TF2023201- Dissertation
TF2023201- Dissertation
1
A. Abstract
This study looks at how traditional retail establishments are adjusting to e-commerce's
growing influence in the apparel, fashion, and luxury sectors. A thorough theoretical
framework that incorporates the Coexistence Theory, the Porter Five Forces, and the
Technology Acceptance Model serves as the foundation for the research. In light of the
digital revolution, the study investigates the tactics used by retailers to stay competitive and
relevant.
The main goal is to comprehend how traditional retail companies are adapting to the growth
of e-commerce by utilizing technology, improving customer experiences, maintaining
premium brand appeal, and incorporating social responsibility. The study also aims to
pinpoint knowledge gaps and offer suggestions for new lines of inquiry and commercial
plans.
Key themes are discovered through qualitative analysis of interviews with 15 people. Virtual
reality and interactive displays are key components of experiential shop design, which
promotes immersive in-store encounters. The temporary online collections and virtual
presentations that make up the Online Luxury Experience emphasize the efforts made by
luxury brands to strike a balance between accessibility and exclusivity. The emphasis on
catering to various consumer bases while maintaining brand exclusivity is emphasized by the
concept "Balancing Accessibility and Exclusivity". The importance of tailored guidance and
technological integration in boosting customer happiness is highlighted through personalized
experiences. To appeal to morally conscientious consumers, social responsibility and
sustainability emphasize ethical sourcing and sustainable operations. The relevance of
technology in constructing seamless omnichannel experiences is highlighted by technology
integration.
According to the interviews, conventional retailers are using a variety of ways to deal with
the problems brought on by the dominance of e-commerce. Retailers may improve consumer
experiences and competitiveness by fusing experiential design, technology, personalization,
luxury branding, and social responsibility. Businesses may want to think about developing
immersive in-store experiences, implementing individualized technologies, and adhering to
morally and environmentally sound business practices. The report suggests more research be
done on how customers react to experiential shop designs and how technology integration
affects consumer loyalty.
2
Contents
A. Abstract.................................................................................................................................2
B. Introduction...........................................................................................................................6
Target Audience.....................................................................................................................6
C. Literature review...................................................................................................................9
D. Theoretical framework........................................................................................................14
Coexistence Theory..............................................................................................................14
Research Contextualization..................................................................................................15
Data Collection.....................................................................................................................17
3
Data Analysis and NVivo Coding........................................................................................17
Ethical Considerations.........................................................................................................18
Introduction..........................................................................................................................19
H. References...........................................................................................................................30
I. Appendices.......................................................................................................................33
4
B. Introduction
The domain of retail, in particular within the clothing, fashion, and luxury industries, has
undergone a dramatic upheaval as a direct result of the rapid expansion of e-commerce in the
ever-changing face of business. This change has been spurred by the advent of online
shopping. Because of the profound changes that the digital age has brought about in the way
in which customers experience and interact with retail, it is imperative that traditional retail
shop tactics be thoroughly reexamined. This research goes deep into the complexities of this
paradigm change, analyzing the delicate relationships between traditional and virtual
shopping experiences, while concentrating on the strategic moves of the industry's most
important actors.
Target Audience
A wide range of people, including academics, business professionals, industry executives,
and policymakers, are served by this study paper. It provides information about the practical
effects of e-commerce's rise and its implications for retail shop strategy for academic
researchers. Actionable insights for shaping decision-making processes and directing
reactions to customer preferences will be found by industry practitioners. A thorough
understanding of the dynamics that are changing can help regulators and stakeholders in the
retail sector develop regulatory frameworks and industry standards.
5
1. Introduction: The topic is introduced, the study is contextualized, and its relevance,
intended audience, and general structure are described in this section.
2. Literature Review: This section looks at the research and studies that are now known
on how retail has evolved in the digital age. This research provides a critical analysis
of how consumer behavior, technical improvements, and corporate reactions have
changed through time.
3. Research Methodology: In this section, the research approach is described in depth,
along with the methods utilized for data collection, participant selection, and NVivo
coding.
4. Findings and Discussion: The empirical data gathered from the interviews is
condensed in a manner that is consistent with the inquiries of the study. Each research
topic is examined while taking into consideration the opinions of the participants,
highlighting significant themes, patterns, and perceptive insights.
