V_Panel_Appendix4_Field_Guide_Fletcher_Creativity
V_Panel_Appendix4_Field_Guide_Fletcher_Creativity
evolve or die
Creative Thinking:
A Field Guide to Building Your
Strategic Core
for
US Army
Command & General Staff College
1
In Memoriam, Colonel Scott Green
2
War breaks victory’s old rules. . .
Genius creates the new.
—Carl von Clausewitz
3
Mission Statement
4
To incorporate scientific rigor, the Guide contains several sets
of definitions along with a formal review of equations at the end.
There's also a quick reference in the form of “10 Myths About
Creativity,” that solidifies the underlying scientific precepts.
5
Table of Contents
Definitions
Introduction
Final Review
Acknowledgements
6
Definitions
7
The Simple Dirty
To think outside, you must forget what has worked and seek what can.
To seek what can work, you must dismiss your hopes and fears.
You must get in the habit of planning fast and re-planning faster.
You must forget about being perfect and strive only to get better.
You must have many minds inside, including your enemy’s mind.
8
Introduction
You’ve just hit the beachhead when you discover: the enemy has
been watching. He’s learned all your protocols, your tactics, your
secrets. He knows what you know, can think how you think, and is
anticipating your every move. What do you do?
9
Section One: Want It, Get It
10
Module 1: Born to Innovate
Your first ancestor is life. Life emerged 3.5 billion years ago,
and it birthed evolution, filling the world with new creations.
11
The bravery to change your mind.
The bravery to risk what no one else has ever risked before.
12
Module 2: War’s Great Unknown
The professors were the products of the Age of Reason. And Reason
taught that life was a machine that obeyed mathematical laws. Those
laws predetermined everything. Know them, and you could compute
victory before a shot was fired.
So radical was this new theory of war that Clausewitz did not
risk publishing it in his own lifetime. So radical was this new
theory of war that it was ignored at 1850s West Point, where the
officers who’d later witness the muddled butchery of Gettysburg
were trained to believe that battles could be won with clockwork
precision. So radical was this new theory of war that it still
appears radical today.
13
data-driven decisions. Today we have Power Points, acronyms,
standard operating procedures, and a million other surefire
formulas for success.
But what was true at Waterloo and Gettysburg remains true now.
There is no way to program victory. If you’re fighting anywhere
except a digital simulation, environmental friction and fog will
frustrate your plans. And a human adversary, born and bred in
cultures different from your own, will shatter them irreparably.
And that’s why you will win, too. Because you will plan before
battle, not to have a plan——but to practice planning. That practice
will energize your innate creativity, giving you the confidence to
plan and plan again.
14
but planning is indispensable.” Recall a past plan of
yours that failed. Then write out how you rebounded
from that failure by planning again.
15
Module 3: Creativity Complements Compliance
The North has therefore garrisoned the town with 12,500 soldiers,
under the command of Colonel Dixon Miles. Miles is a West Point
graduate who was twice cited for “gallant” conduct during the
Mexican-American War but who has more recently disgraced himself
at the First Battle of Bull Run getting drunk out of a mix of
boredom and resentment at being assigned to the reserves. Harper’s
Ferry is his chance to redeem himself, and his orders are clear:
“Hold the town.”
But what should that preparation be? Grimes and several other
junior officers urge Miles to take the offensive, dispatching
16
troops to occupy the three heights and unleashing calva ry to
ambush Jackson’s artillery. Miles, however, rejects this as a
breach of his orders to station his forces at Harper’s Ferry.
He has not been told to “Occupy the heights” or “Ambush the
enemy.” He has been told to “Hold the town,” and dammit, he
will follow that command. Dismayed by Miles’s attitude of
unimaginative compliance, Grimes protests that there’s no way
to “Hold the town” if the enemy gets his cannon on the slopes
above. But Miles, not wanting to be chastised again by his
superiors, insists on hunkering obediently in place.
Those are the basic facts about the Battle of Harper’s Ferry.
Now here’s the question: Who better served his commanding
17
officer? Miles, who followed his orders literally? Or Grimes,
who followed their deeper spirit?
To McClellan, the answer was obvious: Grimes. And the same answer
remains obvious to the Army’s generals today. General Mark Milley,
appointed Chairman of the Joint Chiefs in 2019, has asked us to
imagine that he’s just told a young officer to destroy the enemy
by seizing Hill 101. But then. . .
. . . the young officer sees Hill 101, and the enemy is over on
Hill 102. What does he do? Does he do what I told him to do,
seize Hill 101? Or does he achieve the purpose, destroy the enemy
on Hill 102?
The answer is: Do what Grimes would do. Seize Hill 102.
18
Module 4: Win This Battle, Not the Last One
It was 19 October 202 BC, upon the dusty plains of Zama. To the
northwest were the graying remnants of Rome’s Fifth and Sixth
Legions, exiled for their humiliating defeat to a Carthaginian
general at the Battle of Cannae, fourteen years before. And waiting
across the battlefield, to the southeast, was that same
Carthaginian general: Hannibal.
