Introduction To Self Understanding
Introduction To Self Understanding
The Self and Person in the Contemporary Anthropology • Clifford Geertz was an Anthropology Professor at the
University of Chicago. He studied different cultures and explored on the
• The four subfields of anthropology – Archeology, Biological conception of the self in his writings entitled, “The Impact of the
Anthropology, Linguistics, and Cultural Anthropology, suggest that Concept of Culture on the Concept of Man” (1966) in his fieldwork at
human beings are similar and different in varying ways and tendencies. Java, Bali and Morrocco.
For example, people have the same need for food and water, but they • The analysis of Geertz (1966) in his cultural study about the
have different means on how to satisfy them. These similarities and description of self in Bali is that the Balinese person is extremely
differences make life so interesting. As one learn facts/information that concerned not to present anything individual (distinguishing him or her
make them similar to the other, they will also discover that they have from others) in social life but to enact exclusively a culturally prescribed
different characteristics the define them. This knowledge aims to role or mask. In one instance, Geertz (1973) gave an example of the
highlight the uniqueness of each person and making them value life and stage fright that pervades persons in Bali because they must not be
existence even more. The subfields of Anthropology are as follows: publicly recognizable as individual selves and actors points precisely to
o Archeology. Focus on the study of the past and how it may the fact that agency or an ability to act in one’s own account is an
have contributed to the present ways of how people conduct their daily integral ability of human beings—an ability which continually threatens
lives. Archeologists have so far discovered the unique ways in which the culturally established norm of nonindividuality
human beings adapted to the changes in their environment in order for
them to survive. Among their discoveries around the world is the Psychology
species, homo sapiens did not become extinct because of their ability
to think, use tools and learn from experience. In relating to the • The cognitive aspect of the self is known as self-concept. Self-
contemporary society, people still aim for survival, for their basic needs concept is defined as self-knowledge, a cognitive structure that includes
to be fulfilled and to live legacy to their society. beliefs about personality traits, physical characteristics, abilities, values,
o Biological Anthropology. Focus on how the human body goals, and roles, as well as the knowledge that an individual exist as
adapts to the different earth environments. Among the activities of individuals. As humans grow and develop, self-concept becomes
Anthropologists are identification of probable causes of diseases, abstract and more complex.
physical mutation, and death, evolution, and comparison of dead and • According to the psychologist Dr. Bruce A. Bracken in 1992,
living primates. They are interested in explaining how the biological there are six specific domains that are related to self-concept these are:
characteristics of human being affects their way of living. Accordingly, 1) the social domain or the ability of the person to interact with
human beings at present still share the same biological strengths and others;
vulnerabilities. Like eating balanced nutrients and minerals that are 2) the competence domain or the ability to meet the basic
beneficial to all human beings while being exposed to a virus in a needs;
pandemic might cause negative implications to many. 3) the affect domain or the awareness of the emotional states;
o Linguistic Anthropology. Focused on using language as means 4) the physical domain or the feelings about looks, health,
to discover a group’s manner of social interaction and their worldview. physical condition, and overall appearance;
Anthropologists in this field want to discover how language is used to 5) academic domain or the success or failure in the school; and
create and share meanings, to form ideas and concepts and to promote 6) family domain or how well one function within the family
social change. Furthermore, they also study how language and modes unit.
of communication changes over time.
o Cultural Anthropology. Focused in knowing what makes one William James and the Me-Self and I-Self
group’s manner of living forms an essential part of the member’s
personal and societal identity. This encompasses the principles of • William James is a well-known figure in Psychology who is
Theory of Cultural Determinism which suggests that the human nature considered as the founder of functionalism. He brought prominence to
is determined by the kind of culture he is born and grew up in. Cultural U.S. psychology through the publication of The Principles of Psychology
diversities are manifested in different ways and different levels of dept. (1890) that made him more influential than his contemporaries in the
The following are the ways in which culture may manifest itself in field.
