Vitremer Luting TPP
Vitremer Luting TPP
Vitremer™
Luting Cement
Technical Product Profile
2
3
Components .............................................................................. 7
Indications ................................................................................ 7
Properties ............................................................................... 10
Solubility ............................................................................................... 11
Fracture Toughness .............................................................................. 11
Radiopacity .......................................................................................... 12
Fluoride Release ................................................................................... 13
Adhesion .............................................................................................. 14
pH ......................................................................................................... 16
Ease of use ........................................................................................... 17
Strength ................................................................................................ 19
Instructions ............................................................................ 21
Description Vitremer luting cement consists of two components, a powder and a liquid
of Vitremer like the other products in the 3M glass-ionomer line. The powder is mixed
Luting Cement with the liquid in a 1:1 drop:scoop ratio within 30 seconds. The resulting mix
is mousse-like and is easily scooped off the pad for placement in the crown or
bridge retainers. Working time is 2.5 minutes. After placement of the crown or
bridge, excess cement may be removed from the margins after a minimum of
3 minutes.
This product passes all ISO 9917:1991 (E) requirements for glass-ionomer
luting cements. These requirements include a maximum film thickness of 25
microns, setting time between 2.5 and 8 minutes, minimum compressive
strength of 70 MPa, and acid erosion of less than 0.05 mm/hour.
This system is based on the chemistry of Vitremer Core Buildup/Restorative
product. However, Vitremer luting cement is not light curable. Two setting
reactions do take place in this system, an acid-base reaction between the
fluoroaluminosilicate glass and the polycarboxylic acid (i.e., a true glass
ionomer setting reaction) and a free radical polymerization of the pendant
methacrylate groups of the polymer and HEMA (2-hydroxyethylmethacrylate).
The free radical polymerization reaction takes place without the need for light
activation (a methacrylate dark cure) via the same patented water-activated
redox catalyst system (US Patent 5,154,762) found in 3M Vitremer Core
Buildup/Restorative. FTIR (Fourier Transform Infrared) spectroscopy con-
firms the presence of both a glass ionomer and a methacrylate cure during
setting. Because of this chemistry, Vitremer luting cement can, therefore, be
classified as a hybrid glass-ionomer cement.
Components The Vitremer luting cement powder is composed of a radiopaque, fluoroalum-
7
inosilicate glass. It contains a microencapsulated potassium persulfate and
ascorbic acid catalyst system providing the methacrylate cure without the
need for light (i.e., methacrylate dark cure). The powder also contains small
amounts of an opacifying agent to aid in distinguishing the cement from tooth
structure.
The glass-ionomer liquid is an aqueous solution of polycarboxylic acid
modified with pendant methacrylate groups, i.e., the copolymer used in
Vitrebond liner/base and Vitremer Core Buildup/Restorative. It also contains
HEMA and water and small amounts of tartaric acid (which initially slows the
glass ionomer reaction, affording a snap set). This can be considered a type
of hydrous glass ionomer cement because the polycarboxylic acid moiety is
contained in the aqueous liquid.
The powder and liquid are mixed in a 1.6:1 (w/w) ratio (1 scoop:1 drop).
While the composition of both the powder and the liquid is similar to
Vitremer Core Buildup/Restorative, the actual concentration of each compo-
nent differs. As such, combining these systems is not recommended. Final
properties of the cement, e.g., low film thickness, strength, solubility, etc.,
have been optimized in this cement formulation. These properties, and many
more, may be adversely effected if the two systems are combined.
• Metal inlays, onlays or crowns • Clean tooth with oil-free pumice paste, rinse and dry.
• Orthodontic appliances.
Mixing:
Liquid Powder • Mix all of the powder aggressively into the liquid.
• Continue mixing until all of the powder is incorpo-
rated into the liquid, about 30 seconds.
Placement:
• Seat the crown.
• Wait at least 3 minutes after placement.
Please refer to instructions for more detailed information as well as, precautionary and warranty information.