5. Implications and Recommendations: The implications of our findings for
conventional retail outlets, luxury enterprises, and the industry at large are discussed
in this section. It offers beneficial guidance for managing the competitive retail
industry successfully.
6. Conclusion: The final section summarizes the key findings and contributions of the
research, discussing its implications for academia, industry, and future research
directions.
To address this question, the primary objectives of this research are as follows:
• To critically analyze how luxury brands strategically use technology and online platforms to
maintain their reputation for exclusivity and grandeur in the e-commerce space.
6
changing consumer demands for individualized interactions, social responsibility, and self-
expression.
This study aims to offer a nuanced and thorough understanding of the complex interaction
between traditional retail and e-commerce within the garment, fashion, and luxury industries
by methodically addressing these refined research objectives.
7
C. Literature review
In recent years, there has been a significant amount of discourse surrounding the convergence
of the Apparel, Fashion, and Luxury Industry with the internet domain. The ongoing
expansion of e-commerce has led both researchers and industry experts to focus on
understanding the changing dynamics, difficulties, and opportunities that emerge when
traditional retail establishments intersect with the digital domain.
8
Maintaining Luxury and Exclusivity Online
The complexities associated with preserving exclusivity in the internet era provide significant
hurdles for premium brands and fashion shops. The advent of e-commerce has significantly
broadened the geographical scope of business operations, enabling companies to cater to a
global customer base. However, it is worth noting that the luxury industry, which feeds on the
principles of scarcity and exclusivity, has managed to maintain its appeal and desirability
despite the increased accessibility provided by e-commerce platforms. Luxury brands
strategically negotiate their e-commerce strategies within the framework of this complex
equilibrium. According to Seo et al. (2022), the utilization of limited-time online collections
enables luxury brands to uphold their image of exclusivity through the creation of a
perception of urgency and scarcity. Concurrently, virtual displays offer a novel venue for
luxury businesses to present their expertise, artistic skills, and brand legacy to a worldwide
audience (Batat, 2019). These techniques highlight the crucial significance of e-commerce in
both facilitating broader accessibility and preserving the perception of exclusivity.
9
and foster emotional bonds, thereby forging a connection between businesses and socially
aware consumers, while concurrently developing a unique brand identity (Danielsen et al.,
2023).
10
factor to be taken into account. The concept surpasses the limitations of simple multi-channel
approaches and instead emphasizes the development of a cohesive and uninterrupted
consumer experience across many points of interaction. Companies who demonstrate
exceptional proficiency in providing a seamless and integrated customer experience across
many channels, sometimes referred to as an omni-experience, are able to cultivate stronger
emotional bonds with their customers, resulting in increased brand loyalty and a higher
likelihood of repeat purchases. The investigation of methods, difficulties, and consequences
pertaining to the successful application of omni-experience in retail leads to a thorough
comprehension of how merchants can effectively engage customers and differentiate
themselves in a highly competitive marketplace (Ahmad et al., 2022).
Furthermore, it is worth delving deeper into the complex relationship between social
responsibility, sustainability, and the purchasing decisions made by consumers, as these
concerns have become increasingly significant. Further examination is needed to thoroughly
analyze the impact of virtual interaction tools, including social media platforms, on
promoting self-expression and establishing a sense of community inside the framework of
conventional retail establishments.
The ongoing discussion over the interdependent connection between traditional retail and e-
commerce within the Apparel, Fashion, and Luxury Industry is always developing, driven by
advancements in technology, changing customer desires, and strategic adjustments. This
study aims to make a significant contribution to the existing conversation by examining the
methods and adaptations utilized by traditional merchants. This research endeavors to reveal
the complex relationship between traditional retail tactics and the growing influence of e-
commerce by analyzing the viewpoints of industry actors. The strategies and innovations
11
used by retailers in the current period of transformative change are influenced by the dynamic
interplay among technology, luxury branding, consumer experiences, and social
responsibility.
12
D. Theoretical framework
A comprehensive theoretical framework that draws on Porter's Five Forces, the Technology
Acceptance Model (TAM), and the Coexistence Theory provides the study's foundation.