Hannibal was sure that he’d humiliate the legions again. After
all, he hadn’t just humiliated them at Cannae. He’d humiliated
them at Ticinus, Trebia, Lake Trasimene, and Geronium. And he’d
done so every time with the same basic tactic: unpredictable
movement. Deploying light calvary, fast skirmishers, and galloping
cattle with their horns ablaze, Hannibal had disorientated the
Romans, neutralizing their great technological advantage: heavy
infantry. Before Hannibal, that infantry had mown down army after
army, defeating Samnites, then Gauls, then Western Greeks. But it
had been scrambled by Hannibal’s irregular attacks, turned
lumbering, confused, and flatfooted like a rhinoceros mobbed by
bees.
The Romans had evolved. They weren’t the old Romans that Hannibal
had defeated earlier. They had transformed into agile movers. And
they now moved agilely to destroy Hannibal, routing him into exile.
19
Hannibal’s disaster is the disaster that befalls every commander
who prioritizes what has worked over what can work. That’s because
knowledge of what has worked comes from the past. And if you focus
on the past, you will always be fighting the last war——dooming you
to be outflanked by an adversary who’s imagining the next one.
So, if you want to win the victory, remember: your enemy has
already mastered your previous moves. To defeat him, you must
reinvent yourself.
You must stop being a product of history. And you must make the
future a product of yourself.
20
Module 5: Creativity is Your Gift to Others
The order was issued with the best intentions. The Navy was
hemorrhaging pilots and aircraft over the jungles of Vietnam
in Operation Rolling Thunder, and it was convinced that its
shocking casualties were due to the high failure rate of its
F-4 Phantoms’ air-to-air missiles. To fix the glitch, Admiral
Tom Moorer, Chief of Naval Operations, had therefore
commissioned an in-depth study——the Ault Report——that devoted
200 pages to detailing how missile performance could be
upgraded. This report was the source of the order issued to
Petersen: tucked into the small print of the document’s hefty
paperwork, as item 11 of 15 under paragraph 6 on page 37, was
a recommendation to establish an Advanced Fighter Weapons
School that taught pilots how to best finesse the buggy
missiles.
21
bound. They flew robotically, sticking rigidly to textbook laws
of tactics that had been derived to apply to all aircraft, from
biplanes to bombers. This unimaginative choreography had been
detected by the enemy, who had cannily memorized the US pilots’
predictable dogfight patterns. The result was slaughter in the
sky, as rote-flying F-4 Phantoms were shot down by a nimble
adversary that had hacked the Americans’ drone-like decision-
making.
22
That’s the power of creativity. When the old system breaks
down, when the existing procedure traps you in a dead end, when
the pre-programmed textbook maneuver walks you into an ambush,
creativity can not only provide an escape route but hand you
back the initiative, enabling you to do what Dan Pedersen did
and actively protect the people who depend upon you.
23
Module 6: If You Want To Become More Creative,
You Will
The sky spread wide and blue when Julius Caesar heard the news.
But then the news came: Vercingetorix had sent for the rest of
his army. And it had answered his call, rumbling toward Caesar
with vast numbers of long-sworded warriors, chariots, and horsemen.
It was now the Romans who were encircled. And as the legionaries
blinked through the cold, September rain, they realized that the
Gauls had set a trap, pretending to sit still when they were really
catching Caesar in a massive pincer.
The only logical thing for the Romans to do now was flee. If
they moved fast, abandoning their siege wall, they could save
themselves from being overrun from behind. It would be a
humiliating retreat, certainly. It would tarnish Caesar’s
reputation, perhaps forever. But what else could you do when you’d
been surrounded by an army that outnumbered you ten to one?
24
These were the sensible thoughts that echoed through the minds
of Caesar’s officers. And Caesar felt them in his mind as well.
But then he looked up, through the day’s gathering mist, at the
wide, blue sky above. And he saw another possibility. He would not
run. He would build a second ten-mile wall, around the first, but
facing in the opposite direction. That second wall would enable
the Romans to fight a two-front siege, choking Vercingetorix in
Alesia while they held off the Gallic reinforcements from beyond.
25
to stand out, the more that he did. He intentionally made himself
an original.
26
norm. Be your own Caesar and bend the course of history by
committing yourself to being what every great commander is: an
individual, an independent thinker, an original.
27
Section Two: Unlock Your Creativity
Definitions
28
Module 7: Your Brain’s Two Kinds of Smarts
Over the ensuing decades, this test was improved into the Army
General Classification Test, then the Armed Forces Qualification
Test, and finally, the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery
or ASVAB.
29
systematizes the past; plotting speculates on the future. Logic is
certain and clarifying; plotting is flexible and empowering. Logic
fosters compliance; plotting fosters creativity.
The reason that the ASVAB only measures the first type of
intelligence is that until very recently, scientists believed that
there was only one kind of intelligence: so-called “general
intelligence.” And that general intelligence, the scientists
assumed, was logic. This is why almost all your coursework in high
school and college stressed math, critical thinking, and other
logic-based skills. And why the ASVAB does the same.
So, forget everything else you’ve been told about creativity and
focus on getting better at plotting. Push your brain to imagine
more original storylines and more individual story-characters, and
in a short time you’ll see the results: your brain’s creative
muscles will strengthen, cranking out more dynamic strategies and
more revolutionary innovations.
