Running Head: STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 1

Comprehensive Strategic Analysis of Ulta Beauty

Yohana Perez

Capella University

MBA5006
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 2

Comprehensive Strategic Analysis of Ulta Beauty

Ulta Beauty is considered one of the dominating beauty retailers in the U.S. due to its

vast range of cosmetic products and several customer-specific business strategies. Its name is one

of the very few that has succeeded in creating that space for itself. This paper takes a look at the

strategic positioning of Ulta Beauty through analytic frameworks that consider internal

competencies and external market drivers. Ulta Beauty provides upscale makeup grooming

products for skin, hair, and body at affordable prices to beauty lovers (Maamoun, 2021). This

paper will outline how Ulta has managed to sustain its competitive edge with a superb supply

chain, powerful brand partners, and a hybrid business model of online and physical shops. It will

also discuss consumer trends, regulatory developments, and economic shifts affecting market

dynamics. This PESTEL and Poters Five Analysis assesses the strengths and threats of Ulta

Beauty in terms of operational effectiveness and market resiliency.

Strategic Planning and AFI Framework

Strategic Planning

Ulta Beauty is a leading beauty giant that focuses strategically on growing and expanding

the market through the innovativeness of diversifying its product lines and relentless

enhancement of the customer experience. This is strategic planning toward diversified product

assortments and integrating digital technologies to redefine the retail experience (Gatchell,

2022). Ulta always remains ahead, according to evolving consumer trends and preferences.

All these are framed with the view of the changed retail landscape to stay competitive

and agile. Ulta's approach to strategic planning involves identifying emerging market

opportunities, such as the demand for cruelty-free and sustainable products, and very quickly

includes those trends in its offerings (Blumenthal, 2023). This adaptability as a response to
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 3

market dynamics is one of the critical cornerstones of their strategy to capture and maintain

consumer interest and loyalty in the long term.

Ulta Beauty focuses on creating a smooth omnichannel experience that connects online

and physical retail spaces seamlessly, thus making its services and products accessible and

convenient for every customer (Gatchell, 2022). This is an essential strategic element in that it

meets the diverse shopping preferences of a diverse customer base—from tech-savvy millennials

to more traditional shoppers who value the tactile experience of physically browsing through a

store's physical selection.

AFI Framework Application

The AFI (Analysis, Formulation, Implementation) framework guides Ulta's strategic

initiatives amidst a structured methodology that follows the unceasing circle of improvement and

adaptation (Rothaermel 2021). It is these actionable outcomes that convert the strategic insights

to success for the business.

Analysis

Ulta Beauty is committed to conducting routine and thorough checks on its internal

resources and market conditions. The company's strengths are a strong brand identity and a

humongous supply chain network. On the other hand, the threats are that the company may be

vulnerable to economic downturns due to sensitivity regarding discretionary consumer spending

(Maamoun, 2021). Through these assessments, the company reviews market trends, consumer

behavior, and competitive activities to ensure that its strategy remains relevant and practical to

be on the winning edge.

STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 4

Formulation

Based on the insights, Ulta formulates strategic initiatives that leverage strengths and

address areas of weakness. This is a critical phase, as it includes the decision-making that best

regards the long-term objectives. For instance, considering the digital shift, Ulta has been

striving to enhance its e-commerce capabilities through personalized marketing techniques and

improved online shopping experiences (Sugiarno & Novita 2022). Further, Ulta works to forge

exclusive relationships with emerging and established beauty brands to set apart the product

offering for them and attract a broadened customer base.

Implementation

The final level within the AFI framework is excellently and effectively operationalizing

the formulated strategies (Rothaermel 2021). Ulta Beauty does extremely well by deploying its

well-coordinated operational and marketing strategy with great finesse to provide excellence in

customer value. Implementation is supported by advanced technological tools that streamline

operations, from inventory management to customer relationship management systems. This

strategic execution ensures initiatives are effectively carried out, maximizing impact and driving

sustainable business growth.

Role of Leaders In Strategic Planning Process

The leader of Ultra Beauty Inc. provides the strategy and leads the company forward. The

Ultra Beauty Inc. leader inspires and carries the vision. This requires setting an inspiring long-

term vision for the organization (Al Dhaheri, 2024). The vision will drive the strategic planning,

and at the same time, it will also align stakeholders with the goals of the company. The leader

must set goals to implement the vision. They must be specific, quantifiable, and achievable so
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 5

that the organization knows what goals to reach. They need to align those goals with the vision

of the company and market changes.

