Safety_Study_of_Steel_Structure_of_Weighbridge_I_G
Safety_Study_of_Steel_Structure_of_Weighbridge_I_G
1 (page: 40-49)
e-ISSN: 2723-3944 July 2024
DOI: https://doi.org/10.30650/jse.v3i1.4046
Abstract – Weighbridges play a vital role in coal mining operations. This study aims to calculate
the stress range and fatigue life of steel bridge girder cross-sections. Using the numerical
simulation method with the CSI Bridge V22 application, the maximum axial force of 197 kN and
the minimum axial force of -74 kN were obtained. The axial force is determined from the first 3
spans of the bridge with a span length of 4 m. The span length of the weighbridge is 80 m. From
the calculation, the maximum stress of 40.11 MPa and the minimum stress of -15.06 MPa were
obtained, resulting in a stress range of 55.16 MPa. The nominal bending moment strength of the
beam was found to be 0.56. This modeling allows the simulation of dynamic loads from a 400-
tonne SDT truck (semi-trailer door tipper) passing over the bridge so that accurate stress range
data can be obtained. Fatigue analysis was carried out using the Basquin equation using the
constant C = 1x1012 and exponent m = 3, receiving a fatigue life of 0.006 (6.01x106) cycles
assuming 30-40 hauling trucks passing over the weighbridge. The results of calculations and
simulations obtained longitudinal and transverse profile dimensions of IWF 1000x520x18x31.
40
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons
e-ISSN: 2723-3944
Attribution 4.0 International License.
R. Zulfikar, R. Noor
as bridge geometry, construction materials, and vehicle Some studies may also lack attention to the
load profiles, simulations can provide valuable insights integration of the latest technologies, such as natural
into bridge stability and reliability [9]. frequency analysis, in the monitoring and maintenance
in planning a bridge construction, it is necessary to process. Recent data and facts show that the use of
consider vibration aspects to ensure user safety and natural frequency analysis can provide a deeper
comfort. Steel frame bridges are an attractive alternative understanding of the structural performance of bridges,
for bridges with long spans [10]. allowing the identification of previously overlooked
the fatigue life of the bridge to determine the limitations [20].
eligibility requirements of the bridge theoretically and
experimentally [11]. 2. Methodology
the natural frequency on the weighbridge refers to the
natural frequency of vibrations or oscillations that occur 2.1 Research Procedures
in the bridge structure when a load is applied to the This stage provides an overview of the initial steps to
bridge. This natural frequency is influenced by various the end of the preparation of the final project. The stages
factors such as the shape, size, material, and construction start from the starting stage, data collection, data
of the bridge [12]. analysis, bridge detail planning, CSI Bridge V22
the relationship between the natural frequency of the software planning, and design drawings.
weighbridge and the hauling trailer is that the vibration
generated by the trailer movement can cause the bridge Data Collection Techniques
to vibrate at a frequency that matches the natural In this case, data collection is carried out by taking
frequency of the bridge. If the vibration frequency of the data from the office of PT Ganda Alam Makmur in the
trailer is close to or matches the natural frequency of the form of images of existing data structures that have been
bridge, a phenomenon called resonance can occur [13]. processed again.
Resonance is a condition in which external vibrations The guidelines used in the preparation of the Final
(vibrations from the trailer) match the natural frequency Project entitled "Safety Study of the Weighbridge I
of the bridge, which can cause vibration amplification Girder Steel Structure Against Hauling Trailer" are:
and magnify adverse effects on the bridge structure [14]. 1. Data of 51 meters weighbridge of PT Ganda Alam
all objects that have mass and elasticity are capable of Makmur
vibrating. The magnitude of the natural frequency of a 2. SNI 03-1729-2002, on the Planning of Full-Walled
material that vibrates transversely is strongly influenced Plate Beams (Girder Plates).
by the modulus of elasticity of the material, Data collection is the first step taken in structural
dimensions/geometry (cross-sectional area, length), planning which generally consists of::
density, and the action force acting on the material [15]. 1. General description of the building
in one structural element there will be several different 2. Calculation analysis method and design of
frequency values, this is due to the difference in construction structures such as superstructure.
frequency values in each mode. The greater the mode 3. Determine the working load
number, the greater the natural frequency value [16].
In this study, the loading methods used did not follow Picture of Weighbridge
the standards set by the relevant authorities. This can Figures 2.1 and 2.2 show the design of the
include the use of loads that exceed or fall short of the weighbridge modeling results in AutoCAD 2021
regulated provisions, as well as the application of loading software.
techniques that do not comply with generally accepted
guidelines in construction.
SNI 03-1729-2002, This standard provides guidelines Figure 2. 1 Weighbridge longitudinal section
for the planning of full-walled plate beams (girder
plates), including structural design requirements,
dimensions, and calculation methods that must be
considered to ensure the safety and reliability of bridge
structures using girder plates [17].