people: • James made a clear distinction between ways of approaching
Symbols. These are the words, gestures, pictures or objects the self – the knower (the pure or the I – Self) and the known (the
that have recognized or accepted meaning in a particular culture. objective or the Me – Self). The function of the knower (I-Self)
Example: colors have similar meaning across all cultures. according to James must be the agent of experience. While the known
Heroes. These are persons from the past or present who have (Me-Self) have three different but interrelated aspects of empirical self
characteristics that are important in culture. They may be real of work (known today as self- concept): the Me viewed as material, the Me
of fictions. Example: Fiction – Thor, Captain America; Real – Jose Rizal, viewed as social, and the Me viewed as spiritual in nature.
Apolinario Mabini. • The material self is consists of everything an individual call
Rituals. These are activities participated by a group of people uniquely as their own, such as the body, family, home or style of dress.
for the fulfilment of desired objectives and are concerned to be socially On the other hand, social self refers to the recognition an individual get
essential. Example: Wedding, fiesta, Christmas celebration, graduation, from other people. Lastly, spiritual self refers to the individual inner or
etc. subjective being.
Values. These are considered to be the core of every culture.
These are unconscious, neither discuss or observed, and can only be Carl Rogers : Real and Ideal Self
inferred from the way people act and react to situations. Example:
hospitality, respect for elders etc. • Carl Rogers is best known as the founder of client- centered
• The field of Anthropology offers another way by which a therapy and considered as one of the prominent humanistic or
person can view themselves. As self is formed or determined by the existential theorists in personality. His therapy aimed to make the
person achieve balance between their self- concept (real-self) and ideal • Albert Bandura is a psychologist and Professor Emeritus of
self. Social Science in Psychology at Stanford University. He is known for his
• The real self includes all those aspects of one's identity that theory of social learning by means of modeling. He is famous for his
are perceived in awareness. These are the things that are known to proposed concept of self- efficacy.
oneself like the attributes that an individual possesses. • His personality theory, The Social Cognitive Theory asserts
• The ideal self is defined as one’s view of self as one wishes to that a person is both proactive and agentic, which means that we have
be. This contains all the aspirations or wishes of an individual for the capacity to exercise control over our life. This theory emphasized
themselves. that human beings are proactive, self-regulating, self-reflective, and
• A wide gap between the ideal self and the self-concept self- organizing.
indicates incongruence and an unhealthy personality. Psychologically • Self as proactive means an individual have control in any
healthy individuals perceive little discrepancy between their self- situation by making things happen. They act as agent in doing or
concept and what they ideally would like to be. making themselves as they are. Agency is a defining feature of modern
selfhood. Agents assume some degree of ownership and control over
Real and Ideal Self things, both internally (I control my own thoughts) and externally (I
make things happen in the environment). The ability of an individual to
• According to Multiple Selves Theory, there are different pursue their goals in life is an example of agentic approach to self.
aspects of the self exist in an individual. From here, we can say that self • According to Bandura (1989), self-efficacy beliefs determine
is a whole consist of parts, and these parts manifest themselves when how people feel, think, motivate themselves and
need arise. behave. Such beliefs produce these diverse effects through four major
• Gregg Henriques proposed the Tripartite Model of Human processes. They include cognitive, motivational, affective and selection
Consciousness, wherein he described that self is consist of three processes. A strong sense of efficacy enhances human accomplishment
related, but also separable domains these are the experimental self, and personal well-being in many ways.
private self, and public self. • In contrast Bandura (1989) said that people who doubt their
capabilities shy away from difficult tasks which they view as personal
o The experiential self or the theater of consciousness is a threats. They have low aspirations and weak commitment to the goals
domain of self that defined as felt experience of being. This includes the they choose to pursue. When faced with difficult tasks, they dwell on
felt consistency of being across periods of time. It is tightly associated their personal deficiencies, on the obstacles they will encounter, and all
with the memory. This is a part of self that disappears the moment that kinds of adverse outcomes rather than concentrate on how to perform
an individual enter deep sleep and comes back when they wake up. successfully. They fall easy victim to stress and depression.