Strategic planning involves the allocation of resources by leaders. In strategic planning,

leaders must allocate enough resources, including funds, staff, and technology. Resource

allocation needs leaders to evaluate the company's operational and strategic needs regularly. In

strategic planning, the leader involves stakeholders to ensure better decision-making during the

implementation process (Al Dhaheri, 2024). They include staff, board members, investors,

consumers, and business partners. Effective communication and engagement strategies that build

trust and inform the organization's strategic plan.

Strategic Analysis

Internal Environment

VRIO Analysis

Value

Ulta Beauty has positioned itself well as a leader in the retail market, with the high

growth of vast arrays of product lines and services for diverse customer bases. The company's

value proposition is genuinely multi-pronged, based on the breadth and depth of the product suite

and the service model it subscribes to. This is through professional services offered in the store,

consultations, and a loyalty program for their customers with a perfect rating, which provides

discounts and other special offers. This enables the shopping experience to be more than just for

products and ensures customers have very loyal returns compared to similar services from

competitors.Rarity

Imitability
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 6

Ulta Beauty is an excellent example of an omnichannel retailer business model that fuses

online and physical retail experiences. It is also complemented by a robust loyalty program in

which the company has invested highly in technology, infrastructure, and brand relationships.

Further, such a model is costly to replicate and extraordinarily complex, presenting potential

competitors for Ulta with an insurmountable entry barrier, seeing Ulta's competitive advantage

well-protected by this level of investment and franchise focus.

Organization

Ulta Beauty demonstrates a deep capability of using their organizational structure

towards market leadership; it innovates on product lines and shopping experiences, adapting

quickly to market trends or consumer needs.

Value Chain Analysis

Effective management of the operational chain of value, from procurement to the end of

sale, is critical for Ulta Beauty. Tailoring its supply chain into an efficient one that ensures

smooth product flow with minor bumps and low costs has always been an integral part of how

the firm does business. By doing a whoops-a-daisy deal with such suppliers, Ulta can arrive at an

agreement that is good for both the retailer and the suppliers by ensuring that their price is

competitive without affecting the quality.

External Framework

PESTEL Analysis

Political

Ulta Beauty's operations are within a complex regulatory environment that differs

substantially from state to state. The company has complied with such divergent regulatory

requirements mainly because they affect operational costs and have the necessary product
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 7

offerings across the markets. For example, state-based regulations on the sale of some chemicals

used in beauty products will influence Ulta's product line and compel a change in the logistics

chain supply (Fern Fort University, 2023). This compliance results in legitimacy and affects the

strategic decision concerning product positioning and promotion.

Economic

The economic landscape significantly impacts consumer behavior, affecting Ulta

Beauty's sales and marketing strategy plans. Economic trends, such as disposable income

changes and consumer confidence, are direct determinants of spending patterns within the beauty

industry (Fern Fort University, 2023). Economic prosperity is laced up with consumer spending

on luxury beauty, while economic downturns may shift spending patterns toward more budget-

conscious buying behaviors. In light of these trends, Ulta has modified its marketing campaigns

and stock so that the products are under the current spending capability of the consumer.

Social

The consumer trend in the beauty industry grows very fast towards ethical consumption,

with an incline marked on sustainability and cruelty-free products. Ulta Beauty incurs this trend

by continually rebalancing the product assortment to include brands founded on these values

(Fern Fort University, 2023). This caters not only to the demographic that considers ethics in

their purchasing but also does a lot to place Ulta as a socially responsible retailer in the eyes of

their customers.

Technological

Technology is at the heart of Ulta Beauty's stride to strengthen customers' experiences

and, at the same time, get valuable insights. This kind of advanced technology implemented in

marketing analytics aids Ulta in understanding what consumers want and personalizing
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 8

marketing efforts (Fern Fort University, 2023). Their improved e-commerce platform and mobile

app also offer features of virtual try-ons and recommendation capabilities to enhance customer

shopping experience further, boosting sales and involving the customer.

