Cộng đồng có thể giúp đỡ những cựu chiến binh mắc PTSD như thế nào
Cộng đồng có thể giúp đỡ những cựu chiến binh mắc PTSD như thế nào
+RZ&RPPXQLWLHV&DQ+HOS9HWHUDQVZLWK3RVW7UDXPDWLF6WUHVV'LVRUGHU
%\
-XOLH7KRPDV
$WKHVLVVXEPLWWHGWRWKH8QLYHUVLW\+RQRUV3URJUDPDW6RXWKHUQ1HZ+DPSVKLUH8QLYHUVLW\WR
FRPSOHWH+21DQGDVSDUWRIWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVIRUJUDGXDWLRQIURPWKH8QLYHUVLW\+RQRUV
3URJUDP
0DQFKHVWHU1HZ+DPSVKLUH
0D\
$SSURYHGE\
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
)DFXOW\0HQWRU
8QLYHUVLW\+RQRUV'LUHFWRU
2
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
Abstract
How can communities better help veterans who are suffering from PTSD? Veterans of
our United States Military have long been affected by their service. What used to be called “shell
shock” or “battle fatigue” is known today as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder. They face a great
deal of stigma surrounding their PTSD and there are a variety of barriers to getting the care that
they need. Often, family members want to help but don’t know how. This paper looks into the
ways community members and family members of a veteran with PTSD can help him or her
assimilate into civilian life and cope with PTSD. Data collected will include a literature review
on what has already been tried successfully, what therapies are available, and a review of
A traumatic event can be a war, natural disaster, rape, a very serious accident, and more,
and often threatens survival. Because of the severe nature of trauma, for many, the event isn’t
over once it’s over. In the words of Bessel Van Der Kolk, an expert in the field, “…trauma is not
just an event that took place sometime in the past; it is also the imprint left by that experience on
the mind, brain, and body” (2015). After a traumatic event, some people cope well and are able
to move on. For many others, trauma impacts their lives severely, and can interfere with day-
today life.
To understand trauma, it’s helpful to look at how the brain reacts when faced with a
traumatic situation. The Polyvagal theory, developed by UNC Psychiatry Professor and trauma
expert Stephen Porges does just that. His theory postulates that our autonomic nervous system
has three branches, each of which is one possible response to trauma (Porges). One is
immobilization, one is fight-or-flight, and the third, found only in mammals, is a social
engagement system that detects signs of safety and communicates them (Porges).
Trauma, while physically invisible, has the power to affect the brain and body of an
individual in many ways. Trauma often involves the release of cortisol and adrenaline,
commonly known as stress hormones, in high doses and over long periods of time, (NICABM
2014) explains Dan Siegel, clinical professor of Psychiatry at UCLA school of medicine. While
these chemicals are meant to prepare our body for flight-or-flight to save us from life-threatening
situations, high doses of these chemicals can be toxic and alter brain function (NICABM 2014).
PTSD in History
Wars have been fought all throughout history, and soldiers have been affected by battle
all throughout history, but Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, or PTSD, is a relatively new term.
4
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
PTSD was always present, but only recently recognized. In the early 1900’s, it was given many
names, most commonly “battle fatigue”, shell shock”, “battle neurosis”, and more. Throughout
history, little was known about how to help returning soldiers suffering from “battle fatigue”, and
soldiers often came home to little help and suffered at the hands of their memories.
World War I produced the first diagnoses of “shell shock”, and the associated symptoms
were paralysis, blindness, and problems with sense of hearing, speech, and memories (Lovelace
2019). By World War II, one researcher described the symptoms of shell-shocked soldiers to be
cognitive disorder, emotional struggles, physical complaints, and hysteria (Lovelace 2019).
During World War I and World War II, it was commonly thought in the military that “battle
fatigue” only required hospitalization once total immobilization had been reached (Lovelace
2019). Another common belief was that a true case of “battle fatigue” rendered a solider
completely out of control in his actions (Lovelace 2019). This led to the unfortunate attitude for
many that soldiers were cowards or were faking “battle fatigue” and wanted an easy out. Soldiers
with a range of mental problems from their military service were all grouped as “shell shock”
General George Patton, who served in both World Wars, had a view of shell shock that
was typical of the time. Little information was available, but he did read a French medical review
of shell shock that suggested physical pain as a response to shell shock (Lovelace 2019). General
Patton is widely known for two incidences of slapping a supposedly shell-shocked soldier. The
first soldier, Private Charles Kuhl, was hospitalized after being very nervous, unable to stay on
the front lines, and sensitive to the noise of the weapons (Lovelace 2019). When General Patton
was making rounds on the hospitals, he encountered Private Kuhl, who said he “just couldn’t
take it anymore” (Lovelace 2019). General Patton responded by slapping Private Kuhl across the
5
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
face with his gloves and kicking him out of the hospital (Lovelace 2019). Undoubtedly, General
Patton’s actions were a result of the degree of medical knowledge available at the time. Later,
Private Kuhl was diagnosed with diarrhea and Malarial Fever (Lovelace 2019). General Patton
likely mistook Private Kuhl’s malarial fever symptoms for symptoms of hysteria associated with
shell shock. Today, Private Kuhl’s sensitivity to the weapon sounds would be well-known as a
PTSD Today
In the twenty-first century, Post Traumatic Stress Disorder is defined by the American
Psychological Association as “… a psychiatric disorder that can occur in people who have
terrorist act, war/combat, rape or other violent personal assault” (American Psychiatric
Association). An estimated 3.5% of American adults have PTSD, and it affects approximately
PTSD has a variety of symptoms, many that lead the individual to avoid any reminders of
the original traumatic event. The American Psychiatric Association divides the symptoms of
PTSD into four categories. The first is intrusive thoughts. A person living with PTSD may often
experience unwanted thoughts and memories surrounding the traumatic event. These can take the
form of very vivid flashbacks that feel realistic to the person with PTSD. The second category is
avoiding reminders of the traumatic event. This could be an avoidance of a person, event, place,
objects, or scenarios. The third category is negative thoughts and feelings. A person with PTSD
may suffer from very negative self-blaming thoughts, as if they believe they could have stopped
the event if they tried hard enough. They may experience a new perception of the world around
them, with much more fear and sense of danger than before. They may have comorbid
6
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
depression or anxiety. The fourth category of symptoms is arousal and reactive symptoms.
