Ethics and Human Interface
Ethics and Human Interface
Syllabus
• Ethics and Human Interface: Essence, Determinants and Consequences of Ethics in - Human Actions;
Dimensions of Ethics; Ethics - in Private and Public Relationships.
• Human Values: Lessons from the Lives and Teachings of Great Leaders, Reformers and Administrators;
Role of Family Society and Educational Institutions in Inculcating Values.
• "Ethics is the cornerstone of a civilised society, guiding us to act with integrity and fairness."
• "Without ethics, success is empty and fleeting."
• "Ethics is not a barrier, but a bridge to a better world."
• "Ethics is the armour of the soul."
• "Doing the right thing is more important than doing the thing right."
• "In the race for success, ethics is the compass that keeps us on the right path."
• "A man without ethics is a wild beast loosed upon this world." - Albert Camus
• “In just about every area of society, there’s nothing more important than ethics”- Henry Paulson
• There is no religion higher than Truth and Righteousness.” ~ Mahatma Gandhi
Introduction
• Aristotle: "Ethics is the study of the good life and the virtues that enable us to live that life."
• Immanuel Kant: "Ethics is the study of the moral law and our obligations to obey it."
• John Stuart Mill: "Ethics is the study of the right and wrong of actions and the rules and principles that
govern them."
• Sigmund Freud: "Ethics is the science of the good and evil in human conduct."
• Martin Luther King, Jr.: "Ethics is the art of making choices that are by moral principles."
Source of Ethics
Ethics, or the principles that govern behaviour, derive from various
sources that have shaped societies and individuals over time. There
are the following sources of Ethics -
1. Religion
• Religion is one of the oldest foundations of ethical standards,
prescribing what is right and wrong. Religious teachings
profoundly influence societal norms and individual
behaviour.
• Example:
o The principle of Ahimsa (non-violence) from Hinduism,
Buddhism, and Jainism plays a crucial role in promoting
peace and ethical behaviour.
Principles
• Privacy: Respect for user privacy involves protecting personal information from unauthorized access
and misuse.
o Example: A health app anonymizes user data before storing it and ensures that sensitive health
information cannot be traced back to individual users, protecting their privacy.
• Security: Ensuring the security of technology systems and data protects against unauthorized access,
breaches, and cyber threats.
o Example: An e-commerce platform uses encryption for transactions and regular security updates
to protect customer payment information from hackers.
• Transparency: Transparency requires clear communication about how technology works, what data is
collected, and how it is used.
o Example: A smartphone app provides users with clear information on what data it collects (e.g.,
location, contacts) and how this data will be used, allowing users to make informed decisions.
• Accountability: Accountability means that creators and operators of technology are responsible for
the impacts of their products and services.
o Example: A social media company takes responsibility for the spread of misinformation on its
platform by implementing stricter content moderation policies and fact-checking mechanisms.
• Fairness: Fairness ensures that technology is accessible and does not discriminate against any group.
o Example: An AI-based hiring platform is tested for biases to ensure it evaluates candidates solely
based on their qualifications, without favoring or disadvantaging candidates based on race,
gender, or age.
• Beneficence: Beneficence involves creating technology that benefits individuals and society,
promoting well-being.
o Example: A non-profit organization develops an educational app that provides free access to
quality learning resources for children in underprivileged areas, enhancing educational
opportunities.
• Non-Maleficence: Non-maleficence means avoiding harm through the use of technology.
o Example: A self-driving car manufacturer rigorously tests its vehicles to ensure they are safe and
do not pose risks to passengers, pedestrians, or other road users.
• Informed Consent: Informed consent involves ensuring that users understand how technology works
and the implications of its use before they agree to use it.
o Example: A genetic testing service provides comprehensive information about what the tests can
reveal, the limitations of the results, and potential privacy concerns before users agree to
participate.
• Sustainability: Sustainability involves creating technology in ways that minimize environmental impact
and promote long-term ecological health.
o Example: A tech company designs its products with recyclable materials and invests in renewable
energy sources to power its data centers, reducing its overall environmental footprint.
5. Media Ethics
• Media ethics scrutinises ethical standards in journalism and information dissemination. Preventing
information monopolies, upholding pluralism, and maintaining objectivity are key concerns.
• More coverage in class.