The previous modules of this book filled your mind with stories—
—about the Battle of Zama, Top Gun, Harper’s Ferry, and Alesia——
and characters——Hannibal, Dan Pedersen, Napoleon, Caesar——to
energize the plot-circuits of your imagination. And the following
modules will now focus that mental energy via precise plotting
techniques and technologies.
So, you don’t just think logically. You also think creatively,
going beyond ASVAB math and data to pass battle’s adaptive test.
30
Exercise 1. To train yourself to identify the difference between
logic and plotting, revisit one of your favorite
narratives, whether in a novel, a film, or a history.
Circle global events and character actions that make
sense but aren’t strictly rational. Your ability to
process those events is evidence of your brain’s
powers of causal reasoning, or in other words,
thinking in story.
31
Module 8: Shut Off Logic
Vincent van Gogh and Ludwig Beethoven used versions of the same
recipe. Only instead of playing a violin, van Gogh unwound by
reading his favorite author: Shakespeare. And instead of cruising
the open sea, Beethoven wandered the woods outside Vienna.
Over the next few modules, we’ll explore how to sharpen and
upgrade that imaginative work. But first, in this module, we’ll
lay the foundation for that work by focusing on how to relax logic.
Logic, as we learned in the last module, operates in a
fundamentally different way from plotting. So, the crucial first
step toward maximizing your plotting potential is to actively shut
down your brain’s logical regions.
32
also more targeted and efficient ways to power off your brain’s
logical circuits:
(2) Rather than defining what something is, imagine what it can
do. So, instead of thinking, That is an M8 smoke grenade,
think, That can be used to signal, or conceal, or surprise,
or distract, or. . . This mental technique is potential.
33
Training yourself to pause logic takes as much discipline as
training yourself to hone it. That’s because you’ve been
conditioned to prioritize critical thinking, evidence-based
reasoning, and logic’s other tools. And it’s also because when
you’ve relaxed in the past, you’ve done it like Einstein,
Beethoven, and Van Gogh: instead of zeroing in specifically on
relaxing logic, you’ve unwound in more imprecise ways.
Exercise 3. Pull a random book from your work library and skim
its index, chapter titles, or section headings. Pick
one that strikes your eye and use it to freestyle a
new idea.
34
Module 9: Story Constantly
The same that goes for Shakespeare goes for other creative
thinkers. They weren’t born creative. They became creative by
relentlessly exercising the plotting circuits of their brains.
35
for potential exigencies. And they also actively initiated new
plans. Instead of getting stuck on a single storyline that they
revised over and over, they constantly hatched original schemes,
until their minds were filled with a library of different stories
of the future, each with its own rich subplots and branching
variants. Like Shakespeare, they imagined hundreds of possible
life stories, each as unique as Hamlet or Cleopatra.
If these creatives had attempted to act out all their inner plots
and plans, they’d have descended into schizoid mania. But because
this creative activity took place inside the brain, it was richly
productive: it expanded Alexander, da Vinci, and Napoleon’s ability
to simultaneously inhabit multiple storylines——and multiple
perspectives. Just like reiterated pullups strengthen a biceps, so
did this repeated mental plotting strengthen the brain’s creative
muscle, giving it the power to craft richer, more elaborate
strategies.
You can practice these two skills every second of your life.
Because your life is itself a story. Which means you’re free to
plot it. Start by planning original ways to spend your vacation
time and weekends, then ramp up to imagining new ways to fulfill
your responsibilities and job mandates. And don’t just imagine how
you would plan your time; imagine how people you respect would
plan it.
And remember: just because you devise a plan, you don’t have to
execute it, so feel free to thought-experiment adventurously.
36
What’s the most creative workday you can script? What innovation
could you plot to make your organization its better self?
37
Module 10: See Yourself As Part of a Bigger
Narrative
The Red Baron had his lucky scarf, certain that it protected
him——right up to the instant of his death.
These beliefs can seem absurd, even dangerous. What good can come
of listening to mystic creatures or continuing down the wrong path?
Yet they were all helpful. Not because miniature red prophets
really exist. But because the beliefs of Grant, Napoleon, Geronimo,
and the Red Baron all made them feel psychologically connected to
a power bigger than themselves. And as modern neuroscience has
shown, when our brain feels emotionally joined to a bigger power,
it creates courage——and with it, optimism, resilience, and self-
belief.
38
us to believe that we can adapt and overcome. The moment we stop
believing, our creativity stalls, and we spiral into fatalism.
39
So, let go of fatalism and self-doubt. Have faith in your
creative destiny——and you will adapt and overcome.
40
Module 11: Plunge into the Unknown
The king had read Sun Tzu’s Art of War and was intrigued. But he
was also wary. What if Sun Tzu was just a writer of books? What if
Sun Tzu could tell fine stories about strategy but lacked the
capacity to act strategically in real war? So, the king decided to
test Sun Tzu.
“Yes, my king.”
“Then here is your army.” The king clapped his hands, and into
the court marched a harem, led by two concubines.
Without hesitation, Sun Tzu divided the women into two units,
each commanded by one of the concubines. He armed each unit with
spears. Then he struck up war drums, and ordered the women to
march.
Calmly, Sun Tzu stopped the drums. He asked the two concubines:
”Did your soldiers hear my orders?”
