRD measurement.
• Sample length, Gonoimeter radius……….
– Correction : surface roughness, micro-absorbtion, polarization.
– Refine the background, zero shift, lattice parameter,
• Scale factor
• Correct the intensity – preferred orientation,
• Refine the atomic position, temperature factor and occupancy
• Observe the refinement result.
131
How good is the model
- Agreement indices
To judge the quality of refinement
Goodness of fit
132
Crystallite size
• Crystallite size determination is one of the
most important applications in powder
diffractometry for materials characterisation.
133
Basic principle of crystallite measurement
• Therefore to calculate Bc, the instrument broadening, Bi must be
known. It must be measured using a reliable standard with very
good quality of data (30,000 counts)
• After subtraction the instrument broadening,
→ BR=Bc + Bs
• Substitution the equations:
k
BR tan q
L cos q
k
BR cos q sin q
L
137
Size Broadening
• SCHERRER (1918) first observed the crystallite
size could give rise to line broadening.
• Scherrer formula
138
Lattice Strain (Microstrain)
• Strain is defined as the deformation of an object divided by
it’s ideal length, d/d
• 2 types of strain: uniform strain and Non-uniform strain.
• Uniform strain causes the unit cell to expand/contract in an
isotropic way. This simply leads to a change in a unit cell
parameters and shift of the peaks (No broadening
associated with this type of strain.
• Non-uniform strain leads to systematic shift of atoms from
their ideal positions and to peak broadening. This type of
strain arises from the following sources: point defect,
plastic deformation and poor crystallinity
139
Strain Broadening
140
William-Hall Analysis
Simplified Integral Breadth Methods
141
Methods used in Jade to Define Peak
Width
• Full Width at Half Maximum (FWHM)
FWHM
– the width of the diffraction peak,
in radians, at a height half-way
Intensity (a.u.)
between background and the
peak maximum
• Integral Breadth
46.746.846.947.047.147.247.347.447.547.647.747.847.9
– the total area under the peak 2q(deg.)
background 143
Integral Breadth
2q
L cos q
• Warren suggests that the Stokes and Wilson method of using
integral breadths gives an evaluation that is independent of
the distribution in size and shape
– L is a volume average of the crystal thickness in the
direction normal to the reflecting planes
– The Scherrer constant K can be assumed to be 1
K
B2q
Intensity (a.u.)
L cos q
23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41
2q (deg.)
Size/Strain Analysis
• The analysis of crystallite size and/or micro strain by the Rietveld
method is based on the change of the profile parameters, compared
to a standard sample.
• The profile parameters are, of course, depending on the instrument
settings used for data collection and on the profile function used for
the refinement.
Size-strain standard:
• The first thing is to measure a size-strain standard. This should be a
material with no micro strain and no size broadening. Often the NIST
SRM674 CeO2 is used for this purpose. It has a very limited amount of
size broadening, which does not substantially influence the results.
• You need a high quality scan up to at least 140 degrees 2θ, performed
with optics tuned for resolution. 148
Refinement The Profile Function
• Open the file CEO2-NBS.RD from the tutorial
folder. Insert the structure of cerianite (the
mineral name of cerium oxide) from the
Standard.CRY structures file from the tutorial
folder.
• Now start an automatic Rietveld refinement
using the parameter set Size-Strain Analysis.
149
• Select the cerianite phase node and click on Take as
Size-Strain Standard. This copies the refined profile
and shape parameters from the phase to the
standard values of the global parameters section.
150
The results obtained
The global agreement indices:
• R expected = 5.04721
• R profile = 12.46318
• Weighted R profile = 17.41862
• D-statistics = 0.37421
• Weighted D-statistics = 0.36507
• Goodness of Fit = 11.91036
151
Measurement of size and strain
• Start a Rietveld refinement with the Size-Strain
Analysis parameter set.
• Observe the quality of the fit and note the
calculated values for size and strain.
• Change the phase analysis mode to size only and
re-start the refinement. Note the crystallite size
result.
• Change the phase analysis mode to strain only
and re-start the refinement. Note the micro strain
result
152
Crystallite size and
strain measurement
CEO2-NBS.RD, CAF2-RAW.RD.CAF2-
PseudoVoigtStandar 400.RD, CAF2-500.RD
d.HPF ,Standard.CRY CAF2-600.R
153
Results
154
AMORPHOUS MEASUREMENT
• Degree of crystallinity calculations require the
definition of at least two phases in order to
describe the intensity contributions coming from
the crystalline and the amorphous parts of the
sample.
Examples
• Sample A, sample B, sample C, sample D
• Cryst.50.RD – constant background /intensity
ratio method
155
Amorphous
content
Intensity ratio
Spiking method
method
Sample A, Sample
Cryst50+.RD Standard.CRY B, Sample C,
Sample D
156
Basic principle
• Same chemistry
– No need to involve internal and external standard
– Measurements are performed under identical
condition (don’t change instrument setting)
157
Degree of crystalinity
• Determine the background using automatic
mode
• Separate the crystalline peaks from the
amorphous hump and the background
• It is better to calibrate using the known value
with the same instrument setting, and enter
the calibration value for the constant
background before the measurement.
158
Crystallinity Algorithm
• Amorphous substance- Amorphous hump
159
Crystallinity Determination
• Used standard sample – crystalline: amorphous 1:1
(amorphous 50%)
• Determine the background. Choose the background.
• Select the scan and double click to open object
inspector pane. Open scan statistic node
• Enter a value into the constant background replacing -
1.
• Change constant b/g until you get 50% crystallinity.
• Load cryst10.RD. Repeat b/g determination and enter
calibration value of const b/g
160
161
Intensity ratio method
• Sample A – 100% crystalline
• Sample B- 100% amorphous
• Insert sample D-take as new anchor scan data
• Start autoscale-using default parameter
• Watch the sum profile and the difference plot
in Analyze view
• The autoscale values is displayed in the
Analyze view.
162
The solutions:
163
Measurement of amorphous phase
by spiking method using Rietveld
164
Objective
• To determine the amorphous content of a
sample with Rietveld refinement by addition
of crystalline standard phase.
• Important when amorphous and multiphases
with different linear attenuation coefficient
exist in the sample.
• Small amount of standard e.g alumina, rutile
or silicon was used and mixed with the sample
165
Spiking method-Cryst.50+.RD
• The true weight percentage of Quartz in this ample is 50%. The other
50% is made up of completely amorphous Quartz glass. (For a more
accurate result you need to calibrate the Rietveld analysis by tuning
the Boverall parameter of the standard phase.)
166