BBB4M - 4-2E - Selling Canadian Products Abroad - Oluseye Tolu
BBB4M - 4-2E - Selling Canadian Products Abroad - Oluseye Tolu
Oluseye Toluwanimi
Victoria Crossan
BBB4M
14 November 2024
(Ilich, 2013)
Introduction:
A Canadian snack product that I would like to introduce to my home country,
Nigeria, is the chocolate candy known as Smarties. Famous for its colourful
decoration and chocolatey taste, Smarties has been a long-time favourite candy
in states such as Germany, Australia, South Africa and Canada (Nestle, 2024).
Under the popular corporation known as Nestle, Smarties has been creating
wonderful sweet treats that have reached all parts of the globe, with no
artificial colours or flavours as well as the use of highly recyclable paper
packaging (Nestle, 2024). The light-hearted, yet satisfactory nature of the
product makes it a reasonable product to be marketed and imported into my
country Nigeria.
General Information:
Political, Social and Environmental Challenges
Nigeria, as a developing country, has numerous barriers and limitations that
make the importation of goods difficult. The country is faced with a number of
political, social and environmental problems that do well to further hinder the
process of successful importation. Political challenges in the sense that Nigeria
Oluseye 2
has been faced with the issue of bad leadership for numerous years. Alongside
the presence of conflict caused by political competition, there is a high rate of
corruption between high-ranking officials that has affected the country on an
economic scale (USAID, 2016). Social challenges such as poverty,
unemployment, terrorism (in the form of a terrorist group known as Boko
Haram) and education inequality have been on the rise in Nigeria and have
greatly affected the economic standards and security of the country (LaVopa,
2021). Such problems lead to numerous other disadvantages for the country in
not only local but also international affairs. These problems divide Nigeria and
as a result, make the process of business between countries all the more
difficult. Environmental issues in Nigeria, although not as discussed, is another
major problem that hinders business in the country. Air pollution, Land
pollution, Water pollution and, especially Noise pollution, has severely
degraded the environment in which the Nigerian economy is set and has had
many adverse effects on the country (Folorunso & Folorunso, 2022). Erosion,
flooding, and oil spillage are common causes of such pollution in the country
and are prominent in all the six geo-political zones of the country (Folorunso &
Folorunso, 2022).
Geographic Location:
The Federal Republic of Nigeria is located in West Africa, on the border of the
Gulf of Guinea in the South, Chad and Cameroon in the East, the Republic of
Benin in the West and Niger in the North. It is known as the most populous
African country (Embassy of Nigeria Sweden, 2023).
(Meshioye, 2024).
(Worldometer, 2024)
According to the above table, it is sensible to say that Nigeria faces a steady
growth in population and has maintained such growth from as far back as
1960, when it gained its independence. As of 2024, the growth rate of the
country is about 2.1% and has been on a 2% growth from the years 1983 till
date (Worldometer, 2024).
There are three major ethnicities in Nigeria; Hausa in the North, Yoruba in the
Southwest and Igbo in the Southeast (MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, 2022)
and these languages, apart from English and Pidgin, are the main languages
usually spoken throughout the country. The language varies depending on
which ethnic group the person speaking belongs to and due to the fact that
there are over 250 ethnic groups, there are multiple languages used by
Nigerians (MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, 2022). In terms of religion, Nigeria is
mainly made up of both Christians and Muslims. Most Hausa people and a
majority of states in the Northern part of Nigeria as well as in Nigeria as a
whole are Muslims and have been Islam for as far back as the 10th century, the
other states are mainly made up of Christians with the the occasional
traditional worshipper (MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, 2022).
Communication Systems:
There are numerous communication systems in Nigeria, including, radio,
television, fixed and mobile telephones, the internet and others. Among these
are telecommunication networks such as 9mobile, Airtel, MTN and Glo (Media
Landscapes, 2018). Television services such as GoTv and DSTV are made
available to Nigerians and internet service providers such as MTN and
Spectranet are also widely used throughout the country.
Concerning the taste and ingredients, the product has a chocolatey taste which
might not capture the attention of Nigerians as they are more concerned with
spicy foods and traditional meals. The ingredients used will not be a problem
however as there is a relatively significant amount of calcium provided in the
meal, of about 4% (Nestle, 2018). Despite being a small amount, Nigerians have
a wide variety of food that contain Calcium and find it to be very valuable.