The purpose of this study was to determine the
characteristics of fatigue fracture propagation rates in
structural components subjected to maximum forces on
steel arch bridges and to determine the fatigue life of
structural components subjected to excessive loads [18].
In recognizing the limitations of previous research, it
was found that most previous studies focused on bridge
supervision and maintenance, which may not fully
consider complex structural dynamics [19]. Figure 2. 2 Weighbridge cross-section
41
2. To a/h ≤ 1,5:
= 2213026,651 cm4
And cross-sectional modulus:
The self-weight of the beam can now be calculated: Furthermore, the coefficient Kg for beams with full-
2 walled plates was also calculated :
Extensive web = 1,8 x 93,8 = 168,8 cm
Extensive flens = 2 (154,1) = 308,2 cm2
Total = 477 cm2 By:
43
Vn = (0,6.Aw.fyw.Cv)
a = 32 cm:
44
= 127,41 ton
ɸVn = 0,9 (127,41) = 114,669 ton > 8,560 ton OK
= 32,15 cm2
From equation 10.70
= 560,54 cm4
OK
45
47
48
49
2. Moment at span 2
50
51
52
Axial Force
From the results of the analyses carried out with the
CSI Bridge V22 software, data were obtained on the
magnitude of the maximum axial force that occurred due
to the hauling trailer on span 1 (one) and span 2 (two) of
the weighbridge. This data is illustrated in detail in
Figures 3.16, 3.17, 3.18, 3.19, 3.20, and 3.21 below. The
figures show the axial forces at three points along the
span, providing a clear visual representation of the areas
experiencing the highest axial forces.
1. Axial Force at span 1
53
54
Shear Force
The results of the analysis using CSI Bridge V22
software showed that the maximum shear force generated
by the SDT (semi-trailer door tipper) hauling trailer when
crossing the weighbridge was 315.764 kN. This detail is
presented in illustration figure 3.23 below.
55
56
References
Figure 3. 27 Area stress step 500 [1] Ryan Zulfikar, Rusandi Noor, & Muhammad Irkham
Firdaus. (2024). Upaya Kontribusi Melalui
Keterlibatan Pengabdian Mahasiswa Dalam Proses
4. Conclusions and Suggestions Konstruksi Pondasi Bored Piled Jembatan Timbang.
4.1. Conclusion PengabdianMu: Jurnal Ilmiah Pengabdian Kepada
Masyarakat, 414-422. DOI:
Based on the results of calculations and analyses that https://doi.org/10.33084/pengabdianmu.v9i3.6053
have been carried out on the data presented above, the [2] Yazila, S. (2020). Modifikasi Konstruksi Jembatan
following important conclusions can be drawn : Timbang Untuk Truk Batubara. Skripsi. DOI:
http://repository.univ-tridinanti.ac.id/id/eprint/736
1. The design of the 80-meter span weighbridge is safe [3] Atos, P. D. (2020). Perancangan dan Analisis
against the load of hauling trailer type SDT (semi- Kekuatan Konstruksi Portable Truck Scale di PT.
trailer door tipper) vehicles and from the results of Bukit Asam Tbk. Skripsi. DOI:
running analysis using the CSI Bridge V22 program https://doi.org/10.51967/tanesa.v23i1.963
obtained : [4] Widi Nugraha, & Gatot Sukmara. (2018). Uji Coba
a. The maximum moment force of 407.8331 kN at Model Fisik Sistem Bridge Weigh In Motion
the center of span 1 and 352.0961 kN at the center Sederhana Pada Baja Komposit (Trial Model Of a
of span 2, indicates a significant value in the Simple Bridge Weigh In Motion System On Steel
structural analysis at the center of the two spans. Girder Composite Bridge). Jurnal Jalan-Jembatan, 1-
b. The maximum axial force of 197.268 kN at the 15.
center of span 1 and 100.66 kN at the center of [5] Adib Maulana, & Rini Kusumawardani. (2020). Uji
span 2, showed significant values in the structural Durabilitas Jembatan Kereta Api Dengan
analysis at the center of the two spans. Menggunakan Analisis Mikrotremor. Dinamika
c. The maximum deflection at the center of the Teknik Sipil, 54-59. DOI:
bridge span was found to be 0.6 mm. 10.23917/DTS.v13i2.13055
d. The simulation and modeling results show that the [6] Heri Khoeri, Sofia W. Alisjahbana, & Panji
bridge can withstand the load of SDT-type Nugroho. (2024). Uji Beban Dinamik dan Analisis
hauling trailers effectively and efficiently, making Modal Operasional Jembatan Baja Komposit
it safe and reliable for coal mining purposes. Underpass Bekambit. Dinamika Rekayasa, 65-75.