People with PTSD may become hyperaware of their surroundings and startle at the smallest
noises that are unexpected. Problems with memory and sleep patterns may also occur, as well as
Because military service often involves exposure to and participation in violent combat
and other scenarios that are highly traumatic, military veterans develop PTSD at an alarmingly
high rate. It’s almost impossible to pin down an exact number, but on average, military veterans
suffer from PTSD at approximately ten times the rate of civilians (Wharton, et al., 2019). While
the number of military veterans seeking care for PTSD has seemed to increase in recent years,
the VA estimated in 2016 that a third of veterans diagnosed with PTSD were treated for it
(Wharton, et al., 2019). Why are so many veterans suffering from PTSD without receiving care?
There are many barriers to receiving adequate care, including stigmatization, lack of support,
Barriers to Care
Stigma
One of the biggest reasons that military veterans do not seek help for their mental health
is the stigma that surrounds mental health care in the Unites States. Veterans do not come home
to a world that understands their trauma and is ready to help them heal. Not every veteran who
serves develops PTSD and needs services, so it is easy for a veteran suffering from PTSD to
compare himself or herself to a fellow veteran and wonder, “Why can’t I be fine? Why do I face
these internal struggles, and he or she doesn’t?”. Veterans may feel ashamed or weak for needing
help, especially if they are comparing themselves to their fellow veterans with different
experiences and diagnoses. Even in a case where two veterans both develop PTSD, they will
7
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
likely have a different presentation of symptoms that could lead each to believe that the other
doesn’t have PTSD. This sometimes leads to veterans thinking that it’s “all in their head” and
In addition to their own insecurities, veterans interviewed reported that the military
culture was one that mocked people who used mental healthcare services and told soldiers to
“suck it up” (Cheney 2018). Veterans were afraid of being labeled “crazy” or being thought of as
weak among their peers for using mental healthcare services. Some expressed a distrust in the
confidentiality of mental healthcare services, afraid of their diagnoses and private details of their
service being leaked, potentially causing embarrassment, lack of security clearance, and other
issues (Cheney 2018). Many veterans struggle to cope with some of their own actions during
their service and do not want anyone to know about them, lest they be judged.
For people suffering from PTSD, having a strong support system is pertinent. Doctors,
therapists, psychiatrists, support groups, sponsors, parents, friends, and spouses can all be
invaluable sources of support and encouragement for a veteran. Professional support persons,
like therapists and doctors, have medical and psychological training that lends an understanding
of PTSD and can offer positive support and healthy coping strategies. Personal support persons,
like friends and spouses, often lack that training and don’t know how to help their loved one. In
some cases, personal support persons may offer well-meaning advice or suggestions that are
persons in veterans’ therapies. The study found that not only can a veteran’s relationship with his
or her significant other influence whether or not he or she seeks mental health treatment, but
having a loved one who encourages the veteran to face situations or events that make them
8
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
nervous or uncomfortable, veterans were twice as likely to finish their treatment (Prolonged
exposure therapy and cognitive processing therapy were the two therapeutic modalities studied).
In prolonged exposure therapy and cognitive processing therapy, facing things that make the
client uncomfortable and nervous plays a large part in treatment (Thompson-Hollands 2019.
Because of the upsetting nature of the therapies, along with other reasons, veterans sometimes
The role of the support person was found to be very important to veterans, and many
veterans wished for increased family participation in their therapy (Thompson-Hollands 2019).