o The private self consciousness system or the
narrator/interpreter is a portion of self that verbally narrates what is Western and Oriental/Eastern Thought
happening and tries to make sense of what is going on. The moment
that you read this part, there is somewhat like a “voice” speaking in Cultural differences and environment creates different perceptions of
your head trying to understand what this concept is all about. the self. The most common distinction between people and cultures is
o Lastly, the public self or Persona, the domain of self that an the Eastern-Western distinction. Eastern are known as the Asian
individual shows to the public, and this interacts on how others see an countries, and Western represents the Europe and Northen America. It
individual. Henriques’ Tripartite Model attempts to capture the key must be noted that countries who are geographically closer to each
domains of consciousness, both within the self and between others. other my share commonalities, but factors that may create diffrences
• Unified being is essentially connected to consciousness, must be considered.
awareness, and agency. A well-adjusted person is able to accept and
understood the success and failure that they experienced. They are Individualistic versus Collective Self
those kinds of person who continually adjust, adapt, evolve and survive
as an individual with integrated, unified, multiple selves. Understanding individualism and collectivism could help in the
understanding of the cross-cultural values of a person. Not every
Donald Winnicott: True versus False Self culture is at one end or the other of the spectrum, but the majority
tend to favor one over the other in everyday life.
• Donald Winnicott was a pediatrician in London who studied
Psychoanalysis with Melanie Klein, a renowned personality theorist and Individualistic Self
one of the pioneers in object relations and development of personality
in childhood. • Individualism is not the idea that individuals should live like
• According to him, false self is an alternative personality used isolated entity, nor the idea that they should never get or give help
to protect an individual’s true identity or one’s ability to “hide” the real from others, nor the idea that an individual never owes anything to
self. The false self is activated to maintain social relationship as other people.
anticipation of the demands of others. Compliance with the external • Individualism is the idea that the fundamental unit of the
rules or following societal norms is a good example of this. false self can human species that thinks, lives, and acts toward goals is the individual.
be a healthy self if it is perceived as functional for the person and for This means that we can form our own independent judgments, act on
the society and being compliant without the feeling of betrayal of true our own thoughts, and disagree with others.
self. On the other hand, unhealthy false self happens when an • Each adult individual can consider what is in his own best
individual feels forced compliance in any situation. interests. Each can act on his own private motivations and values and
• On the contrary, true self has a sense of integrity and can judge other people as good people to form relationships with, or as
connected wholeness that is rooted in early infancy. The baby bad people to be avoided. Each can decide whether to cooperate with
creates experiences of a sense of reality and sense of life worth living. others to solve problems. Each can choose to think for himself about
Winnicott claimed that true self can be achieved by good parenting that the conclusions that the majority of others in a group come to,
is not necessarily a perfect parenting. accepting or rejecting their conclusions as indicated by his own
thought.
The Self as Proactive and Agentic Albert Bandura • Example of the description would include an individual
identifies primarily with self, with the needs of the individual being
satisfied before those of the group. Looking after and taking care of o Western Self as materialistic and rationalistic. The western
ourselves, being self-sufficient, guarantees the well-being of the group. accentuation of rational, scientific approach to reality has tended to
Independence and self-reliance are greatly stressed and valued. define spiritual and immaterial phenomena as potentially superstitious
• In general, people tend to distance themselves and dangerous. In any society, belief system is stratified and composed
psychologically and emotionally from each other. One may choose to of a hierarchy of interrelated, causal-explanatory models.
join groups, but group membership is not essential to one’s identity or
success. Individualist characteristics are often associated with men and The Self as Embedded in Relationships and through Spiritual
people in urban settings. Development in Confucian Thought
• Western cultures are known to be individualistic. • Confucius was born in the period of the Zhou Dynasty in 551
BCE in the state of Lu. He grew up poor although he was descended
Collective Self from scholarly family.
