paprint
paprint
personal tasks, often measured using functional and personal sensitive information to unauthorized
measures. access and use
- Comfort - relief from physical and emotional
suffering, often exacerbated by illness. ● Sensitive information, such as social security
- Calm - normal living condition, allowing patients numbers, financial account numbers, passwords and
to live normally while receiving care, especially authentication credentials, and intellectual property, is
crucial for those with chronic or long-term at risk
conditions. ● Personal sensitive information, including names,
- Improved care outcomes in capability, comfort, and home addresses, medical records, phone numbers,
calm are a result of the efficacy and empathy of dates of birth, race, ethnic origin, sexual
healthcare, rather than its hospitality. orientation, and more, can be mishandled,
emphasizing data protection
b. Issues involving Access to Care
- Access to health care means having "the timely Data protection allows employees to share shared
use of personal health services to achieve the logical and physical address spaces safely
best health outcomes"
- In order to understand what issues are involved ● The logical address space- apps
with regards to access to care, we must first ● a physical address space - device
determine the elements of access to healthcare
according to the Agency for Healthcare Three key attributes describe security: availability,
Research and Quality (AHRQ) in 2018. integrity, and confidentiality
● Availability: preventing unauthorized actors from
Elements of Access to Healthcare (AHRQ, 2018): withholding information, such as during a ransomware
● Coverage in healthcare improves access to care, attack. (New amsterdam)
reducing uninsured individuals' health status. (AHRQ, ● Integrity and confidentiality: concerned with
2018) keeping information private, undamaged, and safe from
● Services from usual sources lead to recommended hostile parties. External dangers are classified as
screening and prevention. (AHRQ, 2018) indirect or direct
● Timeliness ensures timely healthcare (AHRQ, 2018)
● Workforce ensures competent, qualified care. ● Indirect: Examples include trojans, worms, and
(AHRQ,2018) computer viruses.
● Direct: A hacker's targeted attack.
Issues on access to healthcare: While protection and security work toward the same
- ‘’Bahala na’’ mentality drains our healthcare system. goal of a secure and effective system, they deal with
Shortage of healthcare workers, limited access to different risks
health care facilities, and high out pocket expenses for ● Protection: a system-specific strategy for dealing
hospitalization and healthcare needs are among the with dangers and
problems that we face because of the ‘’bahala na’’ ensuring proper operation.
mentality. ● Security: deployed to manage external system risks
- In addition to a shortage of healthcare providers, to keep the system running well.
there is a lack of hospital beds and medical equipment
in the Philippines. In particular, there is a shortage of Specifically, security is an approach to protecting user
doctors and equipment in rural areas and poorer and system resources from unauthorized external
provinces. entities in terms of functioning. On the contrary,
protection establishes a guideline for managing
Ethical Issues related to Technology access to data, processes, programs, and other
resources (Udan et al., 2023).
in the Delivery of Healthcare
A. Data Protection and Security The main difference between security and protection is
policy.
● Security policy: The system administrator assesses b. Personal Information Controller: It refers to the
whether a person may utilize a system. individual or organization that has authority over the
● Protection policy: determines the user's access to gathering, retaining, processing, and use of
particular data resources. personal data. (Ex. healthcare providers, hospitals).
c. Personal Information Processor: Any natural or
juridical person qualified to act as such under this Act
Individuals and organizations to whom a personal information controller may
- giving rights to a person; outsource the processing of personal data pertaining to
- encryption keys; a data subject. (Ex. IT professionals).
- electronic signatures; and d. Consent of Data Subject: It refers to any voluntarily
- data vaults; provided, informed statement of will that the individual
consents to the gathering and processing of his or her
External threat defense systems personal information (Ex. written consent form).
- firewalls; e. Personal Information: Information that can be
- antivirus software; and reasonably or directly ascertained to an individual, or
- eliminate users no longer authorized to use the when put together with other information would directly
systems. and certainly identify an individual.
f. Sensitive Personal Information: Information about
Implications to Practice an individual’s race, ethnic origin, marital status, age,
- Healthcare services rely primarily on the open color, and religious, philosophical or
sharing of information between anyone political affiliations, education, health record, criminal
involved, whether they are clients, healthcare record, & etc. (Ex. health information from check-
professionals, or health institutions. ups/documented findings from health
assessments).
- Clients are more likely to provide complete and g. Information and Communications System: A
accurate data when they believe their system for generating, sending, receiving, storing or
information is safe and secure in the hands otherwise processing electronic data messages or
of their healthcare provider. electronic documents and includes the computer
system or other similar device by or which data is
Data privacy measures ensure that the client's recorded, transmitted or stored (Ex. EHR/electronic
information remains safe and secure. It assures that health record).
their data is always secure and not exposed to risks
and vulnerabilities such as: Data subjects are entitled to exercise the following
● unauthorized access; rights:
● processing; 1. Right to be informed
● sharing; and 2. Right to access
● disclosure (Udan et al., 2023). 3. Right to object
DATA PRIVACY ACT OF 2012 4. Right to erasure or blocking
Republic Act No. 10173 or the Data Privacy Act of 5. Right to rectify
2012 6. Right to data portability
- is the law that protects personal information of 7. Right to damages
an individual that is gathered and handled by 8. Right to file a complaint
the information or communication systems of
the government or private sectors (National Who oversees the DPA?