e. The analysis results show that the largest floor DOI:10.20884/1.dinarek.2024.20.1.20
plate stress value at Step 100 is -275.92 MPa with [7] Muhammad Akbar, H. Gufran D Dirawan, & Moh.
an object area of 1 fulfilling 95%. This indicates Junaedy Rahman. (2020). Analisis Pemodelan Beban
that at Step 100, the floor plate is safe because it Pada Struktur Jembatan Box Girder Menggunakan
does not exceed the yield limit and permit stress Software Csi Bridge. Pendidikan Teknik Sipil
of 290 MPa. Universitas Negeri Makassar. DOI:
http://eprints.unm.ac.id/id/eprint/20165
57
[8] Rusandi Noor, Hiroshi Tamura, & Hiroshi Katsuchi. [19] Siti Mulidiya , & Rusli. (2017). Penentuan Frekuensi
(2023). Study on the Assessment of Fatigue Natural dan Arah Pergerakan Gelombang (Studi
Durability of Corroded Steel Girder Ends Repaired Kasus: Jembatan Soekarno Hatta Kota Malang).
with Carbon Fiber Reinforced Polymer. Jurnal Mipa Unsrat Online, 1-7. DOI:
International Journal of Steel Structures, 1500-1512. https://doi.org/10.35799/jm.6.1.2017.15222
DOI:10.1007/s13296-023-00784-6 [20] Widiarto Sutrisno, Dimas Langga Chandra, &
[9] Kharurrijal, Muhammad Fauzan, & Sekar Mentari. Agung Deonanda. (n.d.). Perbandingan Frekuensi
(2022). Kekuatan Struktur Jembatan Terhadap Alami Jembatan Karangsemut Menggunakan
Beban Gempa (Studi Kasus: Jembatan Cisomang Accelerometer dan Sap2000. Program Studi Teknik
Tol Purbaleunyi STA 100+700). Jurnal Teknik Sipil Sipil, Fakultas Teknik, Universitas Sarjanawiyata
dan lingkungan. DOI: Tamansiswa.
https://doi.org/10.29244/jsil.7.1.17-32
[10] Andreas Brian V P, Ari Wibowo, & Lilya Susanti.
(n.d.). Pengaruh Pengencangan Baut Terhadap
Frekuensi Natural Pada Model Jembatan Rangka
Baja. Jurusan Teknik Sipil Fakultas Teknik
Universitas Brawijaya.
[11] Firdaus, A. (2023). Studi Perbandingan Pembebanan
Dinamis Pada Jembatan Beton Terhadap Pemodelan
FEA. Skripsi.
[12] Ainil Mardhiyah, Johanes Tarigan, & Emma Patricia
Bangun. (2023). Analisis Frekuensi Alami Dengan
Undamped-Degree Of Freedom System Pada
Jembatan Sei Wampu. Jurnal Aplikasi Teknik Sipil,
329-360. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.12962/j2579-
891X.v21i4.15128
[13] Hinawan T. Santoso, Laely F. Hidayatiningrum,
Adityo B. Utomo, Juandra Hartono, & Masrianto.
(2021). Analisa Korelasi Antara Frekuensi Dengan
Bentang Jembatan Berdasarkan Uji Dinamik
(Correlation Analysis Between Frequency And
Bridge Span Based On Dynamic Test). Jurnal Jalan-
Jembatan, 60-72.
[14] Fauzi Alantia, & Endah Wahyudi. (2015). Studi
Perilaku Struktur Jembatan Pejalan Kaki Akibat
Beban Statis dan Dinamis Dari Beban Manusia
Berjalan. Jurnal Teknik Pomits, 1-6.
[15] Diah Prawestri, Widiarto Sutrisno, & Agus Priyanto.
(n.d.). Perbandingan Analisis Frekuensi Alami
Jembatan Gantung Dengan Menggunakan aplikasi
Accelerometer Meter dan Software (Studi Kasus
Jembatan Gantung Kemiri Buluharjo Karangmojo).
Program Studi Teknik sipil, Fakultas Teknik,
Universitas Sarjanawiyata Tamansiswa.
[16] Guntur Nugroho. (2018). Pengaruh Mode Shape
Frekuensi Alami Terhadap Estimasi Gaya Tarik
Batang Baja Dengan Metode Vibrasi. Semesta
Teknik, 198-205. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.18196/st.212226
[17] SNI 03-1729-2002. (n.d.). Standar Ini Memberikan
Pedoman Untuk Perencanaan Balok Pelat
Berdinding Penuh (Pelat Girder).
[18] Rusandi Noor, & Muhammad Noor Asnan. (2018).
Prediction of Service Life Decline of Double
Welded Wide Flanges due to Fatigue in Steel Arch
Bridge under Excessive Loads. Journal of
Engineering and Technological Sciences, 392-408.
DOI:10.5614/j.eng.technol.sci.2018.50.3.6
58