For some veterans, their families or support person may have psychology training or trauma-
informed care training and be able to support their veteran in a helpful way. In some cases,
though, families or support persons may not know how to help their veteran and may end up
Accessibility of Resources
Another barrier that veterans face when accessing mental health care treatment is a lack
of resources. In many rural communities, it can take forty-five minutes or more of travel to reach
a mental health care treatment facility. For some veterans, this can be a barrier if their schedule
does not easily allow for long drives. Often, though, the resources just are not plentiful enough to
keep up with the growing demand for mental health care services. This is true for many facets of
the mental health care industry, from eating disorder treatment to addiction counseling. Many
therapists, both in private practices and in clinical settings, have a full client caseload and have a
lengthy waitlist. The mental health care industry in the US is often overburdened and new clients
cannot find care immediately. For some, this could mean waiting months to receive much-
needed care. In one female-focused study, up to 40% of female veterans reported not always
9
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
being able to get an appointment for mental health care as soon as they need it though the VA
(article 6). Six percent of women reported never being able to get an appointment as soon as they
One interview revealed that may veterans don’t have faith in the mental healthcare
provided by the VA (Cheney 2018). One study found that as low as 20% of veterans use VA
healthcare as their primary healthcare provider, (Fuehrlein, B., et al. 2016) demonstrating
veterans’ lack of faith in the system. Interviewees reported having difficulty scheduling
appointments promptly, getting follow-up care, staying at the same facility, or even with the
same provider (VA healthcare facilities are often understaffed with a high turnover rate, possibly
from burnout) which lowered veterans’ confidence in VA mental healthcare. Additionally, many
reported that even before enrolling in VA healthcare, they struggled to understand their insurance
coverage options and steps to enroll. They were not educated on enrollment prior to leaving
service, and did not understand which forms to use to get the care they needed. Once enrolled,
they still experienced trouble understanding their benefits and how to use the system to meet
Another surprising barrier to care is a concern that veterans voiced about the military’s
policy to deny security clearance to service members who are known to use VA mental
healthcare services (Cheney 2018). This is likely due in part to the military culture of mocking
those who use mental healthcare services and of thinking of people using services as “weak”. It
is possible that higher-up service members create and sustain this culture on purpose to
Beyond the overburdened mental health care industry struggling to meet the growing
need for services for veterans, there are cultural differences in mental health treatment. Some
10
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
cultures view mental healthcare treatment as an admittance of weakness, and this could cause
veterans not to seek the help they need. Another factor is racism—unfortunately, racism can
play a part in getting treatment for those of ethnic minorities in some cases. It has been indicated
that veterans who identify as African American, Latino, and Asian or Pacific Islander are less
likely to receive treatment for PTSD at the same rates as white veterans, even after controlling
for veteran’s individual treatment beliefs, access to treatment, and the scope of treatment needed
How do we start to tackle the mountain of barriers to mental healthcare for veterans? A
great start would be to dismantle the stigma in the US about mental health. The US has a
negative stigma that those who struggle with their mental health are “making it up” or wanting
attention or are “crazy”. Fear of mental health often comes from a lack of understanding. More
education is needed about mental health disorders, treatments, and care. This isn’t true only for
the US. Some veterans of ethnic minorities come from other countries or are part of cultures that
originated in other countries where there is greater stigma about mental health. Some countries
have the belief that mental health isn’t something to be talked about, and when service members
have those beliefs, it makes it difficult for them to get the care they need. By increasing
awareness and spreading education about mental health worldwide, we can start to change
cultures worldwide to be more accepting of diverse mental health and start increasing treatment
The younger generations are starting to advocate for more mental health acceptance and
understanding on social media, which may help veterans of the younger generations feel more
11
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
encouraged to seek treatment. Posts often circulate on social media sites urging readers to take
care of their mental health, and to see a therapist if they feel it would help.
treatment, the US needs some changes to make the mental healthcare industry better suited to
handle the demand for services. Training more therapists and counselors in different specialties
would decrease waiting lists and make veterans more likely to be able to access a timely
appointment when needed. Opening more clinics and centers for mental health would also
increase service availability. The idea of urgent care clinics, but for mental health, is new. The
development would be invaluable to veterans who are suffering and cannot access timely
appointments.
Another way to help veterans with their mental health is to educate their support persons-
friends, family, significant others, parents, and children of veterans. Since we know that support
persons often want to help their veteran, but don’t know how, we can conclude that support
person education could be beneficial. Greater online resources could be available to support
persons wondering how to help their loved one with a recent diagnosis of depression, anxiety,
PTSD, or any other common mental health problem for veterans. There are already online groups
of military wives and spouses. If we take this idea of a support group and make it an in-person
support group with an instructor/leader trained in trauma informed care, we could help many
veterans’ support persons feel more confident about handling their loved one’s diagnosis and
trauma. This could help support persons feel more connected to their loved veteran, and in turn,
help their veteran feel less alienated and alone in their trauma, and hopefully help them feel more
could benefit from additional training. Mental healthcare providers are sometimes uninformed on
military culture and norms, and this could lead to service members and veterans feeling
estranged and misunderstood when trying to seek treatment. For care centers and clinics, hosting
professional development sessions specifically geared toward care of veterans and the unique
struggles they face could increase understanding and ultimately improve treatment for veterans.
Another way to better prepare mental health professionals for unique needs of veterans is
to have classes on veterans’ studies at universities at the undergraduate and graduate levels.
Many of our mental health professionals are coming from 4-year universities that do not have
any specialized classes in veteran’s studies and how to help them with their unique struggles
undergraduate and graduate programs would help better prepare mental health professions to
meet the needs of their clients, and perhaps increase the number of mental health professionals
available.
Veteran returning home face many issues, from mental health, to adjusting to a new
environment and their new role in it, to re-building their social lives, to finding new employment.