3M Technical Hotline 1-800-634-2249 © 1994 3M
Bridge Cementation
3 9
VitremerTM Luting Cement
Indications: Tooth Preparation:
• Luting porcelain-fused-to-metal crowns and bridges to • Remove provisional restoration.
tooth structure, amalgam, composite or glass ionomer
core buildups. • Remove all temporary cement.
• Metal inlays, onlays or crowns • Clean tooth with oil-free pumice paste, rinse and dry.
• Do not desiccate the tooth.
• Pre-fabricated and cast posts.
• Orthodontic appliances.
Placement:
• Seat the bridge.
• Wait at least 3 minutes after placement.
• Remove excess with an appropriate instrument.
Please refer to instructions for more detailed information as well as, precautionary and warranty information.
3M Technical Hotline 1-800-634-2249 © 1994 3M
10 Properties Vitremer luting cement was designed to be the cement of choice for routine
crown and bridge procedures. As such, comparisons will be made with the
major competitive products that are used for routine cementations. These are:
Conventionally setting glass ionomer luting cements
KETAC-CEM® RADIOPAQUE (ESPE)
Fuji I (GC International)
GlasIonomer Cement, Type I (Shofu, Inc.)
AquaCem (Dentsply)
Zinc phosphate
Fleck’s® (Mizzy)
Polycarboxylate cement
DURELON® (ESPE)
Poly-F Plus (Dentsply)
The fourth class of cements, resins (e.g., Panavia®, Kuraray Co., LTD. and C
& B Metabond™, Parkell), are more frequently used as a secondary cement in
the office. Resin cements are not typically used for routine cementation
procedures, however comparisons, where appropriate, are given.
For the purposes of this profile, the following abbreviations are used:
Name Abbreviation
µm/hour
50
40
30
20
Figure 1.
10
Lactic Acid
Erosion 0
) B
EM
EX
em
N
er
:1
s
)
w
:1
k'
O
ji
.4 &
om
ne
Fu
-C
aC
ec
EL
a
.6
(1 C
vi
I(
on
C
Fl
(1
qu
R
na
A
ji
U
sI
ET
A
Fu
Pa
D
la
Vitremer Luting
G
Fracture Toughness
Fracture toughness is defined as the ability of a material to resist propaga-
tion of an initiated crack. As shown in Figure 2, the conventional glass-
ionomer products and polycarboxylate cements and are very brittle, i.e.,
have a low fracture toughness. The zinc phosphate specimens all broke
during sample preparation, as such, the fracture toughness could only be
estimated. The
fracture tough- 1.4
ness of Vitremer
luting cement is 1.2
products. In fact, it
K1c (MN/m^1.5)
typical resin
0.6
systems such as
Panavia EX or 3M
0.4
Restorative Z100.
Figure 2. 0.2
Fracture
Toughness 0
I
00
t)
d)
EM
us
LC
er
EX
em
ji
's
w
en
O
Z1
te
k
Fu
om
ne
Pl
-C
aC
ec
EL
er
a
ar
en
vi
I(
F
on
C
em
Fl
sp
qu
na
A
ly
ji
U
sI
ig
an
ET
A
tr
Fu
Po
Pa
D
la
Vi
(p
(tr
K
B
&
&
C
C
12 Radiopacity
Radiopacity was determined in accordance with ISO specification 4049. In
this specification, the radiographic density of the test material is compared
and normalized to that of a 2 mm thickness of aluminum. A value greater
than or equal to one indicates the material is radiopaque. A value less
than one indicates the material is radiolucent. Radiopacity is important during
crown and bridge procedures for two reasons, it allows the doctor to discover
any residual excess material subgingivally and allows the doctor to discover any
marginal discrepancies. As shown in Figure 3, Vitremer luting cement is
radiopaque, whereas several other cements (i.e., AquaCem, GlasIonomer and
C&B Metabond) are not. In the field evaluation, 98% of the respondents
stated Vitremer luting cement was distinguishable from tooth structure under
X-ray.
3.5
2.5
radiopacity
1.5
0.5
Figure 3.