These theoretical frameworks provide a strong foundation for investigating how traditional
retail outlets in the apparel, fashion, and luxury sectors are evolving as a result of the growth
of e-commerce.
Coexistence Theory
The Coexistence Theory, which is based on research by Barabás et al. (2018), serves as a
conceptual framework for understanding the beneficial relationship between traditional brick-
and-mortar retail outlets and e-commerce. This theoretical framework puts out the idea that
instead of competing directly, the two channels could actually strengthen one another's
13
performance by utilizing the distinct benefits that each platform has to offer. The Coexistence
Theory is relevant to the current research because it provides information on how traditional
retail businesses might use e-commerce to increase their reach and engagement. This strategy
enables them to take use of online platforms' benefits while still offering clients the tangible
and experiential elements that may be lacking in the digital world.
Research Contextualization
The chosen theoretical framework offers an organized method to direct research design,
analysis, and conclusion interpretation. It provides a lens through which the conclusions and
suggestions can be combined. TAM and the Coexistence Theory offer insights into the micro-
level dynamics of customer behavior and technology adoption within the growing retail
sector, whilst Porter's Five Forces framework offers a macroscopic picture of the industrial
landscape. These three frameworks operate in concert to provide a comprehensive knowledge
of how traditional retail establishments are handling the benefits and problems brought on by
e-commerce's growing dominance in the apparel, fashion, and luxury industries.
This theoretical framework will be used as a compass as the study develops to locate themes,
code interview answers, and derive significant conclusions. The incorporation of these
theoretical viewpoints aims to increase our knowledge of the strategic adjustments needed by
established traditional retail businesses in response to the industry-reshaping digital
transformation.
14
E. Research design & methodology
Research Question Integration
The central focus of this study revolves around a crucial research inquiry: "How are
traditional retail establishments adapting their tactics to maintain their competitiveness and
relevance in light of the increasingly dominant presence of e-commerce, particularly within
the dynamic context of the Apparel, Fashion, and Luxury Industry?" The fundamental
question at the heart of this study forms the foundation upon which the investigation is built,
and it is easily integrated into the chosen theoretical framework, which includes Porter's Five
Forces, the Technology Acceptance Model, and the Coexistence Theory. The methodology
employed in this study incorporates various dimensions, including Consumer Behavior,
Technology Adoption, Experiential Marketing, Luxury Branding, Social Responsibility, Self-
Expression, and Coexistence. This comprehensive approach enhances the study's design and
analysis by providing a greater level of richness and depth.
This study creates a strong framework to lead the research by fusing the theoretical
underpinnings of Porter's Five Forces, the Technology Acceptance Model, and the
Coexistence Theory. This framework gives the study the flexibility and depth needed to
unearth the complexities and intricacies of the retail industry's response to the rise of internet
commerce while adhering to the three chosen theoretical views.
15
The basis for a qualitative investigation of the strategic adaptations of conventional retail
outlets within the context of the apparel, fashion, and luxury industries is provided by this
comprehensive approach, which is based on the chosen theoretical frameworks.
Data Collection
The efficacy of the data gathering process relies heavily on the careful design of semi-
structured interviews. These interviews serve as a medium through which participants are
able to navigate their responses smoothly and elaborate on complex perspectives. In order to
maintain a high level of accuracy in capturing participants' perspectives, the interviews are
carefully recorded using audio technology and transcribed in an exact manner. This rigorous
approach guarantees the truthfulness and genuineness of the participants' statements. The
interview guide has been carefully customized to align with both the primary research
question and the theoretical framework. It effectively covers various subjects, including the
underlying strategies of adaptation, the integration of technological advancements, the
fluctuations in consumer behaviors, and the significant changes occurring within the industry.
16
analysis remains firmly rooted in the conceptual framework and research goals, fostering a
mutually beneficial connection between the empirical data and the theoretical foundations.
