BMW's Magnesium-Aluminium Composite Crankcase, State-of-the-Art Light Metal Casting and Manufacturing
BMW's Magnesium-Aluminium Composite Crankcase, State-of-the-Art Light Metal Casting and Manufacturing
SAE TECHNICAL
PAPER SERIES 2006-01-0069
400 Commonwealth Drive, Warrendale, PA 15096-0001 U.S.A. Tel: (724) 776-4841 Fax: (724) 776-5760 Web: www.sae.org
Downloaded from SAE International by University of Minnesota, Tuesday, July 31, 2018
The Engineering Meetings Board has approved this paper for publication. It has successfully completed
SAE's peer review process under the supervision of the session organizer. This process requires a
minimum of three (3) reviews by industry experts.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise,
without the prior written permission of SAE.
SAE Permissions
400 Commonwealth Drive
Warrendale, PA 15096-0001-USA
Email: [email protected]
Tel: 724-772-4028
Fax: 724-776-3036
ISSN 0148-7191
Copyright 2006 SAE International
Positions and opinions advanced in this paper are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of SAE.
The author is solely responsible for the content of the paper. A process is available by which discussions
will be printed with the paper if it is published in SAE Transactions.
Persons wishing to submit papers to be considered for presentation or publication by SAE should send the
manuscript or a 300 word abstract to Secretary, Engineering Meetings Board, SAE.
Printed in USA
Downloaded from SAE International by University of Minnesota, Tuesday, July 31, 2018
2006-01-0069
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
Dynamic performance, the ultimate driving experience, Figure 1: Definition of efficient dynamics
is one of the essential elements of all cars made by
BMW. The brand stands for high level of agility. To It quickly became clear that new concepts were needed.
achieve this objective not only by the one-sided optimi- On the other hand it was obvious that there was
sation of one single parameter a balanced coordination sufficient potential to reduce the weight of the main
of all properties is necessary. The mass of the engine is engine component, the crankcase.
particularly important for this, since it not only deter-
mines the car’s gross weight significantly, but also has a
considerable effect on the axle load distribution [1].
The history of this component shows that one techno- Since magnesium alloys cannot be used as material for
logical leap had already taken place: from iron casting to cylinder liners, appropriately designed cylinder liners
aluminium. This resulted in a significant reduction in were developed from aluminium and integrated in a
weight (Figure 2), especially in the case of larger magnesium housing (Figure 3). The essential selection
engines with specific power > 55 kW per litre. Following parameters in this case are the resistance to wear and
several generations of aluminium crankcases, a further tear coupled with low friction and good thermal
weight reduction hardly seemed feasible. properties. These combined properties are realised by
using the hyper-eutectic aluminium alloy AlSi17Cu4Mg
In order to develop new potentials for new engines, the (A390), which has tradition and long since been used at
following boundary conditions had to be fulfilled: BMW.
- high power density with the potential Due to the low corrosion stability of magnesium, it is not
for further development possible to add commercial available liquid engine
- compliance with existing package coolants in contact with magnesium. It is therefore
boundary conditions necessary to separate the addition of the media for the
- favourable thermal properties liquid coolant from the magnesium surface. A further
- high potential for acoustic properties restriction with regard to design is the low creep
resistance of magnesium, especially at temperatures
Taking these boundary conditions into consideration, it above 120°C, which cannot be avoided in high perfor-
appears useful to investigate magnesium in a more mance engines. This creep can result in an unwanted
detailed manner. It is around 30% less dense than deformation of functional areas and to the loosening of
aluminium with comparable strengths: however, the special high strength bolts made of aluminium. In order
Young’s modulus is around this percentage lower than to avoid these effects, it is necessary to generate
that of aluminium. In the case of a corresponding supporting structures in zones with high loads and to
construction, there are the following options to ensure accommodate e.g. the cylinder head bearings in this
further reduction in weight. structure.
aluminium
bedplate sintered
steel inlays
the crankshaft bearings and the cylinder head bearings. two process steps. In the first step the insert is
In order to enable this composite technology, an ‘open- manufactured in a low-pressure casting process from a
deck’ design (this means an open water jacket) is hyper-eutectic aluminium alloy, type AISi17Cu4Mg. The
necessary as a further essential construction feature. material is cast via a feeding tube with low pressure into
a heated, permanent mould. After filling, the mould is
water cooled in order to guarantee a guided solidification
of this most sensitive aluminium alloy. After complete
solidification had taken place, the mould is opened and
the insert is removed. Due to the high silicon content,
the alloy used is considerably more difficult to cast than
the usual die casting alloys, since the optimal process
parameters are in a smaller range and the processing
takes place at elevated temperatures. In addition to the
actual component quality like density and solidification
porosities, the distribution of the silicon particles close
to the surface of the cylinder liner are decisive, because
the silicon distribution can only be represented by a
precise temperature control of the whole process and a
very efficient cooling system. Therefore the casting
process was planned and optimised right from the
beginning by casting computer simulation using the
Figure 5: Insert, made of AlSi17Cu4Mg FDM-software tools from MagmaSoft.
The insert bears significant percentage of the rigidity After the casting process, every insert component is
and the strength of the composite crankcase, whilst the labelled by means of a two dimensional, machine
magnesium housing causes the maximum weight readable code, called ‘data matrix code’ (DMC), figure 6.
reduction. All relevant process parameters, like casting machine,
mould, shift, operator and metal batch, are stored in an
Great attention has been paid to the design of the ALS control system with reference to the part. Following
interlock between the aluminium insert and the cooling, all inserts are automatically X-ray controlled
magnesium housing. During the cooling after the die before they are machined and prepared for the following
casting process the magnesium jacket shrinks around die casting process.
the aluminium insert, which is permanently anchored
within the magnesium jacket by ribs and undercuts. This
design philosophy ensures the transmission of all forces
under maximum operating loads [3].