This can create a very stressful situation for returning veterans, particularly those with intense
mental health issues. Some veterans cope with these issues by drinking, and while it relieves the
stress temporarily, it often is the start of a much bigger problem that leads to alcohol use
disorder. Having mental health problems even in the general population can lead to an increased
risk of a co-morbid Alcohol or Substance Use Disorder, but especially for veterans who have
spent years immersed in military culture that promotes heavy drinking, it’s easy to see why
13
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
veterans are prone to Alcohol Use Disorder. The American Psychological Association reports
that persons with Alcohol Use Disorder have no reliable control over their drinking and often
cannot stop drinking once they’ve started (2012). The APA characterizes alcohol use disorders in
part by a person’s heightened tolerance to alcohol and the presence of withdrawal symptoms
The lifetime prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorder for veterans is estimated at forty-two
percent (Fuehrlein, B., et al. 2016). This translates to 2 out of 5 veterans having Alcohol Use
Disorder at some point in their lives. For a one-year snapshot, approximately fifteen percent of
veterans have Alcohol Use Disorder. How do these numbers compare to general population
statistics? The lifetime prevalence of Alcohol Use Disorder for the general population is
estimated at thirty percent, a 25% decrease from the rates for veterans (Fuehrlein, B., et al.
2016). In 2018, the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism estimated that
approximately five percent of adults had Alcohol Use Disorder in a single-year snapshot, and
that it was more prevalent in men than women. The NIAAA’s estimation was conducted from a
sample of adults in the general population, which includes veterans, so the comparison isn’t truly
of veterans to civilians, but it does a good job at showing the increased rate of Alcohol Use
Disorder in veterans.
One important study on veterans’ heightened alcohol use examined common co-morbid
disorders and life factors that are correlated with Alcohol Use Disorder using data from the
National Health and Resilience in Veterans Study (Fuehrlein, B., et al. 2016). The study found
that Alcohol Use Disorder in veterans is associated with higher rates of drug use disorders,
suicidality and suicide attempts, and comorbid psychological disorders, such as Depression,
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, and Anxiety disorders. Being younger in age, of the male sex,
14
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
and lower education levels were also found to be associated with Alcohol Use Disorder. A
similar study found an association between Substance Use Disorders (including alcohol and
other drugs) and increased suicidality. Going a step further, this study controlled for sex, and
found that the association is even stronger in females than in males (Bohnert 2017). The reason
for the difference in sex is not identified, but the information can be valuable to mental
How can we help veterans suffering from Alcohol Use Disorder? There isn’t one clear-
cut answer to solve the problem, but several steps that can be taken to help. The first way is to
start at the source, before the Alcohol Use Disorder takes hold. Military culture often normalizes
heavy drinking, and this can be the start of post-service alcohol abuse. Behaviors like binge
drinking and blacking out from drinking occur regularly and aren’t seen as the dangerous
behaviors that they are. Increased education about the dangers of alcohol abuse is a good start for
the military, as well as having substance use counselors more readily available.
Increasing mental healthcare services available while service members are in active duty
could help improve mental health and prevent or slow the course of mental illnesses, to decrease
the chances of veterans self-medicating later in life. Improving mental healthcare available to
veterans both during active duty and post-service has the potential to curb Alcohol Use Disorder
and lessen symptoms in part because other mental illnesses are often co-morbid with Alcohol
Use Disorder, so by treating the comorbid mental health challenges, a more healthy person
overall is created, and this leaves veterans in better health and more able to appropriately address
Alcoholics Anonymous can be a helpful resource for veterans struggling with alcohol
abuse, but we know that veterans are sometimes hesitant to use mental healthcare services
15
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
because of the stigma surrounding them. There are a lot of negative stereotypes about alcoholics,
such as them being lazy, uneducated, unwilling to fix themselves, fragile, or weak, and these are
all stereotypes that could deter a veteran from AA services, or make him or her believe that they
don’t “fit in” with the AA crowd, and therefore shouldn’t use their services.
A possible solution is to have an AA group that is meant specifically for veterans. This
could help them feel more as if they belong, and less alone in their struggles, by surrounding
general US population (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2019). For veterans, who we
know have higher rates of mental illnesses, suicide rates are approximately 50% higher than the
general population (Hammond, et al., 2013). In the general population, an individual’s risk for
suicide increases if he or she has mental illnesses, and this is true for the veteran population as
well. Because veterans are prone to service-related disorders, such as depression, anxiety, Post-
Traumatic Stress Disorder, and substance use disorders, among others, this accounts for some of
the difference in suicide rates between the general population and the veteran population.
While mental illnesses are correlated with increased risk for suicide, there is also research
that the correlation works in the opposite direction, too. An article by Cerel, et al., published in
2015, found that half of veterans had been exposed to suicide. Cerel and colleagues found that
those who were exposed to suicide had double the chance of having depression, and more than
twice the risk of having anxiety, compared to their peers who have not been exposed to suicide.
Additionally, having been exposed to suicide made veterans more than twice as likely to report
16
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
suicidal ideation than those who were not exposed to suicide. Increased closeness to the person
When veteran suicide is discussed, it cannot be thought of in the same way as civilian
suicide. When precipitating factors and risk profiles were analyzed between veteran and non-
veteran populations in relation to suicide, substantial differences were found (Wood, et al., 2020)
that can be helpful in implementing suicide prevention strategies for veterans. Some
recommendations for suicide prevention include increasing economic support to ensure housing
stability, ensure insurance coverage for mental illness treatment, reduced access to means of
suicide, (guns, poison, etc.) increase community engagement, education on positive coping
skills, and strengthening of interpersonal relationships (Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention, 2013).