Privacy Commission, 2012). - The National Privacy Commission is mandated
This act is consisted of different concepts, some are to monitor the implementation of DPA.
the following; - All types of information processes should be
a. Data Subject: Individual whose personal information following the rules and regulations set in DPA.
is processed (Ex.clients, patients). - Should be followed whether the actors involved
in the process are natural or juridical persons in
nature.
Natural: pertains to a person as a single human being. - The processing is necessary for the purposes
Juridical: pertains to an entity or a fictitious person of medical treatment; and
- Healthcare members involved must have
Data Privacy Officer minimum and essential access to the health
- DPO ensures that information collected or records of recipients in order to execute tasks.
circulated within an organization's records or
database is processed in compliance with the Notify data subjects of the following information before
Data Privacy Act. entering personal information into a processing system:
- PIC's and PIP's should be obliged to appoint a 1. Description of the personal data
DPO which is a legal requirement. - sensitive personal information
- Data Privacy Officers should be registered to 2. Purpose for which data will be processed
the National Privacy Commission. - goal sa pagcollect ng information
3. Basis for processing, especially when it is not based
Privacy Notice on consent
- Known as Privacy Policy - related sa purpose
- Statement from PIC's or PIP's on how they will 4. Scope and method of the personal data processing
handle the processed information, including the 5. Recipients to whom data may be disclosed
collection, - sino lang ang pwedeng mag access
6.Methods used for automated access by the recipient
Privacy Impact Assessment and the extent to which such access is authorized
- A tool used to assess the possible privacy - may limitations dapat ang naaccess sa kanilang
impacts of a process, information system, or information
other initiative that handles personal data. 7. Identity and contact details of PIC or its
1.Project/System Description representative
2.Threshold Analysis 8. The duration for which data will be stored
3.Stakeholders Engagement - hanggang kailan maisstore
4.Personal Data Flows 9. Existence of the rights of the data subjects
5.Privacy Impact Analysis
6.Privacy Risk Management Retention of personal data shall only
7.Recommended Privacy be for as long as necessary:
Solutions - for the fulfillment of the declared, specified, and
legitimate purpose;
Privacy Management Program (PMP) - for the establishment, exercise, or defense of
- Holistic approach to privacy and data protection legal claims; or
- Ensures compliance with the set privacy laws - for legitimate business purposes, which must
and regulations, specifically by the DPA be consistent with standards followed by the
- It would help safeguard the reputations of either applicable industry or approved by the
organizations and individuals appropriate Government agency.
Guidelines in collecting, processing and accessing How may personal data be disposed of?
personal data - It must be disposed securely in order to avoid
- The data subject has given their consent, additional processing, unauthorized access, or
specific to the purpose prior to the processing; disclosure to third parties.
- Anyone involved in healthcare delivery must - Data disposal should be performed based on
gather only the required personal an organization’s retention policy.
information;
- It is necessary to protect the life and health Data disposal methods
of the data subject and he/she is not legally or - Data anonymization
physically able to express consent prior to the - Data deletion
processing; - Data crypto shredding
- Data degaussing (weakening the magnetic field 3. Can I publicly disclose the identities of COVID-19
to dispose data) patients?
- Data destruction COVID-19 Patient Contact Tracing
• No public identity disclosure required.
Data Privacy Act of 2012 penalizes improper disposal • DPA doesn't hinder tracing or data processing.
of personal information and sensitive personal
information.
Penalty for improper disposal of personal information
(IDPI) Benefits and challenges of technology
- imprisonment ranging from six months to two - Technology has its advantages on the health
years care system primarily on streamlining the
- a fine of PHP 100,000 to PHP 500,000 services and makes the workload of healthcare
(Republic Act 10173 - Data Privacy Act of 2012 professionals lighter and more efficient.
- National Privacy Commission, 2022).
1. Improve care coordination
- Information should not be in jargons for better - act of organizing patient care
understanding of the patient - ex. IoT wearable devices(ex. heart rate
- information can be withdrawn if a patient wants watch, fitness apps)-challenge is
to. accuracy
- electronic health record (universal
Penalty for improper disposal for sensitive personal healthcare)-lahat ng healthcare
information (IDSPI) providers ay kaya maaccess yung
- imprisonment ranging from one to three years document ng patient para sa continuity
- a fine of PHP 100,000 to PHP 1,000,000 of care.
