Midway Report 1
Midway Report 1
on
STUDY OF ENERGY ECONOMY IMPROVEMENT OF A
THREE WHEELER ELECTRIC VEHICLE
Submitted by
Priymohana Misra
102004073
2024
Electrical and Instrumentation Engineering Department
Thapar Institute of Engineering and Technology, Patiala
(Declared as Deemed-to-be-University u/s 3 of the UGC Act., 1956)
Post Bag No. 32, Patiala – 147004
Punjab (India)
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
LIST OF FIGURES 3
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION 4
1.1 ABOUT THE PROJECT 4
CHAPTER 2: WORK DONE TILL NOW IN THE PROJECT 5
2.1 UNDERSTANDING THE WORKING OF
SUPERCAPACITOR 5
2.2 UNDERSTANDING THE WORKING OF ELECTRIC
VEHICLE 6
2.3 UNDERSTANDING THE WORKING OF BATTERY
MANAGEMENT SYSTEM 7
2.4 COMMON TAKEAWAY POINTS FROM THE RESEARCH
PAPERS 9
2.5 DETAILED ANALYSIS OF EACH RESEARCH PAPER 11
CHAPTER 3: RESULTS & CONCLUSIONS 17
CHAPTER 4: REMAINING TASKS TO BE COMPLETED 18
REFRENCES 19
2
LIST OF FIGURES
3
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
In the context of the growing demand for sustainable transportation solutions, electric
vehicles (EVs) have emerged as a promising alternative to traditional internal combustion
engine vehicles. However, challenges such as limited range, lengthy charging times, and
concerns about battery degradation continue to hinder widespread adoption. Herein lies the
significance of supercapacitors, offering rapid energy storage and discharge capabilities that
complement the slower energy delivery of batteries. Integrating supercapacitors alongside
batteries in EVs presents an opportunity to address these challenges effectively. As the
project unfolds, it will commence with a thorough exploration of supercapacitors, elucidating
their fundamental principles and operational characteristics through a comprehensive review
of relevant research papers. Subsequently, the focus will shift towards understanding the
dynamics of three-wheeler EVs with integrated supercapacitors and batteries, analyzing
existing literature to discern the synergistic effects and potential challenges of this
integration. Concurrently, a detailed examination of Battery Management Systems (BMS)
will be undertaken to optimize the performance and lifespan of the integrated energy storage
system. By reviewing literature and research findings, the project aims to understand the
functionalities of BMS, including state-of-charge monitoring, cell balancing, and thermal
management, and explore their implications for energy economy and longevity. Leveraging
insights gleaned from these investigations, the project will progress towards the development
of Simulink models to simulate the integrated energy storage system. Incorporating relevant
parameters and variables identified from research papers, these models will facilitate the
analysis of system performance and efficiency under diverse driving conditions, thereby
providing valuable insights for future development and optimization. Ultimately, this project
aims to advance our understanding of energy economy improvement in three-wheeler EVs
through the integration of supercapacitors and batteries, contributing to the ongoing evolution
of sustainable transportation technologies and accelerating the transition towards a greener
automotive landscape.
4
CHAPTER 2
WORK DONE TILL NOW IN THE PROJECT
5
them, as well as the properties of the electrolyte. Due to the large surface area and short
distance between electrodes, supercapacitors can achieve much higher capacitance values
compared to traditional capacitors.
During discharging, when a load is connected to the supercapacitor, stored energy is released
as ions return to the electrolyte solution, and current flows through the external circuit.
Supercapacitors can deliver high power output rapidly, making them suitable for applications
requiring quick energy bursts, such as regenerative braking in electric vehicles or peak power
shaving in renewable energy systems.
6
The motor's speed and torque are controlled by the motor controller, which adjusts the
voltage and current supplied by the power electronics.
The Battery Management System (BMS) is responsible for monitoring and managing the
battery pack's health, performance, and safety. It ensures proper charging, discharging, and
cell balancing to optimize battery life and prevent overcharging or over-discharging. In an
EV with integrated supercapacitors, the BMS also coordinates the operation of the
supercapacitors, ensuring seamless integration and optimal energy utilization.
The Control System coordinates the operation of all components in the EV, including the
battery pack, supercapacitors, power electronics, and motor. It implements algorithms to
optimize energy management, regulate power flow, and enhance overall vehicle performance.
The control system may prioritize using supercapacitors during high-power demand
situations such as acceleration, while relying on the battery pack for steady-state driving.
The battery management system (BMS) serves as the "brain" of an electric vehicle's (EV)
battery pack, overseeing its operation, ensuring safety, and optimizing performance. The
working of each of its processes is mentioned as follows:
1. State of Charge (SOC) Monitoring: One of the primary functions of the BMS is to
monitor the state of charge of individual cells within the battery pack. It accurately measures
the remaining capacity of each cell and aggregates this information to determine the overall
state of charge of the battery pack. This data is crucial for estimating the range of the EV and
providing accurate feedback to the driver.
7
2. Cell Balancing: The BMS ensures that all cells within the battery pack are balanced,
meaning they have the same state of charge. This is essential for maximizing the capacity and
lifespan of the battery pack. To achieve this, the BMS can redistribute energy between cells
during charging and discharging cycles, ensuring that no cell is overcharged or over-
discharged.
4. Cell Voltage Monitoring: The BMS continuously monitors the voltage of each cell to
ensure that it remains within safe operating limits. It can detect abnormal voltage levels that
may indicate cell degradation, internal shorts, or other faults. In case of an anomaly, the BMS
may trigger protective measures such as cell isolation to prevent further damage.
5. State of Health (SOH) Estimation: By analyzing data collected over time, the BMS can
estimate the state of health of the battery pack, which refers to its overall condition and
remaining lifespan. This information helps vehicle owners and manufacturers make informed
decisions regarding battery maintenance, replacement, and warranty claims.