There are a lot of available resources on the internet for veteran suicide prevention. But,
with any resources available on the internet, some are of higher quality than others. When these
available resources were evaluated for safe messaging, usability, readability, and credibility,
researchers found that many were lacking in readability and credibility and could be improved
with more safety information about lethal means (Chen, et al., 2019).
Because the problem of veteran suicide scaffolds off of other mental health problems
among veterans—like poor access to healthcare, mental health stigma, and substance use and
dependency—the solution to the problem of veteran suicide scaffolds, likewise, off the solutions
to other mental health problems among veterans. If appropriate adjustments are made to improve
veterans’ mental health concerns, in turn, the rate of veteran suicides would decrease.
17
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
Therapy Modalities
Because Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder has only in recent years been properly named
and identified, therapy modalities suitable for veterans with PTSD (and possibly other comorbid
EMDR Therapy
reprocessing, or EMDR. The creator of EMDR, Francine Shapiro, was taking a walk in the
woods and happened to notice that her anxiety settled after performing quick side-to-side eye
movements. After trying this technique with her patients and observing success, EMDR was
born. Side-to-side eye movement is the hallmark of EMDR therapy, thought the technique has
(Whitehouse 2018). This is based on the idea that traumatic memories are unique in the way they
are stored and cannot adapt (Whitehouse 2018). There have been claims that EMDR is an
effective therapy for many different types of trauma and mental illnesses, veterans and PTSD
among them. After comparing many different peer-reviewed studies of EMDR being performed,
Whitehouse confirmed that while more research is still needed, particularly in sub-groups of
population who may benefit from EMDR, it has potential to be an effective therapy, if done
correctly (2018).
Even with research supporting EMDR as an effective therapy, there are multiple
competing therapies. One is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, or CBT. CBT is sometimes thought
18
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
of as “traditional” therapy and is one of the most common therapy modalities offered today.
There are subsets of CBT, such as Trauma-Focused CBT (TF-CBT) and Integrated CBT (ICBT).
CBT has proven effective for veterans as well as for children of veterans, who are in a unique
position that leaves them vulnerable to a few traumas and mental illnesses (Ridings, Moreland, &
Petty 2019). One study, however, suggested that ICBT may be less effective for veterans than in
the general population, (Capone, et al. 2018) but since that study was limited to only Iraq and
Afghanistan veterans who has comorbid PTSD and Substance Use disorders, the results of that
study cannot necessarily be generalized to compare the effects of CBT for all veterans to the
effects of CBT for the civilian population. In the interest of finding the superior therapy
modality, Moghadam, et al., set up a study in 2020 designed to test the effectiveness of EMDR
After gathering a sample of eighty veterans who all met the criteria for PTSD based on
the Mississippi Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Questionnaire, forty subjects were randomly
assigned to receive EMDR therapy, and forty were randomly assigned to receive CBT therapy.
Each group underwent eight weeks of therapy. The treatment methods for both EMDR and CBT
therapy were uniform, to ensure reliable data. The results found that when comparing both
therapy groups to a control group, both therapies were effective in treating PTSD. When
comparing CBT and EMDR directly, EMDR was proven to be more effective in treating PTSD
(Moghadam 2020).
EMDR is a relatively new therapy modality but shows promise in treating PTSD in
veterans. While more research is needed to support effectiveness claims and find the best
deliverance, making the therapy more accessible to veterans could certainly help those suffering
from PTSD.
19
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
Prolonged Exposure Therapy
Prolonged exposure therapy is another fairly recent therapy modality that has shown
some promise in treating clients with trauma. According to the American Psychological
Association, prolonged exposure therapy is based on the idea that symptoms of PTSD can be
reduced by changing the client’s response to fearful stimuli. Many people with PTSD avoid any
reminder of their trauma that occurs in their environment, because they interpret the stimuli as
Owen Hunt of Grey’s Anatomy. The combat veteran from Iraq suffered from PTSD and actively
avoided stimuli that reminded him of his trauma. One night, Owen awoke to the blades of the
ceiling fan spinning, and the stimuli reminded him of a helicopter in Iraq. Because he interpreted
the stimuli as fearsome, he reacted by choking his sleeping partner (McKee, 2009). If the client’s
response to these stimuli can be neutralized, the symptoms of PTSD have been shown to
decrease. In the case of Owen Hunt, the goal would be for him to be faced with the fearful
stimuli (the blades of the ceiling fan spinning) and to not have a fearful reaction (American
Initial sessions typically involve psychoeducation, where a background of trauma and the
2017) (Tuerk, et al., 2011). A trustful therapeutic relationship is important, given the nature and
difficulty of the therapy. The prolonged exposure comes in two forms, imaginal exposure, and in
vivo exposure. Imaginal exposure is done in session with the client and therapist together. The
client vividly pictures the traumatic experience as if they are re-living it, and describes it in
detail. Together, the therapist and client talk about emotions that occur as the client is imagining
the traumatic experience, and process the emotions as they come up. Sessions are audio recorded
20
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
so that they client has access to them at home to continue processing emotions (American
In vivo exposure is the at-home counterpart of imaginal exposure. The client and
therapist together come up with possible stimuli to confront that are relevant to the client’s
trauma. Exposure should be gradual so as to set the client up for success and to have a positive
experience (American Psychological Association 2017). In the case of Owen Hunt, the stimuli
would the fan blades spinning, perhaps on a low setting, and to face the stimuli during the day in
a calm setting to retain control over his emotions and make it a positive experience (McKee
One study in 2011 sought to analyze the effectiveness of prolonged exposure therapy
specific to Afghanistan and Iraq veterans (Tuerk, et al). The study treated 65 veterans from
Operation Enduring Freedom and Operation Iraqi Freedom and used a self-assessment before
and after therapy measuring PTSD symptoms as they’re listed in the DSM-IV. Results showed
that the treatment significantly reduced PTSD symptoms, and that the therapy could be used
effectively (Tuerk, et al 2011). Their participation rates suggested that it could be a preferred
therapy modality, as the dropout rate was relatively low (Tuerk, et al 2011).