• Examples:
o Recent scandals like the TRP manipulation by some media houses and the media's role in
influencing public opinion in cases like the Aryan Khan drug case underscore the importance of
ethical conduct in media.
o The coverage of sensitive issues such as communal violence or caste-based discrimination in
Indian media requires adherence to ethical standards. Media ethicists assess the balance between
freedom of speech and responsible journalism, ensuring accurate and unbiased reporting.
6. Digital Media Ethics
• Digital media ethics addresses ethical challenges arising from digital news media. Issues like
plagiarism, digital manipulation of images or videos, invasion of privacy, and the spread of fake news
pose ethical dilemmas.
• Digital media ethicists advocate for policies to combat fake news, protect user privacy, and promote
digital literacy among the Indian populace.
• Examples: The spread of misinformation and hate speech on social media platforms during communal
riots or elections poses ethical challenges.
o Deepfake technology and biases in facial recognition systems are examples of emerging ethical
concerns in the digital sphere.
Normative Ethics Theories- Will be covered under Western Thinkers Topic
Determinants of Ethics
• Religion: Religion provides a moral framework based on divine commandments or spiritual teachings,
influencing ethical behavior and decision-making.
Examples:
o Ten Commandments in Christianity: Guidelines such as "Thou shalt not kill" and "Thou shalt not
steal" shape ethical conduct.
o Five Precepts in Buddhism: Ethical principles such as abstaining from killing and stealing guide
followers' actions.
• Culture: Culture encompasses the beliefs, customs, and practices of a society, shaping individuals'
perceptions of right and wrong.
Examples:
o Hospitality in Middle Eastern cultures: Emphasizes the ethical duty to be hospitable to guests.
o Respect for Elders in many Asian cultures: Cultural norms dictate showing respect and care for older
family members.
2. Integrity: It is the practice of being honest and showing a consistent and uncompromising adherence to
moral and ethical principles. Holders of public office should not place themselves under any financial or
other obligation to outside individuals or organisations that might influence them in the performance of
their official duties.
Holders of public office should not place themselves under any financial or other obligation to outside
individuals or organizations that might influence them in the performance of their official duties.
Example–
• Mahatma Gandhi and Abraham Lincoln were exemplary leaders who were famous for their integrity.
Both in times of crisis adhered to their values like Lincoln sticking to the abolition of slavery and Gandhi
towards non-violence
3. Objectivity: Decisions are made on merit and based on the best evidence available, without bias or
favouritism. It means making decisions based on established facts and figures rather than personal opinion
or bias.
• Interconnectedness: Public and private ethics are interconnected because individuals' personal ethical
beliefs and values often shape their behaviour and decision-making in public roles and settings. Conversely,
societal norms and expectations, which are influenced by public ethics, can impact individuals' private
ethical choices.
• Example:
o Mahatma Gandhi's personal commitment to nonviolence and truth influenced his public role as a
leader of the Indian independence movement. His adherence to ethical principles like Satyagraha
(truth-force) inspired a nation and shaped the course of history.
o The #MeToo movement sparked by allegations of sexual harassment and assault against prominent
figures, led to a re-evaluation of societal norms around gender relations and workplace conduct. This
societal shift influenced individuals' private ethical choices regarding respect, consent, and
accountability.
• Influence on Individuals: Public ethics can influence individuals' private ethical conduct by shaping their
perceptions of what is morally acceptable or unacceptable. For example, laws and regulations enacted
based on public ethical principles may influence individuals' behaviour by setting standards for acceptable
conduct and deterring unethical actions through legal consequences.
o Example: The introduction of stringent anti-corruption laws in India, such as the Prevention of
Corruption Act, has influenced individuals' private ethical conduct by setting clear standards for
acceptable behaviour and deterring corrupt practices in both public and private sectors.
• Conflicts of Interest: Conflicts of interest can arise when individuals' private interests or relationships
conflict with their public duties or responsibilities. Managing conflicts of interest ethically requires
individuals to prioritize the public good over personal gain and to disclose any potential conflicts to avoid
compromising the integrity of their decision-making.
o Examples- The Supreme Court of India has set precedents by requiring judges to recuse themselves
from cases where there is a potential conflict of interest. This ensures impartiality and upholds the
integrity of the judiciary, even in cases involving influential individuals or sensitive matters.
• Legal and Ethical Considerations: While laws and regulations establish legal standards for behaviour in
both public and private domains, ethical considerations may go beyond legal requirements. Ethical
Overall, the relationship between public and private ethics underscores the importance of promoting ethical
behaviour and accountability at all levels of society, recognizing the interconnectedness between individual
actions, organizational practices, and broader societal values and norms. By upholding ethical principles in
both public and private spheres, individuals and institutions can contribute to the creation of a more just,
equitable, and sustainable society.