Environmental

Legal

The legal framework under which a beauty retailer operates involves adherence to

particular labor laws, product safety regulations, and advertising standards. Ulta's vigilance to

ensure adherence to these helps the company avoid litigation and fines that could be potential

sources of instability, either financial or brand-based (Fern Fort University, 2023). Maintaining

track of changes in legal standards is critical to maintaining operational integrity and consumer

trust.

Porter's Five Forces Analysis

Industry Rivalry

The competition in the beauty industry is very high, and critical players are continuously

innovating to grab and maintain market share. Ulta Beauty faces huge rivalry with other big

beauty chains in department stores and online retailers (Cornell University 2024). This

competitive environment forces Ulta to innovate its products and offer customer service

continually.

Threat of New Entrants

Ulta's strong brand presence and solid customer loyalty work as entry barriers amidst the

growth potential the beauty industry provides. The other mitigating aspect of this threat is the

considerable investment in branding and customer acquisition, ensuring it reclaims this

competitive advantage.
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 9

Bargaining Power of Suppliers

In general, Ulta should have the ability and considerable market power to negotiate with

suppliers in most cases. However, the nature of some highly demanded brands' exclusivity may

give some suppliers tremendous bargaining power (Cornell University 2024). In such situations,

a commitment to the diversity of suppliers and the development of in-house brands can help

rebalance this power.

Bargaining Power of Buyers

High buyer bargaining power comes into play due to the reach of online shopping and the

accessibility to beauty products (Cornell University, 2024). Buyers can quickly shift brands and

compare prices, making Ulta develop attractive value propositions and constantly maintain its

competitive pricing strategies.

Threat of Substitutes

The threat of substitutes—moderate. In fact, despite offering convenience and sometimes

being cheaper, all of these products and services do not provide the same experience as the wide

product selection Ulta offers, including exclusive ones and the in-store experience.

Summary and Recommendations

Summary

Ulta Beauty has strategically positioned itself as a leader in the market within the

competitive beauty industry by leveraging its ample internal resources adaptively and responding

to external pressures. Through integration with analytic frameworks like VRIO and PESTEL,

Ulta has portrayed an inherent capability to be ahead and confidently tackle the numerous

challenges witnessed within the industry.

STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 10

The VRIO analysis shows Ulta's ability to exploit valuable, rare, inimitable, and

organized resources for the best benefits while maintaining its competitive advantage. This may

include integrated retail formats, a one-stop assortment of products and services, exclusive brand

partners, and a compelling loyalty program (Jain et al., 2021). This strategic approach ensures

Ulta will keep its current customer base and acquire customers, holding on to them with the help

of distinctive offerings and service par excellence.

From the PESTEL analysis, Ulta shows its ability to handle the influence that may come

from a range of external forces, which includes political, economic, social, technological,

environmental, and legal forces (Jain et al., 2021). The approach is highly proactive and can

allow risk minimization and capturing the opportunity in the market. For example, its

sustainability and ethical commitment position it more in the current social trends and bring the

brand reputation closer to consumers, who are more and more conscientious.

Further, Ulta's assessment of Porter's Five Forces provides insights into its level of

competitive dynamics, whereby the high industry rivalry is found along with the bargaining

power of suppliers and buyers. Still, with all those challenges, Ulta has maintained an excellent

level in the market due to strategic initiatives that help it differentiate itself through innovation

and engagement with its customers.

Recommendations

Innovate Product Offerings

Therefore, Ulta Beauty needs to innovate its product offerings further to embrace the new

beauty outlooks and customers' expectations perfectly. This includes further expanding their line

of sustainable and cruelty-free products. This will help better equip Ulta to proactively stay in

front of trends, such as the growing trend within clean beauty, to meet their dynamic needs in the
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 11

future. Proactively working with up-and-coming brands and influencers may also help generate

buzz and connect with a younger consumer base.

Enhance Digital Engagement

Ulta Beauty should further personalize its digital touchpoints, given the reshaping retail

environment in light of digital transformation. This would mean enhancing the functionality and

user experience of its e-commerce site and harnessing advanced technologies such as A.I. and

A.R. to offer customers personalized shopping experiences, including virtual try-ons and

customization of product recommendations (Barney, 2023). This can further enhance Ulta's

customer engagement and increase online sales by creating a more interactive and personalized

online experience.

