Chapter 10
Chapter 10
10.1. Dozers
A tractor equipped with a front-mounted earthmoving blade is known as dozer or bulldozer. A dozer
moves earth by lowering the blade and cutting until a full blade load of material is obtained. It then pushes
the material across the ground surface to the required location. The material is unloaded by pushing it over
a cliff or into a hopper or by raising the blasé to form spoil pile.
Because of their excellent traction and low ground pressure (typically 41 to 62 kPa), crawler dozers
are well suited for use in rough terrain or areas of low trafficability. Crawler dozers can operate on steeper
side slopes and climb greater grades than can wheel dozers.
Wheel dozers, on the other hand, operate at higher speed than do crawler dozers. Wheel dozers are
also capable of operating on paved roads without damaging the surface. While the wheel tractor’s dozing
ability is limited somewhat by its lower traction and high ground pressure (172 to 241 kPa), its high ground
pressure makes it an effective soil compactor.
Either rubber-tired or crawler tractors may be equipped with attachments other than dozer blades.
These includes rakes used for gathering up brush and small fallen trees and plows, rippers and scarifiers
which are used to break up hard surfaces. Tractors are also used to tow construction equipment such as
compactors, scrapers, and wagons.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 72
Dozer-type utilization comparison.
Wheel dozer Crawler dozer
Good on firm soils and concrete and abrasive soils Can work on a variety of soils; sharp-edged pieces
that have no sharp-edged pieces not as destructive to dozer, though fine sand will
increase running gear wear.
Best for level and downhill work, wet weather Can work over almost any terrain.
causing soft and slick surface conditions will slow or Can work of soft ground and over mud-slick
stop operation. surfaces; will exert very low ground pressures with
special low ground pressure undercarriage and
track configuration.
The concentrated wheel load will provide
compaction and kneading action to ground surface.
Good for long travel distances Good for short work distances
Best in handling loose soils Can handle tight soils
Fast return speeds (8 – 26 mph) Slow return speeds (5 – 10 mph)
Can handle only moderate blade loads Can push large blade loads
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 73
Angling
Angling the blade is helpful when side-hill cutting, ditching, and moving material laterally.
Note:
All blades may be tilted except the cushion blade.
Only the angle blade maybe angled
Estimating the volume of earth that can be moved by the dozer during each operating cycle
Estimating the number of operating cycles that can be completed during an operating hour
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 74
blade load (LCM) = 0.375WHL Where:
W = load widths
productivity
load volume operational efficiency W W2
1
2
cycle time
H = load heights
H1 H 2
2
Note:
Total dozer cycle time is the sum of its fixed cycle time (time required to maneuver, change gears,
start loading, and dump) and variable cycle time (haul time and the time required to doze and return)
The haul time and the travel time are determined by dividing the haul distance by the dozer speed.
10.7. Loaders
A tractor equipped with a front-end bucket is called a loader, front-end loader, or bucket loader.
Loaders are used for excavating soft to medium-hard material, loading hoppers and haul units, stockpiling
material, backfilling ditches, and moving concrete and other construction materials.
Wheel loaders possess excellent job mobility and are capable of over-the-road movement between
jobs at speeds of 40.23 kph or higher. While their ground pressure is relatively low, however, they do not
have the all-terrain capability of track loaders.
Track loaders are capable of overcoming steeper grades and side slopes than are wheel loaders.
Their low ground pressure and high tractive effort enable them to operate in all but the lowest trafficability
soils. However, because of their lower speed, their production is less than that of wheel loader over longer
haul distances.
Attachments available for the loader include augers, backhoes, cranes boom, dozer and snow blades,
and forklifts in addition to conventional loader bucket. Backhoe loader is a combination of backhoe and
loader.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 76
10.8. Estimating Loader Production
Loader production may be estimated as the average of bucket load multiplied by cycles per hour
(equation given Chapter 5, section 5.2). Basic cycle time for a loader includes the time required for loading,
dumping, making four reversals of direction, and traveling a minimum distance. Loader bucket capacity is
rated in heaped (loose) volume. Bucket capacity should be adjusted by a bucket fill factor to obtain the best
estimate of actual bucket volume.
productivity
bucket capacity operational efficiency
cycle time
The operating load for a loader is the maximum load (weight) the loader can safely carry. Industry
standards (SAE Standard J818) limit the maximum safe load to:
The static tipping load is the minimum weight placed in the loader bucket that causes the front rollers
of a tracked loader to clear the tracks or the rear wheels of a wheeled loader to clear the ground.