There is, thankfully, no specific food item used in the production of Smarties
that would upset the people of Nigeria. The fact that Smarties come in
different flavours will attract Nigerians to it as diversity is praised in the
country, they thoroughly believe in the fact that ‘monotony kills interest’.
NAFDAC (National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control) is an
organisation in Nigeria that is responsible for the importation, distribution,
manufacturing etc. of goods and will be responsible for assessing the product
quality, packaging and labelling and product benefits of Smarties such as
ensuring that everything is well labelled and does not have any misleading
information and will thoroughly inspect the product (NAFDAC, n.d.). Language
may not necessarily be a problem because English is one of the most common
languages in Nigeria and Smarties is essentially written in and advertised in
English. It may need to be converted into different languages though if it wants
to reach a majority of the country. It is advisable that the Smarties label and
the like is translated into the language of the three major ethnic groups,
Yoruba, Hausa and Igbo as they may not be able to translate it into all the
different ethnic languages and apart from English, these three are the most
commonly spoken.
Place Considerations:
Concerning the choice of distribution channel, I believe it is best to go through
the most common channel of distribution. From the producers (in Canada) to
the wholesalers, to retailers and then to the consumers. Buying in bulk and
selling through wholesalers is the most popular distribution channel in Nigeria
so it is advised that the distribution channel used is concentrated on the
middlemen like retailers, but mainly wholesalers and wholesalers are beneficial
in the importation of goods into Nigeria. E-distribution is known as the digital
process of spreading products, services and/or information through electronic
channels (Editorial Staff, 2024). As beneficial as using E-distribution could be,
Nigeria has not yet reached that level of development so it would not be
Oluseye 8
advised to use such means to properly distribute the products. Currently, there
is no branch of Smarties in Nigeria, or any country in Africa, so the company
would have to establish a place, preferably in a city as influential as Lagos or
Abuja, to open up shop and start selling. There are different types of licensing
agreements available in Nigeria such as copyright licence and trademark
licence, but there are also distribution licences put in place to give businesses
the opportunity to freely go through with business processes (Pavestones
Legal, 2023). Smarties will have to go through with company verification,
trademark, NAFDAC registration, Franchise and distribution agreement and a
Letter of Credit, before it can be fully assimilated into the country as a company
(Aluko, 2017). The Nigerian International Franchising Association is responsible
for franchising within the country, and they have defined franchising as a
business arrangement whereby the franchisor grants a franchisee permission
and rights to operate and distribute certain products or services in a specific
way, at a specific location for a specific period of time (Global Legal Group,
2024). The company would have to go through certain registration
requirements relating to the franchise system such as the use of trademarks,
supply of machinery and plant, supply of detailed engineer drawings, provision
of operating staff and the likes (Global Legal Group, 2024).
Pricing Considerations:
In terms of pricing, the best pricing strategy to use would be the penetration
pricing strategy. This is due to the fact that entering the market with a low price
would naturally attract consumers to the product. Nigeria has been facing large
periods of inflation throughout the years, where the prices of everything is high
and entering the market at a low price would naturally encourage consumers
to buy the product so even when the company decides to increase the price in
future, there would be many loyal customers who would be willing to buy the
product. Due to this, the demand for the product will be higher and the
company would have multiple opportunities to increase the price. It is heavily
advised that price skimming is completely avoided in this situation. The local
cost of labour in Nigeria is relatively low in comparison to other countries
(Iarossi et al., 2009). The minimum wage of work in Nigeria is currently
70,000NGN which amounts to $44 USD and $61.55 CAD, a reasonable price for
labour and if the company offers labour to multiple people they would not be
Oluseye 9
facing many significant losses (Varrella, 2021). Nigeria is rich in many resources
such as cocoa and milk which are essential in the production of Smarties, there
are many other resources that are readily available and could cause the
company to save the money that could have been wasted on having to import
said resources from somewhere else. This also ultimately reduces the overall
price for the consumers in Nigeria. In order to get capital, the minimum capital
base is NGN 500 billion which is $417,747,729.49 CAD so this price must be put
into consideration when trying to acquire capital (HKTDC Research, 2024). The
company would also have to consider overhead costs such as exchanging their
currency into the Naira to cover the salaries of the people, insurance and all
other things that may not directly be linked to the product. The company
would have to contact the Nigerian Chamber of Shipping, a trade association
that is concerned with the formulation, implementation and monitoring of
maritime affairs technical matters and whatnot (Nigerian Chamber of Shipping,
2017). The company would also have to consider the different shipping fees in
Nigeria. Packaging and Inspection are still covered by NAFDAC (National Agency
for Food and Drug Administration and Control) to ensure that everything is
properly regulated and will not cause harm to consumers. The legal fees, plus
additional costs, can range from a total of NGN 15,000 to NGN 150,000 or more
(counseal, 2024). These fees need to be put into consideration when trying to
create business there.