Radiopacity 0
) ) ) B
EM
um
er
us
N
em
:1 :1 :1
s
)
I
50
:1
k'
O
ji
.2 .4 .8 &
om
Pl
Fu
P-
aC
-C
ec
in
EL
.6
(1 (1 (1 C
um
on
C
Fl
(1
qu
R
ly
U
sI
al
ET
Po
D
la
——Vitremer Luting——
m
G
m
2
Fluoride Release 13
One of the key features of true glass-ionomer cements is their sustained
fluoride release. It is generally believed that this release of fluoride aids in the
prevention of secondary caries which may be difficult to detect under a crown
or bridge. Fluoride release was measured in-vitro in a buffer solution using a
fluoride-ion-specific electrode. As evidenced by Figures 4 and 5, the fluoride
release of Vitremer Luting Cement is typical of true glass-ionomer cements.
Figure 4 is a composite of two separate fluoride release studies. As the
fluoride release of Ketac-Cem in both of these studies was similar, the data
was combined to produce this summary graph. Figure 5 demonstrates the
fluoride release of Vitremer luting cement is not effected by differing powder
liquid ratios.
Vitremer Luting 1.6:1
KETAC-CEM
GlasIonomer
4000 DURELON
Fuji I
3500
3000
µg F / g Sample
2500
2000
1500
Figure 4. 1000
Cumulative
Fluoride 500
Release
0
3000
2500
µg F- / g Sample
2000
1500
Days
14 Adhesion
Another advantage of glass-ionomer cements is their inherent ability to bond
to tooth structure without utilizing acid etch or dentin conditioning tech-
niques. While this adhesion is lower than that of properly placed resin sys-
tems, clinical experience has proven it to be adequate for retention of most
fixed prostheses. The shear adhesion was measured by cementing a sand-
blasted, 5 mm Rexillium III (a common non-precious alloy, Jeneric Pentron)
button to an appropriate substrate. Bovine dentin and enamel substrates were
prepared by potting teeth in methylmethacrylate, then grinding and polishing
these to expose dentin or enamel. Cements were mixed, according to manu-
facturers’ instructions, and sandwiched between the Rexillium III and the
substrate with a moderate amount of pressure. The samples were placed in a
37° C/95%RH environmental chamber for 2-3 minutes prior to clean-up of the
excess. After the excess was removed, the samples were replaced in the
environmental chamber for an additional 15 minutes. They were then stored in
distilled water at 37° C for 24 hours and shear adhesion values were measured.
Figure 6 demonstrates that different powder liquid ratios do not effect adhe-
sion. Additionally, the adhesion of Vitremer luting cement was found to be
similar to that of other glass
ionomer and polycarboxylate
cements and higher than
12
zinc phosphate. Properly
Enamel
placed resin cements 10
Dentin
Figure 6.
Shear Adhesion 4
to Bovine
2
Enamel
and Dentin 0
) ) I
EM
N
:1 :1
em
ji
s
)
:1
k'
O
.4 .8 Fu
ec
aC
-C
EL
.6
(1 (1
C
Fl
(1
qu
R
A
U
A
ET
——Vitremer Luting——
D
K
30
25
20
MPa
15
10
Figure 7.
Shear Adhesion 5
to Bovine
Enamel 0
Vitremer LC (1.6:1) C&B Panavia EX
Cements are also used to bond to other substrates, i.e., core buildup materials.
15
Figure 8 reveals the shear adhesion of Vitremer luting cement to a variety of
core buildup materials. These samples were prepared by substituting the core
buildup for the bovine teeth in the procedure detailed above.
P/L = 1.4:1
10 P/L = 1.6:1
9
P/L = 1.8:1
8
mPa
Figure 8. 5
Vitremer Luting 4
Cement/Rexillium 3
III Adhesion to 2
Various Core
1
Buildup
Substrates 0
re
re
er
y
00
llo
cu
cu
ilv
Z1
ra
-S
o
ht
pe
ut
ac
ig
is
)a
)l
et
D
K
B
B
(C
(C
er
er
em
em
tr
tr
Vi
Vi
16 pH
As stated earlier, one of the proposed causes of postoperative sensitivity is
low pH (acidic) when the cement contacts tooth structure. Vitremer luting
cement and KETAC-CEM were mixed at room temperature (23° C/50%RH).