Ethical Considerations
The ethical foundation of this research is a fundamental principle. The research is carried out
in accordance with the ethical concept of informed consent, which aims to protect the
independence of participants by providing them with clear information about the goal of the
study, the voluntary nature of their involvement, and the strict confidentiality measures in
place. The utilization of pseudonyms serves to protect the confidentiality of individuals
during every phase of the study procedure. Stringent data security protocols are implemented,
encompassing encrypted storage, password-protected devices, and regulated access to the
interview materials (Pocock et al., 2021). This study aims to adhere to the tenets of ethical
research by conscientiously navigating the research terrain with a commitment to integrity
and the safeguarding of the rights and welfare of its participants.
17
F. Findings & analysis
Introduction
The emergence of e-commerce has had a huge impact on the changing retail landscape,
notably in the areas of apparel, fashion, and luxury. Traditional retail businesses have had to
review their strategies in order to stay competitive and relevant as a result of this dramatic
shift. This study dives into the information obtained from interviews with important industry
stakeholders in order to understand the complex dynamics of this shift. These interviews have
uncovered a range of themes and codes that shed light on the complex techniques used by
retail enterprises to negotiate the coexistence of physical locations and online marketplaces.
This introduction provides a foundation for the subsequent analysis that covers consumer
perceptions, the impact of digitalization, strategies for maintaining exclusivity, omnichannel
marketing, profitability exploration, and innovative retail experiences. It provides a glimpse
into the depth of insights obtained through these interviews. The combination of these ideas
not only makes it easier to understand how the sector is doing right now, but it also prepares
the way for important business recommendations and directions for future research.
Several participants admitted that they started their online presence in the first ten years of
the twenty-first century. Notably, in 2009 (Participant 02), TK Max increased its business
through online platforms, while in 2010 (Participant 11), Zara embraced e-commerce. These
examples indicate early adoption of the possibilities of online markets and the aggressive
steps these businesses took to gain a presence online.
Participants emphasized the importance of the 2010–2020-time frame, during which the
sector saw a spike in the creation of online presence. For instance, H&M began selling its
products online in 2010 (Participant 05), and Zara also expanded its online presence around
this time (Participant 12). These incidents demonstrate how internet channels are becoming
increasingly important, and how large businesses are incorporating these platforms into their
retail strategy.
18
3. Established after Covid
Some retailers entered the online market in response to the pandemic's effects on consumer
behavior. Primark had a notable online debut in November 2022 (Participant 09),
highlighting the importance of outside forces in advancing digitization.
5. Website Only
Many participants emphasized that their retail enterprises had specific online websites. The
only means of operation for Lovisa (Participant 07), Primark (Participant 09), and H&M in
the UK (Participant 10) are their respective websites. These examples support theoretical
frameworks, in particular the Coexistence Theory, because they show how online platforms
can coexist with physical and digital channels without being in direct conflict with one
another.
6. Application Also
Retail businesses like Zara (Participant 02), H&M (Participant 03), and Lovisa (Participant
05) are utilizing the Technology Acceptance Model by incorporating mobile applications into
their strategies. In line with the framework's emphasis on perceived usefulness and simplicity
of use in promoting technology adoption, these applications promote user-friendly
experiences.
Participant 09 Primark and Participant 14 Zara are two examples of how social media is used
in contemporary retail strategy. In accordance with Porter's Five Forces and the Coexistence
Theory, Primark's Instagram marketing (Participant 09) indicates efforts to engage clients
through diverse online channels, while Zara (Participant 14) makes use of partnerships with
fashion-specific online platforms.
Participant 01's example of retail outlets in marketplaces and multi-brand apps supports the
Coexistence Theory. These businesses are aware of the potential for these platforms to
increase their audience without necessarily replacing their physical locations.
The results highlight the diverse strategies used by retail companies to incorporate digital
platforms, taking into account various timeframes and digitalization techniques. These tactics
echo the theoretical frameworks that place an emphasis on adaptability and cohabitation and
19
show how the business has responded to changing consumer demands and technology
improvements. The study that follows will shed more light on how these findings may be
interpreted in the context of the retail industry as a whole.
The discussion frequently brought up the idea of increased sales. A TK Max participant
(Participant 02) said that increased sales had been directly correlated with their internet
presence. According to Porter's Five Forces, digitization can increase market share and
strengthen competitiveness, and this is consistent with those forces.