Promotion Considerations:
In terms of advertising, the Smarties company has invested in all sorts of
advertising methods, mostly focusing on advertisements, posters, shirts,
posters and the like. The colorfulness and vibrancy of not only the product
itself but also the ads will easily attract the attention of people and will be a
smart way to get potential customers. In Nigeria, brightness and diversity are
associated with good things. The eye-catching nature of the product will peak
multiple people’s interest and increase its popularity within the country.
Although, there are not really a lot of advantages associated with Smarties as a
chocolate company that make it stand out, Smarties compares to its
competitors such as KitKat and M&M’s through its engagement with social
media, it regularly interacts with its followers and has a pronounced social
media presence, which encourages buyers to purchase the product. Smarties
also finds a way to make its cover and product look extremely attractive, so
Oluseye 10
much so, people want to bite through their screens to get a taste (paulinaam,
2015). An advisable promotion tactic would be the creation of new ads,
tailored to suit the culture and customs of the country. Rather than using the
foreign advertisements, make the advertisement a little more personal and
make it pertain more to the Nigerian market and emphasising its success in
other countries. Also consider translating posters into more local languages and
using slang and phrases common to Nigerians to make them more interested
and engaged with the product.
Consumer Considerations:
The domestic target market demographic is mainly tweens and families.
Children will also be largely considered due to the fact that it is a chocolate
producing company. The demographic is children and pre-teens from the age
ranges of 6-12 as it is a convenient snack for people who like sugar. This love for
sugar is mostly found in children. Psychographic determinations are most likely
nostalgic and imagination driven. The child-like and youthful appearance of the
Smarties pack might cause people to become nostalgic and be encouraged to
buy the product or there could be people who are attracted to the creative and
imaginative nature of the product and become encouraged to buy the product.
Local cultural norms have a large part to play in all this as culture is one of the
most important things to Nigerians and they hold their cultures with pride and
high esteem. For example, celebrations and special occasions are always held
with utmost importance and extravagantly celebrated, if Smarties is to make
their brand available at these times or find a way to appeal to the entire
concept of the celebration, it would greatly influence people’s decision to buy
the products. This is also applicable in terms of education, seeing as intellectual
prowess is very valuable, so the whole concept of ‘Smarties’ and the slogan of
‘Only Smarties has the answer’ would cause people to automatically associate
it with being intellectually smart and encourage more people to buy it. In 2019,
24.16% of total household expenditure was spent on food consumed outside
the house (National Bureau of Statistics, 2019). The spending patterns of
Nigerians are usually planned and not all that impulsive, so it is essential that
the company gives them a reason to want to buy their product. Motivations of
domestic consumers include wanting to satisfy personal needs. This satisfaction
of personal needs mostly pertains to Maslow’s hierarchy of needs concerning
Oluseye 11
esteem. The satisfaction of slight hunger would lead to the purchase of goods
such as Smarties.
Competition Considerations:
Direct competition would be other chocolate brands such as M&M’s, Kinder Joy
eggs, KitKat and the like. Indirect competition includes locally made sweets
such as puff puff, chin-chin, coconut candy and other sweets that have been
locally made and will cause competition for profit in terms of money seeing as
they are all small snacks meant to satisfy personal needs. There are numerous
local markets in Nigeria that make a living off selling their local-made sweets.
They have more experience between Nigerians and have higher advantages
concerning production and distribution costs. They most likely would not have
to spend as much money in hiring labour or looking for distribution channels
and due to their time and experience in this field it is likely they will serve as a
significant competition to the newly arrived Smarties company. They also have
better insight into the local customs and culture of Nigeria and will have an
easier time appealing to the nature of Nigerians. The product Smarties has
significant product differentiation by means of their packaging which is unique
to them as well as their quality of packaging and the quality of the product
itself. The way the Smarties are made and presented also make it stand out in
comparison to other products in the market. Due to the fact that Smarties is a
relatively well-known brand outside of the country and around the world, it has
brand equity that will make it seem even more important and significant in
comparison to other brands. It is highly recognised world-wide not only for its
good quality but the simplicity and attractiveness of its design that would make
it stand out among competitors.