(Republic Act 10173 - Data Privacy Act of 2012 - telemedicine (practice of medicine using
- National Privacy Commission, 2022). gadgets)
2. Easy access to patient medical records
Relevant Issues and Concerns of Data Privacy to 3. Reduction in medical errors
COVID-19 Response 4. Better diagnostics and treatment
5. Improved population health management
1. What are the guidelines when conducting contact 6. Greater patient care
tracing? 7. Simplified workflow
DOH Guidelines on COVID-19 Contact Tracing 8. Improved patient education
• Emphasizes data privacy and subjects' rights. 9. Reduced cost
• Balances risks and benefits.
• Ensures fair, lawful, secure data processing. According to Zarif, the challenges of technology in
• Designing processing systems with data privacy in healthcare can be viewed into three categories:
mind. - Healthcare organizations
• Integrating data subjects' rights into the system. - Healthcare provider
• Conducting Privacy Impact Assessment (PIA) to - Patients
identify and resolve risks.
HEALTHCARE ORGANIZATIONS
2. Can I share Information about COVID- 19 patients? Interoperability (easy sharing of data to other
NPC's PHE Bulletin No. 6: Healthcare facility)
• Requires sharing and disclosure of COVID-19 patient - a big concern, raised by the idea of new
data to proper authority. technology.
• Adheres to data privacy principles: transparency, - The expense of technology is one of the most
legitimate purpose, proportionality. significant difficulties for enterprises in terms of
• Allows PICs and PIPs to execute DSAs. installation, and subsequent upkeep.
- kakayahan magshare ng information sa iba't
ibang healthcare facility
- may possibilities na hindi nagrreflect ang ● Individual Health- related practices
continuity of care. - digital health technologies often include
Data Security self tracking features and restricts
- also an important factor that comes with the human action
challenges of technology in healthcare. ● Interpersonal relationship
- mataas ang possibility na mahack - Health-related use of social media can
- season 4 episode 9 ng New Amsterdam create interpersonal networks that
reinforce specific viewpoints on health
HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS issues, which can potentially harm
- Despite the fact that healthcare technology public health.
offers great opportunities to enhance healthcare ● Organizational policies
outcomes, it also comes with its own - Digital technologies can significantly
challenges: change daily work practices, thereby
- All medical staff must know how to use these altering the structure and function of
technologies properly. organizations.
- The comfort and ease of use of current systems
make users reluctant to change to new Lobbying / Advocating for Ethical Issues in
technology. Healthcare
Advocacy
PATIENTS ● Advocacy means a coordinated combination of
- The necessity to assure appropriate use of problem identification, solution creation, strategy
costly equipment and the moral obligation to development, and actions taken to make positive
use new technology directly contradicts the change.
need to protect patient autonomy. ● In the context of nursing practice, there is a
- Lack of physical patient to doctor interaction. distinction made between “case advocacy” directed at
individual patients. “class advocacy” directed at
Current technology: Issues and dilemmas changing policies and social conditions.
1. Privacy and security
- A growing concern about how this data Case Advocacy
is used, stored, and shared. ● It is well known to nursing professionals, being part
2. Sociotechnical (telemedicine) of the field’s traditions and continuing professional
- Emphasizes interconnectedness of values.
technology and social systems,
highlighting how they co-evolve and Class Advocacy
shape each other. ● It is a more overtly political approach, and is quite
● Application Software different. Instead of focusing mainly on the client’s
- Ensuring the software is effective, fair opportunity choices, class advocacy focuses on
(unbiased), inclusive, transparent about its changing the system of opportunities itself to further
operations and data usage, and respectful of the interests of larger groups, organizations, or
user privacy and security. communities.
● Material Devices and Supply Chains Ethics Example: A mayor in Pampanga, established a dialysis
- Ethical considerations involve fair treatment of center designed to help the poor residents, she said
workers, environmental sustainability, and they will prioritize “ San Fernando residents and poor
responsible sourcing of materials throughout ones, and the services will be free”.
the production and distribution process.
● infrastructures Basis of Nursing Advocacy:
- this refers to the hardware and software 1. Preserving human dignity- privacy regulations, they
needed for digital devices should be mindful of how culture and ethnicity may
- It lacks high-speed internet prevents influence a patient's experience. Generally speaking,
certain communities from accessing nurses are in a unique position that enables them to
digital health care combine all facets of patient care, ensuring that issues
are addressed, standards are upheld, and successful ● In health care, nurses who transition into lobbying
results continue. are well-placed to represent and advocate for their
2. Patient equality- The healthcare industry is patient’s interests.
constantly evolving, with new technology and
regulations affecting care. However, the ANA code of Health Care Lobbyist are employed by:
ethics requires nurses to represent patients 1. Insurance groups
compassionately, respecting their dignity and 2. Drug companies
uniqueness. 3. Specialty organizations
3. Freedom from suffering- Nursing is a profession 4. Public health groups
aimed at helping others by preventing or managing 5. Other who have a stake in health care legislation
suffering, a critical aspect of patient care, and nurses
must be accessible to patients and their families. TOPIC 2: Code of Ethics for Nurses
NATIONAL NURSES ASSOCIATION WHEREAS, the promulgation of the said Code as a set
● Collaborate with nursing regulatory bodies, of guidelines, regulations or measures shall be subject
voluntary organizations, and global agencies to to approval by the Commission (Sec 9, Art. II of R.A.