As a strategy for drawing in time-pressed customers, the alignment of digitization with the
fast-paced lifestyle of the modern world was highlighted. The participant (Participant 11)
stated that digital platforms cater to people looking for streamlined purchase experiences,
which is consistent with the idea put out by the Technology Acceptance Model that perceived
simplicity of use encourages technology adoption.
The ability to sell things that are unpopular or unavailable has become a noteworthy
opportunity. In line with the Coexistence Theory's idea of digital channels complementing
existing routes without direct competition, businesses can present products that might not
succeed in conventional storefronts by leveraging online platforms.
Several attendees acknowledged the wide-ranging reach and visibility brought about by
digitization. (Participants 04 and 12) They emphasized cutting-edge features like the "buy"
button and social media networks like Instagram. These developments align with the
Coexistence Theory's (Barabás et al., 2018) suggestion that offline and online presence
should combine for greater market penetration.
Quick shopping has become a possibility, made possible by online platforms. (Participant 06
and Participant 07) Participants attested to the usefulness of visual references for desired
products. According to the Technology Acceptance Model, which emphasizes user efficiency
as a key factor in driving technology adoption, this affinity is in line with that model.
The disadvantages of digital convenience were highlighted by challenges in the form of more
returns and exchanges (Participant 02 and Participant 05). These complications are consistent
20
with Porter's Five Forces because they increase consumer power and have an impact on
competitive dynamics (Alves et al., 2020).
In conclusion, the integration of digitalization into the apparel, fashion, and luxury industries
creates an environment that is full of opportunities and difficulties. Our knowledge of how
the sector navigates this transforming terrain is enriched by the interaction of theoretical
frameworks, which emphasize the underlying dynamics.
The Coexistence Theory, which contends that online and physical channels may coexist by
offering different value, is consistent with the emphasis on the overall experience rather than
just the shopping aspect. Shopping online is convenient, but trying things on in real stores
delivers a sensory experience that goes well with it (Barabás et al. (2018).
The preference for physical stores, particularly for luxury items, lends credence to Porter's
Five Forces' claim that a physical presence can increase brand loyalty and trust. Physical
stores' exclusivity and customization align with the Technology Acceptance Model's
emphasis on individual demands and perceived utility (Lee et al., 2003).
The Technology Acceptance Model can be used to examine the trade-off between
convenience and the value of in-person shopping time. The participants' talks about striking a
balance between the convenience of online buying and the experiential value of physical
stores are made clear by the model's notion of perceived ease of use against effort
anticipation.
21
In conclusion, different theoretical frameworks and the participants' perspectives on physical
retail are in agreement. In the context of the apparel, fashion, and luxury industries, the
interaction of Porter's Five Forces, the Technology Acceptance Model, and the Coexistence
Theory offers a thorough knowledge of the complexity within the consumer perceptions of
physical retail. Together, these frameworks highlight how online and offline channels coexist,
each with unique benefits that influence consumer choices and business strategy.
Conflict between customers' expectations and their actual experiences after obtaining the
product is a common problem. This difference may cause resentment and damage trust. This
behavior is consistent with the Technology Acceptance Model, which holds that a consumer's
decision to embrace and use a technology is influenced by the technology's perceived
usefulness and simplicity of use (Rini and Khasanah, 2021). Online firms must work to close
the gap between what customers see online and what they receive if they are to gain and keep
customers' trust.
Concerns about sizing and quality have also become apparent as problems involving trust.
Customers frequently have questions regarding how online-purchased things will fit and feel.
The lack of physical connection with items can affect buyers' capacity to effectively judge
quality, which links into the Coexistence theory. These worries can be allayed and confidence
cultivated by providing accurate product descriptions, sizing charts, and open consumer
feedback.
The problem of money becoming locked in is another concern pertaining to trusts. Customers
who purchase things that fall short of their expectations may have trouble getting refunds or
returns. This issue is especially pertinent to the Coexistence theory since it emphasizes how
22
important it is to match customers' offline expectations with online activities. To establish
and maintain trust, refund and return procedures must be transparent and accommodating to
customers.
Customers show caution when buying for luxury goods online because they are worried
about authenticity, value, and individualized service. Given that luxury brands are frequently
connected to exclusive in-store experiences, this is consistent with the Coexistence idea. To
overcome this reluctance, it is necessary to strategically combine individualized online
experiences with transparent pricing and assurances of product authenticity.
