EM ch3 2021 v2
EM ch3 2021 v2
2021 Fall
郭華丞
Outlines
Laplace’s Equation
The Method of Images
Separation of Variables
Multipole Expansion
Integral eqns v.s differential eqns.
1 r ( r¢ ) rˆ
E=
4pe 0 ò r 2
dt ¢
Integral equations
1 r ( r¢ )
V (r ) = ò dt ¢
4pe 0 r
e0
If r =0 Ñ 2V = 0 Laplace’s equation
¶ 2V ¶ 2V ¶ 2V
In Cartesian coordinate : + 2 + 2 =0
¶x 2
¶y ¶z
One-dimensional cases
If the potential only depends on x d 2V
2
=0
dx
The general solution is
V ( x ) = mx + b
1
V ( x, y ) = ò Vdl
2p R circle
Remark: method of relaxation for calculating solutions.
Remark : a ball on a rubber membrane will roll over one side and fall off
Three-dimensional cases
1. V at point r is the average of the potentials on a spherical surface centered at r
1
V (r ) = ò Vda
4p R 2 sphere
Proof of statement 1
r = z 2 + R 2 - 2 zR cos q z>R
Three-dimensional cases
1. V at point r is the average of the potentials on a spherical surface centered at r
1
V (r ) = ò Vda
4p R 2 sphere
Proof of statement 1
1 q
The potential of the area element is V=
4pe 0 r
r = z 2 + R 2 - 2 zR cos q z>R
V ( R 2 sin q df dq )
p 2p
ò
sphere
Vda = ò
0 ò0
q
ò ò (z + R - 2 zR cos q )
p 2p -1 2
= R 2 2 2
( sin q df dq ) q
4pe 0 0 0
q 2 p 2
R ò ( z + R - 2 zR cos q ) d ( cos q ) r
-1 2
=- 2
z
2e 0 0
q R 2 12 p
=
2e 0 z
( z + R - 2 zR cos q )
2
q
0 R
q R q R2
= éë z + R - ( z - R ) ùû =
2e 0 z e0 z
1 1 æ q R2 ö q
ò Vda = 2 ç ÷ = = V ( 0)
4p R 2 sphere
4p R è e 0 z ø 4pe 0 z
Laplace’s equation
solutions
Boundary conditions
Ñ 2V1 = Ñ 2V2 = 0
Expressing their difference as V3=V1-V2, we have V3 also
obeys Laplace’s equation Ñ 2V3 = 0
Notice that the solutions of Laplace’s equation do not have local max. or
min. Therefore, V3 = 0 in V
V1 = V2
uniqueness theorem for Poison equations
If V1 and V2 are solutions of Poisson’s equation due to the
same charge distribution satisfying the same boundary
condition, we have
r
Ñ V1 = Ñ V2 =
2 2
e0
their difference V3=V1-V2, should obey Laplace’s equation
Ñ 2V3 = Ñ 2 (V1 - V2 ) = 0
Outer boundary
The boundary S consist of outer
boundary and conducting surfaces.
S
Qi
𝑄2
! 𝐄0 # 𝑑𝐚 = ! 𝐄1 # 𝑑𝐚 =
𝜀3
!"#$ %&'()%#!'* !"#$ %&'()%#!'*
+),-.%/ +),-.%/
𝑄676
! 𝐄0 # 𝑑𝐚 = ! 𝐄1 # 𝑑𝐚 =
𝜀3
&)#/, 4&)'(.,5 &)#/, 4&)'(.,5
We have Ñ × E3 = 0 ! 𝐄8 # 𝑑𝐚 = ! 𝐄8 # 𝑑𝐚 = 0
&)#/, 4&)'(.,5 !"#$ %&'()%#!'*
+),-.%/
Consider potentials on the conductors as V1 and V2 respectively. Then V3=V1-V2 is
constant over the conductor surface
ò 3 3
Ñ × (V E ) dt = ò 3 3
V E × d a = - ò 3 dt
E 2
V S V
ò 3 dt = -V3 ò E3 × da = - ò V3E3 × da = 0
2
E
V S outer
boundary
E3 = 0 Everywhere in V
Purcell’s example
+ − + − 0 0
− + − + 0 0
V=0 y
Reasoning:
The point charge will induce some negative charge
on the conducting plane, then the potential is due x
to the point charge and the induced surface charges
Goal:
To solve Poisson’s equation in the region z>0, with a point charge q at
(0,0,d) and the boundary conditions that V=0 at z=0 and at infinity.