understand what makes a client more likely to dropout. Using this information, hopefully therapy
modalities can be improved to be more accessible and to minimize dropout rates and help more
veterans who need it. A recent study examining dropout rates of prolonged exposure therapy
defined “dropout” as attending fewer than the minimum number of sessions to be considered
adequate, which is 8 (Eftekhari, et al. 2020). When clinicians were asked to report dropout rates
21
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
and reasons, numbers showed that the client’s amount of progress made was not a predictor of
dropping out. A majority of dropouts were unable to tolerate treatment or avoided treatment.
This category made up the largest group of dropouts. Being younger in age presented a higher
chance of dropping out, and interestingly, clients being treated for childhood traumas were less
likely to dropout than those being treated for combat trauma (Eftekhari, et al. 2020).
Prolonged Exposure therapy shows promise for treating trauma, and has been shown to
help veterans suffering from PTSD. Given the intense and difficult nature, it will not be ideal for
all veterans. The homework assignments could be another barrier that inhibits success with PE
therapy. Despite this, it is a great tool for those who can commit to homework assignments to
Therapeutic Horsemanship
Veterans are as diverse a group as the civilian population, and different therapies suit
different personality types. For those who may have hesitations about traditional talking therapy
modalities or who feel the stigma of going to a therapist or mental health center, therapeutic
International. Therapeutic horsemanship can take place through therapeutic riding lessons,
driving lessons, hippotherapy, and equine facilitated learning and psychotherapy. Therapeutic
horsemanship benefits a diverse range of clients, and certainly, veterans suffering from PTSD. A
qualitative review of one therapeutic horsemanship program found that the veterans liked it for
three main reasons- the horses, the connections formed with other veteran participants, and the
difference from traditional talking therapy in an office (Krob 2016). Evidence supported the
22
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
possibility for a positive, transformative experience for not just the veterans, but the instructors
and volunteers as well (Krob 2016). As for the participating equines, their body language
expressed that they were content, and veterans seemed to enjoy the connection with them (Krob
2016). The healing properties of horses are difficult to express on a page but are felt by veterans
therapy for veterans and yielded impressive results (Wharton, et al. 2019). Combining the talking
component of cognitive processing therapy with the horse’s natural ability to reflect human
Example session 4: Focuses on the participant telling a story of trauma, with as much
sensory detail, and emotional recall as possible. The individual will be coached and
supported in feeling emotions related to the event and continuing in the telling of the
story.
Suggested equine exercise: The participant selects and grooms a horse from the prior
sessions. As before, the horse will be held or tied as per the horse handler’s safety-based
decision and the individual will be given a curry comb as well as a soft brush and
instructed briefly on the use of these items. The participant will curry in a circular motion
and brush in lengthwise strokes during the session. Participant is aske Socratic questions
by the therapist as they groom the horse. If the participant has difficulty with the Socratic
questions about his/her memories of the event, the participant will be asked to
anthropomorphize the behavior of the horses as observed in the previous sessions, and
this can be a springboard to relate to the participant’s own memories of his/her event.
23
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
(Wharton, et al. 2019).
Two pre- and post-tests were used to assess PTSD symptoms and trauma-related guilt,
and veteran participants in the EF-CPT showed improvement in both categories after completing
therapy, as well as demonstrating good bonds with their equine partners (Wharton, et al. 2019).
Equine facilitated therapy is a great alternative to traditional talk therapy, from which some
veterans are discouraged by the stigma around mental health in the US. Therapeutic riding is also
a great way for veterans to re-connect with their bodies, as it requires a keen awareness of the
rider’s body and the way it is used to give cues to the horse.
The VA
One of the most well-known resources available to veterans is the United States
Department of Veteran Affairs, or the VA. The VA follows a mission statement as follows: “To
fulfill President Lincon’s promise ‘To care for him who shall have borne the battle, and for his
widow, and for his orphan’ by serving and honoring the men and women who are America’s
veterans” (United States Department of Veteran Affairs). The VA strives to meet this goal by
providing four avenues of care: a healthcare networking that serves over nine million veterans
annually, a benefits package and assistance with education, loans, and insurance, a special burial
and the maintenance of cemeteries for veterans, and to prepare the nation to respond to war and
national emergencies (United States Department of Veteran Affairs). The VA has a crisis line at
1-800-273-8255.