“Then it was your job to enforce my orders. But you did not. You
did not discipline your soldiers. So now, I must discipline you.”
And gesturing to the king’s guards, he ordered them to behead the
concubines.
The king stopped laughing. “Sun Zu! Do not kill those concubines!
They are my favorite companions. Without them, my life will be
joyless.”
But Sun Tzu replied. “You have given me these soldiers, and I
will command.” So, to the king’s horror, Sun Tzu again ordered the
41
guards to behead the concubines. And the guards obeyed,
decapitating the concubines before the king’s eyes.
Turning his back on the bodies, Sun Tzu appointed two new women
to lead the units, then struck up the drums. And this time, the
units marched perfectly, just as Sun Tzu commanded.
Silencing the drums, Sun Tzu turned to the king. “My liege. Your
army awaits you.”
But the king was sickened by what he had seen, and he waved Sun
Tzu away. “I have no interest in the army. Go home.”
Sun Tzu did not go. Instead, he strode up to the king. And said
wryly: “I see then that the king is just a reader of books. He
likes fine stories about strategy, but does not have the stomach
for it in real war.”
Then the king acknowledged that Sun Tzu had passed the test. And
he gave him the armies of Wu to command.
This is the only recorded story about Sun Tzu’s life. And if
you’ve heard it before, you were probably told that that it
illustrates Sun Tzu’s ruthless commitment to discipline. But
really, it’s proof of his creativity.
The answer is: It would not have mattered. It would not have
mattered because Sun Tzu could have adapted to those plot twists—
42
—or to any others. He could have adapted because of the way he
conducted himself from the beginning: he did not tentatively walk
into the unfamiliar space of the king’s palace, inching his way
ahead. He entered aggressively, plunging into the unknown.
Why was Sun Tzu confident? He was confident because he’d done it
before. He’d practiced, again and again, throwing himself into
wildly uncertain situations. When he’d initially begun that
practice, he’d struggled, feeling panicky and overwhelmed. So, he
knew that the king and the harem women were likely to struggle in
the same way. They were used to the ordered protocols of the court,
and this was their first taste of extreme volatility. It would
therefore likely scare and disorient them, rendering them meek and
docile.
And Sun Tzu also knew that, the more he’d practiced throwing
himself into uncertainty, the better he’d done. He’d panicked less
and adapted quicker. His powers of original action had improved.
That creative training is what made Sun Tzu confident. And that
training, not his inflexible commitment to order, is what enabled
him to the pass the king of Wu’s test——and then to lead the king’s
armies to victory in future wars.
As it was for Sun Tzu, so too can it be for you. Prepare yourself
to be creative on command by introducing uncertainty into your
daily routine, gradually but intentionally, so that you increase
your capacity for spontaneous inventiveness. Push yourself to enter
new spaces and strike up conversations with strangers. Block
clichéd small talk and mindless interpersonal routines; grow used
to the discomfort of awkward pauses, leveraging adrenaline into
heightened focus.
43
Then when you enter an unprecedented life-or-death situation,
welcome the unknown——and indeed, invite it. Actively generate the
same breakdown of environmental order that Sun Tzu provoked in the
palace of Wu, forcing your adversary to cope with escalating
situational instability.
Because that is how kings fall. And how strategists are made.
Exercise 1. Reach out to someone you admire but have never met.
Schedule a meetup with them.
44
Module 12: Actively Rest
The best breaks for your brain’s creative regions are breaks
that actively strengthen the parts of your heart and body that
support creativity. The key parts of your heart are your positive
emotions: optimism, empathy, curiosity, courage. And the key parts
of your body are your physical athletics: cardiovascular, balance,
strength.
So, now you know why dancing was such a healthy form of active
rest for Washington. Dancing built strength in his limbs, balance
in his torso, and cardiovascular pump in his chest. And it also
bolstered his courage and optimism——and when done with a partner,
45
his empathy and curiosity, all crucial elements of the neural
perspective-taking that drives creativity.
46
Exercise 3. Get 8 hours sleep tonight. Repeat. If you have trouble
falling asleep, consult your doctor.
47
Section Three: Amplify Your Creativity
Definitions
48
Module 13: Unplug Your Ego
The Zulus say that their great general Shaka was so devastated by
the death of his mother Nandi that he ordered the slaying of every
pregnant woman in Zululand. Now that he had lost his mother, there
would be no more mothers across his empire.
This sounds like a myth. But it’s true history, if not of Shaka
then of our human psyche. That’s because at the root of our psyche
is an entity known as the ego. The ego thinks that the world exists
for him. And from that core belief, the ego draws two logical
deductions:
And the ego is also certain that he’s always right. That’s why
he doesn’t question his actions, no matter how much pain they
cause. And that’s why he never changes his mind, no matter how
much havoc he creates. For if the ego were to admit that he was
wrong, he would admit that there is something greater than him.
Then the ego would shrink from being everything to being just
another thing. Which to the ego, is death.
49
you’re never completely right. Because even if you’re right today,
tomorrow will be different, and so tomorrow, you’ll be wrong.