• Confucius philosophy is known as humanistic social
• Collectivism is the idea that the fundamental unit of the philosophy which focusses on human beings and the society in general.
human species that thinks, lives, and acts toward goals is not the • Confucianism is centered on ren which can be manifested
individual, but some group. In different variants, this group may be the through the li (propriety), xiao (filiality), and yi (rightness). For
family, the city, the economic class, the society, the nation, the race, or Confucius, ren reflects the person’s own understanding of humanity. It
the whole human species. The group exists as a super-organism is found within each person and can be realized in one’s personal life
separate from individuals: A group may make its own decisions, acts and relationship. Ren guides human actions that makes life worth living
apart from the actions of individuals, and has its own interests apart which can be realized through li, xiao, and yi:
from those of the individuals that compose it. o Li the propriety. Rules of propriety should be followed to
• Under collectivism, individuals are analogous to ants in the guide human actions. These rules are the customs, ceremonies, and
protection of their queen ant. The individual ant doesn’t have minds of traditions that forms the basis of li. According to Confucius, “to master
their own, and generally cannot disagree with the hive. Any ant that oneself and return to propriety is humanity” (Koller, 2007). Self mastery
acts in a way contrary to the interests of the group is a malfunctioning involves self development. Self mastery is characterized by self-control
ant. If an ant does not follow the certain pattern of how they protect and the will to redirect impulses to change these to socially accepted
their queen, it will be entirely unable to support itself, find other ants expression of human nature. Li conforms to the norms of humanity,
that support other queen ant and will surely die in short order. If the thus one must fulfill their duties and responsibilities in this five (5)
malfunctioning ant stays within the group, it will be a threat to the line relationships: father and son, ruler and subject, older and younger
appropriate to protecting the queen ant. brothers, husband and wife, friend and friend.
• Examples of the collectivist thinking is when our identity is in o Xiao the filiality. This is the virtue of reverence and respect for
large part, a function of our membership and role in a group, e.g., the the family. Parents should be revered for the life they and given.
family or work team. The survival and success of the group ensures the Children show respect to their parents by exerting efforts to take care
well-being of the individual, so that by considering the needs and of themselves. Reverence for parents and family is further
feelings of others, one protects oneself. Harmony and the demonstrated by bringing honor to the family, making something of
interdependence of group members are stressed and valued. Group himself and to earn respect of other. If, however, the person is having
members are relatively close psychologically and emotionally, but difficulty giving his family the honor that they deserved, he should just
distant toward non-group members. Collectivist characteristics are do this best to not disgrace the family. Relationship that exist in the
often associated with women and people in rural settings. family reflect hoe the person relates to others in the community. The
• Asian countries are known to be collective in nature. family is the reflection of the person. How the person interacts socially
and the values they emulate can all be traced back to their family
The Social Construction of the Self in Western Thought environment. This forms the bases of the person’s moral and social
virtues (Koller, 2007).
• Self has been an area of interest by French and English o Yi the rightness. The right way of behaving which is
philosophers, and evident in the ideas of Greek philosophers like unconditional and absolute. Right is right, and what is not right is
Socrates and Plato. wrong. Actions must be performed and carried out because they are
• Descartes in 17th century emphasized the self in his dictum “I right actions. Confucius emphasized that actions should be performed
think therefore I am” which claims that cognitive basis of the person’s because they are right and not for selfish benefits that they provide.
thoughts is proof for the existence of the self.
• Kant believed that the self is capable of actions that entitles it
to have rights as an autonomous agent.
• Here are some qualities imparted to the Western subjective
self. It sketches some features on subjectivity and ways of thinking of
western persons. This provides an impressionistic profile through the
use of a few strokes characterizing some ways of being and thinking of
many western persons.
o Western self as analytic. Since analytic and inductive modes
of thinking were prominent for person in western cultures, to see
objects as divisible combinations of yet smaller objects. Real things are
not only visualized but immaterial things like thoughts, ideas and
memories would be given emphasis.
o Western self as monotheistic. Monotheism can be known as
the rigid consequence of the doctrine of normal human being. It is like
forcing the concentration of supernatural capabilities.