The National Center for PTSD is a smaller organization that is part of the VA. It is very
informational and contains the definition and symptoms of PTSD, available treatment methods
24
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
and their success rates, and an informational database to support the treatment of PTSD (United
States Department of Veteran Affairs). Through their website, a veteran can request a
consultation, as well as find information about local counselors, support groups, and coping
skills (United States Department of Veteran Affairs). Veterans aren’t the only group who can
benefit from the website- there is information for healthcare providers, as well as for friends and
family (United States Department of Veteran Affairs). The information for friends and family
makes the National Center for PTSD a particularly valuable resource because not many
resources also help friends and family. Additionally, the website has general information on
Liberty House
The Liberty House is a transitional living facility for homeless veterans in Manchester,
New Hampshire. It offers housing, meals, clothing, and assistance to those getting back on their
feet after serving our country. Drug tests are required and there is a zero-tolerance policy for any
substance use. Residents follow the Liberty House’s four-step model, which consists of recovery,
health and wellness, employment, and housing (Liberty House). As veterans get back on their
feet, they give half of their pay to the Liberty house from their job, if they work. When they
leave, they get their earnings back, to help jump start them into an independent life.
The Liberty House takes no federal or state funding, and relies on community donations.
These donations often come from fellow veterans, some former residents. The food pantry is
well stocked and the clothing section is quite plentiful with donated clothing items of all seasons
Swim with a Mission is a non-profit organization started by Phil and Julie Taub to raise money
for veterans who are in need. Their primary fundraising event is a swim across Newfound Lake
that raises money and draws a crowd of swimmers and volunteers (Swim with a Mission). Since
then, additional events have been added, like a team-building day led by Navy SEALs, followed
by a paint-ball exercise (Swim with a Mission). Focusing on changing to meet the changing
needs of veterans, the organization has shifted to focus on securing service dogs for veterans and
hosting informational fundraising events surrounding dogs at work (Swim with a Mission). The
organization conducts photoshoots and interviews with veterans to be featured on their website,
Military One Source is a resource for military families funded by the Department of Defense.
They do not charge for services and are available twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week
(Military One Source). Services include relationship and financial counseling, mental health
counseling, childcare assistance, document translation, access to a digital library, health and
wellness coaching, and education and career benefits for military spouses and guidance on how
to use these benefits. (Military One Source). They also have a live chat available and a crisis
line, as well as confidential help (Military One Source). This is a resource with a great deal of
knowledge for military families and can help locate resources families need.
For veterans who are facing a mental health crisis, the Suicide Prevention Lifeline can
offer immediate support via their crisis hotline at 1-800-273-8255. What makes the Suicide
26
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
Prevention Lifeline a great resource is the accessibility that most resources lack. Not only does it
have the typical crisis hotline, but it caters to deaf and hard of hearing clients with a chat option
as well (Suicide Prevention Lifeline). This is a great addition, as some veterans partially or fully
lose their hearing ability in the line of duty. They also have help available in Spanish, further
increasing accessibility for those who either do not speak English or feel more comfortable
The Suicide Prevention Lifeline is well prepared to help with a variety of life challenges
that callers may be struggling to cope with. They have specific resources and information
available for youth considering suicide, survivors of disasters, Native Americans, Veterans, those
who have experienced loss, LGBTQ+ individuals, and suicide attempt survivors (Suicide
Prevention Lifeline). Having these nuanced resources makes the site a great resource as veterans
may fall into several of these categories and need help coping with the culmination of them.
To help those who are struggling feel less alone, the website has a section called “Stories
of Hope and Recovery” (Suicide Prevention Lifeline). There are multiple categories of heart-
warming stories, including addiction, military sexual trauma, serious mental illnesses, anxiety,
gender identity, sexuality, borderline personality disorder, PTSD, depression, recent suicide
attempts, eating disorders, self-harm, suicidal thoughts, suicide loss survivor, and Traumatic
Brain Injury (Suicide Prevention Lifeline). This is valuable because those who suffer from
mental health problems often feel heavily stigma that may prevent them from getting help, and
these stories of hope can help them feel less alone. Visitors to the site can even find stories of
people overcoming the same thing they are struggling with, and hopefully, fell less alone and
Veterans Services organization, with chapters located in the Lakes Region, Manchester, Nashua,
the Seacoast, and the Upper Valley (Veterans Count). Veterans Count has partner organizations
in Massachusetts, Maine, Vermont, and Rhode Island. The organization helps with many facets
of military and veteran life, and provides substantial financial assistance for car repairs, food,
medical and dental procedures, rent and utility payments, and other needed assistance. In January
of 2020, Veterans Count provided over $28,000 in financial relief to struggling veterans and their
Fallen Patriots
Fallen Patriots is an organization that aspires to honor service members killed in the line
of duty by offering tuition assistance and educational counseling to the children of fallen service
members (Fallen Patriots). Fallen Patriots believes that a college education is the greatest gift
they can give to children who have lost a parent in the line of duty, and that that is the best way
to honor fallen service members. When the founder of Fallen Patriots watched a service member
die during duty just days before Christmas, and after research showed that many families of
fallen veterans struggle to make ends meet and often make less than $50,00 a year, Fallen
Patriots was founded. Affording a college degree on $50,000 per year can be very challenging,
so Fallen Patriots gives over $6,000 per year to each student (Fallen Patriots). This is a great
resource for families of veterans to help secure a brighter future for children who lost a parent in
For many service members, finding housing can be a challenge, especially affordable
housing for veterans who may be unable to work due to injuries sustained in the line of duty.