The pH electrode was placed directly into the uncured cement. pH was
measured as a function of time. Figure 9 demonstrates the relatively constant,
less acidic pH (7 is considered a neutral pH) of Vitremer luting cement
compared to the highly acidic, slow rising pH of KETAC-CEM. In Figure 10,
the two cements were mixed and held for at 23° C/50%RH for 2 minutes.
Samples were placed in a test chamber (37° C/95%RH) where the surface pH
was measured as a function of time. Measurements were made by touching
the sample with the pH electrode with 100 microliters of distilled water (pH
6.0-7.5) interfacially. The curves show a rapid rise in pH of the KETAC-CEM
to a less acidic pH. Although the pH of Vitremer luting cement starts out
closer to neutral, it still gradually rises.
4 Vitremer Luting
KETAC-CEM
3.5
(surface electrode)
3
pH
2.5
Figure 9. 2
pH Rise at
Room Temperature 1.5
0 162.5 325 487.5 650
Time (sec.)
@23°C
4.5
(surface electrode)
Vitremer Luting
3.5 KETAC-CEM
pH
2.5
Figure 10.
2
pH Rise
During Setting 1.5
0 4 8 12 16 20
Time (min.)
@ 37°C & 95% RH)
Ease of use 17
Glass-ionomer cements are easy to use. The products are simply mixed,
placed in the crown and excess cement is chipped away after set. No addi-
tional steps are required to prepare the tooth. In field evaluations, it has been
reported that Vitremer luting cement has advantages even over traditional
glass-ionomer cements. The powder and liquid are dispensed in an easy to
remember 1:1 ratio. The mixture size is adjustable for the variety of applica-
tions encountered in routine crown and bridge procedures (less waste).
Traditional glass ionomers may be stringy which may make the crown loading
procedure messy. This stringiness is often used as a measure of mix consis-
tency. The cement is considered properly mixed when it strings between the
pad and the spatula about 1 inch. The mousse-like consistency of Vitremer
luting cement makes placement in the crown easier as the cement is readily
scooped from the pad. However, in field evaluations, a few doctors have
reported this lack of flow as a negative because they feel they have to take
more time to coat the inner aspects of the crown. Clean up of Vitremer luting
cement is easily accomplished by removal of the excess in a waxy state,
during which time the cement is dislodged from the margins in large sections.
The ease of clean up and ease of mixing offers significant advantages over
polycarboxylate and zinc phosphate cements. As stated earlier, there is a
window of opportunity to clean up polycarboxylate cements. If excess cement
is removed too quickly, while the material is in a rubbery stage, marginal
integrity may be compromised by pulling some material away from the
margins. If excess is removed too late, sharper, more aggressive instruments
are required to scale the material away from the tooth structure because of the
adhesion to tooth structure. Zinc phosphate is not an easy cement to mix. In
typical mixes, powder is slowly incorporated into the liquid over a period of 1
minute, 20 seconds. Too rapid incorporation results in a limited working time. The
cement must also be mixed on a cold glass slab to maximize working time.
Field Evaluation In a field evaluation, doctors were asked to rate the performance of their
current cement and Vitremer luting cement for 6 parameters (ease of mix,
length of working time, length of time to set, flow, pressure to seat crown and
ease of clean up). Evaluators rated all 6 parameters as good to excellent for
Vitremer luting cement (Figure 11). Doctors did not report any advantage or
diadvantage for Vitremer luting cement when the ratings for set time, working
time or flow were compared. However, most doctors felt the ease of mix and
the pressure required to
seat a crown was slightly 30 Poor Fair Good Excellent
20
doctors also comfirmed
that the clean up of Vitremer 15
luting cement was easier
than their current product. 10
Figure 11. 5
Field Evaluation
of Vitremer 0
Mix 3 drops of liquid and 3 Mix 4 drops of base and 1 drop Mix 1 scoop of powder to 1 drop
scoops of powder (30 of catalyst (less than 5 seconds). of liquid (60-90 seconds). After
seconds). Paint tooth. mix spread evenly over pad
surface.