Expand Market Reach

It implies a great opportunity for Ulta Beauty to diversify its revenue streams and reduce

dependency on the U.S. market through the exploration of international markets. Entering new

geographic markets might be approached cautiously with digital channels initially, followed by

possible physical store expansions in regions where the brand gained traction. Moreover, the

efforts' relevance will ensure product lines' adaptation to local tastes and regulatory

requirements, which are determinants in such relevance and compliance.

Strengthen Sustainability Initiatives

With corporate responsibility looming large in importance, Ulta's sustainability initiatives

must be boosted. This includes even more aggressive targets for waste reduction, energy

efficiency in stores, distribution centers, and sustainable product packaging (Hamel & Prahalad

1990). This will align with the regulatory expectations of communicating these efforts
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 12

transparently to the consumers and build trust and loyalty with environmentally conscious

consumers.

Conclusion

Ulta Beauty has done quite well against itself, using its internal resources to study and

respond strategically to external threats. VRIO, PESTEL, and Porter's Five Forces show Ulta

will continue its competitive strategic response given value proposition management, social and

market trends, and operations excellence. The VRIO framework affirms that Ulta delivers firm

services and goods with a unique, valuable, and non-imitable feature, safeguarding its

competitive advantage. The PESTEL data shows that Ulta can manage external threats

proactively, such as changes in legislation, economic fluctuation, and consumers' desire for

sustainable goods. In addition, from Porter's Five Forces analysis, Ulta faces strong competitive

forces and consequently focuses its strategic efforts on increasing customer interaction with the

help of new, innovative product offerings that leverage its digital and global footprint. Product

innovation, worldwide expansion, and digital engagement should be three strategic focus areas

for Ulta Beauty. They should double down on improving the customer experience and

sustainability. The tactics would greatly help Ulta maintain its market leadership, prepare for the

brand's development, and adjust to new needs emerging in the beauty market.
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 13

References
Al Dhaheri, A. S. (2024). The role of project management and strategic leadership in enhancing

the investment for local and international businesses. World Journal of Advanced

Research and Reviews, 21(3), 376-386.

Barney, J. B. (2023). Why Has It Been So Hard to Define Competitive Advantage? (Doctoral

dissertation, Clarkson University).

Blumenthal J. (2023). Ulta Beauty: Brand Reputation And Valuation Strongly Signal A Buy.

Ulta Beauty, Inc. (ULTA) Stock. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4625967-ulta-beauty-

brand-reputation-valuation-strongly-signal-buy

Cornell University. (2024). Porter's Five Forces Analysis and Sephora's Bargaining Power.

Retrieved from https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2017/10/23/porters-five-forces-

analysis-and-sephoras-bargaining-power/

Fern Fort University. (2023). Ulta Beauty, Inc. PESTEL & Environment Analysis. Retrieved

from http://fernfortuniversity.com/term-papers/pestel/nyse4/3232-ulta-beauty--inc-.php

Gatchell, M. (2022). Ulta Beauty: Strategic and Industry Comparison. Spring.

https://scholarworks.merrimack.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?

article=1062&context=honors_capstones

Hamel G. & Prahalad C.K. (1990). The core competence of the corporation. HBR.

Jain, P., Chou, M. C., Fan, F., & Santoso, M. P. (2021). Embedding sustainability in the

consumer goods innovation cycle and enabling tools to measure progress and capabilities.

Sustainability, 13(12), 6662.

Maamoun, A. (2021). Bold and beautiful: Ulta beauty thriving in the retail Apocalypse.

https://doi.org/10.4135/9781529761245
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 14

Rothaermel F. T. (2021). Strategic Management. Fifth edition. | New York, NY: McGraw-Hill

Education. ISBN 978-1-264-10370-6. Pp. 1-541.

Sugiarno, Y., & Novita, D. (2022, August). Resources-Based View (RBV) as A Strategy of

Company Competitive Advantage: A Literature Review. In International Conference On

Economics Business Management And Accounting (ICOEMA) (Vol. 1, pp. 656-666).

United States Securities and Exchange Commission. (2023). Ulta Beauty, Inc. Retrieved from

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1403568/000155837023004581/ulta-

20230128x10k.htm
STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 15

Appendices

Appendix A: VRIO Analysis Visual

STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 16

Appendix B: Value Chain Analysis Visual

STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 17

Appendix C: PESTLE Analysis Visual

STRATEGIC ANALYSIS OF ULTA BEAUTY 18

Appendix D: Five Forces Analysis Visual