Loader capacity, therefore, is limited by both a volume and a weight constraint. Volume generally
governs, but the weight criteria may govern when loading dense material.
Loader productivity is influenced by the following factors:
Type of material being loaded
Bucket capacity
Maneuver area for loader operation
Cycle time of loader
Operational efficiency
Loader productivity is estimated by:
Estimating the volume of material that can be moved by the loader during each operating cycle
Estimating the number of operating cycles that can be completed during an operating hour
While manufacturers’ performance curves should be used whenever possible, typical travel-time
curves for wheel loaders are presented in the figure below.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 77
Basic loader cycle time
Basic Cycle Time (min)
Loading Conditions
Articulated Wheel Loader Track Loader
Loose materials 0.35 0.30
Average materials 0.50 0.35
Hard materials 0.65 0.45
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 78
10.11. Scrapers
Scrapers are designed to load, haul, and dump loose material. The greatest advantage is their
versatility. They can be used for a wide variety of material types and are economical for a range of haul
distances and conditions.
Note:
a) Elevating scrapers should be considered if the haul distances are short and haul road conditions
are good.
b) If the material to be removed contains rocks that are too large to load by the elevator, conventional
scrapers or auger scrapers should be used.
c) If the haul road has high rolling resistance or steep grades, twin-engine scrapers should be
considered. Otherwise, single-engine scrapers usually are the most economical to use.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 80
Scraper fixed time (min)
Spot Time
Conditions
Single Pusher Tandem Pusher Push-Pull Self-loading Elevator
Favorable 0.2 0.1 Negligible Negligible
Average 0.3 0.2 0.1 Negligible
Unfavorable 0.5 0.5 0.3 0.2
Load Time
Conditions Single Tandem Elevating
Auger Push-Pull*
Pusher Pusher Scraper
Favorable 0.5 0.4 0.8 0.7 0.7
Average 0.6 0.5 1.0 0.9 1.0
Unfavorable 1.0 0.9 1.5 1.3 1.4
Maneuver and Dump Time
Conditions
Single Engine Twin Engine Push-Pull
Favorable 0.3 0.3 0.3
Average 0.7 0.6 0.5
Unfavorable 1.0 0.9 0.8
productivity
rated capacity operational efficiency
cycle time
10.16. Push-Loading
Except for elevating, pull-scrapers and push-pull scrapers, wheel scrapers require the assistance of
pusher tractors to obtain maximum production. The three basic methods of push-loading scrapers are:
Back-track loading
Use the back-track push-loading technique where it is impractical to load in both directions.
However, this method is inefficient and the slowest method due to the time spent in backing up and
repositioning for the next load. It is the most commonly used since it permits all scrapers to load in
the same general area.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 81
Chain loading
Use the chain push-loading technique where the cut is fairly long, making it possible to pick up two
or more scraper loads without backtracking. The pusher pushes one scraper, then moves behind
another scraper that is moving in the same direction in an adjacent lane. It is suitable for a long,
narrow cut area.
Shuttle loading
Use the shuttle push-loading technique for short cuts where it is possible to load in both directions.
The pusher pushes one scraper, then turns and pushes a second scraper in the opposite direction. It
requires two separate fill areas for efficient operations.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 82
Note:
A complete pusher cycle consists of maneuver time (while the pusher moves into position and
engages the scraper), load time, boost time (during which the pusher assists in accelerating the
scraper out of the cut), and return time.
Tandem pushing involves the use of two pusher tractors operating one behind the other during
loading and boosting. The use of tandem pushers reduces scraper load time and frequently results
in obtaining larger scraper loads.
The dual tractor is more efficient pusher than tandem tractors because the dual tractor is controlled
by a single operator and no time is lost in coordination between two operators.
Extend the horizontal axis of the load growth curve to the left of the origin.
Locate a point A on the axis whose distance from the origin represents “total cycle time less loading
time.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 83
Draw a tangent to the load growth curve from point A intersecting the curve at point B. The loading
time (C) corresponding to point B is the optimum load time.
Note:
Distance AC represents the total scraper cycle time
Distance BC represents the corresponding volume per cycle
Slope of line AB represents the production (volume) per unit of time. When the slope of AB is at a
maximum, the scraper production per unit of time is maximized.
The number of pushers required to fully service a given scraper fleer may then be determined form the
equation
no. of scrapers
No. of pushers required = 2
no. served by one pusher
Note:
The result obtained from equation 1 be rounded down to one decimal place before substituting
in equation 2.