develop position statements and guidelines that No. 9173); and
support human rights, environmental justice
and international peace. WHEREAS, the Board, after consultation on October
● Contribute to legislation and policies on the 23, 2003 at Iloilo City with the accredited professional
ethical use of technology and scientific organization of registered nurses, the Philippine
advances adapted to the health and social Nurses association, Inc (PNA), and other affiliate
norms and context of the country. organizations of Registered Nurses decided to adopt a
● Participate in the development of legislation to New Code of Ethics under the afore-mention new Law:
reduce the impact of hospitals and the
healthcare industry on the environment and
NOW, THEREFORE, the Board hereby resolved as it event of conflicts, their welfare and safety must take
now resolves, to promulgate the hereunder Code of precedence. (Professional Regulation Committee, n.d)
Ethics for Registered Nurses.
ARTICLE III. REGISTERED NURSES AND
ARTICLE I. PREAMBLE PRACTICE
Section 1. SECTION 6.
Health is a fundamental right of every individual. The Ethical Principles
Filipino registered nurse, believing in the worth and 1. Human life is inviolable.
dignity of each human being, recognizes the primary 2. Quality and excellence in the care of the patients are
responsibility to preserve health at all cost. This the goal of nursing practice.
responsibility encompasses promotion of health, 3. Accurate documentation of actions and outcomes of
prevention of illness, alleviation of suffering and delivered care is the hallmark of nursing accountability.
restoration of health. However, when the foregoing are (Professional Regulation Committee, n.d)
not possible, assistance towards a peaceful death shall SECTION 7. Guidelines to be observed:
be his/her obligation. REGISTERED Nurses must
a. know the definition and scope of nursing practice
Section 2. which are in the provisions of R.A. No. 9173, known as
To assume the responsibility, registered nurses have to the “Philippine Nursing Act of 2002” and Board Res.
gain knowledge and understanding of man’s cultural, No. 425, Series of 2003, the “Rules and Regulations
social, spiritual, psychological, and ecological aspects Implementing the Philippine Nursing Act. of 2002”, (the
of illness, utilizing therapeutic processes. Cultural IRR).
diversity and political and socio-economic status are b. be aware of their duties and responsibilities in the
inherent factors of nursing care. practice of their profession as defined in the “Philippine
Nursing Act. Of 2002” and the IRR.
Section 3. c. acquire and develop the necessary competence in
The desire for the respect and confidence of clients, knowledge, skills, and attitudes to effectively render
colleagues, co-workers and the members of the appropriate nursing services through varied learning
community provides the incentive to attain and situations.
maintain the highest possible degree of ethical d. if they are administrators, be responsible in providing
conduct. a favorable environment for the growth and
developments of Registered Nurses in their charge.
ARTICLE II. REGISTERED NURSES AND PEOPLE e. be cognizant that professional programs for specialty
SECTION 4. certification by the BON are accredited through the
Ethical Principles Nursing Specialty Certification Council (NSCC).
1. Values, customs, and spiritual beliefs held by f. see to it that quality nursing care and practice meet
individuals shall be respected. the optimum standard of safe nursing practice.
2. Individual freedom to make rational and g. ensure that modification of practice shall consider
unconstrained decisions shall be resected. the principles of safe nursing practice.
3. Personal information acquired in the process of h. if in a position of authority in a work environment, be
giving nursing care shall be held in strict confidence. normally and legally responsible for devising a system
of minimizing occurrences of ineffective and unlawful
SECTION 5. Guidelines to be observed: nursing practice.
REGISTERED Nurses must: i. ensure that patients’ records shall be available only if
a. consider the individuality and totality of patients they are to be issued to those who are professionally
when they administer care. and directly involved in their care and when they are
b. respect the spiritual beliefs and practices of patients required by law. (Professional Regulation Committee,
regarding diet and treatment. n.d)
c. uphold the rights of individuals.
d. take into consideration the culture and values of SECTION 8.
patients in providing nursing care. However, in the Ethical Principle
Registered Nurses are the advocates of the patients: 2. The Registered Nurse maintains collegial and
they shall take appropriate steps to safeguard their collaborative working relationships with colleagues and
rights and privileges. other health care providers.