Line prosthesis with mix and Apply cement to restoration and Apply thin layer of cement on
seat (1 minute). seat (1 minute). casting. Apply thin layer of
cement to tooth structure. Seat
(1.5 minutes).
Hold casting on tooth until Hold casting on tooth until Apply Oxygard to margins. Wait
cement is set (3 minutes). cement is set (10 minutes). (3-4 minutes). Wash Oxygard
away from margins.
Clean excess cement from Clean any cured cement from Clean excess cured material
restoration and adjacent restoration and adjacent teeth with an explorer and or a disc.
teeth with an explorer or with a scaler.
scaler.
Total Time 1=270 seconds Total Time 1=840 seconds Total Time 1= 500 seconds
1 Total Time is an approximation without including prophy or, in the cases of resin cements,
rubber dam placement.
Strength 19
In addition to fracture toughness, strength of a cement may be represented by
compressive and diametral tensile strengths. ISO 9917:1991 (E) lists a
minimum compressive strength needed for a cement as 70 MPa, no corre-
sponding requirements have been set for diametral tensile strengths. A
porcelain-fused-to-metal restoration gains much of its supporting strength
from the metal coping, not the cement used. The compressive and diametral
tensile strengths are depicted graphically (Figures 12 & 13). As expected, the
compressive and diametral tensile strengths of the resin cement category are
highest. Zinc phosphate and polycarboxylate cements have the lowest
strengths. Glass ionomers, including Vitremer luting cement exhibit moderate
strength.
40000
35000
30000
25000
Psi
20000
15000
10000
Figure 12.
5000
Compressive
Strength 0
1) 1)
EM
EX
er
N
em
s
)
I
2: 4:
:1
k'
O
ji
om
. .
Fu
ec
-C
aC
EL
a
.6
(1 (1
vi
on
C
Fl
(1
qu
R
na
A
U
sI
ET
A
Vitremer Luting
Pa
D
la
K
G
9000
8000
7000
6000
5000
Psi
4000
3000
EX
er
N
em
ji
s
)
2: 4:
:1
k'
O
Fu
om
. .
ec
-C
aC
EL
a
.6
(1 (1
vi
on
C
Fl
(1
qu
R
na
A
U
sI
ET
Vitremer Luting
Pa
D
la
K
G
Questions Q. Why isn’t Vitremer luting cement light curable like other
20
& Answers 3M glass ionomer products?
Indications
Warranty
Polycar-
Hybrid boxylic Zinc
GI ———————Conventional Glass Ionomers—————— Acid Phosphate
Vitremer ESPE KETAC- GC Fuji I Shofu Dentsply ESPE
Luting Cement CEM GC Fuji I (new) GlasIonomer AquaCem DURELON Mizzy Fleck’s
Adhesion to Dentin 4.3 2.9 4.3 N/A N/A N/A 5.3 0.3
(MPa)
Diametral Tensile 3373 3264 3038 3014 2851 1940 2206 1690
Strength (Psi)
Powder:liquid ratio 1.6:1 3.8:1 1.8:1 1.8:1 1.5:1 3.3:1 1.5:1 2.67:1
Mix Time 30 sec 1 min 20 sec 20 sec 20 - 30 sec 15 sec 30 sec 1 min 20 sec.
Working Time 2.5 min 3.5 min 2.25 min 2 min 3 min 2.75 min 2.5 min
23oC/50%RH
Set Time 3 min 5 min 5 min 4 min 5.5 min 5 min 4 min
@37oC/95%RH
Fluoride Release High High High High High High Very low None
25
3
Dental Products Laboratory