The Zulus knew this. Which is why their tale ends with Shaka
snapping out of his pout. Challenged by one of his subjects——a
freethinking man by the name of Gala who says: Are you so self-
absorbed that you really think you’re the first child to lose a
mother?——Shaka looks at himself with outside eyes, realizing how
absurdly narcissistic he’s being. And shaking free of his ego, he
repeals his murderous decree——and returns to being one of the most
innovative leaders in history.
You can do the same by adapting the Zulus’ story into a simple
neural trick: Imagine your own Gala. That is, imagine a person
outside yourself who can serve as a mirror, reflecting your
behavior back. See yourself in that mirror, looking at your
behavior with outside eyes. And then adjust your actions from that
external perspective, discovering how easy it is to change your
behavior once you let go of your ego and take a broader view.
50
perspectives, exploring how you can mold your body in all the
different ways they recommend.
That range of motion is just the start of what you can achieve.
Because once you exit your ego, you can do anything.
52
millions of years of biological evolution, that the exception was
the first sign of an emergent threat or opportunity. By fixating
on those signs, the human brain trained itself to anticipate the
future, so it was always prepared to cope with sudden dangers or
exploit new advantages.
And so the human brain became the winner of the war for life.
While other, rule-focused brains were surprised by disaster or too
slow to seize their chance for triumph, the human brain leveraged
outlying datapoints into groundbreaking tactics, staying one step
ahead of the biological curve.
Yet even though this is how our species became the dominant life
on earth, we’re in danger of losing our inborn instinct for
exceptional information. That’s because, just like Saladin, we
live in a world where we’re all taught to prioritize the universal.
In Saladin’s day, that universal was medieval logic and theology.
In our day, it’s statistics, spreadsheets, metrics, computer AI,
and other logic-based systems for crunching data into general rules
of action. Those systems treat outlying datapoints as blips and
aberrations to be smoothed out of the curve or regressed to the
mean. They condition us to believe that the weird is a glitch, an
aberration, a blip to be ignored.
And most of the time, they’re right. Most of the time, the weird
signal is a random anomaly that means nothing. Most of the time,
the smart thing to do is dismiss it.
But not always. Because some of those outliers are the first
indication that the existing order is about to collapse. They’re
warnings of impending volatility. They’re a heads-up that we have
to adapt now——or risk extinction.
53
Which is to say: You will not act like a computer. You will not
smooth out strange new data to conform to familiar old rules. You
will act like your human forerunners. You will reconnect with your
brain’s primal intuitions. You will actively respect rogue blips,
treating them not as freak facts but as exceptional information.
So, instead of filtering out the strange and the outlying, learn
to tune it in. Be sensitive to peculiar details and be curious
about where they lead, suspending judgment to speculate on unknown
possibilities ahead. Because if you don’t acquire the habit of
active anticipation, then when exception really strikes——which it
inevitably will——you’ll be a fatal step behind, and surprise will
be your ambush not your ally.
Exercise 1. Write down every event today that strikes you as out
of the norm. Follow up on each one and note whether
it portended anything.
54
a situation where that unique perspective could solve
a problem or exploit an opportunity.
55
Module 15: Neutralize Your Hopes and Fears
The question would later become legend, summoned again and again
as a rallying cry in frantic trenches and deadly beachheads. But
at the time, it was utterly original, an invention so singular
that it stunned Frederick’s junior officers. Had their commander
lost his mind? Why was he doing the opposite of what every other
successful commander in history had done? Why wasn’t he making his
troops the usual promise that they would live forever, immortalized
in Valhalla or some other warrior heaven? Why was he instead
mocking eternity and snarling at his soldiers to run into death?
56
they did stabilize the retreat. Heroically covering the flight of
their frightened colleagues, they prevented a massacre, ensuring
that the army survived to fight again.
Hopes and fears are the most powerful drivers of human behavior.
They originate in our brain’s ancient core, the amygdala, from
where they radiate outward, swaying the rest of our neuroanatomy.
And of those potent emotions, the most potent are our fear of
death——and our hope for immortal life. To a biological creature
such as ourselves, life is everything and death the final ending.
So, nothing stirs more raw panic or courage in our brain than the
thought of perishing now or living forever.
57
This is why Frederick’s artillery and infantry were so famously
adaptive, rearranging themselves on the battlefield with
apparently preternatural intelligence. They couldn’t actually see
the future, but they seemed like they could. By vacating their
hopes and fears, they became swifter at reacting to changing
circumstance, so that instead of being made by war’s fast-evolving
environment, they helped to make it.
And above all, do what Frederick’s soldiers did: make peace with
the fact that you are nothing, that you died before this day began,
that all that matters is the greater narrative beyond.
58
Module 16: Get Environmentally Dynamic
For the next thirty years, Giáp held onto this different
perspective. He used it to drive out the Japanese by ambushing
their outposts with American flamethrowers. A decade later, in the
summer of 1954, he used it to tuck Soviet howitzers into the jungle
hillsides around Dien Bien Phu, hammering back the French Army’s
colonial occupiers. And another decade later, in the mid-1960s, he
used it to implement what US National Security Agency described as
“one of the great achievements of military engineering of the 20th
century.” That great achievement was the Ho Chi Minh Trail.