Conclusion
Reflection:
The 4P’s are to be thoroughly considered in terms of Product, Price, Promotion
and Place. The product quality, benefits, packaging, labelling and how the
product is manufactured and presented overall are to be extensively assessed
to ensure that they do not offend the customs and traditions of the country
and do not cause any harm to the consumers consuming the product. Place in
terms of capital, distribution channels (wholesalers), branch plants and
licensing agreements are to be carefully considered to ensure the best place is
Oluseye 12
used to gain the most influence and gain the most profit. Place is a significant
factor due to all the responsibilities surrounding it. Price is important because it
greatly affects the overall business procedures in terms of choosing an effective
pricing strategy that will appeal to Nigerians the most as well as the
accommodation of different costs e.g overhead, shipping, legal fees etc. By
taking this into consideration, the appropriate conversion can be made and the
planning of the product will go smoothly. The different conditions for each of
these costs based on the requirements of the country should be carefully
assessed and carried out. Promotion greatly affects how the company and the
product will be viewed by the general public. This includes means of
advertising that will mostly attract the attention of Nigerians and ensuring that
the advertisements are not demeaning or culturally offensive. For the
Consumer and Competition considerations, they are additionally, very
important factors to be considered. Concerning the consumer, they are always
right, so it is important that the Smarties brand ensures that the consumer is
always satisfied. This is done by understanding the consumer motivations and
trying to gain a deeper understanding of the consumer themself. Competition
is one of the most important things because once the competition is
understood, it will be easy coming up with strategies to overcome said
competition and dominate the market. This is done by acknowledging direct
and indirect competition as well as local competitive advantages and looking at
things such as product differentiation and brand equity which is a relatively
easy task in the country of Nigeria.
Ways Companies can use the 4P’s and 2C’s to Make Decisions :
Companies can use these concepts to make decisions about launching products
in the international market by;
1) Finding out consumer preferences: By applying the 4P’s and 2C’s, they
can understand what the consumers would want and be able to
ascertain and estimate exactly what they would need to ensure that the
consumers get exactly what they need. By doing this, they are assured
that the product will do successfully and be able to adapt the product
where needed to make sure they not only do not offend anyone but also
ensure that they appeal to the cultures and societal norms of that
particular market.
Oluseye 13
Reference List:
Aluko, N. (2017, August 3). The Legal Basics of Distributing Your Products In
Nigeria. KPA.
https://kpakpakpa.com/legal-basics-distributing-your-products-in-nigeria
/
Babamaagi, R., Shabu, H., Nsofor, C., Mbiaorga, G., Musa, A., Owan, V.,
Okunola, O., Chinyere , E., & Kadir , G. (2023, March 22). Nigeria Natural
Hazard Governance: Institutional Perspective. Natural Hazard Science.
https://oxfordre.com/naturalhazardscience/display/10.1093/acrefore/97
80199389407.001.0001/acrefore-9780199389407-e-448
Britannica. (2019). Abuja | Geography, Development, & Population.
Encyclopædia Britannica.
https://www.britannica.com/place/Abuja-national-capital-Nigeria
Canada, G. A. (2020, March 11). Canada-Nigeria relations. GAC.
https://www.international.gc.ca/country-pays/nigeria/relations.aspx?lan
g=eng
Candy Funhouse. (2019, July 29). Canadian vs American Smarties |
Candyfunhouse.ca. Candy Funhouse CA.
https://candyfunhouse.ca/blogs/around-the-funhouse/difference-betwe
en-canadian-and-american-smarties
counseal. (2024, April). Cost Of Business Registration In Nigeria (2024).
Counseal. https://counseal.com/cost-business-registration-nigeria/
Editorial Staff. (2024, May 13). E-Distribution. DevX.
https://www.devx.com/terms/e-distribution/
Embassy of Nigeria Sweden. (2023, March 10). NIGERIA GEOGRAPHICAL
INFORMATION - Embassy of Nigeria Sweden. Nigerian Embassy
Stockholm.
https://nigerianembassy.se/nigeria-geographical-information/
Folorunso, M. A., & Folorunso, S. A. (2022, January 1). Environmental
Degradation in Nigeria: The Challenges of Peaceful Co-existence. Springer
EBooks. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-92474-4_18
Fun, S. (2023, December 7). Nestlé Smarties: Fun Facts and History. Facts about
Sweets; Facts About Sweets.