Trick:
Consider another electrostatic problem that two point charges q at (0,0,d)
and –q at (0,0, –d) without any conducting plane. The potential is easily
found as
é ù
1 ê q q ú
V ( x, y , z ) = -
4pe 0 ê x 2 + y 2 + ( z - d )2 x 2
+ y 2
+ ( z + d )
2 ú
ë û
The boundary conditions for z>0 region is the same as the previous problem, and the
charge distribution for z>0 is the same as the previous problem
By using the uniqueness theorem, we deduce that the solution of the later
problem at z>0 is the solution of the previous problem
Induced surface charge
¶V
The surface charge can be computed using s = -e 0
¶n
The normal direction is z-direction
é ù
¶V 1 ê -q ( z - d ) q(z + d ) ú
= +
¶z 4pe 0 ê é x 2 + y 2 + ( z - d )2 ù 3 2 é x 2 + y 2 + ( z - d )2 ù 3 2 ú
êë ë û ë û úû
1 -qd
s ( x, y ) = (z=0)
2p ( x 2 + y 2 + d 2 )3 2
1 æ q q¢ ö
V (r ) = ç - ¢÷
4pe 0 è r r ø
We may check the potential on the sphere by using the spherical coordinate in
which the origin is the sphere center.
1 æ q q¢ ö r 2 = a 2 + R 2 - 2aR cos q
V (r ) = ç - ¢÷
4pe 0 è r r ø r ¢2 = b 2 + R 2 - 2bR cos q
On the sphere surface
æ ö
V ( R, q ) =
1 ç q
-
(a R) q ÷
ç
4pe 0 ç a + R - 2aR cos q ÷
( R a ) + R - 2 ( R a ) R cos q ÷ø
2 2 2 2 2 2
è
1 æ q ( a R) q ö
= ç - ÷
4pe 0 ç a 2
+ R 2
- 2 aR cos q ( a R ) R 2
+ a 2
- 2aR cos q ÷
è ø
=0
¶ 2V ¶ 2V
+ 2 =0
¶x 2
¶y
Since the first term only depends on x, while the second only on y, the two
terms must be constant.
1 ¶2 X 1 ¶ 2Y
=C =-
X ¶x 2
Y ¶y 2
d2X
2
= k 2
X
A partial differential equation becomes dx Here C=k2 is chosen
two ordinary differential equations d 2Y
2
= - k 2
Y (Why not choose C=-k2?)
dy
The solutions are X = Ae kx + Be - kx
Y = C sin ky + D cos ky
V ( x, y ) = X ( x ) Y ( y ) = ( Ae kx + Be - kx ) ( C sin ky + D cos ky )
To determine all to coefficients and k, we need to impose the boundary conditions
V =0 when y = 0 D¢ = 0
V =0 when y = a e - kx C ¢ sin ka = 0
np
k= , n = 1, 2,3!
a
And the potential is in the form V ( x, y ) = C ¢e - kx sin ky
By choosing any single n value function, we cannot fit it to the last boundary
condition. Here we construct a more general function by using the series:
¥
np y
V ( x, y ) = å Cn e - np x a
sin
n =1 a
It is easily to find that
æ ¥ np y ö ¥ 2 æ - np x a np y ö
Ñ V ( x , y ) = Ñ ç å Cn e
2 2 - np x a
sin ÷ = å Cn Ñ ç e sin ÷=0
è n =1 a ø n =1 è a ø
The last boundary condition yields
¥
np y
å Cn sin
n =1 a
= V0 ( y )
Fourier series
n¢p y
Multiply by sin , and integrate y from 0 to a,
a
¥
np y n¢p y n¢p y
å
a a
Cn ò sin sin dy = ò V0 ( y ) sin dy
n =1
0 a a 0 a
ì0 if n¢ ¹ n
a np y ¢
np y ï
ò0 sin
a
sin
a
dy = ía
if n¢ = n
ïî 2
2 a np y
ò 0( )
Therefore, we have Cn = V y sin dy
a 0 a
If V0 ( y ) = V0
ì0 for even n
2V anp y 2V ï
Cn = 0 ò sin dy = 0 (1 - cos np ) = í 4V0
a 0 a np ïî np for odd n
4V0 ¥
1 - np x a np y
V ( x, y ) = å
p n =1,3,5! n
e sin
a
Orthogonal functions
Completeness Any function can be expressed as a linear combination
of some set of functions, fn
¥
f ( x ) = å Cn f n ( x )
n =1
¶ 2V ¶ 2V ¶ 2V 1 ¶ 2 X 1 ¶ 2Y 1 ¶ 2 Z
+ 2 + 2 =0 + + =0
¶x 2
¶y ¶z X ¶x 2
Y ¶y 2
Z ¶z 2
1 ¶2 X
= C1
X ¶x 2
1 ¶ 2Y C1 + C2 + C3 = 0
