Reading Material for Unit 3
Reading Material for Unit 3
a corporation is governed.
people,
process,
performance, and
purpose.
Corporate governance is important…..
Customers
Shareholders
Employees Environment &
the community at large
Regulators
Suppliers
11/20/2013 13
Examples of Corporate Governance
— HDFC Bank
(Industry – Private Banking and Financial Services)
HDFC Bank was amongst the first four companies which earned a
Corporate Governance and Value Creation (GVC) rating by The Credit
Rating Information Services of India Limited (CRISIL). The bank has
been successful in achieving a ‘CRISIL GVC Level 1’ rating for the last
two consecutive years. This symbolizes that the bank has the potential
to create wealth for all its stakeholders while preaching the highest
degree of corporate governance practices. The Bank truly believes in
transparent disclosures and the empowerment of shareholders for
weaving value.
The chart shows the past 17 years of data from the year 2000. Going by
the chart, HDFC bank has generated huge wealth over the years and is
known for its laurel worthy Corporate Governance.
On the contrary, in recent times, there are several specimens
that have grabbed headlines regarding massive failures of
corporate governance. One such is the Punjab National Bank (
PNB) Scandal.
Punjab National Bank (PNB) scam was put up across all news
channels for a scam size of size 12,000 crores. The fact that the main
accused i.e. Nirav Modi was able to siphon off funds without being
suspected by investigating committees or, the income tax
department points out to the mammoth loopholes in the
governance. The existence of proper corporate governance in
Punjab National Bank (PNB) could have singled out the large scale
scandal of this level.
In the chart, it is clearly evident how the share prices started falling
just prior to the announcement of the scam and went on a downhill
journey since then.
UNIT III
Corporate Board-
Its Powers, Responsibilities
& Development in India
1
Role of the Board of Directors
Corporation
a mechanism established to allow different
parties to contribute capital, expertise and labor
for their mutual benefit
The corporation is governed by the board of
directors that oversees top management
with the concurrence of the shareholders.
2-2
Role of the Board of Directors
Corporate governance
refers to the relationship among the
board of directors,
top management and
shareholders
in determining the direction and performance of
the corporation.
2-3
Responsibilities of the Board
Succession Planning
Sustainability
2-4
Responsibilities of the Board
Due care
the board is required to direct the affairs of the
corporation but not to manage them.
If a director or the board as a whole fails to act with
due care and, as a result, the corporation is in
some way harmed, the careless director or
directors can be held personally liable for the harm
done.
2-5
Role of the Board in
Strategic Management
Monitor developments inside and outside
the corporation
Evaluate and Influence management
proposals, decisions and actions
Initiate and Determine the corporation’s
mission and strategies
2-6
Board of Directors’ Continuum
2-7
Members of a Board of Directors
Inside directors
typically officers or executives employed by the
corporation
Outside directors
may be executives of other firms but are not
employees of the board’s corporation
2-8
Members of a Board of Directors
Agency theory
states that problems arise in corporations
because the agents (top management) are not
willing to bear responsibility for their decisions
unless they own a substantial amount of stock in
the corporation.
2-9
Members of a Board of Directors
Stewardship theory
proposes that, because of their long tenure with
the corporation, insiders (senior executives) tend
to identify with the corporation and its success
2-12
Interlocking Directorates
Direct interlocking directorate
when two firms share a director or when an executive of one firm sits on the
board of a second.
An interlocking directorate occurs when the same person sits on the board
of directors of two or more companies. There is a danger that an interlock
between competing firms (direct interlocks) may be used to co-ordinate
behaviour and reduce inter-firm rivalry.
Indirect interlocking directorate
when two corporations have directors who serve on the board of a third firm
where members of two different Boards serve together on the Board of a
third organisation. Directors who are appointed to more than one Board are
known as multiple directors.
2-13
Interlocking Directorates
Interlocking directorates
Interlocking directorates is a business practice wherein a
member of one company's board of directors also serves
on another company's board or within another
company's management. Under the antitrust legislation,
interlocking directorates are not illegal as long as the
corporations involved do not compete with each other.
useful for gaining both inside information about an
uncertain environment and objective expertise about
potential strategies and tactics.
2-14
Nomination and Election of
Board Members
The Board Nomination Process for Board Members
➢ Robert’s Rules, also known as parliamentary procedure,
outlines the various ways that nominees may be presented to
the board. Board members are typically nominated by a
nominating committee, but they can also be nominated by
ballot, or from the floor. Nominations may also be taken by mail
or by petition, though these methods are less common. Voting
is accomplished through written ballots, voice voting, or a roll
call vote. The actual process for how nominations and voting are
conducted will be outlined in the organization’s bylaws.