59
The Ho Chi Minh Trail was an intricate maze of gravel roads,
bicycle trails, and footpaths that stretched from the supply yards
of North Vietnam to the battlefields of the South. It could move
30 tons of equipment a day, through even thigh-high, monsoon mud.
And perhaps more importantly, it inculcated in Giáp’s soldiers the
same culture of adaptive strength that the guerilla tactics of
1776 had inculcated in America’s original freedom-fighters,
enabling Giáp’s soldiers to do to the Americans what the Americans
had earlier done to the British Empire: out-adapt, out-innovate,
and outmaneuver them.
You can reap the same creative benefit from the environment. The
environment is alien and unpredictable, which is why the average
twenty-first-century American seeks to keep it at bay with air
conditioning and digital playgrounds. But nature is not our enemy.
Nature is the engine of life——and the source of creativity. The
more we try to dominate or repress nature, the more fragile we
make our own culture. But the more we embrace nature’s volatile
pushback, the more we feed off its creative energy to become
creators ourselves.
And the same that goes for nature goes for any environment. In
the strategic environment of war, embrace the adversity of
uncertainty, feeling it feed your ingenuity. In the tactical
environment of local combat, embrace the punch of your adversary,
feeling it feed your fluidity. And in the social environment of
others, embrace the resistance of their opinions. Don’t bully your
subordinates into silencing their objections; and don’t duck the
oversight of your superiors by cloaking your intentions. Onboard
their oppositional perspectives, feeling them grow your
imagination. The more of the outside world that you can
internalize, the more you’ll enhance your adaptive intelligence.
The more of nature’s big struggle you admit into your life, the
more you’ll become like nature: resilient, dynamic, and boundlessly
creative.
60
Then embrace those negatives as positive challenges,
leveraging their resistance into adaptive change.
61
Module 17: Invent Backward then Forwards
The same holds true with most of the subsequent things that our
brains and opposable thumbs have invented: they’re clever re-tweaks
of older gadgets. Which is why the most effective way to innovate
isn’t to forget all the existing technology on the shelf. If you
do that, you’ll usually just end up reinventing the wheel. Instead,
the better route is to start with the wheel——and invent a better
one.
62
of endlessly recycling yesterday’s breakthroughs, you tap into the
infinite possibility that produced them.
And that’s the real key to the strategic genius of Djehuty and
Odysseus. Not baskets, wooden horses, or other bits of fakery. But
reverse-engineering an old technique or tactic to fit a new
situation.
63
Module 18: Harness Conflict
How did the Greeks do it? What was the secret of their genius?
How did they become such effective strategists?
The answer is: before the Greeks fought against the Persians,
they fought against each other.
But the two kings worked. Not that they didn’t fight with each
other. They did. Yet they were mightier than any of Greece’s solo
kings. And at the end of the sixth-century BC, they marched their
armies east——and toppled the one king of Athens.
With that king gone, Sparta tried to make Athens a second Sparta,
ruled by two kings. But the Athenians went further. Instead of two
kings, they opted for thousands, making every Athenian citizen his
own liege. This was democracy, and it was even more contentious
than Sparta’s two-ocracy. The citizens of Athens struggled
endlessly with each other. And then they went to war with Sparta,
so that the two cities became like two competing kings, battling
for control of Greece.
This Greek state of constant inner conflict was not planned. But
it was not entirely accidental, either. Back in the seventh-century
BC, the celebrated Greek poet Hesiod had rhapsodized in Works and
Days that the goddess Strife came in two shapes. The first was the
source of civil war. The second, of civil prosperity:
For when a man sees that the man next door is wealthy,
64
He hastens to plow his fields and work his farm better.
This is why the Greeks outwitted the Persians. The Persians were
born as intelligent as the Greeks. And they benefited from an
excellent military education. But that education was installed
within a one-king system that limited disagreement. When the
Persian generals differed, the king made the final decision. And
so the generals learned that the path to success was always the
same: please the king. This warped the entire political system
around the preferences of a lone individual. Instead of multiplying
creative intelligence, it focused the Persians on obedience and
flattery, narrowing their strategy and making it brittle.
And this is why the Greek model became the basis of later
governments that shocked the world with unthinkable victories.
First, there was Rome, which adapted Sparta’s two kings into its
two republican consuls, creating a culture of perpetual self-
struggle that launched a nobody Italian tribe into conquering
Carthage, Greece, and Egypt. Then there were the 13 American
colonies, who consciously incorporated both the Roman and the Greek
systems into their own founding documents, promoting an inner
contest of leadership at the 1774 Continental Congress that almost
65
tore apart the fledging United States——before knocking back the
British Empire.
66
To commit fully to this path you must once again shut off logic.
Logic teaches that conflict is a waste of energy. So, logic does
its best to eliminate conflict by using metrics, data,
spreadsheets, and rational analysis to identify the better answer
or the harmonious synthesis. Which is to say: logic promotes a
one-king system. That’s why rationalists from Plato onward have
insisted that monarchy is superior to democracy. Better to have a
philosopher-king than a squabbling mob.
We learn the opposite from plotting. Every good plot begins with
a conflict. It’s conflict between characters, or conflict between
characters and their world, that drives creative storylines ahead.