Through the analysis of Porter's Five Forces, it is possible to compare the various discounting
mechanisms that the participants mentioned. The principle of industry competition, where
businesses actively differentiate themselves to keep client loyalty, is supported by
maintaining perceived value through distinctive discounting strategies (Palmatier and
Crecelius, 2019).
The Coexistence Theory's focus on exploiting internet platforms for improved customer
service is shown in strategies that uphold a unique experience, such as home delivery for
quick access to fashion. Such tactics also align with the Technology Acceptance Model,
which holds that customer acceptance of online platforms is influenced by the simplicity of
use and perceived utility (Alves et al., 2020).
23
transactions. Consumer behavior underwent a dramatic change in the post-COVID era, which
hastened the adoption of multichannel strategies.
This technique increases engagement through tailored experiences across numerous platforms
in addition to catering to a larger and more international audience. The growing popularity of
promotions and team-ups in omnichannel marketing exemplifies the sector's efforts to forge
profitable alliances and boost brand recognition.
For instance, a company that rents out luxury clothing has benefited from online sales
because luxury clothing is frequently out of reach for many people due to its high price.
Online rentals of expensive goods have democratized access and increased revenue. Similar
to this, the alliance of well-known brands like Disney and internet marketplaces has
encouraged buyers to make more expensive purchases, increasing profits (Sharma et al.,
2021).
Additionally, the jewelry shop Lovisa emphasizes that the growth of online businesses was a
major factor in its success and that having an online presence was essential to increasing
profitability. These observations support the idea that, when businesses embrace the digital
transition, an increase in online sales directly correlates with increased profitability.
24
A strong trend has been the incorporation of virtual components into physical establishments.
Virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) technologies have the potential to
completely transform the in-store shopping experience. Through virtual try-ons, customers
can see how things would seem on them or in their homes, enhancing their decision-making
process. This is in line with the Technology Acceptance Model, which contends that a
technology's perceived utility and simplicity of use have an impact on its acceptance. These
virtual incorporations are expected to become more complex and interesting as AI and other
technologies develop.
A participant noted that interactive displays have been essential in luring clients to learn more
about products. "Click and collect" is a concept that not only unites online and offline buying
but also encourages customers to visit actual establishments. Once inside the store, customers
are exposed to a variety of items that are stocked on racks and mannequins. This is consistent
with the Coexistence idea, which holds that a seamless fusion of online and offline
experiences can have synergistic benefits that encourage customer involvement and
purchases.
Creative checkout experiences have also been made possible by technological advancements.
Even though it hasn't fully materialized, the concept of employing hand gestures to complete
transactions shows the promise for frictionless and interesting interactions. Such innovations
are consistent with Porter's Five Forces theory since they can give companies a competitive
edge and a special selling proposition.
Participants' mention of the emergence of novel concepts highlights the fluidity of retail
technology. New fashion IT startups are investigating creative strategies to let buyers
virtually try on items. This is an example of the Technology Acceptance Model, which holds
that perceived advantages and usability have an impact on people's readiness to adopt new
technology. Fashion technology may reinvent how consumers interact with products as it
develops, changing the face of conventional shopping.
25
G. Conclusions & recommendations
In order to stay competitive in the face of growing e-commerce predominance, the present
study examined the adaption techniques used by traditional retail enterprises in the apparel,
fashion, and luxury industries. The research offered new information in a variety of fields,
including Experiential Store Design, Online Luxury Experience, Balancing Accessibility and
Exclusivity, Personalized Experience, Social Responsibility and Sustainability, and
Technology Integration. The intricate techniques that retailers are using to handle the altering
retail landscape are illustrated by these interconnected themes. The study's ramifications are
wide-ranging for organizations and present opportunities for additional investigation.
From a strategic perspective, the uptake of online luxury experiences offers light on the
subtle interaction between exclusivity and accessibility. Through exclusive online collections
and virtual presentations that encapsulate the essence of the brand, luxury businesses
successfully utilize e-commerce. The Luxury Branding Theory, which emphasizes the
importance of exclusivity and scarcity in building brand identity, is in line with this strategic
balance.