Oluseye 15
https://www.factsaboutsweets.co.uk/blog/nestl%C3%A9-smarties-fun-fa
cts-and-history
Global Legal Group. (2024, October 22). International Comparative Legal
Guides. International Comparative Legal Guides International Business
Reports.
https://iclg.com/practice-areas/franchise-laws-and-regulations/nigeria
HKTDC Research. (2024, April 25). HKTDC Research. Hktdc.com.
https://research.hktdc.com/en/article/MTY3MjE1NDUwNQ
Iarossi, G., Mousley, P., & Radwan, I. (2009). D I R E C T I O N S I N D E V E L O P
M E N T Private Sector Development An Assessment of the Investment
Climate in Nigeria.
https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/555561468298481682/p
df/476070PUB0338855B01Official0Use0Only1.pdf
Ilich, I. (2013, July 2). Food Fight: U.K. vs. Canadian Smarties candy - NEAROF.
NEAROF.
https://www.nearof.com/food-fight-u-k-vs-canadian-smarties-candy/
LaVopa, J. (2021, January 27). 5 Social Issues Dividing Nigeria. The Borgen
Project. https://borgenproject.org/social-issues-dividing-nigeria/
Media Landscapes. (2018). Media Landscapes. Media Landscapes.
https://medialandscapes.org/country/nigeria/telecommunications/overv
iew#
Meshioye, D. (2024, June 14). Water pollution and economic growth. The
Guardian Nigeria News - Nigeria and World News.
https://guardian.ng/opinion/water-pollution-and-economic-growth/
MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS. (2022). The People – Ministry of Foreign
Affairs, Nigeria. Foreignaffairs.gov.ng.
https://foreignaffairs.gov.ng/nigeria/the-people/
NAFDAC. (n.d.). About NAFDAC. NAFDAC. https://nafdac.gov.ng/about-nafdac/
National Bureau of Statistics. (2019). Reports | National Bureau of Statistics.
Nigerianstat.gov.ng. https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/elibrary/read/1094
Nestle. (2018, March 8). https://www.madewithnestle.ca/smarties-0. Made
with Nestle. https://www.madewithnestle.ca/smarties-0
Nestle. (2024). Smarties. Nestlé Global.
https://www.nestle.com/brands/chocolate-confectionery/smarties
Oluseye 16
Nigerian Chamber of Shipping. (2017, January 29). About Us. Nigerian Chamber
of Shipping. https://nigerian-shipping.org/about/
Ogbuenyi, N. (2022a, February 3). Abuja at 46: The Dreams, Strides, Challenges.
Premiumtimesng.com.
https://www.premiumtimesng.com/features-and-interviews/509441-ab
uja-at-46-the-dreams-strides-challenges.html?tztc=1
paulinaam. (2015, January 21). The candies-chocolate battle: m&m’s, KitKat,
Kinder Bueno, Smarties. Prof Dr Ana Adi - Vives Erasmus Courses.
https://kathonewmedia.wordpress.com/2015/01/21/the-candies-chocol
ate-battle-mms-kitkat-kinder-bueno-smarties/
Pavestones Legal. (2023, October 20). INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LICENSING IN
NIGERIA. Pavestones Legal.
https://pavestoneslegal.com/intellectual-property-licensing-in-nigeria/
USAID. (2016, October 4). Democracy, Human Rights, and Governance | Nigeria
| U.S. Agency for International Development. Usaid.gov.
https://www.usaid.gov/nigeria/democracy-human-rights-and-governanc
e
Varrella, S. (2021, September 20). Nigeria: minimum wage 2018-2020. Statista.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1119133/monthly-minimum-wage-in
-nigeria/
WellaHealth. (2024, August 2). Calcium-Rich Nigerian Foods. WellaHealth.
https://www.wellahealth.com/blog/calcium-rich-nigerian-foods/
World Kids Travel Guide. (n.d.). Nigeria Facts | Geography for Kids | People |
Food | Economy | Animals. Www.kids-World-Travel-Guide.com.
https://www.kids-world-travel-guide.com/nigeria-facts.html
World Population Review. (2024a). Abuja, Nigeria Population 2024.
Worldpopulationreview.com.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/cities/nigeria/abuja
World Population Review. (2024b). Population of Cities in Nigeria 2024.
Worldpopulationreview.com.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/cities/nigeria
Worldometer. (2024). Nigeria Population - Worldometers. Worldometers.
https://www.worldometers.info/world-population/nigeria-population/