67
Section Four: Practice, Practice, Practice
• Here are some workouts that will give back whatever you
give.
68
Module 19: Twister
69
Exercise 2. Revisit a historical battle. What special law of
action was imposed on that battle by the terrain,
the weather, the technology, the culture, the
personalities at play? After identifying the law,
imagine three unexpected consequences that it could
have had in the battle.
70
Module 20: Predictor
When you move onto the next paragraph, compare your prediction
to what actually happened, and then at the end of the next
paragraph, repeat again. Continue this exercise until you can
predict without pausing, then put aside your written narrative to
practice on real-time ones. To start, try predicting the events of
plot-twisty films, tv shows, and documentaries.
71
Exercise 1. Request to observe a meeting that involves personnel
whom you don’t know. Watch the meeting for a few
minutes and then start to make active predictions
about who will speak next and what they will say.
Remember to actively forget each prediction before
you move onto the next one. The long-term scorecard
of your successes and failures will be retained by
your brain’s deep memory; if you hold it in your
near-term consciousness, it will inhibit your
creative openness.
72
Module 21: Tweaker
The best strategies are the ones that are already ready-to-go;
they’re automatic to execute and inspire immediate confidence that
builds when they unfold as practiced.
73
spin you can put on the tactic to outmaneuver the
stronger army and reclaim victory.
74
Module 22: Impersonator
This is what your brain does every time you read a memoir or
watch a movie. It enters the minds of the characters and plans
from their perspective, anticipating their actions.
75
activate your “exit” perspective to make a dispassionate, fast
decision.
That way, you feed your imagination with many perspectives. And
then maximize your odds of practical success by taking the wider
view.
76
Module 23: Blender
With the skills you’ve built in the previous modules, you can
now run all those simulations——and endless more. So go run them.
Impersonate different adaptive intelligences fighting on foreign
battlefields by mix-and-matching past strategists and situations.
That way, the only way for you to win is to sustain the conflict
indefinitely.
77
Module 24: Gamer
(2) Empower the umpire to have the players switch sides (once
or on multiple occasions), prompting each to adopt the
strategic perspective of the other (as in Module 22).
4) Have the other player draw a name from the bag——and respond
to the twist from that strategist’s perspective.
6) Put the names back in the bag and repeat with a different
conflict.
78
Section Five: Advanced Creativity
79
Module 25: Failsafe Planning
(or, Partnering Logic with Creativity)
But even though it’s hard for commanders to evolve their core
psychology, it’s possible. George Washington managed it; so did
Dwight Eisenhower. The key is humility, or to be more technical,
self-distancing. Self-distancing, as we learned back in Modules 13
and 15, comes from exiting ego and neutralizing personal hopes and
fears. It allows your brain to interrupt its habituated mental
scripts and shift its perspective onto different action plans.
80
Creativity, just like boldness and caution, is a virtue in some
circumstances but a detriment in others. Specifically, creativity
is a detriment in any situation that calls for compliance. You
don’t want to get creative when handling a firearm, running through
a preflight check, or doing one of a million other tasks where the
existing rules are working. That would waste time and endanger
lives. It would unnecessarily bleed your operational capacity while
allowing your adversary to build up strength. You only want to get
creative when it’s to your advantage to risk an experiment, when
sticking to logic is actively diminishing your odds of success.
But how do you know when it’s to your advantage to take that
creative risk? How do you know when it’s the smart thing to venture
a new tactic——and when it’s smarter to hang tight with procedure
and trust the existing playbook?
The short answer is: it’s hard to know for sure. Which is why
many commanders get stuck in the personality trap. Just as
commanders who are naturally bold tend to default to boldness, so
do commanders who are naturally creative tend to default to
creativity. And just as commanders who have previously succeeded
by being cautious tend to default to caution, so do commanders who
have previously succeeded by being logical tend to default to
logic. So, instead of making the smart choice, they become victims
of luck.
You can break out of that trap by exiting your personality and
disciplining your brain to identify the difference between
situations that call for logic——and situations that call for
creativity.
81
When you notice either indicator, adjust your thinking in one
direction or the other. And to keep you on the front foot, keep an
eye out for the onset of asymmetric conflict. Since asymmetric
conflict is the primary driver of situational chaos, be sensitive
to any uptick in its range or intensity. The sooner an uptick is
detected, the faster it can be de-escalated with a creative
solution.
82
Module 26: Honing Creativity into Innovation
(Part I)
That’s the bad news. Here’s the good: there’s a way to minimize
the failure. The secret is to aggressively seek the failure.
83
it belongs: not in the creative product but the creative process.
It’s the creative process that is reliable, because the process
enables you to generate a constant stream of potential ideas,
ensuring that, eventually, you’ll find one that works. Getting
mentally wedded to a single idea is thus doubly counterproductive:
it not only invites failure this time around, but separates you
from the process required for future creative successes.
84
Exercise 2. Return to the answers you generated in Exercise 1.
What’s the cheapest, fastest way you could test each
of them?
85
Module 27: Honing Creativity into Innovation
(Part II)
The lesson here is that creative ideas can fail, and fail, and
fail, and fail before they succeed. So, how do you know, for sure,
whether an idea won’t work? How do you implement the training of
the previous module——fast-test a prototype——without discarding an
innovation worth of da Vinci? How can you decide whether you should
move on when your invention doesn’t fly——or whether you should
attempt a Sikorsky?