In summary, ethics in private relations are concerned with personal interactions, guided by individual values
and societal norms, while ethics in public relations involve professional standards and considerations in
managing relationships between organizations and the public. While both involve ethical considerations, the
contexts, standards, and enforcement mechanisms differ significantly.
Constitutional Morality
Constitutional morality refers to the adherence to the core principles and values enshrined in the Constitution,
guiding the behaviour of both government institutions and citizens to ensure justice, liberty, equality, and
fraternity.
Dr. B.R. Ambedkar, the chief architect of the Indian Constitution, advocated for constitutional morality to
ensure social justice and equality.
Basic Characteristics of Constitutional Morality
• Adherence to Constitutional Principles:
o It emphasises the importance of following the spirit of the Constitution rather than merely its literal
interpretation. Ensures that laws and policies are in harmony with constitutional values.
o For Examples –
▪ The Supreme Court's decision in the Sabarimala case emphasised constitutional morality over
traditional practices, allowing women of all ages to enter the temple.
Human Values
• Human values guide people to consider the human element when they interact with other human beings.
• These values are fundamental to ethical conduct and often serve as a framework for individuals and
societies to navigate complex moral dilemmas.
• Examples:
o Honesty, integrity, compassion, fairness, respect, responsibility, and empathy.
o They shape how individuals interact with others, make choices, and contribute to the well-being of
society as a whole.
Ethical lessons from religions offer timeless principles that promote compassion, justice, and harmony. They
provide moral guidelines for individuals and societies, fostering peace, understanding, and ethical behavior.
These teachings transcend cultural boundaries, offering universal values that enrich personal lives and
promote social cohesion.
1. Christianity:
• Golden Rule: Treat others as you would like to be treated. This principle emphasizes empathy and
compassion, guiding individuals to consider the impact of their actions on others.
o Example: A volunteer spends time at a homeless shelter, treating the residents with dignity and
respect, just as they would want to be treated if they were in need.
• Forgiveness: Christians are encouraged to forgive others, as God forgives sins. This teaches the
importance of letting go of resentment and embracing reconciliation.
o Example: A person forgives a friend who has wronged them, choosing to mend the relationship
rather than holding onto anger.
• Charity: Christianity emphasizes helping those in need and practicing generosity. This principle
encourages selflessness and caring for the less fortunate.
o Example: A person donates money to a charity that supports underprivileged children,
demonstrating a commitment to helping those in need.
2. Islam:
• Tawhid (Unity of God): Belief in the oneness of God and the unity of humanity. This principle
emphasizes the equality of all people before God, promoting respect and harmony.
o Example: A person treats people of all races and backgrounds with respect and kindness,
recognizing their shared humanity.
• Adl (Justice): Islam emphasizes justice and fairness in all aspects of life. This principle guides Muslims
to act justly in their dealings with others.
o Example: A leader ensures that everyone in the community has access to resources and
opportunities, promoting fairness and equality.
• Ihsan (Excellence): Muslims are encouraged to strive for excellence in all actions, doing things in the
best possible manner. This principle promotes diligence and integrity.
o Example: A student studies hard and puts in extra effort to excel in their exams, aiming for
excellence in their academic pursuits.
• Compassion and Mercy (Rahmah)
o Compassion and mercy are central to Islamic teachings. Allah is often referred to as "The Most
Compassionate" and "The Most Merciful." Muslims are encouraged to emulate these attributes
in their dealings with others, showing kindness, forgiveness, and empathy.
• Charity and Social Welfare (Zakat and Sadaqah)
o Charity is a fundamental aspect of Islamic ethics. Zakat, one of the Five Pillars of Islam, is a
mandatory alms-giving, aimed at reducing poverty and inequality. Sadaqah, voluntary charity, is
also highly encouraged to support those in need.
3. Hinduism:
• Dharma (Righteousness): Hindus are encouraged to uphold their duty and righteousness in all actions.
This principle emphasizes the importance of fulfilling one's responsibilities.
Conclusion
Ethical lessons from religions offer profound insights into human conduct and societal harmony. From
Christianity's emphasis on love and compassion to Buddhism's teachings on nonviolence and mindfulness,
each faith provides a unique framework for moral living. These teachings encourage empathy, kindness, and a
sense of responsibility towards others, transcending cultural boundaries to foster a more compassionate
world.