Operation FINALLY HOME seeks to aid these veterans by building mortgage-free homes for
veterans and their families. Most of the veterans who receive homes have been wounded or
became ill, or are families of deceased veterans, but veterans who were not injured or ill from
their service are eligible as well, as long as they were honorably discharged and have financial
need (Operation FINALLY HOME). Also on their website is a list of past families homes that
were built and stories of each veteran’s sacrifice (Operation FINALLY HOME). This is a great
resource for veterans who have a financial need for a home and who are adjusting back into
CreatiVets
For veterans who struggle to express their feelings with words, CreatiVets offers an
artistic expression instead, through songwriting, visual arts, songwriting, and music. This can be
a great tool for those suffering from PTSD, as they are often unable to express themselves with
words, and artistic methods can be a great substitute expression. The work done at CreatiVets
has been shown to help reduce symptoms of PTSD and is accessible because it allows veterans to
seek help while avoiding the stigma associated with seeking mental health treatment
(CreatiVets).
War Paints
Created by a Navy SEAL in 2016, War Paints is an organization that encourages veterans
to use their artistic abilities to express themselves, and to develop these abilities thoroughly (War
Paints). The organization seeks to help veterans re-integrate themselves into civilian life while
29
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
focusing on their strengths and artistic abilities rather than their limitations or struggles (War
Paints). The organization seeks to host classes and skill development workshops for veterans, as
well as accepting donation of artistic supplies. On the website, buyers can browse and purchase
art created by veterans in many artistic expressions, including photography, painting, drawing,
org.ezproxy.snhu.edu/10.1037/tra0000484
Fuehrlein, B., et al. (2016). The burden of alcohol use disorders in US military veterans:
results from the National Health and Resilience in Veterans Study. Society for the
Hammond, K.W., Laundry, R.J., O’Leary, T.M., & Jones, W. P. (2013). Use of Text Search
10.1109/HICSS.2013.586
Krob, K. E. (2016). Heroes and horses: Veteran and equine experiences with equine facilitated
learning and therapy [ProQuest Information & Learning]. In Dissertation Abstracts
International Section A: Humanities and Social Sciences 77(3–A(E)).
Liberty House. (n.d.). Resources. Libertyhousenh.org. https://libertyhousenh.org/resources/
Lovelace, A. (2019). “Slap Heard around the World”: George Patton and Shell Shock.
Parameters 49(3) 79-91.
Mckee, S. (Writer) & Ornelas, E. (Director). (2009, March 26). Elevator Love Letter (5, 19)
[TV series episode]. In B Beers (Executive Producer). Grey’s Anatomy. American
Broadcasting Company.
Military One Source. (n.d.). How Can We Help? Militaryonesource.mil.
32
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
https://www.militaryonesource.mil/all-the-
ways?gclid=CjwKCAjw4pT1BRBUEiwAm5QuR3_1VplzRWWQfvlDXUagEhytX6Cg
UtSeiG61eztcb_nzvJKZgpLGtBoCtfIQAvD_BwE
Moghadam, S. A., Kazemi, R., Taklavi, S., & Naiem, M. (2020). Comparing the effectiveness
of eye movement desensitization reprocessing and cognitive behavioral therapy
in reducing post-traumatic stress disorder. Health Psychology Report 8(1), 31-37.
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. (n. d.). Alcohol Use Disorder.
Niaaa.nih.gov. https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-
consumption/alcohol-use-disorders
NICABM. (2014, November 7). Trauma’s Impact on the Brain. [Video]. Youtube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_aleVtn23o
Operation FINALLY HOME. (n.d). Turning a Hero’s Hardship into a Home.
Operationfinallyhome.org. https://www.operationfinallyhome.org/
Porges, Stephen. (n. d). Stephen Porges: Survivors are Blamed because they don’t fight.
porges-interview-survivors-are-blamed-polyvagal-theory-fight-flight-psychiatry-ace
https://vetscount.org/nh/about/chapters/
https://vetscount.org/nh/about/
Wharton, T., Whitworth, J., Macauley, E., & Malone, M. (2019). Pilot testing a manualized
org.ezproxy.snhu.edu/10.1037/prj0000359
Whitehouse, J. (2018). What do clients say about their experiences of EMDR in the research
10.1016/j.ejtd.2019.03.002.
Wood, D. S., Wood, B.M., Watson, A., Sheffield, D., & Hauter, H. (2020). Veteran Suicide
34
HOW COMMUNITIES CAN HELP VETERANS WITH PTSD
Risk Factors: A National Sample of Nonveteran and Veteran Men Who Died by
http://dx.doi.org.ezproxy.snhu.edu/10.1093/hsw/hlz037
https://www.va.gov/ABOUT_VA/index.asp
United States Department of Veteran Affairs. (n.d.). PTSD: National Center for PTSD.
Ptsd.va.gov. https://www.ptsd.va.gov/
Van Der Kolk, B. A. (2015). The Body Keeps the Score. Penguin Books.