= C2
Y ¶y 2
1 ¶2Z
= C3 Since for y and z the boundary condition are V=0
Z ¶z 2
C2 < 0
C3 < 0
¶2 X
Setting C2 = - k 2 ,we have ¶x 2
= ( k 2
+ l 2
) X
C3 = -l 2 ¶ 2Y
= - k 2
Y
¶y 2
¶2Z
= -l 2
Z
¶z 2
The solutions can be written as
X ( x ) = Ae k 2 +l 2 x
+ Be - k 2 +l 2 x
Y ( y ) = C sin ky + D cos ky
Z ( z ) = E sin lz + F cos lz
np mp
From the first 5 boundary conditions, we have A= D= F =0 k= , l=
a b
( n a )2 + ( m a )2 x np y mp z
V ( x, y, z ) = Ce
-p
sin sin
a b
A general solution is
¥ ¥
np y mp z
V ( x, y, z ) = åå Cn ,m e
-p ( n a )2 + ( m a )2 x
sin sin
n =1 m =1 a b
To determine the coefficients
4 a b np y mp z
Cn , m = ò ò V0( y , z ) sin sin dzdy
ab 0 0 a b
V0 ( y, z ) = V0 4V0 a b np y mp z
If Cn , m =
ab ò0 ò0
sin
a
sin
b
dzdy
ì 0 if n or m is even
ï
= í 16V0
ïî p 2 nm if n and m are odd
16V0 ¥
1 -p np y mp z
V ( x, y , z ) =
p2
å
n , m =1,3,5! nm
e
( n a )2 + ( m a )2 x
sin
a
sin
b
Spherical coordinates
1 ¶ æ 2 ¶V ö 1 ¶ æ ¶V ö 1 ¶ 2V
Ñ V = 2 çr ÷+ 2 ç sin q ÷+ 2 2 =0
2
r ¶r è ¶r ø r sin q ¶q è ¶q ø r sin q ¶f 2
So that 1 ¶ æ 2 ¶V ö 1 ¶ æ ¶V ö
çr +
÷ 2 ç sin q ÷=0
r ¶r è ¶r ø r sin q ¶q è ¶q
2
ø
Assuming a solution is product V ( r , q ) = R ( r ) Q (q ) we have
1 d æ 2 dR ö 1 d æ dQ ö
ç r ÷ + ç sin q ÷=0
R dr è dr ø Q sin q dq è dq ø
Since the variables are separated, it follows that each term must be constant
1 d æ 2 dR ö 1 d æ dQ ö
çr ÷ = l ( l + 1) ç sin q ÷ = -l ( l + 1)
R dr è dr ø Q sin q dq è dq ø
Legendre polynomials
d æ 2 dR ö
÷ = l ( l + 1) R
The radial equation has the general solution
çr
dr è dr ø
1
R ( r ) = Ar l + B
r l +1
d æ dQ ö
The angular equation ç sin q ÷ = -l ( l + 1) sin qQ has the solutions what are call
dq è dq ø
Legendre polynomials Q (q ) = Pl ( cos q )
l
1 æd ö 2
Pl ( x ) = l ç ÷ ( x - 1)
l
The polynomials can be defined by Rodrigues formula
2 l ! è dx ø
in which l must be nonnegative integers
P0 ( x ) = 1
Only x even powers
We may list the first few Pl(x) P1 ( x ) = x
P2 ( x ) = ( 3x 2 - 1) 2 Only x odd powers
P3 ( x ) = ( 5 x 3 - 3x ) 2
Is there the other set of solutions? The answer is that the other set solutions are
unphysical since it diverges at q=0 and p
In the end, we obtained the solution for the problems having azimuthal symmetry with l
æ B ö
V ( r , q ) = ç Ar l + l +1 ÷ Pl ( cos q )
è r ø
We may write the general solution as a linear combination of these functions
¥
æ B ö
V ( r , q ) = å ç Al r l + l +l1 ÷ Pl ( cos q )
l =0 è r ø
Orthogonalily of Legendre polynomials
1 p
ò Pl ( x ) Pl ¢ ( x ) dx = ò Pl ( cos q ) Pl ¢ ( cos q ) sin q dq
-1 0
ì 0 if l ¹ l ¢
ï
=í 2
ïî 2l + 1 if l = l ¢
V0 (q )
The potential will not diverge at r=0, it follows that
Bl are zero
¥
V ( r , q ) = å Al r l Pl ( cos q )
l =0
2 p
Al R l
= ò V0 (q ) Pl ( cos q ) sin q dq
2l + 1 0
Suppose V0 (q ) = k sin 2 (q 2 )
k
V0 (q ) = k sin 2 (q 2 ) = (1 - cos q )
2
k
= éë P0 ( cos q ) - P1 ( cos q ) ùû
2
2l + 1 p
l ò0 0 ( ) l (
Because of Al = V q P cos q ) sin q dq
2R
k k
A0 = A1 = -
2 2R
ké r ù
V ( r ,q ) = P ( cos q ) - P ( cos q )
2 êë úû
0 1
R
kæ r ö
= ç1 - cos q ÷
2è R ø
Potential outside a sphere
The potential V0 (q ) on a sphere of radius R is specified.