Within luxury branding, striking a balance between accessibility and exclusivity is crucial.
By providing VIP access to online customers and limited-edition products via digital
channels, luxury brands increase their market presence while preserving a sense of
exclusivity. The Coexistence Theory, which contends that online and offline channels
reinforce one another to serve a variety of clients, is in accordance with this strategy.
26
Consumer behavior theory-based personalized experiences become the driving force behind
retail tactics. By bridging the gap between traditional brick-and-mortar and the digital world
and enabling virtual try-ons and customized items, technological innovations can cater to
specific consumer preferences. Including personalization increases consumer happiness and
fosters enduring loyalty.
The retail industry has prioritized ethical behavior and sustainability. Businesses that place a
high emphasis on sustainable development and ethical sourcing build significant ties with
ethical customers. The adoption of ethical principles is in line with the rising need for
ethically responsible business behavior.
Organizations can also think about incorporating sustainability and moral behavior into their
strategy plans. Consumers that care about the environment may connect with open
communication about ethical sourcing and sustainable methods, supporting brand integrity
and encouraging patronage.
27
Limitations: Addressing Research Constraints
Despite the fact that this study offers interesting findings, some restrictions should be
addressed. The generalizability of the research's findings in different situations can be
constrained by its qualitative nature. The sample size was set with purpose, although it's
possible that it doesn't accurately reflect the range of industry opinions. Participants'
responses could be influenced by social desirability bias, which would undermine the
veracity of their responses.
In conclusion, this study sheds light on the complex interaction between traditional brick-
and-mortar retail and the development of e-commerce. The themes that have been found
show the various tactics that companies use to stay relevant and competitive. Retailers may
successfully traverse the dynamic retail market and improve customer experiences by
integrating experiential design, technology integration, customization, luxury branding, and
social responsibility.
28
H. References
Ahmad, F., Mustafa, K., Hamid, S.A.R., Khawaja, K.F., Zada, S., Jamil, S., Qaisar, M.N.,
Vega-Muñoz, A., Contreras-Barraza, N. and Anwer, N., 2022. Online Customer Experience
Leads to Loyalty via Customer Engagement: Moderating Role of Value Co-
creation. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, p.897851.
Alves, S.R., Ribeiro, H. and Saravanan, R., 2020. The digital transformation of traditional
fashion retail for sustainable growth. Economic and Social Development: Book of
Proceedings, pp.236-245.
Barabás, G., D'Andrea, R. and Stump, S.M., 2018. Chesson's coexistence theory. Ecological
monographs, 88(3), pp.277-303.
Batat, W., 2019. The new luxury experience. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Berberović, D., Alić, A. and Činjarević, M., 2022, May. Virtual reality in marketing:
consumer and retail perspectives. In International Conference “New Technologies,
Development and Applications” (pp. 1093-1102). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Bonfanti, A., Vigolo, V., Vannucci, V. and Brunetti, F., 2023. Creating memorable shopping
experiences to meet phygital customers' needs: evidence from sporting goods
stores. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 51(13), pp.81-100.
Casula, M., Rangarajan, N. and Shields, P., 2021. The potential of working hypotheses for
deductive exploratory research. Quality & Quantity, 55(5), pp.1703-1725.
Chandra, Y. and Shang, L., 2019. Qualitative research using R: A systematic approach.
Danielsen, C.A.M., 2023. The Influence of Clothing Brands in Shaping Sustainable Fashion:
An Examination of Consumer and Brand Perspectives (Master's thesis, Norwegian University
of Life Sciences).
Gerster, V., Melonashi, P. and Nguyen, Q.C., 2021. Digital Customer Experience Matters.
Goyal, P., Goyal, K. and Chauhan, A., 2022. Emerging Trends of E-Commerce perspective in
Developing Countries. Journal of Positive School Psychology, pp.7090-7096.
29
Iyer, S. and Soni, K., 2023. Understanding Online Consumer Behaviours for a Better
Customer Journey. Journal of Communication and Management, 2(02), pp.101-105.
Lee, Y., Kozar, K.A. and Larsen, K.R., 2003. The technology acceptance model: Past,
present, and future. Communications of the Association for information systems, 12(1), p.50.