SURFACE TREATMENT Due to the high metal temperature and the high impact
velocity of the particles on the surface of the insert, a
After machining, the surface of the insert is auto- porous, rough layer (Figure 7) with a very large specific
matically spray-treated in a cool atmosphere with hard surface is produced. During the magnesium die casting
and ductile corundum, to clean and to homogenise the process, the heat of the magnesium melt and the very
surface. For reasons of corrosion and roughness, a high pressure of the HPDC machine transfers the pre-
considerably more economical spraying method with vious AlSi12-coating into a ‘ductile’ reaction zone. This
steel granules accelerated by spinner gates could not be reaction zone is acting as a metallurgical connection
realised. Due to its low density and its high abrasiveness between aluminium and magnesium by resisting thermal
the corundum grains cannot be accelerated by spinner stresses during engine life (Figure 8).
gates, instead injector jet nozzles are used. Previous
experiments have shown that a minimum roughness
about Rz = 70 µm (acc. DIN EN ISO 1302) is necessary. MAGNESIUM MELTING PLANT
pallet geometry (Figure 10), an automatic depalletising matrix code (DMC), including all necessary data of the
of the ingots and ingate systems is realised. The die-casting process (Figure 13).
transportation of the liquid magnesium alloy takes place
in special developed transport furnaces (called MTB)
with a capacity of 600 kg. Handled by a fork lifter the
transport furnaces are docked to the melting furnace on
the one hand and to the casting furnace on the other
hand (Figure 11) [3].
dangerous concentration of hydrogen, some construc- traces (Figure 14). All inside coverings of the BAZ made
tive optimisations and process techniques are neces- of plastic or sheet metal are shaped to generate flat,
sarily added to the process chain. even and smooth surface without any undercuts or areas
where chips can accumulate and originate hazardous
conditions (Figure 15).
SILICON DISTRIBUTION
small specimen or the fax-film method, where an inverse angle and of the depth in the liner. By this data, an
topography copy of the liner surface is produced [7]. extensive image-analysing software system creates a
Both methods have the disadvantage that only a very graphic image, which displays the local electrical
limited area of some square millimetres can be analysed. conductivity and consequently the local silicon distribu-
Also the preparation of the specimens is a long time tion (Figure 18).
consuming process.
piston movement
Figure 17: Primary and secondary silicon particles The testing equipment works fully automatically and
(microscopic analysis) includes a computer aided CA image analysing and
determining system, which delivers detailed information
Contrary to the other properties even small parameter about size, shape and percentage low density silicon
changes during the casting process can influence the areas. It allows the determination of a “quality number”
silicon distribution strongly. Therefore, it was necessary for each individual cylinder liner.
to develop and commission a completely new fast
working testing method with a high grade of reproduci-
bility which must be fully integrated in the manufacturing
process and control system. BONDING BETWEEN MAGNESIUM AND ALUMINIUM
The fundamental idea for determining the grade of In order to carry out standard non-destructive tests on
homogeneous distribution of the silicon particles is the connection layer, the standard tests usually carried
based on the physical effect, that areas with high silicon out to ensure quality in the casting area, e.g. X-ray
content have low electrical conductivity and vice versa, analysis, ultrasonic analysis and computed tomography
hence the value of the local electrical conductivity can CT are not suitable for the composite crankcase. The
be determined by the eddy-current method for high reason is that the internal cracks and detachments of the
resolution analyses. This non-destructive testing connection layer due to the increased thermal expansion
method can be used for all electro-conductive materials of the magnesium and the associated shrinkage on the
by the use of a high-frequency magnetic field, which is insert, have to be present on the insert. For the assess-
created by a micro-coil inside a sensor. Based on this ment of the bonding quality of the magnesium-
magnetic field and the level of electrical conductivity of aluminium interface in the ready machined crankcase, a
the specimen an eddy-current field generates a new non destructive testing method was developed,
measurable signal in another detection micro-coil. The which is called ultrasonic-stimulated lock-in thermo-
higher the level of conductivity the higher is the graphy.
magnetic field of the eddy-current signal. These signals
are amplified and filtered, and can be related to a local
electrical conductivity of the electro-conductive mate-
rial, which corresponds to the local density of the silicon
particles.
This high performance engine celebrated its debut in the [7] H. Brosinsky, ‘Stereoscan-Aufnahmen und Fax-
BMW 6-Series (Figure 22) in 2004, followed by the new Film-Bilder von Oberflächen gußeisener Motoren-
3 Series (Figure 23) and the 5 Series and the 7 Series in zylinder‘ Technische Zeitung für praktische
2005. Recently this engine has become available to the Metallbearbeitung, 64.Jahrgang (1970)
customers in the 130i, the high performance version of
the 1 Series, and will be accelerating the new Z4
roadster and Z4 Coupé (Figure 24) in 2006 as well. In CONTACT
the foreseeable future, engines with the composite [email protected]
crankcase will be an option for all BMW vehicles. [email protected]
[email protected]
BMW Group
Leichtmetall Gießerei Landshut
Ohmstr. 1, 84030 Landshut
Germany
REFERENCES
[1] C. Landerl, R. Jooß, A. Fischersworring-Bunk, J.
Wolf, A. Fent, S. Jagodzinski, ‘Aluminium and
magnesium compound construction-an innovative
approach to lightweight technology in crankcases’,
th
12 Aachen Colloquium (2003)