2l + 1 l +1 p
Bl = R ò V0 (q ) Pl ( cos q ) sin q dq
2 0
Induced charges on a metal sphere
A metal sphere is placed in a uniform external electric field,
and charges would induced on the surface. We will find out
the potential due to the induced charges.
V = - E0 z + C
On the surface, the potential is constant, which we can
assume as zero. It follows that C=0
V = 0 when r = R
V ® - E0 r cos q when r ! R
The general solution for potential is
¥
æ B ö
V ( r , q ) = å ç Al r l + l +l1 ÷ Pl ( cos q )
l =0 è r ø
From the first boundary condition, we get
Bl
Al R l + l +1
=0
R
Bl = - Al R 2l +1
¥
æ l R 2l +1 ö
V ( r , q ) = å Al ç r + l +1 ÷ Pl ( cos q )
l =0 è r ø
For r>>R, the second term is negligible, so the second boundary condition is
¥
V ( r , q ) ® å Al r l Pl ( cos q ) = E0 r cos q
l =0
æ R3 ö
V ( r , q ) = - E0 ç r - 2 ÷ cos q
è r ø
The first term is due to the external field, so the second term contributed from the
induced charges
R3
E0 2 cos q
r Note: this is a dipole field
¶V
s (q ) = -e 0 = 3e 0 E0 cos q
¶r r=R
Potential due to surface charge distribution
In some cases, we do not have potential but the surface charge specified. This is
related to the so-called Neumann boundary condition problems
l =0 R
æ ¶V> ¶V< ö 1
ç - ÷ = - s 0 (q )
è ¶r ¶r ø r = R e0
¥ ¥
Bl 1
-å ( l + 1) l + 2 Pl ( cos q ) - å lAl R l -1 Pl ( cos q ) = - s 0 (q )
l =0 R l =0 e0
1 p
Al = l -1 ò0
s 0 (q ) Pl ( cos q ) sin q dq
2e 0 R
r r rè 2 8 16 ø
n
1 1 ¥ æ r¢ ö
= å ç ÷ Pn ( cos q )
r r n =0 è r ø
¥
1 1
V ( P) =
4pe 0
år
n =0
n +1 ò
r ¢ n
Pn ( cos q ) r ( r¢ ) dt ¢
1 é1 1 1 2æ3 1ö ù
V ( P) = ( ) ( ) ( )
4pe 0 êë r ò r2 ò r3 ò è 2
r r ¢ dt ¢ + r ¢ cos qr r ¢ dt ¢ + r ¢ ç cos 2
q - ÷ r r ¢ dt ¢ + !ú
2ø û
monopole dipole quadrupole
Dipole field
1 1
Vdip ( P ) = ò ( r ¢ cos q ) r ( r¢) dt ¢ cos q = rˆ × rˆ ¢
4pe 0 r 2
1 1
= rˆ × ò r¢r ( r¢ ) dt ¢
4pe 0 r 2
¶V 2 p cos q
Er = - =
¶r 4pe 0 r 3
Eq = -
1 ¶V p sin q
=
r ¶q 4pe 0 r 3
Ε ( r ,q ) =
p
4pe 0 r 3 ( 2 cosq rˆ + sin qqˆ )
1 ¶V
Ef = - =0
r sin q ¶f