Li, X., Wang, X., He, X., Chen, L., Xiao, J. and Chua, T.S., 2020, July. Hierarchical fashion
graph network for personalized outfit recommendation. In Proceedings of the 43rd
International ACM SIGIR Conference on Research and Development in Information
Retrieval (pp. 159-168).
McGrath, P., McCarthy, L., Marshall, D. and Rehme, J., 2021. Tools and technologies of
transparency in sustainable global supply chains. California Management Review, 64(1),
pp.67-89.
Mele, C. and Russo-Spena, T., 2022. The architecture of the phygital customer journey: a
dynamic interplay between systems of insights and systems of engagement. European
Journal of Marketing, 56(1), pp.72-91.
Nguyen, D.H., de Leeuw, S. and Dullaert, W.E., 2018. Consumer behaviour and order
fulfilment in online retailing: A systematic review. International Journal of Management
Reviews, 20(2), pp.255-276.
Palmatier, R.W. and Crecelius, A.T., 2019. The “first principles” of marketing strategy. Ams
Review, 9, pp.5-26.
Pangarkar, A., Arora, V. and Shukla, Y., 2022. Exploring phygital omnichannel luxury
retailing for immersive customer experience: The role of rapport and social
engagement. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 68, p.103001.
Pocock, T., Smith, M. and Wiles, J., 2021. Recommendations for virtual qualitative health
research during a pandemic. Qualitative Health Research, 31(13), pp.2403-2413.
Purwanto, A., 2022. What Is the Role of Customer Behavior for Electronic E-Commerce and
Modern Market Visit Intention?. Available at SSRN 4118047.
Rini, G.P. and Khasanah, I., 2021. Intention to use online meeting applications during Covid-
19 pandemic: A Technology Acceptance Model perspective. Jurnal Manajemen dan
Pemasaran Jasa, 14(1), pp.77-94.
30
Romano, B., Sands, S. and Pallant, J.I., 2021. Augmented reality and the customer journey:
an exploratory study. Australasian Marketing Journal, 29(4), pp.354-363.
Salvietti, G., Ieva, M. and Ziliani, C., 2021. Managing online touchpoints for a consistent
customer experience: Cases from fashion retailing. The Art of Digital Marketing for Fashion
and Luxury Brands: Marketspaces and Marketplaces, pp.365-395.
Seo, D.A., Sulistiawati, A., Imansari, W.A., Prabowo, H. and Sriwidadi, T., 2022, October. Is
Luxury Fit with Sustainability? The Role of Perceive Value and Scarcity. In 2022
International Conference on Sustainable Islamic Business and Finance (SIBF) (pp. 79-84).
IEEE.
Sharma, R.R., Kaur, T. and Syan, A.S., 2021. Conventional marketing practices.
In Sustainability Marketing (pp. 17-29). Emerald Publishing Limited.
31
Tan, Y.C., Chandukala, S.R. and Reddy, S.K., 2022. Augmented reality in retail and its
impact on sales. Journal of Marketing, 86(1), pp.48-66.
Taufek, A.F.A., Suid, K.M.H.K., Bahauddin, M.A. and Idris, Z., 2023. Ethics in Business and
Professional Ethics: Guidelines for Responsible Decision Making and Conduct.
In Proceedings of 1st Glocal Symposium on Information and Social Sciences (GSISS)
2023 (p. 43).
Venkatesh, V.G., Kang, K., Wang, B., Zhong, R.Y. and Zhang, A., 2020. System architecture
for blockchain based transparency of supply chain social sustainability. Robotics and
Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, 63, p.101896.
I. Appendices
Codebook from Nvivo
Visual merchandising 0 0
32
Name Files Referenc
es
Delayed deliveries 1 1
Highly accessible 0 0
Lack of technology-adoption 0 0
Interactive displays 1 1
Exploring profitability 1 1
Impact of digitalisation 0 0
Challenges 0 0
Additional costs 0 0
33
Name Files Referenc
es
Opportunities 0 0
Sales improved 8 8
Omnichannel Marketing 0 0
34
Name Files Referenc
es
Application also 3 3
Website only 6 6
35