The answer is that you cannot know for certain, because any idea
can be made to work. That’s the magic of creativity. Creativity
can always invent fixes. With infinite time and infinite resources,
Sikorsky’s creativity could have made a battleship fly.
But unless you have infinite time and infinite resources, you
don’t want to chase that blue-sky possibility. You want to marshal
the time and the resources you have to maximize the current odds
of success.
86
The payoff from fast-testing multiple ideas is thus different
successes and identical failures, the first of which identifies
what can be accomplished, the second of which identifies what
cannot. And when put together, the can and the cannot reveal what
is feasible, here and now.
But for fast-testing multiples to work, you must ensure that the
ideas are all fundamentally different. If they’re not fundamentally
different, if they’re all variants of the same core plan or design,
then you’re not really testing a range of ideas. You’re simply
testing the same idea, with three tweaks. That kind of testing is
valuable, down the road, once you’ve identified your go-to
candidate. But if you do it at the outset, you’ll stymie innovation
and invite drag and inefficiency.
If you’ve got too many ideas, and not enough time or resources
to test them all, prioritize the ideas that are fastest and
cheapest to test. This might feel counterintuitive. Shouldn’t you
instead test the ideas that inspire the most confidence in you?
And once you identify a winner, remember: you can always keep
the other ideas around, in your memory. You don’t have to delete
them from history because they didn’t work this time. Perhaps in
87
a future situation, when you have different resources available,
or shifted operational parameters, an idea that failed now will
work.
88
Module 28: High Performance Creativity
But high pressure isn’t always bad for creativity. Quite the
opposite: once your creative engine has started, it requires
pressure to keep it humming. Without that pressure, your brain
will conclude that there’s no need to waste energy on further
creativity; everything is copacetic, so it can just chill out on
autopilot.
89
dissociate in moments of stress, they will stick in the ignition
part of the process, never proceeding to the throttle. If people
are naturally high-strung, they will flood their creative engine,
never getting it to fire.
90
Module 29: Break Inertia
Inertia is inevitable.
Not because the human brain is naturally lazy. The human brain
is in fact naturally restless. That’s why the world is full of
anxiety and edgy boredom. That’s why so many people use nicotine,
alcohol, and other chemicals to forcibly relax.
This is why workers grumble about their jobs but are also
pessimistic——even fatalistic——about change. This is why soldiers
know exactly what’s wrong with their unit, but steel themselves to
accepting the same-old troubles without complaint.
91
(1) It provides each unit with a list of potentially useful
solutions, generated by independent, outside eyes.
92
Module 30: Scale Creativity
Now that you’ve reached the end of this book, your creative engine
is humming. You’ve tuned the sparkplugs, timed the belts, revved
the horsepower, and maxed out the torque.
But even so, science has revealed that this natural process of
brain-combination can be optimized. The key is a group version of
the high-performance protocol we covered in Module 28. The group
version has two stages:
The bigger the group, the more creative potential it has——but the
harder it is to achieve ignition. So for fastest results, start
with a small team of three or four members, then feed in new
creatives once the super-engine is humming.
94
Conclusion: Ten Myths About Creativity
Myth Two: Some Original Ideas Are Obviously Better Than Others
It’s true that some people are born with psychological traits—
—such as openness——that can enhance creativity. But the
primary source of creativity is the desire to be creative.
That desire comes more naturally to some people than others,
but it can be cultivated in anyone. With that desire, you can
do what Caesar, Shakespeare, and the world’s other greatest
95
innovators have done: elevate yourself from uninspired, early
works to creations that change the world.
96
pressures of life, true creatives maintain compliance’s
original spirit through the invention of new standard
operating procedures that preserve life and promote it.
97
Coda: The End of War
He was the real life Willy Wonka. But before he could build his
chocolate wonderland, he had to stop the bombs from falling.
98
At first, nothing happened. But suddenly, a flame sparked inside
the floating behemoth. And then in a flash, the whole airship
combusted in fire, tumbling with a horrid shriek into the sea.
For this inventive feat, Cadbury was promoted to major and placed
in charge of his squadron. In his new position, he trained dozens
of pilots in his Zeppelin-hunting method. Until in mid-1918, the
Zeppelins struck back.
For his triumph, Cadbury was knighted. And he remained, for his
entire life, a war hero. But his memory of war was not happy. He
99
confessed to his brother that all he could remember when he shut
his eyes was the Zeppelin’s thirty screaming crew members as they
dropped on fire from the sky. All he could see was their raw panic
as the airship’s fabric combusted and they realized that they were
about to fall, helpless, to death.
Such are creativity’s two great wonders: to win the war and
burnish the peace. And yet these two wonders aren’t creativity’s
most important job. As Cadbury realized when he imagined his way
into the minds of the Zeppelin men who’d died, creativity’s most
important job is to prevent war in the first place.
100
Final Review
101
Acknowledgments
And Sgt. Jones and the other Quantico 96 instructors, for being
the Teacher. “Fletcher, you a doggone miracle, you know that? How
else that little neck be holding up that giant head?”
102