6. Safety Functions: In addition to monitoring and control functions, the BMS incorporates
safety features to protect the battery pack and the vehicle occupants. It can detect and respond
to hazardous conditions such as short circuits, overcurrent, overvoltage, and undervoltage
events by isolating faulty cells or disconnecting the battery pack from the vehicle's electrical
system.
7. Communication and Data Logging: Modern BMSs are equipped with communication
interfaces that allow them to exchange data with other vehicle systems, external devices, and
cloud-based platforms. They can transmit real-time battery information to the vehicle's
onboard display, diagnostic tools, or remote monitoring systems. Additionally, BMSs store
historical data for performance analysis, diagnostics, and predictive maintenance purposes.
8
The battery management system plays a crucial role in ensuring the safe and efficient
operation of electric vehicle battery packs, optimizing their performance, and prolonging
their lifespan. It combines sophisticated monitoring, control, and safety features to manage
the complex electrochemical processes occurring within the battery cells and maintain the
overall health of the battery pack throughout its lifecycle.
10
increase an EV's driving range. This passage delves deeper into the specific benefits
supercapacitors provide, going beyond the general trends previously discussed.
11
This paper explores the simulation of a hybrid storage system (HSS) for Electric Vehicles
(EVs), integrating both battery and supercapacitor modules. The objective is to assess the
system's performance using MATLAB SIMULINK, focusing on mitigating battery stresses
and enhancing storage efficiency. By addressing challenges like high peak currents and
uneven loading profiles, the integration of supercapacitors aims to extend battery lifespan and
improve overall energy storage efficiency. This paragraph provides a more detailed
exploration of the unique advantages offered by supercapacitors, surpassing the preceding
discussion of general patterns.
The research paper conducts a meticulous analysis of the impact of a supercapacitor (SC)
system on battery operation in Electric Vehicles (EVs). By utilizing histogram representation,
the authors reveal significant variations and high absolute values in energy storage current
profiles, highlighting potential negative consequences for battery health. This sets the stage
for exploring how the SC system, coupled with an energy management control algorithm, can
12
effectively mitigate these issues. This paragraph offers a more comprehensive analysis of the
distinct benefits that supercapacitors provide, going beyond the previous discourse on broad
trends.
Research Paper 4: Battery Supercapacitor Energy Storage System for Electric Vehicles:
A Review
13
This study examines challenges faced by contemporary batteries in meeting evolving energy
requirements for electric vehicles (EVs), particularly concerning non-monotonic power
consumption patterns during discharge. It advocates for strategic integration of batteries with
supercapacitors, emphasizing the latter's speed capability and cyclability. The research paper
reviews battery advancements and highlights persistent issues, proposing a symbiotic
coupling of batteries and supercapacitors for future EVs to align with sustainability goals and
mitigate environmental impacts. This paragraph delves deeper into the distinctive benefits
provided by supercapacitors, beyond the previous description of common trends.
2. HESS Topologies:
The common takeaways mentioned different HESS configurations, but the research paper
delves into the technical details. It explains three main HESS topologies based on energy
demand and DC-DC converter configuration: passive (no power circuits), active (single DC-
DC converter), and semi-active (two DC-DC converters). This provides a deeper
understanding of the different ways HESS systems can be architected.
Fig (a)
14
Fig (b)
Fig (c)
Fig 2.4 Topologies for HESS (a) Passive (b) Semi Active (c) Active configuration
15
characteristics of advanced supercapacitors and their potential for electric vehicles, offering a
more nuanced perspective compared to the common takeaways and trends.
2. Exceptional Efficiency:
Supercapacitors can deliver and absorb energy with minimal losses, significantly improving
overall system efficiency compared to batteries. This translates to extended range on a single
charge and reduced reliance on charging infrastructure.
16
CHAPTER 3
RESULT AND CONCLUSION
Here are the general results and conclusions derived from the collective analysis of the
research papers:
1. Enhanced Efficiency: The integration of supercapacitors with batteries in electric vehicles
(EVs) demonstrates a significant improvement in energy efficiency, particularly during
regenerative braking. Supercapacitors excel in capturing and storing energy during braking,
outperforming traditional batteries and contributing to a more efficient overall EV system.
2. Extended Driving Range: The use of hybrid energy storage systems (HESS) combining
batteries and supercapacitors leads to a substantial increase in driving range for EVs. This
improvement is attributed to the superior power density of supercapacitors, allowing for
efficient energy storage and delivery, especially during peak power demands such as
acceleration.
3. Battery Lifespan Extension: Supercapacitors act as a buffer, absorbing high peak currents
and reducing stress on the battery during operation. This results in a slower degradation rate
for batteries, thereby extending their overall lifespan within EVs. Moreover, the efficient
management of energy flow by supercapacitors contributes to the protection and longevity of
battery cells.
5. Cost and Economic Viability: While supercapacitors currently face challenges such as
lower energy density and higher upfront costs compared to batteries, ongoing research
indicates promising advancements in energy density and manufacturing techniques. As
energy density increases and manufacturing costs decrease, supercapacitors have the potential
to become more cost-competitive and economically viable for widespread adoption in EVs.
17
CHAPTER 4
18
REFERENCES
5. Diana Lemian and Florin Bode “Battery-Supercapacitor Energy Storage Systems for
Electrical Vehicles: A Review” August 2022 Energies 15(15):5683.
6. Andrew Burke, Zhengmao Liu & Hengbing Zhao “Present and Future Applications of
Supercapacitors in Electric and Hybrid Vehicles” 2015 IEEE 82nd Vehicular
Technology Conference (VTC2015-Fall)
19