The result obtained from equation 2 must be rounded up to the next whole number to ensure that
scrapers do not have to wait for a pusher.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 84
When the number of pushers actually used is less than the number required to fully serve the
scraper fleet, expected production is reduced to that obtained using the equation below. In
performing this calculation, use the the precise number of pushers required, not the integer
value.
no. of pushers
Production = no. of scrapers production per scraper
required no.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 85
Maintain the haul road in the best possible condition. Full-time use of a motor grader on the haul
road will usually pay off in increased scraper production.
Make the haul road wide enough to permit high-speed hauling without danger. One-way haul
roads should be utilized whenever possible.
Keep the fill surface smooth and compacted to minimize scraper time in the fill.
Boost scrapers on the fill if spreading time is excessive.
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 86
2. The contractor of Problem 1 estimates the hourly ownership cost for the tracked dozer to be ₱4 125, the
hourly operating cost to be ₱2 475, and the dozer operator’s wages to be ₱3 300 per hour.
a) What is the estimated unit cost for excavating the foundation per bank cubic meter?
b) What is the total estimated cost for excavating for the foundation?
c) What is the estimated duration for the excavating operation?
3. A power-shift crawler tractor has a rated blade capacity of 7.65 LCM. The dozer is excavating loose
common earth and pushing it a distance of 61 m. Maximum reverse speed in third range is 8 km/h.
Estimate the production of the dozer if job efficiency is 50 min/h.
4. A contractor has a wheeled loader with a 2.1 cubic meter bucket. The static tipping load for the loader
is 69.4 kN. What is the maximum load the loader can carry per cycle when loaded with:
a) moist loam weighing 11.6 kN per loose cubic meter?
b) wet gravel weighing 19.8 kN per loose cubic meter?
5. A contractor is planning to use a tracked loader to excavate for the foundation for a small building. The
loader bucket has a rated heaped capacity of 1.15 cubic meter. The static tipping load for the loader is
6531.7 kg. The contractor intends to use the loader to excavate for the foundation and stockpile the
excavated material for backfill and landscaping. The average haul distance for the loader is estimated
to be 30.5 m one way, the average speed when moving loaded is estimated to be 2.6 kph, and the
average speed when moving empty is estimated to be 3.9 kph. The material to be excavated is moist
loam weighing 1 305.2 kg per loose cubic meter. What is the estimated productivity of the loader, if the
contractor plans to operate 50 minutes per hour?
6. The contractor of Problem 5 estimates the hourly ownership cost for the loader to be ₱3 520, the hourly
operating cost to be ₱2 475, and the operator’s hourly wages to be ₱3 300. The project plans indicate the
required excavation to measure 1.8 m by 1.2 m by 13.7 m.
a) What is the estimated unit cost for excavating the foundation in bank cubic meter? The percent swell
for the soil is estimated to be 15%.
b) What is the total estimated cost for excavating for the foundation?
c) How long do you estimate it will take the loader to complete the excavation?
7. Estimate the hourly production in LCM of a 2.68 m 3 wheel loader excavating sand and gravel (average
material) from a pit and moving it to a stockpile. The average hauls distance is 61 m, the average effective
grade is 6%, the bucket fill factor is 1.00, and job efficiency is 50 min/h.
8. Estimate the production of a single engine two-axle tractor scraper whose travel time curves are shown
below based on the following information:
Maximum heaped volume = 24 LCM
Maximum payload = 34 020 kg
Material: Sandy clay, 1 898 kg/BCM, 1 571 kg/LCM
Rolling resistance = 50 kg/t
Job efficiency = 50 min/h
Operating conditions = average
Single pusher
Haul route:
Section 1: Level loading area
Section 2: Down a 4% grade, 610 m
Section 3: Level dumping area
Section 4: Up a 4% grade, 610 m
Section 5: Level turnaround, 183 m
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 87
9. Solve problem 8 using the average-speed method and the performance curves.
10. The estimated cycle time for a wheel scraper is 6.5 min. Calculate the number of pushers required to
serve a fleet of nine scrapers using single pushers. Determine the result for both back-track and chain
loading methods.
11. Find the expected production of the scraper fleet of Problem 10 if only one pusher is available and the
chain loading method is used. Expected production of a single scraper assuming adequate pusher
support is 173 BCM/h
Prepared by: Melvin R. Esguerra, mpice Advanced Construction Methods and Equipment Page 88