15
Kinds of Nominations
Nominating Committees
➢ An organization’s bylaws will state which committee has
responsibility for nominating board members. This may
be the governance committee, a board development
committee, or both of them combined. The bylaws may
also state that a separate nominating committee be
formed and outline how the committee is formed.
➢ Prior to seeking nominations, the board secretary should
give the committee a membership list, a copy of the
bylaws, a description of board member duties, and
requirements.
16
Kinds of Nominations (cont-d)
The first step for the nominating committee is to evaluate current
board members to assess whether they are performing
satisfactorily and should be considered for re-election.
Evaluations may be performed by a subset of the nominating
committee or an independent third party to ensure fairness.
The second step for the nominating committee is to receive
recommendations for new board members from management or
current board members. The nominating committee should
review the resumes of potential candidates, assessing their skills
and experience to determine if they meet qualifications for the
position.
17
Kinds of Nominations (cont-d)
In reviewing candidate profiles, the committee should also consider criteria
that includes:
➢ Proven leadership
➢ Previous board experience
➢ Knowledge and experience
➢ Diversity-including age, gender, ethnicity, race, disabilities, geography
➢ Experience with large and complex organizations
➢ Current or prior CEO, COO, or CFO level experience
➢ Skillset-including finance, legal, auditing, government affairs, public relations,
community experience, and knowledge of the organizations
18
Kinds of Nominations (cont-d)
The third step for the nominating committee is to give a list of candidates to the
full committee for discussion and review.
The committee then makes contact with each candidate to make an assessment
for a high level of personal and professional integrity, as well as to assess their
level of commitment to the organization, and availability. This is often done by
assigning one member of the nominating committee to one candidate, who will
bring a candidate summary with recommendations back to the full committee.
Additional interviews by the nominating committee and the CEO may be
necessary to ensure due diligence. Additional interviews may be conducted with
the assistance of a third party.
The committee forms a final slate of recommended candidates to the full board
for formal approval. Nominees should not be present at this meeting to allow for
open discussion by the board.
19
Nomination and Election of
Board Members
97% of boards use nominating committees to
identify potential board members
Staggered boards
only a portion of board members stand for re-
election when directors serve more than one year
terms
2-20
Organization of the Board
2-21
Organization of the Board
2-22
Organization of the Board
Lead director
consulted by the Chair/CEO regarding board
affairs and coordinates the annual evaluation of
the CEO
96% of companies combine the Chairman
and CEO positions had a lead director.
2-23
Organization of the Board
2-24
Nomination and Election of
Board Members
Criteria for a good director include:
Willingness to challenge management when
necessary
Special expertise that is important to the
company
Available for outside meetings to advise
management
Expertise on global issues
Understands the firm’s key technologies and
processes
2-25
Thank You.
26
Regulatory Framework of
Corporate Governance in India
Reforms of Companies Act
Session :16
Regulatory Framework of CG in India
THE COMPANIES ACT, 2017
New rules of the game
SALIENT FEATURES
The entire act has been divided into 29 chapters.
13 Parts 29 Chapters
15 Schedules 7 Schedules
HIGHLIGHTS OF THE COMPANIES ACT,
2013
Smart
Moral
Accountable
Responsive
Transparent Governance.
How it was introduced in THE WORLD
➢Cost effective
➢Speed, efficiency & convenient
➢Minimum use of hardcopy
[ENVIRONMENTAL BONUS]
➢Increases interest of citizens
➢Easily accessible
India's initiative towards
E-governance
COMPUTERIZED PALM
CARD SWIPE
IMPRESSION
Modern method of voting in E-Governance
E- Voting
CHALLENGES of E-Governance
SEBI has many powers for stopping fraud in capital market. It can ban
on the trading of those brokers who are involved in fraudulent and
unfair trade practices relating to stock market. It can impose the
penalties on capital market intermediaries if they are involve in insider
trading
3. Power to make rules for controlling stock exchange.
SEBI has power to make new rules for controlling stock exchange in
India. For example, SEBI fixed the time of trading 9 AM and 5 PM
in stock market.
Reporting of fraud
Adhere to the Code of Ethics and Code of Professional Conduct -
The auditor, being a professional, must adhere to the Code of Ethics
and the Code of Professional Conduct. Part of this involves
confidentiality and due care in the performance of his duties.
Hence, it can be seen that the duties of the auditor are pretty diverse,
it has an all-round and far-reaching impact. The level of assurance
provided by a set of audited financial statements is comparatively far
higher as compared to regular unaudited financial statements.
The manager’s functions are many and varied, including:
Hiring and staffing, Training new employees
Several common activities that can create a conflict of interest are nepotism,
self-dealing, and excess compensation.